Isaiah Chapter 63 Read as one passage

Isaiah 63:10–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10But they rebelled and grieved His Holy Spirit. So He turned and became their enemy, and He Himself fought against them. 11Then His people remembered the days of old, the days of Moses. Where is He who brought them through the sea with the shepherds of His flock? Where is the One who set His Holy Spirit among them,

What the first hearers heard

For the people praying this lament, probably Judeans living among the ruins after Babylon's conquest, or soon after, the verse did several things at once:

  • It owned the disaster. It refused the easy explanations that Babylon's gods were stronger or that the God of Israel had simply forgotten them. Their own defiance, going back to the wilderness, had turned their Savior into their opponent. That is an honest confession of sin as a people, not only as individuals. "They" are the ancestors and, by implication, the praying community too.
  • It kept God at the centre. The stressed "he himself fought against them" sounds harsh, but it holds on to God's power and involvement. If the Lord was the one fighting them, then the Lord was also the one who could stop and turn back.
  • It set up the appeal. Because the conflict is described in family terms (sons who rebelled, a spirit that was grieved), the plea can be family-shaped too. Right after this the community remembers the Exodus and asks, "Where is he…?" (v. 11). Then it cries, "You are our Father … return for the sake of your servants" (63:16–17; 64:8). The verse is confession leading toward hope, not resignation.
  • It used the language of worship they knew. The two verbs echo Psalm 78:40 and the "rebel" vocabulary of Numbers and Deuteronomy. Hearers would have recognised the familiar story of their own wilderness failure, now applied to their present ruin.

From the study of Isaiah 63:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10But they rebelled and grieved His Holy Spirit. So He turned and became their enemy, and He Himself fought against them.

    "But they, the very people he had just lifted up and carried like a child through all the days of old, defied him the way a stubborn son defies his father. They did real hurt to the spirit of his holiness, his own holy presence that had gone among them in the wilderness. So everything was overturned. The God who had become their savior (v. 8) was turned into their enemy. And he himself, not merely Egypt or Assyria or Babylon, took the field and made war on them."

    Several things stand out in the Hebrew:

    • They / He. The verse begins with a stressed "they" and ends with a stressed "he." The people's defiance and God's hostility face each other like two armies.
    • Savior / enemy. Verse 8 and verse 10 are built the same way, "he became to them a savior" and "he was turned to them into an enemy," so the relationship is mirrored and reversed.
    • Rebellion and grief together. "Rebelled" is defiance of rightful authority, especially a parent's. "Grieved" means pain caused, not mere annoyance. The two verbs are taken from the wilderness memory of Psalm 78:40: "How often they rebelled against him in the wilderness and grieved him in the desert."
    • Overturned. The word for "turned" is the word for overturning Sodom and turning the Nile to blood. The God who once overturned Egypt for Israel overturned his own stance toward them.
    • War language. "Enemy" and "fought" are military words. The Divine Warrior who "will fight for you" (Exodus 14:14) now fights against them.

    The speakers are Israel. They are confessing why God's past kindness turned into the disasters of their own history, and the confession prepares the plea that follows: you are our Father; return (63:15–17; 64:8–9).

    Full study →
  2. 11Then His people remembered the days of old, the days of Moses. Where is He who brought them through the sea with the shepherds of His flock? Where is the One who set His Holy Spirit among them,

    Then he remembered (the people, as one body, called back to mind, or perhaps God himself recalled; the Hebrew leaves it open) the days of long ago, the age of Moses, his people. Remembering in Hebrew is not quiet nostalgia but the first move of an appeal: rehearsing what God once did so as to ask him to do it again.

    "Where is the One who brought them up out of the sea, the God whose very title is 'he who brings up', the old exodus name, lifting his people up out of the deadly waters, along with the shepherds of his flock" (Moses and Aaron, his under-shepherds; the flock was always his)?

