Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Romans 9:1–6

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1I speak the truth in Christ; I am not lying, as confirmed by my conscience in the Holy Spirit. 2I have deep sorrow and unceasing anguish in my heart. 3For I could wish that I myself were cursed and cut off from Christ for the sake of my brothers, my own flesh and blood, 4the people of Israel. Theirs is the adoption as sons; theirs the divine glory and the covenants; theirs the giving of the law, the temple worship, and the promises. 5Theirs are the patriarchs, and from them proceeds the human descent of Christ, who is God over all, forever worthy of praise! Amen. 6It is not as though God’s word has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.

What the first hearers heard

To believers in Rome, this sentence was a sudden change of tone. They had just heard the climax of chapter 8, where nothing in creation can separate "us" from God's love. Now Paul goes into the language of the courtroom and the sworn statement. That shift tells them a hard subject is coming, and that Paul expects some to doubt his feelings about it.

Jewish believers may have heard Paul's gospel of Gentile inclusion as abandoning Israel, so for them the oath was a guarantee: he still grieves as a son of Abraham. Gentile believers may have been tempted to see Israel's unbelief as proof that God had moved on to them. For them the oath was a warning: the apostle to the Gentiles himself is in anguish over Israel. By calling Christ, his conscience and the Holy Spirit as witnesses, Paul makes clear that what follows in chapters 9–11, about election, hardening and Israel's final restoration, comes from love and not from bitterness.

From the study of Romans 9:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1I speak the truth in Christ; I am not lying, as confirmed by my conscience in the Holy Spirit.

    "It is the truth I am telling you. I speak as a man who belongs to the Messiah and must answer to him, and I am not lying. My own conscience, my inner knowledge of myself, stands beside me as a second witness and backs up my word, and it gives that testimony in the Holy Spirit."

    Paul has just ended chapter 8 at its high point: nothing can separate us from the love of God in Christ. Then he breaks off with no "and" or "for" to link the two. The first word, emphatic, is truth. He says the same thing twice, once positively and once negatively ("I speak truth... I do not lie"), which was the normal way to make a solemn statement on your honour. He then calls witnesses, as in a law court where Israel's law required more than one (Deut 19:15). The first is himself, speaking "in Christ", meaning in the Messiah's presence and accountable to him. The second is his conscience. In Greek this is not mainly a moral compass. It is the self that "knows along with" you what is really going on inside you. Here it confirms that what he is about to say is sincere. That conscience is not acting alone: its testimony is given "in the Holy Spirit", the same Spirit who, a few lines earlier (8:16), "bears witness with our spirit".

    All this careful vouching prepares for the words that follow (vv. 2–3): great sorrow and unceasing anguish for his own people, Israel, to the point of wishing himself cursed for their sake. Paul swears to his sincerity because some readers might doubt it.

    Full study →
  2. 2I have deep sorrow and unceasing anguish in my heart.

    Paul has just put himself under something close to an oath: I am telling the truth in Christ, I am not lying, my conscience bears witness with me in the Holy Spirit (9:1). Verse 2 says what he is swearing to: "that grief — great grief — is mine, and pain that never lets up sits in my heart."

    The two halves mirror each other. Great grief is the broad, ordinary word for sorrow. Unceasing pain is sharper, a word first used for the ache of a wound, and it has no gaps or off-days. The same "unceasing" is the word Paul uses for his constant prayer. The present tense means this is how things are with him as he writes, not a memory. And it sits in his heart, which in biblical terms is the core of the person, where thinking, willing and feeling all meet, not just a place of emotion.

    Notice what the verse does not say: why. Paul withholds the cause until verse 3, where he says he could wish himself cursed and cut off from the Messiah for the sake of his kinsmen, the people of Israel. The silence is deliberate. It comes straight after the triumphant end of chapter 8 ("nothing can separate us from the love of God"), and it makes the reader feel the drop before learning what caused it.

    Full study →
  3. 3For I could wish that I myself were cursed and cut off from Christ for the sake of my brothers, my own flesh and blood,

    "I could almost pray this. I know it can't be, but I would pray it: that I myself, I personally, might become a thing under God's curse, handed over to destruction like the devoted things of the old conquest stories, and torn away from the Messiah. I would do it on their behalf and in their place: my brothers, my own kin by blood and birth."

    The verb is a wish Paul knows he cannot be granted. It is not a bargain he puts to God. A few lines earlier he said nothing can separate him from the love of God in the Messiah (8:38–39). Now he names the one thing that cannot happen, separation from the Messiah, and says he would take it for his people. "Anathema" is the word his Greek Bible used for things and people put under God's ban for destruction. "For" is the same word he uses for the Messiah dying for others, and for Christ becoming "a curse for us" (Gal 3:13). So Paul's love takes the shape of the Messiah's own: willing to become a curse for others. And "the Messiah" here is pointed. Israel's own Messiah came from these very kinsmen (v. 5), and Paul would be cut off from him if it could bring them to him. Like Moses, who asked to be blotted out of God's book rather than see Israel destroyed (Exod 32:32), Paul speaks as a man who has not stopped being one of them.

    Full study →
  4. 4the people of Israel. Theirs is the adoption as sons; theirs the divine glory and the covenants; theirs the giving of the law, the temple worship, and the promises.

