Jeremiah Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 11:16–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

16The LORD once called you a flourishing olive tree, beautiful with well-formed fruit. But with a mighty roar He will set it on fire, and its branches will be consumed. 17The LORD of Hosts, who planted you, has decreed disaster against you on account of the evil that the house of Israel and the house of Judah have brought upon themselves, provoking Me to anger by burning incense to Baal.” 18And the LORD informed me, so I knew. Then You showed me their deeds. 19For I was like a gentle lamb led to slaughter; I did not know that they had plotted against me: “Let us destroy the tree with its fruit; let us cut him off from the land of the living, that his name may be remembered no more.” 20O LORD of Hosts, who judges righteously, who examines the heart and mind, let me see Your vengeance upon them, for to You I have committed my cause. 21Therefore this is what the LORD says concerning the people of Anathoth who are seeking your life and saying, “You must not prophesy in the name of the LORD, or you will die by our hand.” 22So this is what the LORD of Hosts says: “I will punish them. Their young men will die by the sword, their sons and daughters by famine. 23There will be no remnant, for I will bring disaster on the people of Anathoth in the year of their punishment.”

What the first hearers heard

For Judah in the late 600s or early 500s BC, the verse would have shocked them by turning a compliment into a sentence.

  • A cherished identity. They knew the olive as blessing, and many would have known the psalm's line about a flourishing olive in God's house. Being named that by Yahweh affirmed that he had planted them and they were his.
  • Undermining false security. Verse 15 attacks the belief that being in God's house and offering sacrifices kept them safe. Verse 16 makes the same point with a tree. The name God gave did not protect a people who had given their worship to Baal (v. 17). The beauty was a gift and could be withdrawn.
  • The owner's own act. The fire is not an accident or an enemy acting on its own. He has kindled it, the one who named and planted the tree. To a covenant people this sounded like the curses of Deuteronomy coming true.
  • An echo they would hear. The sound of rāʿû ('smashed') against the repeated raʿ ('evil') told them that what they did and what they suffered were bound together.
  • A coming reality. The roar and fire matched what Babylon would do. The Babylonians burned Jerusalem's houses and temple in 586 BC (Jer 39:8; 52:13). The prophecy was meant to be heard as a warning in time to turn back, a call Jeremiah repeats often (e.g. 18:7-8).

From the study of Jeremiah 11:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 16The LORD once called you a flourishing olive tree, beautiful with well-formed fruit. But with a mighty roar He will set it on fire, and its branches will be consumed.

    "'Luxuriant Olive Tree, lovely in fruit and in form': that is the name Yahweh gave you. But with a deafening roar, like a thunderstorm or an army camp in uproar, he has set her on fire, and its boughs are smashed."

    The verse begins with a name. God, who planted Judah (v. 17), had named her after the most precious tree in the land: an olive, thick with leaves, beautiful in shape, heavy with fruit. Olives gave oil for food, light, healing and anointing. An olive tree takes years to mature and can bear fruit for centuries. To be called a flourishing olive was to be called blessed, rooted and enduring. A worshipper in the psalms uses the same words: I am like a flourishing olive tree in the house of God (Ps 52:8).

    Then the picture turns. The same God has already set the tree alight. The prophet speaks of what is coming as if it has already happened, because it is that certain. The fire comes with a huge roar, a rare word used elsewhere for the noise of an army. The listener hears both lightning hitting a tree and the din of invaders burning an orchard. The final word for what happens to the branches, rāʿû ('smashed'), sounds almost exactly like the raʿ, 'evil', that runs through verses 15 and 17. The evil Judah did becomes the breaking she suffers. The grammar slides between 'her' (Judah) and 'its' (the tree) because the tree is Judah.

    Full study →
  2. 17The LORD of Hosts, who planted you, has decreed disaster against you on account of the evil that the house of Israel and the house of Judah have brought upon themselves, provoking Me to anger by burning incense to Baal.”

    So Yahweh, Commander of the armies, the one who planted you, has passed sentence on you. He has spoken disaster over you because of the disaster-making evil of the house of Israel and the house of Judah: the wrong they did, which comes back on their own heads, insulting and grieving me by sending offering-smoke up to "the Master," Baal.

    The verse finishes the picture in v.16. Judah is the olive tree God once named "lush, beautiful, with fine fruit," and now it is about to be set on fire. The speaker is the grower who planted that tree in the land, and he is also commander of the armies. He has both the right and the power to uproot what he planted.

    The "you" is feminine singular. The nation is addressed as one woman, the "beloved" of v.15. Her offerings to Baal, a name that also meant "master" and "husband," are a betrayal of the relationship. "Provoke" carries that hurt: it is the vexation of being insulted by someone bound to you, not just a burst of temper.

    The Hebrew turns on one word used twice. God speaks raʿah (harm, calamity) over her because of their raʿah (wickedness). What they did becomes what they suffer. "Spoke" is in a completed tense: in a prophet's mouth, God's spoken word is a sentence already passed.

    The charge itself is concrete. They made smoke rise to Baal from altars that, according to v.13, were as many as Jerusalem's streets. That smoke could be incense, burnt fat or grain. And "they did it to themselves": the insult aimed at God ends up as self-harm.

    Full study →
  3. 18And the LORD informed me, so I knew. Then You showed me their deeds.

    It was Yahweh who let me in on it, and only then did I actually know. At that moment, you, Lord, made me see what they were up to.

    The verse starts suddenly, with no explanation of what "it" is. The Hebrew does not say, and the reader, like Jeremiah, is left in the dark until verses 19 and 21 reveal it: the men of his own hometown, Anathoth, were planning to kill him. The sentence is built on the verb "know" used twice: God caused him to know, and so he knew. The next verse cuts against it: "I did not know they had devised schemes against me." Jeremiah's awareness of the danger came entirely from God. On his own he was like a trusting pet lamb walking to the butcher.

    Halfway through the sentence Jeremiah stops talking about God and starts talking to him: "you showed me." The report turns into a prayer, and this verse opens the first of Jeremiah's so-called "confessions", personal laments he pours out to God. The verb "showed me" (literally "made me see") is the one used when God shows a prophet a vision, so uncovering a local murder plot is described in the same terms as his prophetic calling. "Their deeds" is Jeremiah's usual word for Israel's corrupt practices. Without naming them yet, he puts his would-be killers in the same class as the nation he has just been told to condemn.

    Full study →
  4. 19For I was like a gentle lamb led to slaughter; I did not know that they had plotted against me: “Let us destroy the tree with its fruit; let us cut him off from the land of the living, that his name may be remembered no more.”

    "As for me, I was like a pet lamb, one raised among people and trusting them, being walked along to the butcher's knife. I had no idea that it was against me they had been scheming their schemes: 'Come, let's ruin the tree along with its fruit, everything it would ever produce. Let's cut him down and cut him off from the world of the living, so that his name is never spoken or remembered again.'"

