Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Romans 9:18–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18Therefore God has mercy on whom He wants to have mercy, and He hardens whom He wants to harden. 19One of you will say to me, “Then why does God still find fault? For who can resist His will?”
What the first hearers heard
For Paul's Roman hearers, this line did several things.
- It defended God's faithfulness. If most of Israel was not responding to the Messiah, that did not mean God's promise had failed. God had always given mercy freely and had never owed it to descent from Abraham or to effort (9:6–16).
- It humbled every party. Jewish believers could not treat mercy as a birthright, and Gentile believers could not treat it as an achievement. Both received it only because God willed to give it. Paul makes that warning explicit to Gentiles in 11:17–22: "do not be arrogant, but fear."
- It recalled the Exodus. Pharaoh's hardening had served a wider purpose, so that God's name would be "proclaimed in all the earth." That prepared hearers for Paul's claim that Israel's present partial hardening is serving the spread of the message to the nations (11:11–15).
- It raised a question on purpose. The bluntness of the line provokes the objection in v.19. That pushes the hearer toward Paul's eventual answer, which is not a system but praise: "Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God!" (11:33).
To first-century Jewish ears, the statement that God both shows mercy and hardens as he wills would not have sounded strange in itself. Exodus said it, and Jewish thought already gave God that kind of control. The shock was in who now stood in Pharaoh's place and who received mercy.
From the study of Romans 9:18.
Verse by verse
-
18Therefore God has mercy on whom He wants to have mercy, and He hardens whom He wants to harden.
Full study →"So then: the one he chooses, he shows mercy to; and the one he chooses, he hardens."
Paul is drawing a conclusion. The verse is built from the two passages of Exodus he has just quoted, and it sets them side by side in two halves of the same shape:
- Mercy comes from Exodus 33:19. God said, "I will be gracious to whom I will be gracious," at the moment when Israel had just worshipped the golden calf and deserved to be wiped out. So "showing mercy" means active, compassionate kindness to people who have no claim on it: sparing, helping, restoring. It is not just a lighter sentence.
- Hardening comes from Pharaoh (Exodus 9:16, quoted in v.17). To "harden" someone, in biblical terms, is to make them stubborn and unresponsive. Their mind and will close against what God is saying, as Pharaoh refused "Let my people go" again and again. It does not mean making someone emotionally cold. In Exodus this served a purpose: that God's power would be shown and his name made known across the earth.
The verb "wills" or "chooses" is the same in both halves, and Paul repeats it deliberately. One verse earlier he said the outcome does not depend on the human "one who wills" (v.16). Now he says it depends on the God who "wills." The verbs are in the present tense, so this is a statement about how God acts, not a report of one event. The Greek does not even say "God". The subject carries over from "God who has mercy" in v.16.
Two things keep the line from being read in isolation. First, it provokes the objection Paul expects at once: "Then why does God still find fault? Who can resist his will?" (v.19). Second, it opens an argument that runs through chapters 9–11. In that argument Israel is partly hardened for a time (11:7, 11:25), and the argument ends with God having "consigned all to disobedience so that he may have mercy on all" (11:32).
-
19One of you will say to me, “Then why does God still find fault? For who can resist His will?”
Full study →Paul turns to an imagined objector, as debaters did, and puts the protest into his mouth before anyone in Rome can raise it: "You'll say to me, then: 'Then why does he go on blaming people? For who stands against his purpose?'"
The complaint follows directly from verse 18, "he has mercy on whom he wants, and he hardens whom he wants." If God hardened Pharaoh to serve his own plan, the objector reasons, then God's continuing to find fault, to hold people responsible and charge them with guilt, looks unfair. The word for God's "will" here means his settled, deliberate purpose, the plan he actually carries out, not a wish that might come to nothing. "Who stands against" it is phrased as a present condition: no one holds out against that purpose, so how can anyone be blamed for the part they play in it?
