Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Romans 9:6–16
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6It is not as though God’s word has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel. 7Nor because they are Abraham’s descendants are they all his children. On the contrary, “Through Isaac your offspring will be reckoned.” 8So it is not the children of the flesh who are God’s children, but it is the children of the promise who are regarded as offspring. 9For this is what the promise stated: “At the appointed time I will return, and Sarah will have a son.” 10Not only that, but Rebecca’s children were conceived by one man, our father Isaac. 11Yet before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad, in order that God’s plan of election might stand, 12not by works but by Him who calls, she was told, “The older will serve the younger.” 13So it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.” 14What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Certainly not! 15For He says to Moses: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.” 16So then, it does not depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy.
What the first hearers heard
For Jewish believers in Rome, this verse answered a real anxiety: had they followed a Messiah whom God's own people rejected, and did that mean God had left his people behind? Paul's answer was that God's promise had not collapsed. It was working the way it always had, through God's calling and not through bare ancestry. Believing Israelites like Paul himself were evidence that the promise still stood (11:1–5).
For Gentile believers, the verse did two things. It explained how Israel's story could include them (9:24–26) without implying that Israel's God had been unfaithful. It also blocked any sense of superiority over Israel. The God who keeps his word to Israel is the same God whose promises they were relying on (8:28–39). If his word to Israel could fail, his word to them could fail too. Paul later warns Gentiles directly against arrogance toward Israel (11:17–24).
For everyone listening, the opening move would have been recognisable. Paul argues the way Israel's own scriptures do: the faithful core within Israel, and the choice of Isaac over Ishmael and Jacob over Esau, are both Genesis themes. The argument begins at 9:6 and runs through chapter 11, ending in praise of God's unsearchable ways (11:33–36). Verse 6 states the thesis of the whole section: God's word has not failed.
From the study of Romans 9:6.
Verse by verse
-
6It is not as though God’s word has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.
Full study →"But do not conclude that God's promise has fallen to the ground and lies there dead. Because not everyone who is descended from Israel is, for that reason alone, the Israel the promise speaks of."
Paul has just poured out his grief (9:1–5). His own people, Israel, hold the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the Law, the temple worship, the promises and the patriarchs, and the Messiah himself came from them. Yet most of them have not received that Messiah. The obvious, painful question follows: has God's word to Israel collapsed? The verb Paul uses pictures something that has fallen off, like a withered flower dropping to the ground (compare Isaiah 40:8: "the flower falls, but the word of our God stands forever"). It describes a fall that is final. Paul denies it. The "word" here is not "the Bible" but God's spoken pledge, his promises to Abraham's family (9:9 calls it "the word of promise").
His reason rests on a play with one name used twice. The first "Israel" is the family line: those who come out of Israel (Jacob) by birth. The second is the Israel God's promise has in view, the people God himself calls into being (9:7–13: "through Isaac your offspring will be named", "not by works but by him who calls"). Paul is not denying the value of physical descent; he has just praised it. He is saying that physical descent never by itself made a person the bearer of the promise. So the fact that many Israelites are not responding does not mean God broke his word. God's word was always working by his calling, and it still is.
-
7Nor because they are Abraham’s descendants are they all his children. On the contrary, “Through Isaac your offspring will be reckoned.”
Full study →Paul has just said that God's word has not failed, because "not all who are from Israel are Israel" (9:6). Now he goes back to the beginning of the family to prove it. Being Abraham's physical descendants, which they truly are, does not by itself make all of them his children: the recognized family who inherit what was promised. For proof he simply quotes God's own words to Abraham, which his readers would know: "In Isaac seed will be called for you."
That line comes from the moment in Genesis 21 when Abraham was grieving over sending away Ishmael, his firstborn and his real son. God told him that the line counted as his, the seed God would name and recognize, would come in and through Isaac. Isaac was the child of the promise, born to a barren old woman only because God had said he would be. The verb is a divine passive (God does the acting without being named): God will call, meaning name, summon and establish, Abraham's seed. The future tense is God's promise spoken in Abraham's time, and Paul treats it as settled.
The verse turns on one word used two ways. "Seed" first means everyone physically descended from Abraham, Ishmael included; Genesis 21:13 itself calls Ishmael Abraham's seed. Then "seed" means the line God names. Paul does not deny the first sense. He denies that it guarantees the second. Who belongs to Abraham's family in the sense that matters is settled by God's calling. With that, Paul introduces the word call, which carries the rest of the chapter.
-
8So it is not the children of the flesh who are God’s children, but it is the children of the promise who are regarded as offspring.