    "Where is the One who set within them the spirit of his own holiness?" God's holy breath and presence was placed in the midst of the people (or, as some read it, within Moses). It guided them through the wilderness and gave them rest (v.14). It was so personally present that their rebellion could 'grieve' it (v.10).

    The double 'Where is…?' is the cry of lament. It is not doubt that God exists. It is a protest that the God who once lived among them now seems absent, and a plea for him to be that God again. Coming straight after 'he became their enemy' (v.10), it marks the moment the people finally ask the question the prophet Jeremiah once faulted them for never asking (Jer 2:6).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    vexed (KJV: "vexed his holy Spirit")

    ʿiṣṣəbû

    What we hear
    Irritated or annoyed him, a minor bother.
    What they heard
    Caused him pain; hurt or grieved him deeply. The root is linked to anguish and painful toil (Genesis 3:16; 6:6).
  • in v10

    His Holy Spirit (capitalized)

    rûaḥ qodšô

    What we hear
    The proper name of the third Person of the Trinity, with everything later Christian doctrine says about him already assumed.
    What they heard
    "The spirit of his holiness": God's own holy, active presence among Israel in the Exodus and wilderness, named alongside "the angel of his presence" (v. 9) and "the spirit of the LORD" (v. 14). It is personal enough to be grieved, but the text does not define its relationship to God as a separate Person.
  • in v11

    His Holy Spirit

    rûaḥ qodšô

    What we hear
    The Third Person of the Trinity, as defined in later Christian creeds, signalled by the capital letters.
    What they heard
    'The spirit of his holiness': God's own holy breath, power and presence active among Israel in the exodus and wilderness. It is personal enough to be grieved (v.10), but it is not yet set out as a distinct person within the Godhead. The point of the phrase is that God himself was present among them.
  • in v11

    remembered

    zākar

    What we hear
    A private mental recollection or a wistful look back.
    What they heard
    Calling to mind so as to act: rehearsing God's past deeds as the basis of an appeal and a return to him. When God remembers, he takes action for his people.
Every word
  1. וְהֵ֛מָּה

    wəhēmmāh · H1992

    and/but they · v10

    A separate, stressed pronoun: "but THEY." Hebrew does not need it, since the verb already says "they," so its presence sets the people against the "He" of verse 9 who saved, redeemed, lifted and carried them.

  2. מָר֥וּ

    mārû · H4784

    to rebel, be defiant · v10

    "They rebelled." This means stubborn, defiant refusal of someone with rightful authority, the word used for the wilderness generation and for the defiant son of Deuteronomy 21:18. It sharpens the irony of verse 8, where God had said, "they are sons who will not be false."

  3. וְעִצְּב֖וּ

    wəʿiṣṣəbû · H6087A

    to hurt, pain, grieve · v10

    "And they pained / hurt." The verb form means causing pain, not just disappointing someone. The people did real hurt to God's spirit. This is the language of a wounded relationship.

  4. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [direct-object marker] · v10, v11

    This word has no translation. It marks "the spirit of his holiness" as the direct object of the hurting. The spirit is what receives the pain.

  5. ר֣וּחַ

    rûaḥ · H7307G

    spirit, breath, wind · v10, v11

    "Spirit of…" Here it means God's own living, active presence. Verse 14 calls it "the spirit of the LORD" that gave the people rest. Since it can be pained, it is pictured as more than an impersonal force.

  6. קָדְשׁ֑וֹ

    qodšô · H6944G

    holiness; his holiness · v10, v11

    Literally "his holiness." Hebrew often uses a noun where English uses an adjective, so "spirit of his holiness" means "his holy spirit": the spirit that belongs to God's own set-apart, separate sphere. The phrase occurs in the Hebrew Bible only here, in verse 11, and in Psalm 51:11 (51:13 in Hebrew).

  7. וַיֵּהָפֵ֥ךְ

    wayyēhāpēk · H2015

    to turn, overturn, change · v10

    "And he was turned / turned himself." The verb means a full reversal of state. It is the word for overturning Sodom, for the Nile turned to blood, and for a heart that changes completely. The God who had turned things upside down for Israel is now turned against them.

