Psalms Chapter 78 Read as one passage

Psalm 78:16–18

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

16He brought streams from the stone and made water flow down like rivers. 17But they continued to sin against Him, rebelling in the desert against the Most High. 18They willfully tested God by demanding the food they craved.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing Psalm 78 sung or recited in worship, this verse called up a shared founding memory. In the wilderness, with no water, their ancestors had been given flowing water out of solid rock. The wording made the memory larger than the bare event. The water was not a cupful for survival but "streams" and "rivers", the kind of water that made Egypt and Babylon rich.

The verse worked inside the psalm's teaching purpose in three ways:

  • It belongs to the Exodus. The verb "brought out" tied the water to God "bringing Israel out" of Egypt. It also matched the contrast in v. 44, where God turned Egypt's streams to blood.
  • It shows what was abundant. The psalm's whole question is whether the fathers trusted God (v. 22: "they did not believe in God or trust in his salvation"). Lavish water makes their later demand ("Can God spread a table in the wilderness?", v. 19) indefensible.
  • It warns the hearers. The psalm tells this to "the generation to come" (v. 4) so that they would remember the gifts and not repeat the forgetting. Hearers were meant to see themselves in the story: given more than enough, and so without excuse if they doubted.

From the study of Psalm 78:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 16He brought streams from the stone and made water flow down like rivers.

    "And he brought running water out of the bare crag, and sent water pouring down like rivers."

    The verse finishes the thought begun in v. 15 ("He split the rocks in the wilderness and gave them drink as abundant as the great deep"). Both lines describe one act from two angles. In the first, God brings out flowing water. The verb is the one Israel used for God "bringing them out" of Egypt, so the water belongs to the Exodus rescue itself. The water comes from a sela', a crag or rock face, the hardest and driest thing in the desert. In the second line God sends it down, cascading off the height, and the water is compared to the rivers: the permanent, never-failing rivers of the great river lands, not a seasonal desert trickle.

    The Hebrew saves the word "water" for the very end, so the sentence lands on the one thing the wilderness lacked. The language is deliberately excessive. It describes abundance, not just survival. That is the setup for what follows: "But they continued to sin against him" (v. 17). The more generous the gift, the more inexcusable the distrust that came after it.

    Full study →
  2. 17But they continued to sin against Him, rebelling in the desert against the Most High.

    And they did it again. They piled still more sin on top of what came before, wronging him personally and openly defying the Most High, there in the parched, waterless land.

    The verse is built on a contrast with what comes just before it. In verses 15–16 God splits rocks and makes water "flow down like rivers." Verse 17 opens with "they added": God added streams, and they added sin. "Still/yet again" shows that this is a pattern that keeps growing, not a single failure.

    "Sin against him" describes a personal offense against the one who had just kept them alive. The second phrase says what that sin was: defiance. The Hebrew verb is the one used of a son who rejects his parents' authority (Deuteronomy 21:18), and this psalm uses it of Israel again and again (vv. 8, 40, 56). The one they defy has the highest title there is, "the Most High," ruler over all things. The place they do it is named by a word that means simply "dryness," a land with no water. Everywhere else in that land they were dying of thirst, and every mouthful they drank there was his gift. That is where they set themselves against him.

    Full study →
  3. 18They willfully tested God by demanding the food they craved.

    "And they put God himself on trial, deliberately and from the inside, by demanding food to fill their own hungry throats."

    The verse continues the indictment of verse 17 ("they went on sinning against him"). The verb means testing: the people take the role of examiner and treat God as the one who has to prove himself. That turns the pattern of the wilderness stories upside down. In those stories God tests Israel to see what is in their heart, and here Israel tests God. "In their heart" does not mean a passing feeling. In Hebrew the heart is the place of intent and decision, so this was a settled, chosen stance of distrust, and verse 19 shows it coming out in words: "Can God really set a table in the wilderness?"