The objector borrows the vocabulary of Jewish praise ("who can withstand you?", "who will say to him, 'What have you done?'") and turns it into an accusation that God is unjust. Paul does not deny the premise that God's purpose stands. In the next verses he rebukes the objector's stance of putting God on trial (v.20) and then goes on to explain what God is doing (vv.22–29, and on through chapters 10–11).
Where the English drifted
-
in v18
hardens
sklērynei
- What we hear
- Makes someone hard-hearted, meaning cold, unfeeling, cruel.
- What they heard
- Makes someone stubborn and unyielding: mind and will closed against God's word, as with Pharaoh's repeated refusals. In biblical terms the heart is where a person thinks and decides.
-
in v18
has mercy
eleei
- What we hear
- Lets someone off, gives a lighter sentence. Mercy as leniency from a judge.
- What they heard
- Acts with compassion and favour toward someone in need or in guilt: rescuing, helping, restoring. It echoes God sparing and restoring golden-calf Israel, and the Hebrew words for loyal, gracious kindness behind it.
-
in v19
who can resist His will?
tō boulēmati autou tis anthestēken
- What we hear
- 'Will' heard as God's wishes or preferences, which humans plainly resist all the time; or the verse taken as Paul's own statement of doctrine.
- What they heard
- God's settled purpose or plan, which no one successfully stands against. These are the objector's words, a loaded question Paul puts in an opponent's mouth before answering it. They are not Paul's own conclusion.
Every word
-
ἄρα
ara · G0686
so, then, consequently · v18
Marks what follows as a conclusion drawn from what came before. Paired with οὖν it makes Paul's usual 'so then' for summing up an argument.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
therefore, then · v18, v19
Strengthens ἄρα. Together, 'so then' pulls together the two Exodus quotations just cited: mercy (Exod 33:19, in v.15) and Pharaoh (Exod 9:16, in v.17). Paul used the same phrase two verses earlier, in v.16.
-
ὃν
hon · G3739
whom, the one who · v18
Masculine singular object, 'the one whom'. It is left open on purpose: it names no group or category, which puts the stress on God's freedom to choose and not on any quality in the person.
-
θέλει
thelei · G2309
to will, want, intend · v18
God's purposeful will, not a passing wish. The present tense states how God always acts, not one past event. There is no word 'God' in the Greek. The subject carries over from v.16, 'God who has mercy'.
-
ἐλεεῖ,
eleei · G1653
to have mercy, show compassion · v18
To act with pity and kindness toward someone in need or in guilt. The verb echoes Exod 33:19, where God spared Israel after the golden calf, so it means kindness the person had not earned.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, but · v18
A light contrast, 'and on the other hand', setting hardening against mercy as the second side of the one statement.
-
σκληρύνει.
sklērunei · G4645
to harden, make stubborn · v18
To make someone hard, meaning stubborn and unresponsive to God's word and warnings. It points straight back to the Greek Exodus wording about Pharaoh's heart. Again the present tense describes how God acts.
-
Ἐρεῖς
Ereis · G4483
you will say · v19
Future, second person singular. Paul speaks to one imagined objector, a standard move in the 'diatribe' style of debate (teaching through invented dialogue). He sees the objection coming before anyone raises it.
-
μοι
moi · G3165
to me · v19
Paul pictures himself face to face with the objector. It is a personal exchange in a debate, not an abstract puzzle.
-
τί
ti · G5101
why? what? · v19
Used here as 'why?' It asks God to justify himself, and it carries a note of protest.
-
ἔτι
eti · G2089
still, yet · v19
'Still', meaning even after all that. The point is that God goes on blaming people even though, on this view, he is the one who hardened them. Paul used the same 'still' in an earlier objection (Rom 3:7: 'why am I still judged as a sinner?').
-
μέμφεται
memphetai · G3201
to blame, find fault · v19
Present tense, describing something God keeps doing: he goes on holding people to account. The word is about laying blame and charging fault, not directly about sentencing someone to punishment.
-
τῷ
tō · G3588
the · v19
Article marking 'his purpose' as the definite object of the resistance. It stands first in the clause for emphasis.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v19
Gives the objector's reason: blame is unfair because nobody stands against God's purpose.
