Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Romans 9:11–12
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11Yet before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad, in order that God’s plan of election might stand, 12not by works but by Him who calls, she was told, “The older will serve the younger.”
What the first hearers heard
The Roman congregations were a mix of Jewish and non-Jewish believers. They would have heard this verse as part of Paul's defence of God's faithfulness. Everyone knew the story of Jacob and Esau and knew that Israel descended from Jacob. Paul turns that familiar story into a principle: from the start, belonging to the line of promise depended on God's call, not on birth rights or a record of deeds.
For Jewish hearers this cut both ways. It upheld Israel's own origin in God's free choice of Jacob. It also undercut any assumption that physical descent from Abraham or performance of the law automatically secured a place in the promise (9:6–8, 9:32). For non-Jewish hearers it explained how they could be included at all: if God's purpose works by calling and not by pedigree, the door is open to the nations (9:24–26). Paul will later warn them against arrogance toward Israel (11:18–24).
The emphasis falls on God's purpose standing, that is, on his reliability. The verse is not a standalone discussion of individual eternal destiny. It is a step in an argument that ends in praise of God's mercy (11:32–36).
From the study of Romans 9:11.
Verse by verse
-
11Yet before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad, in order that God’s plan of election might stand,
Full study →Before the twins had even been born, before either had done anything at all, good or worthless, God spoke. He did it this way so that his purpose would be seen to work by his own choosing, and so that the purpose would keep standing and stay in force. It does not hang on birth order, ancestry or anyone's record of deeds.
Paul is building an argument. In verse 6 he insisted that God's word "has not fallen", even though much of Israel had not accepted Jesus as Messiah. He then shows that God's promise has always worked by selection within Abraham's family. First came Isaac and not Ishmael, but someone could say they had different mothers. So Paul takes the clearest case possible: one mother, one father, one pregnancy, twins. Even there, the oracle given to Rebekah (Genesis 25:23, quoted in v.12) named the younger, Jacob, over the older, Esau, while they were still in the womb.
The phrase "good or bad" means "anything whatsoever". The Greek phaulos is "base, worthless" rather than lurid "evil". The verse does not say Esau was wicked or Jacob was virtuous. It says that neither had any record yet. "God's purpose by way of selection" (hē kat' eklogēn prothesis) describes a resolve God set before himself that operates by choosing. And "might stand" (menē) carries the sense of remaining in force: Paul's answer to the fear that God's word had failed.
What exactly Jacob was chosen for, whether to carry the covenant line and the destiny of a people, or to personal eternal salvation, the verse itself does not say. Readers have debated it since the early church (see debates).
-
12not by works but by Him who calls, she was told, “The older will serve the younger.”
Full study →The choice did not come out of anything the boys did. It came out of the One who calls, the God who summons people and nations into what they are to be. So, while the twins were still in Rebekah's womb, God told her: "The greater one will be subject, like a slave, to the lesser one."
"Greater" and "lesser" mean firstborn and second-born, but the words also carry size and rank. In their world the firstborn was the one expected to inherit, lead and be honored. God's word reverses that order before birth, before either child has done anything good or bad. "Will serve" is a prediction of subjection, not of helpfulness: one line ruled by the other. In Genesis the oracle explicitly concerns "two nations… two peoples" (Gen 25:23), Israel and Edom. Paul cites it to show that from the very start, who belonged to the line of promise was decided by God's calling, not by descent or performance.
Where the English drifted
-
in v11
election
eklogē
- What we hear
- Either a political vote, or a fixed doctrinal system in which individuals are chosen for heaven (and others passed over for hell).
- What they heard
- Choice, selection, the act of picking out. Here it is God's picking the younger twin over the older to carry the promise. The word itself does not settle what the choice is to or how far it reaches.
-
in v11
evil (KJV: 'good or evil')
phaulos (Byzantine text: kakos)
- What we hear
- Dramatic, malicious wickedness, suggesting the verse is about whether Esau was a villain.
- What they heard
- Worthless or base conduct. 'Good or bad' together means 'anything at all'. The point is that no deeds existed yet.
-
in v12
serve
douleuō
- What we hear
- Help, assist, do something useful for someone, often willingly (as in 'public service' or 'customer service').
- What they heard
- To be in a slave's position, to be subject to another's rule. Here it describes one people becoming the vassal of another.
-
in v12
the older … the younger
ho meizōn … tō elassoni
- What we hear
- A simple statement of age.
- What they heard
- 'The greater … the lesser': birth order, but also rank, size and expected status. The firstborn was the one born to rule.
Every word
-
μήπω
mēpō · G3361
not yet · v11
Places the event before the twins' birth. Paul's whole point depends on this timing: the decision came before either boy had a life story.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v11
Explains why Rebekah's case (v.10) matters. It is an even clearer example than Isaac and Ishmael, because here there is one father, one mother and one pregnancy.
-
γεννηθέντων
gennēthentōn · G1080
to beget; (passive) to be born · v11
Aorist passive participle in the genitive. The phrase stands apart from the main sentence and its subject ('they', the twins) is left unstated. 'Not yet having been born'.
