John Chapter 18 Read as one passage

John 18:39–40

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

39But it is your custom that I release to you one prisoner at the Passover. So then, do you want me to release to you the King of the Jews?” 40“Not this man,” they shouted, “but Barabbas!” (Now Barabbas was an insurrectionist.)

What the first hearers heard

John's first readers, probably in the late first century, already knew the Barabbas story from shared tradition. What stands out in John's telling is its shape:

  • Kingship is the issue. Pilate questions Jesus about being king (18:33–37). He presents him as "the King of the Jews" (18:39), lets soldiers crown him with thorns (19:2–3), announces "Here is your king!" (19:14), and nails the title over the cross in three languages despite protest (19:19–22). Readers would hear Pilate's sneer as an unwilling declaration of the truth.
  • Passover irony. The festival of release becomes the occasion for releasing a rebel and condemning the innocent. Jesus, whom John's Gospel first introduces as "the Lamb of God" (1:29), is sentenced at the hour the lambs were being slaughtered (19:14).
  • Who is really on trial. Pilate has just said "I find no case" but will not act on his own finding. He keeps saying "to you" and passing the choice on. Throughout the scene the judge and the accusers are the ones exposed. The bound prisoner is the one in control (cf. 10:18; 19:11).
  • Choosing a king. The question "Do you want your king?" leads to the leaders' answer in 19:15, "We have no king but Caesar". For a Jewish audience who confessed God alone as Israel's true king, this was a shocking statement.

From the study of John 18:39.

Verse by verse

  1. 39But it is your custom that I release to you one prisoner at the Passover. So then, do you want me to release to you the King of the Jews?”

    Pilate has just come back out to the accusers and announced, "I find no case against him." He then offers a way out: "But you do have a custom — every Passover I let one man go free as a favour to you. So: do you want me to set free for you the King of the Jews?"

    Several things are packed into the Greek:

    • "Your custom." Pilate calls the practice theirs ("there is a custom for you"). He offers Jesus' release as a concession to them, not as a ruling of his own.
    • "Release … to you," twice. The verb is the formal word for discharging someone from custody. Pilate holds the power to release, but he keeps saying "to you," putting the choice, and the blame, on his listeners. Later he says outright, "I have authority to release you and authority to crucify you" (19:10).
    • "At the Passover." The festival remembered Israel's release from slavery. A pardon in that season made political sense. In John's story it also carries irony: the man being offered for release is the one John presents as the Passover lamb (1:29; 19:14, 36).
    • "Do you want…?" Pilate is not giving an order. He asks what they want, and so lets them decide.
    • "The King of the Jews." This is the charge of sedition, a claim to a throne only Rome could grant. Applied to a bound, beaten prisoner, Pilate means it as a sneer at Jesus and a jab at the priests: here is your king; do you want him back? John's readers would hear Pilate saying more than he knows, because John's whole account presents Jesus as a king whose kingdom is "not from this world" (18:36).

    The question backfires. The accusers shout for Barabbas, a lēstēs: a bandit or insurgent, the kind of man Rome crucified for exactly the charge laid against Jesus (18:40).

    Full study →
  2. 40“Not this man,” they shouted, “but Barabbas!” (Now Barabbas was an insurrectionist.)

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v39

    the Jews (as Pilate's audience)

    Ioudaioi

    What we hear
    The Jewish people as a whole, then and now.
    What they heard
    In this scene, the high-priestly leadership and their attendants who had brought Jesus to Pilate (John 18:28; 19:6, 15). In the title "King of the Jews" it means the nation as a political entity.
Every word
  1. ἔστιν

    estin · G1510

    is, there is · v39

    Stands first: "there is" or "there exists." With the dative ὑμῖν that follows, it means "you have." Pilate states it as a known fact.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, now, and · v39

    A mild "but" after Pilate's verdict in 18:38 ("I find no basis for a charge against him"). It turns from that verdict to a way out: "but there is a custom…"

  3. συνήθεια

    synētheia · G4914

    custom, habit, usual practice · v39

    An established practice, done by habit and not written into law. Pilate presents the release of a prisoner as a regular expectation at the festival.

  4. ὑμῖν

    hymin · G4771

    to/for you (plural) · v39

    "For you," meaning "you have." The plural "you" is the Judean authorities standing outside the governor's headquarters. Pilate calls it *their* custom and keeps himself at a distance from it.

  5. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    that, in order that · v39

    It does not express purpose here. It spells out what the custom is: "a custom *that* I release…" (The supplied data tags it as a preposition. Grammatically it is a conjunction.)

  6. ἕνα

    hena · G1520

    one · v39

    "One," masculine: one man. The Greek does not say "prisoner." English versions supply that word, correctly, from the context.

  7. ἀπολύσω

    apolysō · G630

    release, set free, let go · v39

    "I should release": a legal word for letting someone go from custody. It is a one-time act (aorist subjunctive). The word makes clear that Pilate is the one with the power to release.

  8. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, at, during · v39

    "At" or "during": it marks the time of year.

  9. τῷ

    tō · G3588

    the · v39

    Points to *the* festival everyone knows, the one now under way.

  10. πάσχα

    pascha · G3957

    Passover · v39

    The Passover festival, which remembered Israel's release from Egypt. A pardon at the feast of liberation fits the season. In John it also carries the irony that Jesus is the Passover lamb (1:29; 19:14, 36).

  11. βούλεσθε

    boulesthe · G1014

    wish, want, will · v39

    "Do you want…?" A real request for their preference, made formally. Pilate hands the choice to them.

