Genesis Chapter 38 Read as one passage
Genesis 38:7–10
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
7But Er, Judah’s firstborn, was wicked in the sight of the LORD; so the LORD put him to death. 8Then Judah said to Onan, “Sleep with your brother’s wife. Perform your duty as her brother-in-law and raise up offspring for your brother.” 9But Onan knew that the offspring would not belong to him; so whenever he would sleep with his brother’s wife, he would spill his seed on the ground so that he would not produce offspring for his brother. 10What he did was wicked in the sight of the LORD, so He put Onan to death as well.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers, and especially people of Judah, the verse did several things:
- It explained a gap in the family tree. Everyone knew Judah's clans came from Shelah, Perez and Zerah, not from Judah's eldest son. This verse explains why: Er was cut off by God and left no heir.
- It showed that God judges inside the chosen family. Being Judah's firstborn gave Er no protection. The verdict "bad in the eyes of YHWH", which later becomes the standard verdict on Israel's kings, is first passed here on an ancestor's own son.
- It set up the irony of the chapter. The listener knows what Judah does not: his sons died because of their own conduct before God, not because of Tamar. When Judah finally says of Tamar, "She is more righteous than I" (38:26), the story has turned on its head. The Canaanite-connected widow Judah suspected turns out to be the one who keeps his line alive.
- It made the audience enjoy the wordplay. Hearing ʿEr... raʿ would draw a knowing reaction. Hebrew storytelling often lets a name sum up a person, and here the name read backwards gives the verdict.
The verse does not invite speculation about Er's crime. Its point is what God saw, what God did, and what that meant for the line of Judah.
From the study of Genesis 38:7.
Verse by verse
-
7But Er, Judah’s firstborn, was wicked in the sight of the LORD; so the LORD put him to death.
Full study →"And Er, Judah's firstborn, his heir and first hope for a family line, was bad in the LORD's eyes. So the LORD himself made him die."
The verse is brief, and several things are packed into it:
- A pun on the name. In Hebrew, Er (ער) is the word for "bad" (רע) with its two letters reversed. Anyone hearing it read aloud would catch the echo: ʿEr... raʿ. His name turned around describes him.
- A verdict without a charge. The Hebrew does not say Er did some specific evil. It says he was bad, as God judged it. The narrator gives God's assessment and withholds the details. Ancient and modern guesses about what Er did go beyond what the text says.
- God's point of view, not people's. "In the eyes of the LORD" means by God's judgment. This hints that whatever was wrong with Er was not visible to others. Judah never learns the reason, and later he blames Tamar for his sons' deaths (v. 11).
- A direct cause, an unstated method. "Put him to death" is the causative form of "to die": God is the one who caused the death. The text gives no illness, accident or sign. It names who did it, with the name YHWH repeated at the end for emphasis, and says nothing of how.
- The firstborn removed. By losing the firstborn, the verse sets up the question the rest of Genesis 38 answers: how will Judah's line continue? It ends up running through Tamar and her son Perez, ancestor of David.
-
8Then Judah said to Onan, “Sleep with your brother’s wife. Perform your duty as her brother-in-law and raise up offspring for your brother.”
Full study →Judah, as head of the household, gives his second son a command that comes in three linked parts: "Go in to your brother's wife, that is, take her and lie with her. Act toward her as the husband's brother is bound to act. Raise up offspring for your brother."
Every phrase points back to the dead man. Tamar is still "your brother's wife". The child is to be "for your brother". "Your brother" opens and closes the sentence. Onan is not being offered a wife and heirs of his own. He is being told to stand in for Er, so that a line that ended with Er's death can be made to stand up again, which is the picture behind "raise up". The son born of this union would carry Er's name and inherit Er's share. As Er was the firstborn, that share would normally be the larger one.
The command also protects Tamar. A childless widow had no secure place in the household, and bearing a son for her dead husband gave her a recognised future in the family.
