Numbers Chapter 35 Read as one passage

Numbers 35:20–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20Likewise, if anyone maliciously pushes another or intentionally throws an object at him and kills him, 21or if in hostility he strikes him with his hand and he dies, the one who struck him must surely be put to death; he is a murderer. When the avenger of blood finds the murderer, he is to kill him. 22But if anyone pushes a person suddenly, without hostility, or throws an object at him unintentionally, 23or without looking drops a heavy stone that kills him, but he was not an enemy and did not intend to harm him,

What the first hearers heard

The chapter is set on the plains of Moab, with Israel about to cross into Canaan (Num 35:1). The law looks ahead to settled life in towns and fields, where deaths from falls, quarrels and accidents would happen and families would want revenge.

For these first hearers the verse did three things:

  • It confirmed the kinsman's duty. A man who killed out of hatred or from ambush had no protection. The refuge city would not shelter him, and the avenger of blood was to carry out the sentence (v. 21). Deliberate killing was not to be settled by payment (v. 31).
  • It gave the community a way to decide. When there was no weapon, the elders and the assembly could ask: was there a feud? Was he waiting for him? Those questions protected the innocent killer of v. 22 from the anger of a grieving family.
  • It tied justice to the holiness of the land. Unavenged murder "pollutes" the land, and only the blood of the one who shed it can cleanse it (vv. 33–34). Telling murder apart from accident correctly was about keeping the land fit for God to live among his people, not only about fairness between families.

From the study of Numbers 35:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20Likewise, if anyone maliciously pushes another or intentionally throws an object at him and kills him,

    "And if, out of hatred he already held against him, he shoves him, or, having waited in ambush for him, he hurls something down on him, and the man dies…"

    The verse is the first half of a sentence. Verse 21 finishes it: such a killer "is a murderer", and the victim's kinsman, the "avenger of blood", is to put him to death.

    The pictures are plain and physical. One is a man shoving another with force, perhaps off a roof or down a slope or into a pit. The other is someone who has stalked his victim, waiting at a spot he chose, and then throws or drops something on him. No sword or club is named. The verses just before (16–18) judged killings by the weapon. Here there is no weapon to inspect, so the law looks at two things a community could find out: whether there was existing hostility between the two men ("hatred"; the parallel laws say "yesterday and the day before"), and whether the attack was set up in advance ("lying in wait", a rare word for hunting someone down).

    The point is clearest beside verse 22. It uses the same verbs, "shoved" and "threw", for a man who acted "suddenly, without enmity" and "without lying in wait". That man is protected in a city of refuge. The two acts can look the same. The verdict depends on what lay behind the act.

    Full study →
  2. 21or if in hostility he strikes him with his hand and he dies, the one who struck him must surely be put to death; he is a murderer. When the avenger of blood finds the murderer, he is to kill him.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 22But if anyone pushes a person suddenly, without hostility, or throws an object at him unintentionally,

    "But suppose it happened in an instant. There was no feud between them, and he shoved the man. Or he let fly some object, any tool or article at all, and it came down on him, but there was no stalking and no setting a trap..."

    The verse is the first half of a sentence that runs through verse 23 and is completed in verses 24–25. Those verses send the case to the community to judge and give the killer protection in a city of refuge. It deliberately mirrors verse 20 by reusing the same two actions, pushed and threw. In verse 20 a man who pushes "in hatred" or throws "while lying in wait" is a murderer. Here the actions are the same, but each motive is denied. The deed is identical; what lies behind it differs.

    Three markers define the protected case:

    • in an instant: no lead-up;
    • without enmity: no known history of hostility between the two men;
    • without lying in wait: no plan, no ambush.

    The word for the object is as broad as possible: any made thing, a tool, a jar, a weapon. Earlier verses had treated a deadly object as a sign of murder. This verse limits that rule: what the man carried does not settle the question. What settles it is whether there was a feud and a plan.