    The lamb is not a sacrificial victim here. It is a household lamb, so used to the people around it that it walks trustingly to its own slaughter. That is Jeremiah's position: the plotters are his own townsmen from Anathoth (v. 21), even his own relatives (12:6). He found out only because God told him (v. 18). Their words move from the tree picture ('destroy the tree with its fruit', or by a common emendation 'while the sap is still in it') to plain murder ('cut him off from the land of the living'). They end by planning to wipe out his name, which in Israel's world was the worst possible end: no person, no posterity, no memory.

    Full study →
  5. 20O LORD of Hosts, who judges righteously, who examines the heart and mind, let me see Your vengeance upon them, for to You I have committed my cause.

    But you, Yahweh, commander of heaven's armies, you are the judge whose verdicts are right. You test what is hidden inside a person, the deep feelings ("the kidneys") and the thoughts and plans ("the heart"), the way a refiner tests metal. Let me live to see you put things right by bringing your just penalty on them. I have laid my whole lawsuit open before you, and it is in your hands now.

    The language comes from a courtroom. Jeremiah has just found out that the men of his home town have been plotting to kill him (vv. 18–19, 21). He does not hit back himself. He takes the case to the highest court. He addresses God with three titles, each suited to the case: the commander who has the power to act, the judge who decides fairly, and the examiner who sees through the smiles of people who plot in secret, and who can also confirm that Jeremiah's own motives are clean. The "vengeance" he asks for is God's, not his own: the requital a rightful judge brings on the guilty. It is a real request for punishment, but it is made as a legal appeal, not as a private feud. The last line, "to you I have laid open / entrusted my case", marks the handover. The dispute is no longer Jeremiah's to settle.

    Full study →
  6. 21Therefore this is what the LORD says concerning the people of Anathoth who are seeking your life and saying, “You must not prophesy in the name of the LORD, or you will die by our hand.”

    "That is why YHWH, speaking as a king whose envoy announces his decree, has this to say about the men of Anathoth, your own townsmen and kin, who are out to take your life and who keep telling you: 'You will not stand up and speak as YHWH's prophet, claiming his name and authority for your message. Stop, and then you won't die at our hands.'"

    Here the speaker changes. In verse 20 Jeremiah prayed, asking God to judge his enemies. Now God answers him directly ("your life"). The opening "Therefore, thus says YHWH" is the formula for announcing a verdict. Verse 21 names the accused and quotes their crime word for word. Verse 22 repeats "Therefore, thus says YHWH" and passes sentence.

    The townsmen's words are a categorical ban, phrased with the same form as the "You shall not" commandments. It is followed by a quiet "and you won't die", a death threat dressed up as an offer of safety. What they forbid is not prediction as such. It is Jeremiah speaking publicly as YHWH's authorised spokesman and announcing God's judgment. The threat comes from his own priestly hometown, the people who should have protected him, and they say they will do it "by our hand", with no court involved.

    Full study →
  7. 22So this is what the LORD of Hosts says: “I will punish them. Their young men will die by the sword, their sons and daughters by famine.

    "Therefore — this is the word of Yahweh, Commander of armies: Look, I am about to come and call them to account. Their young men, the town's fighting strength, will die by the sword. Their sons and their daughters, their children and their future, will die of the famine."

    The verse is the sentence passed at the end of a trial. "Therefore" turns from the crime (v. 21) to the verdict. The crime: the men of Anathoth, Jeremiah's own hometown, told him, "Do not prophesy in the name of Yahweh, or you will die by our hand." Now the owner of that name speaks for himself, with the formula a royal messenger used when delivering his king's words.

    "Here I am, visiting upon them" uses a verb (paqad) for an overseer arriving to inspect and settle accounts. It is not a burst of temper. The next verse closes with the same root, "the year of their reckoning", so the whole sentence is framed by a review and a payment due. The form ("look, I am…" with a participle) means the action is about to happen and is certain.

    The punishment mirrors the crime. They threatened that Jeremiah would die. God answers twice that they will die, in their own households. The deaths are sorted by age, as in a city under siege. The men of fighting age fall to the sword. The children waste away in the famine that follows. Sword and famine are known curses for breaking the covenant. This passage comes right after Jeremiah has proclaimed "the words of this covenant", so the people who silenced the covenant's messenger receive the covenant's curses.

    Full study →
  8. 23There will be no remnant, for I will bring disaster on the people of Anathoth in the year of their punishment.”

    "As for survivors, they will have none, not one left to carry on their families. For I myself am sending disaster on the men of Anathoth: the sword and the famine I have just named. It will come in the year I have set to look into their case and settle their account with them."

    The verse finishes God's answer to a murder plot. Jeremiah's own townsmen, priests' families from his home village, had secretly planned to kill him and wipe out his name so that no one would remember him (11:19, 21). God turns their plan back on them. They wanted to cut off Jeremiah's line, so they will have no line left: the "remnant" that in Jeremiah usually means hope after judgment is here refused. The "disaster" (literally "the bad thing") is not moral evil on God's part. It is the ruin of war and siege. The last phrase, "the year of their reckoning," pictures an overseer arriving at an appointed time to inspect and settle accounts. It echoes "I am attending to them" in the verse before. Their punishment is not a fit of temper. It is a hearing whose date is already on the calendar.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v16

    a green olive tree (KJV, WEB)

    zayit raʿănān

    What we hear
    An olive tree that is green in colour, or perhaps young and unripe.
    What they heard
    An olive tree that is leafy, healthy and full of life, a picture of blessing and lasting vigour, as in Psalm 52:8.
  • in v17

    pronounced evil against thee (KJV, WEB)

    dibber ʿalayikh raʿah

    What we hear
    God plans or does something morally wicked.
    What they heard
    God has decreed calamity or harm as judgment. The same word also means the people's wickedness, so the two uses mirror each other.
  • in v17

    LORD of Hosts

    YHWH tsəvaʾot

    What we hear
    'Hosts' sounds like a large crowd, or vaguely like 'host' at a meal.
    What they heard
    'Yahweh of armies': the divine commander of heavenly (and earthly) forces.
  • in v17

    burning incense

    ləqaṭṭer

    What we hear
    Lighting fragrant incense sticks or a censer, a fairly gentle act of devotion.
    What they heard
    Sending offerings up in smoke to a god at an altar. Incense was one possibility, alongside burnt fat and grain.
  • in v19

    gentle lamb

    kevesh 'alluf

    What we hear
    A meek, mild, morally gentle lamb: a picture of humble, non-resisting virtue.
    What they heard
    A tame, familiar lamb, a house or pet lamb used to people and trusting them. The point is unsuspecting trust in those close to it, which is why the betrayal by his hometown and family works.
  • in v19

    led to slaughter

    yuval litvoach

    What we hear
    Led to sacrifice, as a sacrificial lamb offered to God.
    What they heard
    Taken to the butcher. Tavach is the ordinary verb for killing animals for meat, not the sacrificial verb zavach. Jeremiah is describing being murdered, not making an offering.
  • in v20

