Nehemiah Chapter 12 Read as one passage

Nehemiah 12:38–39

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

38The second thanksgiving choir proceeded to the left, and I followed it with half the people along the top of the wall, past the Tower of the Ovens to the Broad Wall, 39over the Gate of Ephraim, the Jeshanah Gate, the Fish Gate, the Tower of Hananel, and the Tower of the Hundred, as far as the Sheep Gate. And they stopped at the Gate of the Guard.

What the first hearers heard

To the people of Judah who had just finished the wall, this verse belonged to the climax of their story. It was the day the work of shame and danger ("the wall of Jerusalem is broken down," 1:3) became a day of joy "heard far away" (12:43). Several things would have struck them:

  • The whole community took part. Half of the people walked on each side. No section of the wall, and no group of families who built it, was left out.
  • The leader followed the singers. Nehemiah, the Persian-appointed governor, put the thanksgiving choir in front and walked behind it. His memoir records this as the right order: the praise of God went first.
  • The mockery was answered. Enemies had mocked the wall as flimsy (4:3). Now crowds walked along the top of it, singing.
  • A sacred perimeter. After the purification of 12:30, walking the full circuit marked out the city as holy ground around the temple, where both processions ended in sacrifice and rejoicing (12:40–43).
  • Familiar places. Naming the Tower of the Ovens and the Broad Wall tied the celebration to specific sections that particular families had rebuilt in chapter 3. It was their own work being dedicated.

From the study of Nehemiah 12:38.

Verse by verse

  1. 38The second thanksgiving choir proceeded to the left, and I followed it with half the people along the top of the wall, past the Tower of the Ovens to the Broad Wall,

    "Then the second thanksgiving, the second choir whose very name was 'Thanks', set off the other way round the city, to the left. I came walking behind it, together with half of the people. We went along the top of the wall itself, past the Tower of the Ovens, as far as the Broad Wall."

    Nehemiah is describing a ceremony he organised himself. Two large choirs, each followed by half of the community, climbed onto the newly finished wall and walked around Jerusalem in opposite directions, singing. The Hebrew calls each choir simply "a thanksgiving": the people are the thanks. Ezra led the first choir (12:36). The governor himself walked behind the second. The route went over the wall's own towers and stretches, the same wall enemies had mocked as too weak to hold a fox (4:3). It passed the Tower of the Ovens, which was probably named for the bread ovens nearby, and the Broad Wall, a famous old thick stretch. The scene shows the whole circuit walked, sung over and claimed as God's, before the two halves of the people met again at the temple (12:40).

    Full study →
  2. 39over the Gate of Ephraim, the Jeshanah Gate, the Fish Gate, the Tower of Hananel, and the Tower of the Hundred, as far as the Sheep Gate. And they stopped at the Gate of the Guard.

    This verse continues the route of the second thanksgiving choir, the one Nehemiah himself followed with half the people (v.38). It is laid out like a guided walk along the top of the rebuilt wall. Moving along the northern side, the marchers passed above the Ephraim Gate, which faced north toward the old tribal lands. Next came the gate called "the Old" (or the Jeshanah gate), then the Fish Gate where traders brought fish up from the coast. Then they passed the two towers that guarded the city's most exposed side: Hananel's Tower ("God has been gracious") and the Hundred Tower. They went all the way to the Sheep Gate beside the temple, where flocks came in for sacrifice. There the procession came to a halt and took its position at the Gate of the Guard, a guarded entrance at the edge of the temple area. From there both choirs went on to stand together in the house of God (v.40).

