Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Romans 9:13–14

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

13So it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.” 14What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Certainly not!

What the first hearers heard

For Malachi's hearers, the line was reassurance with an edge. Discouraged returnees who doubted God's love were told to look at the brother nation: Edom was falling and would not be rebuilt, while Israel had been brought back. They had not earned God's choice. It was his choice, and he had kept it.

For the Roman house churches (a mix of Jewish and Gentile believers, a few years after Jews expelled under Claudius had returned to Rome), Paul's use of the line would have made several points:

  • God's word has not failed. Israel's own history shows that being physically descended from the patriarchs never guaranteed being the heir of the promise. A division within the family is not new.
  • Choice comes before works. The twins were not yet born (9:11). Jacob's later scheming and Esau's later carelessness are not the basis of the choice. This removes every ground for boasting, Jewish or Gentile. Paul presses the same point against Gentile pride in 11:17–24.
  • God's freedom. The line sets up the protest Paul answers next: "Is there injustice with God?" (9:14). He answers with God's word to Moses, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy" (9:15).

Jewish listeners steeped in Scripture would also have caught that Paul applies a text that originally set Israel apart from Edom to show that choosing also operates within Israel. That was an unsettling turn, and it drives the rest of chapters 9–11, which end with mercy extended to all (11:32).

From the study of Romans 9:13.

Verse by verse

  1. 13So it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.”

    "This matches what stands written in Scripture, and still holds: It was Jacob I loved, it was Esau I rejected."

    The line is God speaking, quoted from Malachi 1:2–3. Both halves are pointed in the same way: each name comes first for emphasis, and the two acts are simply set side by side as finished facts. In Malachi, "Jacob" and "Esau" are the two nations that came from Rebekah's twins, Israel and Edom. "Loved" means God chose Jacob and bound himself to him. "Hated" is the matching opposite in the covenant vocabulary of the day. It means to pass over, to reject from the line of promise, to refuse the favored place. It is the word used for the less-favored wife in Genesis and Deuteronomy, and the word used to end a marriage in Jewish legal documents of the period. It is not first of all a word for emotional loathing. But it is not soft either. In Malachi, God's rejection of Edom has visible results: ruined mountains and a people under lasting judgment.

    Paul places this line straight after "the older will serve the younger," a word spoken before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad (9:11–12). His point is that God's purpose has always moved forward by his own choosing, not by birth order, ancestry or performance. That is why he immediately raises the objection "Is God unjust?" (9:14).

    Full study →
  2. 14What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Certainly not!

    "So what are we to conclude from this? Surely there is no wrongdoing on God's side, is there? Surely he is not breaking faith or cheating anyone? Perish the thought!"

    Paul has just said something hard. God chose Isaac and not Ishmael, and Jacob and not Esau, "before they were born or had done anything good or bad" (9:11). Scripture even says, "Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated" (9:13). So Paul stops and voices the objection his listeners are already forming. The question is shaped to expect "no": there isn't injustice with God, is there? The phrase "with God there is no injustice" was already an old confession, sung in the Song of Moses ("a faithful God, without injustice, righteous and upright is he", Deut 32:4). Paul turns that creed into a question.

    The word for injustice (adikia) means doing wrong: failing to give what is owed, wronging someone, breaking one's word. It is the exact opposite of "the righteousness of God", the theme of the whole letter. So the question puts God's character and faithfulness on trial, not just his fairness in some abstract sense. Paul's reply is not a careful "well, in a sense..." but a sharp "may it never come to be!" The idea is pushed away as unthinkable. The next verses give his reasons. God's choosing works in the realm of mercy (9:15, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy"), and mercy by nature is not owed to anyone.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v13

    hated

    emisēsa (Hebrew śāneʾti)

    What we hear
    God felt personal loathing or emotional animosity toward Esau.
    What they heard
    God rejected Esau/Edom from the line of covenant promise and favor. This is the covenant and legal opposite of choosing love, and in Malachi it carried real historical judgment on Edom.
  • in v13