-
βουλήματι
boulēmati · G1013
purpose, intention, plan · v19
God's settled, deliberate intention, the purpose he carries out. It is not a passing wish. Paul's opponent takes up the idea of verse 18 ('whom he wants') and hardens it into 'his fixed plan'.
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G0846
his · v19
God's. The verse never names God; he is the obvious subject carried over from verses 14–18.
-
ἀνθέστηκεν
anthestēken · G0436
to stand against, resist, withstand · v19
Perfect tense of 'stand against'. With this verb the perfect describes a present position: 'who stands opposed to / holds out against' his purpose. The objector's claim is that nobody successfully holds a position against God's plan.
The world behind it
Why Paul writes this. Romans was written around AD 57, probably from Corinth, to house churches in Rome made up of Jewish and non-Jewish believers. Chapters 9–11 face a painful question. If Jesus is Israel's promised Messiah, why have most of Israel not accepted him while Gentiles (non-Jews) are flooding in? Has God's word failed (9:6)?
The argument so far. Paul answers from Israel's own story. God has always chosen freely within Abraham's family: Isaac and not Ishmael, Jacob and not Esau, "before they had done anything good or bad" (9:11). The obvious objection, "Is God unjust?" (9:14), he answers with two Exodus texts. In one, God shows mercy to Israel after the golden calf (Exod 33:19). In the other, God raises up Pharaoh to show his power (Exod 9:16). Verse 18 is the summary of both.
How the Pharaoh story sounded to Jews. To Jewish hearers Pharaoh was the archetypal enemy of God's people, and Israel was the people who received mercy. Paul's argument will turn this around in a startling way. By chapter 11, part of Israel stands where Pharaoh stood (hardened, 11:7), while Gentiles receive mercy. Then the hardening turns out to be partial and temporary, "until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in, and so all Israel will be saved" (11:25–26).
Jewish debates about God's control. First-century Jews already argued about how God's control relates to human choice. Josephus says the Essenes put everything down to fate, while the Pharisees held fate and human choice together (Antiquities 13.172; War 2.162–165). The Dead Sea Scrolls' Community Rule (1QS 3–4) speaks of God appointing two spirits that govern humanity. Sirach 33:10–13 and Wisdom 15:7 use the potter-and-clay image that Paul uses in 9:20–21. So Paul's language would have sounded familiar to his hearers. What was new was how he applied it to Israel and the Gentiles.
From the study of Romans 9:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
Is Paul speaking about individuals' eternal destiny, or about God's choice of people and nations for roles in history?
-
Individual and eternal. God unconditionally chooses some people for salvation and leaves others to hardening. This is the Augustinian and Reformed reading (e.g. Piper, Schreiner).
The singular 'the one whom'. Pharaoh is an individual. The objection in v.19 ('who can resist his will?') only makes sense if Paul has made God's will decisive. 9:11 says 'not by works but by him who calls'. In 9:22–23, 'vessels of wrath … prepared for destruction' and 'vessels of mercy' speak of final outcomes.
-
Corporate and historical. Paul is explaining how God freely assigns roles in his saving plan, especially the present positions of Israel and the Gentiles, not fixing each person's final destiny (e.g. Dunn, Wright, many Arminian interpreters; Cranfield in part).
The question in chapters 9–11 is about Israel as a people (9:6). Jacob and Esau stand for nations (Gen 25:23; Mal 1:2–3, quoted in 9:13). Pharaoh's hardening served a public purpose ('that my name might be proclaimed', v.17). Israel's hardening in ch. 11 is partial and temporary (11:25). The argument ends with mercy 'on all' (11:32).
in v18
Does God's hardening respond to prior human resistance, or is it a sovereign act with no stated cause?
-
Hardening is God's judgment on resistance already present. God confirms people in the choice they have made.