    They tested him by asking, which is the grammatical link between the two halves of the verse. The asking was not trusting prayer. It was a demand for proof, made right after God had split the sea and drawn rivers from the rock (vv. 13–16). What they asked for was food in general (the psalm goes on to manna and then quail), and they wanted it for their nefesh: their throat, their appetite, the hungry self. The picture is pointed. God is set opposite a craving gullet, and the people want the Most High to serve their stomach. The coming verses make the irony plain: God does give them exactly what their appetite wanted (vv. 27–29), and the meal itself becomes judgment (vv. 30–31).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v16

    stone (BSB) / rock

    sela'

    What we hear
    A stone or boulder, a single piece of rock lying on the ground.
    What they heard
    A crag, cliff or rock face: bare, solid bedrock, the driest and least water-bearing thing in the landscape.
  • in v17

    provoking (KJV) / provoke (YLT)

    mārâ (lamrôt)

    What we hear
    Annoying, irritating, or deliberately making someone angry.
    What they heard
    Open defiance: rebelling against an authority, like a son rejecting his father (Deut 21:18). The focus is on what Israel did, not on God's feelings.
  • in v17

    wilderness (KJV)

    ṣiyyâ

    What we hear
    Wild, untouched nature, often forest or backcountry.
    What they heard
    A dry, waterless region where people die of thirst. The word itself means "dryness."
  • in v18

    tempted (KJV, WEB)

    nasah

    What we hear
    Enticed God toward sin, or tried to lure him into wrongdoing.
    What they heard
    Put God to the test: demanded he prove his power and faithfulness on their terms.
  • in v18

    meat (KJV)

    'okhel

    What we hear
    Animal flesh specifically.
    What they heard
    Food of any kind. In 1611 English 'meat' still meant food in general (as in 'meat and drink'). The psalm covers both manna and quail.
  • in v18

    lust (KJV, YLT)

    nefesh

    What we hear
    Sexual desire.
    What they heard
    Appetite: the throat or hungry self, here a craving for food. In 1611 'lust' meant any strong desire.
Every word
  1. וַיּוֹצִא

    vayyotsi · H3318

    and he brought out · v16

    The causative form of 'go out': God makes the water come out. The verb form tells a past event in sequence. In a psalm retelling the Exodus, this is the same verb used throughout Israel's tradition for God 'bringing out' his people from Egypt, so the act is heard as part of the same rescue.

  2. נוֹזְלִים

    nozlim · H5140

    streams, flowing waters · v16

    Literally 'flowing ones', a participle of the verb 'to flow, trickle, run' used as a noun. It is a poetic word for running water, not still water in a cistern. The same word comes back in v. 44, where God turns Egypt's 'streams' to blood: the God who ruined Egypt's water makes water for Israel.

  3. מִסָּלַע

    missala' · H5553

    from a crag / rock face · v16

    'From' plus sela', a cliff, crag or rocky height, the bare rock of the desert. It is the word used in Numbers 20:8–11 (Meribah at Kadesh), while v. 15 uses tsur, the word of Exodus 17:6. The point is that the water comes out of the least likely place there is: solid, dry stone.

  4. וַיּוֹרֶד

    vayyored · H3381

    and he made go down · v16

    The causative form of 'go down, descend': God sends the water running downward, the way water pours down from a height into a desert valley. The picture is of water cascading off the crag.

  5. כַּנְּהָרוֹת

    kannehārot · H5104

    like the rivers · v16

    'Like' plus 'the rivers'. Nahar means a permanent, flowing river: the great waters of the Nile, the Euphrates or the Jordan. Desert streams dry up in summer, but this water was like the rivers that never stop. The word 'the' is the usual Hebrew way of comparing to a whole class ('like rivers do').

  6. מָיִם

    māyim · H4325

    water · v16

    The ordinary word for water, which in Hebrew is always plural in form. Holding it to the end of the line makes 'water' the last word, so the sentence lands on the very thing the desert did not have.

  7. וַיּוֹסִ֣יפוּ

    wayyôsîpû · H3254G

    and they added / did again · v17

    Literally "they added." With an infinitive after it, this verb means "they did more of it" or "they did it again." The picture is piling up: God had just poured out water (v. 16), and their answer was to pile on more sin.

  8. ע֭וֹד

    ʿôd · H5750

    still, yet, again · v17

    Strengthens the verb: "yet again" or "still more." Together with "added," it stresses that this was not a first slip but a pattern that kept growing.

