Joshua Chapter 7 Read as one passage

Joshua 7:5–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

5And the men of Ai struck down about thirty-six of them, chasing them from the gate as far as the quarries and striking them down on the slopes. So the hearts of the people melted and became like water. 6Then Joshua tore his clothes and fell facedown before the ark of the LORD until evening, as did the elders of Israel; and they all sprinkled dust on their heads. 7“O, Lord GOD,” Joshua said, “why did You ever bring this people across the Jordan to deliver us into the hand of the Amorites to be destroyed? If only we had been content to stay on the other side of the Jordan! 8O Lord, what can I say, now that Israel has turned its back and run from its enemies? 9When the Canaanites and all who live in the land hear about this, they will surround us and wipe out our name from the earth. Then what will You do for Your great name?”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this verse was a shocking reversal, told with deliberate echoes:

  • Israel in the Canaanites' place. They had just heard that Canaan's heart "melted" before Israel (2:11; 5:1). Now the same words describe Israel. The promises of Deuteronomy, that terror would fall on the enemy (Deut 2:25; 11:25), have been turned around.
  • Echo of an older failure. The pattern of attacking, being struck down and being chased downhill recalls the generation that went up against the Canaanites without God and was "struck and crushed as far as Hormah" (Num 14:45; Deut 1:44, "chased you as bees do"). The hearer would recognise defeat as the sign of God's absence.
  • Corporate responsibility. One man's hidden theft (7:1) costs thirty-six lives and the nerve of the whole nation. The story teaches that Israel stands or falls together before God: one people, one "heart".
  • Small numbers, large meaning. Using "about" twice (about 3,000, about 36) points the hearer to the contrast. The loss is militarily small and theologically enormous. What frightens Israel is not the arithmetic but what it reveals.

The verse prepares for the rest of the chapter: the people's lament (7:6-9), God's diagnosis that Israel has broken his covenant by taking devoted things (7:10-15), and Achan being found out and put to death in the valley of Achor (7:16-26).

From the study of Joshua 7:5.

Verse by verse

  1. 5And the men of Ai struck down about thirty-six of them, chasing them from the gate as far as the quarries and striking them down on the slopes. So the hearts of the people melted and became like water.

    The men of Ai, the little town whose very name means "the Ruin", struck down and killed about thirty-six of Israel's men. They burst out from the fortified gate where Israel had come to attack, and chased the Israelites a long way, as far as "the Breaks" (a landmark of broken ground or quarries). They kept killing them as they ran down the steep slope toward the Jordan valley. At that, the single heart of the whole people, its nerve, its will and its resolve to fight, melted like wax in a fire and turned to water, with no firmness left.

    The verse is built to sting. Israel, which normally does the chasing and striking, is chased and struck. Thirty-six dead out of three thousand is a small loss in military terms, but in a war where the LORD himself was supposed to be fighting for Israel, any defeat meant something had gone badly wrong. The closing words are exactly the ones used twice before for Canaan's terror before Israel (2:11, Rahab: "our hearts melted"; 5:1, the kings: "their heart melted"). Now Israel's heart melts the way the Canaanites' did. The reader already knows the reason (7:1: Achan has taken what was devoted to God). Joshua and the people do not.

    Full study →
  2. 6Then Joshua tore his clothes and fell facedown before the ark of the LORD until evening, as did the elders of Israel; and they all sprinkled dust on their heads.

    When news came that Ai's men had cut down thirty-six Israelites and the army's courage had "melted like water" (v. 5), Joshua ripped his garments, the recognised sign of a death or a disaster, and threw himself down with his face pressed into the ground in front of the LORD's covenant chest. That chest, the ark, had gone before Israel through the Jordan and around Jericho's walls. He was lying before the very presence that was supposed to guarantee victory. He stayed down there for the rest of the day, until evening. The elders of Israel, the heads of the clans who stood for the whole people, lay down with him. Together they scooped up the dirt and flung it up so that it rained down on their heads, marking themselves with the dust of the ground: the sign of the grave, of humiliation, of a people in mourning. This is a whole nation's leadership lying prostrate and in funeral dress before their God, pleading with him and baffled. As v. 7 shows, they do not yet know why the God who parted the Jordan has let them be routed. The reader, told in v. 1, already knows.

