2 Samuel Chapter 5 Read as one passage
2 Samuel 5:17–21
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17When the Philistines heard that David had been anointed king over Israel, they all went in search of him; but David learned of this and went down to the stronghold. 18Now the Philistines had come and spread out in the Valley of Rephaim. 19So David inquired of the LORD, “Should I go up against the Philistines? Will You deliver them into my hand?” “Go up,” replied the LORD, “for I will surely deliver the Philistines into your hand.” 20So David went to Baal-perazim, where he defeated the Philistines and said, “Like a bursting flood, the LORD has burst out against my enemies before me.” So he called that place Baal-perazim. 21There the Philistines abandoned their idols, and David and his men carried them away.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse opens the first test of David's newly united kingship. It does three things:
- It shows what the anointing cost. Being made king over all Israel at once brought on the full weight of the enemy that had destroyed Saul. The story implies a question: can this king do what Saul could not and break Philistine power? Verses 18–25 answer it with two victories in which David asks the LORD for guidance (5:19, 23) and drives the Philistines 'from Geba to Gezer' (5:25).
- It picks up the old hunt. Hearers who knew 1 Samuel would recognise the vocabulary: 'seeking' David and David going to 'the stronghold'. The hunted fugitive of Adullam and the wilderness is hunted again, now as king, and he answers the same way, with caution and a defensible position rather than open battle on the enemy's terms.
- It reverses an old relationship. David had once served a Philistine king. Now the Philistines treat him as their chief enemy. This confirms to Israel that David is not a Philistine client but Israel's own king, the one through whom, as 3:18 says, the LORD would save Israel 'from the hand of the Philistines.'
The matching verbs, 'they heard... he heard' and 'they went up... he went down', show a king who is alert and not caught off guard. That prepares for the next step: David asks the LORD before he moves.
From the study of 2 Samuel 5:17.
Verse by verse
-
17When the Philistines heard that David had been anointed king over Israel, they all went in search of him; but David learned of this and went down to the stronghold.
Full study →News reached the Philistines that the tribes of Israel had poured the oil of kingship on David. The man who had once served a Philistine king, and had ruled only Judah from Hebron, was now king over all Israel. So the Philistines came up, every one of them, from their coastal plain into the hill country, hunting David. They were not just looking for him. They meant to take him, as Saul had once hunted him. David got word of it too. Both sides 'heard', and both acted. While they climbed up, he went down to the stronghold: a known, defended refuge on high, hard ground (Hebrew metsudah, a word related to hunting) where a hunted man could not be caught in the open. The verse sets two "all"s against each other. All Israel has just made David king (5:1–3), and now all Philistia marches to remove him before his kingdom can take hold.
-
18Now the Philistines had come and spread out in the Valley of Rephaim.
Full study →Meanwhile, the Philistines had already marched in and let their forces loose across the broad farmland of the Valley of Rephaim, just outside Jerusalem.
The Hebrew opens with "Philistines" instead of the verb. That marks a change of camera: while David was withdrawing to his stronghold (v.17), this is what the enemy had already done. The verb for "spread out" comes from a root meaning "let loose, leave lying". It pictures troops released to fan out over open ground, the way raiders or an occupying army settle over a district. The same words describe the Philistines spreading out in Judah to hunt Samson (Judges 15:9). The valley was a wide, fertile grain plain on the border between Judah and Benjamin. It lay southwest of the still-Jebusite (or newly taken) Jerusalem and north of Bethlehem. Its old name, "Valley of Rephaim", recalled the legendary ancient people of the land.
For the first hearers the verse sets up the crisis. The old overlord's army is camped on Israel's best land, at the hinge between Judah and the northern tribes, just as David has been made king of both. The next verse turns on whether David will "go up" against them, and on God's answer.
-
19So David inquired of the LORD, “Should I go up against the Philistines? Will You deliver them into my hand?” “Go up,” replied the LORD, “for I will surely deliver the Philistines into your hand.”
Full study →With the Philistine army spread out across the Valley of Rephaim, David did not decide for himself whether to fight. He formally consulted Yahweh, using Israel's recognised way of putting a war question to God. In David's case that most likely meant the priest Abiathar with the ephod, though this verse doesn't say so. He asked two sharp yes-or-no questions: "Am I to go up against the Philistines? Will you hand them over into my power?"
