Esther 2:5
Studied by claude-opus-5-5 Checked against the Hebrew
Hebrew
אִ֣ישׁ יְהוּדִ֔י הָיָ֖ה בְּשׁוּשַׁ֣ן הַבִּירָ֑ה וּשְׁמ֣וֹ מָרְדֳּכַ֗י בֶּ֣ן יָאִ֧יר בֶּן־שִׁמְעִ֛י בֶּן־קִ֖ישׁ אִ֥ישׁ יְמִינִֽי׃
ʾîš yəhûdî hāyâ bəšûšan habbîrâ ûšəmô mordŏkay ben yāʾîr ben-šimʿî ben-qîš ʾîš yəmînî
A man, a Judean, there was in Susa the fortress, and his name: Mordecai, son of Jair, son of Shimei, son of Kish, a man of Yemini [Benjamin].
What it meant
Now, there was a Judean man in Susa, in the royal citadel itself. His name was Mordecai, son of Jair, son of Shimei, son of Kish: a Benjaminite.
The verse opens and closes on the same note. It begins "a man, a Judean" (ʾîš yəhûdî) and ends "a man, a Benjaminite" (ʾîš yəmînî). The two titles rhyme in Hebrew, and they frame Mordecai's double identity. By people he belongs to the exiled community of Judah. By tribe he comes from Benjamin, the tribe of Israel's first king.
The setting is not a ghetto but the citadel, the fortified royal quarter of Susa, one of the Persian Empire's capitals. Mordecai lives where power is. His name points the same way: it comes from Marduk, the god of Babylon. He is an exile who has settled completely into the empire.
Then come the ancestors. Jair is simply his father. But Shimei and Kish in a Benjaminite family line would ring bells for any Israelite listener. Kish was the father of King Saul, and Shimei was the man of Saul's clan who cursed David. The wording itself copies the way 1 Samuel introduces Saul's father: "There was a man of Benjamin, whose name was Kish son of ... a Benjaminite" (1 Samuel 9:1). So the first hearers would have sensed that an heir of Saul's house had walked onstage. When Haman "the Agagite" appears in chapter 3, they would recognize the old enemy. Saul had spared Agag the Amalekite king (1 Samuel 15), and now the families meet again.
The verb "there was" stands after its subject. In Hebrew that marks a pause in the story ("now, there was a man..."), much like a play introducing a new main character before the action resumes.
Where the English drifted
-
Shushan the palace
šûšan habbîrâ
- What we hear
- A single royal residence: Mordecai lived "in the palace", perhaps as a courtier inside the king's house.
- What they heard
- The fortified acropolis of Susa, a walled royal and administrative quarter containing palaces, audience halls, offices and the "king's gate", as distinct from the lower city.
Where the later meaning came from: KJV wording ("Shushan the palace"), following the older Latin and Greek tradition. Modern versions correct it to "citadel" or "fortress".
-
a Jew
yəhûdî
- What we hear
- A follower of the religion of Judaism in its later, rabbinic form. Some readers also assume it means a member of the tribe of Judah, which makes "a Jew ... a Benjamite" look like a contradiction.
- What they heard
- A member of the people and community from Judah, whether exiled or returned. Descent, homeland and worship of Israel's God were bound together. By this period the term covered Benjaminites and others absorbed into the Judean community, not only the tribe of Judah.
Where the later meaning came from: The later history of the English word "Jew" as a religious and ethnic category. "Jew" is not wrong here, but the Persian-period word leaned more toward people and homeland ("Judean").
What the first hearers heard
For Judeans living under Persian rule, and for later readers who kept the festival of Purim, the verse did several things at once:
- It gave them a hero like themselves. Mordecai is a diaspora Judean with a Babylonian name, working at the center of a foreign empire. Many of the first hearers lived exactly that way. The story does not treat his place in the empire as a betrayal. It treats it as the place where God's people would be kept safe.
- It brought the tribes together under one name. A Benjaminite is introduced first as "a Judean". After the exile, Israel's survivors were one people, the Yehudim, and the threat later in the book falls on all of them together.
- It reopened an old story. The pointer to Kish and Shimei told them that Saul's house was back. When Haman the Agagite appeared, they would expect a replay of 1 Samuel 15 with a different ending. Saul had spared Agag and took plunder. Mordecai's people defeat Haman's house and pointedly "did not lay their hands on the plunder" (Esther 9:10, 15, 16).