    Full study →
  3. 7“O, Lord GOD,” Joshua said, “why did You ever bring this people across the Jordan to deliver us into the hand of the Amorites to be destroyed? If only we had been content to stay on the other side of the Jordan!

    Then Joshua cried out: "Ahh — my Lord, Yahweh! Why, why did you actually bring this people across the Jordan — all that crossing over — only to hand us over into the power of the Amorites, so that we would be wiped out? If only we had agreed to settle down and stay on the far side of the Jordan!"

    The cry is a groan of horror, not a polite 'O'. It is the same cry prophets later raise when they fear God is about to destroy Israel. Joshua uses God's personal name and calls him 'my Lord', a servant addressing a master, yet he aims his 'why?' straight at God. He takes the crossing of the Jordan, Israel's great recent miracle, and doubles the verb in protest: you really did make us cross. He then reverses the victory formula God had just used ('I have given Jericho into your hand', 6:2). Now Israel seems 'given into the hand' of the hill-country peoples, to be made to perish, which is what Israel was supposed to do to them.

    Anyone who knew Deuteronomy would hear an echo of the faithless generation at Kadesh, who said that YHWH brought them out 'to give us into the hand of the Amorite to destroy us' (Deut 1:27). Joshua's closing wish, 'if only we had settled for the east bank', sounds like the wilderness complaint 'if only we had died in Egypt.' The words for 'cross', 'bring across' and 'far side' all share one root. God's answer picks up that same root: Israel has 'crossed' (transgressed) his covenant (7:11). The disaster does not come from the crossing God led but from the boundary Israel broke.

    Full study →
  4. 8O Lord, what can I say, now that Israel has turned its back and run from its enemies?

    "Please, my Lord, if I may speak: what can I possibly say, now that Israel, Your own people, has turned tail and shown the back of its neck to its enemies?"

    Joshua opens with a servant's courtesy, the formula used to ask permission before saying something difficult to a master. Then he admits he has nothing to say. The defeat is complete and already done. The image is of soldiers wheeling round so that the men of Ai see only the napes of their necks as they run. To an Israelite ear that image was painfully ironic. God had promised that Israel's enemies would turn their necks to Israel (Exodus 23:27). Now the promise looks reversed, and the verb Joshua uses can also mean "overturn". Israel is spoken of as one body: a few thousand men fled, but "Israel" has turned. Joshua's speechlessness is not only private. As leader and spokesman he has no word to give the people and no explanation for the nations (v. 9). He does not yet know what the reader knows from 7:1: the cause lies inside the camp.

    Full study →
  5. 9When the Canaanites and all who live in the land hear about this, they will surround us and wipe out our name from the earth. Then what will You do for Your great name?”

    "The Canaanites, and everyone else who lives in this land, will hear what happened at Ai. They will close in on us from every side, as we once circled Jericho, and destroy us so completely that Israel's name, its existence and its memory, is erased from the land and from among the living. And then what becomes of your name, the great name the nations learned to fear when you dried up the sea and the Jordan? What will you do about your own reputation?"

    Joshua sets two "names" side by side, Israel's and God's. In his reasoning they rise or fall together: if God's people are wiped out, the nations will conclude that Israel's God could not, or would not, protect them. The closing question is not a request for information. It is an appeal, close to a challenge, made on the ground of God's honour.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v5

    the hearts of the people melted

    wayyimmas ləbab-hāʿām

    What we hear
    Many individuals felt sad or frightened; an emotional reaction inside each person.
    What they heard
    The one corporate 'heart' (mind, will, nerve) of the whole nation dissolved. Israel lost its collective resolve and ability to fight. It is the stock phrase for an army or nation on the edge of collapse, the same words used just before of the doomed Canaanites.
  • in v6

    tore his clothes

    qara' simlotav

    What we hear
    A spontaneous, perhaps frantic, outburst of emotion or anger.
    What they heard
    A conventional, recognised mourning and alarm gesture, the expected public response to news of death, defeat or blasphemy. Everyone knew what it signalled.
  • in v6

    fell facedown

    naphal 'al-panav

    What we hear
    Collapsed or fell over from shock.
    What they heard
    Deliberately threw himself down in full prostration. It is the posture of a petitioner or intercessor before a superior, here before the LORD.
  • in v7

