Jeremiah Chapter 19 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 19:4–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4because they have abandoned Me and made this a foreign place. They have burned incense in this place to other gods that neither they nor their fathers nor the kings of Judah have ever known. They have filled this place with the blood of the innocent. 5They have built high places to Baal on which to burn their children in the fire as offerings to Baal—something I never commanded or mentioned, nor did it even enter My mind.
What the first hearers heard
To the kings, elders and priests standing with Jeremiah in the Valley of Ben-Hinnom, this verse was a formal indictment delivered at the crime scene. It explained the "disaster" just announced (v.3): the coming catastrophe is not random misfortune or the weakness of Judah's God, but the legal consequence of what they had done.
They would have heard four things:
- Covenant betrayal. "They have abandoned me" puts the whole matter in relational terms. Judah was not just breaking rules; it had walked out on its God.
- Loss of the land's identity. "Made this place foreign" told them that the ground they stood on was no longer recognisably the LORD's. It was a quiet warning that people who make their own land foreign will end up in a foreign land, which is what the exile to Babylon brought about.
- Betrayal of their own past. Saying the gods were unknown to "their fathers" and "the kings of Judah" turned the appeal to tradition against them. Judah's leaders could not claim that this worship was ancestral custom. It was a break from it.
- Blood-guilt. "Filled this place with the blood of innocent ones," spoken next to Topheth, named the child sacrifices without softening, and echoed Manasseh's notorious bloodshed. Under Israel's law such blood stained the land and demanded a reckoning.
The combined effect was to strip away every excuse — necessity, tradition, royal approval — and to tie the judgment to this specific place, which v.6 says will be renamed "the Valley of Slaughter."
From the study of Jeremiah 19:4.
Verse by verse
-
4because they have abandoned Me and made this a foreign place. They have burned incense in this place to other gods that neither they nor their fathers nor the kings of Judah have ever known. They have filled this place with the blood of the innocent.
Full study →"Here is why I am bringing disaster on this place: they walked out on me. They made this place foreign ground, signing it over to gods who are strangers to me. Right here they sent up the smoke of their offerings to other gods — gods with no history with them, gods their own ancestors and the kings of Judah had never had any relationship with. And they have soaked this place in the blood of innocent people."
The verse is built as a charge sheet with a single root and three results. The root is personal: "they have abandoned me" — the language of a broken covenant, like a wife leaving her husband or a vassal deserting his lord. Everything follows from that.
The first result is a change of ownership. The verb "made foreign" comes from the same root as "foreigner." A place in the LORD's own land, within sight of his city, has been handed over to foreign gods until it no longer belongs to him or looks like his.
The second is worship. "Burned incense" is too narrow. The verb means making offerings go up in smoke, which includes incense but also the fat and gifts of full sacrifice. The gods are "other gods," the wording of the first commandment, and gods the people "did not know." That is not a lack of information. It means they had no relationship or shared history with these gods. Gods who had never rescued them were replacing the God who had, and the people were breaking with the faith of their own fathers and kings.
The third is blood. "They have filled this place": not one killing but saturation, with the blood of innocent ones (plural). The next verse says who: children burned in fire to Baal. Anyone in Jerusalem would also hear the old charge against King Manasseh, who "filled Jerusalem with innocent blood." In Israel's law, shed blood polluted the land and could not be ignored. So the phrase "this place" sounds three times in a row: the place of false worship is the place of bloodshed, and it will be the place of judgment.
-
5They have built high places to Baal on which to burn their children in the fire as offerings to Baal—something I never commanded or mentioned, nor did it even enter My mind.
Full study →They went out and built them: raised shrine platforms (the "high places") belonging to the Baal, the "Lord" god of the land, down in the valley outside Jerusalem. They built them for one purpose, to burn their own sons in the fire, offering them as whole burnt offerings to the Baal. That is the same word used for the lamb burned completely on the altar every morning and evening, the gift held back from no one. Then God speaks in three steps, each more emphatic than the last: I never commanded it. I never even spoke of it. It never so much as came up in My mind. The "heart" here is the seat of thought and intention, so the last line means: this was never part of what I planned, willed or wanted, not even as an idea.
The Hebrew contains a grim wordplay. A burnt offering is literally "a thing that goes up," because its smoke rises to the deity. The children's smoke went up to Baal, but the idea of it never "went up" on God's heart. Whatever the worshippers told themselves, whether that the rite was commanded, or hinted at, or what God secretly wanted, God denies all three.
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
burned incense
qitter
- What we hear
- Lighting aromatic incense, a fairly mild devotional act.
- What they heard
- Making offerings go up in smoke to a deity: incense, but also fat, grain and other sacrificial gifts. In context it means full sacrificial worship of other gods, culminating in the child offerings of v.5.