- It quietly hinted at providence. Esther never names God. The hand behind events shows instead in patterns like this: the right man with the right ancestry, in the right place, before the crisis arrives.
Every word
Tap any word for its full meaning and everywhere it appears.
-
אִ֣ישׁ
ʾîš · H0376G
man
"A man". It stands first, ahead of the verb, and that is how Hebrew storytelling brings a new character on stage. It also forms one end of a frame: the verse opens with "a man, a Judean" and closes with "a man, a Benjaminite".
-
יְהוּדִ֔י
yəhûdî · H3064
Judean, Jew
"Judean / Jew". This is the first time the book applies the label to anyone. It names Mordecai as a member of the people taken from Judah. That he is also a Benjaminite shows the word had grown beyond the tribe of Judah to cover the whole exiled community.
-
הָיָ֖ה
hāyâ · H1961
to be
"There was" (a completed-action form of the verb). Because it comes after its subject, it reads as a background note that steps outside the flow of the story ("now, there was a man...") rather than as the next event.
-
בְּשׁוּשַׁ֣ן
bəšûšan · H7800
Susa (Shushan)
"In Susa". Susa was the old Elamite city that the Persian kings used as one of their royal capitals. Placing a Judean here puts him at the political center of the empire.
-
הַבִּירָ֑ה
habbîrâ · H1002
-
וּשְׁמ֣וֹ
ûšəmô · H8034
name
"And his name [was]". This is the standard way Hebrew narrative introduces a person, and it echoes the openings of other stories (Judges 13:2; 1 Samuel 1:1; 9:1).
-
מָרְדֳּכַ֗י
mordŏkay · H4782H
Mordecai
The name comes from Marduk, the chief god of Babylon, roughly "Marduk's [man]". The hero carries a foreign, pagan-derived name, just as Daniel, Zerubbabel and Esther herself did. This was normal for Judeans born in exile.
-
בֶּ֣ן
ben · H1121A
son
"Son of". It starts the family line. In Hebrew genealogies "son of" can mean an immediate son or, more loosely, a descendant.
-
יָאִ֧יר
yāʾîr · H2971J
Jair
Jair, Mordecai's father, mentioned only here. The name means something like "he gives light". Unlike the next two names, it carries no famous associations.
-
בֶּן־
ben- · H1121A
son
"Son of". It carries the line back another generation, or reaches back to an ancestor.
-
שִׁמְעִ֛י
šimʿî · H8096U
Shimei
Shimei. The name was common, but for an Israelite hearer it called to mind Shimei son of Gera, the Benjaminite of Saul's clan who cursed David (2 Samuel 16:5–13; 1 Kings 2:8).
-
בֶּן־
ben- · H1121A
son
"Son of". This is the last link in the chain.
-
קִ֖ישׁ
qîš · H7027J
Kish
Kish. In a Benjaminite line this name points straight to Kish the father of King Saul (1 Samuel 9:1). It quietly marks Mordecai as belonging to Saul's royal house, which matters once Haman "the Agagite" appears (3:1).
-
אִ֥ישׁ
ʾîš · H0376G
man
"A man [of]". It repeats the opening word and closes the frame around Mordecai's identity.
-
יְמִינִֽי׃
yəmînî · H1145
Benjaminite
"Benjaminite". This is a short form of the tribal name (literally "of the right hand / of the south"), the same form used for Kish in 1 Samuel 9:1 and for Shimei in 2 Samuel 16:11 and 19:16. It rhymes with yəhûdî at the start of the verse: Judean by people, Benjaminite by tribe.
Key words, in depth
יְהוּדִי yəhûdî H3064
- Range of meaning
Originally "Judahite", meaning a member of the tribe or kingdom of Judah (2 Kings 16:6; 25:25; Jeremiah 32:12). After the Babylonian exile it became the general name for the people taken from Judah and their descendants, whether in the Persian province of Yehud or scattered abroad. The word combined descent, homeland and worship of Israel's God. Esther uses it more than any other biblical book (over 50 times). The same book also has a verb built from it, mityahădîm, "becoming/declaring themselves Jews" (8:17).
