Genesis Chapter 37 Read as one passage
Genesis 37:29–30
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
29When Reuben returned to the pit and saw that Joseph was not there, he tore his clothes, 30returned to his brothers, and said, “The boy is gone! What am I going to do?”
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites hearing the story of their tribal ancestors, this verse is where Reuben's good intention fails. The eldest son, who should have protected his brother and who alone had tried to, arrives too late. Hearers would notice several things:
- The irony of knowledge. The audience has just heard (v.28) that Joseph was pulled out and sold, so they know he is alive. Reuben, and soon Jacob, do not. The grief in this verse rests on a false conclusion, and that sets up the whole story through to the reunion in chapter 45.
- The failure of the firstborn. Reuben had already disgraced himself (35:22). Here his attempt to set things right comes to nothing. This matches the wider story, in which leadership passes not to Reuben but to Judah, who proposed the sale (37:26-27), later offers himself as surety for Benjamin (43:8-9; 44:18-34), and receives the royal blessing (49:8-10). Reuben's own blessing says he is "unstable as water" and will "not excel" (49:3-4).
- The language of death. An empty bor and "there is no Joseph" would sound to Israelite ears like the vocabulary of death. Joseph goes down into the pit, and the story will bring him up again (41:14 uses bor for the dungeon he is rushed out of), a descent and rise that later Israel heard as the pattern of God's hidden providence (50:20).
- A community's guilt. Reuben tears his clothes in v.29. Later in Egypt it is all the brothers together who tear their clothes over Benjamin (44:13), a sign that they have changed. The verse begins the long story of how the brothers come to own what they did (42:21-22).
From the study of Genesis 37:29.
Verse by verse
-
29When Reuben returned to the pit and saw that Joseph was not there, he tore his clothes,
Full study →Reuben comes back to the cistern. He is the one brother who had talked the others out of killing Joseph, and he had secretly planned to "bring him back" to their father (v.22). Now he expects to haul the boy out. The storyteller puts us beside him at the rim of the dry, rock-cut cistern, and we look down with him: and look, there is no Joseph in the pit. Hebrew does not say "Joseph had left." It says something more absolute: "there is no Joseph." The word for absence used here becomes the family's refrain of grief. Reuben will cry "the boy is not" (v.30), and Jacob will say for years that "Joseph is not" (42:13, 36). The "pit" (bor) is also a word Israel used for the grave, so for Reuben the cistern he picked as a hiding place has turned into something like a tomb.
His response is immediate, and the verbs come one after another: he tore his garments. This is not a fit of temper. It is the public sign of mourning and disaster that anyone in his world would recognise. It also turns the scene around: a little earlier the brothers had stripped Joseph's garment off him (v.23), and now the eldest rips his own. Reuben is the first person in the story to mourn Joseph. The reader already knows (v.28) that Joseph is alive and on his way to Egypt.
-
30returned to his brothers, and said, “The boy is gone! What am I going to do?”
Full study →Reuben came back to the brothers. He had gone to the pit meaning to pull Joseph out and bring him back to their father, and found it empty. Now he himself comes back to them empty-handed. He blurts out: "The lad — he's not there! He's gone, maybe gone for good. And I — where am I supposed to go now?"
The Hebrew is clipped and broken. "He is not" is stark and open-ended. It can mean "missing" or "no more," and Reuben cannot tell which. The same words will haunt the family for twenty years ("Joseph is not," 42:36). "The boy" is a seventeen-year-old youth, Jacob's son, and as eldest brother Reuben answered for his safety. Then the sentence breaks. "And I..." he starts, says "I" again, and asks "where am I going?" He means: there is nowhere to turn. He cannot go home to his father without the boy, and there is no way out of what has happened.
Where the English drifted
-
in v29
pit
bor
- What we hear
- A hole in the ground, maybe shallow, like a sandpit or fire pit.
- What they heard
- A deep, rock-cut water cistern with a narrow opening, which made an inescapable prison when dry. The word was also a poetic name for the grave and the underworld.
-
in v29
tore his clothes
wayyiqraʿ ʾet-bəgādāyw
- What we hear
- An emotional outburst, a tantrum, or just a vivid figure of speech for being upset.
- What they heard
- A recognised public rite of mourning and of alarm at disaster, a deliberate sign others would read at once.
-
in v30
the child (KJV, WEB)
yeled
- What we hear
- A small child, a little boy.
- What they heard
- A boy, lad or youth, a son still under family protection. Joseph is seventeen (37:2). The word can even be used of grown young men.
Every word
-
וַיָּ֤שָׁב
wayyāšob · H7725
and he returned · v29, v30
Reuben comes back, which tells us he had been away while Joseph was sold. It is the same root as Reuben's plan in v.22 'to return him (lahashivo) to his father.' He meant to bring Joseph back. Instead he comes back himself to an empty hole.