    Jacob / Esau

    Iakōb / Ēsau

    What we hear
    The two individual brothers from Genesis.
    What they heard
    In Malachi, the two nations named after them: Israel and Edom. Genesis 25:23 already calls the unborn twins 'two nations.'
  • in v14

    God forbid (KJV)

    mē genoito

    What we hear
    Either a pious appeal to God or a mild, everyday 'heaven forbid'.
    What they heard
    An absolute rejection, with no mention of God: 'May it never come to be! Perish the thought!' It rejects a wrong conclusion as unthinkable.
  • in v14

    unjust / unfair / unrighteousness

    adikia

    What we hear
    'Unfair' as unequal treatment (if one person is shown mercy, everyone is owed the same), or 'unrighteousness' as general personal sinfulness.
    What they heard
    Wrongdoing: failing to give what is owed, wronging someone, breaking faith or one's word. It is the opposite of God's 'righteousness', his right and faithful dealing. Withholding a gift that was never owed is not adikia.
Every word
  1. καθὼς

    kathōs · G2531

    just as, even as · v13

    Links the quotation to verses 11–12. What Paul has just said about Rebekah's twins (the older will serve the younger, decided before they had done anything) matches what Scripture says elsewhere.

  2. γέγραπται

    gegraptai · G1125

    to write · v13

    Perfect tense: 'it has been written and still stands written.' This was the standard Jewish formula for quoting Scripture as an authority that still applies. Here it introduces Malachi 1:2–3.

  3. τὸν

    ton · G3588

    the · v13, v14

    The article marks 'Jacob' as the object of the verb. The Hebrew name 'Jacob' cannot be declined in Greek, so the article does the job a case ending would do. English leaves it untranslated.

  4. Ἰακὼβ

    Iakōb · G2384H

    Jacob · v13

    In Genesis, the younger twin. In Malachi, the people descended from him, Israel. Paul puts the name first in the sentence for emphasis: 'Jacob, it was Jacob I loved.'

  5. ἠγάπησα

    ēgapēsa · G0025

    to love · v13

    Aorist: a completed act of loving, viewed as a whole. God is the speaker, and in Malachi the love shows in God choosing and keeping Israel as his covenant people. It is love that chooses and stays loyal, not only a feeling.

  6. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and · v13

    Sets the two halves against each other: Jacob on one side, Esau on the other. 'But' is the better English here. YLT's 'and' weakens the contrast.

  7. Ἠσαῦ

    Ēsau · G2269H

    Esau · v13

    The older twin. In Malachi, also the nation of Edom that came from him (Genesis 36:1, 'Esau, that is, Edom'). Like 'Jacob,' it is placed first in its half of the line for emphasis.

  8. ἐμίσησα

    emisēsa · G3404

    to hate · v13

    Aorist, matching 'I loved.' It translates Malachi's Hebrew śānēʾ. In covenant and family language this word meant to reject, to pass over, or to refuse to choose. It was the opposite of covenant love, not chiefly a feeling of loathing. In Malachi it also brings real judgment: Edom's land laid waste.

  9. Τί

    Ti · G5101

    what? · v14

    The object of 'shall we say': 'What are we to conclude?' It opens one of Paul's standard formulas for stopping the argument to test a possible conclusion.

  10. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    therefore, then · v14

    Draws an inference from what has just been said in 9:6–13: God chose Isaac over Ishmael, and Jacob over Esau before either was born or had done anything good or bad. 'Given all that, then...'

  11. ἐροῦμεν

    eroumen · G4483

    we will say · v14

    A future tense used to ask what to do: 'what are we to say?' The 'we' takes the readers into the reasoning with Paul. They are working out the conclusion together, and he is not yet accusing anyone.

  12. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v14

    At the start of a Greek question, mē signals that the speaker expects the answer 'no': 'There isn't injustice with God, is there?' The form of the question already leans toward the denial that follows.