Full study →"That is to say: being born into Abraham's family line does not by that fact make someone part of God's own family. The ones God counts as Abraham's true line, the heirs of the covenant, are the children who exist because of God's promise."
Paul is explaining a line from Genesis he has just quoted: "Through Isaac your seed will be called" (Genesis 21:12). Abraham had more than one son. Ishmael was as much his biological child as Isaac, yet God named Isaac alone as the line that would carry the covenant. Isaac's birth was itself the promise coming true: God announced it to an old man and a barren old woman (v. 9), and a son was born. So Isaac is the model "child of the promise", someone whose very existence comes from God's word rather than from ordinary human ability.
The verse uses the word "children" three times, contrasting two ways of belonging: by flesh (natural descent) and by promise (God's word and power). It also quietly equates being Abraham's "seed" with being "God's children", Israel's prized status as God's adopted son and heir (9:4). The verb "is reckoned" is passive, with God as the one doing the counting. It is the same verb Paul used in chapter 4 for Abraham's trust being "credited as righteousness." Status in Abraham's line is God's to assign, and God has always assigned it by promise.
The purpose of the argument is to defend God, not to dismiss Israel. Paul's thesis (9:6) is that God's word has not failed, even though many of his fellow Israelites have not accepted Jesus as Messiah. From the very first generation, he argues, "Abraham's seed" was never just a matter of bloodline. It was a matter of God's calling.
-
9For this is what the promise stated: “At the appointed time I will return, and Sarah will have a son.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
10Not only that, but Rebecca’s children were conceived by one man, our father Isaac.
Full study →"And Sarah is not the only case. Take Rebekah. She became pregnant from one and the same man, Isaac, our own forefather. [And before her twins were born, before either had done anything good or bad, she was told, 'The older will serve the younger.']"
Paul has just shown that God's promise ran through Isaac rather than Ishmael (vv. 7–9). Someone could object that this is easy to explain: Ishmael's mother was the slave Hagar and Isaac's was Sarah. So Paul brings in a case where that kind of explanation is impossible. Rebekah's two sons had the same mother, the same father, and the same pregnancy. The Greek is earthy: she "had a bed from one man," a frank idiom for conceiving. It stresses that the twins shared their origin in the most physical sense. "One" refers to the one man, Isaac, who is himself the "son of promise" from the verse before.
The sentence breaks off without a main verb. Paul is moving so quickly that he names Rebekah, inserts a parenthesis (v. 11), and only finishes the thought in verse 12. The verse exists to set up that conclusion. Between Esau and Jacob there was no difference in parentage, lineage or birth that could explain why one line was chosen over the other.
-
11Yet before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad, in order that God’s plan of election might stand,
Full study →Before the twins had even been born, before either had done anything at all, good or worthless, God spoke. He did it this way so that his purpose would be seen to work by his own choosing, and so that the purpose would keep standing and stay in force. It does not hang on birth order, ancestry or anyone's record of deeds.
Paul is building an argument. In verse 6 he insisted that God's word "has not fallen", even though much of Israel had not accepted Jesus as Messiah. He then shows that God's promise has always worked by selection within Abraham's family. First came Isaac and not Ishmael, but someone could say they had different mothers. So Paul takes the clearest case possible: one mother, one father, one pregnancy, twins. Even there, the oracle given to Rebekah (Genesis 25:23, quoted in v.12) named the younger, Jacob, over the older, Esau, while they were still in the womb.
The phrase "good or bad" means "anything whatsoever". The Greek phaulos is "base, worthless" rather than lurid "evil". The verse does not say Esau was wicked or Jacob was virtuous. It says that neither had any record yet. "God's purpose by way of selection" (hē kat' eklogēn prothesis) describes a resolve God set before himself that operates by choosing. And "might stand" (menē) carries the sense of remaining in force: Paul's answer to the fear that God's word had failed.
What exactly Jacob was chosen for, whether to carry the covenant line and the destiny of a people, or to personal eternal salvation, the verse itself does not say. Readers have debated it since the early church (see debates).
-
12not by works but by Him who calls, she was told, “The older will serve the younger.”
Full study →The choice did not come out of anything the boys did. It came out of the One who calls, the God who summons people and nations into what they are to be. So, while the twins were still in Rebekah's womb, God told her: "The greater one will be subject, like a slave, to the lesser one."
"Greater" and "lesser" mean firstborn and second-born, but the words also carry size and rank. In their world the firstborn was the one expected to inherit, lead and be honored. God's word reverses that order before birth, before either child has done anything good or bad. "Will serve" is a prediction of subjection, not of helpfulness: one line ruled by the other. In Genesis the oracle explicitly concerns "two nations… two peoples" (Gen 25:23), Israel and Edom. Paul cites it to show that from the very start, who belonged to the line of promise was decided by God's calling, not by descent or performance.
