Numbers Chapter 15 Read as one passage

Numbers 15:29–30

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

29You shall have the same law for the one who acts in error, whether he is a native-born Israelite or a foreigner residing among you. 30But the person who sins defiantly, whether a native or foreigner, blasphemes the LORD. That person shall be cut off from among his people.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing this, the verse did two things at once.

  1. It extended the obligation. The resident alien was not exempt from the sanctuary's holiness. His mistakes counted as real violations needing ritual repair, because the holiness of the camp, and later the land, applied to everyone living in it. In the priestly laws the gēr is generally bound by the prohibitions (things one must not do, since breaking them pollutes the sanctuary and the land), even where he is not required to perform Israel's positive rites. Milgrom stresses this distinction.

  2. It extended the remedy. The outsider had the same access to the altar, the same priestly ceremony and the same promise of forgiveness as the native. In a society where landless outsiders were easily pushed to the margins, "one instruction for you" meant he was not a second-class participant when it came to having a wrong put right before God.

Read with v. 30, the verse also drew a clear moral line for everyone. What counted was not birth but the posture behind the act. A mistake, however serious, had a way back through the offering. Open, fist-raised defiance of the LORD did not. Coming right after the wilderness generation's defiant refusal to enter the land (Num 14), the line would have hit home.

From the study of Numbers 15:29.

Verse by verse

  1. 29You shall have the same law for the one who acts in error, whether he is a native-born Israelite or a foreigner residing among you.

    "Whether it is the native-born member of Israel's family or the outsider who has settled and lives right among them, you are all to have one and the same procedure for the person who goes wrong by mistake."

    The verse closes the paragraph on individual wrongdoing (vv. 27–29). If any single person strays, by not knowing the rule, by not realising what they were doing, or by plain carelessness, they bring a year-old female goat, the priest performs the atonement rite before the LORD, and the promise is: he will be forgiven (v. 28). Verse 29 then says who that promise covers. It names the full Israelite, rooted in the land by birth, and the resident alien, the outsider with no ancestral land who lives "in their midst". The Hebrew stresses that he really lives there: "the sojourner who sojourns". The "law" here is not the whole Torah. It is this specific ritual instruction, and there is only one of it. The outsider is not given a lesser rite or a separate line.

    The word for "in error" pictures straying off the path, like a wandering sheep. It is broader than English "ignorance". It covers any wrong done without the intent to defy. The next verse makes this the hinge of the passage: whoever acts "with a high hand", openly and defiantly, native or alien alike, has no offering to bring and is "cut off". Native and outsider are equal on both sides of that line. They share the same remedy for mistakes and face the same verdict for defiance.

    Full study →
  2. 30But the person who sins defiantly, whether a native or foreigner, blasphemes the LORD. That person shall be cut off from among his people.

    But the person who acts with an arm raised high — openly, defiantly, shaking a fist at the LORD's command — whether that person is a born Israelite or a foreigner settled among you, is insulting the LORD himself. That person shall be cut off from the heart of their people.

    The verse turns on a contrast with what comes just before it (vv. 22–29). Someone who sins by mistake, through error, carelessness or ignorance, can bring a purification offering, and the priest makes atonement, "and it shall be forgiven." Now the law turns to someone who sins with a high hand. The Hebrew picture is of a lifted arm, the same gesture Israel made marching out of Egypt in triumph, now turned against God himself. This is not the sin of a weak or confused person. It is open rebellion that says "I know whose command this is, and I reject it."

    Such an act, the verse says, is not just a broken rule. It is a taunt aimed at the LORD. The Hebrew puts "the LORD" first for emphasis: it is the LORD this person is insulting. The word for insult is the one used of the Assyrian envoys mocking Israel's God outside Jerusalem's walls. No words need to be spoken, because the deed itself is the insult.

    So no offering is provided. The sacrifices of vv. 24–29 belonged to people living within the covenant who had slipped. The defiant person has stepped outside it by their own act. The result is karet, being "cut off": removed by God from the centre of the community gathered around his presence. The next verse spells out the reason: "he has despised the word of the LORD and broken his commandment; his guilt remains on him." The same rule holds for native and foreigner alike: one law, one mercy for honest error, one judgment for open defiance.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v29

    ignorance (KJV: "sinneth through ignorance")

    bishgāgâ

    What we hear
    Not knowing the rules, or a lack of education. Today it can even sound like an insult.
    What they heard
    Going astray or erring: any wrong done without intent to defy. That includes not knowing the law, not knowing the facts, accidents and negligence. The same word covers accidental manslaughter (Num 35:11).
  • in v29