In Exodus, Pharaoh's heart 'was hardened' or he 'hardened his heart' (7:13–14, 7:22, 8:15, 8:32) before the narrator first says 'the LORD hardened' it (9:12). Romans 1:24–28 has God 'giving people over' to what they already chose. In 11:20 Israel's branches were broken off 'because of unbelief'.
-
Paul grounds hardening only in God's will here and deliberately cites no human cause.
The verse says 'whom he wills', with no reference to the person's prior choices. God announces the hardening before the plagues begin (Exod 4:21, 7:3). Paul does not appeal to Pharaoh's self-hardening, though it would have eased the objection in v.19. Instead he answers with the potter image (9:20–21).
-
Both are true, held in tension, as in Exodus itself. Paul is not offering a theory of how they fit together.
Exodus alternates the two descriptions without resolving them. Paul ends the whole section in doxology, a hymn of praise, saying God's judgments are 'unsearchable' (11:33), instead of a resolution.
in v19
What exactly is the objector complaining about: individuals' eternal destinies, or God's handling of Israel and the nations in history?
-
Individual: the question is how God can blame individuals whom he has unconditionally hardened or passed over for salvation.
The singular 'you', the individual examples of Jacob, Esau and Pharaoh (vv.10–18), and the 'vessels of wrath / of mercy' language (vv.22–23) that follows. Associated with Augustinian and Reformed readings (e.g. Moo, Schreiner, Piper).
-
Corporate and historical: the question concerns God's freedom to use peoples (Israel, Pharaoh's Egypt, the Gentiles) in his saving purpose, especially Israel's present 'hardening'.
Romans 9–11 is driven by Israel's unbelief (9:1–6). Jacob and Esau stand for nations (Gen 25:23; Mal 1:2–3). Hardening in chapter 11 is partial and temporary ('until the full number of the Gentiles has come in', 11:25), and the goal is mercy on all (11:32). Associated with readings by Dunn, N.T. Wright and others.
-
Mediating: Paul's argument works at the level of peoples and salvation history, but the objection raises a principle (divine purpose and human blame) that applies to persons too.
Cranfield and many commentators note that the diatribe states a general principle while the larger argument stays focused on Israel.
in v19
Does Paul answer the objection or refuse to answer it?
-
He refuses: verse 20 rebukes the question itself, and humans are not in a position to judge God.
'Who are you, O man, to answer back to God?' and the potter's rights over the clay (vv.20–21).
-
He rebukes the attitude of accusation, then gives a substantive answer.
Verses 22–24 explain God's patience with 'vessels of wrath' in order to make mercy known. Chapters 10–11 stress Israel's responsibility (10:21) and God's coming mercy (11:23–32). In the Jeremiah 18 background, the potter responds to how the nations behave.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἐλεέω, σκληρύνω, θέλω, ἄρα
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. σκληρύνω
- TDNT s.v. ἔλεος (R. Bultmann); s.v. σκληρός, σκληρύνω (K. L. Schmidt and M. A. Schmidt)
- HALOT s.v. חנן, חזק, כבד, קשׁה
- Septuagint (LXX) Exodus 4:21; 7:3; 9:12, 16; 33:19; Psalm 94(95):8
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
- T. R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- N. T. Wright, 'Romans' (New Interpreter's Bible)
- R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
- J. Piper, The Justification of God
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.172; Jewish War 2.162–165
- 1QS (Community Rule) 3–4; Sirach 33:10–13; Wisdom of Solomon 15:7
- BDAG s.v. μέμφομαι
- BDAG s.v. βούλημα
- BDAG s.v. ἀνθίστημι
- H. W. Smyth, Greek Grammar §1946 (perfects with present meaning)
- S. K. Stowers, The Diatribe and Paul's Letter to the Romans (1981)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), vol. 2
- N. T. Wright, 'Romans' in New Interpreter's Bible vol. 10
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus at Rom 9:19
- Wisdom of Solomon 12:12; 2 Chronicles 20:6 LXX; Daniel 4:35
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.162–163; Antiquities 13.172, 18.13
- Mishnah Avot 3:15
- Vulgate, Rom 9:19
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).