-
13So it is written: “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated.”
Full study →"This matches what stands written in Scripture, and still holds: It was Jacob I loved, it was Esau I rejected."
The line is God speaking, quoted from Malachi 1:2–3. Both halves are pointed in the same way: each name comes first for emphasis, and the two acts are simply set side by side as finished facts. In Malachi, "Jacob" and "Esau" are the two nations that came from Rebekah's twins, Israel and Edom. "Loved" means God chose Jacob and bound himself to him. "Hated" is the matching opposite in the covenant vocabulary of the day. It means to pass over, to reject from the line of promise, to refuse the favored place. It is the word used for the less-favored wife in Genesis and Deuteronomy, and the word used to end a marriage in Jewish legal documents of the period. It is not first of all a word for emotional loathing. But it is not soft either. In Malachi, God's rejection of Edom has visible results: ruined mountains and a people under lasting judgment.
Paul places this line straight after "the older will serve the younger," a word spoken before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad (9:11–12). His point is that God's purpose has always moved forward by his own choosing, not by birth order, ancestry or performance. That is why he immediately raises the objection "Is God unjust?" (9:14).
-
14What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Certainly not!
Full study →"So what are we to conclude from this? Surely there is no wrongdoing on God's side, is there? Surely he is not breaking faith or cheating anyone? Perish the thought!"
Paul has just said something hard. God chose Isaac and not Ishmael, and Jacob and not Esau, "before they were born or had done anything good or bad" (9:11). Scripture even says, "Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated" (9:13). So Paul stops and voices the objection his listeners are already forming. The question is shaped to expect "no": there isn't injustice with God, is there? The phrase "with God there is no injustice" was already an old confession, sung in the Song of Moses ("a faithful God, without injustice, righteous and upright is he", Deut 32:4). Paul turns that creed into a question.
The word for injustice (adikia) means doing wrong: failing to give what is owed, wronging someone, breaking one's word. It is the exact opposite of "the righteousness of God", the theme of the whole letter. So the question puts God's character and faithfulness on trial, not just his fairness in some abstract sense. Paul's reply is not a careful "well, in a sense..." but a sharp "may it never come to be!" The idea is pushed away as unthinkable. The next verses give his reasons. God's choosing works in the realm of mercy (9:15, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy"), and mercy by nature is not owed to anyone.
-
15For He says to Moses: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.”
Full study →"God is not unjust. Look at what he says, in Scripture still speaking, to Moses himself, at the moment Israel had just broken the covenant with the golden calf and deserved nothing: 'I will show mercy (act in pity, help and spare) to whomever I show mercy, and I will feel deep, parental compassion for whomever I feel compassion.'"
The saying is deliberately circular. God gives no outside reason, no qualification in the person, that obliges his mercy. Its only source is God, and it is spoken in the same breath in which he proclaims his name as "compassionate and gracious" (Exodus 34:6). The two lines say one thing twice. The first stresses mercy as something done, the rescue of the undeserving. The second stresses the feeling behind it, a pity as close as a mother's for the child of her womb.
In Paul's argument this is his answer to the charge "Is God unjust?" Mercy that could be demanded would not be mercy. If Israel itself survived the calf only because God freely chose to be gracious, then no one can accuse God of wrongdoing for showing or withholding mercy as he wills. That includes Israel by descent, the Gentiles, or anyone striving to earn it.
-
16So then, it does not depend on man’s desire or effort, but on God’s mercy.
Full study →"So then, it follows: the outcome does not come from the person who wants it, or from the person who runs hard for it. It comes from God, the one who shows mercy."
Paul is drawing a conclusion from what God said to Moses in Exodus 33:19, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy." The Greek is compressed, almost like a proverb. It has no verb and no stated subject, only three figures. Two are human and left without names: the one who wants and the one who runs. These cover human effort from inner desire to outward striving, pictured as a runner straining in a race. The third figure is named and comes last for emphasis: God, the one who shows mercy. "Mercy" here is more than letting someone off a punishment. It is God's active, freely given kindness to people who have no claim on it. In the Exodus story he showed that kindness to Israel just after the golden calf, when it had forfeited every right to his presence.
The "it" left unsaid is God's choosing in 9:11–12: Isaac rather than Ishmael, Jacob rather than Esau, and his decision to keep a rebellious people. The deciding factor is the free and generous will of a God whose character is to show mercy, not human wanting or human striving. Paul is not saying people do not want or run. He is saying that their wanting and running is not what decides the matter. Later in the same argument he shows where this leads: God "has shut up all in disobedience so that he may have mercy on all" (11:32).