    reins (KJV)

    kəlāyôt

    What we hear
    Leather straps used to steer a horse, or control ("take the reins").
    What they heard
    Kidneys, standing for the hidden inner self: deep feelings, conscience, secret motives.
  • in v20

    vengeance

    nəqāmāh

    What we hear
    Personal revenge, getting even, spiteful retaliation.
    What they heard
    Rightful redress carried out by a lawful authority, here God as judge, which punishes the guilty and rescues the wronged.
  • in v20

    cause

    rîb

    What we hear
    A movement, campaign or ideal someone supports.
    What they heard
    A legal case or lawsuit, a complaint brought to a judge.
  • in v20

    heart

    lēb

    What we hear
    The centre of emotion and feeling.
    What they heard
    Mainly the centre of thought, plans, intention and will. In this verse the "kidneys" carry the feelings.
  • in v21

    prophesy

    tinnāḇēʾ (nāḇāʾ, niphal)

    What we hear
    To predict future events.
    What they heard
    To speak publicly as God's messenger, bringing his message of accusation, warning or judgment, which may include what is coming. The townsmen object to Jeremiah announcing God's verdict on Judah, not to fortune-telling.
  • in v21

    in the name of the LORD

    bəšēm YHWH

    What we hear
    A pious phrase or formula attached to words or prayers.
    What they heard
    As YHWH's authorised representative, with his delegated authority, the way an envoy speaks in his king's name. The dispute is over whether Jeremiah really carries that authority.
  • in v22

    the LORD of Hosts

    YHWH ṣəvāʾôt

    What we hear
    'Hosts' sounds like hosts at a party, or a vague 'crowd'. The title becomes a pious phrase without a picture.
    What they heard
    Yahweh 'of armies': the commander of heaven's and Israel's forces, the divine warrior-king. Here he announces death by the sword.
  • in v22

    I will punish them

    hinnî pōqēd ʿălêhem

    What we hear
    A simple statement of retribution, with no link to the next verse.
    What they heard
    'Look, I am about to visit upon them': an overseer coming to call them to account. The same root is used in v. 23, 'the year of their visitation/reckoning', so the sentence is framed as a settling of accounts at an appointed time.
  • in v23

    visitation (KJV, WEB)

    pequddah

    What we hear
    A friendly visit, a custody visitation, or a supernatural appearance.
    What they heard
    An official inspection and settling of accounts: the time when God attends to someone's case and acts on it. Here the outcome is punishment.
  • in v23

    evil (KJV, WEB)

    ra'ah

    What we hear
    Moral wickedness, as if God were doing something wicked.
    What they heard
    Harm, calamity, disaster: something bad that happens to someone. Here it means the sword and famine of v. 22.
Every word
  1. זַ֤יִת

    zayit · H2132

    olive tree, olive · v16

    The olive tree, the most valuable and longest-lived tree in Israel's farming. It comes first in the sentence and works as the name God gave Judah: 'Olive-Tree'.

  2. רַֽעֲנָן֙

    raʿănān · H7488

    luxuriant, leafy, flourishing · v16

    Full of leaves and full of life, a tree in good health. Jeremiah often uses the word in the phrase 'under every leafy tree', meaning the places where people worshipped other gods (2:20; 3:6, 13; 17:2). Here God uses it of Judah's own flourishing, which he gave.

  3. יְפֵ֣ה

    yəpheh · H3303

    beautiful, fair · v16

    Beautiful to look at. The form links it to the next words: 'beautiful of…'.

  4. פְרִי־

    pəri · H6529

    fruit · v16

    The fruit, meaning the olives that become oil. This word makes the phrase heavy ('beautiful of fruit of form'), and the Greek translation lacks it (see textual notes).

  5. תֹ֔אַר

    tōʾar · H8389

    form, shape, appearance · v16

    Good shape or bearing, the word used for handsome Joseph and David (Gen 39:6; 1 Sam 16:18). With the words before it: a tree whose fruit and whole shape are lovely.

  6. קָרָ֥א

    qārāʾ · H7121

    call, name · v16

    A completed past act: Yahweh *named* her. Giving a name said who someone was and claimed them as one's own.

  7. יְהוָ֖ה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh (the LORD) · v16, v17, v18, v20, v21, v22

    The covenant name of Israel's God. Verse 17 adds that he is the one 'who planted you'. The one who named the tree also owns it.

  8. שְׁמֵ֑ךְ

    shəmēkh · H8034

    name · v16, v19, v21

    'Your name', with a feminine 'your'. Judah is spoken to as a woman, God's 'beloved' of verse 15. The name sums up the identity God gave her.

  9. לְק֣וֹל׀

    ləqōl · H6963

    sound, voice, noise · v16

    'At / with the sound of'. The fire comes along with a great noise, like thunder or the shout of an army.

  10. הֲמוּלָּ֣ה

    hămullāh · H1999

    roar, tumult, din · v16

    A rare word for a huge, rushing noise. Its only other use is Ezekiel 1:24, where it is compared to 'the sound of an army camp'. Here it could be the crash of a storm or the din of an invading army.

  11. גְדֹלָ֗ה

    gədōlāh · H1419

    great, large · v16

    'Great'. It describes the tumult and makes it huge and frightening.

  12. הִצִּ֥ית

    hiṣṣît · H3341

    kindle, set on fire · v16

    'He has set alight', past tense in form. Prophets often spoke of a coming disaster as if it had already happened, so certain was it. The word is used for setting fields and cities on fire (2 Sam 14:30; Jer 32:29).

  13. אֵשׁ֙

    ʾēsh · H784

    fire · v16

    Fire, which in the Bible is a common picture of God's judgment. Jeremiah also uses it for the Babylonians literally burning Jerusalem.

  14. עָלֶ֔יהָ

    ʿālêhā · H5921

    upon, against · v16, v17, v19, v21, v22

    'Upon her', feminine, though 'olive tree' is a masculine word. The fire falls on Judah herself, and the picture and the people blur together.

  15. וְרָע֖וּ

    wərāʿû · H7489

    be broken, shattered · v16

    'And they are smashed'. These letters spell both a verb for breaking and the verb 'to be bad'. The sound matches the 'evil' (raʿah) of verses 15 and 17, so Judah's evil comes back as broken branches.

  16. דָּלִיּוֹתָֽיו׃

    dāliyyôtāyw · H1808

    bough, branch · v16

    'Its boughs', the spreading, hanging branches. The same word appears in Ezekiel's tree pictures of kingdoms (Ezek 17; 31). Here it is masculine 'its', back to the tree.

  17. צְבָאוֹת֙

    tsəvaʾot · H6635

    armies, hosts · v17, v20, v22

    'Of armies'. It calls up God as commander of the heavenly forces. The one about to judge has the power to carry the sentence out.