Yahweh answered in David's own words. To "Shall I go up?" he said "Go up!" To "Will you give them?" he said "Giving, I will give", a Hebrew doubling that means I will most certainly hand them over. To "into my hand" he said "into your hand." "Go up" here is the language of attack, and "giving into the hand" is the old formula of Israel's wars: God puts the enemy in his people's grip before the battle begins.
So the verse shows a king who asks before acting, and a God who settles the result in advance. The victory is a gift. In the next verse David says so himself: "Yahweh has burst through my enemies."
-
20So David went to Baal-perazim, where he defeated the Philistines and said, “Like a bursting flood, the LORD has burst out against my enemies before me.” So he called that place Baal-perazim.
Full study →David arrived at the battlefield, the place later called Baal-perazim, and struck down the Philistines there. Then he explained what had happened: "The LORD has broken through my enemies ahead of me, the way water breaks through a dam." The picture is concrete. The Philistine army stood like a wall or an earthen bank. The LORD burst through it the way a flash flood tears through a wadi bank or a dam gives way, all at once and with nothing able to stop it, and David followed through the gap the LORD had opened ahead of him. That is why the place was named Baal-perazim, "Master of Breakthroughs" or "Lord of the Bursting-Through." In this name baal is not the Canaanite god. It is the ordinary Hebrew word for "lord, master, owner", and David has just said who the master of the breakthroughs is: the LORD. The verse repeats the root p-r-ts ("break through") three times: the LORD broke through (parats), like a breach (perets) of waters, at the place of breaches (Perazim). It is also the root behind the name of David's ancestor Perez, "the one who broke out" (Genesis 38:29). One chapter later the same verb is used of the LORD bursting out against Uzzah (2 Samuel 6:8), a reminder that this unstoppable power is God's own and nobody can control it.
-
21There the Philistines abandoned their idols, and David and his men carried them away.
Full study →Right there, at the place of the LORD's breakthrough, the Philistines ran and left behind their gods: the statues they had carried into battle to guarantee victory. David, with his men, picked those gods up and carried them off as war trophies.
The verse completes verse 20. David has just named the battlefield Baal-perazim, "Master of Breakthroughs", because the LORD "burst through" his enemies like floodwater breaking a dam. Now the result: the routed Philistines drop their divine images. The narrator calls them by a dismissive word, 'atsabbim: made, shaped objects, "idols". The irony runs on two levels. First, the verb for "abandoned" is the same word Hebrew uses for "forsaking" a god, so on this day the Philistines "forsook" their gods, and their gods could not keep up. Second, a generation earlier the Philistines had captured Israel's ark and carried it off to their god Dagon's temple (1 Samuel 4–5). Now Israel's new king carries off their gods. The verb is singular ("he carried them off, David and his men"), which keeps David at the front of the action.
Samuel's wording says only that the idols were taken. The parallel in 1 Chronicles 14:12 adds that David ordered them burned, as Deuteronomy 7:5, 25 requires.
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
anointed
mashach
- What we hear
- Given a special spiritual empowerment or 'anointing' for ministry.
- What they heard
- Formally installed as king by having oil poured on the head in a public ceremony, here done by Israel's elders (5:3). The Philistines react to it as a political event.
-
in v17
went in search of him / to seek David
biqqesh
- What we hear
- Looking for someone, possibly to find or meet him.
- What they heard
- Hunting a man down in order to capture or kill him. It is the same verb used throughout 1 Samuel for Saul's pursuit of David.
-
in v17
the hold (KJV)
metsudah
- What we hear
- A ship's cargo hold, or a grip.
- What they heard
- A fortified stronghold or mountain refuge.
-
in v18
Philistines
pelishtim
- What we hear
- In everyday modern English a 'philistine' is a crude, uncultured person hostile to art and learning, so readers may picture a backward, boorish people.
- What they heard
- A real people of Aegean origin on the southern coast of Canaan. They had a sophisticated city culture of five allied cities, fine pottery and advanced metalworking, and they were the leading military power of the region in David's day.
-
in v19
inquired of the LORD
shāʾal baYHWH
- What we hear
- David prayed privately and sensed God's leading.
- What they heard
- A formal consultation of God for a ruling on a specific question. In David's story it is usually carried out through a priest with the ephod and its lots (Urim and Thummim), and it typically gets a yes/no answer.
-
in v19
deliver them into my hand
nātan bəyād
- What we hear
- 'Deliver' heard as 'rescue' or 'save', as in 'deliver us from evil'.