Where the English drifted
-
in v6
God's word / the word of God
ho logos tou theou
- What we hear
- The Bible, the written Scriptures as a whole.
-
in v6
Israel
Israēl
- What we hear
- The modern nation-state, or a purely ethnic or political label.
- What they heard
- The name God gave Jacob, then the covenant people descended from him. In Romans 9–11 it is a title of privilege and calling (9:4). Paul uses it in two senses here: physical descent, and the people of promise.
-
in v7
will be called (KJV) / named / reckoned
klēthēsetai (kaleō)
- What we hear
- Either simply "given a name," or, in church language, a personal inner sense of vocation ("God called me").
- What they heard
- God's own act of naming, summoning and establishing. The Hebrew idiom "seed will be called to you" means "a line will be named and counted as yours." Paul uses it to introduce God's sovereign call, which forms his people (Rom 9:11–12, 24–26).
-
in v8
children of the flesh
tekna tēs sarkos
- What we hear
- Sinful, worldly or "carnal" people, as opposed to spiritual believers.
- What they heard
- Children by natural, physical descent: Abraham's offspring born in the ordinary way, with Ishmael as the clearest example. In context the phrase is about how one belongs to Abraham's line, not about moral character.
-
in v8
children of God
tekna tou theou
- What we hear
- Either all human beings, or individuals who have had a personal conversion.
- What they heard
- Israel's covenant status as God's adopted son and heir (Exodus 4:22; Romans 9:4). Paul is asking who rightly holds that inherited family status.
-
in v8
regarded as (BSB, NASB)
logizetai eis
- What we hear
- Viewed as or thought of as, possibly without really being so.
- What they heard
- Counted or reckoned as, by God's binding act. The reckoning confers the status. It is the same verb as "credited as righteousness" in Romans 4.
-
in v11
election
eklogē
- What we hear
- Either a political vote, or a fixed doctrinal system in which individuals are chosen for heaven (and others passed over for hell).
- What they heard
- Choice, selection, the act of picking out. Here it is God's picking the younger twin over the older to carry the promise. The word itself does not settle what the choice is to or how far it reaches.
-
in v11
evil (KJV: 'good or evil')
phaulos (Byzantine text: kakos)
- What we hear
- Dramatic, malicious wickedness, suggesting the verse is about whether Esau was a villain.
- What they heard
- Worthless or base conduct. 'Good or bad' together means 'anything at all'. The point is that no deeds existed yet.
-
in v12
serve
douleuō
- What we hear
- Help, assist, do something useful for someone, often willingly (as in 'public service' or 'customer service').
- What they heard
- To be in a slave's position, to be subject to another's rule. Here it describes one people becoming the vassal of another.
-
in v12
the older … the younger
ho meizōn … tō elassoni
- What we hear
- A simple statement of age.
- What they heard
- 'The greater … the lesser': birth order, but also rank, size and expected status. The firstborn was the one born to rule.
-
in v13
hated
emisēsa (Hebrew śāneʾti)
- What we hear
- God felt personal loathing or emotional animosity toward Esau.
- What they heard
- God rejected Esau/Edom from the line of covenant promise and favor. This is the covenant and legal opposite of choosing love, and in Malachi it carried real historical judgment on Edom.
-
in v13
Jacob / Esau
Iakōb / Ēsau
- What we hear
- The two individual brothers from Genesis.
- What they heard
- In Malachi, the two nations named after them: Israel and Edom. Genesis 25:23 already calls the unborn twins 'two nations.'
-
in v14
God forbid (KJV)
mē genoito
- What we hear
- Either a pious appeal to God or a mild, everyday 'heaven forbid'.
- What they heard
- An absolute rejection, with no mention of God: 'May it never come to be! Perish the thought!' It rejects a wrong conclusion as unthinkable.
-
in v14
unjust / unfair / unrighteousness
adikia
- What we hear
- 'Unfair' as unequal treatment (if one person is shown mercy, everyone is owed the same), or 'unrighteousness' as general personal sinfulness.
- What they heard
- Wrongdoing: failing to give what is owed, wronging someone, breaking faith or one's word. It is the opposite of God's 'righteousness', his right and faithful dealing. Withholding a gift that was never owed is not adikia.
-
in v15
have mercy
eleeō
- What we hear
- To let an offender off, to hold back a deserved penalty, as in 'throw yourself on the mercy of the court'.
- What they heard
- To feel pity and act on it: to help, rescue or spare someone in need or in the wrong. Here it translates Hebrew ḥanan, 'to be gracious, to show favour'. Sparing the guilty is part of it (the golden-calf setting), but the word is broader and warmer: favour freely given.