    To the first hearers the list was more than geography. Every name was a familiar place: where you bought fish, where sacrificial animals came in, which tower was named after whom. A few years earlier much of this had been rubble. Now a singing crowd could walk across the top of it all, naming it piece by piece. This was a public declaration that the city was whole again and was being handed back to God with thanks.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v38

    the tower of the furnaces (KJV, WEB)

    migdal ha-tannurim

    What we hear
    A tower beside an industrial furnace: metal smelting, kilns or a heating plant.
    What they heard
    The 'Tower of the Ovens': a tannur was a clay bread oven. The name probably came from bakers' ovens in that part of the city.
  • in v38

    went over against [them] (KJV)

    le-mo'l (mul)

    What we hear
    Went against them, as if in opposition or confrontation.
    What they heard
    Went toward the opposite side: the second choir circled the city the other way from the first. There was no conflict.
  • in v39

    prison gate (KJV, YLT)

    šaʿar hammaṭṭārâ

    What we hear
    A gate attached to a jail, where prisoners were kept.
    What they heard
    "Gate of the guard/watch": a guarded gate or guard-post, here at the temple's edge.
  • in v39

    tower of Meah (KJV, YLT); tower of Hammeah (WEB)

    migdal hammēʾâ

    What we hear
    A tower named after a person or place called Meah.
    What they heard
    "The Tower of the Hundred." Hebrew speakers heard the ordinary number word.
Every word
  1. וְהַתּוֹדָה

    veha-todah · H8426

    thanksgiving; thanksgiving choir · v38

    Literally 'and the thanksgiving', but here it means the group doing the thanking: a choir and procession giving thanks. Nehemiah names the group by what it does, as in 12:31, where he set up 'two great thanksgivings'.

  2. הַשֵּׁנִית

    ha-shenit · H8145

    second · v38

    Feminine, agreeing with todah. This is the second of the two choirs from 12:31. The first one went with Ezra (12:36).

  3. הַהוֹלֶכֶת

    ha-holekhet · H1980

    walk, go · v38

    A participle with the article, 'the one that was going'. It pictures the choir in motion rather than simply reporting that it left.

  4. לְמוֹאל

    le-mo'l · H4136

    in front of, opposite · v38

    As written, 'toward the opposite (side)': the second choir went the other way round from the first. The spelling is unusual, and many scholars correct it to 'to the left' to pair with 'to the right' in 12:31. Either way, the two choirs set off in opposite directions.

  5. וַאֲנִי

    va'ani · H589

    and I · v38

    Nehemiah speaks for himself. This is his own first-person memoir, which resumes at 12:31. The governor places himself in the procession.

  6. אַחֲרֶיהָ

    achareha · H310

    after, behind · v38

    'Behind her', meaning behind the choir. Nehemiah walks after the singers, just as Hoshaiah and half the leaders of Judah walked behind the first choir (12:32).

  7. וַחֲצִי

    va-chatsi · H2677

    half · v38

    'And half of'. The assembly is split evenly between the two processions, so that both halves of the community are represented on each side of the city.

  8. הָעָם

    ha-'am · H5971

    people · v38

    The gathered community of Judah. Verse 40 suggests that leading men ('the officials') are especially in view.

  9. מֵעַל

    me'al · H5921

    from upon, above · v38, v39

    Together with the following 'to the wall', this gives 'on top of the wall'. The procession walks along the top of the wall itself.

  10. לְהַחוֹמָה

    la-chomah · H2346

    wall · v38

    The city wall that had just been rebuilt and dedicated. Walking on it in public showed that it was finished, solid and consecrated.

  11. לְמִגְדַּל

    le-migdal · H4026

    tower · v38, v39

    A defensive tower built into the wall. The procession passes over or beside it.

  12. הַתַּנּוּרִים

    ha-tannurim · H8574

    ovens · v38

    'Of the ovens'. A tannur was the ordinary clay oven for baking bread. The tower was probably named after bakers' ovens nearby. It was one of the sections repaired in 3:11.

  13. וְעַד

    ve-'ad · H5704

    as far as, until · v38, v39

    'And as far as'. It marks the next landmark on the route.

  14. הָרְחָבָה

    ha-rechavah · H7342

    broad, wide · v38

    'The broad (one)': the Broad Wall, a known stretch of the wall that was unusually thick, mentioned in 3:8.

  15. לְשַׁעַר־

    ləšaʿar · H8179

    to the gate of · v39

    The first gate named on the northern stretch of the route. The preposition "to" goes with the "from over" before it to mean "over the gate of."