    Full study →
  4. 23or without looking drops a heavy stone that kills him, but he was not an enemy and did not intend to harm him,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    thrust (KJV); thrust him through (YLT)

    hadaf

    What we hear
    Stabbing or running someone through with a blade.
    What they heard
    A forceful shove or push. The case is a death caused by bodily force, such as a push off a height, with no blade involved.
  • in v20

    with malice aforethought (NIV)

    besin'ah

    What we hear
    The common-law definition of murder: the killer's state of mind at the moment, including an intent to cause serious harm.
    What they heard
    'In hatred': an established hostility between the two men that witnesses could speak to (compare Deut 19:4, 'did not hate him yesterday and the day before').
  • in v22

    thrust (KJV); thrust him through (YLT)

    hādap

    What we hear
    Stabbed or ran him through with a blade.
    What they heard
    Pushed or shoved him with the body; a jostle that could cause a deadly fall.
  • in v22

    unintentionally (BSB)

    bəlōʾ ṣədiyyâ

    What we hear
    He didn't mean to do it at all; a mental-state test about whether the act was intended.
    What they heard
    Without lying in wait: no plan or ambush behind the act. The test is about evidence of premeditation, not about a private state of mind.
Every word
  1. וְאִם־

    ve'im · H0518A

    and if · v20, v22

    Opens a new legal case. Vv. 16–18 judged a killing by the weapon used. Here the 'if' turns to a second test: the killer's attitude and method.

  2. בְּשִׂנְאָה

    besin'ah · H8135

    in hatred · v20

    'Out of hatred': the push came from an existing hostility toward the victim. Elsewhere the Torah tests this by whether there was enmity 'yesterday and the day before' (Deut 19:4, 6), so it is something witnesses can establish, not just a feeling.

  3. יֶהְדָּפֶנּוּ

    yehdafennu · H1920

    he shoves him · v20, v22

    A forceful push or shove, the kind that could send someone off a roof, down a slope or into a pit. It does not mean stabbing. The same verb in v. 22 describes the innocent case: a sudden shove 'without enmity'.

  4. אוֹ־

    'o · H0176A

    or · v20, v22

    Joins a second way of killing, at a distance this time instead of by contact.

  5. הִשְׁלִיךְ

    hishlikh · H7993

    he threw, hurled · v20, v22

    To fling or cast something. The object is not named. Hebrew legal style lets the hearer supply it, and v. 22 does: 'any object'. English versions add 'something' or 'an object'.

  6. עָלָיו

    'alav · H5921A

    upon him · v20, v22

    'At him' or 'down upon him'. With this verb it can suggest dropping something from above, as when a woman threw a millstone 'upon' Abimelech's head from a tower (Judg 9:53).

  7. בִּצְדִיָּה

    bitsdiyyah · H6660

    lying in wait, ambush · v20, v22

    'From ambush', 'having stalked him'. A rare word that appears only here and in v. 22. Its root means to lie in wait or hunt someone down, so it marks a killing that was planned and staged ahead of time.

  8. וַיָּמֹת׃

    vayyamot · H4191

    and he died · v20

    The result: the victim died. The case only becomes a capital case because death followed. The sentence carries on into v. 21, where the verdict comes: 'he is a murderer'.

  9. בְּפֶ֥תַע

    bəpetaʿ · H6621

    suddenness, an instant · v22

    'In an instant': the act happened on the spot, with no plan behind it. It is the first of three phrases in the verse that rule out premeditation.

  10. בְּלֹא־

    bəlōʾ · H3808

    not; with 'in-', 'without' · v22

    Literally 'in not'. Hebrew uses it to mean 'without'. Here: without enmity.

  11. אֵיבָ֖ה

    ʾêbâ · H0342

    enmity, hostility · v22

    An ongoing hostile relationship. This is the exact opposite of 'in enmity' in verse 21, which marks the murderer.

  12. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, any · v22

    'Any': whatever object it was, the kind of object is not what decides the case.

  13. כְּלִ֖י

    kəlî · H3627

    vessel, implement, tool, weapon · v22

    Any made object: a tool, a vessel, or a weapon. The supplied gloss 'weapon' is narrower than the Hebrew. Verses 16–18 used this word for an 'iron object' and a 'wooden object' as murder tools.

The world behind it

Blood redemption and refuge. Ancient Israel had no police. When someone was killed, the duty to respond fell to the nearest male relative, the go'el haddam. The phrase literally means "redeemer of the blood", and it is often translated "avenger of blood" (v. 19). He was the same family figure who bought back land or relatives sold into debt. Numbers 35 keeps this kinship duty but limits it. Six "cities of refuge" were set aside (vv. 9–15). Anyone who killed someone could flee there. Then the community ('edah, v. 24) judged "between the striker and the avenger of blood", and at least two witnesses were required for a death sentence (v. 30).