The word "offspring" (zeraʿ) also means "seed" in the sense of semen. That sets up the next verse. Judah asks for seed for Er, and Onan wastes his seed rather than give it to his brother.
-
9But Onan knew that the offspring would not belong to him; so whenever he would sleep with his brother’s wife, he would spill his seed on the ground so that he would not produce offspring for his brother.
Full study →Onan understood exactly how this arrangement worked: any son Tamar bore would not count as his. Under the custom of the brother-in-law marriage, the child would carry the name and inheritance of his dead older brother Er. So every time he went in to his brother's widow (not once, but as a habit), he ruined his seed on the ground. The verb is a hard one: destroyed, spoiled, wasted, the same verb Genesis uses for the corruption and destruction of the earth before the Flood. He did it so as not to give seed to his brother.
The verse is framed by one word used in two senses. Hebrew zeraʿ means both semen and offspring. It opens with "the seed would not be his" and closes with "so as not to give seed to his brother". The seed he threw onto the ground was the heir he refused to give. Outwardly Onan obeyed his father's command, "go in to your brother's wife" (v.8): he kept sleeping with Tamar and kept his place in the family. In secret he made sure the arrangement could never produce the one thing it existed for. The narrator also states his motive: he was not avoiding a child as such, but refusing a child who would belong to Er. Verse 10 gives the verdict: what he did was evil in the LORD's sight.
-
10What he did was wicked in the sight of the LORD, so He put Onan to death as well.
Full study →"What Onan had been doing was evil in Yahweh's eyes, the same verdict that had fallen on his brother Er, and Yahweh put him to death too."
"What he had done" points back to the whole of verse 9. Onan knew that any son Tamar bore would carry his dead brother's name and inheritance, not his own. So every time he slept with her, he made sure she could not conceive: "so as not to give offspring to his brother." He took the sexual access that the duty gave him and secretly refused the duty itself, while appearing to obey his father Judah.
Hebrew hearers would have caught the echo. Er's name (ער) is the word "evil" (רע) spelled backwards, and Er was "evil in Yahweh's eyes" (v. 7). Now the same words land on Onan. "In the eyes of Yahweh" carries real weight: no one in the household could see what Onan was doing, but Yahweh saw it. The verdict is not mild disapproval. It is "evil," and Yahweh himself ends Onan's life. The final "him too" sets up the next scene: Judah, fearing his last son will "die too, like his brothers," wrongly treats Tamar as the danger and sends her away.
Where the English drifted
-
in v7
wicked
raʿ
- What we hear
- A notorious, recognisably villainous person: someone known for some specific gross sin. (Readers often assume it was a sexual sin, by analogy with Onan in vv. 9–10.)
- What they heard
- "Bad" as God judged it. It is a general verdict that names no specific act and is framed as God's private view ("in the eyes of YHWH"), not a public reputation. It is also a pun on Er's own name.
-
in v8
marry her (KJV, YLT)
yabbēm
- What we hear
- Start an ordinary marriage, in which the woman becomes his wife and her children are his.
- What they heard
- Take up the specific role of the 'husband's brother': unite with the widow so that the son counts as the dead brother's heir, not his own.
-
in v8
raise up seed (KJV, YLT)
hāqēm zeraʿ
- What we hear
- 'Seed' heard as semen, or as a vague old-fashioned word.
- What they heard
- Establish descendants, a line that carries the dead man's name and inheritance. The sense 'semen' comes into play in verse 9, not here.
-
in v9
spilled / spill his seed
šiḥēt (from šāḥat)
- What we hear
- An accidental or merely physical spill, a neutral description of where the semen went.
- What they heard
- He ruined, destroyed or wasted it, a verb of deliberate damage. The same root describes the earth's corruption and destruction before the Flood (Genesis 6:11–13). The Hebrew carries moral weight that 'spill' does not.