  18. הַנּוֹטֵ֣עַ

    ha-noṭeaʿ · H5193

    to plant · v17

    A participle with 'the', so it works almost as a title: 'the Planter of you'. It carries on the tree image of v.16. The one who planted Israel in the land has the right to uproot it.

  19. אוֹתָ֔ךְ

    ʾotakh · H0853

    [object marker] + you (fem. sing.) · v17, v20, v21

    'You' is feminine singular. The people are addressed as one woman, the 'beloved' of v.15 and the olive tree of v.16.

  20. דִּבֶּ֥ר

    dibber · H1696

    to speak · v17

    'Has spoken', in a completed past tense. In prophetic speech God's spoken word is a sentence already passed, so 'decreed' or 'pronounced' is fair.

  21. רָעָ֑ה

    raʿah · H7451

    evil, harm, disaster · v17, v23

    Here it means harm or calamity that God sends, not moral wickedness in God. It is the first half of a deliberate echo with the next 'raʿah'.

  22. בִּ֠גְלַל

    biglal · H1558

    because of, on account of · v17

    A causal preposition. It ties the disaster directly to its cause.

  23. בֵּֽית־

    beit- · H1004

    house, household · v17

    'House of' means a family line or a people, here a whole kingdom treated as one household.

  24. יִשְׂרָאֵ֜ל

    Yisraʾel · H3478

    Israel · v17

    Paired with Judah, so it most likely means the old northern kingdom, destroyed in 722 BC. Its fate is evidence against Judah.

  25. יְהוּדָ֗ה

    Yəhudah · H3063

    Judah · v17

    The southern kingdom with Jerusalem, Jeremiah's actual hearers.

  26. אֲשֶׁ֨ר

    ʾasher · H0834

    which, that · v17

    Points back to 'the evil'. The evil is what they did.

  27. עָשׂ֥וּ

    ʿasu · H6213

    to do, make · v17

    'They did' or 'they committed'. The deeds are finished and on the record.

  28. לָהֶ֛ם

    lahem

    to/for them(selves) · v17

    'For themselves' or 'to themselves'. It can mean they acted on their own behalf, or that the harm comes back on them (compare Jer 7:19). The rendering is debated.

  29. לְהַכְעִסֵ֖נִי

    ləhakʿiseni · H3707

    to provoke, vex, offend · v17

    'So as to provoke me'. The verb means insulting and grieving someone you are bound to, not just making God lose his temper. It is a stock phrase of Deuteronomy and Kings for idolatry.

  30. לְקַטֵּ֥ר

    ləqaṭṭer · H6999

    to make (offerings) smoke · v17

    'By making smoke' means sending offerings up in smoke. It covers incense but also burnt fat and grain. Jeremiah uses this form again and again for worship of other gods.

  31. לַבָּֽעַל׃

    la-Baʿal · H1168

    Baal ('lord, owner, husband') · v17

    'To the Baal'. The word 'the' marks it as a title, 'the Lord/Master': the Canaanite storm and fertility god, and in Jeremiah a catch-all for rival gods. The ס after it marks the end of a paragraph in the Hebrew manuscripts.

  32. הֽוֹדִיעַ֖נִי

    hodiʿani · H3045

    he made me know, informed me · v18, v19

    The causative form of 'know', in the completed tense: 'he caused me to know'. The thing made known is not named. Hebrew leaves it unstated, and only verses 19 and 21 reveal that it was a murder plot.

  33. אָ֖ז

    ʾaz · H0227

    then, at that time · v18

    Marks the moment of revelation, 'at that point'. It could also carry a sense of consequence ('so then'). It moves the account from the general statement to the specific seeing.

  34. הִרְאִיתַ֥נִי

    hirʾitani · H7200

    you made me see, you showed me · v18, v20

    The causative of 'see', and now addressed to God as 'you'. In mid-sentence Jeremiah stops reporting about God and starts speaking to him, so the report becomes a prayer. 'Made me see' is the language used for prophetic visions (Jer 1:11–13; 24:1).

  35. מַעַלְלֵיהֶֽם׃

    maʿalleyhem · H4611

    their deeds, their practices · v18

    Their doings, meaning conduct, practices and schemes. In Jeremiah the word nearly always describes bad conduct ('the evil of your deeds'). 'They' have no named antecedent here. Verse 21 shows they are the men of Anathoth, Jeremiah's hometown, who were plotting his death.

  36. וַאֲנִ֕י

    va'ani · H0589

    and I · v19

    An emphatic 'as for me' that sets Jeremiah's own unsuspecting state against what God has just shown him in v. 18. The Hebrew has no verb here; the context makes it past: 'I was'.

  37. כְּכֶ֥בֶשׂ

    kekhevesh · H3532

    like a lamb · v19

    A young male sheep, the ordinary animal of a household flock. The prefix ke- makes it a comparison: Jeremiah was as unsuspecting as a lamb.

  38. אַלּ֖וּף

    'alluf · H0441A

    tame, familiar · v19

    A lamb that has grown up among people and trusts them, a pet or house lamb. The word is used elsewhere of a close friend, so the picture is a lamb that follows its own people without fear.

  39. יוּבַ֣ל

    yuval · H2986

    is led, is brought · v19

    A passive form: the lamb is walked along by others and has no say. The same word appears in Isaiah 53:7 in almost the same phrase.

  40. לִטְב֑וֹחַ

    litvoach · H2873

    to slaughter · v19

    To butcher an animal, usually for meat. It is not the usual word for offering a sacrifice (that is zavach). The lamb trusts the hand that is taking it to the knife.

  41. וְלֹֽא־

    velo · H3808

    and not · v19, v21, v23

    Negates 'I knew'. It stresses that he had no idea what was happening.

  42. כִּֽי־

    ki · H3588A

    that · v19, v20, v23

    Introduces what he did not know.

  43. חָשְׁב֣וּ

    chashvu · H2803I

    they devised · v19

    To think out, calculate, scheme. The plot was deliberate. 'They' are identified in v. 21 as the men of his hometown, Anathoth.

  44. מַחֲשָׁב֗וֹת

    machashavot · H4284

    plans, plots · v19

    A noun from the same root as the verb, so the phrase is literally 'they plotted plots', meaning they schemed in earnest. KJV keeps the echo: 'devised devices'.

  45. נַשְׁחִ֨יתָה

    nashchitah · H7843

    let us ruin, destroy · v19

    A plotters' 'let us...'. The verb means to spoil, ruin or bring to destruction. Their actual words are quoted, as if Jeremiah heard them through God's revelation.

  46. עֵ֤ץ

    'etz · H6086H

    tree; wood · v19

    The tree is Jeremiah himself, a common Hebrew picture of a person (Ps 1:3; Jer 17:8). The same word also means 'wood', which is why the Greek translation could read it as 'wood into his bread'.

