Nehemiah Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Nehemiah 9:15–17
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15In their hunger You gave them bread from heaven; in their thirst You brought them water from the rock. You told them to go in and possess the land that You had sworn to give them. 16But they and our fathers became arrogant and stiff-necked and did not obey Your commandments. 17They refused to listen and failed to remember the wonders You performed among them. They stiffened their necks and appointed a leader to return them to their bondage in Egypt. But You are a forgiving God, gracious and compassionate, slow to anger and rich in loving devotion, and You did not forsake them.
What the first hearers heard
For the community gathered in Persian-period Jerusalem, this verse was part of a shared act of remembering. It is also an argument addressed to God.
- Proof of God's character. The manna and the water from the rock were the classic evidence that Israel's God provides for his people when there is no natural way to survive. To the returned exiles, a small and struggling community, these stories said that God had kept a helpless people alive before.
- The basis for the land. By tying the land to God's raised-hand oath, the prayer reminds everyone that Israel's claim to the land rests on God's promise, not on Persian permission. That matters to people living there as tribute-paying subjects (9:36–37).
- A foil for confession. Listing God's gifts makes the next confession land harder: "But they and our fathers became arrogant" (9:16). The point is not to blame only the ancestors. The prayer moves from "they" to "we" ("we have acted wickedly", 9:33) and leads to the written pledge of Nehemiah 10, where the community commits to keep the Torah.
- Hope from the pattern. Because God kept giving manna and water even after the rebellion (9:19–21), the prayer implies he might again show mercy to a generation that confesses.
From the study of Nehemiah 9:15.
Verse by verse
-
15In their hunger You gave them bread from heaven; in their thirst You brought them water from the rock. You told them to go in and possess the land that You had sworn to give them.
Full study →"And food, out of the sky, from God's own realm, you gave them when they were starving; and water, out of a bare cliff of rock, you brought out for them when they were parched. And you told them to go in and take over the land that you had raised your hand in oath to give them."
The people are speaking straight to God, and every verb is "you". The gifts come first in each line ("bread from heaven you gave… water from a crag you brought out"), so the hearer's attention goes to what God provided. Each gift matches a need: hunger, then thirst. "Bread" (lechem) means food in the broad sense: the daily manna that kept a whole people alive in the desert. "From heaven" means it came down out of the sky like dew, and so from God. It says nothing about the afterlife. The water came "from a crag", out of stone in the desert, and "brought out" is the same verb Israel used for being brought out of Egypt.
The verse begins with God giving and ends with God's oath to give. Between those two the people are told to "go in and take possession", the language of Deuteronomy for entering Canaan. The phrase "you lifted your hand" pictures God raising a hand to swear, the way a person takes a solemn oath. "To them" comes four times. The prayer is piling up everything that was done for them before the next verse turns: "But they and our fathers became arrogant…" (9:16).
-
16But they and our fathers became arrogant and stiff-necked and did not obey Your commandments.
Full study →"But they — our own fathers — boiled over in insolent defiance, deliberately locked their necks like an ox that will not be turned, and would not hear (and so would not obey) your commandments."
The verse begins with an emphatic "But they". It reverses everything said just before. Verses 9–15 have listed what God did: he saw their misery in Egypt, split the sea, led them by cloud and fire, spoke to them from Sinai, gave them good laws, fed them bread from heaven and water from the rock, and told them to go in and take the land. The first verb, hezidu, comes from a root meaning "to boil over". It is the legal word for wilful, high-handed wrongdoing, and only six verses earlier it described the Egyptians' insolence toward Israel. The charge is that the freed slaves treated their Liberator the way their slave-masters had treated them. "Stiffened their neck" pictures a draft animal tensing against the driver's rope. These are the words God used in Exodus after the golden calf, and the causative verb ("they made it hard") makes the stubbornness their own choice. Last, "they did not hear" uses the Hebrew word that covers both hearing and obeying. They had heard God's voice from heaven (v. 13). What they refused was the hearing that turns into action.
The people praying say "our fathers". They are not condemning strangers. They are owning their family's record.
-
17They refused to listen and failed to remember the wonders You performed among them. They stiffened their necks and appointed a leader to return them to their bondage in Egypt. But You are a forgiving God, gracious and compassionate, slow to anger and rich in loving devotion, and You did not forsake them.