    stranger (KJV, also ESV)

    gēr

    What we hear
    Someone you have never met, an unknown person.
    What they heard
    A resident alien: an outsider settled long-term in the community, known to its members, but without inherited land or clan standing, and so legally vulnerable and protected by law.
  • in v29

    law

    tôrâ

    What we hear
    A legal code or 'the Law' as a whole system, often heard as a burden set against grace.
    What they heard
    A single priestly ruling or procedure, here the rite of atonement that ends in 'he will be forgiven'.
  • in v30

    blasphemes (BSB, NIV, WEB)

    megaddef (gadaf)

    What we hear
    Saying something irreverent or profane about God, such as swearing or mocking religion in words.
    What they heard
    To insult, taunt or treat with contempt. Here the insult is the defiant act itself, and no words are involved.
  • in v30

    soul (KJV, WEB)

    nefesh

    What we hear
    The immaterial, immortal part of a person, so that 'that soul shall be cut off' sounds like eternal damnation.
    What they heard
    A living person, 'anyone'. The whole individual as a member of the community.
  • in v30

    presumptuously (KJV)

    beyad ramah

    What we hear
    Taking liberties, assuming too much, being forward or overconfident.
    What they heard
    With a raised hand: in open, deliberate defiance of the LORD's authority.
Every word
  1. הָֽאֶזְרָח֙

    ha'ezraḥ · H0249

    the native · v29, v30

    The full Israelite native, the person rooted in the land by birth and family inheritance. It stands first in the sentence, without the 'for' that the next noun has, as a heading: 'As for the native…'.

  2. בִּבְנֵ֣י

    bivnê · H1121G

    among the sons of · v29

    'Sons of Israel' is the normal name for the people as a family descended from Jacob. 'Among' places the native inside that kinship group.

  3. יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל

    yisra'ēl · H3478

    Israel · v29

    The ancestor Jacob/Israel, and so the nation descended from him. Belonging is set by descent.

  4. וְלַגֵּ֖ר

    welaggēr · H1616

    and for the sojourner · v29, v30

    The resident outsider: a non-Israelite (or Israelite from elsewhere) who has settled long-term in Israel's territory but has no inherited land and no clan standing. He is named here deliberately alongside the native.

  5. הַגָּ֣ר

    haggār · H1481A

    who sojourns · v29

    A participle (a verb used like 'the one who is sojourning') from the same root as gēr: 'the sojourner who sojourns'. The repetition stresses that he actually lives there, not someone passing through.

  6. בְּתוֹכָ֑ם

    betôkhām · H8432

    in their midst · v29

    Literally 'in the middle of them'. The sojourner lives inside the community, among the camp and later the towns, not on its edges.

  7. תּוֹרָ֤ה

    tôrâ · H8451

    instruction, ruling · v29

    Here it means a specific priestly procedure: the ritual just described in vv. 27–28 (a year-old female goat as a purification offering, and the priest's atonement rite). It does not mean 'the Law' as a whole body of writings.

  8. אַחַת֙

    'aḥat · H0259

    one · v29

    'One' in the sense of 'one and the same'. There is a single procedure and a single remedy, not a native version and an alien version.

  9. יִהְיֶ֣ה

    yihyeh · H1961

    shall be · v29

    A standing rule for the future, 'shall be'. It is a legal ordinance, not a prediction.

  10. לָכֶ֔ם

    lākhem · H9036

    for you (plural) · v29

    The whole assembled community is addressed. The rule belongs to 'you all', and the sojourner is counted within it.

  11. לָעֹשֶׂ֖ה

    lā'ōśeh · H6213A

    for the one who does · v29, v30

    Simply 'the one doing'. The verb itself does not say 'sin'; the context (v. 27, 'if one person sins') supplies that. In v. 30 the same verb returns, 'the person who does with a high hand', which sets up the contrast.

  12. בִּשְׁגָגָֽה׃

    bishgāgâ · H7684

    in error, inadvertently · v29

    'By straying, in error': a wrong done without defiant intent. That could be not knowing the rule, not realising what one was doing, or carelessness. Its opposite comes in the next verse: 'with a high hand', open defiance.

  13. וְהַנֶּ֜פֶשׁ

    vehannefesh · H5315

    and/but the person · v30

    The prefixed 'and' works as 'but', setting this case against the accidental sins of vv. 22–29. Nefesh here simply means a living person, a 'someone'; it is grammatically feminine, which is why the following verbs and 'her people' are feminine.