-
in v4
have never known
lo yeda'um
- What we hear
- The people had never heard of these gods, or they were brand new.
- What they heard
- The people had no relationship or covenant history with these gods. They had done nothing for Israel, unlike the LORD who brought them out of Egypt. (Kings like Manasseh plainly knew about them.)
-
in v5
high places
bāmôt
- What we hear
- Shrines on hilltops or mountains.
- What they heard
- Raised, built worship platforms or shrine structures, which could be anywhere. These ones stood in a valley.
-
in v5
nor did it come up on My heart (YLT); "heart"
lēḇ
- What we hear
- It didn't move my emotions or touch my feelings.
- What they heard
- It never entered my thinking or intention. The heart is where a person thinks and decides.
Every word
-
יַ֣עַן
ya'an · H3282
because · v4
Opens the legal grounds for the sentence announced in v.3 ('I am bringing disaster on this place'). What follows is the charge sheet.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
'asher · H0834A
that, which · v4, v5
Joined with ya'an to form the full conjunction 'because that' — a formal, somewhat legal 'for the reason that'.
-
עֲזָבֻ֗נִי
'azavuni · H5800A
forsake, abandon, leave · v4
'They have abandoned me.' The first and root charge: walking out on a covenant relationship, the way one leaves a spouse or a lord. Everything else in the verse flows from this.
-
וַֽיְנַכְּר֞וּ
vaynakkeru · H5234B
make foreign, alienate, treat as strange · v4
'And they made foreign' this place: they handed it over to foreign gods so that it no longer belongs to, or is recognisable as, the LORD's. The verb is related to nokhri, 'foreigner'.
-
אֶת־
'et · H0853
[object marker] · v4, v5
Untranslatable marker showing that 'this place' is the direct object of 'made foreign'.
-
הַמָּק֤וֹם
hammaqom · H4725
place · v4
'The place' — here the site where Jeremiah stands (the Valley of Ben-Hinnom, v.2) and by extension Jerusalem. In Israel's vocabulary 'the place' could also carry the ring of a sacred site (Deut 12:5).
-
הַזֶּה֙
hazzeh · H2088
this · v4
'This place' — pointing: the speaker is standing in it. The phrase recurs three times in vv.3–4, hammering the location.
-
וַיְקַטְּרוּ־
vayqatteru · H6999H
make (offerings) go up in smoke · v4
'And they sent up sacrificial smoke' — burning offerings (incense, but also fat, grain or other gifts) so the smoke rises to a deity. The form used is the one Jeremiah regularly uses for illegitimate worship.
-
בוֹ֙
vo · H9033
in it · v4
'In it' — in this very place. The worship happened on the spot now under judgment.
-
לֵאלֹהִ֣ים
le'lohim · H0430J
gods · v4
'To gods' — here a true plural, meaning other deities, not the God of Israel.
-
אֲחֵרִ֔ים
'acherim · H0312
other · v4
'Other gods' — the stock phrase of the first commandment (Exod 20:3) and of Deuteronomy; naming them this way identifies the act as covenant breach.
-
לֹֽא־
lo · H3808
not · v4, v5
Negates 'knew'.
-
יְדָע֛וּם
yeda'um · H3045
know · v4
'They had not known them' — not 'had never heard of', but had no relationship or history with them. These gods had done nothing for Israel, unlike the LORD who brought them out of Egypt.
-
הֵ֥מָּה
hemmah · H1992
they · v4
Emphatic 'they' — the present generation, stated outright for emphasis.
-
וַאֲבֽוֹתֵיהֶ֖ם
va'avoteihem · H0001G
fathers, ancestors · v4
'And their fathers' — the ancestors. The point: these gods have no place in the family's inherited faith; the people are breaking with their own lineage.
-
וּמַלְכֵ֣י
umalkhei · H4428G
kings · v4
'And the kings of' — the royal line, addressed in v.3, is named among those to whom these gods were never 'known'.
-
יְהוּדָ֑ה
yehudah · H3063G
Judah · v4
The southern kingdom. The main pause in the verse falls here, closing the idolatry charge before the bloodshed charge.
-
וּמָֽלְא֛וּ
umal'u · H4390
fill · v4
'And they have filled' — not one killing but bloodshed to the point of saturation.
-
דַּ֥ם
dam · H1818
-
נְקִיִּֽם׃
neqiyyim · H5355A
innocent, free of guilt · v4
'Innocent ones' — plural: people who had done nothing to deserve death. In context (v.5) this means above all the children burned at Topheth, possibly also others killed unjustly.
-
וּבָנ֞וּ
ūḇānū · H1129
and they built · v5
Continues the charge from v. 4 ("because they have abandoned Me…"). "They" means the people and the kings of Judah together. The verb is about construction: these shrines were deliberately built and kept up, not something that just happened.