-
μηδὲ
mēde · G3366
nor, and not · v11
Adds a second 'not yet'. They had not been born, and they had not acted.
-
πραξάντων
praxantōn · G4238
to do, practise, carry out · v11
'Having done'. The word is about conduct and deeds, so it sets up the 'not from works' that follows in v.12.
-
τι
ti · G5100
something, anything · v11
'Anything at all'. No act of any kind, good or bad, had yet taken place.
-
ἀγαθὸν
agathon · G0018
good · v11
Good as a deed. It is the positive half of a stock pair that covers every kind of conduct.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v11
Joins the two halves of the 'good or bad' pair.
-
φαῦλον
phaulon · G5337
worthless, poor, base, bad · v11
The opposite of 'good'. It means base or worthless conduct, not necessarily monstrous wickedness. Paul uses the same pairing in 2 Corinthians 5:10.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
in order that · v11
States the purpose. God made the announcement before birth so that his choosing purpose would be seen to rest on him and not on their record.
-
ἡ
hē · G3588
the · v11, v12
Article for 'purpose'. It wraps around 'according to election' and turns that phrase into a description of the purpose: 'the election-shaped purpose'.
-
κατ᾽
kat᾽ · G2596
according to, by way of · v11
Says how the purpose works: by selection, by picking one rather than the other.
-
ἐκλογὴν
eklogēn · G1589
choice, selection · v11
The act of choosing out. Here it is God's choice of the younger twin, Jacob, over the older, Esau, for the line of promise (v.12, Gen 25:23).
-
πρόθεσις
prothesis · G4286
purpose, resolve; a setting forth · v11
God's set intention, decided beforehand. The same word appears in Romans 8:28, 'called according to his purpose'.
-
θεοῦ
theou · G2316
God · v11
'Of God'. The purpose belongs to God, the one who calls (v.12).
-
μένῃ
menē · G3306
to remain, stay, abide · v11
Present subjunctive: 'might keep standing, remain in force'. It answers v.6, where Paul insists God's word has not 'fallen'.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v12
Flat negation. Opens the phrase that rules out human deeds as the basis of God's choice. (Not in the supplied word list; see textual notes on verse division.)
-
ἐξ
ex · G1537
out of, from · v12
Marks the source or basis: God's purpose does not come *out of* works.
-
ἔργων
ergōn · G2041
work, deed · v12
Deeds, things done. In context it echoes verse 11, 'before they had done anything good or bad'. Whether Paul also has in mind his usual phrase 'works of the law' is discussed in the debates.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G235
but · v12
Strong contrast: not this, but that.
-
καλοῦντος
kalountos · G2564
-
ἐρρέθη
errethē · G2046
to say, speak · v12
Aorist passive, 'it was said'. The speaker is not named, but in Genesis 25:23 it is the LORD answering Rebekah. This is a common Jewish way of letting God be the unspoken speaker.
-
αὐτῇ
autē · G846
her · v12
Rebekah, named in verse 10, pregnant with twins by one man, Isaac. Paul stresses this to rule out every difference of parentage.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v12
Here it works like opening quotation marks. It introduces the words of the oracle exactly.
-
μείζων
meizōn · G3173
greater, bigger, older · v12
Comparative of 'great'. In Genesis it means the firstborn, Esau. But the word also carries size, rank and standing, so the reversal is sharper than 'older' alone suggests.
-
δουλεύσει
douleusei · G1398
to be a slave, serve, be subject to · v12
Future tense, a prophecy. It means to be in subjection as a slave or vassal: a reversal of status, not helping out.
-
ἐλάσσονι
elassoni · G1640
lesser, smaller, younger, inferior · v12
'The lesser', meaning Jacob, the second-born. Like 'greater', it suggests lower rank as well as younger age.
The world behind it
The Genesis story behind the verse. Rebekah's pregnancy was troubled. The twins "struggled within her", and when she asked the LORD, she was told: "Two nations are in your womb… the older will serve the younger" (Genesis 25:22–23). In the ancient Near East the firstborn son normally inherited leadership and a double share; this is called primogeniture. An oracle reversing that order before birth was a striking statement that the outcome was God's doing. The twins became the ancestors of Israel (Jacob) and Edom (Esau). Paul's next quotation, Malachi 1:2–3 ("Jacob I loved, Esau I hated"), comes from a prophet speaking about the two nations centuries later.
How Jews of Paul's day explained the choice. Jewish interpreters often looked for a reason in the boys' character. Jubilees 19 and later rabbinic traditions (e.g. Genesis Rabbah 63) portray Esau as wicked from early on, even in the womb. Philo of Alexandria, on the other hand, noted that God named one ruler and one subject before birth (Allegorical Laws 3.88–89), much as Paul does. Paul deliberately sides with the "before birth, before deeds" reading, to shut out any explanation based on merit.
Why Paul raises it. Romans 9–11 deals with an anguished question for a Jewish apostle in the 50s AD. If Jesus is Israel's Messiah, why have most Israelites not believed, and does that mean God's promises to Israel have failed (9:1–6)? Paul answers that God's promise has always worked through his own choosing, not through physical descent alone. The argument ends in chapter 11 with a remnant "according to the selection of grace" (11:5), and with the hope that "all Israel will be saved" (11:26).