- What they heard
- 'Hand over, give into the power of'. This is the fixed formula for God handing an enemy over to defeat.
-
in v20
Baal (in Baal-perazim)
baʿal
- What we hear
- The Canaanite false god Baal, so it looks as though David named a battlefield after a pagan deity.
- What they heard
- The ordinary word for 'lord, master, owner'. Here it describes the LORD as 'master of breakthroughs'. In David's time baʿal could still be used of Israel's God (David's son Beeliada, 1 Chr 14:7; the warrior Bealiah, 'YHWH is lord', 1 Chr 12:5).
-
in v21
images (KJV, WEB)
'atsabbim
- What we hear
- Pictures, photographs, or visual impressions.
- What they heard
- Three-dimensional cult statues of the Philistine gods, carved or cast, portable enough to carry into battle.
-
in v21
burned them (KJV)
wayyissa'em (from nasa')
- What we hear
- That 2 Samuel itself says David destroyed the idols by fire.
- What they heard
- "He carried them off / took them away". Samuel says only that the idols were seized as spoils. Burning is reported in the parallel account, 1 Chronicles 14:12.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v20
'Lord of the Breakthrough' is a battle name, not a blanket promise
- What's often taught
- Baal-perazim shows God as 'the Lord of the Breakthrough', so believers can declare and expect God to break through every barrier in their lives: in finances, health, careers or ministry.
- What the text supports
The teaching gets one thing right. The name does mean something like 'Master of Breakthroughs', and David gives the credit to the LORD. But the verse records a single event: a military breach of an invading army that had come to kill David (5:17). It came after David asked the LORD whether to attack and received a specific 'Go up' (v.19). It is not presented as a pattern that can be called up whenever someone wants it:
- The next battle went differently. When the Philistines returned, God gave a different plan: wait, circle around, and listen for the sound in the trees (vv.22-25).
- The same verb turns up against David's side a chapter later. 'The LORD burst out (pāraṣ) against Uzzah', and the place was named Perez-uzzah (2 Sam 6:8). David was angry and afraid.
- The prophets turned the memory around. Isaiah 28:21 warns that the LORD will rise up 'as at Mount Perazim', this time against his own people.
In its setting, pāraṣ describes God's overwhelming power, which no one can manage or contain, not a breakthrough promised to the one who declares it.
- Where the English feeds it
- The modern English word 'breakthrough' sounds positive and personal (a medical breakthrough, a career breakthrough). The Hebrew verb is about breaching walls and bursting out, sometimes in judgment. Translations that say 'broken through' are accurate, but the English noun 'breakthrough' brings in connotations of success.
Every word
-
וַיִּשְׁמְע֣וּ
vayyishmeʿu · H8085
and they heard · v17
Opens a new scene in the usual Hebrew storytelling form ('and then...'). Word reaches the Philistines as news or intelligence. The same verb comes back for David later in the verse, so both sides 'hear' and act.
-
פְלִשְׁתִּ֗ים
felishtim · H6430
Philistines · v17, v18, v19
The coastal people who were Israel's main military rivals, and who had been David's own overlords while he served Achish of Gath. Here it means them as a political and military power.
-
כִּי־
ki · H3588
that · v17, v19
Introduces what they heard: the content of the news, not a reason.
-
מָשְׁח֨וּ
mashechu · H4886
they anointed · v17
'They' are the elders of Israel, who anointed David at Hebron (5:3). This was a public act of pouring oil that installed him as king. To the Philistines it was a political fact: Israel had a single king again.
-
אֶת־
ʾet · H0853
[direct object marker] · v17, v19, v20, v21
Marks David as the one anointed. It has no English equivalent.
-
דָּוִ֤ד
david · H1732
David · v17, v19, v20, v21
The former Philistine vassal, now king over the tribes.
-
לְמֶ֙לֶךְ֙
lemelekh · H4428
as king · v17
The preposition 'to/for' gives the new role: they anointed him into the office of king.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921
over · v17, v20
Rule over a people. The scope is the point: no longer just Judah from Hebron, but Israel as a whole.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל
yisraʾel · H3478
Israel · v17
Here it means the tribes that had followed Saul's house (5:1–3), now joined to Judah under one man. This union is what alarms the Philistines.
-
וַיַּעֲל֥וּ
vayyaʿalu · H5927
and they went up · v17, v19
Taken literally as geography: from the low coastal plain up into the central hill country. It is also the normal verb for an army marching out to attack.
