Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Romans 9:15–16

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15For He says to Moses: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.” 16So then, it does not depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy.

What the first hearers heard

To Jewish believers in Rome, and to Gentile believers who knew the synagogue Scriptures, this quotation said several things at once:

  • God has not broken faith. The objection was that if God passes over physical Israel, he is unjust or his promises have failed. Paul answers from the Torah itself. God's way of dealing with Israel was always free mercy, so his present way of working is consistent with his character, not a departure from it.
  • Mercy cannot be owed. Everyone knew that Israel survived the golden calf only because God chose to be gracious. Quoting the words spoken to Moses then took away any sense that descent from Abraham, or keeping the law, put God in one's debt (9:16).
  • The quote reveals God's name. In Exodus the saying comes just before God proclaims his name as "compassionate and gracious". Hearers steeped in Exodus 34:6, a text repeated across the Psalms and Prophets, would hear God's freedom and God's compassion together, not in tension.
  • Room for Gentiles, and hope for Israel. If mercy rests on God's own will and not on ancestry, then God can show it to Gentiles (9:24–26). Paul's later chapters show he can also show it again to Israel (11:31–32). Gentile believers had no grounds for boasting (11:18–20), and Jewish believers had no grounds for despair.

From the study of Romans 9:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15For He says to Moses: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.”

    "God is not unjust. Look at what he says, in Scripture still speaking, to Moses himself, at the moment Israel had just broken the covenant with the golden calf and deserved nothing: 'I will show mercy (act in pity, help and spare) to whomever I show mercy, and I will feel deep, parental compassion for whomever I feel compassion.'"

    The saying is deliberately circular. God gives no outside reason, no qualification in the person, that obliges his mercy. Its only source is God, and it is spoken in the same breath in which he proclaims his name as "compassionate and gracious" (Exodus 34:6). The two lines say one thing twice. The first stresses mercy as something done, the rescue of the undeserving. The second stresses the feeling behind it, a pity as close as a mother's for the child of her womb.

    In Paul's argument this is his answer to the charge "Is God unjust?" Mercy that could be demanded would not be mercy. If Israel itself survived the calf only because God freely chose to be gracious, then no one can accuse God of wrongdoing for showing or withholding mercy as he wills. That includes Israel by descent, the Gentiles, or anyone striving to earn it.

    Full study →
  2. 16So then, it does not depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy.

    "So then, it follows: the outcome does not come from the person who wants it, or from the person who runs hard for it. It comes from God, the one who shows mercy."

    Paul is drawing a conclusion from what God said to Moses in Exodus 33:19, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy." The Greek is compressed, almost like a proverb. It has no verb and no stated subject, only three figures. Two are human and left without names: the one who wants and the one who runs. These cover human effort from inner desire to outward striving, pictured as a runner straining in a race. The third figure is named and comes last for emphasis: God, the one who shows mercy. "Mercy" here is more than letting someone off a punishment. It is God's active, freely given kindness to people who have no claim on it. In the Exodus story he showed that kindness to Israel just after the golden calf, when it had forfeited every right to his presence.

    The "it" left unsaid is God's choosing in 9:11–12: Isaac rather than Ishmael, Jacob rather than Esau, and his decision to keep a rebellious people. The deciding factor is the free and generous will of a God whose character is to show mercy, not human wanting or human striving. Paul is not saying people do not want or run. He is saying that their wanting and running is not what decides the matter. Later in the same argument he shows where this leads: God "has shut up all in disobedience so that he may have mercy on all" (11:32).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    have mercy

    eleeō

    What we hear
    To let an offender off, to hold back a deserved penalty, as in 'throw yourself on the mercy of the court'.
    What they heard
    To feel pity and act on it: to help, rescue or spare someone in need or in the wrong. Here it translates Hebrew ḥanan, 'to be gracious, to show favour'. Sparing the guilty is part of it (the golden-calf setting), but the word is broader and warmer: favour freely given.
  • in v16

    mercy

    eleeō

    What we hear
    Leniency: holding back a punishment someone deserves, as a judge reduces a sentence.
    What they heard
    Active, freely given kindness and compassion toward someone in need who has no claim on it. In Jewish Greek it is tied to God's gracious favour (ḥānan) and loyal covenant love (ḥesed). In Exodus 33:19, the verse behind this one, it means God choosing to keep a guilty people and go with them.
  • in v16

    him that willeth / human will

    thelōn (from thelō)

