Jeremiah Chapter 12 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 12:1–2

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1Righteous are You, O LORD, when I plead before You. Yet about Your judgments I wish to contend with You: Why does the way of the wicked prosper? Why do all the faithless live at ease? 2You planted them, and they have taken root. They have grown and produced fruit. You are ever on their lips, but far from their hearts.

What the first hearers heard

To Jeremiah's first hearers, and to the exiles who later read his collected words, the verse said several things at once:

  • Lament is legitimate covenant speech. A loyal servant of Yahweh, the prophet himself, could take God to court in prayer, using legal language. Israel's psalms of lament already did this. Jeremiah's version is unusually bold because it applies to God the very phrase God used when he put Judah on trial (1:16; 4:12).
  • The problem is real, and Scripture names it. The covenant promised security to the loyal and disaster to traitors. What people actually saw was the reverse. The verse does not explain the problem away. It states it as a formal charge, and the "why" goes unanswered in the verse itself.
  • It is personal. The betrayers include Jeremiah's own clan (11:21; 12:6). For a man whose identity rested on family and town, this was the deepest kind of wrong.
  • The answer that follows is not an explanation. In 12:5-6 God replies with a harder challenge ("If you have raced with men on foot and they have worn you out, how will you compete with horses?") and a warning about his family. In 12:7-13 God then voices his own grief at abandoning "my house," "my inheritance," "the beloved of my soul." For readers who had lived through Jerusalem's fall in 587 BC, this showed that the traitors' ease was temporary, that judgment was coming on the whole land, and that God was not untouched by it.

From the study of Jeremiah 12:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1Righteous are You, O LORD, when I plead before You. Yet about Your judgments I wish to contend with You: Why does the way of the wicked prosper? Why do all the faithless live at ease?

    "You are in the right, LORD. I know that if I take you to court, you will win. Even so, I am going to lay my case before you and argue it with you. Why is it that the road the guilty travel keeps getting them where they want to go? Why are they all living secure and untroubled, every one of these traitors who make betrayal their way of life?"

    The verse is built like a legal brief. Jeremiah starts with a concession borrowed from ordinary worship ("Righteous are you, O LORD," compare Psalm 119:137), but in his mouth it is courtroom language: God is the party "in the right." Then he says "yet" and files his charges anyway. The words are the technical terms of an Israelite lawsuit: riv, "bring a case," and "speak cases with," the same phrase God used when he put Judah on trial (Jer 1:16; 4:12). One "why" covers two complaints. The first is that the guilty (the legal opposite of God's "in the right") are on a road that succeeds. The second is that the betrayers, people who break faith with covenant, marriage and family, are at ease, safe and carefree. Both verbs describe a settled state: this is how things stand, not a passing blip. Behind the general question is a personal one. Jeremiah's own kinsmen in Anathoth have plotted to kill him (11:18-23), and verse 6 will name them among the "betrayers."

    Full study →
  2. 2You planted them, and they have taken root. They have grown and produced fruit. You are ever on their lips, but far from their hearts.

    "You planted them, and yes, they've put down roots. They keep spreading and growing, and yes, they've borne fruit. You are close by in their mouths, but far away from their kidneys, the hidden depths where they really live."

    Jeremiah is arguing a case with God (verse 1 uses courtroom language: "I would bring a case against you"). He piles one stage of growth on another, planted… rooted… growing… fruiting, and each "yes, even" adds to his frustration. The picture is the blessed tree of Psalm 1 and Jeremiah 17:8, but the people living out that picture are the faithless. Worse, he says God himself planted them, using the very verb from Jeremiah's own call to "uproot and plant" (1:10).

    The last line explains why this is unbearable. These people are not unbelievers. God's name is constantly in their speech: in oaths, prayers and temple talk. Yet he is "far" from their kidneys, which Hebrew treated as the seat of a person's hidden motives and deepest feelings, the place God alone examines (11:20). The God who "tests kidneys and heart" knows exactly how hollow they are, and they are thriving anyway. That is the question Jeremiah cannot let go.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v1

    plead (KJV, BSB)

    riv

    What we hear
    To beg or implore earnestly.
    What they heard
    To bring a lawsuit, argue a legal case, contend in court.
  • in v1