-
כָל־
khol · H3605
all · v17
Full mobilisation, every Philistine city's forces. It mirrors 'all the tribes' and 'all the elders' of Israel in 5:1–3: all Israel crowns him, all Philistia comes after him.
-
לְבַקֵּ֣שׁ
levaqqesh · H1245
to seek · v17
The purpose of the march. In David's story this verb is used again and again for hunting him down (Saul 'sought' David), so it means hostile pursuit, not just looking for him.
-
וַיֵּ֖רֶד
vayyered · H3381
and he went down · v17
The opposite of 'went up'. The Philistines climb up, David goes down. The direction is real geography and is one clue to which stronghold is meant.
-
אֶל־
ʾel · H0413
to, toward · v17, v19
Marks where he went.
-
הַמְּצוּדָֽה׃
hammetsudah · H4686
-
בָּ֑אוּ
ba'u · H0935G
came, entered · v18, v20
A completed-action verb placed after its subject. It gives the situation David now faces: the Philistines had already arrived, picking up from 'went up to search for David' in v.17. It has a military sense here: they entered Israelite territory.
-
וַיִּנָּטְשׁ֖וּ
vayyinnatshu · H5203
spread out, deployed · v18
The root basically means 'let go, let loose, leave lying'. In this passive-reflexive form it pictures troops let loose and fanning out across open ground. That is how raiding or occupying forces deploy, rather than standing in one tight battle line. The same expression describes the Philistines hunting Samson at Lehi (Judg 15:9).
-
בְּעֵ֥מֶק
be'emeq · H6010P
in the valley (of) · v18
An ʿemeq is a broad, open valley or plain. It is not a narrow gorge. The ground was farmable and good for camping and moving troops. That suits an army that 'spread out'.
-
רְפָאִֽים׃
refa'im · H7497G
-
וַיִּשְׁאַל
wayyishʾal · H7592
and he asked · v19
Combined with the preposition "by/of Yahweh" that follows, this is the set phrase for formally consulting God for a decision, usually through a priest's oracle. It is not a word for general prayer.
-
בַּיהוָה
baYHWH · H3068
by/of Yahweh · v19, v20
The preposition be- ("in, by") marks who is consulted. The phrase means 'consulted Yahweh' or 'sought a ruling from Yahweh'. Most English Bibles print the divine name as "the LORD".
-
לֵאמֹר
lēʾmōr · H559
saying · v19, v20
The standard marker that introduces direct speech, like opening quotation marks. Here it introduces the exact questions put to the oracle.
-
הֲתִתְּנֵם
hătittənēm · H5414
will you give them? · v19
A second yes-or-no question: will Yahweh 'give them', that is, hand them over? David asks first whether to go and then whether he will win.
-
בְּיָדִי
bəyādî · H3027
into my hand · v19
'Hand' stands for power and control. To be 'given into someone's hand' is to be put at their mercy.
-
בְּבַעַל־
bəḇaʿal- · H1188
in Baal-(perazim) · v20
'In/at Baal-'. The first half of the place name. The common noun baʿal means 'lord, master, owner'. The narrator uses the name the place will receive at the end of the verse.
-
וַיַּכֵּם
wayyakkēm · H5221
strike, smite, defeat · v20
'And he struck them'. The usual word for striking down an enemy in battle, with 'them' (the Philistines) attached as a suffix. It reports a decisive military defeat.
-
שָׁם
šām · H8033G
there · v20, v21
'There'. It ties the victory to this exact spot, which is the reason the place gets its name.
-
פָּרַץ
pāraṣ · H6555
break through, burst out, breach · v20
'He has broken through'. A completed action. The picture is of a wall or dam giving way, or an attacker smashing through a defensive line. The same root gives the name of David's ancestor Perez (Genesis 38:29).
-
אֹיְבַי
ʾōyəḇay · H0341
enemy · v20
'My enemies'. The Philistines, who had come specifically to hunt David (5:17). The word comes from a verb meaning 'to be hostile to'.
-
לְפָנַי
ləp̄ānāy · H6440G
before me, ahead of me · v20
'Before me', literally 'to my face'. It means both 'in front of me / ahead of me' and 'in my presence'. The LORD goes first and David follows through the gap.