    Lord GOD

    ʾadonai YHWH

    What we hear
    Two general titles, 'Lord' and 'God', placed side by side.
    What they heard
    'My Lord' followed by God's personal name, Yahweh. The capitals are a printer's signal that the name stands there. Joshua is calling on Israel's covenant God by name.
  • in v7

    content (to stay)

    hoʾalnu

    What we hear
    Emotionally satisfied, at peace with one's lot.
    What they heard
    'If only we had agreed / made up our minds to settle there.' It describes a decision to accept a lesser place, not a feeling.
  • in v8

    O Lord

    bî ʾădōnāy

    What we hear
    An emotional exclamation, a sigh or cry of distress directed at God.
    What they heard
    A formal courtesy: "Please, my Lord / pardon me, my Master", the phrase a servant used to ask leave before speaking to a superior, especially before saying something risky.
  • in v9

    from the earth

    min-ha'arets

    What we hear
    Wiped off the whole planet, a global scale that sounds different from 'the land' earlier in the verse.
    What they heard
    The same word as 'the land' earlier in the verse. In this stock phrase it means 'from the land / from among the living', that is, total extinction, with the particular sting that Israel would vanish from the very land it was promised.
  • in v9

    our name

    shemenu

    What we hear
    A label or title, as if only Israel's reputation were at stake.
    What they heard
    Israel's very existence, survival and memory as a people. To 'cut off a name' is to leave no descendants and no remembrance.
Every word
  1. וַיַּכּוּ

    wayyakkû · H5221

    to strike, smite · v5

    "And they struck down." The usual Hebrew verb for a deadly blow in battle. Here it means killing, not just wounding, and it opens the verse with Israel on the receiving end.

  2. מֵהֶם

    mēhem · H9038

    from them, of them · v5

    "From among them." The preposition singles out a part: some of the 3,000 were killed, not the whole force. KJV keeps this with "smote of them."

  3. אַנְשֵׁי

    ʾanšê · H0582

    men of · v5

    "The men of." This is the standard plural of 'man'. Here it means the fighting men or citizens of the town.

  4. הָעַי

    hāʿay · H5857

    Ai ("the Ruin") · v5

    Ai always appears with "the" in Hebrew, and the name sounds like "the ruin-heap." A town with a name like 'the Ruin' that the spies called small (7:3) is the one that routs Israel.

  5. כִּשְׁלֹשִׁים

    kišlōšîm · H7970

    about thirty · v5

    The prefix kə- ("about, approximately") marks the number as a rough count. It echoes "about three thousand" in 7:4 and invites the reader to compare the two figures.

  6. וְשִׁשָּׁה

    wəšiššâ · H8337

    and six · v5

    Thirty-six in all. In military terms the loss is small, about one man in eighty-three. The point of the story is that it is out of all proportion to the shock it causes.

  7. אִישׁ

    ʾîš · H0376

    man · v5

    A singular noun used after a number, which is normal Hebrew style: "thirty-six man" = thirty-six men.

  8. וַיִּרְדְּפוּם

    wayyirdəpûm · H7291

    to pursue, chase · v5

    "And they chased them." This verb normally describes Israel pursuing beaten enemies (e.g. Josh 10:19). Here the roles are reversed: the Canaanites are the pursuers.

  9. לִפְנֵי

    lipnê · H6440

    before, in front of · v5, v6, v8

    "From before the gate." The fighting began right in front of Ai's gate, which is where Israel's attack was aimed and where it broke.

  10. הַשַּׁעַר

    haššaʿar · H8179

    gate · v5

    The town gate was the fortified entrance and the strongest defensive point of an ancient town. The defenders came out from it and pushed the attackers back.

  11. עַד־

    ʿad- · H5704

    until, as far as · v5, v6

    "As far as." It marks how far the chase went. Israel was driven a long way.

  12. הַשְּׁבָרִים

    haššəbārîm · H7671

    Shebarim ("the Breaks") · v5

    Literally "the breaks" or "the fractures," from the root 'to break'. It may be a place name (KJV, WEB), broken ravine country, or stone quarries (BSB). With the word 'the' in front it reads like a local landmark. Whichever it is, the image of breaking fits the rout.

  13. בַּמּוֹרָד

    bammôrād · H4174

    descent, slope · v5

    "On the descent": the steep downhill route from Ai's ridge toward the Jordan valley, which Israel took in retreat. YLT treats it as a place name, 'Morad'. Men running downhill with their backs to the enemy were easy to kill.