-
in v9
seed / offspring / semen
zeraʿ
- What we hear
- Modern readers hear either a plant seed or, in versions that say 'semen' and 'offspring' separately, two unrelated things.
- What they heard
- One word meaning both semen and descendants or lineage. The verse uses it at the start and the end so that the destroyed semen and the refused heir are named the same way.
-
in v10
displeased the LORD (KJV; NASB "displeasing")
wayyēraʿ bəʿênê YHWH
- What we hear
- God was disappointed or mildly unhappy with it.
- What they heard
- It was judged evil and harmful by Yahweh: the same verdict formula used of Er in v. 7, and one that ends in death.
-
in v10
what he did / the thing which he did
ʾăšer ʿāśâ
- What we hear
- Read through the word "onanism": masturbation, or simply "spilling seed," as the offence in itself.
- What they heard
- Onan's whole repeated conduct as v. 9 describes it: withdrawing during intercourse with Tamar, done on purpose so his brother would have no heir. The text names the motive ("the offspring would not be his") and the purpose ("so as not to give offspring to his brother").
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v8
Onan's story isn't about masturbation. Verse 8 names the duty he dodged
- What's often taught
- Onan was struck down for masturbation, which is why it came to be called 'onanism', and the story is a general warning against 'spilling one's seed'.
- What the text supports
Verse 8 sets the terms: Onan was ordered to unite with his dead brother's widow and raise up offspring (zeraʿ) for his brother. Verse 9 describes what he did during intercourse with Tamar ('whenever he went in to his brother's wife'). It was withdrawal, not masturbation. The text also gives his motive twice, in words that echo verse 8: he knew the offspring 'would not be his', and he acted 'so as not to give offspring to his brother'.
Read in context, the wrong lies in his secret refusal of the levirate duty. He took the union while denying its purpose, which wronged Er's name, Tamar's future and Judah's line.
Calling masturbation 'onanism' does not come from the text. It became common through an anonymous 18th-century English tract, Onania (c. 1716), and later medical writings.
Whether the passage also says something about contraception is a separate question on which serious interpreters still disagree (see Debates).
in v9
Onan's sin wasn't masturbation
- What's often taught
- Genesis 38:9 is often cited as the Bible's condemnation of masturbation, and 'onanism' became a byword for it. On this reading God killed Onan for 'spilling his seed'.
- What the text supports
The verse places Onan's act during intercourse with Tamar: 'whenever he went in to his brother's wife', the standard Hebrew idiom for sex (bôʾ ʾel). What he did was withdraw and destroy his seed on the ground (šiḥēt, 'ruin/destroy'). Ancient Jewish interpreters described it the same way (b. Yevamot 34b).
The narrator also states the motive twice: he knew 'the seed would not be his', and he did it 'so as not to give seed to his brother'. Under the brother-in-law custom, any son would carry dead Er's name and inheritance. Onan repeatedly took sexual access to Tamar while sabotaging the duty, cheating his brother's memory and leaving Tamar childless and exposed, apparently to enlarge his own inheritance.
What the popular reading gets right: the text does treat the deliberate destruction of seed as part of the wrong, since the verb is strong and verse 10 calls 'what he did' evil. Whether the act itself is condemned apart from the refusal is a real debate (see Debates). But a man alone with no levirate duty, no widow and no brother's heir at stake is simply not the situation this verse describes.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Spilled his seed on the ground' (KJV, BSB, NIV-style 'spilled his semen') isolates the physical image and drops the strong verb 'ruin/destroy'. Read out of context, the phrase makes the emission itself look like the whole story. The English term 'onanism', coined in an early-18th-century pamphlet, cemented the association.
in v10
Onan wasn't killed for masturbation
- What's often taught
- Genesis 38 shows that God struck Onan dead for "spilling his seed," so "the sin of Onan" (onanism) is masturbation, and the story is the Bible's warning against it.