-
כְּפֶרֶץ
kəp̄ereṣ · H6556
like a breach of · v20
'Like a breach of...'. The noun form of the same root as pāraṣ: a gap torn open, a breach in a wall, a bursting out.
-
מָיִם
māyim · H4325G
water(s) · v20
'Waters'. Together with the previous word: water bursting through a dam, an embankment or a wadi bank in a sudden flash flood. It is fast, violent, and nothing can stop it.
-
כֵּן
kēn · H3651C
so, thus · v20
Second half of 'therefore'. It is the standard formula Hebrew stories use to explain how a place got its name.
-
קָרָא
qārāʾ · H7121H
call, name · v20
'He called', or impersonally 'one called', meaning people called it. The subject is not stated. It may be David or general usage.
-
שֵׁם־
šēm- · H8034
name · v20
'The name of'. In Israel a place name could hold the memory of an event and carry it forward.
-
הַמָּקוֹם
hammāqôm · H4725
place · v20
'The place'. The particular battlefield site, apparently near the Valley of Rephaim southwest of Jerusalem (v.18).
-
הַהוּא
hahûʾ · H1931
that · v20
'That (place)'. It points back to the spot where the battle happened.
-
וַיַּעַזְבוּ־
wayya'azvu · H5800
leave, abandon, forsake · v21
"And they left behind": the Philistines, fleeing the rout described in verse 20, drop what they brought into battle. The verb is the same one used of people 'forsaking' a god, so the scene carries a quiet irony: the Philistines abandon their gods on the field.
-
עֲצַבֵּיהֶם
'atsabbeihem · H6091
idol, cult image · v21
"Their idols": physical cult statues of Philistine gods, carried into battle as a guarantee of divine presence and help. The word stresses that they are made, shaped objects, and in Israelite usage it is a disparaging term.
-
וַיִּשָּׂאֵם
wayyissa'em · H5375
lift, carry, take away · v21
"And he carried them off": David picks up the enemy's gods and takes them as spoils of war. The verb is singular ('he') although the subject is 'David and his men'; Hebrew often matches the verb to the first-named subject, which puts David forward as the one acting.
-
וַאֲנָשָׁיו
wa'anashav · H0582
men · v21
"And his men": David's personal fighting force, the band that had been with him since his outlaw years (1 Sam 22–30). They share in the carrying off of the spoils.
The world behind it
David the former vassal. Before he became king, David spent about sixteen months as a vassal (a subordinate ruler who served a stronger king) of Achish king of Gath. He held the town of Ziklag from him and was even expected to march with the Philistines against Saul (1 Sam 27; 29). During his seven and a half years as king of Judah in Hebron, Samuel records no Philistine attack. Many historians think the Philistines were content to see Israel split between a Judah ruled by their old client and a weak northern kingdom under Saul's son Ish-bosheth.
Why the anointing changed things. When the northern elders anointed David at Hebron (5:3), the hill country was united under a proven commander. From the Philistine side this ended a useful division and amounted to rebellion by a former subordinate. Hitting him at once, with everything they had, before he could organise the kingdom, was sound policy.
The geography. The Philistine cities lay on the low coastal plain. Israel's heartland was the central ridge. The Philistines 'went up' and spread out in the Valley of Rephaim (5:18), the broad valley running southwest from Jerusalem toward Bethlehem. An army there drives a wedge between Judah and the northern tribes, the very union David had just made. 2 Samuel 23:13–17 describes what seems to be the same campaign: David 'in the stronghold' near the cave of Adullam, a Philistine garrison in Bethlehem, and their camp in the Valley of Rephaim.
Order of events. The chapter is arranged by topic: capture of Jerusalem (5:6–10), Hiram's embassy (5:11–12), David's sons (5:13–16), Philistine wars (5:17–25). The Philistine attack, triggered directly by the anointing, may in fact have come before Jerusalem was taken.
From the study of 2 Samuel 5:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Which 'stronghold' did David go down to?
-
The stronghold of Zion (Jerusalem's citadel), just named in 5:7 and 5:9.
Same word with the article ('the stronghold') only a few verses earlier. In the present order of the chapter David already lives in 'the stronghold' and has named it the City of David (5:9). The Valley of Rephaim lies right beside Jerusalem.
-
David's old refuge at or near Adullam in the lower foothills (the Shephelah).