  14. וַיִּמַּס

    wayyimmas · H4549

    to melt, dissolve · v5

    "And it melted." The word is used for wax melting in fire and manna melting in the sun. Of a heart, it means courage and resolve dissolving. This is the exact verb used of the Canaanites' hearts in 2:11 and 5:1.

  15. לְבַב־

    ləbab- · H3824

    heart, mind, will · v5

    Singular: 'the heart of the people'. In Hebrew the heart is the centre of thinking, deciding and nerve, not mainly of feeling. The whole nation is pictured as having one heart, and it gives way.

  16. הָעָם

    hāʿām · H5971

    people · v5, v7

    "The people": Israel as a whole, including the army camped at Gilgal and not only the 3,000 who went up. The collapse spreads to everyone.

  17. וַיְהִי

    wayhî · H1961

    to be, become · v5

    "And it became." Together with the next word it describes a change into something else, not just a comparison.

  18. לְמָיִם

    ləmāyim · H4325

    water · v5

    "Into water" or "became water." There is no 'like' in Hebrew. The heart has no firmness left, as formless as spilled water.

  19. וַיִּקְרַ֨ע

    vayyiqra' · H7167

    to tear, rip · v6

    The standard verb for ripping one's garment in grief or shock. The narrative verb form moves the story straight on from the rout at Ai in v. 5: news of defeat, then this response.

  20. יְהוֹשֻׁ֜עַ

    Yehoshua' · H3091

    Joshua ("YHWH is salvation/help") · v6, v7

    Israel's commander, Moses' successor. Joshua acts first and alone in the tearing; the elders are only added after the next verb.

  21. שִׂמְלֹתָ֗יו

    simlotav · H8071

    outer garment, cloak; clothes · v6

    His outer garments. The plural can mean 'his clothes' in general. Tearing them was a public, visible sign of grief.

  22. וַיִּפֹּל֩

    vayyippol · H5307

    to fall · v6

    He threw himself down on purpose. This is not collapsing or fainting but the deliberate posture of someone pleading with or submitting to a superior.

  23. עַל־

    'al- · H5921

    upon, on · v6, v9

    Part of the fixed phrase 'fell upon his face'.

  24. אַ֜רְצָה

    artsah · H776

    earth, ground; (with -ah) to the ground · v6, v9

    'Groundward'. The ending -ah marks direction, so the face goes down to the earth. It stresses how low he went.

  25. אֲר֤וֹן

    aron · H727

    chest, box; the Ark · v6

    The covenant chest that had led Israel across the Jordan (ch. 3–4) and around Jericho (ch. 6). It was the place where Israel met the LORD.

  26. יְהוָה֙

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v6

    Israel's covenant God, by his personal name. The ark is his.

  27. הָעֶ֔רֶב

    ha'erev · H6153

    evening · v6

    'The evening': the close of the day. Elsewhere in the Bible, day-long mourning and fasting last 'until evening' (Judg 20:23, 26; 2 Sam 1:12).

  28. ה֖וּא

    hu' · H1931

    he · v6

    'He' is added after the fact to set up 'he and the elders', widening the subject of the prostration.

  29. וְזִקְנֵ֣י

    veziqnei · H2205

    elder(s) · v6

    'And the elders of'. These are the senior heads of clans and households who represented the people. Their presence makes this the whole nation's lament, not only Joshua's.

  30. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v6, v8

    The tribal people as a whole, whom the elders represent.

  31. וַיַּעֲל֥וּ

    vayya'alu · H5927

    (causative) to make go up, bring up, raise · v6

    'And they made [dust] go up'. The plural covers Joshua and the elders. The verb pictures scooping dust and flinging it up so that it lands on the head. It is stronger than 'sprinkled'.

  32. עָפָ֖ר

    'afar · H6083

    dust, loose earth · v6

    The dust of the ground, a symbol of humiliation and of death (Gen 3:19). Putting it on oneself was a standard sign of mourning.

  33. רֹאשָֽׁם׃

    rosham · H7218

    head · v6

    'Their head': singular in Hebrew but meaning each man's head. This is the same idiom as 'fell upon his face'.

  34. וַיֹּ֨אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v7, v8

    This is the ordinary verb that moves a story forward. Joshua's words come straight after the mourning rite of v.6, so they are spoken lying face down before the ark.