- Against the English
Most versions say "a Jew" or "a Jewish man", and that is basically right. The English word can carry later associations, though: a defined religion with rabbis and synagogues, or modern ideas of ethnicity. Some scholars prefer "Judean" to keep the link to Judah as a land and people. The word does not mean "of the tribe of Judah" here, since Mordecai is a Benjaminite.
- How it drifted
Over the centuries "Jew" came to mean a religious identity (Judaism) as much as a people. In Persian-period usage the main sense was belonging to the people and community from Judah. Religious practice was part of that, but it was not yet a separate category.
- Used elsewhere in the period
In Aramaic the same label (yhwdy) appears in the Elephantine papyri (5th century BCE), where the Judean garrison in Egypt calls itself "the Judean force". Babylonian tablets from Āl-Yāhūdu, "Judah-town" (c. 572–477 BCE), record exiles from Judah living as a distinct community. Ezra, Nehemiah and Daniel 3:8, 12 use yəhûdî/yəhûdāyēʾ of the returnee and diaspora community. Rabbinic tradition (b. Megillah 12b) noticed the oddity of a Benjaminite called yəhûdî and explained it by saying he refused idolatry.
- What it does in this verse
Calling a Benjaminite "a Judean man" tells us how the exile had reshaped identity: the old tribal lines were folded into one people defined by where they came from and by their God. It also prepares the plot. Haman will target not Mordecai alone but "the people of Mordecai", that is, all the Yehudim (3:6).
בִּירָה bîrâ H1002
- Range of meaning
Fortress, citadel, fortified palace complex. It is a late word in Hebrew, borrowed (through Aramaic) from Akkadian birtu, "fortress". It is used of the acropolis of Susa (Esther 1:2, 5; 2:3, 5, 8; Nehemiah 1:1; Daniel 8:2), of the fortress beside the temple in Jerusalem (Nehemiah 2:8; 7:2), and once of the temple itself as a monumental structure (1 Chronicles 29:1, 19).
- Against the English
KJV's "Shushan the palace" suggests a single royal residence. Modern versions say "citadel" (ESV, NIV, NASB, BSB, WEB) or "fortress" (NLT), which better fits a walled royal quarter set apart from the town.
- How it drifted
"Palace" in KJV came through the Latin and Greek tradition and narrowed a word about fortification and official complexes into a word about a royal home.
- Used elsewhere in the period
Aramaic birtāʾ is common in Achaemenid documents. The Elephantine papyri speak of "Yeb the fortress" (yb byrtʾ), and the Aramaic Arsames letters use it of administrative strongholds. Archaeologists have found at Susa a raised fortified mound holding Darius I's palace and audience hall (apadana), separated from the lower city. The Greek Esther often renders it simply as "the city".
- What it does in this verse
Mordecai belongs to the royal citadel, not just the town. That fits his place "at the king's gate" (2:19), the area where officials served, and it explains how he overhears a plot against the king (2:21–23). Esther draws a sharp line between the citadel, where Haman's decree goes out, and the city, which is thrown into confusion by it (3:15).
מׇרְדֳּכַי mordŏkay H4782H
- Range of meaning
A personal name formed from Marduk, the patron god of Babylon. It corresponds to the Babylonian and Elamite name Marduka / Mardukaya, roughly "(man) of Marduk".
- Against the English
English simply transliterates it. Readers rarely realize the hero of a book about Jewish survival bears a name honoring a Babylonian god.
- Used elsewhere in the period
Marduka occurs several times in the Persepolis Fortification tablets (Elamite administrative texts, c. 509–493 BCE) and in Babylonian documents. A tablet published by A. Ungnad (1940) names a Marduka serving as an official (sipīr) at Susa in the early reign of Xerxes I. Whether this is the same man is debated. A different Mordecai appears among the returnees with Zerubbabel (Ezra 2:2; Nehemiah 7:7). Comparable double names include Daniel/Belteshazzar and Hananiah/Shadrach (Daniel 1:7). Zerubbabel's own name is Babylonian ("seed of Babylon").
- What it does in this verse
The name marks Mordecai as a fully settled exile, at home in Persian administration, which is just how Esther (Babylonian Ištar/Persian "star", Hebrew name Hadassah, 2:7) is presented as well. The story does not criticize this. The man with a pagan name is the one who will refuse to bow (3:2) and who ends up second to the king (10:3).