-
in v16
mercy
eleeō
- What we hear
- Leniency: holding back a punishment someone deserves, as a judge reduces a sentence.
- What they heard
- Active, freely given kindness and compassion toward someone in need who has no claim on it. In Jewish Greek it is tied to God's gracious favour (ḥānan) and loyal covenant love (ḥesed). In Exodus 33:19, the verse behind this one, it means God choosing to keep a guilty people and go with them.
-
in v16
him that willeth / human will
thelōn (from thelō)
- What we hear
- The philosophical 'free will', the faculty of choosing, as argued in theological debates about whether humans can choose God.
- What they heard
- Simply 'the one who wants / wishes / intends'. It is ordinary human desire and purpose, paired with 'running' to cover inner wanting and outward effort.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v6
"Not all Israel is Israel" doesn't say God has given up on Israel
- What's often taught
- This verse is often cited to show that God has transferred his promises from the Jewish people to the church. The church is now the "true Israel", and ethnic Israel no longer has a distinct place in God's purposes.
- What the text supports
The reading gets something right. Paul really does say that physical descent alone never made someone the bearer of the promise, and by 9:24–26 Gentiles are among the people God calls. Scholars genuinely disagree on whether the "Israel" of 9:6b includes them (see the debates above).
But the verse's own claim points the other way from "God is finished with Israel":
- The thesis is God's faithfulness to Israel. "The word of God has not fallen" (ἐκπέπτωκεν) answers the worry raised by Israel's privileges in 9:4–5. Paul is defending the claim that God has kept his promise, not announcing that he has withdrawn it.
- The distinction is drawn inside Israel. "Not all those from Israel" assumes that some of them are Israel. The examples that follow (Isaac/Ishmael, Jacob/Esau, 9:7–13) are all within Abraham's family, and Paul offers himself as proof (11:1).
- The argument does not end here. The same section says "God has not rejected his people" (11:1–2), that "all Israel will be saved" (11:26), and that "the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable" (11:29).
The verse supports the claim that God's promise works by his calling and not by bare ancestry. It does not, on its own, support the claim that the church has replaced Israel.
- Where the English feeds it
- Paraphrases that render the second "Israel" as "God's people" or "true believers" (e.g., NLT "truly members of God's people") can make the verse sound as if it were about a group outside Israel. In fact Paul keeps the same name, Israel, for both halves of the sentence.
in v13
'Esau I hated' wasn't first said over an unborn baby
- What's often taught
- Before Esau was born, God declared that he hated him: a personal, emotional loathing of the individual infant.
- What the text supports
Paul joins two separate texts. The word spoken before the twins were born is Genesis 25:23, "the older will serve the younger" (Romans 9:11–12). The love/hate line is from Malachi 1:2–3, spoken more than a thousand years later to Judah about the nations Israel and Edom, and it points to Edom's ruin as evidence. The verb (miseō, Hebrew śānēʾ) belongs to the covenant vocabulary of choosing and rejecting. It is used for the less-favored wife (Genesis 29:31; Deuteronomy 21:15) and as a divorce formula. It is not mainly a word for emotion.
What the popular reading gets right: Paul does link the two texts. His point is that God's choice did not depend on anything the twins did, and Malachi's "hate" is real rejection with consequences, not merely loving a little less. Whether Paul applies the choice to individuals' final salvation is a genuine debate. But the text does not describe God's emotional hatred of a newborn.
- Where the English feeds it
- Modern English 'hated' is almost purely emotional, and printing the line on its own, without Malachi's context, makes it sound like a statement about one person's feelings toward another.
Every word
-
Οὐχ
ouch · G3756
not · v6, v8, v10, v12, v16
A flat denial that opens the sentence. Paul shuts down the conclusion someone might draw from his grief in 9:1–5 before anyone can say it out loud.
-
οἷον
hoion · G3634
of what sort, such as · v6
Combined with οὐχ and ὅτι it makes an idiom: "the situation is not of the kind that…", i.e. "it is not as though…". It denies that this is the right way to describe what has happened.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v6, v10, v13
Marks the turn from lament (Paul's anguish over his own people, 9:1–5) to argument. The sense is "But do not conclude from this…".
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v6, v7, v12
Introduces the claim being denied: "that God's word has fallen".
-
ἐκπέπτωκεν
ekpeptōken · G1601
to fall out, fall away, fail · v6
Literally "has fallen out / fallen off", the way a withered flower drops or a ship runs aground. The perfect tense describes a finished, lasting state: "has fallen and now lies fallen", i.e. has collapsed and come to nothing.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v6, v8, v10, v11, v12, v13, v14, v15, v16
Points to a specific, known "word": the one God spoke to Israel, just listed in 9:4–5.