  47. בְּלַחְמוֹ֙

    belachmo · H3899G

    with its bread/food · v19

    Literally 'with its bread'. Lechem means food in general, so here it is the tree's produce or fruit: kill the man and everything that would come from him. Many scholars read 'in its sap' instead (see textual notes).

  48. וְנִכְרְתֶ֙נּוּ֙

    venikhretennu · H3772I

    and let us cut him off · v19

    'Cut off' fits the tree image (cutting a tree down) and is also a standard Hebrew phrase for removing someone from the community or from life. The 'him' makes clear the tree is a person.

  49. מֵאֶ֣רֶץ

    me'eretz · H0776G

    from the land of · v19

    Part of the set phrase 'the land of the living', meaning this world of living people as opposed to the grave.

  50. חַיִּ֔ים

    chayyim · H2416A

    the living · v19

    'From the land of the living' means 'kill him'. The same phrase is used of the suffering servant in Isaiah 53:8.

  51. יִזָּכֵ֥ר

    yizzakher · H2142

    will be remembered · v19

    A passive form: 'be called to mind, be mentioned'. Remembering in Hebrew includes speaking the name aloud and keeping it alive. The plotters want total oblivion.

  52. עֽוֹד׃

    'od · H5750

    any more, again · v19

    'Ever again': not just death, but being forgotten permanently.

  53. שֹׁפֵ֣ט

    šōpēṭ · H8199

    judging, judge · v20

    A participle ("one who judges") used as a title: God is the one whose role is to judge. In Israel the judge decided the case and also put things right for the wronged party.

  54. צֶ֔דֶק

    ṣedeq · H6664G

    rightness, justice · v20

    The thing judged or the way of judging: "a judge of rightness". Here it means fair verdicts that clear the innocent and convict the guilty.

  55. בֹּחֵ֥ן

    bōḥēn · H0974

    testing, examining · v20

    Another participle-title: "one who tests". The verb is used for testing metal to find out what it really is. God examines what cannot be seen from outside.

  56. כְּלָי֖וֹת

    kəlāyôt · H3629

    kidneys · v20

    Literally "kidneys". Hebrew uses the hidden organ for a person's deepest feelings, motives and conscience, the part nobody else can see.

  57. וָלֵ֑ב

    wālēb · H3820A

    and heart · v20

    "And heart". In Hebrew the heart is mainly where a person thinks, plans and decides. Kidneys and heart together mean the whole inner self, feelings and purposes alike.

  58. נִקְמָֽתְךָ֙

    niqmātəkā · H5360

    your vengeance · v20

    "Your vengeance": the redress God carries out as rightful judge against people who wronged someone under his protection. "Your" matters. Jeremiah asks for God's vengeance, not his own.

  59. מֵהֶ֔ם

    mēhem · H9038

    from them · v20, v23

    The preposition min ("from") with "them": redress taken from them, required of them. "Them" means the plotters of v. 19, who are named in v. 21 as the men of Anathoth.

  60. אֵלֶ֖יךָ

    ʾēlêkā · H0413

    to you · v20, v23

    "To you", placed first for emphasis: to you, and to no one else (not a human court, not his own hand).

  61. גִּלִּ֥יתִי

    gillîtî · H1540H

    I have uncovered, revealed · v20

    "I have laid bare": he has set out his whole case openly before the judge. Many scholars think the original word was the similar-looking gallôtî, "I have rolled onto", meaning "entrusted to".

  62. רִיבִֽי׃

    rîbî · H7379

    my case, my dispute · v20

    "My lawsuit": a legal complaint or dispute. Jeremiah presents himself as a plaintiff whose case is now in the hands of the highest judge.

  63. לָכֵ֗ן

    lāḵēn · H3651C

    therefore · v21, v22

    Made of 'to' plus 'so'. In the prophets it is the standard hinge between a charge and the sentence: 'because of this, here is the verdict.' The charge here is the murder plot Jeremiah has just lamented about (vv. 18–20).

  64. כֹּֽה־

    kōh · H3541

    thus, so · v21, v22

    'Thus' or 'in these words'. It opens the messenger formula a royal envoy used when delivering his master's exact words.

  65. אָמַ֤ר

    ʾāmar · H0559

    to say · v21, v22

    Perfect tense, literally 'has said'. In the messenger formula this points to a word God has already settled, which the prophet now passes on. English renders it 'says'.

  66. אַנְשֵׁ֣י

    ʾanšê · H0582

    men, people · v21, v23

    'The men of', the usual plural for adult males of a place. It means the town's citizens as a group, the ones who speak and act for the community. According to 12:6, this group included Jeremiah's own brothers and his father's household.

  67. עֲנָת֔וֹת

    ʿănāṯôṯ · H6068G

    Anathoth · v21, v23

    Jeremiah's hometown, a priestly town in Benjamin a few miles north-east of Jerusalem (1:1). The threat is coming from his own kin and neighbours, not from strangers or the royal court.

  68. הַֽמְבַקְשִׁ֥ים

    ha-mḇaqšîm · H1245

    to seek · v21

    'The ones seeking', an ongoing participle. With 'life' as its object it becomes a fixed idiom: 'seek someone's life' means trying to kill them. This is a continuing plot, not a passing threat.

  69. נַפְשְׁךָ֖

    napšəḵā · H5315H

    life, self, person · v21

    'Your life', meaning Jeremiah's living, breathing self. The 'you' is Jeremiah, whom God now addresses directly in reply to his prayer in v. 20.

  70. תִנָּבֵא֙

    tinnāḇēʾ · H5012

    to prophesy · v21

    'You shall act as a prophet', meaning to speak publicly as God's messenger. What they want stopped is his preaching on God's behalf, especially his announcements of judgment. It is not about predicting the future in general.

  71. תָמ֖וּת

    tāmûṯ · H4191

    to die · v21, v22

    'You will die' (here negated: 'you will not die'). They offer to let him live if he stops, which is a death threat put the other way round.

  72. בְּיָדֵֽנוּ׃

    bəyāḏēnû · H3027G

    by our hand · v21

    'By our hand', singular in Hebrew. The hand stands for power and agency: the townsmen themselves will carry out the killing. They are not talking about handing him over to a court or the king.

  73. הִנְנִ֥י

    hinnî · H2005

    look! here I am · v22

    'Look, I…'. It points at the speaker as the one about to act. Together with the next word it means 'I am about to', describing action that is close and certain.

  74. פֹקֵ֖ד

    pōqēd · H6485H

    to visit, attend to, call to account; punish · v22

    An active participle, 'visiting'. God is about to inspect them and settle the account. With 'upon' it means calling someone to account for wrongdoing. The same root comes back in v. 23's 'year of their visitation'.

  75. הַבַּֽחוּרִים֙

    habbaḥûrîm · H0970

    young men · v22

    Young men in their prime, the age for marrying and fighting. They are the town's strength and its future, and they fall in battle.

