Job Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Job 11:2–3

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

2“Should this stream of words go unanswered and such a speaker be vindicated? 3Should your babbling put others to silence? Will you scoff without rebuke?

What the first hearers heard

To Israelite readers trained in wisdom teaching, Zophar's opening would sound like a clever, crushing appeal to common sense. He quotes the proverb about the "multitude of words" and labels Job a "man of lips", putting Job in the fool's category before he makes a single argument about God.

But the book is written so that the reader knows more than the friends do. From the prologue (chapters 1–2) the reader knows Job's suffering is not punishment for hidden sin. So Zophar's confident questions ring hollow and land back on the speaker. He objects to a flood of words while adding to it. He denies that Job can be "in the right" when the reader has heard God call Job blameless. And his insistence that Job's words "must be answered" points ahead to the real answer, which comes from God in the whirlwind (38:1). God then declares that the friends "have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has" (42:7).

The verse therefore did two things. It shows the honour-and-shame tactics of ancient public dispute: belittle the opponent's speech so you need not deal with its content. And it invites readers to question tidy wisdom that judges a sufferer by how much he talks rather than by what is true.

From the study of Job 11:2.

Verse by verse

  1. 2“Should this stream of words go unanswered and such a speaker be vindicated?

    "Is this great flood of words supposed to go without a reply? Is a man who is nothing but lips going to win his case?"

    Zophar opens his first speech with two scornful questions. Both expect the answer no.

    • The first takes a phrase straight out of the proverbs: "a multitude of words" (compare Prov 10:19, "in a multitude of words, sin is not lacking"). Without saying "fool", Zophar files Job's long, anguished speeches (chapters 9–10) under the fool's habit of talking too much. Leaving such talk unanswered, he implies, would be like letting it win by default. So he has to reply.
    • The second calls Job "a man of lips": all mouth, fluent talk with nothing solid behind it. The verb yitsdaq means "to be in the right, win the case, be vindicated." It is the very word Job had just used when he asked how a person could be "in the right" with God (9:2) and despaired that even if he were "in the right", his own mouth would condemn him (9:20). Zophar throws that word back at him: words alone cannot win anyone a verdict.

    The irony runs through the whole book. Zophar condemns a flood of words by adding his own. The "man of lips" demands an answer, and in the end he gets one from God, who says that Job, not his friends, spoke rightly (42:7).

    Full study →
  2. 3Should your babbling put others to silence? Will you scoff without rebuke?

    Zophar, the third and harshest of Job's friends, opens with a pair of indignant questions:

    "Is your empty, made-up talk supposed to leave everyone else speechless? You have mocked, so is nobody going to show you up and put you to shame?"

    The word for Job's speech is not simply "words". It means hollow, self-invented, boastful talk: claims with nothing solid behind them. In a public dispute, silence counted as surrender. If the friends said nothing, Job's protest of innocence would stand as the winning argument, and Zophar will not allow that. "You mock" probably reaches back to Job's own bitter words a chapter earlier, that God "mocks at the despair of the innocent" (9:23). To Zophar, it is Job who is doing the mocking, of God's justice and of his friends' wisdom. "No one to shame you" is not about stirring guilt in Job's conscience. It means no one has yet refuted him in public, stripped away his standing and left him with nothing to say. Zophar is volunteering for that job. Readers should keep in mind that this is Zophar's verdict on Job, not the book's. In the end God says the friends "have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has" (42:7).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    be justified (KJV, WEB)

    yitsdaq (tsādēq)

