2 Kings Chapter 3 Read as one passage
2 Kings 3:16–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
16and he said, “This is what the LORD says: ‘Dig this valley full of ditches.’ 17For the LORD says, ‘You will not see wind or rain, but the valley will be filled with water, and you will drink—you and your cattle and your animals.’ 18This is a simple matter in the sight of the LORD, and He will also deliver the Moabites into your hand. 19And you shall attack every fortified city and every city of importance. You shall cut down every good tree, stop up every spring, and ruin every good field with stones.”
What the first hearers heard
To Israelite hearers this was a story about YHWH's power in a place and situation where no human means could help, and about the standing of his prophet.
- An Israelite king who had drifted toward his father Ahab's gods (v.13) finds his army about to die of thirst. Only a prophet of YHWH can tell him what will happen, and he does so for the sake of the faithful Judean king Jehoshaphat.
- The oracle has the solemn form of a royal decree ("Thus has YHWH spoken"). Its content is concrete and checkable: this dry streambed will hold pools of water, with no wind or rain to be seen.
- For people who knew desert wadis, the picture was vivid. A dead gravel channel turns into pool after pool, enough for horses, cattle and three armies.
- The pools also drive the rest of the story. The same water, red in the dawn light ("red", adom, sounds like "Edom" and like "blood", dam), fools Moab into charging the camp and being routed (vv.22–24). Within the wider Elijah–Elisha stories, it joins Elisha's other water miracles (2:19–22) as a sign that YHWH, not Baal the storm god, controls water and life.
From the study of 2 Kings 3:16.
Verse by verse
-
16and he said, “This is what the LORD says: ‘Dig this valley full of ditches.’
Full study →Elisha, with the hand of YHWH on him as the harpist plays, speaks in the voice of a royal messenger: "Thus has YHWH spoken: Make this wadi pits upon pits, nothing but pools from one end to the other."
The "valley" is a wadi, a dry desert streambed that carries water only when rain falls somewhere upstream. Three thirsty armies are camped in it with their animals, seven days into a waterless march.
The key verb is a bare "make!" or "making", with no person or tense. It can be an order to the kings ("Make this streambed into pits," as the ancient Greek and Latin translations took it) or God's announcement of what he is about to do ("This streambed will be made into pools"). The doubled noun, "pits, pits", is a Hebrew way of saying everywhere, one after another. The picture is a dry gravel channel covered from end to end with hollows ready to hold water.
The next verse explains the oracle: no wind, no rain will be seen, and yet this very streambed will fill, and men and animals will drink.
-
17For the LORD says, ‘You will not see wind or rain, but the valley will be filled with water, and you will drink—you and your cattle and your animals.’
Full study →Elisha has just given an odd command: dig this dry wadi full of pits (v. 16). Now he gives the reason, in the formal words of a royal herald: "For this is what Yahweh has declared: you will not see wind, and you will not see rain. Yet that very wadi, the dry stone channel you are standing in, will be filled up with water. Then you will drink: you yourselves, your herds, and every animal in your train."
The force of the promise depends on how people in that land knew water arrived. A wadi fills only after a storm, and a storm shows itself first in wind and then in a heavy downpour. Those are the signs the Canaanite world credited to the storm god Baal. The oracle rules out both, one at a time: not wind… and not rain. The armies will see no weather at all. The water will simply come. The verb is passive ("will be filled"), so the soldiers do nothing but dig, and the filling is done by the God who spoke. The last clause is a plain statement of what will follow. The wadi fills, and then everyone drinks. That includes the men who have marched seven days without water (v. 9), the flocks brought for food and sacrifice, and the pack animals the campaign depended on. Verse 18 adds that this is "a light thing" for Yahweh. Water is the small gift, and victory over Moab is the larger one.
-
18This is a simple matter in the sight of the LORD, and He will also deliver the Moabites into your hand.
Full study →"And this, water filling a dry riverbed with no wind and no rain, is a featherweight thing as Yahweh sees it. He will do the heavy thing as well: he will hand Moab itself over into your power."