-
בָּמ֣וֹת
bāmôt · H1116
high places · v5
Raised worship platforms or shrine structures. Here they stand in the Valley of Ben-hinnom, low ground, which shows that a bāmâ was a built platform and not necessarily a hilltop.
-
הַבַּ֗עַל
habbaʿal · H1168A
the Baal · v5
"The Baal," with the article: "the Lord/Master" god of Canaanite religion. In Jeremiah it often works as a blanket label for the foreign gods Judah had turned to.
-
לִשְׂרֹ֧ף
lisrōp · H8313
to burn · v5
States what the shrines were for. The verb means burning something up completely. It is not a word for symbolic passing near a flame.
-
בְּנֵיהֶ֛ם
bənêhem · H1121A
their sons / children · v5
Literally "their sons." The masculine plural can cover children in general, and the parallel in 7:31 says "sons and daughters." The word "their" carries the horror: parents were giving up their own offspring.
-
בָּאֵ֖שׁ
bāʾēš · H0784
in the fire · v5
"In the fire," with the article: the particular fire of the Topheth hearth named in the next verse.
-
עֹל֣וֹת
ʿōlôt · H5930A
burnt offerings · v5
The ordinary term for the "whole offering," the sacrifice burned up entirely on the altar. Using the normal temple word for children makes the point: they were treated as sacrificial animals.
-
צִוִּ֙יתִי֙
ṣiwwîtî · H6680
I commanded · v5
"I commanded": the verb God uses for giving his instructions (the root of miṣwâ, "commandment"). God denies that the rite ever had his authority behind it.
-
דִבַּ֔רְתִּי
dibbartî · H1696G
-
עָלְתָ֖ה
ʿāləṯâ · H5927G
it went up · v5
"It went up." It comes from the same root as ʿōlôt, "burnt offerings" (literally "things that go up"). The smoke of the offering went up, but the idea never "went up" onto God's heart.
-
עַל־
ʿal- · H5921A
upon · v5
"Upon," part of the fixed phrase "to go up upon the heart," meaning to come to mind or be thought of.
-
לִבִּֽי
libbî · H3820A
my heart · v5
"My heart": in Hebrew the place of thinking, planning and intending, closer to English "mind" or "will" than to feelings. God never had such a thing in mind as something he wanted.
The world behind it
Where Jeremiah stands. The LORD sends Jeremiah to buy a potter's clay jar and take elders of the people and senior priests out to the Valley of Ben-Hinnom, at the entrance of the "Potsherd Gate" (19:1–2). This valley runs along the south and southwest of Jerusalem. In it was Topheth, a site where children were "passed through the fire" or burned as offerings (2 Kgs 23:10; Jer 7:31–32). So when Jeremiah says "this place," his hearers are standing on the actual ground of the crimes he names. He then smashes the jar (19:10–11) to show that city and people will be broken past mending.
The history behind the charges. King Manasseh (roughly 697–642 BC) had promoted the worship of other gods, made his own son pass through the fire, and "filled Jerusalem with innocent blood from end to end" (2 Kgs 21:6, 16). King Josiah tried to shut this down, defiling Topheth so no one could use it (2 Kgs 23:10). Jeremiah's preaching here is generally placed after Josiah, probably under Jehoiakim (609–598 BC), when the old practices had come back. The kings of Judah, addressed directly in v.3, are therefore heirs of a royal line that had both promoted and fought these rites.
Why "innocent blood" mattered so much. In Israel's law, blood shed unjustly was not just a private wrong. It polluted the land and laid guilt on the whole community until it was dealt with (Num 35:33; Deut 21:1–9). Saying the people had "filled this place" with such blood meant the land itself was now under a burden that called for judgment. The book of Kings says the same about Manasseh's bloodshed: "the LORD was not willing to forgive" (2 Kgs 24:4).
"Gods they did not know." In ancient Near Eastern treaties a vassal was to "know" (acknowledge) only his own overlord. Israel's covenant used the same language. Worshipping gods "not known" meant transferring loyalty to powers that had no claim on Israel and had done nothing for it. In a society where ancestral religion was part of family honour, it was also a betrayal of one's own fathers.
From the study of Jeremiah 19:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
What is 'this place' — the Valley of Ben-Hinnom/Topheth, or Jerusalem (and its temple)?
-
The valley and Topheth specifically.
Jeremiah is standing in the Valley of Ben-Hinnom (v.2); v.5 names the high places where children were burned; v.6 renames 'this place' as the Valley of Slaughter.
-
Jerusalem and Judah as a whole, possibly including the temple.
V.3 addresses the kings of Judah and inhabitants of Jerusalem; v.7 speaks of Judah and Jerusalem; vv.12–13 extend the judgment to the city and its houses. Elsewhere in Jeremiah 'this place' often means the temple or Jerusalem (Jer 7:3–7), and the parallel charge against Manasseh says he filled 'Jerusalem' with innocent blood.