- What the text supports
Whatever one concludes about the ethics, this passage does not describe masturbation. Verse 9 describes withdrawal during intercourse with Tamar, "whenever he went in to his brother's wife." Verse 10 condemns "what he did," and the narrator has just defined it by its motive ("Onan knew the offspring would not be his") and its purpose ("so as not to give offspring to his brother"). The wrong the text names is a man secretly refusing his duty to his dead brother and to the widow, out of self-interest, while using her sexually and appearing to obey his father.
The common reading gets one thing right: the physical act is part of the deed, and serious Jewish and Christian interpreters have long debated whether that act carried guilt of its own (see Debates). But linking this verse to masturbation came largely from the 18th-century tract Onania and the moral literature that followed it, not from the Hebrew.
Every word
-
וַיְהִ֗י
vayhi · H1961
and he was · v7, v9
Here it is not the usual opening phrase 'and it came to pass'. It is the plain linking verb: 'Er... was bad.' Its narrative form moves the story on straight from the marriage in verse 6.
-
עֵ֚ר
ʿer · H6147
Er (personal name) · v7
Judah's first son by the Canaanite daughter of Shua (38:2–3). In Hebrew the name is the letters ʿayin–resh, and the word for 'bad' two words later is the same two letters reversed (resh–ʿayin). The name probably comes from a root meaning 'awake, watchful'.
-
בְּכ֣וֹר
bekhor · H1060
firstborn · v7
Being the firstborn mattered: he was the main heir and the one who carried the family line on. The narrator points out that it is Judah's firstborn, his first hope for a line, who is cut off.
-
יְהוּדָ֔ה
yehudah · H3063
Judah · v7, v8
Jacob's fourth son, who has 'gone down' from his brothers (38:1) and is now head of his own household among Canaanites. He is the ancestor of the tribe, and later the royal house, that bore his name.
-
רַ֖ע
raʿ · H7451
bad, evil, displeasing · v7
An adjective that describes what Er was, not a verb naming a deed. It is the broadest Hebrew word for 'bad', running from harmful to morally wrong. Here it is God's verdict on Er's character or conduct, and the narrator leaves the content unnamed.
-
בְּעֵינֵ֣י
beʿenei · H5869
in the eyes of · v7, v10
An idiom for 'in the judgment of'. The badness is measured by YHWH's view, which hints that people may not have seen it. Judah, at least, never seems to know why his son died (38:11).
-
יְהוָ֑ה
YHWH · H3068
the LORD (Yahweh) · v7, v10
Israel's God, named personally. This is the first time the divine name appears in Genesis 38, and it comes in at once as the judge.
-
וַיְמִתֵ֖הוּ
vaymitehu · H4191
and he caused him to die · v7, v10
The causative form of 'to die', with 'him' attached: 'he made him die / put him to death.' The text makes God the direct cause but does not say how. No illness or accident is described.
-
וַיֹּ֤אמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v8
The ordinary narrative verb that moves the story on. What follows is an instruction from the head of the household, not a suggestion.
-
לְאוֹנָ֔ן
ləʾônān · H0209
to Onan · v8, v9
Judah's second son, now the oldest one alive. That is why the duty falls to him. The name is often linked to a root meaning 'vigour' or 'wealth', but that is uncertain and the text makes nothing of it.
-
בֹּ֛א
bōʾ · H0935
-
אֶל־
ʾel · H0413
to, toward · v8, v9
Completes the idiom 'go in to'. It names the woman he is to have relations with.
-
אֵ֥שֶׁת
ʾēšet · H0802
wife of · v8, v9
Tamar is still called 'your brother's wife' even though Er is dead. In the household's eyes she still belongs to Er's line, and that is the whole point of the command.
-
אָחִ֖יךָ
ʾāḥîkā · H0251
your brother · v8, v9
The first of two times 'your brother' appears. The repetition frames the command: it is about the brother from start to finish.