One normally goes 'up' to Jerusalem, not 'down'. 2 Sam 23:13–14 places David 'in the stronghold' at the cave of Adullam during a Philistine occupation of the Valley of Rephaim and Bethlehem. 1 Sam 22:4–5 uses 'the stronghold' for that same refuge. Held by many modern commentators (e.g. McCarter, Anchor Bible).
in v17
Did this Philistine attack come before or after David captured Jerusalem?
-
Before: the chapter is arranged by topic, and the attack followed directly on the anointing.
The verse ties the attack to the news of the anointing, not to the conquest of Jerusalem. The battle in the Valley of Rephaim makes most sense if Jerusalem was still a Jebusite city on the Philistine route. The verb 'went down' fits a base outside Jerusalem.
-
After: the chapter follows the order of events.
The narrative order as it stands. The definite 'the stronghold' read as the one named in 5:7–9. Some take the Philistine move as a reaction to David's growing power, including his new capital.
in v18
Did this Philistine campaign happen before or after David captured Jerusalem (5:6–9)?
-
Before: the editor arranged the chapter by topic, and the Philistine wars followed directly on David's anointing over all Israel.
Verse 17 links the attack to the anointing (5:3), not to Jerusalem. David 'went down' to 'the stronghold', and one goes *up* to Zion. 2 Sam 23:13–14 puts 'the stronghold' near Adullam during a Philistine occupation of the Rephaim valley and Bethlehem. Commentators such as P. Kyle McCarter (Anchor Bible) favour this order.
-
After: the events are told in roughly chronological order, and 'the stronghold' is the stronghold of Zion just mentioned in 5:7, 9.
The same word, metsudah, is used of Zion in 5:7 and 5:9. The surface sequence of the chapter places the wars after the capture. A Philistine move into the valley beside a newly won Jerusalem would also make strategic sense.
in v18
What does the name 'Rephaim' refer to, and why was the valley so called?
-
The valley was named after the legendary early people called Rephaim, remembered as very tall.
Deut 2:11, 20; 3:11 and Josh 12:4; 13:12 use Rephaim as a people name. The Septuagint's 'valley of the Titans' shows ancient readers took it this way.
-
The name relates to the Rephaim as ancestral dead or 'shades', perhaps through tombs or cult sites in the area.
Ugaritic rpum and Phoenician rp'm refer to the deified or honoured dead. Hebrew uses refa'im for the shades in Isa 14:9 and Ps 88:10. The exact reason for the valley's name is unknown, and the two meanings may be historically linked.
in v19
How did David 'ask Yahweh' here: through the priest's ephod (Urim and Thummim), through a prophet, or some other way?
-
Through Abiathar and the ephod (the majority view).
Abiathar joined David 'with an ephod in his hand' (1 Sam 23:6). The next consultations (23:9–12; 30:7–8) explicitly use it, and they share this verse's pattern of paired yes/no questions answered by echoing the question's verb. Numbers 27:21 ties a leader's war decisions to the priest's Urim.
-
Possibly through a prophet such as Gad, or the means is deliberately left unspecified.
Gad advised David (1 Sam 22:5; 2 Sam 24:11). The second answer in 5:23–24 is detailed (a flanking move, a sign in the treetops), which goes beyond a simple yes/no lot and may suggest a prophetic word or a combination of methods. The text itself names no means.
in v19
When did this battle happen: before or after David captured Jerusalem, and which 'stronghold' did he go down to (v. 17)?
-
Before the capture of Jerusalem. The 'stronghold' is the cave or fortress of Adullam.
2 Sam 23:13–14 places David 'in the stronghold' at Adullam while a Philistine force camped in the Valley of Rephaim and held Bethlehem. You 'go down' from Jerusalem, not to it. Many commentators (e.g. McCarter) think the narrator grouped the material by theme rather than by date.
-
After the capture of Jerusalem, as the present order of the text suggests.
5:17 says the Philistines reacted to David being anointed king over Israel. Chronicles keeps the same order. On this reading 'the stronghold' could be a fortified position near Jerusalem, and the Philistine move a response to the new capital.
in v20
Did the place already have a Baal-related name that David reinterpreted, or was the name coined from this battle?
-
The name was coined from the battle, as the text says.
The 'therefore he called' formula presents the name as arising from David's words. The repeated root p-r-ts ties the name tightly to David's saying.
-
An existing name, perhaps tied to a local Baal shrine or a natural feature, was reinterpreted to honour YHWH.