  14. אֲשֶֽׁר־

    asher · H0834

    who, which · v30

    Introduces the description of which person is meant: the one who acts in the way about to be described.

  15. בְּיָ֣ד

    beyad · H3027

    with a hand · v30

    First half of the idiom 'with a high hand'. In Hebrew the hand stands for power and action.

  16. רָמָ֗ה

    ramah · H7311

    raised, high · v30

    'Raised high' completes the picture of an arm lifted in open defiance, like a fist shaken in someone's face. It describes a public, deliberate act of rebellion, not just knowing that something is wrong.

  17. מִן־

    min · H4480

    from, of · v30

    'Of / from among': the person may come from either group named next.

  18. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    [marks the object] · v30

    Marks YHWH as the object of the verb. It is placed first in the clause for emphasis: it is the LORD, of all people, whom this person is insulting.

  19. יְהוָ֖ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v30

    Israel's God, named personally. Putting it first makes the point that the act is aimed at him, not merely at a rule.

  20. ה֣וּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v30

    'He' (the offender) is the one doing the insulting. It switches to masculine here, unlike the feminine 'nefesh', because it points to the person as a man in the community.

  21. מְגַדֵּ֑ף

    megaddef · H1442

    insulting, reviling · v30

    A participle (an ongoing state): 'is insulting'. The defiant act itself is treated as a public insult, a taunt thrown at God. No spoken words are required.

  22. וְנִכְרְתָ֛ה

    venikhretah · H3772

    and shall be cut off · v30

    The penalty known as karet, 'cutting off'. The passive form leaves the one who cuts unnamed; parallel texts (Lev 17:10; 20:3–6) show God as the one who does it.

  23. מִקֶּ֥רֶב

    mikkerev · H7130

    from the midst of · v30

    Literally 'from the inner part of'. The person is removed from the centre of the community's life, where the LORD dwells among his people.

  24. עַמָּֽהּ׃

    ammah · H5971

    her (its) people · v30

    'Her people' (feminine, agreeing with nefesh): the person's own kin and the covenant people they belong to. The loss is a loss of belonging.

The world behind it

Where this sits. Numbers 15 comes straight after the spies' report and Israel's refusal to enter the land (Num 13–14). That generation is condemned to die in the wilderness. Chapter 15 then opens with "When you come into the land…" (v. 2), which quietly assures the next generation that they will arrive. The chapter's laws are for life in the land.

Two kinds of wrongdoing. Verses 22–31 set out:

  • Community error (vv. 22–26): if the whole congregation unknowingly fails to keep a commandment, they offer a bull as a burnt offering and a male goat as a purification offering.
  • Individual error (vv. 27–29): a year-old female goat as a purification offering.
  • Defiant wrongdoing (vv. 30–31): acting "with a high hand", the picture of a raised fist or an arm lifted in open challenge, is treated as reviling the LORD. No sacrifice is given. The person is "cut off". Verses 32–36 (the man gathering wood on the Sabbath) follow, apparently as a case study.

Why the sanctuary mattered. In priestly thinking, the wrongs of people living around the sanctuary build up as impurity that clings to it. If that is left untreated, God's presence could withdraw. The "purification offering" (traditionally "sin offering") cleansed the sanctuary from that pollution, and the wrongdoer was forgiven. So a resident alien's error was not a private matter. It affected the holy place in the middle of the community. That is one reason the alien is brought fully into the remedy.

The resident alien's position. The gēr had no family land, and in an agrarian clan society that meant no secure base. He typically worked for others and depended on legal protection. Israel's law repeatedly grounds his protection in memory: "you were sojourners in the land of Egypt." Leviticus 4, the earlier law on these offerings, does not mention him. Numbers 15 repeatedly insists that he be included (vv. 14–16, 26, 29, 30).

From the study of Numbers 15:29.

Where scholars differ

in v29

Who is the gēr here: a resident alien or a religious convert?

  • A resident alien: a settled outsider, defined by social and legal status, not by conversion.

    The usage in the Hebrew Bible pairs gēr with tôshāv (settler) and lists him with widows and orphans. Israel itself was a gēr in Egypt. The priestly laws treat him as bound by prohibitions but not all positive rites (e.g. he may choose whether to keep Passover, Num 9:14 / Exod 12:48). This is the view of most modern scholars (Milgrom, Levine, van Houten).