Full study →They flatly refused to hear you, and hearing you would have meant obeying. They knew about the wonders you had worked in their company, the plagues, the sea, the cloud, the bread from heaven and the water from the rock, but those memories did not shape how they lived. Like an ox bracing its neck against the yoke, they hardened themselves against being led. They even set up a new head for themselves to take them back to their slavery: such was their rebellion that they would rather be slaves in Egypt than follow you. But you, you are a God of pardons, of forgiveness given again and again. You freely show favour to people who have no claim on it. You feel a tender, parent-like compassion. You are "long of nostrils": your anger is slow to flare. You are abundant in loyal, committed love that keeps faith when the other side has broken it. And so you did not walk away from them.
The verse turns on "but you." It sets what the people did against who God is. The list of God's qualities is the famous description he gave of himself at Sinai after the golden calf (Exodus 34:6). The prayer adds "a God of pardons," which recalls God's words after the "let us appoint a leader and go back to Egypt" rebellion: "I have pardoned" (Numbers 14:20).
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
heaven
shamayim
- What we hear
- The afterlife paradise where believers go when they die.
- What they heard
- The sky above, where dew and rain come from. It is also pictured as the realm of God's throne. Here it means the manna came down out of the sky, sent by God.
-
in v15
bread
lechem
- What we hear
- Loaves of baked bread, as if loaves fell from the sky.
- What they heard
- Food, the staple that keeps people alive. The manna was a flaky substance gathered each morning, then ground or pounded and boiled or baked into cakes.
-
in v16
dealt proudly / became arrogant
hezidu (zid)
- What we hear
- An inner attitude or personality flaw: conceit, feeling superior, a big ego.
- What they heard
- Deliberate, high-handed defiance of a rightful authority, a wilful 'boiling over' of the boundary. In Torah law it separates deliberate wrongdoing from accidental, and here it is the same verb used of Egypt's insolence toward Israel (v. 10).
-
in v17
kindness (KJV); love (NIV)
khesed
- What we hear
- General niceness, warmth or affection.
- What they heard
- Loyal love that keeps faith with a relationship and carries an obligation, shown especially to a partner who has broken faith.
-
in v17
a forgiving God / ready to pardon
Eloah selikhot
- What we hear
- Forgiveness as letting go of resentment, something anyone can do.
- What they heard
- A God marked by repeated acts of pardon. The verb behind it (salakh) is used only of God in the Hebrew Bible: it is a sovereign act that releases guilt and keeps the relationship going.
Every word
-
וְ֠לֶחֶם
ve-lechem · H3899
and bread, food · v15
The manna. Lechem means bread, but also food or a meal in general. Putting it first in the sentence puts the gift itself in the spotlight: 'and bread, from the sky, you gave.'
-
מִשָּׁמַ֜יִם
mi-shamayim · H8064
-
נָתַ֤תָּה
natattah · H5414
you gave · v15, v17
A completed act of giving, addressed straight to God ('you'). The long spelling with a final -ah is common in later Hebrew. The same verb comes back at the end of the verse ('to give'), so the whole verse is framed by God's giving.
-
לָהֶם֙
lahem · H9038
to them · v15
The first of four uses of 'to/for them' in the verse. Repeating it keeps attention on the people who received all this, setting up the sharp turn in v. 16: 'But they…'
-
לִרְעָבָ֔ם
lir'avam · H7458
for their hunger · v15
Ra'av is the usual word for famine. Here it means the people's real hunger in the desert. The 'for' gives the purpose: the bread was given to meet that hunger.
-
וּמַ֗יִם
u-mayim · H4325
and water · v15
Water is put first, matching 'bread' at the start of the first line, so the two lines run in parallel: food, then drink.
-
מִסֶּ֛לַע
mi-sela' · H5553
from a crag, cliff · v15
A cliff or rock face, the word used in the Meribah story of Numbers 20 (Exodus 17 uses tsur, 'rock'). The picture is water coming out of bare desert stone, which no one could make happen.
-
הוֹצֵ֥אתָ
hotseta · H3318
you brought out · v15
'Caused to come out.' This is the verb of the Exodus itself ('who brought you out of Egypt'), and the same prayer uses it for bringing Abram out of Ur (9:7). The God who brought Israel out also brings water out of stone.
-
לִצְמָאָ֑ם
litsma'am · H6772
for their thirst · v15
It pairs with 'for their hunger': each need is met by a matching gift.