  9. לַחֲטֹא־

    laḥăṭōʾ · H2398

    to sin, to do wrong · v17

    "To sin," meaning to fail in what you owe someone and so wrong them. Joined to "against him," it describes an offense against a person, here the God who had just rescued them, not only the breaking of a rule.

  10. ל֑וֹ

    lô · H9033

    to him, against him · v17

    The preposition marks who was wronged. With the verb "sin" it means "against him." The wrong is aimed at God personally.

  11. לַֽמְר֥וֹת

    lamrôt · H4784

    to rebel, to defy · v17

    A shortened causative-stem infinitive (from *lehamrôt*): "to act defiantly," "to set oneself against." It can explain the previous phrase ("sinning, *that is*, defying") or run alongside it as a parallel line. The same root marks Israel's history throughout this psalm (vv. 8, 40, 56).

  12. עֶ֝לְי֗וֹן

    ʿelyôn · H5945B

    Most High · v17

    An ancient royal title for God as the supreme ruler over everything. It sets the highest power in the universe against a wandering people who are openly defying him.

  13. בַּצִּיָּֽה׃

    baṣṣiyyâ · H6723

    dryness, parched land · v17

    "In the dry land," a waterless place. Coming right after v. 16, where God made water "flow down like rivers," the word is pointed: they defied him in the very land where they could only live because he gave them water.

  14. וַיְנַסּוּ־

    vayenassu · H5254

    and they tested · v18

    To put someone to the test in order to find out what they will do or can do. Here Israel is the one doing the testing and God is being tested, which turns the usual direction around: normally God tests Israel (Exodus 16:4; Deuteronomy 8:2). The verb form carries the story on from verse 17, as the next step in a chain of rebellion.

  15. אֵ֥ל

    'el · H410

    God · v18

    The short, ancient word for God, used here without the article, almost as a name. Verse 19 picks it up again ("Can El…?"), so the psalm stresses that the one being treated as a suspect is God himself, the Most High of verse 17.

  16. בִּלְבָבָ֑ם

    bilvavam · H3824

    in their heart · v18

    In Hebrew the heart is mainly where you think, decide and plan, not chiefly where you feel. 'In their heart' means the testing came from their inner intent and settled attitude: it was deliberate, not a slip of the tongue. That is why BSB and NIV render it 'willfully'.

  17. לִֽשְׁאָל־

    lish'ol · H7592

    to ask, request · v18

    The ordinary verb for asking. The grammar ('to ask' with the little prefix 'l-') tells us how they tested God: they tested him by asking. Next to 'tested' and 'in their heart', the asking reads as demanding proof rather than trusting prayer, which is why modern versions say 'demanding'.

  18. אֹ֥כֶל

    'okhel · H400

    food · v18

    Food in general, anything you eat. The psalm goes on to tell of manna, the 'grain of heaven' (v. 24), and then meat, the quail (v. 27). The word is broad and does not mean only meat.

  19. לְנַפְשָֽׁם׃

    lenafsham · H5315

    appetite; throat; life, self · v18

    Nefesh is first of all the throat, and from there the living, hungry self that wants and needs. Next to 'food' it means appetite. They asked for food to satisfy their own craving, and the psalm names that craving outright a few verses later (vv. 29–30).

The world behind it

The two water-from-rock stories. The Torah tells of water from rock twice. The first is at Massah and Meribah near Horeb, early in the journey, when Moses strikes the tsur (Exodus 17:1–7). The second is at Meribah in Kadesh, late in the journey, when Moses is told to speak to the sela' but strikes it (Numbers 20:2–13). Psalm 78 uses tsur (plural) in v. 15 and again in v. 20, and sela' in v. 16, the vocabulary of both stories. Its order (water, then the demand for bread and meat in vv. 18–31) follows the pattern of Exodus 17 and Numbers 11 more than Numbers 20.

Desert water. In the Sinai and Negev, water means springs, cisterns and wadis: dry valleys that flood briefly after rain and then dry out. A nahar, a river that flows all year, was the mark of Egypt (the Nile) and Mesopotamia (the Euphrates). To say rock-water ran "like rivers" in that landscape was to say the desert had been given what only the richest lands had.