קִישׁ qîš H7027J
- Range of meaning
A personal name, in Benjaminite settings above all Kish son of Abiel, father of Saul (1 Samuel 9:1–3; 14:51). Together with Shimei (שִׁמְעִי, H8096), it makes up the genealogy's "famous names".
- Against the English
Most English versions give a straight chain ("son of Jair, son of Shimei, son of Kish"), which a modern reader takes as three literal generations. NLT turns the last two into ancestors ("descendant of Kish and Shimei"). The Hebrew allows either reading.
- Used elsewhere in the period
1 Samuel 9:1 introduces Kish with the same pattern as our verse: "a man ... and his name was Kish son of ... son of ... a Benjaminite". Shimei son of Gera, "a man of the family of Saul's house" (2 Samuel 16:5), is likewise called "the Benjaminite" (2 Samuel 19:16; 1 Kings 2:8). Josephus (Antiquities 11.198) and the Targums treat Mordecai as a descendant of Saul's line, and the Talmud (b. Megillah 13a) links him to David's sparing of Shimei.
- What it does in this verse
Two chapters later Haman is introduced as "the Agagite" (3:1). Agag was the Amalekite king whom Saul son of Kish failed to destroy (1 Samuel 15). By ending Mordecai's line with Kish, the narrator sets up a rematch between Saul's house and Agag's house, which explains the long feud (Exodus 17:14–16; Deuteronomy 25:17–19). This time the Benjaminite does not take any plunder (Esther 9:10, 15–16).
יְמִינִי yəmînî H1145
- Range of meaning
Benjaminite. It is short for ben-yəmînî, from Binyāmîn, "son of the right hand", which can also mean "son of the south", since in Hebrew orientation the right-hand side is the south. The short form clusters in stories about Saul's family and Benjaminite troublemakers (1 Samuel 9:1, 4, 21; 22:7; 2 Samuel 16:11; 20:1; 1 Kings 2:8).
- Against the English
KJV, WEB and YLT say "a Benjamite" at the end of the verse, as the Hebrew does. BSB and NIV move the tribe forward ("from/of the tribe of Benjamin") into the opening phrase. That reads smoothly but breaks the frame between "a man, a Judean" and "a man, a Benjaminite".
- Used elsewhere in the period
The same form ends the introduction of Kish (1 Samuel 9:1: ben-ʾîš yəmînî) and labels Sheba the rebel (2 Samuel 20:1: ʾîš yəmînî). The Greek Esther expands it to "from the tribe of Benjamin".
- What it does in this verse
Ending on the tribal name rather than starting with it matches the wording used for Saul's father. The verse's opening words, ʾîš yəhûdî, and its closing words, ʾîš yəmînî, rhyme. Mordecai is both things at once: a member of the wider Judean people and an heir of Benjamin's royal line.
The world behind it
Susa under the Persians. The book is set in the reign of Ahasuerus, the Hebrew form of Xšayāršā, generally identified with Xerxes I (486–465 BCE). Susa (Shushan) was an ancient Elamite city that Darius I rebuilt as one of the Achaemenid capitals, alongside Persepolis, Ecbatana and Babylon. Excavations show a raised, walled royal mound holding Darius's palace and a huge columned audience hall, set apart from the lower town. That mound is "Susa the citadel" (habbîrâ). Esther consistently tells it apart from "the city of Susa" (3:15; 8:15).
Judeans in the eastern diaspora. Judeans deported by Babylon in 597 and 586 BCE settled in Mesopotamia and stayed there in large numbers after Persia allowed a return (538 BCE). Cuneiform tablets from Āl-Yāhūdu ("Judah-town") in Babylonia and the later Murashu business archive from Nippur show Judeans farming, trading and holding minor posts. Many carried names honoring Israel's God, and many carried Babylonian names, sometimes within the same family. A Judean in royal service with a name built on Marduk would have looked entirely ordinary.
Why the ancestors matter. Hebrew genealogies often skip generations and choose names for what they mean. To an Israelite ear, a Benjaminite line running back through Shimei to Kish is a pointer to Saul's royal house. The story depends on that pointer. Haman is "the Agagite" (3:1), and Agag was the Amalekite king Saul spared against the divine command (1 Samuel 15). Amalek was Israel's proverbial enemy (Exodus 17:14–16; Deuteronomy 25:17–19). The conflict between Mordecai and Haman is set up as the unfinished business of Saul and Agag, and this verse is where the setup starts.