How the community told murder from accident. The chapter gives three tests in a row:

  • The object (vv. 16–18): iron, a stone or a wooden tool "by which one could die". A deadly weapon points to murder.
  • Motive and method (vv. 20–21, this verse): hatred, ambush, enmity. Prior hostility or a planned attack points to murder.
  • The innocent mirror image (vv. 22–23): "suddenly, without enmity", "without lying in wait", "without seeing". These point to accidental killing, and the killer is protected.

Wider legal world. Other ancient Near Eastern law codes also distinguished unintended homicide. Hittite law speaks of a case where "only his hand sins", and Hammurabi's laws (§§206–207) let a man who struck someone in a brawl swear "I did not strike knowingly." Israel's laws on this run from Exod 21:12–14 ("if he did not lie in wait") through this chapter to Deut 19:1–13 ("hates his neighbour and lies in wait"). What stands out in Numbers 35 is the reason given at the end (vv. 33–34): murder "pollutes the land" where Israel's God lives, so a murderer cannot simply pay a ransom (v. 31).

From the study of Numbers 35:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

Does 'lying in wait' (tsediyyah) mean a literal ambush, or premeditation in general?

  • A literal ambush or stalking: the killer hid or waited at a chosen spot.

    The root is used for hunting someone's life (1 Sam 24:12 Heb.; Lam 4:18). The Septuagint translates 'from ambush'. Deut 19:11 uses the concrete ambush word 'arav.

  • A concrete term standing for premeditation of any kind.

    The contrast in v. 22 is 'suddenly', which points to planned versus unplanned. Exod 21:13 sets 'did not lie in wait' against 'God let it happen to his hand', which is about intent, not tactics. Later Jewish law (Mishnah Makkot 2) treats the issue as one of intent and foreseeability.

in v20

How do the homicide laws of Exodus 21, Numbers 35 and Deuteronomy 19 relate?

  • One developing body of law. Numbers and Deuteronomy spell out, for life in the land, the asylum principle that Exodus first stated.

    They share vocabulary (lying in wait, hatred) and the same structure (asylum for the unintentional killer, none for the murderer). Numbers 35 is framed as instruction given before entering Canaan.

  • Separate legal traditions (often called the Covenant Code, the Priestly writings and Deuteronomy) that use different terms and institutions.

    Exodus names an altar or 'place' of refuge. Numbers names six cities, the congregation as judge, and release at the high priest's death. Deuteronomy assigns the elders of the town a role. Each uses its own words for intent.

in v22

Does verse 22 cover only pure accidents, or also a deliberate but spontaneous act (a sudden shove in a quarrel) where death was not intended?

  • Pure accident only: the killer did not mean to hit or harm anyone.

    Verse 23 ('without seeing', 'did not seek his harm') and the axe-head case in Deut 19:5 picture true mishaps. Exod 21:13 calls it something 'God let happen to his hand'. Rabbinic law (Mishnah Makkot 2) limits exile to unintentional killing and excludes near-deliberate cases.

  • It also covers a sudden, unplanned act of force without prior enmity, roughly what modern law calls manslaughter.

    'Pushed him' (hādap) describes a deliberate physical act, and 'in an instant, without enmity' would hardly need saying for a pure accident. The defining contrasts are a prior feud (v. 21) and an ambush (v. 20), not whether the push was meant. Several modern commentators (e.g. Levine, Milgrom) note that the test turns on premeditation and enmity.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. הָדַף, צְדִיָּה, צָדָה, שִׂנְאָה, שָׁלַךְ
  • HALOT s.v. צְדִיָּה; הדף
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary), on 35:16–34 and Excursus on asylum
  • Baruch Levine, Numbers 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 35:20–23
  • Timothy Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT), on 35:16–21
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§206–207; Hittite Laws §§1–4 (in M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • Mishnah Makkot ch. 2
  • Septuagint, Numbers 35:20 (Rahlfs)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. צְדִיָּה, צָדָה
  • HALOT s.v. פֶּתַע
  • HALOT s.v. אֵיבָה
  • HALOT s.v. הדף
  • Jacob Milgrom, The JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), on 35:16–29
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 35:16–29
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§206–207
  • Hittite Laws §§3–4
  • Septuagint Numbers 35:22

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.