The verse is built as a step from the lesser to the greater. The word for "light" (naqal) is the opposite of the Hebrew word for "heavy" or "weighty". The miracle that meant life or death to three thirsty armies and their animals (v.17) barely weighs anything on God's side of the scale. "In the eyes of Yahweh" means "in Yahweh's judgment." The weightier promise follows: "he will give Moab into your hand." This was the standard wording of a war oracle, and it means that before any battle is fought, God has already put the enemy under their control. The "your" is plural, covering all three allied kings and their forces. It answers the king of Israel's despairing cry in v.10, where he feared that Yahweh had brought them out only to "give them into the hand of Moab." Elisha turns the phrase around: Moab will be given into their hand. "Moab" means the land as well as the army, which is why the next verse moves straight on to its cities, trees, springs and fields.
-
19And you shall attack every fortified city and every city of importance. You shall cut down every good tree, stop up every spring, and ruin every good field with stones.”
Full study →The prophet Elisha has just promised three thirsty kings that God will fill the dry valley with water and hand Moab over to them (vv.16–18). He goes on:
"And you will strike down every walled stronghold and every prize town. Every productive tree, the fruit and olive trees a village lives on, you will bring crashing down. Every spring, every 'eye' of water in the land, you will choke shut. And every good family plot of farmland you will make sick, wounding it with stones until it cannot be plowed."
The Hebrew says "all/every" five times, and the phrase "fortified city… choice city" rhymes (mivtsar… mivḥor). The effect is a drumbeat of total devastation. The things to be destroyed are exactly the things called good: good trees, good fields. The last verb is a word for bodily pain: the land itself is made to ache. The grammar sits between prediction and command. It continues God's promise ("He will give Moab into your hand, and you will…"), yet it also works as marching orders, and verse 25 reports each item carried out. The verse also has an edge of irony. The God who has just made water flow for Israel tells them to shut off Moab's water.
Where the English drifted
-
in v16
valley
naḥal
- What we hear
- A broad lowland between hills, often pictured as green or fertile.
- What they heard
- A wadi: a streambed or gully that is dry most of the year and carries water only after rain, often as a sudden flood. Its defining feature is that it is a watercourse.
-
in v17
the valley
hannaḥal
- What we hear
- A wide, low, often green stretch of land between hills.
- What they heard
- A wadi: a narrow, stony streambed, dry most of the year, that runs with a torrent only after rain. The promise is exactly that this dry channel will run full.
-
in v17
your cattle
miqnêkem
- What we hear
- Cows.
- What they heard
- Livestock as property in general: sheep, goats and cattle, the herds the army brought with it.
-
in v18
deliver the Moabites into your hand
natan ... beyad
- What we hear
- 'Deliver' today usually means bring something to someone, or in church language rescue or save. 'He will deliver the Moabites' can sound like he will rescue them.
- What they heard
- 'Give into the hand' means to hand someone over to another's control, here to be defeated in war. Moab is the enemy being given up, not the one being saved.
-
in v19
mar (KJV, WEB, NASB)
takʾivu (hiphil of kaʾav)
- What we hear
- To spoil the look of something, a surface blemish.
- What they heard
- To cause pain, to make sick or wounded. The fields are hurt so badly they cannot produce.
-
in v19
wells of water (KJV)
maʿyenei mayim
- What we hear
- Dug shafts reaching groundwater.
- What they heard
- Natural springs: flowing sources, the "eyes" of the land.
-
in v19
every good tree
kol-ʿets tov
- What we hear
- Any healthy or nice-looking tree.
- What they heard
- Every useful, productive tree, chiefly fruit and olive trees, the long-term wealth of a farming village (compare Deut 20:19–20).
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v16
'Dig your ditches' might not even be a command
- What's often taught
- This verse is often preached as a principle of faith in action: God told them to dig ditches before any rain came, so believers must 'dig ditches' to prepare for blessing, and God fills only as much room as we have prepared.