  13. ἀδικία

    adikia · G0093

    injustice, wrongdoing, unrighteousness · v14

    Acting against what is right or owed: wronging someone, or breaking faith. Here the suspicion is that God's choosing (Jacob over Esau, with no reference to merit) would make him unjust, or untrue to his word to Israel. It is the exact opposite of 'the righteousness of God', the theme of the whole letter.

  14. παρὰ

    para · G3844

    beside, with, in the presence of · v14

    With the dative it means 'with, on the side of, in the person of': 'Is injustice found with God, is it part of his dealings?' The same idiom appears in Rom 2:11, 'there is no partiality with God.'

  15. θεῷ

    theō · G2316

    God · v14

    The God of Israel, the one who 'calls' (9:12) and whose word is said not to have failed (9:6). His character is what is on trial in the question.

  16. γένοιτο

    genoito · G1096

    to become, happen, be · v14

    A wish form of 'to come to be': 'may it not come to be!' With mē it is a strong, almost shocked rejection: 'Perish the thought! Absolutely not!' The idea is pushed away as unthinkable.

The world behind it

Malachi's world (5th century BC). The quotation comes from the opening of Malachi, addressed to the small community back in Judah under Persian rule. They were discouraged and asking, "How have you loved us?" God's answer points to their neighbor and kin, Edom ("Esau"). Edom had celebrated and profited when Babylon destroyed Jerusalem (Psalm 137:7; Obadiah). It was now itself being overrun and pushed out of its homeland, as Arab peoples who later became the Nabataeans moved in. Edom vowed to rebuild, and God replies that he will tear it down (Malachi 1:4). Israel's survival, set against Edom's collapse, was the proof of God's choosing love. Malachi 1:2 itself says Esau was "Jacob's brother." The point is not that Israel was better, but that of two brothers one was chosen.

The love/hate vocabulary. In the ancient Near East, "love" and "hate" were the working words of family law and treaties. A king "loved" his loyal vassal, and a vassal swore to "love" his overlord. A husband who "hated" his wife was divorcing her. A father's "loved" and "hated" wives were legal categories (Deuteronomy 21:15–17). Israel's first hearers would have heard the line as a statement about covenant standing: who is in the chosen relationship and who is not.

Paul's argument (Romans 9–11). Paul is grieving that most of his fellow Jews have not accepted Jesus as Messiah (9:1–5). Has God's word failed? No, he says, because "not all who are descended from Israel are Israel" (9:6). God's promise has always worked by choosing within Abraham's physical family: Isaac, not Ishmael (9:7–9); Jacob, not Esau (9:10–13), before either twin had done anything. The sequence continues to Pharaoh (9:17), to the potter and the clay (9:20–23), and in the end to God's purpose to have mercy on all, Jew and Gentile (11:32).

From the study of Romans 9:13.

Where scholars differ

in v13

Is Paul speaking of individuals chosen for salvation, or of peoples chosen for a role in history?

  • Individual election to salvation: Esau and Jacob stand for individuals chosen or passed over with regard to their final destiny.

    The chapter opens with Paul wishing himself 'accursed' (anathema) for his kinsmen (9:3), which concerns salvation. 9:11 stresses that the twins were individuals not yet born. The argument moves to 'vessels of mercy' and 'vessels of wrath' (9:22–23). Held in the tradition of Augustine and Calvin, and argued in detail by J. Piper (*The Justification of God*) and T. Schreiner.

  • Corporate or historical election: the line concerns peoples (Israel and Edom) and the role each plays in God's purpose, not the eternal destiny of individuals.

    Genesis 25:23 speaks of 'two nations,' and the promise 'the older will serve the younger' was never fulfilled in the brothers' own lives but in their nations. Malachi 1:2–5 is plainly about Israel and Edom. Paul's argument ends with God's mercy to all (11:32). Held in various forms by many Arminian and 'New Perspective' interpreters (e.g. J. D. G. Dunn, N. T. Wright, B. Witherington).

  • Mediating: Paul draws on national texts but applies the principle (God's free, unearned choice) to the question of who belongs to the true 'Israel' in his own day.