  16. אֶפְרַיִם

    ʾeprayim · H669

    Ephraim · v39

    The gate takes its name from the direction it faced: north, toward the old tribal lands of Ephraim. It is named in 2 Kings 14:13 and Nehemiah 8:16, but not in the repair list of Nehemiah 3.

  17. הַיְשָׁנָה

    hayšānâ · H3466

    the old / Jeshanah · v39

    The word literally means "the old (one)." It is grammatically feminine, so it does not simply describe the gate, which is masculine. That is why it is read as "gate of the old (city or quarter)," as a place name (Jeshanah), or as a copying slip. See Debates.

  18. הַדָּגִים

    haddāgîm · H1709

    the fish · v39

    "The fish (plural)." The name probably comes from the fish market. Fish was brought up from the coast, and Nehemiah 13:16 mentions men of Tyre selling fish in Jerusalem.

  19. חֲנַנְאֵל

    ḥănanʾēl · H2606

    Hananel · v39

    A personal name, "God has been gracious," probably the man who built the tower or gave it its name. The tower was a well-known landmark at the city's northern edge (Jeremiah 31:38; Zechariah 14:10).

  20. הַמֵּאָה

    hammēʾâ · H3968

    the Hundred · v39

    This is the ordinary word for the number "hundred," with "the" in front, used as a name. Hebrew readers heard "the Hundred Tower," not a foreign-sounding name like "Meah." No one knows why it was called that.

  21. הַצֹּאן

    haṣṣōʾn · H6629

    the sheep / flock · v39

    "The flock": sheep and goats together. The gate was probably named for animals brought in for the temple sacrifices. The priests rebuilt it first (Nehemiah 3:1).

  22. וְעָמְדוּ

    wəʿāmədû · H5975

    and they stood / halted · v39

    "And they came to a stop and took their position." The moving procession halts and stands as a group, ready to enter the temple courts (v.40).

  23. הַמַּטָּרָה

    hammaṭṭārâ · H4307

    the guard / watch · v39

    From a root meaning "to keep, guard." It names a guard-post or watch station. It is the word behind the "court of the guard" where Jeremiah was held, which is why the KJV says "prison." Here it is a gate near the temple, probably where a guard was stationed.

The world behind it

The dedication of the wall (around 445 BC or shortly after). Nehemiah was a Jewish official at the Persian court who had been appointed governor of Judah. He rebuilt Jerusalem's ruined wall in 52 days (6:15). Chapter 12:27–43 describes its formal dedication:

  • Purification first. Priests and Levites purified themselves, the people, the gates and the wall (12:30). The wall was treated as something set apart for God, not just as a defence.
  • Two processions. From a starting point on the western side, probably near the Valley Gate (2:13; 3:13), one choir went to the right (south and then east): the Dung Gate, the Fountain Gate, the steps of the City of David, the Water Gate. The other, in this verse, went to the left (north): the Tower of the Ovens, the Broad Wall, the Ephraim Gate, the Old Gate, the Fish Gate, the Towers of Hananel and of the Hundred, the Sheep Gate, and the Gate of the Guard (12:39). Between them they covered the whole circuit and met at the temple.
  • Walking on top. Ancient city walls had a walkway along the top for defenders, wide enough for people to walk in a line. Using it for a procession was a public display that the work was solid and finished.
  • Circling the city. Psalm 48:12–13 invites worshippers to "walk about Zion... count her towers... consider her ramparts" so they can tell the next generation. Nehemiah's procession acts this out in a literal way.
  • The landmarks. The Tower of the Ovens and the Broad Wall both appear in the building list of chapter 3 (3:8, 11). Many readers of the time would have known the families who repaired those sections.

From the study of Nehemiah 12:38.

Where scholars differ

in v38

Does the second choir go 'to the left' or 'in the opposite direction'?

  • Correct the text to 'to the left' (lismo'l).

    It matches 'to the right' in 12:31. The consonants are similar. The received spelling with aleph is unique and looks damaged. Many modern commentators (e.g. Williamson) and the BSB and NASB take this view.