Many Canaanite place names begin with Baal- (Baal-hazor, Baal-gad, Baal-tamar). Stories that explain names often attach new meanings to old names. Isaiah's 'Mount Perazim' suggests a height, the kind of place where shrines stood.
in v20
Is the flood imagery a deliberate jab at the Canaanite storm god Baal?
-
Yes. The storm and flood belonged to Baal in Canaanite belief, so crediting a flood-like burst to YHWH at a 'Baal' place is pointed.
In the Ugaritic texts Baʿlu is the storm god. The Philistine idols are abandoned on this field (v.21). Elsewhere the Old Testament claims storm imagery for YHWH (Ps 29).
-
Probably not deliberate. Baʿal here is simply 'master', and the flood is an everyday image of sudden force.
Baʿal was used of YHWH without controversy in David's circle (Beeliada, Bealiah). The text makes no polemical comment. Flash floods were a common sight.
in v20
Who named the place?
-
David himself.
David is the subject of the surrounding verbs and the speaker of the explanation. Most English versions read 'he called'.
-
An impersonal 'one called', meaning the name came into general use.
Biblical Hebrew often uses a third-person singular verb with no stated subject as an impersonal ('people called'), and no new subject is introduced here.
in v21
Did David keep the captured idols as trophies, or burn them?
-
Both are true: David carried the idols off and then had them burned. Samuel gives the first step and Chronicles the second.
The two accounts do not strictly contradict each other. Deuteronomy 7:5, 25 commands burning idols and forbids keeping their metal; a king who 'inquired of the LORD' (5:19, 23) would be expected to comply. This is the traditional harmonising view (e.g., Keil & Delitzsch).
-
Samuel records the older, plainer report (the idols were taken as spoils), and the Chronicler reshaped it to show David obeying the Torah.
Chronicles regularly retells Samuel–Kings to stress David's piety and Torah observance. It also replaces the disparaging 'idols' with 'gods' and the verb 'carried' with 'burned with fire'. Elsewhere David does keep foreign cult-related spoil: he takes the crown of 'their king' (or 'Milcom', the Ammonite god) in 2 Sam 12:30. Taking enemy gods as trophies was standard Near Eastern practice.
Sources
- BDB s.v. מָשַׁח, בָּקַשׁ, מְצוּדָה
- HALOT s.v. מְצוּדָה, בקשׁ
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
- A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 11)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 5
- Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 5:17 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 5:17
- 1 Chronicles 14:8 (parallel account)
- Medinet Habu inscriptions of Ramesses III (Peleset among the Sea Peoples)
- Amarna letter EA 51 (royal anointing with oil)
- BDB s.v. נָטַשׁ
- HALOT s.v. נטשׁ (Niphal 'spread out')
- HALOT s.v. רְפָאִים
- BDB s.v. עֵמֶק
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 5:17–25
- A. F. Rainey & R. S. Notley, The Sacred Bridge (historical geography of the Valley of Rephaim)
- Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 5:18, 22
- 1 Chronicles 14:9, 13 (parallel)
- Judges 15:9; 1 Samuel 30:16; 2 Samuel 23:13–17 (parallel usage and campaign)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. שׁאל (with בְּ, 'consult an oracle')
- HALOT s.v. עלה (military 'go up against')
- HALOT s.v. נתן; s.v. יָד
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, §35.3.1 (infinitive absolute for emphasis)
- Cornelis Van Dam, The Urim and Thummim: A Means of Revelation in Ancient Israel
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 2 Kingdoms 5:19
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 5:19
- 1 Chronicles 14:8–17 (parallel account)
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines on Chemosh's command
- HALOT s.v. בַּעַל I, פרץ, פֶּרֶץ
- BDB s.v. בַּעַל, פָּרַץ, פֶּרֶץ
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 5:17-25
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle (KTU 1.1-1.6)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 2 Kingdoms 5:20
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 5:20
- 1 Chronicles 14:7-12; 12:5; 8:33-34 (parallel and onomastic evidence)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. עָצָב (idol), נָשָׂא (lift, carry), עָזַב (leave, forsake)
- Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex) of 2 Samuel 5:21 and 1 Chronicles 14:12
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) 2 Kingdoms 5:21
- Vulgate 2 Samuel (2 Kings) 5:21
- Keil & Delitzsch, Commentary on the Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 5:21
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 5:17–25
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 5:21
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 17–18
- Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (OTL), on 1 Chronicles 14:12
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).