-
Deliberately both.
The passage moves from the valley (vv.2–6) to the city (vv.10–13); many commentators read 'this place' as starting at the site and widening to the whole city.
in v4
Does 'the blood of innocent ones' refer only to child sacrifice, or also to other unjust killing?
-
Mainly or only the child sacrifices.
V.5 immediately explains it: they built Baal's high places 'to burn their children in the fire'. The setting at Topheth supports this.
-
Child sacrifice plus judicial murder and oppression.
The phrase matches the charge against Manasseh, whose bloodshed (2 Kgs 21:16) is listed separately from his child sacrifice (21:6). Jeremiah also uses 'innocent blood' for oppression of the poor and royal killings (Jer 2:34; 22:3, 17; 26:15).
in v5
To whom were these children actually offered: Baal, Molech, or (in the worshippers' minds) YHWH?
-
To a foreign god, as the text says: Baal here, Molech in 32:35, which may be one figure or overlapping ones.
The verse says "to the Baal" twice. Leviticus 18:21 and 20:2–5 and 2 Kings 23:10 tie the rite to "Molech." The Phoenician Baal Hammon at the Carthage tophet offers a close parallel.
-
Many worshippers believed they were offering to YHWH, and the triple denial answers exactly that belief.
God says "I did not command" three times (7:31; 19:5; 32:35), which would be unnecessary if no one claimed his authority. Exodus 22:29 ("the firstborn of your sons you shall give to me"), Micah 6:7, and Ezekiel 20:25–26 ("statutes that were not good… offering every firstborn") show the firstborn idea could be misread in that direction. Argued by e.g. Levenson (*Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son*). Others reply that "Baal" here is a deliberate label for a cult the prophet treats as foreign whatever its practitioners called it.
in v5
Is "Molech" (the parallel term in 32:35) a god's name or a kind of sacrifice?
-
A kind of sacrifice ("molk-offering"), not a deity.
O. Eissfeldt (1935) pointed to Punic inscriptions using *mlk* as a sacrifice term, so "to make pass through for a molk" would name the type of offering.
-
A deity, probably an underworld god whose name was scribally altered.
Leviticus 20:5 speaks of "whoring after Molech," language used of gods. Ugaritic and Mesopotamian texts know an underworld deity *Malik/Mlk*. This view is defended by J. Day and G. Heider. Jeremiah's use of "Baal" in the matching slot also implies a divine recipient.
in v5
Did the rite actually kill children, or was it a dedication "through" fire?
-
A non-lethal dedication ritual.
Some argued (e.g. M. Weinfeld) that "make pass through the fire" in Kings and Leviticus could mean a symbolic passage or dedication.
-
Actual killing by burning.
This verse uses "to burn" (śārap) and calls the children "burnt offerings" (ʿōlôt), and v. 4 speaks of "the blood of the innocent." Ezekiel 16:20–21 speaks of children "slaughtered." Most scholars accept that for 19:5 the language means killing.
in v5
Does "nor did it enter My mind" say something about the limits of God's knowledge?
-
Yes, it suggests God did not foresee Israel would do this.
Some recent theologians who argue that God does not fully know the future cite this verse (and 7:31; 32:35) as evidence.
-
No, the idiom is about intention, not foreknowledge.
"To go up upon the heart" elsewhere means to think of something as one's own plan or wish (Isa 65:17; Jer 3:16; 2 Kgs 12:4). Here it follows "I did not command… did not speak" as the third step in denying that God was the source. The context is God disowning the rite, not saying what he could foresee, and most commentators read it this way.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. נכר (piel), קטר (piel), נָקִי
- BDB s.v. עָזַב, נָכַר, קָטַר, יָדַע
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 19:4
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 19:4
- 2 Kings 21:6, 16; 23:10; 24:4
- Deuteronomy 11:28; 13:2–13; 19:10–13; 21:1–9; 32:17
- Jeremiah 2:13, 34; 5:19; 7:6, 9, 31–32; 22:3, 17; 26:15
- BDB s.v. בָּמָה, בַּעַל, עֹלָה, לֵב
- HALOT s.v. בָּמָה; לֵב; עלה
- Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
- J. Day, Molech: A God of Human Sacrifice in the Old Testament (1989)
- G. C. Heider, The Cult of Molek (1985)
- O. Eissfeldt, Molk als Opferbegriff (1935)
- J. D. Levenson, The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son (1993)
- M. Weinfeld, 'The Worship of Molech and of the Queen of Heaven', UF 4 (1972)
- L. Stager & S. Wolff, 'Child Sacrifice at Carthage', BAR 10/1 (1984)
- Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (Jer 7:31; 19)
- Mesha Stele (KAI 181)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).