    Paul has just said he would accept being cursed and cut off from the Messiah if that would help his own kin (verse 3). Now he says who they are: "They are Israelites, the people who bear the name God gave Jacob. To them belongs the standing of God's own son, his firstborn. To them belongs the glory, God's own presence, which came down in cloud and fire to live among them in the tabernacle and the temple. To them belong the covenants, the bonds God bound himself to again and again with their ancestors and with the nation. To them belongs the law God himself gave at Sinai. To them belongs the true worship of God, the sacred service still being offered in his temple. And to them belong the promises God swore to their fathers."

    A few things carry weight here that English can blur:

    • It is all in the present tense. Paul says they are Israelites and these things are theirs. He does not say were. This is not a list of things Israel used to have.
    • It is a roll call, counted out with care. The six gifts may be arranged in two matching sets of three whose endings rhyme in Greek: huiothesia (sonship) with nomothesia (lawgiving), doxa (glory) with latreia (worship), and diathēkai (covenants) with epangeliai (promises).
    • Each term is weighty. 'Adoption' means a son's legal standing and inheritance. 'Glory' means God present, not fame. 'Service' means worship at the sanctuary.

    The list continues into verse 5 and reaches its peak there: theirs are the patriarchs, and from them, by human descent, comes the Messiah himself. Paul's grief comes from exactly this. Everything God gave was given to them.

    Full study →
  5. 5Theirs are the patriarchs, and from them proceeds the human descent of Christ, who is God over all, forever worthy of praise! Amen.

    Paul is finishing a list of everything that belongs to his own people, Israel. They have the patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, through whom God's promises came. Then he changes the wording. The Messiah is not described as Israel's possession, but as coming out of Israel. As far as his human descent goes, Israel's own anointed king, long hoped for, is an Israelite. That limiting phrase ("as far as the flesh goes") prepares for something more, and in the most natural reading of the Greek Paul supplies it at once: this Messiah is the one who stands over all things and all peoples, God, praised forever and ever. Amen.

    "Blessed" here is not "fortunate". It is the synagogue word of praise (Hebrew barukh): the one who is spoken well of and worshipped. "Amen" is the congregation's "so it is" at the end of a blessing.

    Paul's earliest manuscripts had no punctuation, so a second reading is possible: "…from them, by human descent, came the Messiah. May God, who rules over all, be praised forever! Amen." On that reading, Paul breaks into Jewish-style praise of God at the climax of the list. Most commentators today, and nearly all early Christian writers, take the first reading. A respectable minority holds the second. In both readings, the verse moves from grief over Israel (9:1–3) to the claim that the one who came from Israel, or the God who gave him, rules over everyone, Jew and gentile alike.

    Full study →
  6. 6It is not as though God’s word has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.

    "But do not conclude that God's promise has fallen to the ground and lies there dead. Because not everyone who is descended from Israel is, for that reason alone, the Israel the promise speaks of."

    Paul has just poured out his grief (9:1–5). His own people, Israel, hold the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the Law, the temple worship, the promises and the patriarchs, and the Messiah himself came from them. Yet most of them have not received that Messiah. The obvious, painful question follows: has God's word to Israel collapsed? The verb Paul uses pictures something that has fallen off, like a withered flower dropping to the ground (compare Isaiah 40:8: "the flower falls, but the word of our God stands forever"). It describes a fall that is final. Paul denies it. The "word" here is not "the Bible" but God's spoken pledge, his promises to Abraham's family (9:9 calls it "the word of promise").

    His reason rests on a play with one name used twice. The first "Israel" is the family line: those who come out of Israel (Jacob) by birth. The second is the Israel God's promise has in view, the people God himself calls into being (9:7–13: "through Isaac your offspring will be named", "not by works but by him who calls"). Paul is not denying the value of physical descent; he has just praised it. He is saying that physical descent never by itself made a person the bearer of the promise. So the fact that many Israelites are not responding does not mean God broke his word. God's word was always working by his calling, and it still is.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v1

    conscience

    syneidēsis

    What we hear
    An inner moral compass or 'still small voice', often taken as God speaking inside you and telling you ahead of time what to do.
    What they heard
    'Co-knowledge': a person's awareness of their own inner state and conduct. It is mostly a backward-looking inner verdict, here acting as a witness to Paul's sincerity. Paul knew it could be weak, defiled or simply mistaken (1 Cor 4:4; 8:7).
  • in v1

    Holy Ghost (KJV)

    pneuma hagion

    What we hear
    'Ghost' suggests the spirit of a dead person, an apparition.
    What they heard
    God's own Spirit. In 1611 'ghost' simply meant 'spirit' or 'breath' (Old English gāst), with no sense of a phantom.
  • in v2

    heart

    kardia

    What we hear
    The seat of feelings, as opposed to the mind or reason.
    What they heard
    The inner center of the whole person: thought, will, conscience and emotion together. Paul's pain sits at the same core from which he reasons and decides.
  • in v3

    accursed / anathema

    anathema

    What we hear
    Something hated or repugnant, or formal excommunication from a church.
    What they heard
    A thing or person handed over to God for destruction, under divine curse (the Old Testament ḥerem).
  • in v3

    brothers / brethren

    adelphoi

    What we hear
    Fellow Christians, the usual sense of 'brothers' in a church setting.
    What they heard
    Fellow Jews, Paul's people. The word is explained at once as 'my kinsmen according to the flesh'.
  • in v3