-
וַתֹּ֣אמֶר
va-tomer · H0559
-
לָבוֹא֙
lavo · H0935
to come, to enter · v15
'To go in', meaning crossing into Canaan. The supplied gloss 'to go' is acceptable, but the Hebrew verb is the one for coming or entering.
-
לָרֶ֣שֶׁת
lareshet · H3423
to take possession of · v15
To take over and occupy land, usually by replacing those living there. Paired with 'to go in', it is the stock phrase of Deuteronomy for the conquest.
-
אֶת־
et- · H0853
[direct object marker] · v15, v16, v17
An untranslatable word that marks 'the land' as the direct object.
-
הָאָ֔רֶץ
ha-arets · H0776
-
אֲשֶׁר־
asher- · H0834
which, that · v15, v17
It introduces the description of the land: the land God had sworn to give.
-
נָשָׂ֥אתָ
nasata · H5375
you lifted · v15
Literally 'you lifted.' With 'your hand' it is the gesture of swearing an oath. The supplied tag 'vow' names what the idiom means, not what the verb itself means.
-
יָדְךָ֖
yadekha · H3027
-
וְהֵ֥ם
wehem · H1992
and they · v16
An emphatic pronoun with 'and' (here 'but'). It marks a sharp turn: after the long list of God's gifts in vv. 9–15, the subject switches to 'they', and the story of rebellion begins.
-
וַאֲבֹתֵ֖ינוּ
wa'avotenu · H1
and our fathers · v16
'Our fathers' means the ancestors, the wilderness generation. The 'and' most likely explains rather than adds: 'they, that is, our fathers'. The word 'our' ties the people praying to the guilty generation.
-
הֵזִ֑ידוּ
hezidu · H2102
acted presumptuously, insolently · v16
From a root meaning 'to boil (over)'. In this verb form it means to act with deliberate, high-handed defiance. Six verses earlier (v. 10) the same verb describes how the Egyptians treated Israel, so Israel is said to have treated God the way Pharaoh treated them.
-
וַיַּקְשׁוּ֙
wayyaqshu · H7185
and they made hard / stiffened · v16, v17
A causative form, 'they made (their neck) hard'. The hardening is something they did, not something that happened to them. The verb form continues the narrative sequence.
-
עָרְפָּ֔ם
'orpam · H6203
their neck (back of the neck) · v16, v17
The back of the neck. The picture is a draft animal locking its neck so it will not be turned by the driver's goad or rope. The idiom comes from Exodus and Deuteronomy, where God calls Israel 'a stiff-necked people'.
-
וְלֹ֥א
welo' · H3808
and not · v16, v17
Plain negation of the following verb, finishing the three-part charge.
-
שָׁמְע֖וּ
shame'u · H8085
they heard / listened / obeyed · v16, v17
Hebrew has no separate verb for 'obey'. To 'hear' a command means to take it in and act on it. So 'they did not hear' means they refused to comply, not that they failed to catch the words.
-
אֶל־
'el · H413
to, toward · v16
With 'hear' it gives 'listen to, heed'. The commandments are pictured as a voice speaking to them.
-
מִצְוֹתֶֽיךָ׃
mitswoteykha · H4687
your commandments · v16
The specific instructions God gave at Sinai, which the prayer has just praised in vv. 13–14 as 'right ordinances, true laws, good statutes and commandments'. Their refusal is aimed at gifts they had just been handed.
-
וַיְמָאֲנ֣וּ
vaymaʾanu · H3985
to refuse · v17
A firm, deliberate refusal, not a failure to understand. It opens the list of what the wilderness generation did and makes their unwillingness the first charge.
-
זָכְר֤וּ
zakhru · H2142
to remember · v17
Biblical 'remembering' means letting the past shape what you do now, not just recalling a fact. They knew about the wonders, but those wonders did not govern how they acted.
-
נִפְלְאֹתֶ֙יךָ֙
nifleʾotekha · H6381
wonders · v17
'Your wonders': acts beyond human power. In context these are the plagues, the sea crossing, the pillar of cloud, manna and water from the rock, all listed in vv.9–15.
-
עָשִׂ֣יתָ
ʿasita · H6213A
to do, make · v17
'You did.' God is the one who acted, and the prayer speaks to him directly.