-
λόγος
logos · G3056
-
θεοῦ.
theou · G2316
God · v6, v8, v11, v14, v16
The word belongs to God and comes from him. The question is about God's reliability, not about Israel's performance.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v6, v11, v15
Gives the reason God's word has not failed. The promise never worked by mere descent, so Israel's partial unbelief does not cancel it.
-
πάντες
pantes · G3956
all · v6, v7
"All" those born of Israel. The point rests on this word: the promise was never a guarantee that applied to every descendant as such.
-
ἐξ
ex · G1537
out of, from · v6, v10, v12
Origin and descent: "sprung from". The same preposition was just used in 9:5 of the Messiah coming "from" Israel by physical descent.
-
Ἰσραὴλ
Israēl · G2474
Israel · v6
The first "Israel" is the line of physical descent. It means either the patriarch Jacob, whose God-given name was Israel, or the nation descended from him. Either way it refers to birth and ancestry.
-
οὗτοι
houtoi · G3778
these · v6, v8
Picks the subject back up for emphasis: "all those from Israel—these are not all Israel". It sharpens the contrast between the two uses of the name.
-
οὐδ᾽
oud' · G3761
and not, nor · v7, v16
Carries on the denial begun in 9:6 ("not all who are from Israel are Israel"). It sets up a second, parallel statement: the same principle now shown with Abraham's family.
-
εἰσὶν
eisin · G1510
they are · v7, v8
Present tense. Paul does not deny the fact: they really are Abraham's physical descendants. He denies only the conclusion drawn from it.
-
σπέρμα
sperma · G4690
seed, offspring, descendants · v7, v8
Used here in its plain, physical sense: biological descent from Abraham. It is a collective singular, meaning a whole line of descendants as one group.
-
Ἀβραὰμ
Abraam · G11
Abraham · v7
The founding father to whom God promised land, many descendants and blessing (Gen 12, 15, 17). Being "of Abraham" was the basic claim of Jewish identity.
-
τέκνα
tekna · G5043
children · v7, v8
Children in the sense of recognized family members and heirs, those who count as belonging to the father. Verse 8 shows Paul has "children of God" and "children of the promise" in view.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G235
but, rather · v7, v8, v10, v12, v16
A strong contrast. It leads straight into a quotation from Genesis with no "as it is written." Paul expects his readers to recognize God's words to Abraham.
-
Ἐν
En · G1722
in, through, by · v7
Translates the Hebrew preposition be-. It means both "in" (the line is found in Isaac) and "through" (it runs by way of Isaac).
-
Ἰσαὰκ
Isaak · G2464
Isaac · v7, v10
The son born by God's promise to the old and barren Sarah. He is set against Ishmael, who was also Abraham's son by blood (Gen 21:9–13).
-
κληθήσεταί
klēthēsetai · G2564
-
σοι
soi · G4771
to you, for you · v7
"To you" means "as yours": the seed God names through Isaac will be counted as Abraham's own.
-
σαρκὸς
sarkos · G4561
flesh · v8
Here it means natural, bodily descent: being born into Abraham's line the ordinary human way, as Ishmael was. It is not mainly a word about sinfulness in this verse.
-
ἐπαγγελίας
epangelias · G1860
promise · v8
God's announcement to Abraham that Sarah would have a son (Genesis 18:10, 14). "Children of the promise" means children who exist because God said so. Isaac was born to a barren, elderly couple by the power of God's word.
-
λογίζεται
logizetai · G3049
is reckoned, counted · v8
Present passive. God is the unstated one who does the reckoning, and that reckoning sets a person's status. It is the same verb as "credited as righteousness" in Romans 4.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, as · v8
With λογίζομαι it gives the biblical idiom "reckon *as*", meaning to give someone a status or category (compare Genesis 15:6 in the Greek Old Testament).
-
μόνον
monon · G3441
only, alone · v10
Used as an adverb, 'only'. With 'not' it means 'that is not the only case'. The thing being referred to is left unstated: Sarah and the promise spoken about her.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and, also, even · v10, v15
'Also' or 'even'. Rebekah is added as a second, stronger witness alongside Sarah.
-
Ῥεβέκκα
Rhebekka · G4479
Rebekah · v10
Isaac's wife (Genesis 24–27), the mother of the twins Esau and Jacob. Her name is the grammatical subject, but the sentence never reaches its main verb. Paul breaks off, and v. 12 picks the thought back up with 'it was said to her'.