    Christ

    Christos

    What we hear
    Jesus' second name.
    What they heard
    'The Messiah', Israel's anointed king. The article makes the title stand out, and v. 5 says this Messiah came from Israel.
  • in v4

    adoption

    huiothesia

    What we hear
    Taking in an orphaned or needy child, or a private, inner sense of being loved by God.
    What they heard
    Being given a son's full legal standing and inheritance. Here it is Israel's standing as a people, God's 'firstborn son' (Exodus 4:22).
  • in v4

    the glory

    doxa

    What we hear
    Fame, honor, splendor: Israel's glorious history or reputation.
    What they heard
    God's own visible, weighty presence (Hebrew kavod), the cloud and fire that dwelt in the tabernacle and temple.
  • in v4

    the service (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    latreia

    What we hear
    Helping or working for others, or a church meeting ('the Sunday service').
    What they heard
    The God-appointed worship of the sanctuary: sacrifice, priesthood, festivals. In Paul's day this was still being carried out in the Jerusalem temple.
  • in v4

    Israelites

    Israēlitai

    What we hear
    An ethnic label, or citizens of the modern State of Israel.
    What they heard
    The honorific covenant name of Jacob's descendants as God's people, the name they used for themselves before God.
  • in v5

    Christ

    ho Christos

    What we hear
    Jesus' personal name, rather like a surname.
    What they heard
    'The Anointed One', the Messiah: Israel's expected king. In a list of Israel's national privileges, the point is that Israel's own Messiah came from Israel.
  • in v5

    blessed

    eulogētos

    What we hear
    Fortunate, favoured, having received good things.
    What they heard
    Praised, spoken well of, worthy of worship. It is the Greek form of the Hebrew berakhah formula 'Blessed be…'.
  • in v5

    according to the flesh

    to kata sarka

    What we hear
    Something to do with the sinful nature, or something lower or bad.
    What they heard
    'As far as physical descent goes': human ancestry and ethnic lineage, with no moral overtone.
  • in v6

    God's word / the word of God

    ho logos tou theou

    What we hear
    The Bible, the written Scriptures as a whole.
    What they heard
    God's spoken pledge: specifically his promises to Abraham and Israel (9:4, 9:9). The question is whether God has kept his promise, not whether a text is reliable.
  • in v6

    Israel

    Israēl

    What we hear
    The modern nation-state, or a purely ethnic or political label.
    What they heard
    The name God gave Jacob, then the covenant people descended from him. In Romans 9–11 it is a title of privilege and calling (9:4). Paul uses it in two senses here: physical descent, and the people of promise.
Every word
  1. Ἀλήθειαν

    Alētheian · G0225

    truth · v1

    Put first for emphasis, with no linking word before it: "Truth is what I am speaking." It means truthful speech, words that match reality, as opposed to a lie. It does not mean abstract or doctrinal 'Truth' here.

  2. λέγω

    legō · G3004

    to say, speak · v1

    Present tense: "I am speaking". Paul is vouching for the words he is about to write, the grief of verses 2–3.

  3. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v1

    Marks the setting Paul speaks from: as someone who belongs to Christ and stands in his presence.

  4. Χριστῷ

    Christō · G5547

    Christ, Anointed One, Messiah · v1, v3, v5

    Paul speaks as one bound to the Messiah, so his words answer to the Messiah. The title carries extra weight here: in verse 5 Paul will say the Messiah came from Israel, the people he is grieving over.

  5. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v1, v6

    A flat denial that makes the next verb negative.

  6. ψεύδομαι

    pseudomai · G5574

    to lie, speak falsely · v1

    "I am not lying." Paul says the same thing twice, once as a positive and once as a negative. This was the normal way to make a solemn statement of truthfulness (compare Gal 1:20; 2 Cor 11:31; 1 Tim 2:7).

  7. συμμαρτυρούσης

    symmartyrousēs · G4828

    to testify with, confirm by testimony · v1

    "While ... bears witness with". This is a courtroom word. The phrase it starts runs alongside Paul's statement and brings in a second witness who backs it up.

  8. μοι

    moi · G3165

    to me, with me · v1, v2, v3

    "With me" or "for me": Paul is the one whose testimony the conscience supports.

  9. τῆς

    tēs · G3588

    the · v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6

    The definite article attached to 'conscience'.

  10. συνειδήσεώς

    syneidēseōs · G4893

    conscience, inner awareness · v1

    Literally 'knowing-with', a person's awareness of their own inner state and conduct. Here Paul treats it as a witness that can vouch for how sincere he is.

  11. πνεύματι

    pneumati · G4151

    spirit, breath, wind · v1

    God's Spirit, the same Spirit who in Romans 8:16 'bears witness with our spirit'.

  12. ἁγίῳ

    hagiō · G0040

    holy · v1

    "Holy": belonging to God and set apart for him. It identifies the Spirit as God's own and not a human mood or 'spirit'.