  • Keep the received text: 'toward the opposite side' (le-mul).

    It is the written Hebrew. It makes good sense without correction, since the choir went the other way round. It is supported by the Vulgate's ex adverso and by renderings such as KJV, YLT and NIV. An aleph used as a spelling aid occurs elsewhere in late biblical Hebrew.

in v38

Is Nehemiah's 'Broad Wall' the massive wall Avigad excavated in the Jewish Quarter?

  • Yes, or at least the name comes from it.

    Avigad found a wall about 7 m thick from Hezekiah's time (late 8th century BC). It is the kind of wall that would be called 'broad', and its line could fit the northwest part of the route.

  • Probably not the same line in Nehemiah's day.

    Archaeological finds suggest Persian-period Jerusalem was small, limited to the City of David ridge and the temple area. On that view Nehemiah's wall did not take in the Western Hill, so his 'Broad Wall' was either a different stretch or only a remnant reused near the old line. Scholars still dispute the extent of Nehemiah's circuit.

in v38

Where did the two processions start?

  • At or near the Valley Gate on the west.

    The first choir's route (Dung Gate, Fountain Gate) and the second's (Tower of the Ovens, Broad Wall) both lead away from the area of the Valley Gate. It was also where Nehemiah's night inspection began (2:13).

  • The text does not name the starting point.

    Verse 31 says only that they went 'up onto the wall'. Any starting point is worked out from the route, and the locations of several landmarks are themselves uncertain.

in v39

What is the "Jeshanah" (yəšānâ) gate?

  • "Gate of the old (city or quarter)": translate it as "Old Gate."

    yəšānâ is the ordinary feminine form of "old." A feminine noun such as "city" may be implied. KJV, NASB and the Vulgate translate it this way.

  • A gate named for the town of Jeshanah, where its road led.

    Jeshanah was a town north of Jerusalem (2 Chronicles 13:19), and gates were commonly named for where their roads led (the Ephraim Gate). This explains the grammar.

  • A copying error for "the Mishneh (Second Quarter) Gate."

    The Mishneh was a newer northwestern quarter of Jerusalem (2 Kings 22:14; Zephaniah 1:10). The emendation fixes the grammar, but no manuscript supports it.

in v39

Where was the Gate of the Guard?

  • A gate on the north side of the temple area, perhaps the same as the Muster or Inspection Gate (Nehemiah 3:31).

    The procession stops there just before entering the temple (v.40). In the repair list of chapter 3 the Inspection Gate is near the Sheep Gate.

  • A gate tied to the royal "court of the guard" (Nehemiah 3:25; Jeremiah 32:2).

    It uses the same word. Against this, that court lay south of the temple, near the old palace, which fits the northern route badly.

in v39

How large was Nehemiah's Jerusalem, and so how long was this route?

  • A small city on the eastern ridge only (the City of David and the temple mount).

    Excavations have found little Persian-period occupation on the western hill (argued by Ussishkin and Finkelstein). That would make the circuit short.

  • A larger circuit that took in part of the western hill.

    The Broad Wall (v.38) and gates such as the Ephraim and Jeshanah Gates are sometimes placed on the western hill, where Avigad found the Broad Wall of the 8th century BCE.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. תּוֹדָה, מוּל, תַּנּוּר, רָחָב
  • HALOT s.v. מוּל, תּוֹדָה, תַּנּוּר
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
  • F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
  • N. Avigad, Discovering Jerusalem (1983), on the 'Broad Wall'
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Neh 12:27–43
  • Vulgate, Nehemiah (2 Esdras) 12:38
  • BDB s.v. מַטָּרָה, יָשָׁן, מֵאָה
  • HALOT s.v. מַטָּרָה, יְשָׁנָה
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library, 1988)
  • F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT, 1982)
  • D. Ussishkin, "The Borders and De Facto Size of Jerusalem in the Persian Period" (2006)
  • N. Avigad, Discovering Jerusalem (1983)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).