-
רְאוּבֵן֙
rəʾûbēn · H7205
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H413
to, toward · v29, v30
Gives the direction of his return: straight to the cistern, the place where he expected to find Joseph and secretly rescue him.
-
הַבּ֔וֹר
habbôr · H953
the pit, cistern · v29
The dry water cistern of v.24 ('the pit was empty; there was no water in it'). It is a dug, usually bottle-shaped reservoir that nobody could climb out of. Elsewhere bor is also a word for the grave and the underworld.
-
וְהִנֵּ֥ה
wəhinnēh · H2009
and behold, look · v29
A word that pulls the reader into Reuben's eyes at the moment of discovery: 'and look!' The shock is told from his point of view, not reported from outside.
-
אֵין־
ʾên- · H369
-
יוֹסֵ֖ף
yôsēp · H3130
Joseph · v29
The missing brother. His name was explained as 'may he add' (30:24). Here the narrative is all about his subtraction, and he is now absent.
-
וַיִּקְרַ֖ע
wayyiqraʿ · H7167
and he tore · v29
A violent ripping of cloth. This is the customary public act of mourning and of shock at disaster, not a private outburst of temper.
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H853
[direct object marker] · v29
Untranslatable grammatical marker showing that 'his garments' is the definite object of 'tore'.
-
בְּגָדָֽיו׃
bəgādāyw · H899
his garments, clothes · v29
The ordinary word for clothing. In a story full of garments, Joseph's special tunic stripped off him (v.23), soaked in blood (v.31) and then Jacob tearing his own cloak (v.34), Reuben's torn clothes are the first public sign of mourning.
-
אֶחָ֖יו
ʾeḥāv · H251
his brothers · v30
Literally 'his brothers'. The word 'brother' carries weight all through this chapter, because the brothers are failing at what brothers owe each other (compare Judah in v. 27: 'he is our brother, our own flesh').
-
וַיֹּאמַ֑ר
vayyōʾmar · H559
and he said · v30
Brings in Reuben's outburst. No reply from the brothers is recorded. They go straight on to the cover-up in v. 31.
-
הַיֶּ֣לֶד
hayyeled · H3206
the boy, the child, the lad · v30
Joseph is seventeen (37:2), so this means 'the lad' or 'the youngster', not a small child. The word comes from the verb 'to give birth', so it calls him someone's offspring: Jacob's son, whom Reuben was supposed to protect.
-
וַאֲנִ֖י
vaʾănî · H589
and I · v30
Placed first for emphasis: 'And as for me...' Reuben breaks off and turns to his own situation. The sentence is left hanging, like a gasp.
-
אָ֥נָה
ʾānāh · H575
where? to where? · v30
Asks about direction ('whither?'). Reuben has nowhere to turn and no way to face his father.
-
בָֽא׃
vāʾ · H935
going, coming · v30
A present 'going/coming' form of the verb. It describes what is happening to him right now: 'where am I going?', meaning 'what will become of me, where can I take myself?'
The world behind it
Cisterns in the hill country. Around Dothan, on the route between the hill country and the coast, herders depended on cisterns: chambers dug into rock to catch winter rain. They were often bottle-shaped, with a narrow mouth. One that was dry in the dry season (v.24, "there was no water in it") made a natural prison, because nobody could climb out unaided (compare Jer 38:6). Reuben's plan relied on this. Joseph would stay put until Reuben could come back alone.
Caravans. Dothan lay near a trade route used by caravans carrying gum, balm and resin down to Egypt (v.25). That explains how Joseph could disappear so quickly and so completely while Reuben was away.
The firstborn's responsibility. Reuben was Jacob's eldest son, and an eldest son was expected to answer for his younger brothers. Herding custom made a shepherd liable for any animal lost while in his care unless he could produce evidence that it had been killed by a wild animal (Gen 31:39; Exod 22:13). The brothers will soon produce exactly that kind of "evidence": the tunic dipped in goat's blood, which leads Jacob to say "torn, torn is Joseph" (v.33). Reuben had already lost his father's favour by sleeping with Bilhah (35:22), and here he faces being blamed for the missing boy. That is the force of his cry in v.30: "and I, where am I to go?"
Tearing garments. Ripping the front of one's clothing was a standard, visible rite of mourning and of shock at catastrophe across Israel and its neighbours, usually followed by sackcloth (37:34). Witnesses would read it at once as "disaster has happened."
From the study of Genesis 37:29.
Where scholars differ
in v29
Why was Reuben absent, and who actually removed Joseph from the pit?
-
The brothers sold Joseph to the Ishmaelite/Midianite traders (treated as one group) while Reuben was away. The text simply does not say where he was.
Judah proposes a sale (vv.26-27); Joseph later says to the brothers 'whom you sold into Egypt' (45:4-5). 'Ishmaelites' and 'Midianites' are used interchangeably in Judg 8:22-24. Traditional Jewish commentary (Rashi) and most translations (BSB supplies 'his brothers' in v.28) read it this way. Midrash fills the gap: Reuben was away fasting in penance (Genesis Rabbah 84:19) or taking his turn attending his father.