  13. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v2, v6

    Introduces what Paul has just sworn to in 9:1 ("I speak the truth… I am not lying… my conscience bears witness"). The grief is the thing being sworn to, so the verse is a statement under oath, not a passing mood.

  14. λύπη

    lypē · G3077

    grief, sorrow, distress · v2

    The ordinary, wide word for inner pain and sorrow. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: before anything else, Paul names grief.

  15. ἐστιν

    estin · G1510

    is · v2, v4, v5

    Present tense: this is how things stand with him now, as he writes. It is not a memory of past distress.

  16. μεγάλη

    megalē · G3173

    great, large · v2

    Describes how great the grief is. It is held back until after the verb, so it lands with extra weight: "grief I have, great grief".

  17. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v2, v4, v5

    Joins two matching statements of the same pain, the second one heightening the first.

  18. ἀδιάλειπτος

    adialeiptos · G88

    unceasing, without a break · v2

    Something that never lets up, with no pause or gap. Paul uses the same word family for his unceasing prayer (Rom 1:9; 1 Thess 5:17). The pain has no off-days.

  19. ὀδύνη

    odynē · G3601

    pain, anguish · v2

    A sharper and more physical word than lypē. Its root sense is pain you feel in the body, used for mental anguish. The second pair moves from 'sorrow' to 'ache'.

  20. καρδίᾳ

    kardia · G2588

    heart · v2

    The center of the person, where thinking, willing and feeling all happen. The pain sits at the core of who Paul is, not only in his feelings.

  21. ηὐχόμην

    ēuchomēn · G2172

    to pray, to wish · v3

    An imperfect-tense verb used for a wish the speaker knows cannot be granted: 'I could wish', 'I would pray, if it were possible'. It does not say Paul actually made this request. It says how far he would go.

  22. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v3, v6

    Explains the 'great sorrow and unceasing anguish' of v. 2. This wish shows how deep the grief goes.

  23. ἀνάθεμα

    anathema · G0331

    something devoted to destruction, a curse · v3

    In the Greek Old Testament this is the word for ḥerem, something handed over to God for destruction. Paul pictures himself as an accursed thing, given up to God's judgment.

  24. εἶναι

    einai · G1511

    to be · v3

    The infinitive that completes the wish: 'to be anathema'.

  25. αὐτὸς

    autos · G0846

    self · v3

    Used with ἐγώ to give a strong 'I myself'. Paul is putting his own person in the place of his people.

  26. ἐγὼ

    egō · G1473

    I · v3

    Greek does not need this pronoun, since the verb already says 'I'. Doubled with αὐτός it puts heavy weight on Paul himself: I, the one who just said nothing can separate us from Christ.

  27. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    away from · v3

    'Anathema away from the Messiah' packs two ideas into one phrase: cursed, and so cut off from him. BSB and ESV spell this out with 'cut off'.

  28. ὑπὲρ

    hyper · G5228

    on behalf of, for the sake of · v3

    This is the preposition Paul uses for Christ dying 'for' people (Rom 5:6–8). It carries a sense of standing in for them: Paul would take the curse for them.

  29. ἀδελφῶν

    adelphōn · G0080

    brother · v3

    Here this means fellow Jews, Paul's people. It does not mean fellow believers, which is how Paul usually uses the word. The next phrase makes that clear.

  30. συγγενῶν

    syngenōn · G4773

    relative, kinsman · v3

    Kin, people of the same family or race. Paul uses the same word for Jewish fellow workers in Rom 16:7, 11, 21.

  31. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    according to · v3, v5

    'As measured by': this sets the standard by which they are his kin.

  32. σάρκα

    sarka · G4561

    flesh · v3, v5

    Physical descent, blood relationship. Here it is neutral, not 'sinful nature'. It quietly sets up v. 8, where Paul separates 'children of the flesh' from 'children of the promise'.

  33. οἵτινές

    hoitines · G3748

    who, the kind who · v4

    Picks up 'my brothers, my kin by flesh' from verse 3. This form of 'who' often carries a sense of character: 'people who are, as such, Israelites'. It explains why Paul's grief runs so deep: these are not just relatives but the people of God.

  34. Ἰσραηλῖται,

    Israēlitai · G2475

    Israelite · v4

    The insider, honorific name for the covenant people descended from Jacob-Israel. Paul uses it here instead of 'Jews' because he is naming their standing before God, not just their nationality.

  35. ὧν

    hōn · G3739

    of whom, whose · v4, v5

    'Whose' (literally 'of whom'). It governs the whole list: each item belongs to them. Paul repeats this word twice more in verse 5 ('whose are the fathers', 'from whom is the Messiah'), so the whole passage rings with 'theirs... theirs... theirs'.

  36. υἱοθεσία

    huiothesia · G5206

    adoption as son · v4

    Literally 'placing as son'. Here it is Israel's corporate standing as God's son, his 'firstborn' (Exodus 4:22; Hosea 11:1). It is the first and most intimate privilege on the list.

  37. δόξα

    doxa · G1391

    glory · v4

    In Jewish Greek, the 'glory' (Hebrew kavod) is God's own visible, weighty presence: the cloud and fire that filled the tabernacle and Solomon's temple. Israel was the people among whom God's glory came to live.

