Psalms Chapter 115 Read as one passage
Psalm 115:17–18
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17It is not the dead who praise the LORD, nor any who descend into silence. 18But it is we who will bless the LORD, both now and forevermore. Hallelujah!
What the first hearers heard
For worshipers in Jerusalem, this line did several things at once.
- It gave a reason to praise now. Life is the only time and the earth is the only place for praising Yah, because the Silent Land below has no voice. Verse 18 turns this into a pledge: "But we will bless Yah, from now and forever." "Forever" ('ad-'ôlām) here means the ongoing life of the people from generation to generation. It does not promise individual immortality.
- It answered the nations' taunt. The idols are mute, and those who make them become like them (v. 8), heading for the same silence. Yahweh has a living, singing people. Their voice is the visible proof, on earth, that their God is real.
- It made an argument to God. As in Ps 6:5, 30:9, 88:10–12 and Hezekiah's prayer in Isa 38:18–19, God's praise on earth depends on his people staying alive. So the line is also a quiet appeal: keep us alive, and you will be praised. Psalm 118:17 makes the link explicit: "I shall not die but live, and recount the deeds of Yah."
- It framed the shout itself. Sung in the Hallel at festivals, the verse led straight into the congregation's "Hallelu-Yah!" The worshipers were saying, in effect: we are not the dead, so we will say it.
From the study of Psalm 115:17.
Verse by verse
-
17It is not the dead who praise the LORD, nor any who descend into silence.
Full study →The dead do not shout "Hallelu-Yah", and neither does anyone who has gone down into the Silent Land.
The line opens with an emphatic "Not": it is not the dead who raise Yah's praise. The verb is the word for loud, public acclaim, the same word the congregation is about to shout in the next verse ("Hallelu-Yah!"). "The dead" means everyone who has died, without exception. The second half restates the first and says where they have gone. They are "those going down", the standard phrase for the dying as they descend beneath the earth, and they go down to Dumah, "Silence". This is the realm of the dead under one of its poetic names, the place defined by the fact that no voice sounds there.
The verse is part of a picture of the world. Verse 16 says the heavens belong to Yahweh and the earth has been given to human beings. The dead have gone below. They are as voiceless as the idols mocked earlier in the psalm, which "have mouths but do not speak" (vv. 5–7). Praise is sound, and it rises only from the living. That is why the next verse turns sharply: "But we will bless Yah, from now and for ever. Hallelu-Yah!" The living community must do what the dead cannot. The psalm proves its point by ending on the very shout the dead are unable to give.
-
18But it is we who will bless the LORD, both now and forevermore. Hallelujah!
Full study →"But we — we, the living — will keep on blessing Yah, from this very moment on and through all time to come. All of you: praise Yah!"
The verse only makes sense together with the one before it. Verse 17 has just said that the dead do not praise Yah, nor anyone who goes down into "the Silence", a name for the grave and the underworld. Verse 18 answers with an emphatic "but we." The living, gathered people of God are the ones whose mouths are still open. The psalm has already mocked idols that "have mouths but cannot speak" (v. 5). Now it sets the silent dead and the speechless idols beside a congregation that speaks, and the congregation has the last word.
"We will bless" answers what comes before it. Four times in verses 12–15 the psalm promises that the LORD "will bless" Israel, the priests, and all who fear him. Here the people return the blessing. They cannot give God anything he lacks. Blessing God means declaring him blessed, praising him out loud and with gratitude as the source of every good thing. The verb describes ongoing and resolved action: we will do this and keep doing it.
"Yah" is God's personal name in short form, the form people shouted in worship. "From now until forever" means starting today and never stopping, with the praise handed on from generation to generation for as long as time goes on. The closing "Hallelujah" is a plural command, "all of you, praise Yah!" It calls everyone present to do at once what the dead cannot do.
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
into silence
dûmāh
- What we hear
- Dying quietly, fading out, or a state of hush.
- What they heard
- A place name: the Silent Land, a poetic name for Sheol, the realm of the dead beneath the earth. 'Going down to Dumah' means dying and entering the underworld.
-
in v17
the dead
mētîm
- What we hear
- Readers who believe the faithful departed are already praising God in heaven often take this to mean the spiritually dead or the unbelieving dead. Others take it as a statement that the dead simply no longer exist.
- What they heard
- All who have died, righteous and wicked alike. They have gone down to Sheol and are cut off from the living community's worship. It is a statement about being shut out of praise, not a technical claim about whether the dead are conscious.
-
in v17
praise
hālal (piel)
- What we hear
- An inward feeling of worship, or a style of worship song.
- What they heard
- Loud, public acclaim: telling out God's deeds before others in the assembly. It is the verb behind 'Hallelu-Yah'.