  • A full convert (ger tzedeq), equal to a native in all obligations.

    This is the classical rabbinic reading (Sifre Numbers; Talmud), helped by the LXX's prosēlytos. It reflects the later situation, when 'joining Israel' had become a recognised religious act. Its strength is that it explains why the gēr has full access to atonement rites.

in v29

How wide is shegāgâ, and is there any atonement for deliberate wrongs?

  • Shegāgâ covers all non-defiant wrongs. Deliberate but repented wrongs can be brought into the atonable category through confession.

    Milgrom points to Lev 5:20–26 (6:1–7) and Num 5:6–7, where knowingly committed offences such as false oaths and fraud are atoned for after confession and restitution. On this view only 'high-handed', unrepentant defiance (v. 30) is beyond the sacrificial system.

  • The sacrificial system covers only true inadvertence. Deliberate sins are beyond it, and are left to God or punishment.

    A plain reading of the sharp contrast in vv. 29–30. The cities-of-refuge laws also separate accidental from intentional killing (Num 35). Some later interpreters (and the logic of Heb 10:26) read it this way.

in v29

How does Num 15:22–31 relate to Leviticus 4?

  • A different or later layer of priestly law that revises Lev 4.

    The offerings differ: for the community, Lev 4 has a bull as purification offering, while Num 15 has a bull as burnt offering plus a goat as purification offering. Lev 4 also never mentions the gēr. Many critical scholars assign Num 15 to a later 'Holiness' layer concerned with the alien and the land.

  • They deal with different cases. Num 15:22–26 concerns failure in 'all these commandments', i.e. idolatry.

    Rabbinic tradition (Sifre Numbers; b. Horayot 8a) reads 'all these commandments' (v. 22) as the sin that uproots the whole Torah, namely idolatry, and so harmonises the two passages.

in v30

What does 'cut off' (karet) mean?

  • Premature death brought about by God.

    God says 'I will cut him off' (Lev 20:3–6). Mishnah Keritot treats karet as a penalty from heaven, separate from court execution, and rabbinic tradition often linked it with dying young.

  • The ending of the offender's family line.

    In a kinship society, being 'cut off from one's people' naturally suggests losing descendants. Compare the fear of a 'name being cut off' (Ruth 4:10; Ps 109:13). Milgrom stresses the extinction of the lineage.

  • Exclusion from the community (a kind of excommunication).

    The wording 'from the midst of her people' suggests removal from the community. Qumran's use of the 'high hand' category for permanent expulsion (1QS 8) reads it this way.

  • Denial of a share with one's ancestors after death.

    This mirrors the idiom of being 'gathered to one's people' at death. Milgrom argues that karet may include losing that reunion. Later rabbinic texts speak of losing the world to come.

in v30

Is 'high-hand' sin simply any deliberate sin?

  • Yes. The contrast is between unintentional and intentional sin, and only unintentional sins could be atoned for by sacrifice.

    Verses 29–30 place 'in error' (bishgagah) directly against 'with a high hand', and many commentators read these as the only two categories.

  • No. It is a narrower category of open, defiant rejection of God's authority.

    Lev 6:1–7 (5:20–26 in Hebrew) provides a guilt offering for deliberate fraud and false oaths once the person confesses and makes restitution. The Day of Atonement covers Israel's 'transgressions' (pesha'im, rebellious acts) (Lev 16:16, 21). The idiom elsewhere means open, bold action (Exod 14:8), and v. 31 defines the offence as despising the LORD's word. Milgrom argues that repentance could reduce a deliberate sin to the level that sacrifice could cover.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שְׁגָגָה, גֵּר, אֶזְרָח, תּוֹרָה
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁגָגָה; גֵּר; אֶזְרָח
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), comm. on 15:22–31 and Excursus on the gēr
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on shegāgâ and the purification offering
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Christiana van Houten, The Alien in Israelite Law (JSOTSup 107)
  • Timothy R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Numbers 15:29 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Numeri 15:29
  • Sifre Numbers on 15:22–31; b. Horayot 8a
  • 1QS (Community Rule) cols. 8–9
  • BDB s.v. גָּדַף; רוּם; כָּרַת
  • HALOT s.v. גדף; אֶזְרָח; גֵּר
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on 15:22–31 and Excursus on karet
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on the ḥaṭṭat and asham and on repentance
  • Baruch Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Timothy Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Numbers 15:30
  • Community Rule (1QS) 8
  • Mishnah Keritot 1:1–2

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).