  38. διαθῆκαι

    diathēkai · G1242

    covenant · v4

    Plural: the covenants God made with Israel's ancestors and with the nation (with Abraham, at Sinai, on the plains of Moab, with David, and the promised new covenant). These are binding bonds of relationship that God made himself, not deals worked out between equals.

  39. νομοθεσία

    nomothesia · G3548

    lawgiving, legislation · v4

    The giving of the Torah at Sinai, and the God-given body of law that came from it. Paul counts it as a gift and an honor, not a burden.

  40. λατρεία

    latreia · G2999

    worship, sacred service · v4

    The sacred service of God in his sanctuary: sacrifices, priesthood and festivals. When Paul wrote, this was still going on daily in the Jerusalem temple. It means worship, not generic 'service'.

  41. ἐπαγγελίαι,

    epangeliai · G1860

    promise · v4

    God's sworn promises, above all those to the patriarchs: descendants, land, blessing for the nations, and a coming king. In Romans 4 and 15:8 Paul calls these 'the promises given to the fathers', and the list flows straight into 'whose are the fathers' in verse 5.

  42. πατέρες

    pateres · G3962

    fathers · v5

    The patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, to whom the promises were first given (compare 11:28, 'beloved for the sake of the fathers'). It is about ancestry and inherited covenant standing, not fatherhood in general.

  43. ἐξ

    ex · G1537

    out of, from · v5, v6

    An important change. Every other privilege was Israel's ('whose'); the Messiah comes 'out of' Israel. He springs from them, but Paul does not say he belongs to them.

  44. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    over, upon · v5

    'Over' in the sense of authority and rule.

  45. πάντων

    pantōn · G3956

    all · v5, v6

    The form could mean 'all things' or 'all people'. Either way it is universal: Jews and gentiles alike (compare 10:12, 'the same Lord is Lord of all').

  46. θεὸς

    theos · G2316

    God · v5, v6

    The disputed word. If the sentence continues, the Messiah is called 'God over all'. If a new sentence begins, 'God over all' is the subject of a blessing.

  47. εὐλογητὸς

    eulogētos · G2128

    blessed, to be praised · v5

    The standard Greek equivalent of Hebrew barukh: 'blessed', meaning praised or worthy of praise. In the Bible this word is used only of God. It says he is praised; it does not say he is favoured or fortunate.

  48. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, unto · v5

    Part of the set phrase 'into the ages' = forever.

  49. αἰῶνας

    aiōnas · G0165

    age, era · v5

    'The ages' in the plural: age after age without end. This is the usual Jewish formula of praise, 'forever'.

  50. ἀμήν

    amēn · G0281

    amen, truly, so be it · v5

    A Hebrew word for 'firm, sure', used in synagogue worship to confirm a blessing. Paul seals the praise as listeners would in a service.

  51. οἷον

    hoion · G3634

    of what sort, such as · v6

    Combined with οὐχ and ὅτι it makes an idiom: "the situation is not of the kind that…", i.e. "it is not as though…". It denies that this is the right way to describe what has happened.

  52. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and · v6

    Marks the turn from lament (Paul's anguish over his own people, 9:1–5) to argument. The sense is "But do not conclude from this…".

  53. ἐκπέπτωκεν

    ekpeptōken · G1601

    to fall out, fall away, fail · v6

    Literally "has fallen out / fallen off", the way a withered flower drops or a ship runs aground. The perfect tense describes a finished, lasting state: "has fallen and now lies fallen", i.e. has collapsed and come to nothing.

  54. λόγος

    logos · G3056

    word, statement, message · v6

    God's spoken commitment, especially his promises to Israel (9:4 "the promises"; 9:9 calls it "the word of promise"). Not a book but a pledge God made.

  55. Ἰσραὴλ

    Israēl · G2474

    Israel · v6

    The first "Israel" is the line of physical descent. It means either the patriarch Jacob, whose God-given name was Israel, or the nation descended from him. Either way it refers to birth and ancestry.

  56. οὗτοι

    houtoi · G3778

    these · v6

    Picks the subject back up for emphasis: "all those from Israel—these are not all Israel". It sharpens the contrast between the two uses of the name.

The world behind it

A solemn statement without swearing by an object. Jewish custom took vows and oaths very seriously (Num 30; Deut 23:21–23). By Jesus' day, people used formulas such as swearing "by heaven" or "by the temple" to make statements binding, and Jesus criticised that system (Matt 5:33–37; 23:16–22). Paul's formulas are a little different. He does not swear by something. He states that he speaks before God or in Christ, inside a relationship where lying would be a betrayal (Gal 1:20; 2 Cor 1:23; 11:31; 1 Tim 2:7). Hearers would recognise this as language for a sworn statement.

Two witnesses. Under Israel's law a matter was established "on the evidence of two or three witnesses" (Deut 19:15). Paul uses this rule elsewhere (2 Cor 13:1). Here his conscience serves as the corroborating witness.