-
עִמָּהֶ֔ם
ʿimmahem · H5973A
with · v17
'With them,' not merely 'for them' or 'in front of them.' The wonders were acts done in their company, as part of the relationship.
-
רֹ֛אשׁ
rosh · H7218H
head, leader · v17
'A head,' meaning a leader to replace Moses. The wording repeats Numbers 14:4 almost exactly.
-
לָשׁ֥וּב
lashuv · H7725G
to return, turn back · v17
'To go back.' The same verb is used elsewhere for turning back to God in repentance; here it describes going the wrong way, back to Egypt.
-
לְעַבְדֻתָ֖ם
leʿavdutam · H5659
slavery, servitude · v17
'To their slavery': going back to Egyptian forced labour. It anticipates the prayer's end, where the speakers say 'we are slaves today' under Persian kings (9:36).
-
בְּמִרְיָ֑ם
bemiryam · H4805H
rebellion · v17
'In their rebellion,' meaning defiant resistance to authority. The Greek translation read 'in Egypt' here instead (see textual notes).
-
וְאַתָּה֩
veʾattah · H0859A
you · v17
'But you.' The pronoun is emphatic, and this is where the verse turns: the people's actions on one side, God's character on the other.
-
אֱל֨וֹהַּ
ʾEloah · H0433
God · v17
The rare singular form of the word for God, used mostly in poetry and late books. It is linked to the next word: 'a God of…'.
-
סְלִיח֜וֹת
selikhot · H5547
forgiveness, pardon · v17
'Of forgivenesses': the word is plural, suggesting repeated, abundant pardons. Together with the previous word it means 'a God characterised by pardoning,' the God who forgave after the episode in Numbers 14 (Num 14:20, 'I have pardoned').
-
חַנּ֧וּן
khannun · H2587
gracious · v17
Disposed to show favour freely, to someone who has no claim on it. In the Hebrew Bible this adjective is used almost only of God.
-
וְרַח֛וּם
verakhum · H7349
compassionate · v17
Related to rekhem, 'womb': tender, deep-felt compassion, like a parent's for a child.
-
אֶֽרֶךְ־
ʾerekh- · H0750
long · v17
'Long of…'. The first half of the idiom 'long of nostrils.'
-
אַפַּ֥יִם
ʾappayim · H0639G
nostrils; anger · v17
'Nostrils' (a dual form, meaning two of something), standing for anger, which was pictured as hot breath from the nose. 'Long of nostrils' means God's anger takes a long time to flare up: he is patient.
-
וְרַב־
verav- · H7227A
great, abundant · v17
'And great in / abundant in.'
-
חֶ֖סֶד
khesed · H2617A
covenant loyalty, steadfast love · v17
Loyal, committed love that keeps faith with a relationship, especially when the other side has failed. It is the key quality here: God stays loyal to a people who broke faith.
-
עֲזַבְתָּֽם׃
ʿazavtam · H5800A
to forsake, abandon · v17
'You did not abandon them,' meaning leave them on their own. Verse 19 repeats it: 'in your great compassion you did not abandon them in the wilderness.'
The world behind it
When and where this prayer is spoken. Nehemiah 9 records a day of fasting and confession on the 24th of the seventh month, probably in the mid-5th century BC. Judah was then a small province of the Persian Empire and Jerusalem's walls had just been rebuilt (Neh 6:15). Levites lead a long prayer that retells Israel's history: creation, Abraham, the Exodus, Sinai, the wilderness, the conquest, the judges and kings, and the exile. It ends with a sharp admission: "Here we are, slaves today, in the land you gave our fathers" (9:36).
Fresh memories of the wilderness. The assembly comes right after the people have kept the Festival of Booths (Sukkot) for the first time in generations (Neh 8:14–17). For a week they had lived in temporary shelters to remember the wilderness years. Manna, water from the rock and the march toward the promised land were on their minds.
The edge of the land oath. Recalling that God had "lifted his hand" to give them the land was not just nostalgia. Those praying were back in that land, but its harvests went in tribute to foreign kings (9:37). Reciting the oath reminded God and themselves of a promise that, as they saw it, had not yet been fully restored.
How the prayer is built. Prayers that retell history (compare Psalms 78, 105, 106) set God's repeated generosity against Israel's repeated failure. Verse 15 is the high point of the generosity before the failure in vv. 16–18. After the rebellion the prayer repeats the same gifts on purpose (vv. 20–21: "you did not withhold your manna… and gave them water for their thirst"). God kept providing even after the golden calf.