  8. לָהֶ֛ם

    lāhem · H9038

    to/for them · v10

    "For them / toward them." The words "lāhem lə-" ("to them … into") repeat the pattern of verse 8, "he became to them a savior," so the two verses mirror each other: savior there, enemy here.

  9. לְאוֹיֵ֖ב

    ləʾôyēb · H0341

    enemy · v10

    "Into an enemy." In form the word is "one who is hostile," the ordinary word for a military foe. Lamentations 2:5 says the Lord became "like an enemy." This verse leaves out the "like."

  10. ה֥וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he · v10

    A stressed pronoun again: "He himself." It answers the "they" that opens the verse. The people who fought against Israel were only instruments. The real opponent was God.

  11. נִלְחַם־

    nilḥam- · H3898A

    to fight, wage war · v10

    "He fought / made war." This is the vocabulary of the divine warrior: "The LORD will fight for you" (Exodus 14:14). Here the warfare is aimed the other way.

  12. וַיִּזְכֹּר

    wayyizkōr · H2142

    and he remembered · v11

    A story verb ('and then he remembered') that moves the narrative on. It follows straight from v.10, where God became Israel's enemy. The grammatical subject is 'he' and is not named: it may be the people taken as one body, or God. Hebrew 'remembering' means calling something to mind so that it shapes what you do next, not only recalling it.

  13. יְמֵי־

    yəmê- · H3117

    days of · v11

    'Days' in the sense of an era or period, here the founding age of the nation.

  14. עוֹלָם

    ʿôlām · H5769

    antiquity, long duration · v11

    With 'days', it means the distant past, 'the days of long ago'. In this phrase it does not mean 'eternity'. It points to the foundational time of the exodus.

  15. מֹשֶׁה

    mōšeh · H4872

    Moses · v11

    It stands awkwardly next to 'days of old' without a connecting word, as if to say 'the old days, Moses' days'. It names the leader through whom God acted. His name sounds like 'one who draws out' (Exod 2:10), which fits the 'brought up from the sea' that follows.

  16. עַמּוֹ

    ʿammô · H5971

    his people · v11

    'His people', meaning God's people or Moses' people. It may be the subject ('his people remembered'), a further description ('Moses, and his people'), or an added scribal note. The covenant word ʿam marks Israel as kin and as God's own.

  17. אַיֵּה

    ʾayyēh · H346

    where? · v11

    The 'where is…?' of lament. It does not doubt that God exists. It complains that he seems absent and asks him to act as he once did.

  18. הַמַּעֲלֵם

    hammaʿălēm · H5927

    the one who brought them up · v11

    'Bring up', the stock verb for the exodus ('who brought you up from Egypt'). It is in the form of a title: 'the One-who-brings-them-up', a name drawn from what God did.

  19. מִיָּם

    miyyām · H3220

    from the sea · v11

    The Sea of Reeds crossing. The sea was also the ancient picture of chaos and death, so being brought 'up from the sea' is a rescue out of the deep.

  20. אֵת

    ʾēt · H854

    with · v11

    'Together with', which puts the shepherds alongside the people as God brings them up. (The Greek translators read the same letters as the object marker instead, so that God brought up 'the shepherd'.)

  21. רֹעֵי

    rōʿê · H7462

    shepherds of · v11

    A verb form used as a noun: 'those who pasture', meaning shepherds. In the ancient Near East this was a standard title for leaders. In the plural it most naturally means Moses and Aaron (Ps 77:20).

  22. צֹאנוֹ

    ṣōʾnô · H6629

    his flock · v11

    God's flock, meaning Israel. The people belong to God, and Moses and Aaron are his under-shepherds.

  23. הַשָּׂם

    haśśām · H7760

    the one who put/set · v11

    Another title-like phrase: 'the One-who-set'. The verb means to place or set something deliberately, as one sets a thing in position.