  35. אֲהָ֣הּ

    ʾahah · H0162

    alas! ah! · v7

    A raw cry of dismay or alarm, used when something has gone terribly wrong. It is not a polite 'O' that opens a prayer. It is a groan.

  36. אֲדֹנָ֣י

    ʾadonai · H0136

    Lord, my Lord · v7, v8

    A respectful title, 'my Lord'. Joshua speaks as a servant to his master even while he protests.

  37. יְהוִ֗ה

    YHWH · H3069

    Yahweh · v7

    God's personal name. After 'Adonai' the scribes gave it the vowels of 'Elohim' (God), so that readers would say 'Lord GOD' and not repeat 'Lord Lord'. This is why English prints it as 'GOD' in small capitals.

  38. לָ֠מָה

    lammah · H4100

    why? · v7, v8, v9

    The classic 'why?' of Israel's laments (compare Ps 22:1; 44:23-24). It is a protest put to God, not a calm request for information.

  39. הֵעֲבַ֨רְתָּ

    heʿevarta · H5674

    you brought across · v7

    'You made [us] cross over.' It is the key verb of the Jordan crossing in chapters 3–4. Joshua turns the great miracle into an accusation.

  40. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [object marker] · v7, v9

    This small word marks 'this people' as the object of the verb. It has no English equivalent.

  41. הַזֶּה֙

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v7

    'This people'. Joshua points to the nation before God. In the next breath he switches to 'us' and counts himself among the doomed.

  42. הַיַּרְדֵּ֔ן

    hayyarden · H3383

    the Jordan · v7

    The river boundary that was crossed by a miracle only days before (ch. 3–4). It was the line between the promise and its fulfilment.

  43. לָתֵ֥ת

    latet · H5414

    to give · v7

    'To give', used in the idiom 'give into the hand of', the formula of holy war. God had just said 'I have given Jericho into your hand' (6:2). Joshua fears the formula has been turned around against Israel.

  44. בְּיַ֥ד

    beyad · H3027

    into the hand of · v7

    'Hand' stands for power and control. To be given into someone's hand is to be put at their mercy.

  45. הָאֱמֹרִ֖י

    haʾemori · H0567

    the Amorite · v7

    A collective singular, 'the Amorite'. In Deuteronomy and Joshua it is a broad name for the people of Canaan's hill country, where Ai stood. It is not one narrow tribe.

  46. לְהַאֲבִידֵ֑נוּ

    lehaʾavidenu · H0006

    to make us perish · v7

    'To cause us to perish, to wipe us out.' Israel was meant to make the nations of Canaan perish (Deut 7:24). Joshua fears the reverse is happening.

  47. וְלוּ֙

    velu · H3863

    and if only · v7

    A word of wishing for what did not happen: 'if only…!' The same wish appears in the wilderness complaints (Num 14:2; 20:3).

  48. הוֹאַ֣לְנוּ

    hoʾalnu · H2974

    we had been willing · v7

    'We had agreed, made up our minds, settled for it.' Paired with 'stay', it is a fixed expression for agreeing to settle somewhere (Exod 2:21; Judg 17:11).

  49. וַנֵּ֔שֶׁב

    vannēshev · H3427

    and we had stayed / settled · v7, v9

    'Sit, remain, settle down to live.' Joshua wishes Israel had made its home east of the river.

  50. בְּעֵ֖בֶר

    beʿever · H5676

    on the far side of · v7

    'The region across.' It comes from the same root as 'cross over', so the verse's sounds circle back to the crossing Joshua now regrets.

  51. בִּ֖י

    bî · H0994

    please, pardon me · v8

    A short, polite word used to open a request to a superior: roughly "please, by your leave" or "pardon me, may I speak". Joshua does not simply cry out; he first asks permission to address his Master.

  52. אַ֠חֲרֵי

    ʾaḥărê · H0310A

    after · v8

    "After", combined with the next word into "after (the fact) that", meaning "now that" or "seeing that". It points to something already done that cannot be undone.

  53. אֲשֶׁ֨ר

    ʾăšer · H0834A

    which, that · v8

    Links "after" to the clause that follows: "after that Israel has turned…"

  54. הָפַ֧ךְ

    hāpak · H2015

    to turn, overturn · v8

    "Has turned": a completed act. The verb often means a turning-over or reversal, and here describes an army wheeling round in flight. Israel's whole situation has been turned upside down.