-
וְיַבֵּ֣ם
wəyabbēm · H2992
act as husband's brother (levir) · v8
A command built from the noun yābām, 'husband's brother'. It means 'act as the husband's brother toward her': take your dead brother's place with his widow so she can bear a child for him. The verb appears only here and in Deuteronomy 25:5, 7.
-
אֹתָ֑הּ
ʾōtāh · H0853
(object marker) her · v8, v10
Tamar is the direct object of the duty. Onan owes this to her as well as to Er. A childless widow had no secure place in the household, and this duty gave her one.
-
וְהָקֵ֥ם
wəhāqēm · H6965
raise up, establish · v8
A command form of 'stand': 'make stand, set up, establish'. A line that died with Er is to be made to stand again. Compare 'raise up a name for his brother' in Deuteronomy 25:7 and Ruth 4:5, 10.
-
זֶ֖רַע
zeraʿ · H2233
seed; offspring · v8, v9
Here it means offspring, a descendant to carry on the line. The same word also means semen, and verse 9 plays on both senses.
-
וַיֵּ֣דַע
wayyēdaʿ · H3045
to know · v9
'And he knew': here it means understanding, not sex. Onan worked out the legal outcome. Because the story could have said he 'didn't know', this word marks what follows as a deliberate, informed choice.
-
כִּ֛י
kî · H3588A
that · v9
Introduces what Onan knew.
-
לֹּ֥א
lōʾ · H3808
not · v9
Negates the clause. It comes first, before 'to him', which gives the thought weight: 'not his would the seed be.'
-
ל֖וֹ
lô · H9033
to him / his · v9
'Belonging to him.' Placed before the verb for emphasis: the issue in Onan's mind is whose the child would count as. (The supplied tagging gives the suffix code; the preposition is lĕ, 'to, belonging to'.)
-
אִם־
ʾim · H518A
if, when · v9
Here 'when(ever)', not a real 'if'. The construction describes what kept happening each time he went in to her.
-
וְשִׁחֵ֣ת
wəšiḥēt · H7843
to ruin, destroy, spoil · v9
'And he would ruin/destroy.' This is a strong verb of deliberate destruction, not 'spill' in the sense of an accident, and its form again marks a repeated act. The object is left unstated; readers understand it as his seed. It is the same verb used for the earth's corruption and destruction in the Flood story (Genesis 6:11–13).
-
אַ֔רְצָה
ʾarṣâ · H776H
earth, ground · v9
'Groundward, onto the ground.' The ending -â shows direction. The seed went to the dirt instead of to Tamar.
-
לְבִלְתִּ֥י
ləbiltî · H1115
so as not, lest · v9
States purpose: 'in order not to.' The narrator spells out the motive. He was not avoiding pregnancy for its own sake but specifically denying his brother an heir.
-
נְתָן־
nəton · H5414G
to give · v9
'To give.' A rare form of the infinitive (the usual one is tēt). It reverses Judah's 'raise up seed' (v.8): Onan refuses to 'give' what he was charged to provide.
-
וַיֵּ֛רַע
wayyēraʿ · H7489
be evil, be bad · v10
"And it was evil." The grammatical subject is the clause that follows, "what he did." It is a verdict, not a feeling: Onan's conduct is classed as bad and harmful. It deliberately echoes v. 7, where Er was "evil (raʿ) in the eyes of Yahweh," and Er's name (ער) is the word raʿ (רע) spelled backwards.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H834
which, that which · v10
"That which." It turns "he did" into a noun phrase, "what he did." That points back to the whole conduct described in v. 9: his motive, his repeated action and its purpose.
-
עָשָׂ֑ה
ʿāśâ · H6213
do, make · v10
"He did." It sums up v. 9, which describes a habit ("whenever he went in to his brother's wife"), not a single act. The deed judged is a pattern of behaviour with a stated aim: "so as not to give offspring to his brother."
-
גַּם־
gam · H1571
also, too · v10
"Also." It ties Onan's fate to Er's: a second son of Judah dies for evil in Yahweh's eyes. It also sets up Judah's fear in v. 11 that Shelah "may die too (gam), like his brothers."