- What the text supports
The reading that this is a command is a real option. The Septuagint, Vulgate and KJV all take it that way. But the verse rests on a bare form of 'make' (ʿāśōh) with no subject, which can just as well mean 'this wadi shall be made into pools'. ESV, NIV and others read it as God's own promise.
What the text plainly emphasises is in v.17: no wind and no rain will be seen, yet the wadi itself will be filled. Verses 18–20 never mention digging; the water simply arrives from Edom and fills the land. Nothing in the passage links the amount of water to the amount of human effort. The 'pits, pits' doubling describes how complete the provision is, not a measure of preparation.
In its setting this is a battlefield oracle that saves three armies from dying of thirst and sets up Moab's defeat, given (v.14) out of regard for Jehoshaphat, not as a reward for effort.
- Where the English feeds it
- BSB's 'Dig this valley full of ditches' and the KJV's imperative 'Make' present one reading of an ambiguous Hebrew form as certain, and 'Dig' adds a verb that is not in the text.
in v17
The ditches weren't dug for rain
- What's often taught
- Sermons on 'make this valley full of ditches' often teach that believers should dig their ditches, preparing in faith, so they will be ready when God sends the rain of blessing or revival.
- What the text supports
The call to act on God's word before you see anything happen really is in the passage. The army dug under a clear sky because a prophet said to. But the next verse explicitly says there would be no rain: you will not see wind, and you will not see rain (gešem). The point is that the water came without the signs that usually bring it. People in that land knew a wadi (naḥal) fills only after a storm. This one filled with no storm in sight. Turning the passage into 'get ready for the rain' reverses its central contrast.
The context also differs from the usual application. This was water for a military campaign, given to a coalition led by a king the prophet said he would not even look at except for Jehoshaphat's sake (3:14). And the gift went straight on to the slaughter of Moab (3:18–27).
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Valley' and 'ditches' suggest a green field waiting for rain, which makes 'rain' an easy word to slip in. The Hebrew naḥal is a dry flood channel, and the text says outright that no rain would come.
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֕אמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v16, v17
The usual Hebrew storytelling verb form ('and then he said'). The speaker is Elisha. The hand of YHWH has just come on him while the harpist plays (v.15), so what follows is an oracle, not his own advice.
-
כֹּ֖ה
kōh · H3541
thus, so · v16, v17
Opens the standard prophetic messenger formula, 'Thus...'. It marks the words that follow as a quotation from the one who sent the messenger.
-
יְהוָ֑ה
YHWH · H3068
the LORD (the divine name) · v16, v17, v18
Israel's God by his personal name. That matters here: Joram has just been told to go to his father's prophets, the prophets of Baal (v.13). The oracle is pointedly from YHWH, and it is given out of regard for Jehoshaphat (v.14).
-
עָשֹׂ֛ה
ʿāśōh · H6213
make, do · v16
A bare verbal noun (the 'infinitive absolute') with no person or tense marked. Hebrew uses this form both for sharp commands ('Make!') and for vivid statements ('[I am] making', '[it will be] made'). So it is unclear whether the kings are told to dig or God announces what he will do. 'Make' with two objects means 'make X into Y': turn this wadi into pits.
-
הַנַּ֥חַל
hannaḥal · H5158
wadi, streambed, torrent · v16, v17
A watercourse that is dry most of the year and runs only after rain, often as a sudden flash flood. The army is standing in a dry channel, which is exactly the kind of place water would flow if it came (v.20).
-
הַזֶּ֖ה
hazzeh · H2088
this · v16
'This wadi', the one in front of them. The oracle points at a particular streambed where the thirsty armies are camped.
-
גֵּבִ֥ים
gēḇîm · H1356
pits, cisterns, pools · v16
Hollows or pits that hold water. The same word appears in Jeremiah 14:3, where servants come to the cisterns and find no water. Here it means places where water collects and stays.
-
כִּֽי־
kî · H3588A
for, because · v17
Links this verse to the command in v. 16 ('dig this wadi full of pits'). It gives the reason for digging: water is coming, though not the way they would expect.