Why Paul needed to vouch for himself. Paul wrote Romans around AD 56–57, probably from Corinth, to house churches in Rome he had never visited. They included Jewish believers and a growing number of Gentile believers. Claudius had expelled Jews from Rome around AD 49, and when they returned after his death in 54 they found Gentile-led congregations. Paul had a reputation, among both Jews and Jewish Christians, as a man who had turned against his people and the law (compare Acts 21:21, 28). He was about to take a collection to Jerusalem and was worried about how he would be received (Rom 15:30–31). Romans 9–11 deals with the most painful question of his mission: why most of Israel had not accepted Jesus as Messiah. Before tackling it he needs his readers to believe that he speaks as a grieving Israelite (11:1), not as someone who has given up on Israel. Later he warns Gentile believers against looking down on Israel (11:18–20).

From the study of Romans 9:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

Does 'in Christ' work as an oath ('by Christ') or as a statement of where Paul stands ('as one united to Christ')?

  • It is effectively an oath formula. Paul calls on Christ as guarantor, much like 'before God' in Gal 1:20. Some ancient interpreters and modern paraphrases (NLT: 'With Christ as my witness') read it this way.

    The surrounding statements ('I am not lying', calling a witness) are oath language, and Paul pairs 'in Christ' with 'before God' in 2 Cor 2:17 and 12:19.

  • It names the sphere Paul speaks from: as someone joined to Christ, whose speech is answerable to him. It is solemn, but it is not swearing by Christ. Many major commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Moo, Dunn) favour this or a blend of the two.

    Paul's very frequent 'in Christ' language elsewhere describes belonging and union, not swearing. The Greek has *en* ('in'), not the usual oath wording (*nē* or *ὀμνύω κατά*, 'swear by').

in v1

Does the 'with' (syn-) in symmartyreō still mean a second, separate witness, or has it faded to just 'confirm'?

  • The 'with' still matters: conscience is a second witness alongside Paul's own word, as Deut 19:15 requires.

    The dative *moi* ('with me') supports it, and so does the clearly double witness of Rom 8:16 (the Spirit bears witness *with* our spirit). Paul cares about two or three witnesses elsewhere (2 Cor 13:1).

  • In Koine Greek the compound often just means 'confirm' or 'testify', and the prefix has worn down.

    In Rom 2:15 a co-witness is harder to identify, and BDAG gives 'confirm' as a valid sense. BSB and NIV translate this way.

in v1

What does 'in the Holy Spirit' qualify?

  • It qualifies the conscience's testimony: conscience testifies as a faculty under the Spirit's influence and made trustworthy by the Spirit.

    Word order: the phrase follows 'my conscience' directly. Paul also elsewhere refuses to trust conscience on its own (1 Cor 4:4).

  • It sets up a third, distinct witness, the Spirit beside the conscience. Some paraphrases, such as NLT, read it this way.

    The parallel with 8:16, where the Spirit testifies *with* the human spirit, together with the pattern of three witnesses (Christ, conscience, Spirit).

in v2

Is Paul's grief genuine personal emotion, or a rhetorical move to win his audience?

  • Genuine personal anguish, deliberately stressed

    The oath formula in 9:1, the present tense, "unceasing", the extreme wish in 9:3 (echoing Moses in Exod 32:32), and the repeated prayer in 10:1 all point to real feeling. Most commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Moo, Dunn) read it this way.

  • A rhetorical appeal to build trust and goodwill

    Ancient rhetoric valued establishing a speaker's good character and sympathy (ēthos and pathos) before taking on a hard subject. Some scholars (e.g. Jewett) stress that Paul needs to answer the charge that he abandoned Israel and to curb Gentile arrogance (11:18-20).

  • Both together

    Ancient rhetorical technique and sincere emotion were not opposites. Paul can mean every word and also be using it with care to shape how the Romans hear chapters 9-11. Many recent commentators take this middle position.

in v3

What does the imperfect ηὐχόμην signify?

  • A wish Paul knows cannot be fulfilled: 'I could wish (if it were possible or right).' This is the majority view (Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Fitzmyer, Schreiner).

    The same idiom appears with ἐβουλόμην in Acts 25:22 and ἤθελον in Gal 4:20 (Blass–Debrunner–Funk §359). It also fits the claim just made in 8:38–39 that nothing can separate believers from Christ.

  • A real past wish: before his conversion Paul, as a persecutor, wished himself separated from Christ. This view was held by some older interpreters and suggested by readings like YLT's 'I was wishing'.

    It takes the past-tense form at face value. But 'for the sake of my brothers' does not fit a persecutor's wish, and the grief of v. 2 points to the present. Most scholars reject it.

  • An actual prayer Paul offered and God refused, on the model of Moses (Exod 32:32–33).

    εὔχομαι often means 'pray', and the Moses echo is strong. But the imperfect most naturally marks the request as one that is not, or cannot be, carried out.

in v3

Is Paul speaking of eternal damnation, or using strong language for intense feeling?

  • He seriously means being cut off from Christ under God's final curse, and offers it knowing it is impossible. Chrysostom (Homily 16 on Romans) treated it as the height of love.

    'Anathema' from the Messiah echoes the ḥerem language of destruction. The oath in v. 1 insists he is not exaggerating.

  • It is deliberate overstatement: a wish shaped like Moses' prayer, meant to show how deep his grief is rather than to name a real outcome.

    The imperfect already marks the wish as impossible. Paul wishes, but does not ask. The rhetorical setting is an oath plus a lament.

in v4

Where does Paul's 'adoption' (huiothesia) language come from?