    What we hear
    The philosophical 'free will', the faculty of choosing, as argued in theological debates about whether humans can choose God.
    What they heard
    Simply 'the one who wants / wishes / intends'. It is ordinary human desire and purpose, paired with 'running' to cover inner wanting and outward effort.
Every word
  1. τῷ

    tō · G3588

    the · v15, v16

    The article goes with 'Moses'. Greek often puts an article before a personal name. English leaves it out.

  2. Μωϋσεῖ

    Mōusei · G3475

    Moses · v15

    'To Moses' comes first in the Greek sentence, which puts weight on it. The words were spoken to Israel's lawgiver and go-between with God, at the very moment he was pleading for a people who had just sinned with the golden calf (Exodus 33).

  3. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v15

    This gives the reason for Paul's flat 'Certainly not!' in 9:14. God is not unjust, and here is why: Scripture shows that mercy has always been his to give.

  4. λέγει

    legei · G3004

    he says · v15

    Present tense, 'he says'. The subject is God, carried over from 'God' in 9:14. Paul quotes Scripture as God speaking now, not only as a report of something said long ago.

  5. ἐλεήσω

    eleēsō · G1653

    to have mercy, show pity · v15, v16

    Future: 'I will show mercy.' This is the verb of pity that acts: helping or sparing someone in need or in the wrong. In the Greek Old Testament (the Septuagint) it stands here for the Hebrew ḥanan, 'to be gracious, show favour'.

  6. ὃν

    hon · G3739

    whom · v15

    'Whom', the object of the mercy. Together with ἄν it makes an open-ended 'whomever'.

  7. ἂν

    an · G302

    (-ever) · v15

    A small particle that leaves the relative clause open: 'whoever it may be'. It is not 'maybe' in the sense of doubt. It marks the person as not specified in advance.

  8. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v15

    Joins two parallel lines that say the same thing in two ways, as Hebrew poetry and speech often do.

  9. οἰκτιρήσω

    oiktirēsō · G3627

    to have compassion, pity · v15

    Future: 'I will have pity.' This word puts more weight on the feeling, a deep inner pity. In the Septuagint it stands for Hebrew raḥam, a verb related to the word for 'womb'.

  10. ἄρα

    ara · G0686

    so, then, consequently · v16

    Marks a conclusion. Paul is drawing out what follows from the Exodus quotation he has just given in 9:15.

  11. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    therefore, then · v16

    Paired with ara as 'ara oun', a combination Paul is fond of (Rom 5:18; 7:3, 25; 8:12; 9:18). It means 'so then, it follows that' and makes this verse the stated conclusion of 9:15.

  12. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v16

    A flat, factual denial. The Greek has no subject and no verb here. Something like 'it is not' has to be supplied, and every English 'it' is an addition.

  13. θέλοντος

    thelontos · G2309

    to want, wish, will · v16

    'The one who wants / wills.' A present participle, describing someone defined by wanting or intending. It is ordinary human desire and purpose, not a technical philosophical 'free will'.

  14. οὐδὲ

    oude · G3761

    nor, and not · v16

    Adds a second denial that runs parallel to the first. Neither the inner wanting nor the outward striving is the deciding factor.

  15. τρέχοντος

    trechontos · G5143

    to run · v16

    'The one who runs.' A vivid picture of a runner in a race, straining and exerting himself. Paul uses running elsewhere for strenuous effort in the life of faith and in his ministry. Here it stands for human exertion, the outward counterpart to wanting.