    [thy] judgments / about Your judgments

    mishpatim

    What we hear
    God's verdicts or punishments, which Jeremiah wants to discuss.
    What they heard
    Legal cases or charges. "Speak cases with" is a set phrase for arguing or pursuing a case against someone. The Hebrew has no "your."
  • in v1

    happy (KJV)

    shalu

    What we hear
    Feeling glad or cheerful.
    What they heard
    Secure, untroubled, at ease, living without fear of a reckoning.
  • in v1

    the faithless (BSB, NIV)

    bogdey baged

    What we hear
    People without religious faith, unbelievers.
    What they heard
    Traitors: people who break faith with a bond of loyalty (covenant, marriage, kin). The doubled root marks them as thorough betrayers.
  • in v1

    Righteous are You

    tsaddiq

    What we hear
    A statement about God's moral perfection or holiness in general.
    What they heard
    In this legal setting: "You are in the right," meaning you would win the case. It includes moral rightness, but here it is a courtroom concession.
  • in v2

    far from their hearts (BSB, NIV, ESV, WEB) / reins (KJV, YLT)

    kilyôt (kidneys)

    What we hear
    'Heart' suggests feelings or sincerity of emotion. 'Reins' suggests horse-reins or control.
    What they heard
    The kidneys: the deepest, hidden inner self of motive and feeling, which only God searches. It is distinct from the 'heart' (the mind and will), which Jeremiah pairs with it in 11:20, 17:10 and 20:12.
  • in v2

    You are ever on their lips (BSB)

    qārôv ʾattāh bephîhem (near are you in their mouth)

    What we hear
    They talk about God a lot; a general sense of frequent mention.
    What they heard
    A spatial contrast: God is near (in the mouth) yet far (from the kidneys). The point is the gap between outward speech and inner reality, not how often they speak.
Every word
  1. צַדִּ֤יק

    tsaddiq · H6662

    righteous, in the right · v1

    Put first for emphasis: "In the right are you." In a lawsuit setting this is the word for the party who wins, the one found innocent. Jeremiah grants God's case before he makes his own.

  2. אַתָּה֙

    attah · H0859A

    you (masc. sing.) · v1, v2

    Direct address. The whole verse is spoken to God face to face, not said about God to someone else.

  3. יְהוָ֔ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh, the LORD · v1

    God's personal covenant name. Jeremiah appeals to the God who bound himself to Israel by covenant, and so can be held to his own terms.

  4. כִּ֥י

    ki · H3588A

    for, that, when, if · v1

    Most likely "when" or "if": "You would be in the right if I took you to court." It is a concession that the case is unwinnable, made before the case is argued anyway.

  5. אָרִ֖יב

    ariv · H7378

    to contend, bring a lawsuit · v1

    "I bring a case." This is the technical verb for a legal dispute. Jeremiah is not begging. He is filing a complaint.

  6. אֵלֶ֑יךָ

    eleykha · H0413

    to, toward · v1

    "To you." God is the one the case is addressed to. Oddly, he is both the judge who hears it and the party whose running of the world is in question.

  7. אַ֤ךְ

    akh · H0389

    surely, only, yet · v1

    A sharp turn: "Yet," "Even so." Having granted that God is in the right, Jeremiah presses ahead regardless.

  8. מִשְׁפָּטִים֙

    mishpatim · H4941G

    judgment, justice, legal case · v1

    Plural, with no "your": "legal matters," "cases," "charges." These are the arguments Jeremiah means to lay out, not God's verdicts.

  9. אֲדַבֵּ֣ר

    adabber · H1696G

    to speak · v1

    "I will speak" or "let me speak." Joined to "cases" and "with," it is the set phrase for arguing a case or passing sentence (Jer 1:16; 39:5).

  10. אוֹתָ֔ךְ

    otakh · H0854

    with · v1

    "With you." This is the preposition "with," not the Hebrew marker of a direct object. It finishes the legal phrase "speak cases with someone."

  11. מַדּ֗וּעַ

    maddua · H4069

    why? · v1

    The heart of the complaint. One "why" governs both of the questions that follow. English versions that add a second "why" are supplying it.

  12. דֶּ֤רֶךְ

    derek · H1870L

    way, road, journey · v1

    The "road" of the wicked: the whole course of their lives and schemes, pictured as a journey that keeps going well.

