Luke Chapter 23 Read as one passage

Luke 23:9–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9Herod questioned Jesus at great length, but He gave no answer. 10Meanwhile, the chief priests and scribes stood there, vehemently accusing Him.

What the first hearers heard

Only Luke tells this scene, and his readers would have picked up several things:

  • A silent servant. Jesus' silence fits the picture of the suffering servant in Isaiah 53, "like a sheep that before its shearers is silent, so he opens not his mouth." Luke quotes those lines in Acts 8:32–33 and applies Isaiah 53 to Jesus' arrest in Luke 22:37. The silence shows him accepting his path, not losing control of the situation.
  • Two rulers set against him. In Acts 4:25–27 the early church reads Psalm 2 ("the kings of the earth set themselves... against his Anointed") as fulfilled when "Herod and Pontius Pilate" joined forces against Jesus. Herod's hearing provides the second of those two rulers.
  • A second witness to innocence. Herod finds nothing to condemn (23:15). Under Jewish law a matter was established by two witnesses (Deut 19:15), and so Pilate and Herod both clear Jesus. This matters to Luke's case that Jesus, and the movement that followed him, posed no criminal threat to Rome.
  • No performance for the curious. The man who killed the prophet John and wanted to see tricks gets neither a miracle nor a speech. His mockery that follows (23:11) shows what his "joy" at seeing Jesus (23:8) really was.

From the study of Luke 23:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9Herod questioned Jesus at great length, but He gave no answer.

    So Herod kept firing questions at him, a great many words, on and on. But Jesus himself gave him no answer, not one word.

    Herod has waited "a long time" to meet the miracle-worker everyone in his territory talked about (v. 8). Now he pours out "a good many" words, and Luke uses the same adjective for both, as if Herod's long wait has turned into long talk. The tense shows questions repeated or continuing. The second half turns sharply: Greek adds the emphatic "he himself" to set Jesus against Herod, and the negative is total, nothing. Jesus had given the Jewish council and Pilate at least a brief reply. To the ruler who wanted a sign and who had beheaded John the Baptist, he gives none. Readers who knew the Scriptures would hear the servant of Isaiah 53:7, led like a sheep that is silent before its shearers, who "did not open his mouth." Meanwhile the chief priests and scribes stand shouting accusations (v. 10). Everyone in the room is talking except the accused.

    Full study →
  2. 10Meanwhile, the chief priests and scribes stood there, vehemently accusing Him.

    All the while Herod was firing question after question at Jesus, and Jesus answered nothing, the leading priests and the experts in the Law stood there in front of the ruler, pressing their case against him with all their strength. They were not just grumbling or making accusations in passing. They were acting as prosecutors, laying formal charges, and they kept at it, hard and without letting up. The word Luke chooses for how they spoke pictures a cord pulled tight: forceful, sustained, nothing held back.

    The men making the charges were the most powerful people in Jerusalem. The chief priests were the priestly ruling class who ran the temple and dealt with Rome. The scribes were the trained legal scholars of the Law of Moses. They had already accused Jesus before Pilate, and they followed him to Herod's quarters to say it all again. Luke sets the scene as a deliberate contrast: on one side, a flood of words from the ruler and the accusers; on the other, total silence from the accused.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    scribes

    grammateis

    What we hear
    Copyists or secretaries who write documents out by hand.
    What they heard
    Trained experts in the Law of Moses: legal scholars, teachers and interpreters whose opinions carried authority, some of whom sat on the Jerusalem council.
  • in v10

    chief priests

    archiereis

    What we hear
    Senior clergy, religious officials separate from the civil government.
    What they heard
    The priestly aristocracy of Jerusalem (the ruling high priest, former high priests, and the leading priestly families), who held religious, financial and political power under Roman oversight.
Every word
  1. ἐπηρώτα

    epērōta · G1905

    to question, put questions to · v9

    The tense (imperfect) shows action that goes on or repeats: Herod kept asking, one question after another. The prefix ep- makes the asking pointed, aimed at someone, the ordinary word for questioning a person under examination.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, then, but · v9, v10

    A light link moving the story on from Herod's delight (v. 8) to what he did about it: 'So he questioned him...'

  3. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v9, v10

    Jesus, the one being questioned.

  4. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, with · v9

    Here 'with' or 'by means of': the questioning was carried out in a flood of words.

  5. λόγοις

    logois · G3056

    word, statement, speech · v9

    Plain 'words' or 'remarks', Herod's talk. It carries no theological weight here. The irony is that a great many words come from Herod and none from Jesus.

  6. ἱκανοῖς·

    hikanois · G2425

    sufficient, considerable, many · v9

    'A good many, a considerable amount.' It is the same word Luke used one verse earlier for the 'long time' (literally 'considerable times') Herod had wanted to see Jesus. His long wish turns into long questioning.

  7. οὐδὲν

    ouden · G3762

    nothing, not one thing · v9

    A complete denial: not a single word in reply, not even the brief 'You say so' that he gave Pilate (23:3).

  8. ἀπεκρίνατο

    apekrinato · G0611

    to answer, reply · v9

    A single completed action (aorist) set against Herod's ongoing questioning: in the end, no answer came. This less common form of the verb appears in the other Gospels' silence scenes too (Mark 14:61; Matt 27:12), and grammarians often link it to formal or courtroom settings.

  9. εἱστήκεισαν

    heistēkeisan · G2476

    to stand · v10

    The form looks like 'had stood', but for this verb it works like a plain past tense of an ongoing state: 'they were standing there'. It paints a scene of the accusers standing in place in Herod's presence, which was how prosecutors stood in a hearing.

  10. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v10

    The article marks out a known group: the same chief priests who brought the charges before Pilate (23:1–5).

