Mark Chapter 12 Read as one passage

Mark 12:19–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19“Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if a man’s brother dies and leaves a wife but no children, the man is to marry his brother’s widow and raise up offspring for him. 20Now there were seven brothers. The first one married and died, leaving no children. 21Then the second one married the widow, but he also died and left no children. And the third did likewise. 22In this way, none of the seven left any children. And last of all, the woman died. 23In the resurrection, then, whose wife will she be? For all seven were married to her.”

What the first hearers heard

To the crowd in the Temple courts, and to Mark's later readers, this verse was a familiar point of Torah. Everyone knew the duty of a brother-in-law to give a childless dead man a line. The Sadducees state it correctly and with appropriate respect ("Teacher", "Moses wrote").

What the hearers would catch is the set-up. A group known to deny resurrection opens with a law whose whole purpose is to keep a dead man going without resurrection: through a son, a name and a plot of land. The verb "raise up" (from the same root as "resurrection") makes the contrast audible. In the Sadducees' world a man "rises" only through his offspring. They mean to show next (vv. 20–23) that bodily resurrection would make nonsense of Moses' law: one woman, seven legal husbands. Jesus' reply (vv. 24–27) turns the tables. They know neither the Scriptures nor the power of God, because resurrection life is not a continuation of marriage, and God is "the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob", the God of the living. Their own appeal to Moses is answered from Moses (Exodus 3:6).

For a Jewish audience the verse also brought up concrete concerns: a widow's security, the survival of a family's land, and the shame of a family line being cut off.

From the study of Mark 12:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19“Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if a man’s brother dies and leaves a wife but no children, the man is to marry his brother’s widow and raise up offspring for him.

    "Teacher" (the respectful title for a recognised interpreter of the Law), "Moses put it in writing, for us, the people of Israel: if any man's brother dies and leaves a wife behind but leaves no child at all, then the surviving brother is to marry that widow and raise up a line of descendants for his dead brother. The child born would legally count as the dead man's heir, carrying his name and holding his share of the family land, so that he is not wiped out of Israel."

    Three things sit under the surface. First, the speakers are Sadducees, who denied the resurrection (v. 18) and accepted only what was written. So they lean on "Moses wrote". Second, the word for "raise up" seed comes from the same root as "resurrection" (anastasis). For the Sadducees, the only way a dead man "rises" is through a son born in his name. Third, the law they cite really exists (Deuteronomy 25:5–6, with wording that echoes Genesis 38:8). It is set up as the premise of an absurd case, seven brothers and one wife, meant to make bodily resurrection look ridiculous by Moses' own rules.

    Full study →
  2. 20Now there were seven brothers. The first one married and died, leaving no children.

    "Suppose there were seven brothers. The eldest took a wife, and when he died he left behind no offspring: no son to carry on his name and inheritance in Israel."

    That is the Sadducees' scenario in full. Each detail is chosen to meet the exact terms of the law they have just cited (Deut 25:5–6, with wording from Gen 38:8). The men are real brothers. The woman is a lawful wife. The man dies with no heir. So the duty of "raising up seed" for him passes to the next brother. The number seven tells the listener at the start that the law will be applied over and over, all the way to its end. Mark's bare chain of "and… and…" makes the deaths read like a ledger. For these hearers, "seed" did not just mean "kids". It meant the line through which a dead man's name and his share of the land lived on. In the Sadducees' view, that was the only future the Torah promised a man. The story is built to make bodily resurrection look absurd: whose wife will she be?

    Full study →
  3. 21Then the second one married the widow, but he also died and left no children. And the third did likewise.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 22In this way, none of the seven left any children. And last of all, the woman died.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  5. 23In the resurrection, then, whose wife will she be? For all seven were married to her.”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    Master (KJV)

    didaskale

    What we hear
    Lord, owner, someone in command.
    What they heard
    Teacher. It is the Greek equivalent of 'Rabbi', a respected expounder of the Law.
  • in v19

    raise up offspring / raise up seed

    exanastēsē sperma

    What we hear
    Bring up or rear children.
    What they heard
    Produce and establish a descendant who legally counts as the dead brother's heir, keeping his name and land alive in Israel. The verb shares its root with 'resurrection' in v. 18.
  • in v19, v20

    seed (KJV, YLT)

    sperma

    What we hear
    Plant seed, or a biological or sexual term.
    What they heard
    Offspring, descendants, a family line (Hebrew zeraʿ).
Every word
  1. διδάσκαλε

    didaskale · G1320

    teacher · v19

    Addressed directly to Jesus ('O Teacher'). It is the standard polite title for a recognised expounder of the Law, much like 'Rabbi'. Here it opens a trap question: they are asking him to rule on a point of Torah.