    What we hear
    Either Paul's doctrine of being declared righteous before God by faith, or the everyday sense of 'giving good reasons for' or excusing one's behaviour.
    What they heard
    To be found in the right in a dispute: to win the case, be vindicated, have one's claim upheld. Zophar is asking whether a mere talker should come out of this argument (and Job's hoped-for hearing with God) as the party in the right.
  • in v3

    lies (KJV)

    baddîm

    What we hear
    Deliberate, knowing falsehoods: Job is being called a liar.
    What they heard
    Empty, made-up or boastful talk: hollow claims with nothing behind them. Zophar thinks Job is wrong and full of himself, not necessarily that he is knowingly deceiving anyone.
  • in v3

    make thee ashamed (KJV, WEB)

    maklim

    What we hear
    Make Job feel guilty or embarrassed inside: an emotional or moral feeling.
    What they heard
    Publicly refute and humiliate Job, take away his standing as a speaker and leave him silenced before others.
  • in v3

    babbling (BSB, ESV "babble")

    baddîm

    What we hear
    Incoherent, rambling chatter, as from a child or a confused person.
    What they heard
    Fluent, confident, even eloquent speech that Zophar judges to be empty and self-invented. The charge is hollowness, not incoherence.
Every word
  1. הֲרֹ֣ב

    harōv · H7230

    abundance, multitude, great amount · v2

    The prefix ha- turns the line into a question. Rōv here means 'a great heap of', a sheer quantity. The stress falls on how much has been said, not on what it said.

  2. דְּ֭בָרִים

    dəvārîm · H1697

    words, speech, matters · v2

    Job's speeches in chapters 9–10. Joined to rōv, it echoes a stock proverb against talking too much ('in a multitude of words', Prov 10:19; Eccl 5:3).

  3. לֹ֣א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v2

    Negates the verb. The question expects the answer 'No, it must not go unanswered.'

  4. יֵעָנֶ֑ה

    yēʿāneh · H6030

    to be answered (passive) · v2

    The passive of the debate's key verb: every speech in Job opens 'and X answered' (11:1). Zophar is claiming he has a duty to reply. In a public dispute, letting a speech stand without challenge could look like agreeing with it.

  5. וְאִם־

    wəʾim · H0518

    and if; or (in a double question) · v2

    After a first question opened with ha-, ʾim brings in the second half of a paired question: 'Is it…? Or is it…?' It does not mean 'if' here.

  6. אִ֖ישׁ

    ʾîsh · H0376

    man, person · v2

    In the form 'man of [quality]' it describes a person by his defining trait. It points at Job without naming him.

  7. שְׂפָתַ֣יִם

    səfātayim · H8193

    lips; speech · v2

    The dual form, 'pair of lips'. 'A man of lips' is someone who is all mouth: talk with nothing behind it, like 'mere talk of the lips' in Prov 14:23 and Isa 36:5.

  8. יִצְדָּֽק׃

    yitsdāq · H6663

    to be in the right, be vindicated, win one's case · v2

    Courtroom language: to be declared the party in the right. Job had just asked how a man could 'be in the right' (yitsdaq) with God (9:2). Zophar throws Job's own word back at him.

  9. בַּדֶּיךָ

    baddêkā · H0907

    empty talk, idle boasts · v3

    "Your empty talk": a plural noun meaning hollow, made-up or boastful words. It stands first for emphasis, so Zophar's opening sneer is aimed at the substance of everything Job has said.

  10. מְתִים

    mĕtîm · H4962

    men, people · v3

    An old poetic word for "men" or "people" (not the word for "the dead", which has different vowels). Here it means "people in general", and above all Job's friends, who are expected to fall silent.

  11. יַחֲרִישׁוּ

    yaḥărîšû · H2790B

    be silent / reduce to silence · v3

    "Will they keep silent?" or "will it silence?" Hebrew can make a question by tone alone, and that is what happens here. Zophar asks whether Job's flood of words should leave everyone else speechless, as though talking longest meant winning.

  12. וַתִּלְעַג

    wattilʿag · H3932

    mock, deride, scoff · v3

    "And you mock": Zophar takes Job's protests as open ridicule, whether of the friends' counsel or of God's justice. The verb form presents the mocking as something Job has already done.

  13. וְאֵין

    wĕʾên · H0369

    there is not · v3

    "And there is no one": it sets up the complaint that nobody is holding Job to account.

  14. מַכְלִם

    maklim · H3637

    one who humiliates / puts to shame · v3

    "One who puts [you] to shame": someone who publicly shows Job up and leaves him disgraced and silenced. Zophar casts himself in that role.