The psalm's purpose. Psalm 78 is a maskil (a teaching psalm) of Asaph. It retells Israel's history as "riddles from of old" (v. 2) so that the children "should not be like their fathers, a stubborn and rebellious generation" (v. 8). It moves back and forth between God's wonders and Israel's forgetting. Verses 15–16 are a high point of the wonders, placed just before the account of rebellion (vv. 17–20). The psalm ends with God rejecting Ephraim/Shiloh and choosing Judah, Zion and David (vv. 67–72).

Later echoes. The memory of rock-water became a pattern for hope (Isaiah 43:19–20; 48:21). Later Jewish tradition developed the idea of a well or rock that travelled with Israel through the wilderness (e.g. Pseudo-Philo, Biblical Antiquities 10:7; Tosefta Sukkah 3:11–12). Paul alludes to this in 1 Corinthians 10:4 ("the spiritual rock that followed them"). The psalm itself says nothing about the rock moving. It speaks only of abundance.

From the study of Psalm 78:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

Do vv. 15–16 refer to one water-from-rock event or to both (Exodus 17 and Numbers 20)?

  • The psalm sums up both events together.

    It uses both words the Torah uses: tsur, the word of Exodus 17:6 (Ps 78:15, 20), and sela', the word of Numbers 20:8–11 (Ps 78:16). It also uses the plural 'rocks' (tsurim) in v. 15 and describes God doing this habitually, which fits a summary of repeated provision across the wilderness years.

  • The psalm chiefly has the first, Horeb event in mind, and the words are poetic synonyms.

    Tsur and sela' often stand in parallel in Hebrew poetry as mere variants (e.g. Ps 18:2; 31:2–3). The psalm's sequence of water, then the demand for bread and meat (vv. 18–31), follows the early wilderness stories (Exodus 16–17; Numbers 11) rather than Numbers 20. Verse 20 recalls the striking of the tsur.

in v17

What does "still / again" point back to?

  • It points to the sins already listed in vv. 10–11 (not keeping the covenant, forgetting God's works). The water episode is one more mercy they answered with more sin.

    The psalm is arranged by theme. Verse 17 follows the account of rescue (vv. 12–16) and picks up the earlier list of sins, so "added still" means added to what had come before.

  • It means sin committed right after, and in spite of, the gift of water in vv. 15–16.

    The verse directly follows v. 16. The contrast between "made water flow down like rivers" and "in the dry land" is sharp, and vv. 18–20 have the people mentioning the water gift while they demand bread and meat (v. 20). In Exodus, though, the grumbling at Massah comes *before* the water, so the psalm is ordering events by theme rather than by date.

in v17

When was Psalm 78 composed?

  • Before the exile, in the time of the kings. Some say soon after the united monarchy, others after the fall of the northern kingdom (722 BC), perhaps under Hezekiah.

    The psalm ends with God rejecting Ephraim and choosing Judah, Zion and David (vv. 67–72). It does not mention the destruction of Jerusalem, which would be strange if that had already happened.

  • After the exile, or edited then.

    Its teaching style and its use of Pentateuch traditions in combination are like other historical psalms (105, 106) that many date late. This position argues that the silence about Jerusalem's fall carries less weight.

in v18

Which wilderness episode does verse 18 have in view: the manna (Exodus 16) or the quail (Numbers 11)?

  • Mainly the quail craving of Numbers 11.

    The language of appetite (nefesh) and craving matches Numbers 11:4–6, and Psalm 78:29–31 ends with God giving 'their craving' and striking them while the food was still in their mouths, which is the Kibroth-hattaavah story.

  • A summary charge covering the whole sequence of food demands (manna and quail, possibly after the water at Massah).

    The psalm goes on to narrate both the manna (vv. 23–25) and the quail (vv. 26–29). The general word 'okhel ('food') and the general question 'Can God set a table?' (v. 19) suggest a summary of the wilderness pattern rather than one incident. Psalm poetry often merges episodes.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).