From the study of Nehemiah 9:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
What does the crowd quote in John 6:31, 'He gave them bread from heaven to eat'?
-
Mainly Psalm 78:24.
The Greek of Ps 77:24 (Septuagint numbering) has 'bread of heaven he gave them', with 'to eat' in the same verse. This is the classic identification (e.g. Borgen, Bread from Heaven).
-
Exodus 16:4, 15, perhaps mixed with the Psalm.
Exodus has 'bread from the heavens' and 'the bread the LORD has given you to eat', and John 6 is built around the manna story.
-
Nehemiah 9:15 is a real contributing source.
Greek Neh 9:15 has 'bread from heaven you gave them', closer to John's 'from heaven' than the Psalm's 'of heaven'. Some scholars (e.g. Menken) argue that John blends several passages. In any case the phrase was a shared formula, so certainty is not possible.
in v15
Is 'you said to them to go in to possess' a command or a promise?
-
A command or commission.
'Go in to possess' is the imperative language of Deuteronomy (Deut 1:8, 21). WEB, ESV, BSB and NIV take it as an instruction.
-
A promise.
KJV's 'promisedst' reads it as an assurance, and the relative clause ('the land you swore to give them') makes the promise behind it explicit. The best answer is that both are present: a command based on an oath already sworn.
in v16
Who are 'they' in 'they and our fathers'?
-
One group: 'they, that is, our fathers'. The 'and' explains rather than adds (most commentators; NIV, NASB).
From v. 9 on, the only subject has been 'our fathers' in Egypt and the wilderness. No second group has been introduced, and the verbs that follow fit the wilderness generation alone. Hebrew 'and' sometimes works this way, meaning 'namely'. The Exodus 'stiff-necked' wording points specifically to the golden calf generation.
-
Two groups: the wilderness generation ('they') plus the later ancestors ('our fathers'), so the verse sums up the whole history.
This takes the double 'and' at face value, as the Septuagint's 'both… and' seems to. It also fits the prayer's later point that rebellion continued through every generation (vv. 26–30). But vv. 16–18 go on to describe only wilderness events, which weakens this reading.
in v17
Did the original text say 'in their rebellion' or 'in Egypt'?
-
'In their rebellion' (bemiryam) is original.
It is the Masoretic Text. It is the less obvious reading, and copyists tended to bring texts into line with well-known parallels such as Num 14:4's 'to Egypt,' not away from them. Rebellion (mrh) is also a theme throughout the prayer (9:26).
-
'In Egypt' (bemitsrayim) is original.
The Septuagint and a few Hebrew manuscripts have it. It matches Num 14:4, which the verse clearly quotes. A dropped tsade would easily turn בְּמִצְרַיִם into בְּמִרְיָם. Some modern translations (BSB, ESV, NASB) follow it.
Sources
- BDB s.v. לֶחֶם, שָׁמַיִם, סֶלַע, יָרַשׁ, נָשָׂא
- HALOT s.v. נשׂא (with יָד, oath gesture), ירשׁ, סֶלַע
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- P. Borgen, Bread from Heaven (1965), on John 6:31
- M. J. J. Menken, Old Testament Quotations in the Fourth Gospel (1996)
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 19:15; Exod 6:8 LXX
- Vulgate, Nehemiah 9:15
- Parallel texts: Exod 16:4, 13–15; 17:6; Num 11:7–8; 20:8–11; Deut 1:8, 21; Ps 78:15–16, 23–25; 105:40–41; Ezek 20:5–6
- BDB and HALOT s.v. זִיד (to boil; act presumptuously)
- HALOT s.v. עֹרֶף; קשׁה hiphil
- BDB s.v. שָׁמַע
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16) on Neh 9:16–17
- Joseph Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (OTL) on Neh 9
- Keil & Delitzsch, Commentary on Nehemiah 9:16
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 19:16 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Nehemiah 9:16
- BDB and HALOT s.v. סְלִיחָה, סָלַח
- HALOT s.v. חֶסֶד
- HALOT s.v. אַף (ʾerekh ʾappayim)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Neh 9:17
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 19:17
- Exodus 32–34; Numbers 14 (parallel texts)
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra–Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Nehemiah 9
- Mark J. Boda, Praying the Tradition: The Origin and Use of Tradition in Nehemiah 9
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).