-
ἑνὸς
henos · G1520
one · v10
'One' in the masculine form: one man. This is the point of the verse. Both children had the same father as well as the same mother, so their parentage gives no ground for telling them apart.
-
κοίτην
koitēn · G2845
bed; marriage-bed; intercourse; conception · v10
Literally 'bed'. With 'having' it is a frank Greek idiom for conceiving: 'having [the] bed from one man' means becoming pregnant by him.
-
ἔχουσα
echousa · G2192
having · v10
A present participle ('having') that describes Rebekah. Together with koitēn it means 'having conceived' or 'being pregnant'. It was never completed by a main verb.
-
πατρὸς
patros · G3962
father, ancestor · v10
Here 'forefather' or 'ancestor', the usual Jewish way of speaking of the patriarchs. It is not a personal or spiritual title.
-
ἡμῶν·
hēmōn · G3165
of us, our · v10
'Our'. Paul is speaking as a Jew of Israel's ancestor. In a letter to a mixed church of Jews and gentiles, it may also echo Romans 4, where Abraham is father of all who believe.
-
μήπω
mēpō · G3361
not yet · v11, v14
Places the event before the twins' birth. Paul's whole point depends on this timing: the decision came before either boy had a life story.
-
γεννηθέντων
gennēthentōn · G1080
to beget; (passive) to be born · v11
Aorist passive participle in the genitive. The phrase stands apart from the main sentence and its subject ('they', the twins) is left unstated. 'Not yet having been born'.
-
μηδὲ
mēde · G3366
nor, and not · v11
Adds a second 'not yet'. They had not been born, and they had not acted.
-
πραξάντων
praxantōn · G4238
to do, practise, carry out · v11
'Having done'. The word is about conduct and deeds, so it sets up the 'not from works' that follows in v.12.
-
τι
ti · G5100
something, anything · v11
'Anything at all'. No act of any kind, good or bad, had yet taken place.
-
ἀγαθὸν
agathon · G0018
good · v11
Good as a deed. It is the positive half of a stock pair that covers every kind of conduct.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v11
Joins the two halves of the 'good or bad' pair.
-
φαῦλον
phaulon · G5337
worthless, poor, base, bad · v11
The opposite of 'good'. It means base or worthless conduct, not necessarily monstrous wickedness. Paul uses the same pairing in 2 Corinthians 5:10.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
in order that · v11
States the purpose. God made the announcement before birth so that his choosing purpose would be seen to rest on him and not on their record.
-
κατ᾽
kat᾽ · G2596
according to, by way of · v11
Says how the purpose works: by selection, by picking one rather than the other.
-
ἐκλογὴν
eklogēn · G1589
choice, selection · v11
The act of choosing out. Here it is God's choice of the younger twin, Jacob, over the older, Esau, for the line of promise (v.12, Gen 25:23).
-
πρόθεσις
prothesis · G4286
purpose, resolve; a setting forth · v11
God's set intention, decided beforehand. The same word appears in Romans 8:28, 'called according to his purpose'.
-
μένῃ
menē · G3306
to remain, stay, abide · v11
Present subjunctive: 'might keep standing, remain in force'. It answers v.6, where Paul insists God's word has not 'fallen'.
-
ἔργων
ergōn · G2041
work, deed · v12
Deeds, things done. In context it echoes verse 11, 'before they had done anything good or bad'. Whether Paul also has in mind his usual phrase 'works of the law' is discussed in the debates.
-
ἐρρέθη
errethē · G2046
to say, speak · v12
Aorist passive, 'it was said'. The speaker is not named, but in Genesis 25:23 it is the LORD answering Rebekah. This is a common Jewish way of letting God be the unspoken speaker.
-
αὐτῇ
autē · G846
her · v12
Rebekah, named in verse 10, pregnant with twins by one man, Isaac. Paul stresses this to rule out every difference of parentage.
-
μείζων
meizōn · G3173
greater, bigger, older · v12
Comparative of 'great'. In Genesis it means the firstborn, Esau. But the word also carries size, rank and standing, so the reversal is sharper than 'older' alone suggests.
-
δουλεύσει
douleusei · G1398
to be a slave, serve, be subject to · v12
Future tense, a prophecy. It means to be in subjection as a slave or vassal: a reversal of status, not helping out.
-
ἐλάσσονι
elassoni · G1640
lesser, smaller, younger, inferior · v12
'The lesser', meaning Jacob, the second-born. Like 'greater', it suggests lower rank as well as younger age.
-
καθὼς
kathōs · G2531
just as, even as · v13
Links the quotation to verses 11–12. What Paul has just said about Rebekah's twins (the older will serve the younger, decided before they had done anything) matches what Scripture says elsewhere.