  • Greco-Roman legal adoption

    The noun is a technical term in Hellenistic and Roman legal documents and inscriptions. In Roman practice an adoptee took on a new legal identity and full inheritance rights. Paul's Roman readers would have known this well.

  • Israel's sonship tradition, especially the Davidic promise

    The noun never appears in the Septuagint, but the idea runs through Exodus 4:22, Hosea 11:1 and 2 Samuel 7:14. James M. Scott (*Adoption as Sons of God*, 1992) argues that Paul's usage is shaped mainly by this Jewish background. Applying the word to Israel here supports that.

  • Both

    Many commentators (e.g. Moo, Jewett) hold that Paul used a Greco-Roman legal word to express a biblical reality. The word is Greek, but the content is Israel's sonship.

in v4

Which covenants are meant by the plural?

  • The covenants with the patriarchs

    Sirach 44 and 2 Maccabees 8:15 speak of 'covenants with the fathers' (Abraham, Isaac, Jacob), and verse 5 goes on to 'the fathers'.

  • The whole sequence of covenants in Israel's story

    Abraham, Sinai, Moab, Phinehas/priesthood and David are all called covenants in Scripture. Wisdom 18:22 and Ephesians 2:12 use the plural broadly.

  • Including the new covenant of Jeremiah 31

    Jeremiah 31:31 addresses the new covenant to 'the house of Israel and the house of Judah', and Paul cites new-covenant hopes for Israel in Romans 11:27. Others think Paul would not list the new covenant among Israel's existing possessions.

in v4

Are these still Israel's present possessions, or privileges now fulfilled and redefined in Christ?

  • Present and lasting possessions

    The present tense 'they are', and the list's dependence on it, support this. So does Romans 11:28–29 ('the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable'), and Romans 3:1–2, where 'the oracles of God' were entrusted to the Jews. Scholars across a wide range (e.g. Cranfield, Dunn, Wright, Jewett) agree that Paul presents them as genuinely Israel's.

  • Real privileges whose meaning is now found in the Messiah

    In 9:6 Paul immediately says 'not all who are from Israel are Israel'. In 8:15–23 the adoption is experienced through the Spirit, and 2 Corinthians 3 contrasts old and new covenant ministries. On this reading, the privileges are real and belong to Israel, but they point to and find fulfillment in Christ.

in v4

Does 'the glory' mean God's presence in the past, or the glory to come?

  • God's presence (the kavod) in tabernacle and temple

    It stands next to 'the worship', and Exodus 40 and 1 Kings 8 use the same Septuagint language.

  • Also the coming glory promised to God's children

    Romans 8:18, 21, just before, uses doxa for the coming glory of the children of God, matching 'adoption' at the head of this list.

in v5

Does Paul call the Messiah 'God over all', or does the verse end with a separate blessing of God?

  • The whole clause refers to the Messiah: 'who is God over all, blessed forever' (Cranfield, Metzger, Murray Harris, Fitzmyer, Moo, Schreiner; most modern translations).

    (1) The participle ho ōn ('who is') naturally refers back to the nearest subject, as in Paul's identical construction in 2 Cor 11:31 and his relative clause in Rom 1:25. (2) The limiting 'as far as the flesh goes' (to kata sarka) expects a contrast, as in 1:3–4. (3) Stand-alone biblical blessings almost always put 'blessed' first ('Blessed be God'), but here 'God' comes first. (4) Paul's other doxologies attach to a subject already named, not without a connecting word. (5) Suddenly praising God in the middle of a lament over Israel's unbelief would be abrupt. (6) The early Christian readers, Greek speakers themselves, read it this way.

  • A full stop after 'flesh': 'May God, who is over all, be blessed forever' (RSV, NEB, NABRE, TEV, and a minority of modern commentators).

    (1) Paul's undisputed letters nowhere else clearly call Christ theos. He normally reserves theos for the Father and kyrios for Jesus (1 Cor 8:6; 15:28). (2) 'God over all' fits Paul's monotheistic language elsewhere (Eph 4:6; Rom 3:29–30). (3) Jews customarily added a blessing on mentioning God's gifts, and the list of privileges in 9:4–5 is exactly such a list. (4) The reverse word order has at least one biblical parallel (LXX Ps 67:19).

  • A stop after 'over all': 'the Messiah, who is over all. God be blessed forever.'

    This keeps 'over all' with the Messiah (compare 10:12, 'Lord of all') while still reading a separate blessing of God. However, the resulting doxology (a short formula of praise) lacks a verb and still puts 'blessed' after 'God', so few scholars adopt it.

in v6

Who is the second "Israel" ("these are Israel")?

  • A faithful remnant within ethnic Israel: those Jews whom God has called, including Jewish believers in Jesus such as Paul.

    The proofs that follow (9:7–13) all draw distinctions inside Abraham's physical family: Isaac/Ishmael, Jacob/Esau. Paul later speaks of "a remnant chosen by grace" (11:5) and quotes Isaiah's "remnant" (9:27). Most modern commentators (e.g., Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Schreiner, Fitzmyer) read 9:6b this way.

  • The whole people of God, Jews and Gentiles, called through the Messiah: an Israel redefined around Christ.