  11. ἀρχιερεῖς

    archiereis · G0749

    high priest; (plural) chief priests · v10

    In the plural this means the priestly upper class in Jerusalem: the ruling high priest, former high priests such as Annas, and senior men from the leading priestly families who ran the temple. They were the main Jewish political authority under Rome.

  12. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v10

    Joins the two groups so that they act together as one accusing party.

  13. γραμματεῖς

    grammateis · G1122

    scribe; expert in the law · v10

    Not copyists. These were trained experts in the Law of Moses and how to interpret it. They gave the charges legal and religious weight.

  14. εὐτόνως

    eutonōs · G2159

    vigorously, vehemently · v10

    The image behind it is a well-strung, taut string. The accusations were forceful and sustained. The word is about intensity and force, not necessarily shouting.

  15. κατηγοροῦντες

    katēgorountes · G2723

    to accuse, bring charges · v10

    A courtroom word: to press formal charges as a prosecutor. The tense shows the action going on and on while Jesus stays silent.

The world behind it

Who this Herod is. This is Herod Antipas, son of Herod the Great. He ruled Galilee and Perea as tetrarch (a client ruler under Rome, below the rank of king) from 4 BC to AD 39. Jesus was from Galilee, so he was Antipas's subject. Antipas was probably in Jerusalem for Passover, staying in the old Hasmonean palace.

Why Pilate sent Jesus to him. When Pilate hears that Jesus is a Galilean (23:6–7), he sends him to Antipas. Roman law allowed a governor to hand an accused person over to the authority of his home region, but did not require it (A. N. Sherwin-White discusses this). The move was a diplomatic courtesy that may also have let Pilate push off a difficult case. Luke notes that the two men, previously enemies, became friends that day (23:12).

What Luke's readers already knew about Antipas. He had imprisoned and beheaded John the Baptist (Luke 3:19–20; 9:9). Earlier he had been "perplexed" about Jesus and "kept trying to see him" (9:9). Some Pharisees warned that he wanted to kill Jesus, and Jesus called him "that fox" (13:31–32). Luke had informants close to the court: Joanna, wife of Herod's steward Chuza (8:3), and Manaen, who was brought up with Herod (Acts 13:1).

Signs on demand. Verse 8 says Herod hoped to see a "sign." Earlier in Luke, Jesus refused to give signs to a crowd demanding them ("no sign will be given except the sign of Jonah," 11:29). In Luke's story, a ruler's curiosity gets no display.

From the study of Luke 23:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

Why does Jesus answer Herod nothing, when he speaks briefly to the council and to Pilate?

  • Fulfilment of the silent servant of Isaiah 53:7

    Luke applies Isaiah 53 to Jesus (Luke 22:37; Acts 8:32–33), and the 'answered nothing' wording matches the other Gospels' silence scenes.

  • A refusal to perform for idle curiosity

    Verse 8 says Herod hoped to see a sign, and Jesus refuses signs on demand in Luke 11:29. The mockery that follows (23:11) confirms that Herod was not asking sincerely.

  • A judgment on Herod in particular

    Herod had killed John (9:9), and Jesus called him 'that fox' (13:32). Silence towards a ruler who had silenced God's prophet works as a verdict on him.

  • No legal need to answer

    The case belonged to Pilate. Herod held only a courtesy hearing and had no power to try it, and he too finds no guilt (23:15).

in v9

Is the Herod hearing historical or Luke's own composition?

  • Largely shaped by Luke's reading of Psalm 2

    Acts 4:25–27 explicitly reads Herod and Pilate as the 'kings and rulers' of Psalm 2, so some scholars (e.g., Dibelius) think the scene grew out of that interpretation.

  • Rests on genuine tradition

    Luke had sources close to Antipas's court (Joanna, 8:3; Manaen, Acts 13:1). Antipas's presence in Jerusalem at Passover is plausible, and Roman practice allowed a case to be sent to the accused's home ruler (Sherwin-White, Hoehner).

in v10

Did the hearing before Herod Antipas really happen, or did Luke build it from Scripture?

  • Historical: Luke drew on real information about the Herodian court.

    Luke had contacts close to Antipas's household: Joanna, wife of Herod's steward Chuza (Luke 8:3), and Manaen (Acts 13:1). Antipas being in Jerusalem for Passover is plausible. Courtesy referrals between Roman officials and client rulers are attested (compare Festus consulting Agrippa II in Acts 25–26). Herod's earlier wish to see Jesus (9:9; 23:8) is part of a consistent thread.

  • Largely shaped by Luke's theological purposes.

    Only Luke tells the story. The mockery and robe (23:11) look like the Roman soldiers' mockery in Mark 15:16–20, which Luke leaves out. The pairing of Herod and Pilate matches Luke's reading of Psalm 2 in Acts 4:25–27. Luke also likes to have two witnesses to innocence (23:15), as in Deuteronomy 19:15.

  • A middle position.

    Many commentators accept a historical core, a brief referral to Antipas, that Luke has told in a way that brings out the Psalm 2 echo and the double verdict of innocence.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἐπερωτάω, ἱκανός, ἀποκρίνομαι
  • BDF §78 (aorist middle ἀπεκρινάμην)
  • Thayer s.v. ἱκανός
  • H. W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas (1972)
  • A. N. Sherwin-White, Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament (1963)
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
  • J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119 (Antipas and John the Baptist)
  • BDAG s.v. εὐτόνως, κατηγορέω, ἀρχιερεύς, γραμματεύς, ἵστημι
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. εὐτόνως
  • LSJ s.v. εὔτονος
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.243, 2.316–320; Life 193–197 (plural archiereis)
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
  • I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 23:6–12
  • Harold W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas
  • Nestle-Aland 28th edition apparatus, Luke 23:10–12

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).