-
לֹֽא־
lōʾ · H3808
not · v17
A flat negative. The usual signs of a storm will be completely absent.
-
תִרְא֥וּ
tirʾû · H7200G
you will see · v17
Future (imperfect) and plural, addressed to the whole coalition army. The stress is on what they will see with their own eyes: nothing.
-
ר֙וּחַ֙
rûaḥ · H7307H
wind, breath, spirit · v17
Here it is plainly the physical wind, the gusts that come before a desert rainstorm (compare 1 Kings 18:45, 'clouds and wind, and a heavy rain').
-
גֶ֔שֶׁם
gešem · H1653
rain, downpour · v17
Heavy, soaking rain, not drizzle. This is the kind of storm that would normally fill a dry streambed.
-
הַה֖וּא
hahûʾ · H1931
that · v17
Points to the particular wadi they are camped in and have just been told to dig. The water will come here, not somewhere in general.
-
יִמָּ֣לֵא
yimmālēʾ · H4390
will be filled · v17
Passive and future. Someone else fills the wadi; the army only digs. The verb suggests filling right up, not a trickle.
-
מָ֑יִם
māyim · H4325G
water · v17, v19
What fills the wadi. For an army seven days into a waterless march (v. 9), this is life or death.
-
וּשְׁתִיתֶ֛ם
ûšətîtem · H8354
and you will drink · v17
In Hebrew narrative this form carries the sequence forward into the future: the wadi fills, then you drink. It states what will happen. It is not a command or a 'so that'.
-
אַתֶּ֥ם
ʾattem · H0859D
you (plural) · v17
An emphatic added pronoun, 'you yourselves', which starts the list of everyone who will be saved from thirst.
-
וּמִקְנֵיכֶ֖ם
ûmiqnêkem · H4735
livestock, herds · v17
Owned animals as property: flocks and herds the army brought along, probably for food and sacrifice. The word is singular but collective.
-
וּֽבְהֶמְתְּכֶֽם׃
ûbəhemtəkem · H0929
beasts, domestic animals · v17
The animals that 'followed them' (v. 9), most likely the pack and draft animals the march depended on. Next to miqneh it rounds the list out to every living thing in the camp.
-
וְנָקַ֥ל
wenaqal · H7043
to be light, slight, trifling · v18
Niphal (a form that often gives a passive or state-of-being sense) of the verb 'to be light': 'and it is a light thing.' Its opposite is the root for 'heavy, weighty' (kabed). Calling the miracle 'light' means it weighs almost nothing on Yahweh's side of the scale.
-
זֹ֖את
zot · H2063
this · v18
Points back to the miracle just promised in v.17: the dry riverbed filling with water with no wind or rain. 'This' is the thing the kings were desperate for, and Elisha calls it small.
-
בְּעֵינֵ֣י
be'eynei · H5869
in the eyes of · v18
A standard Hebrew idiom for 'in the judgment, estimation, or view of.' What counts as hard is measured from Yahweh's point of view, not the thirsty armies'.
-
וְנָתַ֥ן
wenatan · H5414
to give · v18
'And he will give.' The form looks ahead to the future. With 'into your hand' it becomes the fixed phrase of holy-war oracles: God hands an enemy over to be defeated.
-
אֶת־
'et · H0853
[marks the direct object] · v18
An untranslatable grammatical marker showing that 'Moab' is the thing given.
-
מוֹאָ֖ב
Mo'av · H4124
Moab · v18
The land and people east of the Dead Sea, ruled by King Mesha. The name stands for the whole nation, its army, cities and land. English versions often write 'the Moabites.'
-
בְּיֶדְכֶֽם׃
beyedkhem · H3027
hand; power, control · v18
'Into your hand.' The 'your' is plural, so it covers the three allied kings (Israel, Judah, Edom) and their armies. 'Hand' is the usual Hebrew picture for power and control.
