Proverbs Chapter 23 Read as one passage

Proverbs 23:7–8

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7for he is keeping track, inwardly counting the cost. “Eat and drink,” he says to you, but his heart is not with you. 8You will vomit up what little you have eaten and waste your pleasant words.

What the first hearers heard

To a young man being trained for life among the powerful, the verse gave a practical warning with a moral edge. Not every invitation is generosity. A host can say all the right words ("Eat! Drink!") while inwardly counting the cost and resenting the guest. Such hospitality brings obligation and humiliation, not friendship. The sage wants the student to read people by their "eye" and "heart", their real disposition, and not by their words.

Within the wider teaching of Proverbs, it fits the repeated contrast between the generous "good eye" (22:9) and the grudging "evil eye" (23:6, 28:22), and the warnings about lips that do not match the heart (26:23–26). The first hearers would have heard a sharp, slightly comic sketch of a type they all knew: the host who urges a second helping while silently totting up the bill.

From the study of Proverbs 23:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7for he is keeping track, inwardly counting the cost. “Eat and drink,” he says to you, but his heart is not with you.

    You are a guest at the table of a stingy man, literally a man with an "evil eye" (v.6). The reason not to want his food: he is like someone pricing every mouthful to himself as it goes down. That is what he really is. Out loud he plays the generous host: "Eat! Drink! Help yourself!" He keeps saying it. But his heart, meaning his real intention, is not with you. He does not mean a word of it, and he resents every bite you take.

    The rare verb at the centre is related to words for "measure" and "market price". It pictures a man doing sums. The word for "in himself" (nefesh) can also mean "throat" or "appetite". In a passage about eating, where the next line has the guest vomiting up his few bites (v.8), that echo is probably not accidental: the meal sticks in your throat. The verse is a warning about false hospitality: friendly words covering a grudging heart. It is not a statement about the power of thought.

    Full study →
  2. 8You will vomit up what little you have eaten and waste your pleasant words.

    This verse finishes a short warning that begins in verse 6: do not eat at the table of a begrudging man, literally a man with an "evil eye", meaning a stingy one who resents what others get. He says, "Eat and drink!", but he is counting every bite, and his heart is not with you (v.7).

    Verse 8 tells you how the meal ends. "The very piece of bread you have eaten — you will bring it back up. And all your gracious, agreeable talk will have been thrown away."

    The Hebrew puts "your morsel" first for emphasis. It is the bread you took as a gift, the symbol of hospitality, and it will not stay down. The vomiting is a blunt picture of revulsion: once you see what the host really thinks, the food turns sour, and whatever you seemed to gain from his table is lost. The verb tenses look back from that moment. What you "have eaten" is already spoiled, and you "will have ruined" your words.

    Those words are the "pleasant" things a guest says at a meal: thanks, praise of the food, warm conversation. They were offered in good faith and wasted on someone who never meant the welcome. In short, a false host costs you twice. His food does you no good, and your courtesy is spent for nothing.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    as he thinketh … so is he (KJV)

    kəmô šāʿar bənapšô kēn hûʾ

    What we hear
    A general law: your thoughts shape who you become, so think positively.
    What they heard
    A description of one stingy host: he is like a man calculating the price of your meal, and that is what he really is.
  • in v7

    in his heart (KJV)

    bənapšô

    What we hear
    In one's deepest emotional core or beliefs.
    What they heard
    'In himself, inwardly', possibly with an echo of 'throat/appetite'. The Hebrew word is nefesh, not lev ('heart').
Every word
  1. כִּ֤י

    kî · H3588

    for, because · v7

    Gives the reason for the warning in v.6 ('Do not eat the bread of a stingy man'). The verse explains why his food is not worth having.

  2. כְּמוֹ־

    kəmô · H3644

    like, as · v7

    A comparison word: 'like one who…'. It introduces a portrait of the host's character. It does not state a general rule.

  3. שָׁעַ֥ר

    šāʿar · H8176

    to reckon, estimate, calculate · v7

    The verb appears only here in the Hebrew Bible. Related words mean 'measure' or 'market price', so the picture is a man tallying the cost of what you eat. The meaning is disputed (see debates).

  4. בְּנַפְשׁ֗וֹ

    bənapšô · H5315

    in his self / throat / appetite · v7

    'Inwardly, to himself.' Nefesh can also mean 'throat' or 'appetite', which fits a verse about eating where the next line mentions vomiting. Some hear a deliberate double meaning.

  5. כֶּ֫ן־

    kēn · H3651

    so, thus · v7

    Completes the comparison: 'like a calculator… so he is.' The host's hospitality is just bookkeeping.

  6. ה֥וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he · v7

    Refers to the stingy host of v.6, literally the man with 'an evil eye'. It is not 'a man' in general.

  7. אֱכֹ֣ל

    ʾĕkōl · H398

    eat! · v7, v8

    A command, the polite insistence of a host. Here the words are hollow.

  8. וּ֭שְׁתֵה

    ûšətēh · H8354

    and drink! · v7

    Together with 'eat', it is a stock phrase of hospitality, roughly 'Help yourself!'

  9. יֹ֣אמַר

    yōʾmar · H559

    he says · v7

    The verb form describes something he does habitually. He keeps saying it, and it costs him nothing to say it.