  76. בַחֶ֔רֶב

    vaḥerev · H2719

    sword · v22

    'By the sword', meaning death in war. Here it is the coming invasion, the fighting men's fate.

  77. בְּנֵיהֶם֙

    bənêhem · H1121A

    sons · v22

    'Their sons', the children of the households. Next to 'young men' it points to the younger, more vulnerable members of the family.

  78. וּבְנ֣וֹתֵיהֶ֔ם

    ûvənôtêhem · H1323G

    and daughters · v22

    'And their daughters'. With 'sons' it means all the children, the family line itself.

  79. בָּרָעָֽב׃

    bārāʿāv · H7458

    famine, hunger · v22

    'By the famine', meaning starvation, the slow death of a siege. It falls hardest on children. The definite article ('the famine') treats it as a known, expected horror.

  80. וּשְׁאֵרִ֕ית

    ushe'erit · H7611

    and a remnant · v23

    What is left over after a disaster: survivors who carry a family or group forward. Placed first in the sentence for emphasis: 'As for a remnant, there will be none.'

  81. תִֽהְיֶ֖ה

    tihyeh · H1961

    will be · v23

    Future 'there will be'. With the following 'to them' it is the normal Hebrew way to express ownership: 'they will have no remnant'.

  82. אָבִ֥יא

    avi · H0935

    I will bring · v23

    Literally 'I will cause to come'. God is the active subject: the coming harm is not chance but something he sends.

  83. שְׁנַ֥ת

    shenat · H8141

    year of · v23

    With no preposition in front it most likely means '[in] the year of'. It describes a set time already fixed, not an open-ended threat.

  84. פְּקֻדָּתָֽם

    pequddatam · H6486

    their reckoning, punishment, visitation · v23

    From the verb paqad, 'to attend to, inspect, call to account'. It is the moment God looks into their case and settles it, and in this context the settlement is punishment. It echoes 'I will punish' (poqed, the same root) in v. 22.

The world behind it

The olive in Israel's economy. The olive, along with grain and new wine, was one of the three main crops of the land (Deut 7:13). It gave food, lamp oil, medicine, cosmetics and the oil used to anoint kings and priests and to light the temple lamp. A new tree needs many years before it bears well, and an established grove could serve a family for generations. Burning an olive grove was not one bad harvest. It wiped out decades of a family's wealth. Armies of the time cut down or burned the enemy's orchards on purpose (compare Deut 20:19-20, which forbade Israel to do this).

Jeremiah 11 as a covenant speech. The chapter opens with 'the words of this covenant' (11:1-8): the blessings and curses of Deuteronomy, and a 'conspiracy' (11:9) to go back to other gods. Verse 15 pictures God's 'beloved' in his house (the temple) offering 'holy meat' (sacrifices) as if ritual could prevent disaster while wrongdoing went on. Verse 17 names the charge: burning incense to Baal. A rich tree destroyed for unfaithfulness fits the covenant curses on crops and land (Deut 28:38-40: 'you will have olive trees… but you will not anoint yourself with oil').

Trees as nations. Prophets and the kings of the time often pictured a nation as a tree or vine that a god plants and tends, or uproots (Jer 2:21; Isa 5:1-7; Ezek 17; 31). Jeremiah's own call is to 'uproot… and to build and to plant' (1:10).

From the study of Jeremiah 11:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

What is the 'great tumult' (hămullāh gədōlāh)?

  • A thunderstorm. Lightning sets the tree on fire.

    It fits the tree picture naturally, since lightning does burn trees. Several modern versions translate 'storm' or 'tempest', and God's judgment is often pictured as a storm (Jer 23:19).

  • The din of an invading army.

    The word's only other use, Ezekiel 1:24, compares it to 'the sound of an army camp'. Burning orchards was a known war tactic, and Jeremiah expects Babylon to burn Judah (Jer 21:10; 34:2).

  • Both on purpose: a storm in the picture, an army in reality.

    Prophetic pictures often lay the natural image over the historical event. The word itself only means a huge noise, so it does not force a choice.

in v16

Does the text originally speak of 'fruit'?

  • Keep the Hebrew 'beautiful of fruit of form'.

    All Hebrew manuscripts have it. Fruit is central to the olive's value and to the covenant blessing.

  • 'Fruit' is a later addition; the original was 'beautiful of form'.

    The Greek translation lacks it. The construction is unusually heavy, and 'beautiful of form' (yəpheh tōʾar) is a fixed phrase elsewhere (Gen 29:17; 39:6).

in v16

What does wərāʿû mean?

  • 'And (its branches) are broken.'

    The breaking verb רעע (Jer 15:12; Ps 2:9) suits branches. KJV, WEB and NIV take this view.

  • 'And (its branches) are bad / worthless.'

    The Greek translation has 'became useless', NASB follows it, and it ties directly to the 'evil' (raʿ) words in vv. 15 and 17.

  • Change the text to 'and are burned' (ūbāʿărû).

    It fits the fire and matches the Vulgate's 'were burned', but no Hebrew manuscript has it.

in v17

What does עָשׂוּ לָהֶם ('they did lahem') mean: 'to their own harm' or 'for themselves'?

  • Self-harm: 'which they have done against/to themselves' (KJV, WEB, BSB 'brought upon themselves').

    Jeremiah repeatedly says idolatry harms the worshippers, not God: 7:19 ('Is it me they provoke?... Is it not themselves, to their own shame?'), 25:7 ('to your own harm') and 44:7 ('great evil against yourselves'). It also fits the echo of evil done coming back as evil suffered.

  • Reflexive or self-interested: 'which they did for themselves', meaning on their own account or for their own ends, with the purpose clause 'to provoke me' following.

    The preposition 'lə-' attached to a pronoun after a verb often just points action back to the doer (e.g., 'lekh-lekha', 'go for yourself', Gen 12:1) without implying harm. Neither the Greek (heautois) nor the Latin (sibi) specifies harm.

in v17

Who wrote the prose sermon of Jeremiah 11:1–17, and when?

  • It belongs to a later editorial layer in the style of Deuteronomy (Mowinckel's 'Source C', Thiel, Nicholson).

    The stock phrases ('provoke me to anger', 'house of Israel and house of Judah', 'make smoke to Baal') closely match Deuteronomy and Kings, and the passage is prose rather than Jeremiah's usual poetry.

  • Substantially Jeremiah's own preaching, in the style of his time (Bright, Holladay, Lundbom).

    Josiah's reform made Deuteronomic language standard in Jerusalem. The sermon is tied to its context by the olive-tree poem (v.16) and the 'tree' plot against Jeremiah (v.19). It fits a late seventh-century situation of relapse after reform.

in v17

What act does the Piel verb קִטֵּר (qiṭṭer) describe: incense specifically, or offerings in general?

  • Incense offering specifically.

    The related noun qəṭoret often means incense. Incense altars are well attested archaeologically in Iron Age Judah (e.g., Arad), and incense suits small rooftop and household offerings.