  13. רְשָׁעִים֙

    resha'im · H7563

    wicked, guilty · v1

    The legal opposite of tsaddiq. In court the rasha is the guilty party. The verse sets God, who is "in the right," against the "guilty" who nonetheless thrive.

  14. צָלֵ֔חָה

    tsalechah · H6743B

    to succeed, prosper · v1

    "Has succeeded" or "goes well." The form describes an established state. The road of the guilty reaches its goal; their plans work.

  15. שָׁל֖וּ

    shalu · H7951

    to be at ease, untroubled · v1

    "They are at ease": secure, carefree, untouched by trouble. It describes a safe and settled life, not a feeling of happiness.

  16. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all, every · v1

    "All" of them. Not one traitor seems to have been caught.

  17. בֹּ֥גְדֵי

    bogdey · H0898

    to act treacherously, betray · v1

    "Betrayers of." These are people who break faith with a bond of loyalty: covenant, marriage, kinship. In verse 6 the same verb is used of Jeremiah's own brothers.

  18. בָֽגֶד׃

    baged · H0899A

    treachery · v1

    "Betrayal." Verb and noun from the same root are stacked, "betrayers of betrayal," which in Hebrew intensifies: thorough, habitual traitors. KJV catches this with "deal very treacherously."

  19. נְטַעְתָּם֙

    neṭaʿtām · H5193

    to plant · v2

    'You planted them': a completed act, with God as the subject. Jeremiah puts the wicked's success down to God himself. It is the same verb God used in Jeremiah's call (1:10, 'to build and to plant'), and for Judah as the olive tree 'the LORD planted' (11:16–17).

  20. גַּם־

    gam · H1571

    also, yes, even · v2

    Adds each stage to the one before: 'yes, and on top of that…' It gives the line a building, frustrated rhythm, as if Jeremiah were counting off how far things have gone.

  21. שֹׁרָ֔שׁוּ

    shorāshû · H8327

    to take root (in this stem); to uproot (in another) · v2

    'They have been rooted / have taken root.' The verb comes from the noun 'root'. In one form it means 'uproot', but in this rare passive form it means 'be firmly rooted'. The wicked are settled and stable, not about to fall.

  22. יֵלְכ֖וּ

    yēlekhû · H1980

    to go, walk, go on · v2

    Literally 'they go on'. Used of a plant, it means they keep spreading and growing (compare Hosea 14:6, 'his shoots shall go out'). The verb form shows an action still under way: their growth has not stopped.

  23. עָ֣שׂוּ

    ʿāśû · H6213

    to make, do, produce · v2

    'They have made', the ordinary Hebrew way of saying a plant bears fruit. The form is completed: the harvest is already there to see.

  24. פֶ֑רִי

    pherî · H6529

    fruit · v2

    The visible result of a healthy plant. Here it stands for prosperity, success and probably children: everything the covenant blessings promised the faithful.

  25. קָר֤וֹב

    qārôv · H7138

    near · v2

    'Near.' It comes first for emphasis and stands in sharp contrast with 'far' in the next line. God is close to them, but only in one place.

  26. בְּפִיהֶ֔ם

    bephîhem · H6310

    mouth · v2

    'In their mouth': God's name is in their speech. They swear by him, pray to him and talk the language of the temple (compare 5:2, 'As the LORD lives…' sworn falsely; 7:4).

  27. וְרָח֖וֹק

    wərāḥôq · H7350

    far, distant · v2

    'And far', the exact opposite of 'near'. The two words frame the gap between what they say and what they are.

  28. מִכִּלְיוֹתֵיהֶֽם׃

    mikkilyôtêhem · H3629

    kidneys; (figuratively) inmost self · v2

    'From their kidneys.' Hebrew located a person's deepest, hidden feelings and motives in the kidneys, the part that only God can examine. God is in their mouths but absent from their innermost selves.

The world behind it

The plot at Anathoth. Jeremiah came from a priestly family in Anathoth, a village about three miles north-east of Jerusalem (Jer 1:1). The verses just before (11:18-23) describe a plot by the men of his home town to silence him: "Do not prophesy in the name of the LORD, or you will die by our hand." Verse 12:6 adds that "even your brothers and your father's house" have betrayed him. In a society built on clan loyalty, kin who turned on their own committed the worst kind of treachery.