-
Midianite passers-by found and took Joseph from the pit before the brothers could carry out the sale, so the brothers, like Reuben, were surprised.
The unstated subject of 'they drew him up' in v.28 most naturally continues the nearest noun, 'Midianites.' Joseph says 'I was stolen (gunnov gunnavti) from the land of the Hebrews' (40:15). Reuben's report in v.30 assumes the brothers will be as alarmed as he is. The medieval commentator Rashbam held this view, and some modern literary readers (e.g. E. Greenstein) defend it.
-
Two older versions of the story have been woven together: in one Reuben rescues and Midianites kidnap; in the other Judah proposes a sale to Ishmaelites.
The doublets (Reuben and Judah both intervene; Midianites and Ishmaelites both appear; 37:36 versus 39:1) are a classic case for source criticism (e.g. Westermann; older Documentary Hypothesis analyses). Literary critics such as Alter and Wenham reply that the combined text reads coherently as it stands and that the ambiguity may be deliberate.
in v29
What is Reuben grieving: Joseph, or his own position?
-
Genuine grief and fear for his brother.
He alone resisted killing Joseph and planned to restore him to Jacob (vv.21-22). Years later he still reproaches the others: 'Did I not tell you, Do not sin against the boy?' (42:22). Tearing garments is the standard sign of mourning.
-
Mainly alarm about his own responsibility and standing as firstborn.
His words in v.30 are self-focused: 'and I, where am I to go?' He had already forfeited his father's favour (35:22), and some read the rescue plan as an attempt to win it back. The firstborn would be held answerable for a lost brother.
-
Both together; the text deliberately leaves his motives mixed.
Biblical narrative rarely states inner motives. The torn garments (grief) and the cry of v.30 (self-concern) stand side by side, and many commentators (e.g. Sarna, Wenham) read Reuben as well-meaning but ineffective.
in v30
Why was Reuben absent, and who actually took Joseph from the pit (v. 28)?
-
Reuben had simply stepped away. The brothers sold Joseph to the Ishmaelite or Midianite traders while he was gone, and these are two names for the same traders.
Judges 8:24 calls Midianites 'Ishmaelites', so the names can overlap. 37:36 and 39:1 can be read as the same transaction. Jewish tradition gave explanations for his absence: Genesis Rabbah 84:19 says he was off doing penance, and Rashi follows this.
-
Midianites passing by pulled Joseph out without the brothers knowing, so none of them knew where he went. That explains Reuben's shock and maybe the brothers' silence.
v. 28 says 'Midianite men passed by and they drew Joseph up'. The subject is ambiguous. Joseph later says 'you sold me' (45:4), which counts against this view or needs explaining.
-
Source-critical scholars (who study how the text may have been assembled from earlier written accounts) see two versions combined: in one, Reuben tries to save Joseph and Midianites take him; in the other, Judah proposes selling him to Ishmaelites.
There are parallel rescuers (Reuben in vv. 21–22, Judah in vv. 26–27), two trader names, and 37:36 sits alongside 39:1. Critics see these doublets as signs of two strands. Literary readers answer that the doubling is deliberate.
in v30
Is Reuben's cry genuine grief or mainly self-concern?
-
It is mainly about himself: the fronted, repeated 'and I' shows a firstborn worried about his own liability and standing with Jacob.
The doubled pronoun. He says no more about Joseph and turns to himself, and he puts up no resistance to the cover-up that follows. Compare his weak offer in 42:37.
-
It is real anguish. His self-reference is the natural panic of the brother responsible, and his torn clothes show true grief.
v. 29: he tore his clothes. v. 22: he planned the rescue. 42:22: years later he still recalls having pleaded for 'the boy'.
Sources
- BDB s.v. שׁוּב, בּוֹר, אַיִן, קָרַע, בֶּגֶד
- HALOT s.v. בּוֹר; s.v. בגד I and II
- Septuagint, Genesis 37:29 (lakkos; dierrēxen ta himatia)
- Vulgate, Genesis 37:29
- Genesis Rabbah 84:19
- Rashi and Rashbam on Genesis 37:28-29
- Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16-50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Nahum M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
- Claus Westermann, Genesis 37-50
- Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative; The Five Books of Moses
- Adele Berlin, Poetics and Interpretation of Biblical Narrative (on hinneh and point of view)
- Edward L. Greenstein, 'An Equivocal Reading of the Sale of Joseph'
- BDB s.v. אַיִן; s.v. יֶלֶד; s.v. אָן
- HALOT s.v. אַיִן; s.v. יֶלֶד; s.v. בּוֹא
- Septuagint, Genesis 37:30
- Vulgate, Genesis 37:30
- Laws of Hammurabi §266
- Genesis Rabbah 84:19; Rashi on Genesis 37:29
- Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
- Gordon Wenham, Word Biblical Commentary: Genesis 16–50
- Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative / Genesis translation
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).