  12. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    so, therefore · v39

    "So then": it draws the conclusion. Since the custom exists and I find no case against him, shall I use the custom on him?

  13. βασιλέα

    basilea · G935

    king · v39

    "King": the political charge under which Jesus was handed over (18:33). From Pilate it is partly a taunt: this bound, powerless man is your "king"? For John's readers it is also true.

  14. Ἰουδαίων

    Ioudaiōn · G2453

    Jews, Judeans · v39

    "Of the Jews" or "Judeans." In the title "King of the Jews" it means the Jewish nation. It was the title Rome had given Herod the Great. Pilate is speaking to "the Jews" of 18:38, whom John identifies as the chief priests and their officers (19:6).

The world behind it

Pilate in Jerusalem at Passover. Pontius Pilate, Roman prefect of Judea (AD 26–36), normally lived in Caesarea on the coast. He came up to Jerusalem at the great festivals with troops, because the city filled with pilgrims and Passover, the feast of freedom from a foreign king, was a likely moment for unrest. Josephus describes riots at Passover under later governors (War 2.224–227).

The setting of the scene. The accusers would not enter the governor's headquarters (the praetorium, probably Herod's former palace) to avoid ritual impurity before eating the Passover (18:28). So Pilate keeps going in to question Jesus and out to talk to them. This verse is one of the "outside" scenes.

Festival pardons. All four Gospels assume that the governor released a prisoner at the feast (Mark 15:6; Matt 27:15; John 18:39; Luke 23:18 implies it). No Roman or Jewish source outside the Gospels mentions such a custom in Judea. Ancient governors did grant pardons as political favours, though. A prefect of Egypt is recorded saying "I give you to the crowds" (Papyrus Florence 61, c. AD 85). Roman festivals sometimes involved freeing prisoners (Livy 5.13.8). Josephus reports governors releasing prisoners under public pressure (Antiquities 20.208–210, 215). A Mishnah ruling about slaughtering the Passover lamb for someone "promised release from prison" (m. Pesachim 8:6) is sometimes read as a reference to pardons timed for the feast. A governor who owed his hearers nothing legally could still use a pardon to calm a festival crowd.

"King" as a charge. Under Roman rule only Caesar could make someone a king (as the Senate did for Herod the Great). An unauthorised "King of the Jews" was a rebel. Hence 19:12: "Everyone who makes himself a king opposes Caesar."

From the study of John 18:39.

Where scholars differ

in v39

Did a regular Passover amnesty actually exist?

  • Historical: a real local practice, or at least an ad hoc custom under Pilate.

    All four Gospel traditions assume it, independently in John's case. Ancient governors are known to have granted pardons to crowds (Papyrus Florence 61; Josephus, *Ant.* 20.208–210, 215). Mishnah *Pesachim* 8:6 may refer to prisoners promised release in time for the Passover meal. Some trace it to Hasmonean or Herodian practice that Rome continued.

  • Doubtful or literary: no such fixed custom is attested, and the scene is shaped to contrast Jesus with a rebel.

    No non-Christian source mentions a yearly Passover release in Judea. Freeing a known insurgent at the most volatile festival would be odd Roman policy. The m. Pesachim passage is ambiguous. On this view the scene may build on a single historical release of a man named Barabbas, or work as a dramatic device (see R. Merritt, *JBL* 1985, for discussion).

in v39

What is Pilate doing with the offer?

  • A genuine attempt to free Jesus.

    It follows straight after his verdict "I find no case" (18:38). He repeats that verdict in 19:4 and 19:6, and "from then on Pilate tried to release him" (19:12).

  • A taunt and political manoeuvre.

    Calling Jesus "the King of the Jews" mocks both prisoner and accusers. Pilate's later "Here is your king!" and "Shall I crucify your king?" (19:14–15) force the leaders into declaring loyalty to Caesar. Josephus and Philo depict Pilate as hostile to his subjects and provocative toward them (Philo, *Embassy* 299–305).

  • Both at once.

    Many commentators (e.g. Brown, Keener) read Pilate as wanting to avoid condemning a man he thinks harmless, while enjoying the chance to humiliate the priestly leadership. John's text supports both motives.

in v39

Should Ioudaioi here be translated "Jews" or "Judeans"?

  • "Judeans."

    In the first century the term was tied to the territory and people of Judea (Josephus). The rendering lessens the risk of hearing a blanket religious-ethnic accusation.

  • "Jews."

    The term was also used of Galileans and diaspora Jews, so it was not purely regional. In the title "King of the Jews" it means the nation as a whole. Within John's narrative context shows the authorities are meant, without changing the word.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. συνήθεια, ἀπολύω, πάσχα, Ἰουδαῖος
  • LSJ s.v. συνήθεια
  • Josephus, Antiquities 14.385; 20.208–210, 215; Jewish War 2.224–227
  • Philo, Embassy to Gaius 299–305
  • Mishnah Pesachim 8:6
  • Papyrus Florence 61 (c. AD 85)
  • Livy, History of Rome 5.13.8
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1 (Barabbas section)
  • Robert L. Merritt, "Jesus Barabbas and the Paschal Pardon," Journal of Biblical Literature 104 (1985)
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • Andrew T. Lincoln, The Gospel According to Saint John
  • Steve Mason, "Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism," Journal for the Study of Judaism 38 (2007)
  • NA28 apparatus on Luke 23:17
  • Vulgate, John 18:39

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.