-
וְהִכִּיתֶ֞ם
vehikkitem · H5221
and you will strike · v19
The standard Hebrew verb for striking a military blow: attacking, defeating, and often destroying. Its verb form carries on the promise of v.18 ("He will give Moab into your hand"), so it reads first as a prediction: "and you will strike".
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all, every · v19
"Every". This is the first of five uses of "all/every" in the verse. The repetition hammers home that the devastation will be total.
-
עִ֤יר
ʿir · H5892B
city, town · v19
A settlement, usually walled. In Iron Age Moab this means towns on the plateau east of the Dead Sea, many of them small.
-
מִבְצָר֙
mivtsar · H4013
fortification, stronghold · v19
From a root meaning "to cut off, make inaccessible". A "city of fortification" is a walled stronghold, the kind that normally needed a long siege.
-
מִבְח֔וֹר
mivḥor · H4004
choice, choicest · v19
From the verb "to choose": the select, best or most prized. A rare word, found elsewhere only in 2 Kings 19:23 ("its choicest cypresses"). It sounds like mivtsar, so "fortified city and choice city" rings as a jingle.
-
עֵ֥ץ
ʿets · H6086H
tree · v19
Tree, here living trees standing in the land: orchards, olive groves and shade or timber trees.
-
טוֹב֙
tov · H2896A
good · v19
"Good" in the practical sense: valuable and productive. Next to Deuteronomy 20:19–20 it most naturally means fruit-bearing or useful trees. The Latin Vulgate takes it as "fruit-bearing".
-
תַּפִּ֔ילוּ
tappilu · H5307M
you will make fall, fell · v19
The causative form of "to fall": you will bring them down, i.e. cut them down. Putting the object first ("every good tree you will fell") gives each item in the list its own stress.
-
מַעְיְנֵי־
maʿyenei- · H4599
springs of · v19
Natural springs, from ʿayin, which means both "eye" and "spring" (the eye of the land). These are flowing sources, not dug shafts.
-
תִּסְתֹּ֑מוּ
tistomu · H5640A
-
הַחֶלְקָ֣ה
haḥelqah · H2513A
portion, plot of land · v19
An allotted share of land, a family's field plot (compare Ruth 2:3, "the portion of the field belonging to Boaz"). It means more than "land" in general: these are the cultivated holdings a household lived on.
-
תַּכְאִ֖בוּ
takʾivu · H3510
you will cause pain, spoil · v19
The causative form of the verb "to be in pain": literally "you will make [the field] ache/sick". The land is pictured as a body that can be wounded. In practice it means making the fields unworkable.
-
בָּאֲבָנִֽים׃
baʾavanim · H0068G
The world behind it
The campaign. After Ahab's death, Mesha king of Moab stopped paying Israel his huge tribute of lambs and wool (3:4–5). The Moabite Stone (Mesha Stele, c. 840 BC), Mesha's own inscription, tells the same story from Moab's side: Omri's dynasty had "oppressed Moab many days", and Mesha threw off Israel's control.
Joram of Israel, joined by Jehoshaphat of Judah and Judah's vassal, the king of Edom, chose to attack from the south, "by the way of the wilderness of Edom" (v.8). That meant swinging around the southern end of the Dead Sea instead of hitting Moab's fortified northern border. After a seven-day circuit there was no water "for the army or for the animals that followed them" (v.9).
Wadis and flash floods. In this region, rain falling on the high Edomite plateau can send a flash flood rushing down a wadi many miles away under a clear sky. Hollows in the gravel bed of a channel can trap and hold water after the flow passes. This is the kind of event v.20 describes: water came "from the direction of Edom" at the hour of the morning offering. A favoured candidate for the wadi is Wadi el-Hasa (the biblical Zered) on the Edom–Moab border, but the text does not name it.
Prophet and music. Calling for a musician before prophesying (v.15) fits older Israelite prophetic practice (compare the band of prophets with harp and lyre in 1 Sam 10:5). The oracle comes from YHWH, not Baal, and Elisha says plainly he gives it only out of respect for Jehoshaphat (v.14).