  10. לָ֑ךְ

    lāk

    to you · v7

    Addressed to 'my son', the student in the wisdom collection. This is the pause form of 'to you' (masculine).

  11. וְ֝לִבּ֗וֹ

    wəlibbô · H3820

    and his heart · v7

    The heart was the seat of intention, thought and will, not mainly of feeling. What he actually intends is set against what he says.

  12. בַּל־

    bal · H1077

    not · v7

    A poetic negative, used mostly in Psalms and Proverbs. It is emphatic.

  13. עִמָּֽךְ׃

    ʿimmāk · H5973

    with you · v7

    'His heart is not with you' means he does not mean it and is not on your side. He resents every bite.

  14. פִּֽתְּךָ־

    pittekha · H6595

    morsel, bit (of bread) · v8

    'Your morsel': the piece of bread, and by extension the share of the meal, that the guest has taken. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: the very food you enjoyed is what will come back up.

  15. תְקִיאֶ֑נָּה

    teqi'ennah · H6958

    to vomit, spew out · v8

    'You will vomit it up.' The verb form means to cause to come up, and the attached 'it' is feminine, pointing back to the morsel (a feminine noun in Hebrew). It is a strong, physical picture of disgust: the meal will not stay down.

  16. וְ֝שִׁחַ֗תָּ

    veshichatta · H7843

    to ruin, spoil, waste · v8

    'And you will have ruined/wasted.' This is the intensive form of a verb for spoiling or destroying something so it is useless. Your polite talk at the table has gone to waste.

  17. דְּבָרֶ֥יךָ

    devarekha · H1697

    word, speech, matter · v8

    'Your words': here the things the guest said during the meal, such as thanks, compliments and friendly conversation.

  18. הַנְּעִימִֽים׃

    hanne'imim · H5273

    pleasant, lovely, sweet · v8

    'The pleasant ones.' The adjective describes the guest's gracious, agreeable speech, which was offered in good faith and given to someone who did not deserve it.

The world behind it

Section of Proverbs. Proverbs 22:17–24:22 is a separate collection, the "words of the wise". It is addressed to a young man learning to move in the world of officials and wealthy households (23:1 opens with dining before a ruler). It is widely recognised as closely related to the Egyptian Instruction of Amenemope. Amenemope's chapter on coveting a poor man's goods says such food is "a blocking to the throat" and "a vomiting to the gullet", which is close to the vomiting in v.8. The parallel is not exact, but the shared theme of food that sticks in the throat is often noted.

Meals and honour. In the ancient Near East, eating at someone's table created a bond and an obligation. A host's "Eat and drink!" was the ritual language of generosity. Accepting it made you his debtor and put you in his circle. A host with an "evil eye" (Hebrew idiom for a stingy, grudging person, the opposite of the "good eye" of the generous man in 22:9) keeps the outward forms but begrudges the cost. The sage's advice is to avoid such tables. The food comes with strings attached. The guest leaves humiliated, sick, and having wasted his "pleasant words" (v.8), the compliments and thanks he paid his host.

From the study of Proverbs 23:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

What does שׁער mean in 'like šʿr in his nefesh'?

  • 'Calculate, reckon (the cost)': the host is counting what you eat (most modern translations, BDB, HALOT).

    The noun šaʿar 'measure' (Gen 26:12). Later Hebrew and Aramaic use of the root for estimating value and market price. A good fit with 'stingy man' in v.6.

  • 'Hair' (śēʿār): the meal is like a hair stuck in the throat (Septuagint, NRSV, some commentators).

    The Septuagint's reading. Nefesh can mean 'throat'. It fits the vomiting in v.8 and the Amenemope image of food 'blocking the throat'.

  • Other emendations, such as 'storm' or 'gatekeeper'.

    Based on similar consonants and on cognate words in related languages. These have little support.

in v7

Does Proverbs 23:6–8 depend on the Egyptian Instruction of Amenemope?

  • Yes, it adapts Amenemope chapter 11.

    The shared images of food choking the throat and being vomited up, set within a collection (22:17–24:22) with many clear Amenemope parallels.

  • The parallel is loose. Shared wisdom themes, not direct borrowing at this point.

    Amenemope's passage concerns coveting a poor man's goods, while Proverbs concerns a stingy host. The wording differs.

in v8

Is the vomiting literal or figurative?

  • A literal reaction: nausea or physical revulsion when the guest realises the host's real attitude.

    The verb is blunt and physical, and Proverbs elsewhere uses it literally (25:16, overeating honey). A meal eaten under a resentful gaze can make a person sick.

  • Figurative or exaggerated: whatever you seemed to gain from the meal is lost and becomes disgusting to you.

    The Amenemope parallel pairs vomiting with being 'emptied of your gain', which is a picture of loss. The second half of the verse, about wasted words, is clearly about lost effort, not about the body.

in v8

What are 'your pleasant words'?

  • The guest's courtesies to the host: thanks, compliments, table talk.

    This fits the banquet setting of vv.6–7 and is reflected in the NIV/NASB rendering 'compliments'.

  • More broadly, the guest's wise and gracious speech, wasted on someone unworthy.

    The adjective na'im is used for wisdom kept within in 22:18 (the start of this collection), and v.9 immediately warns against wasting wise words on a fool.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).