    In 9:24–26 Paul applies Hosea's "not my people… my people" to Gentiles among the called. Elsewhere he defines true Jewishness inwardly (2:28–29), makes Abraham father of uncircumcised believers (4:11–12) and speaks of "the Israel of God" (Gal 6:16). N. T. Wright and others argue for a redefined Israel that includes Gentiles.

  • The distinction in 9:6 is real but not Paul's last word; ethnic Israel as a whole still has a future.

    Romans 11:26 ("and so all Israel will be saved") and 11:28–29 ("the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable") suggest that the narrower Israel of 9:6 does not exhaust God's purposes for the nation. Interpreters disagree over whether "all Israel" in 11:26 means ethnic Israel, the elect remnant, or Jews and Gentiles together.

in v6

What does the first "Israel" ("those out of Israel") refer to?

  • The patriarch Jacob: "those descended from Israel (the man)".

    ἐξ is the language of physical descent, as in 9:5 ("from them… the Messiah according to the flesh"), and the argument moves straight into the patriarchs (9:7–13).

  • The nation of Israel: "those who belong to the people Israel".

    "Israelites" in 9:4 refers to the people. Phrases like "of the race of Israel" (Phil 3:5) use Israel for the nation. In practice both readings mean physical membership by birth.

in v6

Is the "calling" that defines Israel in 9:6–13 about individuals' final salvation, or about God's choosing of a line to carry his purpose?

  • It concerns individual salvation: God's word has not failed because it was always aimed at those he chose for salvation.

    The context is Paul's grief over Israelites who are lost (9:1–3; 10:1). The language of calling, mercy and wrath (9:11–23) is used elsewhere for salvation. Associated with Augustinian and Reformed interpretation (e.g., Piper, Schreiner).

  • It concerns God's sovereign shaping of the line and people who carry the promise in history, with salvation in view corporately.

    The Old Testament texts cited (Gen 21:12; 25:23; Mal 1:2–3) are about peoples and lines of descent: "two nations are in your womb". Esau personally is never described as damned. Held by many Arminian, Wesleyan and "New Perspective" interpreters (e.g., Dunn, Wright, Witherington).

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀλήθεια, συμμαρτυρέω, συνείδησις, ψεύδομαι
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. συνείδησις
  • C. Maurer, 'σύνοιδα, συνείδησις', TDNT vol. 7
  • C. A. Pierce, Conscience in the New Testament (1955)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:1
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:1
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
  • M. V. Novenson, Christ among the Messiahs (2012)
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:1
  • BDAG s.v. λύπη, ὀδύνη, ἀδιάλειπτος, καρδία, μέγας
  • LSJ s.v. ὀδύνη, ἀδιάλειπτος
  • Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. ἀδιάλειπτος
  • Septuagint: Gen 42:38; Isa 35:10; 51:11; Exod 32:32
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:1-5
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:1-5
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9-16 (WBC)
  • BDAG s.v. ἀνάθεμα
  • BDAG s.v. εὔχομαι
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, A Greek Grammar of the New Testament §359
  • J. Behm, TDNT s.v. ἀνάθεμα
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:3
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:1–5
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans 16
  • Septuagint: Lev 27:28–29; Deut 7:26; Josh 6:17; 7:12; Exod 32:30–33
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:3
  • BDAG s.v. υἱοθεσία, δόξα, διαθήκη, νομοθεσία, λατρεία, ἐπαγγελία, Ἰσραηλίτης
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. νομοθεσία, λατρεία
  • TDNT, K. G. Kuhn, s.v. Ἰσραήλ, Ἰουδαῖος
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Romans 9:4
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Romans 9:4
  • James M. Scott, Adoption as Sons of God (1992)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
  • James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • Robert Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • Septuagint: Exodus 4:22; 12:25–26; 40:34–35; 1 Kings 8:10–11; Sirach 44:12, 18; Wisdom 18:22; 2 Maccabees 2:8; 6:23; 8:15; 4 Maccabees 5:35; 17:16; 18:1; Psalms of Solomon 12:6
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Romans 9:1–5
  • BDAG s.v. εὐλογητός, σάρξ, Χριστός, ἐπί
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. εὐλογητός
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Rom 9:5
  • Bruce M. Metzger, 'The Punctuation of Rom. 9:5', in Christ and Spirit in the New Testament (1973)
  • Murray J. Harris, Jesus as God: The New Testament Use of Theos in Reference to Jesus (1992), ch. 6
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), vol. 2, on 9:5
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible), on 9:5
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:5
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.16.3; Tertullian, Against Praxeas 13, 15
  • Septuagint: Ps 40:14; 67:19; Psalms of Solomon 17:32
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκπίπτω
  • BDAG s.v. οἷος
  • BDAG s.v. λόγος
  • Thayer s.v. ἐκπίπτω
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §304
  • LXX Isaiah 40:7–8; Joshua 21:45; 23:14; 1 Kings 8:56; Sirach 34:7
  • D. J. Moo, The Letter to the Romans (NICNT)
  • N. T. Wright, Paul and the Faithfulness of God
  • Philo, on the name Israel as "one who sees God" (e.g., De Abrahamo 57)
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:6

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).