-
in v18
bless the LORD
barakh (nevarekh)
- What we hear
- To give God a blessing or benefit, or to wish good on him, as if he needed something from us.
- What they heard
- To declare God blessed: to speak well of him, praise and thank him as the source of the blessing he has just been asked to give (vv. 12–15).
-
in v18
forevermore
'ad olam
- What we hear
- Praise that goes on forever in heaven or after death.
- What they heard
- Without a break into the time beyond sight. Here it means the living people of God keeping up their praise generation after generation. Verse 17 has just said the dead do not praise.
-
in v18
the LORD
Yah
- What we hear
- A title of rank, 'Lord'.
- What they heard
- The personal name of Israel's God in its short form, the one shouted in worship (as in 'Hallelu-Yah').
Every word
-
לֹ֣א
lō' · H3808
not · v17
Placed first for emphasis: 'Not the dead…'. It sets up the answer in verse 18, which opens with an emphatic 'But we…'.
-
הַ֭מֵּתִים
hammētîm · H4191
the dead (ones) · v17
A participle of the verb 'to die' with the article, so 'the dead' as a whole class: everyone who has died and now lies in the grave or the underworld, with no distinction between good and wicked.
-
יְהַֽלְלוּ־
yəhaləlû · H1984B
they praise · v17, v18
An intensive verb form with an ongoing or general sense, 'they do (not) praise'. It means loud, public acclaim of God, the same word as the closing shout of verse 18, 'Hallelu-Yah'.
-
יָ֑הּ
Yāh · H3050
Yah (short form of the divine name YHWH) · v17, v18
The short form of God's personal name used in hymns and in the cry 'Hallelu-Yah'. 'Yehalelu-Yah' here deliberately echoes 'Hallelu-Yah' in the next verse.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all, any · v17
Leaves no exceptions: not one of those who have made the descent takes part in the praise.
-
יֹרְדֵ֥י
yōrədê · H3381
-
דוּמָֽה׃
dûmāh · H1745
silence; the Silent Land · v17
Not a mood of quiet but a name for the realm of the dead, the place where no voice sounds. In the Psalms it is used this way only here and in Ps 94:17 ('my soul would soon have dwelt in Silence').
-
וַאֲנַ֤חְנוּ
va'anachnu · H0587
and/but we · v18
A separate pronoun is not needed, because the verb already says 'we', so adding it puts stress on it: 'but WE'. It sets the living worshipping community against 'the dead' and 'all who go down into silence' in verse 17.
-
נְבָ֘רֵ֤ךְ
nevarekh · H1288
we will bless · v18
An unfinished-action verb in the intensive form, meaning 'we will bless' or 'we keep blessing'. In a hymn it can also carry a resolve, 'let us bless'. When God is the object, it means to speak of him as blessed: to praise him with thanks for the good he gives. It answers the 'he will bless' (yevarekh) repeated in verses 12–15.
-
מֵֽעַתָּ֥ה
me'attah · H6258
from now · v18
'From this moment.' The praise starts in the present, in the act of worship the psalm itself performs.
-
וְעַד־
ve'ad · H5704
and until · v18
'And as far as.' It marks the far end of a stretch of time that begins 'now'.
-
עוֹלָ֗ם
olam · H5769G
The world behind it
A psalm against idols, sung by the assembly. Psalm 115 answers a taunt from the nations, "Where is their God?" (v. 2). Its answer is that Israel's God is in the heavens and does as he pleases, while the nations' gods are silver and gold, with mouths, eyes, ears and throats that do nothing. Verses 9–11 and 12–13 address in turn "Israel", "the house of Aaron" (the priests) and "you who fear the LORD". This suggests the psalm was performed in the temple with groups answering one another. Most scholars date it after the exile, though this is not certain. In Hebrew manuscripts it sometimes runs on from Psalm 114. The Greek and Latin Bibles join 114 and 115 into one psalm (their Ps 113).
The Hallel. Psalms 113–118 became the "Egyptian Hallel", sung at Passover and the great festivals. The Mishnah (m. Pesachim 10:6–7) describes its use at the Passover meal, and many think it is the hymn mentioned in Matt 26:30 / Mark 14:26. Worshipers singing this line were singing about themselves: they were alive and present, so they could praise.