  16. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but, rather · v16

    A strong contrast ('not this … but that'), shifting the deciding factor away from the human figures entirely.

  17. θεοῦ.

    theou · G2316

    God · v16

    Placed last for emphasis. The two human figures are left anonymous ('the one who wants', 'the one who runs'), but the third is named: it is God.

The world behind it

The quotation. Paul quotes the Greek Old Testament of Exodus 33:19 word for word. The Hebrew is weḥannoti et-asher aḥon, weriḥamti et-asher araḥem, "I will be gracious to whom I am gracious, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion." The scene comes straight after the golden calf (Exodus 32). God had threatened to wipe the people out and had said he would no longer go up among them (33:3). Moses pleads, then asks, "Show me your glory." God answers that he will make his goodness pass before Moses, proclaim his name YHWH, and be gracious as he wills. The next day he proclaims that name: "compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in loyal love and faithfulness" (34:6–7). So in its first setting the saying is God's free decision to keep going with a people who had forfeited everything.

Paul's argument. Romans 9 opens with Paul's grief that most of his fellow Jews have not accepted Jesus as Messiah. That raises the question of whether God's word has failed (9:6). Paul argues that God's purpose has always moved through his own call, not through physical descent alone: Isaac, not Ishmael; Jacob, not Esau, "before they were born or had done anything good or bad" (9:11). The obvious objection follows: "Is God unjust?" (9:14). Paul answers with two scenes from Exodus. One is mercy to sinful Israel (9:15). The other is God's purpose with Pharaoh (9:17). A Jewish hearer would know both scenes well, and the first was uncomfortable: Israel's own existence as a covenant people rested on unearned mercy after apostasy.

Where the word leads. The verb "show mercy" runs through Romans 9–11 and comes to its peak in 11:30–32. There Gentiles and Jews alike are said to receive mercy, and God "has bound all over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all."

From the study of Romans 9:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

What kind of mercy is in view: individuals' eternal salvation, or God's purpose with peoples (Israel and the Gentiles) in history?

  • Mercy toward individuals, deciding who is saved. Paul defends God's freedom to choose particular people for salvation (an Augustinian and Reformed reading, e.g. Piper, Schreiner, and in modified form Moo).

    9:16 denies that the outcome depends on human willing or running. 9:18 pairs mercy with hardening. 9:22–23 speaks of 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. And Paul's grief in 9:1–3 is about his kinsmen being cut off from Christ, which seems to concern salvation itself.

  • Mercy in God's dealings with peoples and his historical purpose. The issue is how God forms his covenant people (Gentiles included, Israel's unbelief only partial and temporary), not the fixed fate of each individual (e.g. Dunn, Wright, Abasciano, and in part Cranfield).

    The Old Testament examples concern nations and roles: Jacob and Esau stand for Israel and Edom (Genesis 25:23; Malachi 1:2–3), and Pharaoh's hardening served God's purpose in history. Exodus 33:19 is about mercy to a whole people. And the argument ends in 11:32 with mercy 'on all', where the groups in view are Jews and Gentiles.

in v15

What does the repeated formula 'I will be gracious to whom I am gracious' stress?

  • God's sovereign freedom. God declines to name any condition outside himself, which closes off debate (Lundbom).

    The same pattern elsewhere ends discussion (compare Exodus 3:14). Paul uses the verse to answer the charge of injustice, and 9:16 spells out that the outcome lies in God, not in human effort.

  • The certainty and fullness of God's grace. In Exodus it reassures Moses that God really will be gracious to sinful Israel, not merely that he is free to choose.

    In context Moses is asking whether God will still go with the people (33:12–17). God agrees, and then proclaims his name as compassionate and gracious (34:6–7). On this view freedom and generosity belong together, since mercy that is free cannot be cancelled by Israel's sin either.

in v16

What is the unstated 'it' that does not depend on willing or running?

  • Individual salvation: whether a particular person receives saving mercy depends only on God's choice, not on that person's will or effort.