  55. עֹ֖רֶף

    ʿōrep · H6203

    back of the neck, nape · v8

    "Neck": to turn the neck toward an enemy is to show him the back of your head as you run. The same word is used in God's earlier promise that Israel's enemies would show Israel their necks (Exod 23:27).

  56. אֹיְבָֽיו׃

    ʾōyəbāyw · H0341

    enemy · v8

    "Its enemies": the hostile peoples of Canaan, here the men of Ai. The word comes from a verb meaning to be hostile toward someone, so it names people who are actively against Israel.

  57. וְיִשְׁמְעוּ

    veyishme'u · H8085

    and they will hear · v9

    Opens the chain of feared consequences: news of the defeat at Ai will spread. In Joshua, 'hearing' is what made the Canaanites' hearts melt (2:10–11; 5:1); now Joshua fears the news will run the other way.

  58. הַכְּנַעֲנִי

    hakkena'ani · H3669

    the Canaanite · v9

    Grammatically singular ('the Canaanite') but used for the whole population as one group, hence 'the Canaanites' in English.

  59. וְכֹל

    vekhol · H3605

    and all · v9

    Widens the threat from one people to everyone in the region.

  60. וְנָסַבּוּ

    venasabbu · H5437

    and they will surround · v9

    A Niphal form with 'against us': to close in from every side, the picture of a coalition encircling a vulnerable people. The irony is sharp: Israel had just 'circled' Jericho (Josh 6, same verb) and won; now Joshua fears being circled.

  61. וְהִכְרִיתוּ

    vehikhritu · H3772

    and they will cut off · v9

    Causative form of 'cut': to destroy so completely that nothing is left. Paired with 'name' it means total extinction of a people and its memory.

  62. שְׁמֵנוּ

    shemenu · H8034

    our name · v9

    Not just a label but Israel's existence, reputation and remembrance as a people. To lose the 'name' is to vanish from history.

  63. מִן־

    min · H4480

    from · v9

    Removal 'from' the land/earth.

  64. תַּעֲשֵׂה

    ta'aseh · H6213

    will you do · v9

    'What will you do' addressed to God (second person singular): what will become of God's own reputation, and what will he do to protect it?

  65. הַגָּדוֹל

    haggadol · H1419

    the great · v9

    God's name is 'great': famous, feared and honoured among the nations because of the Exodus and the Jordan crossing (Josh 2:9–11; 4:24). Joshua's point is that this greatness is now at stake.

The world behind it

Holy war, and why 36 deaths was a disaster. In the conquest stories of Deuteronomy and Joshua, the LORD fights for Israel. Victory proves he is present, and defeat means he has withdrawn (Num 14:42-45; Deut 1:42-44). So far in Joshua not a single Israelite death has been recorded. Jericho fell with no reported losses. Measured against that, thirty-six dead is not a minor setback. It is a sign that God is no longer with the army. God says exactly this in 7:12: "I will not be with you anymore unless you destroy what is devoted to destruction among you."

The irony set up in 7:2-4. The spies came back confident: Ai's people "are few", so there was no need for everyone to "toil up there" (7:3). Only about 3,000 went. The writer has already told the reader (7:1) that Achan secretly kept goods from Jericho that were ḥērem, meaning devoted wholly to God and forbidden for personal use. That made the whole people guilty in God's eyes.

Terrain. Ai lay on the hill country east of Bethel, about 1,000 m (over 3,000 ft) above the Jordan valley where Israel was camped near Jericho. Going up to attack meant a hard climb, and a retreat meant a long run downhill along ravines with the enemy behind. That is the "descent" (môrād) where most of the killing happened.

The town gate. An ancient town's gate was its fortified entrance and the focus of any attack. The fighting began "before the gate". The defenders came out through it and broke the attackers.

What comes next. In 7:6 Joshua and the elders tear their clothes, throw dust on their heads and lie face down before the ark until evening. These were the standard signs of mourning and disaster. The defeat in 7:5 sets off that public crisis.

From the study of Joshua 7:5.

Where scholars differ

in v5

What is 'Shebarim'?

  • A proper place name, a local landmark called 'the Breaks'.

    It has the definite article like many local names, and KJV, WEB, ESV and NASB keep it. Its exact location is unknown.

  • Stone quarries or broken ground (ravines, gullies) east of Ai.