  24. בְּקִרְבּוֹ

    bəqirbô · H7130

    in its midst / within him · v11

    Qereb means the inside or the middle. The word for 'its' or 'him' could refer to the flock or people ('among them') or to Moses ('within him'). Elsewhere qereb is the word for God dwelling 'in the midst' of Israel (Exod 33:3, 5).

The world behind it

The kind of poem. Isaiah 63:7–64:12 is a community lament, a prayer the whole people speak in a time of national ruin. It follows a familiar pattern, also found in Psalms 44, 78, 89 and 106 and in Nehemiah 9:

  1. Recalling God's past kindness (63:7–9): the Exodus, when God was their savior and carried them.
  2. Confessing the people's failure (63:10): this verse.
  3. Remembering, and asking where God has gone (63:11–14): "Where is he who brought them up out of the sea … who put his holy spirit in their midst?"
  4. A plea built on the relationship (63:15–64:12): "You are our Father … our holy and beautiful house has been burned with fire."

What history it remembers. The verse first points back to the wilderness, when Israel defied God at Meribah and refused to enter the land (Numbers 14; 20; Deuteronomy 1). At Hormah, God's absence meant defeat (Numbers 14:41–45). But the poem is spoken from a later disaster: Jerusalem and the temple lie in ruins (63:18; 64:10–11), which most readers connect with the Babylonian destruction of 587 BC and its aftermath. The confession explains that ruin. The story was not "our God lost to Babylon's gods" but "our God turned and fought us."

The Divine Warrior. Throughout the ancient Near East, a people's god was expected to fight its battles, and a defeat was often explained as the god's anger. The Moabite Stone (c. 840 BC) says Moab was oppressed because its god Chemosh "was angry with his land." Israel's own tradition celebrated the Lord as warrior (Exodus 15:3) and also warned that he could turn that power against his covenant people (Leviticus 26:17, 25; Deuteronomy 28:25). Prophets and poets said it plainly (Jeremiah 21:5; Lamentations 2:4–5). Isaiah 63:10 belongs to that tradition.

Spirit in the Exodus memory. Israel told the wilderness story with God present through his "angel," his "presence" (literally his "face," Exodus 33:14–15) and his spirit resting on Moses and the elders (Numbers 11). Nehemiah 9:20 and Haggai 2:5 likewise recall God's spirit guiding Israel. This verse and verse 11 name that spirit "the spirit of his holiness."

From the study of Isaiah 63:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

What is "the spirit of his holiness" here: God's own presence, or a distinct personal agent?

  • God's own active presence, a way of speaking of God himself at work among Israel.

    It stands alongside "the angel of his presence" (v. 9) and "the spirit of the LORD" (v. 14), and compare Exodus 33:14–15, where God's "presence" (literally "face") goes with Israel. Psalm 51:11 puts "your holy spirit" in parallel with "your presence." Grieving the spirit is grieving God (compare Psalm 78:40, "grieved him"). Many critical commentators (e.g., Westermann, Blenkinsopp) read it this way.

  • A distinct, personal figure, close to being separate from God, which prepares for later Jewish and Christian developments.

    The spirit is the object of grief, which is personal language. It is "put in their midst" (v. 11) and "gives rest" (v. 14), acting like an agent. Some readers see God, the angel of the presence and the spirit as a threefold portrait in vv. 9–14. Ephesians 4:30 takes up the verse in a personal sense, and Christian interpreters from the early church onward read it in Trinitarian terms.

  • The spirit resting on Moses and the leaders, given to the people through them.

    Verse 11 links the spirit to Moses and "the shepherds of his flock." Numbers 11:17, 25 has God's spirit on Moses shared with the seventy elders. Psalm 106:33's "his spirit" is often taken as Moses' spirit or God's spirit in Moses. This reading mainly concerns v. 11 but affects how v. 10 is read.

in v10

When and from where was this lament composed?