  • Any offering made to smoke: fat, grain, incense.

    The same root is used of burning fat and whole offerings on the altar (Lev 1:9). Lexicons such as HALOT give 'make sacrifices smoke' for the Piel. Its use alongside 'pouring drink offerings' and cakes in Jer 44 suggests general sacrificial worship.

in v18

Is 11:18 connected to what comes before, or is it out of place?

  • The section has been rearranged; 12:6 (or 12:1–6) originally came before 11:18–23.

    The unnamed 'it' and 'their deeds' have no antecedent in 11:1–17, while 12:6 names the brothers and father's house as traitors, which would give the reader the background. Rudolph and Bright, among others, proposed this kind of reordering.

  • The present order is deliberate.

    Holding back the identity of the plotters reproduces Jeremiah's own experience of being unaware (v.19). The link to v.17 is thematic: Israel's 'evil' and the plotters' 'deeds' belong together. Many recent commentators (for example Lundbom, and Allen to a degree) read the unit as it stands. No manuscript evidence supports moving it.

in v18

Why did the men of Anathoth want to kill Jeremiah?

  • Resentment over Josiah's reform.

    The preceding passage (11:1–8) has Jeremiah proclaiming 'the words of this covenant', often linked to the law-book found under Josiah (2 Kgs 22–23). The reform closed local shrines and demoted rural priests (2 Kgs 23:8–9), and Anathoth was a priestly town.

  • Reaction to his message of judgment in general.

    Verse 21 gives their stated demand: 'Do not prophesy in the name of the LORD.' The objection is to his prophesying as such. Elsewhere priests and prophets seek his death over his preaching against the temple (Jer 26:7–11). The link to Josiah's reform is inferred, not stated.

in v18

How should the move from 'Yahweh made me know' to 'you showed me' be understood?

  • A natural shift within a prayer.

    Lament psalms often move between speaking about God and speaking to him (e.g. Ps 23:1–4; Ps 22:8 vs 22:9 in the Hebrew numbering). Verse 20 continues the direct address: 'But you, O LORD of hosts.'

  • A sign of editing or a scribal error.

    The Septuagint and Vulgate both smooth the persons, and some scholars emend one verb. This reading is less widely held today.

in v19

Which way does the borrowing go between Jeremiah 11:19 and Isaiah 53:7-8?

  • Isaiah 40-55 draws on Jeremiah, and the suffering servant is partly modelled on Jeremiah.

    Most critical scholars date Isaiah 40-55 to the exile, after Jeremiah. Studies of the shared vocabulary (e.g. B. D. Sommer, *A Prophet Reads Scripture*) argue that Isaiah 40-55 often echoes Jeremiah. Medieval Jewish commentary records the identification of the servant with Jeremiah (Ibn Ezra on Isa 52:13, citing Saadia Gaon).

  • Jeremiah echoes an earlier Isaianic text, or both draw on common lament language.

    Those who date all of Isaiah to the 8th century see Jeremiah as quoting Isaiah. Others note that 'sheep for slaughter' and 'land of the living' are stock phrases (Ps 44:22; Ps 27:13; 52:5), so direct dependence need not be assumed.

in v19

Is the verse a prophecy about the Messiah?

  • It is a type or prefiguring of Christ.

    Church fathers, working mainly from the Greek/Latin 'wood into his bread', read it as a reference to the cross. Christian typology sees the persecuted prophet as foreshadowing the rejected Messiah, as the Gospels portray Jesus as a prophet rejected by his hometown (Luke 4:24).

  • In its own context it is Jeremiah's lament about a real plot against his life.

    The speaker is 'I'. The plot is revealed to Jeremiah (v. 18), the plotters are identified as the men of Anathoth (v. 21), and he asks God for vengeance on them (v. 20). Nothing in the passage looks forward to a future figure. Typological readings are a later use of the text, not its original meaning.

in v19

What does 'the tree with its bread' mean?

  • Keep the Hebrew: 'the tree with its produce', i.e. the man and all that comes from him (offspring, influence, words).

    Lechem can mean food or produce generally. The following line about his name being forgotten supports the idea of destroying his posterity.

  • Emend to be-lecho: 'the tree in its sap', i.e. cut him down while he is young and vigorous.

    It is a small change in letters, it gives a natural tree picture (Deut 34:7 uses lech of vigour), and it avoids the odd 'bread of a tree'.

in v20

Did Jeremiah write "I have revealed" or "I have committed" his case?

  • Keep the Hebrew as written: gillîtî, "I have revealed/laid open".

    It is the reading of all Hebrew manuscripts, the LXX (apekalypsa) and the Vulgate (revelavi), and the same word appears in 20:12. It also makes sense: you disclose a case to a judge who examines hidden things.

  • Read gallôtî, "I have rolled onto/committed".

    "Rolling" one's way or works onto the LORD is an established idiom for trust (Psalm 37:5; 22:9; Proverbs 16:3). The consonants are close, and it explains the "committed" in BSB, ESV, NIV and NASB. But no manuscript supports it.

in v20

What is nəqāmāh, "vengeance", in a prayer like this?

  • Mainly vindication or deliverance carried out by a lawful sovereign.

    Mendenhall's study shows nqm usually has God or a legitimate authority as subject and is tied to rescuing the oppressed.

  • Judicial retribution: actual punishment of the guilty, though done lawfully.

    Peels and others point out that Jeremiah 11:22–23 follows with sword and famine on Anathoth, so the word includes penalty, not only rescue. Both positions agree it is not private revenge.

in v20

Why did Anathoth want Jeremiah dead?

  • Because of Josiah's reform.

    Centralising worship in Jerusalem (2 Kings 23:8–9) would have hurt country priests. If Jeremiah backed the covenant reform (Jeremiah 11:1–8), his own priestly kin would have counted him a traitor.

  • Because of his message of judgment in general.

    Verse 21 only says "do not prophesy in the name of the LORD". His oracles against Judah brought shame and danger on his hometown whether or not the reform was involved.

in v21

Why did the men of Anathoth want Jeremiah dead?

  • Resentment over Josiah's reform: Jeremiah backed a centralisation that harmed rural priests.

    Chapter 11 opens with Jeremiah proclaiming 'the words of this covenant' (11:1–8), usually connected with the covenant renewal of Josiah's reform (2 Kings 23:1–3). That reform closed local shrines and sidelined country priests (2 Kings 23:8–9). Anathoth was a priestly town, possibly home to the line of Abiathar, whom Solomon had already demoted (1 Kings 2:26–27).

  • Hostility to his message of doom itself, seen as endangering or shaming the community.

    Elsewhere Jeremiah's opponents object to the content of his preaching, not to any reform programme (Jeremiah 26:8–11; 38:4). Prophets were widely silenced for announcing disaster (Amos 7:10–13; Micah 2:6). Jeremiah 26:9 shows priests treating a prediction of disaster 'in the name of YHWH' as a capital offence, perhaps on the basis of Deuteronomy 18:20.