The world behind it

A wisdom dispute staged like a court case. The middle of Job is a formal debate. Each friend speaks in turn and Job replies ("and X answered"). In the ancient Near East, disputes were settled in public, often by elders at the town gate, through argument and counter-argument. A charge left unanswered could look like a charge admitted, and verse 3 makes the point that Job's talk should not be allowed to "silence" others. In chapters 9–10 Job had begun using lawsuit language against God: bringing a case, being in the right, needing someone to judge between them. Zophar answers in the same legal terms.

Zophar. He is the third and harshest of the friends. His speeches are short (chapters 11 and 20), and he has no clear third speech. His home, Naamah, has not been identified for certain; most locate it somewhere in the region of Edom or Arabia. The Greek Septuagint calls him "king of the Minaeans", a people of south Arabia.

Speech in wisdom culture. Israel's wisdom teachers prized speaking little and at the right moment (Prov 10:19; 17:27–28; Eccl 5:1–3). Calling someone a "man of lips" or charging him with a "multitude of words" applied that standard directly: the wise man restrains his mouth, the fool pours out words.

From the study of Job 11:2.

Where scholars differ

in v2

Does Zophar's 'be in the right' (yitsdaq) mean winning the argument with the friends, or being vindicated before God?

  • Mainly the debate at hand: Job should not 'win' the exchange just by talking more.

    The first line ('should it go unanswered?') and verse 3 ('should your babble silence men?') are about the human exchange and who gets the last word.

  • Mainly Job's hoped-for case with God: a mere talker cannot be acquitted in God's court.

    Job had just used the same verb for standing in the right before God (9:2, 15, 20; 10:15). Zophar goes on to wish that God himself would speak against Job (11:5). The verb carries this meaning throughout the book (4:17; 13:18; 40:8).

  • Deliberately both: Zophar merges winning the debate with being vindicated by God, because he assumes God's verdict matches the friends' wisdom.

    The friends consistently treat their own judgment as God's (e.g. 15:11). The book's ending (42:7) exposes exactly that assumption.

in v3

Does the first line mean "Your talk silences men" or "Should men keep silent at your talk?"

  • Causative: Job's empty words reduce people to silence (KJV, BSB, ESV, NIV).

    The hiphil form can be causative, and the line reads naturally with "your empty talk" as the subject that silences "men".

  • Intransitive: "Should men keep silent before your prattle?" (Vulgate and some Jewish and modern commentators).

    Elsewhere in Job (13:5, 13:19; 33:31, 33) and in most other places, the hiphil of ḥrš means "keep silent" without a direct object, and the 3rd-person plural verb agrees naturally with "men".

in v3

Whom is Job accused of mocking?

  • God, or God's justice.

    Zophar is answering Job 9:23, where Job said God "mocks" the despair of the innocent, and 10:2–7, where Job challenges God directly. Verse 4 quotes Job's claim to be pure "in your eyes" (God's).

  • The friends and their wisdom.

    Verses 2–3 are about a contest between speakers, and Job had dismissed the friends' counsel (6:14–27). Job later answers in kind: "after I have spoken, mock on" (21:3).

  • Both, without distinction.

    In the friends' view, rejecting their traditional teaching amounts to scorning God, so Zophar need not separate the two.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. רֹב, שָׂפָה, צָדֵק, עָנָה
  • HALOT s.v. צדק qal ('to be in the right, have a just cause')
  • HALOT s.v. שָׂפָה
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
  • Septuagint, Job 11:2 (Brenton translation)
  • Vulgate, Iob 11:2
  • Cross-references: Prov 10:19; Eccl 5:3; Prov 14:23; Isa 36:5; Prov 21:13; Job 9:2, 20; 42:7
  • BDB s.v. בַּד III ("empty, idle talk") and בָּדָא ("devise, invent")
  • HALOT s.v. בַּד, חרשׁ II, לעג, כלם, מַת
  • Septuagint (Old Greek) Job 11:2–3
  • Vulgate Job 11:3
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Job 4–27 (disputation setting)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).