The world behind it
Where this sits. Genesis 38 breaks into the Joseph story just after Judah has helped sell Joseph and deceive Jacob (37:26–35). Judah "goes down" from his brothers, settles near Adullam, and marries the daughter of a Canaanite named Shua (38:1–2). Er is the first of their three sons. Judah then arranges Er's marriage to Tamar (38:6). As head of the family he chose his son's wife, which was normal at the time.
What a firstborn meant. In Israel and the wider ancient Near East, the firstborn son was the main heir and carried the family's name and land into the next generation. Losing him without children threatened the line itself. That is why the very next verse (38:8) turns to the custom we call levirate marriage, after the Latin levir, "brother-in-law": a dead man's brother fathered a child with the widow, and the child counted as the dead man's heir (formalised later in Deut 25:5–10).
A recurring pattern. Genesis keeps passing over or removing the firstborn (Cain, Ishmael, Esau, Reuben, Manasseh, and in this chapter Zerah). Israelite listeners would recognise the pattern. The family line is shaped by God's choosing, not by birth order.
Why the tribe of Judah cared. The clans of Judah traced themselves to Shelah, Perez and Zerah. Er and Onan had no descendants (Num 26:19–21; 1 Chr 2:3–4). This verse is part of the story of why the royal line comes through Perez, Tamar's son, and not through Judah's firstborn.
From the study of Genesis 38:7.
Where scholars differ
in v7
What was Er's sin?
-
It is left unstated on purpose. The verse gives God's verdict, not the charge.
Verse 7 uses only the adjective raʿ ('bad'), with no verb naming an act. Verse 10 does describe what Onan did. The contrast suggests the narrator had no interest in detailing Er's sin, and the Er/raʿ pun may be part of why the verse is so brief. Westermann and Wenham broadly take this view.
-
It was the same as Onan's: avoiding conception with Tamar.
Rabbinic tradition (Genesis Rabbah 85; b. Yevamot 34b) reads 'him also' in v. 10 as meaning Onan's sin matched Er's. Critics reply that 'also' in v. 10 more naturally refers to the death ('he put him to death also'), not to the sin.
-
Er refused Tamar under the influence of his Canaanite mother.
Jubilees 41 and the Testament of Judah 10, both Second Temple Jewish works, link Er's sin to his mother's Canaanite family, drawing on 38:2. This is ancient interpretation, not something the Genesis text states.
in v7
What does the name Er mean, and is the pun with raʿ intended?
-
The name means 'watchful/awake', from the root ʿ-w-r, and the reversal with raʿ is a deliberate narrative pun.
Lexicons connect the name with that root. Genesis often plays on names, and many commentators (e.g. Sarna, Alter) point out the ער/רע reversal.
-
The derivation is uncertain, and the pun, though obvious to the ear, should not be pressed into a claim that the name caused or predicted his character.
Proper names often have obscure origins. The text draws no explicit link between the name and the verdict, unlike the explained names elsewhere in Genesis ('she called his name... because...').
in v8
Was the levirate union a full marriage or a limited duty to produce an heir?
-
A full marriage: the brother took the widow as his own wife.
Deuteronomy 25:5 says he 'shall take her to himself as wife'. In Ruth 4 Boaz marries Ruth outright. Onan's repeated relations with Tamar (v. 9, 'whenever he went in') suggest an ongoing union, not a single act.
-
A defined duty centred on producing an heir, which need not have created an ordinary marriage.
Genesis 38:8 states only the aim: offspring for the brother. Judah 'did not know her again' after Tamar conceived (38:26). Comparisons with other ancient Near Eastern laws and Raymond Westbrook's work stress the inheritance purpose (Westbrook 1991).
in v8
Given the duty stated in v. 8, why was Onan put to death (v. 10)?