How Israel pictured death. In most of the Hebrew Bible the dead go down to Sheol, also called the Pit, Abaddon ("Destruction"), and here Dumah ("Silence"). The dead are not exactly nothing: they are "shades" (rəphā'îm), weak and shadowy, and some poems show them stirring (Isa 14:9–10). But they are cut off from the temple, the sacrifices, the festivals and the remembrance of God's deeds (Ps 6:5; 30:9; 88:10–12; Isa 38:18–19). That cutting-off is what this verse means. Praise in Israel was a public act in the assembly, and the dead had left the assembly. Clear hope of a resurrection appears only at the edges of the Hebrew Bible (Isa 26:19; Dan 12:2). Even around 180 BC, Sirach 17:27–28 still repeats this psalm's view.
From the study of Psalm 115:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Does this verse teach what happens to people after death, for instance that the dead are unconscious?
-
It is a statement about the state of the dead: they are unconscious or inactive until a future resurrection.
The flat 'not… nor all' language; parallels such as Ps 6:5, 'in death there is no remembrance of you'; Eccl 9:5, 'the dead know nothing'.
-
It expresses Israel's view of Sheol as being cut off from worship and from the community. It is not a precise teaching on consciousness.
Elsewhere the dead are pictured as shades who can stir and speak (Isa 14:9–10; 1 Sam 28). In the Psalms praise is public and tied to the temple, so the point is exclusion from the praising assembly. Verse 18's contrast is between the dead and 'we', the living congregation, not between kinds of existence.
-
Read within the whole Bible, it describes death before later revelation about resurrection and the afterlife, so later texts complete it.
Isa 26:19 and Dan 12:2 introduce resurrection hope. Later Judaism and the New Testament develop this. On this view the psalm accurately reflects an earlier stage of Israelite understanding.
in v17
Who are 'the dead' here: all the deceased, or a particular group?
-
All who have died, without distinction.
'All who go down to Silence' (kol yōrədê dûmāh) is unrestricted. The parallels in Ps 88 and Isa 38 speak of death in general.
-
Those who are 'dead' like the idols: idolaters or the wicked, in contrast to Israel.
The psalm's contrast between mute idols and those who make them (vv. 4–8). Some early Christian interpreters, including Augustine, gave the verse a spiritual reading. Critics answer that verse 18's contrast ('But we… from now and forever') concerns life against death, not faithful against idolaters.
in v18
Does the contrast with 'the dead' (v. 17) mean the psalmist expected no praise of God after death?
-
Yes, within the psalm's own horizon. It reflects Israel's earlier view of Sheol as a silent place cut off from worship, and the point is that praise belongs to the living now.
Parallel statements in Ps 6:5; 30:9; 88:10–12; Isa 38:18–19. The word dumah ('silence') is used for the realm of the dead (Ps 94:17). 'From now until olam' is a stock phrase for continuity across generations (Ps 113:2; 121:8).
-
The verse states a liturgical contrast rather than a full teaching about the afterlife, and later readers reasonably heard 'forever' as pointing toward unending praise.
Psalms are worship poetry, not doctrinal statements. Later texts such as Dan 12:2 and Second Temple writings develop hope beyond death. The Septuagint's 'we who live' kept the contrast while leaving room for later reflection. Even so, this reading goes beyond what the verse itself says.
in v18
Who exactly is the 'we'?
-
The whole worshipping assembly named in vv. 9–13: Israel, the house of Aaron, and 'those who fear the LORD'.
The same three groups are addressed in vv. 9–11 and blessed in vv. 12–13. The plural command 'halelu' addresses a congregation.
-
'Those who fear the LORD' may include non-Israelite adherents, so the 'we' may be wider than ethnic Israel.
The phrase is listed separately from Israel and Aaron (vv. 11, 13; cf. Ps 118:4; 135:20). Whether it means proselytes or simply all the devout is debated.
Sources
- BDB s.v. דּוּמָה, הָלַל, יָרַד
- HALOT s.v. דּוּמָה I
- Septuagint, Psalm 113:25 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate (Gallican Psalter), Psalm 113:25
- Mishnah Pesachim 5:7; 10:6–7 (Hallel at Passover)
- Sirach 17:27–28; Baruch 2:17
- N. J. Tromp, Primitive Conceptions of Death and the Nether World in the Old Testament (1969)
- P. S. Johnston, Shades of Sheol: Death and Afterlife in the Old Testament (2002)
- L. C. Allen, Psalms 101–150 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- J. Goldingay, Psalms, vol. 3: Psalms 90–150
- Augustine, Expositions of the Psalms (Enarrationes in Psalmos) on Ps 113/115
- BDB s.v. בָּרַךְ, עוֹלָם, הָלַל, יָהּ
- HALOT s.v. ברך, עולם, הלל II, יָהּ
- Septuagint, Psalm 113:26 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Psalm 113:26 (Gallican)
- Leslie C. Allen, Psalms 101–150 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- Hans-Joachim Kraus, Psalms 60–150
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ps 115
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).