The Israelite lawsuit. Disputes were settled at the town gate before elders. Both sides argued their case (riv), and the court declared one party tsaddiq, "in the right," and the other rasha, "in the wrong/guilty" (Deut 25:1). Hearers would have recognised every key word of this verse as courtroom vocabulary. The prophets regularly pictured God bringing such a case against Israel (Jer 2:9; Hos 4:1; Mic 6:1-2). Here the prophet turns the procedure around.

The covenant expectation. Deuteronomy's covenant promised that loyalty would bring blessing and security and that betrayal would bring curse and disaster (Deut 28). Wisdom psalms put it the same way: the righteous man "prospers," the wicked are "like chaff" (Ps 1). So a world where traitors flourish untroubled looked like a breach of the covenant order, and that is what drives the complaint here, as in Ps 37, Ps 73, Job 21 and Hab 1.

The "confessions" of Jeremiah. This verse opens one of a series of personal laments in Jer 11–20 (11:18–12:6; 15:10-21; 17:14-18; 18:18-23; 20:7-18). They follow the pattern of the lament psalms: address to God, complaint, and a plea for justice. In Israel, bringing a complaint to God was a recognised form of prayer, not a breach of piety.

From the study of Jeremiah 12:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

How should the little word ki in "You are righteous, O LORD, ki I contend" be taken?

  • Temporal ("when/whenever I bring a case"): God always proves in the right whenever Jeremiah argues with him.

    Ki commonly means "when." This reading is followed by BSB, KJV, WEB and NIV.

  • Conditional or concessive ("if/even if I were to bring a case, you would be in the right"): Jeremiah admits in advance that he cannot win.

    It fits the following "yet" (akh) and Job's similar thought (Job 9:2-3, 14-20). The Vulgate's "si" (if) reads it this way, and many commentators (e.g. Holladay, McKane) favour some form of it.

  • Causal ("for") or emphatic ("indeed").

    These are possible meanings of ki, but they make a less natural sentence here. Few modern translations adopt them.

in v1

Who are "the wicked" and "the betrayers"?

  • Primarily the men of Anathoth and Jeremiah's kin who plotted against him.

    The setting in 11:18-23 and the same verb bagad used of his brothers in 12:6.

  • The corrupt, prosperous leadership and people of Judah generally.

    "All the betrayers" is sweeping. Jeremiah uses bagad for the whole nation's covenant disloyalty (3:7-11, 20; 5:11; 9:2), and 5:26-28 describes the wicked growing rich. The image of God planting them (12:2) recalls Israel as God's planting (2:21; 11:16-17).

  • Both: a personal wound voiced as a general question about the whole society.

    The confessions typically move between Jeremiah's own suffering and the nation's condition. Many commentators combine the two readings.

in v1

Is 12:1-6 in its original position after 11:18-23?

  • Rearrange: 12:1-6 originally came before 11:18-23.

    In 12:6 God seems to reveal the family's betrayal for the first time, while 11:18-23 already assumes it is known. Proposed by several twentieth-century commentators (e.g. Bright, Rudolph).

  • Keep the received order as a deliberate arrangement.

    11:20 ("to you I have laid open my case") links naturally to 12:1 ("I bring a case"), and the unit can be read as a progression from complaint about enemies to complaint about God. Many recent commentators (e.g. Lundbom, and Holladay in modified form) interpret the text as it stands.

in v2

Who are the 'wicked' and 'faithless' Jeremiah describes?

  • The men of Anathoth who plotted against him (11:18–23).

    The confession follows directly from that plot, and 12:6 mentions his own brothers and father's house betraying him.

  • Judah's people and leaders as a whole, or the prosperous wicked in general.

    Verse 1 says 'all' the faithless. God's answer widens to the whole land and its neighbours (12:7–17). 'Near in their mouth' fits the temple-going population described in 5:2 and 7:4.

in v2

What does yelekhu ('they go on') mean here?

  • Botanical growth: they spread, put out shoots.

    The surrounding plant imagery, and Hosea 14:6, where shoots 'go out' (same verb).

  • General progress or prosperity: they advance, carry on successfully.

    הָלַךְ is often used of a course of life, and the Vulgate renders it with a word for advancing or prospering.

  • Producing offspring.

    The Septuagint's rendering, which reads 'fruit' as children; this is probably interpretive.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).