How the translations handle it
“Now there was at the citadel of Susa a Jewish man from the tribe of Benjamin named Mordecai son of Jair, the son of Shimei, the son of Kish.”
- Gets right
- "Citadel" is accurate, and "Jewish man" keeps the Hebrew word "man" (ʾîš).
- Loses
- It moves "from the tribe of Benjamin" to the front, which breaks the rhyming frame (a Judean man ... a Benjaminite man) and the echo of 1 Samuel 9:1, where the tribe comes last.
“¶ [Now] in Shushan the palace there was a certain Jew, whose name [was] Mordecai, the son of Jair, the son of Shimei, the son of Kish, a Benjamite;”
- Gets right
- It keeps the Hebrew order of the genealogy, ending on "a Benjamite", so the frame with the opening "Jew" survives. "A certain Jew" captures the indefinite "a man" well.
- Loses
- "The palace" shrinks the fortified citadel (bîrâ) into a single residence.
“There was a certain Jew in the citadel of Susa whose name was Mordecai, the son of Jair, the son of Shimei, the son of Kish, a Benjamite,”
- Gets right
- It keeps the Hebrew order and the correct sense of "citadel".
- Loses
- It drops the second "man", so the echoing pair of phrases is lost in English, as in most versions.
“A man, a Jew, there hath been in Shushan the palace, and his name [is] Mordecai son of Jair, son of Shimei, son of Kish, a Benjamite —”
- Gets right
- It is the most literal: it keeps "a man" up front and the subject-first order that marks a new character.
- Loses
- It also says "palace". "There hath been" is a stiff rendering of a simple background "there was".
“…a Jew in Susa the citadel ... a Benjaminite…”
- Gets right
- It keeps "Susa the citadel" as a name-plus-title phrase, as in Hebrew, and puts the tribe at the end.
- Loses
- It drops "man", so the verse loses its paired frame.
“…a Jew of the tribe of Benjamin…”
- Gets right
- Clear and accurate on "citadel of Susa".
- Loses
- Like BSB, it moves the tribe forward and so loses the closing echo of Saul's introduction in 1 Samuel 9:1.
“…at the citadel in Susa a Jew…”
- Gets right
- Literal in structure, and it keeps "Benjamite" at the end.
- Loses
- "Citadel in Susa" slightly separates two terms that Hebrew treats as one name ("Susa-the-citadel"), though the meaning is unaffected.
“…a descendant of Kish and Shimei…”
- Gets right
- It tells the reader that Shimei and Kish may be famous ancestors rather than literal grandfather and great-grandfather, which is one well-supported reading. "Fortress" captures bîrâ well.
- Loses
- It settles an open question in its translation and reorders the names, so the reader no longer sees the formal genealogy that copies 1 Samuel 9:1.
Text and manuscripts
Hebrew text. The Masoretic Text of this verse is stable, and there are no significant manuscript variants.
Note on the supplied word data. The contextual gloss "a Jaminite" for יְמִינִי is misleading. The lemma given (H1145) is correct: Benjaminite, the shortened form found in 1 Samuel 9:1 and 2 Samuel 16:11. It should not be confused with "the Jaminites" (הַיָּמִינִי), a clan of Simeon descended from Jamin (Numbers 26:12). That is a different name with different vowels. Every major translation reads "Benjaminite/Benjamite" here.
Greek (Septuagint) Esther. The Greek reads roughly "And there was a Jewish man in Susa the city, whose name was Mardochaios, son of Jair, son of Semei, son of Kisaios, of the tribe of Benjamin." It renders bîrâ as "the city" and spells out the tribe. Greek Esther also adds a whole opening section ("Addition A", placed before 1:1), which introduces Mordecai with the same family line, gives his dream, and calls him "a great man, serving in the king's court". The shorter, separate Greek version (the "Alpha Text") has the same genealogy with small differences.
Latin Vulgate. Jerome's Latin also calls Susa a city (in Susis civitate) and keeps the short tribal form, roughly "of the stock of Jemini".