  2. Μωϋσῆς

    Mōusēs · G3475

    Moses · v19

    Named as the author of the written Law. The Sadducees appeal to Moses because they treated only written Torah as binding, and so they put the most authoritative name possible on their premise.

  3. ἔγραψεν

    egrapsen · G1125

    wrote · v19

    'Wrote', not 'said'. The stress on writing fits the Sadducean refusal of unwritten tradition: their case rests on the text itself.

  4. ἡμῖν

    hēmin · G3165

    for us / to us · v19

    'For us', meaning Israel, the people to whom the Law was given. It presents the levirate law as binding instruction for the community, Jesus included.

  5. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754G

    that · v19

    Introduces the content of what Moses wrote. It works almost like an opening quotation mark, though what follows is a paraphrase and not an exact quotation.

  6. ἐάν

    ean · G1437

    if · v19

    Opens a case-law condition ('if such-and-such happens…'), the typical shape of the laws in Deuteronomy.

  7. τινος

    tinos · G5100

    of someone / anyone's · v19

    'Anyone's brother'. The law is general and applies to any Israelite family.

  8. ἀδελφὸς

    adelphos · G0080

    brother · v19, v20

    A literal blood brother. Deuteronomy 25:5 specifies brothers 'dwelling together', meaning on the shared family land.

  9. ἀποθάνῃ

    apothanē · G0599

    die · v19, v20

    Physical death. In the Sadducees' framing, death is where a man's own existence ends. Only his name and line can go on.

  10. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v19, v20

    Links the conditions of the case.

  11. καταλίπῃ

    katalipē · G2641

    leave behind · v19

    'Leaves behind' a wife. She survives him, a widow tied to his household and his land.

  12. γυναῖκα

    gynaika · G1135H

    woman, wife · v19, v20

    'Wife'. Greek uses one word for 'woman' and 'wife', and context decides. Here it is the dead man's wife.

  13. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v19

    The usual negative inside an 'if' clause.

  14. ἀφῇ

    aphē · G0863G

    leave, let go · v19, v20

    'Leaves' no child. It is the same verb used elsewhere for 'forgive' or 'release', but here it plainly means to leave behind at death.

  15. τέκνον

    teknon · G5043

    child · v19

    'A child'. Deuteronomy's Hebrew says 'son' (ben), but Mark's broader 'child' matches how later Jewish law read it: any child, son or daughter, ended the obligation.

  16. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    that, in order that · v19

    Here it does not mean 'in order that'. It carries the command itself: '(Moses wrote) that the brother is to take…'. The sentence shifts structure midway, as natural speech does.

  17. λάβῃ

    labē · G2983

    take · v19, v20

    'Take (as wife)'. 'Take a woman' is the ordinary Hebrew and Greek idiom for marrying. It is not a word for seizure.

  18. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v19, v20

    Definite article: 'the' (surviving) brother.

  19. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G0846

    his · v19

    'His brother', the dead man's brother.

  20. ἐξαναστήσῃ

    exanastēsē · G1817

    raise up · v19

    'Raise up', in the sense of produce or establish a descendant. It is not 'bring up' a child. The verb comes from the same root as anastasis, 'resurrection', in v. 18. The only 'raising up' the Sadducees allow for a dead man is a son born in his name.

  21. σπέρμα

    sperma · G4690G

    seed, offspring · v19, v20

    'Seed' means offspring, a descendant, a family line. That line carries on the dead man's name and inheritance in Israel.

  22. ἑπτὰ

    hepta · G2033

    seven · v20

    Comes first in the sentence for emphasis. Seven is the number of fullness in Jewish storytelling, so the case runs the levirate law all the way to the end and turns it into a joke.

  23. ἦσαν

    ēsan · G1510

    were · v20

    An imperfect, 'there were', that opens a story the way a teacher sets up a case: 'Suppose there were…'. The Sadducees present it as having happened 'among us' (compare Matt 22:25), but it works as a made-up test case.

  24. πρῶτος

    prōtos · G4413

    first · v20

    First in a sequence, most naturally the eldest. In Israelite inheritance the firstborn's line was the main line, so his dying without an heir is the most serious loss of all.

  25. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v20

    Plain negation of a fact: he did not leave offspring.