  • In Judah during the exile, soon after 587 BC, before the return.

    The temple is described as burned and Zion as a wilderness (64:10–11), with no sign of rebuilding. H. G. M. Williamson and others argue that the lament comes from Judeans who stayed in the land, and may even be older than parts of Isaiah 40–55.

  • After the exile (Persian period), within the collection often called "Third Isaiah" (chs. 56–66).

    Its links with the surrounding chapters and its concern with who belongs to the true "servants" (63:17; 65:8–15) suggest the community debates of the restoration period. Many commentators (e.g., Westermann, Blenkinsopp) place it here, though some still date the core lament earlier.

  • Written by Isaiah of Jerusalem (8th century BC), speaking ahead of the coming judgment.

    This is the traditional Jewish and Christian view of the book's unity, based on the book's single title (1:1) and the New Testament's citing of the whole as "Isaiah." On this view the prophet speaks for a future people looking back on a destruction still to come.

in v11

Who is the subject of 'he remembered'?

  • The people (collective): 'his people remembered' (BSB, NIV, NASB).

    The questions that follow ('Where is he…?') naturally come from the people. 'His people' can be read as the subject placed after the verb, and the lament form expects the community to recall God's acts (Ps 77:11).

  • God: 'Then he (God) remembered the days of old.'

    The nearest subject is God in v.10 ('he turned… he fought'), and the verb is singular. Lev 26:42, 45 has God 'remembering' the exodus covenant in the middle of judgment. On this view the 'where?' questions are either the people's (with 'saying' supplied) or God's own searching.

  • The text is disturbed, and the original subject cannot be settled with certainty.

    The awkward 'Moses, his people', the Septuagint's apparently shorter text, and modern emendations (NRSV) all suggest some early textual trouble.

in v11

Where was the holy spirit set: 'among them' or 'within him'?

  • Among the people or flock (most modern versions).

    Qereb is the word for God dwelling 'in the midst' of Israel (Exod 33:3, 5; Hag 2:5 has 'my spirit remains in your midst'), and v.14 says the spirit gave the people rest.

  • Within Moses (KJV's 'within him' allows this).

    Num 11:17, 25 speaks of the spirit that was upon Moses and was shared with the seventy elders, and the nearest singular noun is 'shepherd/flock'.

in v11

How personal is 'the spirit of his holiness' here?

  • God's own presence and power, described by God's holiness, not a separate figure.

    Hebrew rûaḥ language elsewhere refers to God's own active presence (Ps 139:7, 'Where can I go from your spirit… your presence?'). In vv.9–14 the angel of presence, spirit and arm are three ways of describing God himself acting.

  • Treated in personal terms, a step toward later Jewish and Christian ideas of the Spirit as an agent.

    The spirit can be 'grieved' (v.10), it 'gave them rest' (v.14), and it is placed alongside the 'angel of his presence' (v.9). The NT echoes this language for the Spirit (Acts 7:51; Eph 4:30).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מָרָה, עָצַב, הָפַךְ, אֹיֵב, לָחַם
  • HALOT s.v. מרה, עצב I, הפך, רוּחַ, קֹדֶשׁ
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 63:10 (Göttingen ed., J. Ziegler)
  • Claus Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL)
  • Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 56–66 (Anchor Bible)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, "Isaiah 63,7–64,11: Exilic Lament or Post-Exilic Protest?" ZAW 102 (1990)
  • Brevard S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
  • Shalom M. Paul, Isaiah 40–66 (Eerdmans Critical Commentary)
  • Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 4–6
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 63
  • BDB s.v. זָכַר, עָלָה, רוּחַ, קֶרֶב
  • HALOT s.v. רוּחַ, רֹעֶה, אַיֵּה
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Isaiah 63:11
  • BHS critical apparatus, Isaiah 63:11
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 56–66 (Anchor Bible)
  • C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL)
  • J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 40–66 (NICOT)
  • B. S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
  • F. Delitzsch, Commentary on Isaiah

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).