-
For refusing the levirate duty: a self-serving, deceptive evasion that wronged his brother, Tamar and Judah's line.
Verse 9 gives his motive twice, in terms that echo v. 8: 'the offspring would not be his' and 'so as not to give offspring to his brother'. Because Deuteronomy 25's penalty for open refusal is only public shame, many commentators (e.g. Wenham, Sarna, Hamilton) see the death as punishment for secret, repeated exploitation of Tamar while pretending to do his duty.
-
For the act of wasting seed or preventing conception as such.
Some rabbinic texts link Er's and Onan's sin to the misuse of seed (b. Yevamot 34b), and a long Christian tradition, including Augustine and Pius XI's encyclical *Casti Connubii* (1930), cited the passage against contraception. Supporters note that verse 10 calls 'what he did' evil.
in v8
How does this command relate to the later ban on relations with a brother's wife (Lev 18:16; 20:21)?
-
The Levitical ban applies while the brother is alive, or when he has children. The levirate is a deliberate exception for a brother who died childless.
Deuteronomy 25:5-10 explicitly requires the union in that case. Later Jewish law (the Mishnah, tractate Yevamot) harmonises the texts this way.
-
The texts reflect different periods or traditions about the practice.
Some critical scholars read Leviticus 20:21 ('they shall be childless') as reflecting a stance that limited or disfavoured the custom.
in v9
Why was Onan's act 'evil in YHWH's eyes' (v.10): the act of withdrawing and destroying seed itself, or his refusal of the levirate duty?
-
The sin was the refusal: selfish, deceptive sabotage of his duty to his dead brother and to Tamar, motivated by inheritance.
The verse states the motive twice: 'the seed would not be his' and 'so as not to give seed to his brother'. The habitual 'whenever' shows exploitation: he kept sexual access while denying the purpose. Er's death and Judah's withholding of Shelah fit the same theme of men failing the family line, and Judah's confession (v.26) concerns the levirate duty. Most modern critical commentators (e.g. Wenham, Sarna, Westermann) read it this way.
-
The act of deliberately destroying seed was itself part of the evil, not only the refusal.
The strong verb šāḥat ('ruin/destroy') names the act, not merely the refusal. Deuteronomy 25:7–10 punishes a brother who openly refuses levirate duty with public shame, not death, so some argue the death penalty here points to the act itself. Rabbinic law (b. Niddah 13a) and long Christian tradition (Augustine, later Luther and Calvin) drew this conclusion. Respondents note that Deuteronomy is a later law code dealing with an open refusal, not deceit, and that Genesis 38 does not explain the death beyond 'what he did'.
in v9
What exactly did Onan do physically?
-
Coitus interruptus: withdrawing before ejaculation during intercourse with Tamar.
'Whenever he went in to his brother's wife' is the standard idiom for intercourse, and the act happens in that setting. The Talmud describes it the same way (b. Yevamot 34b). This is the overwhelming majority view.
-
Masturbation (the later sense of 'onanism').
Rests on the 18th-century coinage and on reading 'spilled his seed' apart from its context. It has little exegetical support, because the verse places the act during intercourse.
in v10
What exactly was the "evil" for which Onan died?
-
The refusal of the brother-in-law duty, done by fraud and for gain: cheating his dead brother of an heir and Tamar of a child while appearing to comply.
Verse 9 gives the motive ("Onan knew the offspring would not be his") and the purpose ("so as not to give offspring to his brother"). The repeated-action form ("whenever he went in") shows a deliberate pattern. Verse 10's "what he did" sums up that described conduct. Most modern critical and evangelical commentators read it this way (e.g. Wenham, Westermann, Sarna, Hamilton).
-
The sexual act itself, deliberately wasting seed or preventing conception, was the evil (or a central part of it).