  • The text does not say, and it may have been a mix of family, economic and religious motives.

    The passage gives only the townsmen's words. The dating of chapter 11 relative to Josiah's reform is itself disputed. Scholars differ on these points (for example Holladay, Lundbom and Carroll).

in v21

What is the original order and setting of 11:18–12:6?

  • The passage should be read in its present order: lament (11:18–20), God's verdict on Anathoth (11:21–23), then a second lament (12:1–6).

    The Masoretic text runs this way. Verses 21–23 answer the prayer of v. 20 directly, and the 'lamb' and 'tree' imagery of v. 19 is resolved by the sentence in vv. 22–23.

  • 12:1–6 originally came before 11:18–23.

    In 12:6 Jeremiah is only now told that his family has betrayed him, while 11:18 says he already knows about a plot. Some commentators (for example Bright) have therefore proposed rearranging the passage. Others answer that the present order makes literary sense and that the proposal is guesswork.

in v22, v23

Why did the men of Anathoth turn on Jeremiah?

  • Josiah's reform: Jeremiah's support for the covenant cost the country priests their status.

    Chapter 11 has Jeremiah proclaiming 'the words of this covenant', often linked to the Deuteronomy-based reform of 622 BC. That reform shut down local shrines and moved worship to Jerusalem. Country priests lost their altars (2 Kgs 23:8–9), and Anathoth was a priests' town. Holladay and others consider this link plausible.

  • His message of doom shamed the clan and endangered it.

    Verse 21 quotes their objection directly: 'Do not prophesy in the name of the LORD.' In Jer 26:7–11 priests and prophets demand Jeremiah's death for prophesying against the temple. A kinsman publicly announcing the nation's ruin brought dishonour and danger on the whole family (12:6). Commentators such as Lundbom stress the prophetic content itself over reform politics.

  • The exact cause cannot be recovered.

    The text names no motive beyond silencing his prophecy. The dating and setting of 11:1–17 are themselves disputed (McKane and others), so firm links to the reform remain conjectural.

in v22

How does 'no remnant' (v. 23) square with men of Anathoth returning from exile?

  • The sentence targets the conspirators and their households, not every inhabitant of the town.

    In v. 21 the subject is 'the men of Anathoth who seek your life', and v. 22's 'them' and 'their sons and daughters' refer back to that group. Ezra 2:23 and Neh 7:27 count 128 'men of Anathoth' among the returnees. Jeremiah himself buys land there (Jer 32:6–15) as a sign of future restoration.

  • The language is a standard, sweeping judgment formula rather than a literal census.

    'Sword and famine' and 'no remnant' are fixed curse expressions in Jeremiah and the covenant tradition. Such formulas describe a total catastrophe and were not necessarily meant to count every survivor.

in v23

How total is 'there will be no remnant', given that 128 'men of Anathoth' returned from exile (Ezra 2:23; Neh 7:27)?

  • It targets the plotters and their households, not every person ever linked to the town.

    'To them' points back to v. 21, the men 'who seek your life'. Verse 22 also speaks of 'their' young men, sons and daughters. Jeremiah himself still had family land in Anathoth (Jer 32:6–15).

  • It is the language of total-judgment oracles, which focus on the certainty and severity of the blow rather than on a census.

    Similar sweeping 'no remnant' language appears against Judah as a whole (Jer 44:7, 14), yet Jeremiah elsewhere speaks of a remnant of Judah surviving. 44:14 itself adds 'except a few fugitives'.

  • The town was depopulated in 587 BC and later resettled, partly by people with different family lines.

    Benjamin was overrun by Babylon. The Ezra list may reflect people tied to Anathoth by settlement or ancestry, not necessarily descendants of the plotters. This cannot be proved either way.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. רַעֲנָן, הֲמֻלָּה, רָעַע II, דָּלִית
  • HALOT s.v. הֲמֻלָּה, רעע, דָּלִית
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 11:16
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 11:16
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1-25 (ICC)
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jeremiah 11
  • BDB s.v. נָטַע, רָעָה, כָּעַס, קָטַר, בַּעַל, צָבָא
  • HALOT s.v. קטר (Piel 'make sacrifices smoke'), כעס, רָעָה
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 11:1–17
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 11:15–17
  • J. Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
  • J. G. Janzen, Studies in the Text of Jeremiah (on the LXX minus of 'Sabaoth')
  • E. Tov, The Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on the shorter LXX Jeremiah)
  • J. Day, Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan
  • E. W. Nicholson, Preaching to the Exiles (on the Jeremiah prose sermons)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. יָדַע (hifil 'make known')
  • HALOT s.v. רָאָה (hifil 'show', of visions)
  • HALOT s.v. מַעֲלָל
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 11:18 (Rahlfs ed.)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 11:18
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 1
  • L. C. Allen, Jeremiah (OTL)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 11:18–23
  • BDB s.v. אַלּוּף, טָבַח, לֶחֶם, לֵחַ
  • HALOT s.v. אַלּוּף I (tame, familiar), טבח, לֵחַ
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • B. D. Sommer, A Prophet Reads Scripture: Allusion in Isaiah 40–66
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 11:19; Vulgate Jeremiah 11:19
  • Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 72
  • Tertullian, Against Marcion 3.19; 4.40
  • Ibn Ezra, commentary on Isaiah 52:13 (citing Saadia Gaon)
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, critical apparatus to Jer 11:19
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. כִּלְיָה, לֵב, נְקָמָה, רִיב, גָּלָה, בָּחַן
  • G. E. Mendenhall, The Tenth Generation (1973), ch. 3 on nqm
  • H. G. L. Peels, The Vengeance of God (1995)
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 11:20 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate Jeremiah 11:20
  • BHS critical apparatus at Jer 11:20
  • Brown-Driver-Briggs (BDB) s.v. נָבָא, נֶפֶשׁ, בָּקַשׁ, יָד
  • HALOT s.v. נבא (niphal), נֶפֶשׁ, שֵׁם
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 11:18–12:6
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 11:21–23
  • Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, on lōʾ + imperfect prohibitions and result clauses
  • Gesenius-Kautzsch-Cowley, Hebrew Grammar, on consequence clauses after commands and prohibitions
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Anathoth and Josiah's reform
  • STEP Bible / Tyndale Amalgamated Hebrew OT data (supplied)
  • BDB s.v. פָּקַד, בָּחוּר, צָבָא
  • HALOT s.v. פקד, בָּחוּר, צָבָא
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 11:18–23
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 11:18–23
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 11:22; Vulgate, Jeremiah 11:22
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. פקד / פְּקֻדָּה
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁאֵרִית
  • HALOT s.v. רָעָה
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 11:23 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 11:23
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 11:18–23 and Anathoth
  • Ezra 2:23; Nehemiah 7:27; Joshua 21:18; 1 Kings 2:26; Jeremiah 32:6–15

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).