From the study of 2 Kings 3:16.
Where scholars differ
in v16
Does YHWH command the kings to dig, or announce that he himself will turn the wadi into pools?
-
A command: the armies are to dig pits or trenches in the streambed.
The infinitive absolute often works as an emphatic command (Deut 5:12). The Septuagint (*Poiēsate*) and Vulgate (*Facite*) read it this way, as do KJV, NASB, BSB and WEB, along with many commentators. Digging pits in a gravel wadi to trap floodwater is realistic practice.
-
A promise or prediction: God will make the wadi full of pools.
The form marks no subject. Verse 17 begins 'For thus says YHWH' and describes only what will happen, with no instruction. Verses 18–20 never report anyone digging; the water simply comes and fills the land. ESV, NIV (2011), NLT and the Jewish Publication Society translation take this reading, and several modern commentators (e.g. Cogan & Tadmor, Anchor Bible) treat it as a prediction.
in v16
Was the water a purely supernatural event or a providentially timed natural flash flood?
-
Providential natural event: rain on the Edomite highlands sent an unseen flash flood down the wadi.
Verse 20 says the water came 'from the direction of Edom'. Verse 17 stresses that no wind or rain would be seen *by them*, not that none fell anywhere. Flash floods under clear skies are a well-known feature of the region.
-
The narrator presents it as a sign whose point is YHWH's direct action, whatever the mechanism.
The story frames the water as the fulfilment of a prophetic word at a set hour (the morning offering, v.20), and v.18 calls it 'a light thing in the eyes of YHWH'. The text shows no interest in a mechanism.
in v17
Was the water a natural flash flood, or a miracle with no natural cause?
-
A distant storm caused it: rain on the Edomite highlands sent a flood down the wadi, and the oracle's wonder lies in its timing and in the fact that no one saw any weather.
v. 20 says the water came 'from the direction of Edom'. Flash floods from far-off rain are well known in these wadis. Commentators such as Gray and Cogan & Tadmor discuss this mechanism.
-
The text presents it as a direct act of God, and no natural mechanism is needed or implied.
The oracle stresses that no wind or rain will be seen, and calls the water a 'light thing' in Yahweh's sight (v. 18). The water arrives at the hour of the morning offering (v. 20), which ties it to worship and to the prophet's word.
-
The two are not opposed. The narrator cares that the word was fulfilled, not about how.
Kings often has God acting through natural means (e.g. 1 Kgs 18:45, wind and cloud). Here the point is that the event matched the prophecy, without the usual signs.
in v17
What were the 'pits' of v. 16 for, and how do they relate to the filling in v. 17?
-
The pits were dug to catch and hold the water so it would not all run off down the wadi.
gēbîm means 'pits, cisterns' (compare Jer 14:3). Holding water in a channel after a flash flood makes practical sense. Most translations take it this way.
-
Verse 16 is a prediction: 'This wadi will be made into pools', describing what God will do, not a command.
The Hebrew verb form in v. 16 (an infinitive absolute, 'making') can stand for a command or a statement. Some ancient and modern interpreters read it as a statement, which makes v. 17's 'for' an explanation of how the pools will appear.
in v18
Was the promise 'he will give Moab into your hand' fulfilled, given that the allies withdrew from Kir-hareseth (3:27)?
-
Fulfilled. The promise concerns victory in battle, and the narrative records exactly that.
Moab's army is routed (v.24), its cities are destroyed, its springs stopped and its fields ruined (v.25), carrying out v.19 point by point. The usual 'give into hand' formula promises defeat of the enemy, not permanent occupation.
-
Fulfilled only in part. The narrator deliberately shows the limits of the victory.
After Mesha's sacrifice of his son, 'great wrath (qetsef) came upon Israel' and they withdrew (v.27), and Moab stayed independent. Interpreters dispute whose wrath this was: Chemosh's (as ancient readers might have assumed), Yahweh's (perhaps at Israel's overreach or at Jehoram's dynasty), or human horror and fury. Some read the story as a muted judgment on the house of Ahab, which Elisha had already snubbed (vv.13–14).