Some rabbinic tradition treats Er and Onan as guilty of "destroying seed" (b. Yevamot 34b; b. Niddah 13a; Genesis Rabbah 85). Augustine and Jerome condemned the act, and Luther and Calvin wrote sharply against it. Supporters note that Deut 25 punishes open refusal only with shame, so the death penalty suggests something more than refusal. Historic Catholic moral teaching cited the passage against contraception, though modern Catholic arguments rest mainly on other grounds.
-
The deed was a compound wrong: greed, deception, sexual exploitation of Tamar, and disobedience to Judah, together with the hidden act.
The text joins motive, method and purpose in one sentence. The contrast with Deut 25 can be explained by Onan's pretence and his repeated use of Tamar rather than by the physical act alone. The verb in v. 9, šiḥēt ("ruin, corrupt"), describes what the act did to the brother's line.
in v10
Why does Onan die when later law (Deut 25:5–10) gives only public shame for refusing the duty?
-
Open refusal and secret fraud are different wrongs. Onan pretended to comply and exploited Tamar, which is worse than refusing openly.
Deuteronomy's ceremony assumes a public refusal before the elders. Onan's conduct was hidden from everyone but Yahweh ("in the eyes of Yahweh").
-
The death shows that the act itself carried special guilt beyond the refusal.
Argued from the gap in penalty by many traditional interpreters. Critics reply that this is an inference, since the narrator states only the motive and purpose.
-
The comparison is out of place: Genesis is narrative, not law, and the deaths are direct divine judgments rather than penalties set by a law code.
Neither Er's death nor Onan's involves any human legal process. Er's death (v. 7) has no stated crime at all, so the story is about Yahweh's verdict rather than a schedule of penalties.
Sources
- BDB s.v. רַע
- HALOT s.v. רַע
- HALOT s.v. עֵר
- BDB s.v. מוּת (Hiphil)
- N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis, on 38:7
- G. Wenham, Word Biblical Commentary: Genesis 16–50, on 38:7
- C. Westermann, Genesis 37–50, on 38:7
- R. Alter, The Five Books of Moses, note on Gen 38:7
- Genesis Rabbah 85
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 34b
- Jubilees 41:1–3
- Testament of Judah 10
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Genesis 38:7
- Vulgate, Genesis 38:7
- Numbers 26:19; 1 Chronicles 2:3
- BDB s.v. יָבַם
- HALOT s.v. יבם
- BDB s.v. קוּם (Hiphil)
- HALOT s.v. זֶרַע
- Hittite Laws §193
- Middle Assyrian Laws A §§30, 33, 43
- Deuteronomy 25:5-10; Ruth 3–4
- Septuagint, Genesis 38:8
- Matthew 22:24; Mark 12:19; Luke 20:28
- R. Westbrook, 'The Law of the Biblical Levirate', in Property and the Family in Biblical Law (1991)
- G. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. Sarna, The JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
- V. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Gen 38
- Onania, or the Heinous Sin of Self-Pollution (anonymous tract, London, c. 1716)
- BDB s.v. שָׁחַת; זֶרַע; יָבַם
- HALOT s.v. שׁחת; זֶרַע; יבם
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax (on frequentative weqatal)
- Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew (on frequentative wehayah + ʾim)
- Gordon Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Nahum Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
- Claus Westermann, Genesis 37–50
- Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative (on Genesis 38)
- Middle Assyrian Laws A §§30, 33, 43; Hittite Laws §193
- Septuagint, Genesis 38:9
- Vulgate, Genesis 38:9
- Targum Onkelos, Genesis 38:9
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 34b; Niddah 13a
- Onania (anonymous pamphlet, c. 1716)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. רָעַע (raʿaʿ)
- HALOT s.v. מוּת (hiphil)
- HALOT s.v. יבם (yibbem, levirate)
- Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
- Victor Hamilton, Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
- Hittite Laws §193; Middle Assyrian Laws A §§30, 33, 43
- Babylonian Talmud Yevamot 34b; Niddah 13a; Genesis Rabbah 85
- Vulgate, Gen 38:10
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).