The world behind it

Levirate marriage. The custom gets its name from Latin levir, "husband's brother", and in Hebrew it is yibbum. It is laid down in Deuteronomy 25:5–10 and appears in the stories of Tamar (Genesis 38) and Ruth (Ruth 4:5, 10). If a man died without a son, his brother married the widow, and the firstborn son of that union counted as the dead man's son. This did several things in an Israelite world built on family land:

  • it kept the dead man's name from being "blotted out of Israel" (Deuteronomy 25:6);
  • it kept his inheritance within the clan;
  • it gave the widow, who had no son to support her, a place and protection in her husband's household.

A brother who refused had to go through a public shaming ceremony, ḥalitzah: the widow pulled off his sandal and spat in his face (Deuteronomy 25:7–10). Josephus describes the law in the 1st century (Antiquities 4.254–256), and the Mishnah gives it a whole tractate (Yevamot). So it was a live legal topic in Jesus' day, though how often it was actually carried out is uncertain.

The Sadducees. They were a priestly and aristocratic party tied to the Jerusalem Temple leadership. Josephus says they rejected the Pharisees' traditions that were "not written in the laws of Moses" (Antiquities 13.297), and that they believed souls perish with the body (Antiquities 18.16; War 2.165). For them a man's ongoing presence in Israel came through his descendants and his name, which is exactly what the levirate law protects. Their question comes in Mark 11–12, a run of public challenges in the Temple courts during Jesus' last week (from chief priests, Pharisees and Herodians, and now Sadducees).

A stock puzzle? The story that follows (seven brothers, one wife, v. 20) may echo the book of Tobit, where Sarah's seven husbands each die on the wedding night (Tobit 3:8). Whether or not that is a deliberate allusion, the case is plainly hypothetical. It is built to turn the Mosaic law against the idea of resurrection.

From the study of Mark 12:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

Did the Sadducees accept only the five books of Moses as Scripture?

  • Yes, they recognised only the Pentateuch as authoritative.

    Several church fathers say so (e.g. Origen, Against Celsus 1.49; Jerome on Matthew 22:31). Here and in Jesus' reply the debate is conducted entirely from Moses ('Moses wrote'; Exodus 3:6).

  • No. They rejected the Pharisees' unwritten traditions, not the Prophets and Writings.

    Josephus, the nearest contemporary witness, says only that they rejected what was 'not written in the laws of Moses' (Antiquities 13.297) and does not say they rejected the Prophets. The patristic claim may confuse them with the Samaritans. Appealing to Moses may simply be a matter of choosing the highest authority.

in v19

Was levirate marriage still actually practised in the 1st century, or is the case purely academic?

  • It was still a live legal institution.

    Josephus describes it as current law (Antiquities 4.254–256). The Mishnah devotes the tractate Yevamot to it, and the early rabbis debated whether carrying it out or releasing the brother (ḥalitzah) was preferable.

  • It was rarely practised, and the Sadducees' case is a deliberately artificial scholastic puzzle.

    The seven-brothers scenario is absurd on its face and may echo Tobit 3:8. Some early rabbinic voices already favoured ḥalitzah over marriage (e.g. Mishnah Bekhorot 1:7), which suggests the marriage itself was becoming uncommon.

in v20

Is the seven-brothers scenario a deliberate allusion to earlier Jewish stories?

  • It echoes Tobit (Sarah's seven husbands who died).

    Tob 3:8; 6:14; 7:11 have a woman whose seven husbands die, followed by marriage to a near kinsman under family-marriage obligation. The overlap in number and theme is close.

  • It parodies 2 Maccabees 7, the seven martyred brothers who hoped for resurrection.

    Seven brothers and the hope of resurrection are both central to 2 Macc 7. A Sadducee might take the Pharisees' favourite martyr story and turn it into a reductio. The link is suggestive, but there is no shared wording.

  • Seven is simply the conventional number for completeness, and no particular text is in view.

    Seven appears as a stock number throughout Jewish storytelling. The argument works without any allusion. Many commentators remain cautious.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἐξανίστημι, σπέρμα, διδάσκαλος, λαμβάνω
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἐξανίστημι
  • Septuagint: Deuteronomy 25:5–10; Genesis 38:8–9; Ruth 4:5, 10
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.254–256; 13.297; 18.16; Jewish War 2.164–165
  • Mishnah, tractate Yevamot; Mishnah Bekhorot 1:7; Babylonian Talmud Bava Batra 109a
  • Tobit 3:7–8
  • Origen, Against Celsus 1.49
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 12:18–27
  • BDAG s.v. σπέρμα, ἀφίημι, λαμβάνω
  • Septuagint, Gen 38:8; Deut 25:5–6
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.164–166; Antiquities 18.16
  • Mishnah, tractate Yevamot
  • Tobit 3:8; 6:14; 2 Maccabees 7
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 12:20

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

3 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.