The age problem in v. 6. Verse 6 continues with "who had been exiled from Jerusalem ... with Jeconiah" (597 BCE). If that "who" refers to Mordecai, he would be well over 100 years old under Xerxes. Many interpreters therefore take "who" to refer to the last-named ancestor, Kish, and translations differ on this. See the debates below.
Other Mordecai. A Mordecai is listed among those who returned with Zerubbabel (Ezra 2:2; Nehemiah 7:7). Most scholars take him to be a different person, since the name was common among exiles.
Where scholars differ
Are Shimei and Kish Mordecai's grandfather and great-grandfather, or famous distant ancestors?
-
A literal three-generation genealogy. Kish is Mordecai's great-grandfather, and he is the one exiled with Jeconiah in 597 BCE (v. 6).
"Son of X, son of Y" is the ordinary form of a family line. Taking the "who" of v. 6 to refer to Kish gives Mordecai a believable age under Xerxes. Shimei and Kish were common names, so they need not refer to the famous figures. Several commentators (e.g. Moore, Anchor Bible) take this approach.
-
A shortened or allusive genealogy that names famous ancestors: Shimei son of Gera (2 Samuel 16) and Kish father of Saul (1 Samuel 9).
The verse copies the wording of 1 Samuel 9:1 ("a man ... and his name ... son of ... a Benjaminite"). Haman is introduced as "the Agagite" (3:1), which sets up a Saul-against-Agag rematch, and the story pointedly reverses Saul's taking of plunder (9:10, 15–16). Josephus (Antiquities 11) and the Targums and Talmud (b. Megillah 12b–13a) read Mordecai as being of Saul's line.
-
Both at once: real family names chosen and arranged so they call up the famous ancestors.
Hebrew genealogies regularly skip generations and choose names for their meaning. Many modern commentators (e.g. Fox, Berlin, Levenson) stress the literary echo without needing to decide how many generations are meant.
Is yəhûdî better rendered "Jew" or "Judean" here?
-
"Judean": the word mainly names an ethnic and geographic people tied to Judah.
The word comes from the name Judah. Persian-period Aramaic documents (Elephantine) use yhwdy alongside other place-based peoples. Some historians argue that a "religious" sense of the word only develops later (e.g. S. Mason).
-
"Jew": by Esther's time the term already included shared customs and worship, open to people who joined.
Here it covers a Benjaminite, so it is no longer about the tribe of Judah. Esther 3:8 describes the Yehudim by their distinct laws, and 8:17 speaks of many "declaring themselves Jews" (mityahădîm), which suggests an identity people could take on (S. J. D. Cohen discusses this transition).
Does the Marduka of Persian administrative texts confirm a historical Mordecai?
-
Possibly: a Marduka served as an official at Susa under Xerxes.
A tablet published by A. Ungnad (1940) names a Marduka, an official (sipīr) at Susa, early in Xerxes' reign. The Persepolis Fortification tablets record Marduka officials too. Some scholars count this as real background support.
-
Unproven: the name was common, and the identification cannot be confirmed.
Several different Marduka appear in Persian-period texts, and none of the documents calls him a Judean or links him to Esther's events. Commentators such as Clines and Fox advise caution. At most, the evidence shows that a Judean with this name serving at Susa is historically plausible.
Sources
- BDB s.v. בִּירָה, יְהוּדִי, יְמִינִי
- HALOT s.v. בִּירָה (Akkadian birtu loanword); s.v. יְהוּדִי; s.v. מׇרְדֳּכַי
- Michael V. Fox, Character and Ideology in the Book of Esther
- Adele Berlin, Esther (JPS Bible Commentary)
- Jon D. Levenson, Esther (Old Testament Library)
- Carey A. Moore, Esther (Anchor Bible)
- David J. A. Clines, Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther (New Century Bible)
- Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 12b–13a
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 11
- A. Ungnad, 'Keilinschriftliche Beiträge zum Buch Esra und Ester', ZAW 58 (1940/41)
- R. T. Hallock, Persepolis Fortification Tablets (1969)
- L. E. Pearce and C. Wunsch, Documents of Judean Exiles and West Semites in Babylonia (Āl-Yāhūdu tablets, 2014)
- S. J. D. Cohen, The Beginnings of Jewishness
- Septuagint Esther (Greek, incl. Addition A); Vulgate Esther 2:5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
What readers are saying
Loading…