From the study of Romans 9:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
Is the choice of Jacob over Esau about individual eternal salvation, or about roles and peoples in God's plan?
-
Individual election to salvation. Paul uses Jacob and Esau to show that God chooses individuals for salvation unconditionally (associated with Augustine and the Reformed tradition, and argued at length by some modern commentators).
Romans 9 begins with Paul's grief that his kinsmen are 'accursed' (9:3), so salvation is at stake. 'Not from works but from the one who calls' (v.12) echoes Paul's salvation language. Verses 9:15–23 speak of mercy, hardening, and 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. The singular pronouns in 9:18–19 suggest individuals.
-
Election to a role in salvation history, and of peoples. The choice concerns which line carries the promise and what Israel and Edom become, not the eternal destiny of each twin.
Genesis 25:23 speaks of 'two nations', and the oracle is about *serving* ('the older will serve the younger'), which Esau personally never did. Malachi 1:2–3 (v.13) concerns the nations Israel and Edom. The argument of Romans 9–11 is about Israel as a whole and ends with mercy on all (11:32).
-
Mediating views. Paul's point is God's freedom to choose without regard to merit, applied in his own day to Israel and the nations and to who belongs to the true 'Israel' (9:6). The question of individuals is real but not the focus of verse 11.
In the verse itself the subject is God's 'purpose' remaining, answering 9:6. Paul moves between corporate examples (nations) and individual ones (Pharaoh, 'whom he wills').
in v11
Does 'not having done anything good or bad' rule out choice based on foreseen future deeds or faith?
-
Yes. Paul's wording and the contrast with 'works' exclude any basis in the twins themselves, including foreseen conduct.
The emphasis on 'before birth' and 'not from works but from the one who calls'. Paul's next question, 'Is there injustice with God?' (9:14), would only arise if the choice had no basis in the person.
-
Paul rules out *works* and birth rights specifically, so a choice in view of foreseen faith is not addressed (a view found in some early Greek commentators and in Arminian readings).
Romans 9:30–32 contrasts righteousness 'from faith' with 'from works'. Romans 8:29 says 'those whom he foreknew'.
in v12
Is Paul talking about individuals chosen for salvation, or about peoples chosen for a role in God's purposes?
-
Corporate and historical: the oracle concerns the nations Israel and Edom and their roles in salvation history. Paul uses it to show that God's choosing has always been free of lineage and merit, not to decide the eternal fate of Jacob and Esau as individuals.
Genesis 25:23 explicitly says 'two nations… two peoples'. Esau personally never served Jacob, and the fulfillment is national (2 Sam 8:14). Malachi 1:2-5, quoted in v.13, is about Edom as a nation. Romans 9-11 is about Israel and the Gentiles as groups and ends in mercy on 'all' (11:32). Commentators taking broadly this line include J.D.G. Dunn and N.T. Wright, and in part C.E.B. Cranfield.
-
Individual: Paul applies the oracle to God's free choice of particular persons for salvation, and Jacob and Esau are examples of that.
The problem Paul raises is the salvation of his kinsmen, for whom he would wish himself 'accursed' (9:3). He stresses the individual twins, 'not yet born', 'one conceived' (9:10-11). Verses 14-23 talk about mercy and hardening of individuals ('on whom he wills', 9:18). Commentators taking this line include D. Moo, T. Schreiner and J. Piper.
-
Mixed: the two cannot be cleanly separated. Paul's argument moves from historical election (peoples, roles) to the present question of who belongs to the true 'Israel'.
9:6-8 defines 'children of the promise' within physical Israel, and 9:24 speaks of 'us whom he called'. Both corporate and individual language appear in the chapter.
in v12
What are the 'works' that God's choice was 'not from'?
-
Human deeds in general, good or bad.
Verse 11 defines the context: 'before they had done anything good or bad'. The phrase has no 'of the law'.
-
Paul also has in mind 'works of the law', the Torah practices (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath) that marked Jews off from others, as in 3:20, 28.
This is Paul's normal use of 'works' in Romans, and 9:32 says Israel pursued righteousness 'as if from works'. Proponents point to 'New Perspective on Paul' readers (e.g. Dunn). Critics answer that Jacob and Esau lived before the Law was given, which favors the general sense here.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἐκλογή, πρόθεσις, μένω, φαῦλος
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἐκλογή, φαῦλος
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Romans 9:11
- Psalms of Solomon 9:4
- Philo, Legum Allegoriae 3.88–89
- Jubilees 19; Genesis Rabbah 63
- Genesis 25:21–26; Malachi 1:2–3 (LXX)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- T. R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Romans 9
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., Rom 9:11-12
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Genesis 25:23
- BDAG s.v. δουλεύω, μέγας, ἐλάσσων, καλέω, ἔργον
- HALOT s.v. רַב, צָעִיר, עבד
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.257-258 (Idumean conquest)
- Jubilees 19; 35 (Jacob and Esau traditions)
- J.D.G. Dunn, Romans 9-16 (WBC)
- D. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- C.E.B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- T. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Rom 9
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).