    The individual examples (Jacob, Esau, Pharaoh), the language of 9:18 ('he has mercy on whom he wants, and he hardens whom he wants'), and the potter imagery of 9:20–23 with 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. This view is held in the Augustinian and Reformed tradition (e.g. Augustine, To Simplician 1.2; modern exegetes such as J. Piper and T. Schreiner).

  • God's choice of people for a role in his saving purposes in history (Isaac's line, Jacob's people, Moses, even Pharaoh), rather than the final destiny of individuals.

    Genesis 25:23, behind 9:12, concerns two nations and which serves which. Pharaoh is 'raised up' to display God's power (9:17). The whole argument answers a question about Israel as a people (9:6). Associated with readings by C. E. B. Cranfield (in part), J. D. G. Dunn and N. T. Wright.

  • God's mercy toward a people, as a group: God is free to define who his covenant people are and to include gentiles on the basis of faith, not descent or law-works.

    Exodus 33, the source of the quotation, is about God's mercy to the whole nation after the golden calf. 9:24–26 applies the argument to 'us, whom he called, not only from the Jews but also from the gentiles'. 9:30–32 explains the outcome in terms of faith versus works. 11:32 has mercy on 'all'. Argued in detail by B. J. Abasciano and others.

in v16

Does the verse deny that human willing and running play any part?

  • It denies that they are the source or basis of mercy, not that they exist or matter. People want and run, but God's mercy is what decides.

    Paul elsewhere commands running (1 Cor 9:24) and in this same section speaks of faith and calling on the Lord as the way righteousness is received (9:30–10:13). Early on, Origen (On First Principles 3.1.18) compared it to a ship arriving safely: the sailors' work is real, but the safe arrival is rightly credited to God.

  • It denies that human willing and running have any decisive role in who receives mercy. God's mercy comes first and decides who will in fact want and run.

    The strict 'not … nor … but' contrast. The parallel 'not from works but from the one who calls' (9:11–12), said before the twins were born. 9:18's 'whom he wants'. This was developed by the later Augustine and the Reformers.

in v16

Do 'willing' and 'running' allude to a specific story?

  • They are general pictures of human desire and effort, with running drawn from athletics as elsewhere in Paul.

    Paul regularly uses trechō in this way (1 Cor 9:24–26; Gal 2:2; 5:7; Phil 2:16), and the race picture continues in 9:30–32. This is the majority view.

  • They echo Genesis 27: Isaac's wish to bless Esau and Esau's hurrying out to hunt, both of which failed to stop Jacob receiving the blessing.

    It fits the Jacob–Esau context of 9:10–13. But the LXX of Genesis 27 does not use trechō, so the verbal link is weak, and most commentators doubt it.

Sources
  • Septuagint, Exodus 33:19; Masoretic Text, Exodus 33:19; 34:6–7
  • BDAG s.v. ἐλεέω, ἔλεος
  • BDAG s.v. οἰκτίρω, οἰκτιρμός
  • HALOT s.v. חנן, רחם
  • J. R. Lundbom, 'God's Use of the Idem per Idem to Terminate Debate', Harvard Theological Review 71 (1978)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:14–18
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:15
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • J. Piper, The Justification of God: An Exegetical and Theological Study of Romans 9:1–23
  • B. J. Abasciano, Paul's Use of the Old Testament in Romans 9.10–18
  • N. T. Wright, 'The Letter to the Romans' (New Interpreter's Bible)
  • BDAG s.v. ἐλεέω
  • BDAG s.v. τρέχω
  • BDAG s.v. θέλω
  • LSJ s.v. τρέχω
  • LXX Exodus 33:19; 34:6
  • NA28 critical apparatus at Rom 9:16
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
  • James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • Thomas R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
  • N. T. Wright, 'Romans', New Interpreter's Bible vol. 10
  • Brian J. Abasciano, Paul's Use of the Old Testament in Romans 9.10–18
  • John Piper, The Justification of God
  • Augustine, Ad Simplicianum 1.2
  • Origen, De Principiis 3.1.18

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).