-
Historical-critical reading: the story preserves memory of a campaign that achieved little in the end.
The Mesha Stele claims Moab's successful liberation from Israel. Some scholars (e.g. the discussion in Cogan & Tadmor) think the biblical account frames a strategically failed campaign around a prophetic promise of victory, without hiding the outcome.
in v19
Is the verse a prediction of what will happen or a command to do it?
-
Prediction. Elisha forecasts the scale of the victory.
The opening verb continues v.18's promise ("He will give Moab into your hand, and you will strike…"). The following verbs are ordinary future forms. NIV and NLT translate "you will".
-
Command. Elisha gives battle orders as part of God's word.
In Hebrew, future forms often work as instructions (as in the Ten Commandments). The detailed checklist, fulfilled item by item in v.25, reads like orders being carried out. KJV, ESV, NASB and BSB use "shall".
-
Both. Oracles of victory often blend promise and directive.
Ancient Near Eastern oracles before battle typically combined assurance of victory with instructions. The Hebrew does not force a choice.
in v19
How does this fit with Deuteronomy 20:19–20, which forbids cutting down fruit trees?
-
No real conflict, because Deut 20 covers a different situation.
Deut 20:19–20 concerns a city under prolonged siege whose land Israel might live off or occupy. Moab was not Israel's to possess (Deut 2:9), and this is a punitive raid against a rebel. Some medieval Jewish commentators treat the order as a one-time prophetic exception.
-
A real tension that the narrator leaves unresolved, or even quietly criticises.
The campaign ends with Mesha's sacrifice, "great wrath against Israel", and withdrawal (v.27). Some scholars read the scorched-earth success followed by failure as an implied verdict, or as a sign the story comes from a tradition not yet shaped by Deuteronomy.
-
Deut 20 is itself a reaction against common practices like these.
J. L. Wright (JBL 2008) and M. Hasel (2005) argue that Deut 20:19–20 sets Israel apart from Assyrian-style orchard-cutting. 2 Kings 3 would then show the more common ancient practice that Deuteronomy limits.
Sources
- BDB s.v. גֵּב
- HALOT s.v. גֵּב; s.v. נַחַל
- Gesenius–Kautzsch, Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive absolute for imperative or finite verb), §123e (repetition expressing 'nothing but')
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §123
- Septuagint, 4 Kingdoms 3:16
- Vulgate, 4 Kings 3:16
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible)
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Kings 3
- HALOT s.v. נַחַל
- BDB s.v. רוּחַ, גֶּשֶׁם, מִקְנֶה
- J. Gray, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- J. A. Montgomery, The Books of Kings (ICC)
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), c. 840 BC
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.5 V 6–8
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 4 Kingdoms 3:17
- HALOT s.v. קלל
- BDB s.v. קָלַל
- BDB s.v. נָתַן; יָד
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), KAI 181
- M. A. Sweeney, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 4 Kingdoms 3:18
- Vulgate, 4 Regum 3:18
- BDB s.v. כָּאַב, מִבְחוֹר, חֶלְקָה, מַעְיָן
- HALOT s.v. כאב (hiphil), מִבְחוֹר, סתם
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible), notes on 3:19, 25
- Deuteronomy 20:19–20; Deuteronomy 2:9; Genesis 26:15–18; 2 Chronicles 32:3–4; Judges 9:45; Isaiah 5:2
- J. L. Wright, "Warfare and Wanton Destruction: A Reconsideration of Deuteronomy 20:19–20 in Relation to Ancient Siegecraft," JBL 127 (2008)
- M. G. Hasel, Military Practice and Polemic: Israel's Laws of Warfare in Near Eastern Perspective (2005)
- ANET: Annals of Thutmose III; inscriptions of Shalmaneser III; Sargon II's Eighth Campaign
- Septuagint (4 Kingdoms 3:19); Vulgate (4 Reg 3:19)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).