    The root šbr means 'to break'. BSB and NIV adopt 'quarries', and the terrain descending toward the Jordan is cut by ravines.

  • Not a place at all, but a verb: 'until they shattered them'.

    The Greek Septuagint seems to read it this way. Most scholars think the Hebrew noun is the original, but the Greek shows the word's meaning was unclear in antiquity.

in v5

How does this account relate to the archaeology of Ai?

  • Ai is et-Tell, and that site was unoccupied in the Late Bronze Age, so the story is a later explanation for a famous ruin ('the Ruin').

    Excavations by Judith Marquet-Krause and Joseph Callaway found a large Early Bronze city and a small Iron Age I village, but no town in the period usually given for Joshua.

  • Ai is a different site, such as Khirbet el-Maqatir, which had a small Late Bronze fortress.

    Excavations led by Bryant Wood and later Scott Stripling report a small fort with a gate. Its fit with the biblical geography (east of Bethel) and its date are disputed.

  • The identification of Bethel itself, and therefore of Ai, is uncertain, so the question cannot yet be settled.

    Some (e.g. David Livingston) have argued for a different location of Bethel. This remains a minority view.

in v6

Is Joshua's prostration and lament presented as right piety or as faithless despair that the LORD rebukes?

  • It is a fitting act of intercession and lament in the tradition of Moses. The LORD's 'Get up!' (v. 10) is a call to action, not a condemnation of lament itself.

    Moses and Aaron repeatedly 'fell on their faces' to intercede (Num 14:5; 16:22; Deut 9:18, 25). Israel weeps 'until evening' before the LORD after defeat in Judg 20:23–26 and receives guidance. The LORD answers Joshua by revealing the cause.

  • The rites are sincere, but Joshua's accompanying words (v. 7) echo the wilderness complaints, and v. 10 is a mild rebuke: the problem is Israel's sin, not God's faithfulness, so lying on the ground is the wrong response.

    Verse 7's 'If only we had been content to stay on the other side' echoes Num 14:2–3 and Exod 16:3. Verse 10's sharp 'Why is it that you have fallen on your face? Israel has sinned' (vv. 10–11) redirects attention from lament to finding the sin. The reader already knows of Achan's sin (v. 1).

in v7

Is Joshua's prayer faithless complaint or legitimate lament?

  • It echoes the faithless murmuring of the wilderness generation, and God's sharp 'Get up! Why have you fallen on your face?' (v.10) is a rebuke.

    The wording nearly copies Deut 1:27 ('to give us into the hand of the Amorite to destroy us'). The 'if only' wish matches Num 14:2 and 20:3. Joshua blames God for a defeat caused by Israel's sin.

  • It is a proper lament and intercession on the model of Moses. God's 'Get up' simply moves things from mourning to action, because the cause is sin that has to be dealt with.

    The setting is a recognised mourning rite before the ark (v.6). The cry *ʾahah ʾadonai YHWH* is the prophets' own way of pleading (Ezek 9:8; 11:13). V.9 appeals to God's name, as Moses did (Num 14:13-16; Deut 9:28). God does not punish Joshua; he answers him.

  • The narrator means it to be ambiguous. The prayer uses the language of murmuring inside the form of a lament, so that hearers feel the danger of repeating the wilderness failure.

    The narrator lets the reader know about Achan (7:1) while Joshua does not. The prayer stands on the edge between faith and despair, and the wordplay on 'cross'/'transgress' in 7:11 turns Joshua's complaint back on Israel.

in v8

Is Joshua's prayer (vv. 7–9) a faithful lament or a faithless complaint?

  • It is close to the wilderness murmuring and is implicitly rebuked.

    "If only we had been content to stay on the other side of the Jordan" (v. 7) echoes Israel's complaints about wishing to have stayed in Egypt (Exod 14:11–12; Num 14:2–3). The question "why did You bring us… to destroy us?" sounds like an accusation. God's answer begins abruptly: "Get up! Why are you lying on your face?" (7:10).

  • It is legitimate lament in the tradition of Moses' intercession.

    Joshua uses the deferential "bî ʾădōnāy" (as Moses did, Exod 4:10, 13). He mourns before the ark with the elders, and he appeals to God's reputation among the nations (v. 9), the classic argument of Mosaic intercession (Exod 32:12; Num 14:13–16; Deut 9:28). God answers him with information instead of punishment. Many commentators see a mixture of both elements: honest anguish in the form of lament, coloured by echoes of the wilderness complaints.

in v8

What is the origin of the particle bî?