    9:6 ('not all who are of Israel are Israel') is about membership within the people. C. E. B. Cranfield and D. Moo both note the national setting of the Old Testament texts while treating Paul's application as concerning more than historical role. Moo leans toward individual salvation, Cranfield less so.

in v13

How strong is 'hate' here: 'love less,' 'reject,' or active hostility?

  • Comparative: 'loved less' or 'did not choose.'

    Genesis 29:30–31 (Leah 'hated' = loved less than Rachel), Deuteronomy 21:15–17, and Luke 14:26 compared with Matthew 10:37.

  • Rejection with real disfavor: more than 'love less,' including judgment.

    Malachi 1:3–4 describes Edom's land laid waste and the LORD's lasting anger. The word sits in a prophecy of judgment, not a comparison of affections. The aorist, matched with 'loved,' presents two opposite decisions.

in v14

What exactly is the objection: is God being unfair to individuals, or untrue to his promises to Israel?

  • Mainly about arbitrariness or fairness. If God chooses before anyone has done good or bad, he seems to treat people unequally, and that looks unjust.

    The objection comes straight after 9:11 ('before they were born or had done anything good or bad'). Paul's answer speaks of mercy and hardening of particular figures (Moses, Pharaoh, 9:15–18). The follow-up objection in 9:19 ('Why does he still find fault? Who resists his will?') is about individual blame. Commentators such as Cranfield, Moo and Schreiner tend to stress this.

  • Mainly about God's faithfulness to his word. If most of Israel is now outside, has God broken his covenant promise?

    The section opens with 'it is not as though the word of God has failed' (9:6). Chapters 9–11 are about Israel as a people. Malachi 1:2–3 refers to the nations Israel and Edom. In Rom 3:3–5 adikia stands against God's faithfulness (pistis) and truthfulness. Commentators such as Dunn and Wright stress this.

  • Both are in view. The fairness question arises inside the question of God's faithfulness.

    Adikia covers both wronging someone and breaking faith. Paul's answer (God's freedom to show mercy, 9:15–16) speaks to both at once. Many commentators combine the readings.

in v14

Is the 'choosing' that prompts this objection about individuals or about peoples?

  • Individual election: God chooses particular persons.

    Jacob and Esau are named individuals. Pharaoh is a person. 9:16 speaks of 'the one who wills or runs' and 9:19 of 'who' in the singular. The objection of injustice is sharpest if individuals are in view.

  • Corporate or historical election: God chooses peoples and their roles in his purpose.

    Gen 25:23, quoted in 9:12, says 'two nations are in your womb'. Mal 1:2–3, quoted in 9:13, concerns Israel and Edom. The whole of chapters 9–11 concerns Israel and the gentiles as groups, and ends with mercy on 'all' (11:32).

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. μισέω
  • BDAG s.v. ἀγαπάω
  • HALOT s.v. שׂנא
  • BDB s.v. אָהֵב
  • Septuagint, Malachi 1:2–4; Genesis 25:23
  • Genesis 29:30–31; Deuteronomy 21:15–17; Luke 14:26 with Matthew 10:37
  • W. L. Moran, 'The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy,' CBQ 25 (1963)
  • Elephantine Aramaic marriage contracts (e.g. TAD B2.6 / Cowley 15), 'hate' as divorce formula
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.257–258 (Idumeans)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • J. Piper, The Justification of God
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:13
  • BDAG s.v. ἀδικία
  • BDAG s.v. γίνομαι (μὴ γένοιτο)
  • BDAG s.v. παρά (with dative)
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §§384, 427 (optative of wish; μή in questions)
  • Septuagint: Deut 32:4; 2 Chr 19:7; Ps 91:16 (Eng. 92:15); Gen 44:7, 17; Josh 22:29
  • Epictetus, Discourses 1.1.13; 1.2.35
  • A. J. Malherbe, 'ΜΗ ΓΕΝΟΙΤΟ in the Diatribe and Paul', Harvard Theological Review 73 (1980)
  • S. K. Stowers, The Diatribe and Paul's Letter to the Romans (1981)
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC 38B)
  • R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:14

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).