  • It comes from a root meaning "to ask, request" (compare Aramaic bʿy, Arabic bġy), so it means roughly "I ask (you)" or "please".

    A request sense fits every occurrence, and the Septuagint's δέομαι ("I beg") supports it. This view is noted in HALOT.

  • It is the preposition "on" plus "me": "on me (be it), my lord", a formula taking responsibility for speaking out of turn.

    This is the older traditional explanation (reflected in BDB's discussion). It is supported by expressions such as Abigail's "on me, my lord, be the guilt" (1 Sam 25:24). It is less favoured now because bî is always written as a fixed particle. Either way, the function is the same: a humble request for leave to speak.

in v9

Is Joshua's prayer (7:7–9) faithful intercession or faithless complaint?

  • Legitimate intercession in the tradition of Moses

    The appeal to God's name before the nations repeats Moses' arguments in Exod 32:12, Num 14:13–16 and Deut 9:28, which God accepted. Lament with torn clothes and dust before the ark is a proper religious act.

  • A lament that echoes the wilderness grumbling and misreads the situation

    In v. 7, 'If only we had been content to stay beyond the Jordan', Joshua sounds like the complaints of Exod 16:3 and Num 14:2. God's reply in v. 10 ('Stand up! Why have you fallen on your face?') is a rebuke or redirection, and the real cause (Achan's sin, 7:1) lies within Israel, not with God.

  • Mixed: sincere and rightly focused on God's name, but uninformed

    The narrator gives the reader information Joshua lacks (7:1). God does not condemn the prayer's concern for his name. He corrects Joshua's diagnosis and gives him a task.

in v9

Should 'min-ha'arets' be read as 'from the earth' or 'from the land'?

  • 'From the earth', meaning from the world of the living

    This matches the stock idiom of cutting off a memory or name 'from the earth' (Ps 34:16; compare Ps 109:15). Most English versions read it this way.

  • 'From the land', meaning Canaan

    The same word, with the article, was used three words earlier for 'the land' whose inhabitants will attack. The setting is the conquest of a particular land.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מָסַס, לֵבָב, נָכָה, שֶׁבֶר
  • HALOT s.v. מסס, שְׁבָרִים, מוֹרָד
  • Septuagint, Joshua 7:5
  • Vulgate, Josue 7:5
  • Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 121b; Sanhedrin 44b
  • Richard S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
  • Trent C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Marten H. Woudstra, The Book of Joshua (NICOT)
  • Robert G. Boling, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 7
  • Joseph A. Callaway, excavation reports on et-Tell (Ai)
  • Bryant G. Wood, reports on Khirbet el-Maqatir
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. קרע, נפל, ארון, זקן, עפר, עלה (Hiphil)
  • Ezekiel 27:30; Job 2:12; Lamentations 2:10; 1 Samuel 4:12; 2 Samuel 1:2, 11–12; Judges 20:23–26 (parallel usage)
  • KTU 1.5 vi (Ugaritic Baal Cycle, El's mourning rites)
  • Richard D. Nelson, Joshua (OTL) on 7:6–9 and the Old Greek text
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Joshua 7:6; Vulgate, Josue 7:6
  • BDB s.v. אֲהָהּ, יָאַל, עָבַר, אָבַד, עֵבֶר
  • HALOT s.v. אֲהָהּ; יאל hiphil
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §113 on the infinitive absolute for emphasis
  • Waltke & O'Connor, Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax §35.3 (infinitive absolute)
  • T. C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
  • L. D. Hawk, Joshua (Berit Olam)
  • M. H. Woudstra, The Book of Joshua (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Joshua 7:7 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Josue 7:7
  • BDB s.v. בִּי
  • HALOT s.v. בִּי
  • HALOT s.v. הפך
  • HALOT s.v. עֹרֶף
  • BDB s.v. אֲדֹנָי
  • TDOT s.v. hāpak
  • Richard D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Joshua 7:8
  • Vulgate Joshua 7:8
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. שֵׁם
  • HALOT s.v. כרת (Hiphil)
  • HALOT s.v. סבב
  • BDB s.v. אֶרֶץ
  • Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied data)
  • Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 4–6

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).