-
γέγραπται
gegraptai · G1125
to write · v13
Perfect tense: 'it has been written and still stands written.' This was the standard Jewish formula for quoting Scripture as an authority that still applies. Here it introduces Malachi 1:2–3.
-
Ἰακὼβ
Iakōb · G2384H
Jacob · v13
In Genesis, the younger twin. In Malachi, the people descended from him, Israel. Paul puts the name first in the sentence for emphasis: 'Jacob, it was Jacob I loved.'
-
ἠγάπησα
ēgapēsa · G0025
to love · v13
Aorist: a completed act of loving, viewed as a whole. God is the speaker, and in Malachi the love shows in God choosing and keeping Israel as his covenant people. It is love that chooses and stays loyal, not only a feeling.
-
Ἠσαῦ
Ēsau · G2269H
Esau · v13
The older twin. In Malachi, also the nation of Edom that came from him (Genesis 36:1, 'Esau, that is, Edom'). Like 'Jacob,' it is placed first in its half of the line for emphasis.
-
ἐμίσησα
emisēsa · G3404
to hate · v13
Aorist, matching 'I loved.' It translates Malachi's Hebrew śānēʾ. In covenant and family language this word meant to reject, to pass over, or to refuse to choose. It was the opposite of covenant love, not chiefly a feeling of loathing. In Malachi it also brings real judgment: Edom's land laid waste.
-
Τί
Ti · G5101
what? · v14
The object of 'shall we say': 'What are we to conclude?' It opens one of Paul's standard formulas for stopping the argument to test a possible conclusion.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
therefore, then · v14, v16
Draws an inference from what has just been said in 9:6–13: God chose Isaac over Ishmael, and Jacob over Esau before either was born or had done anything good or bad. 'Given all that, then...'
-
ἐροῦμεν
eroumen · G4483
we will say · v14
A future tense used to ask what to do: 'what are we to say?' The 'we' takes the readers into the reasoning with Paul. They are working out the conclusion together, and he is not yet accusing anyone.
-
ἀδικία
adikia · G0093
injustice, wrongdoing, unrighteousness · v14
Acting against what is right or owed: wronging someone, or breaking faith. Here the suspicion is that God's choosing (Jacob over Esau, with no reference to merit) would make him unjust, or untrue to his word to Israel. It is the exact opposite of 'the righteousness of God', the theme of the whole letter.
-
παρὰ
para · G3844
beside, with, in the presence of · v14
With the dative it means 'with, on the side of, in the person of': 'Is injustice found with God, is it part of his dealings?' The same idiom appears in Rom 2:11, 'there is no partiality with God.'
-
γένοιτο
genoito · G1096
to become, happen, be · v14
A wish form of 'to come to be': 'may it not come to be!' With mē it is a strong, almost shocked rejection: 'Perish the thought! Absolutely not!' The idea is pushed away as unthinkable.
-
Μωϋσεῖ
Mōusei · G3475
Moses · v15
'To Moses' comes first in the Greek sentence, which puts weight on it. The words were spoken to Israel's lawgiver and go-between with God, at the very moment he was pleading for a people who had just sinned with the golden calf (Exodus 33).
-
λέγει
legei · G3004
he says · v15
Present tense, 'he says'. The subject is God, carried over from 'God' in 9:14. Paul quotes Scripture as God speaking now, not only as a report of something said long ago.
-
ἐλεήσω
eleēsō · G1653
to have mercy, show pity · v15, v16
Future: 'I will show mercy.' This is the verb of pity that acts: helping or sparing someone in need or in the wrong. In the Greek Old Testament (the Septuagint) it stands here for the Hebrew ḥanan, 'to be gracious, show favour'.
-
ὃν
hon · G3739
whom · v15
'Whom', the object of the mercy. Together with ἄν it makes an open-ended 'whomever'.
-
ἂν
an · G302
(-ever) · v15
A small particle that leaves the relative clause open: 'whoever it may be'. It is not 'maybe' in the sense of doubt. It marks the person as not specified in advance.
-
οἰκτιρήσω
oiktirēsō · G3627
to have compassion, pity · v15
Future: 'I will have pity.' This word puts more weight on the feeling, a deep inner pity. In the Septuagint it stands for Hebrew raḥam, a verb related to the word for 'womb'.
-
ἄρα
ara · G0686
so, then, consequently · v16
Marks a conclusion. Paul is drawing out what follows from the Exodus quotation he has just given in 9:15.
-
θέλοντος
thelontos · G2309
to want, wish, will · v16
'The one who wants / wills.' A present participle, describing someone defined by wanting or intending. It is ordinary human desire and purpose, not a technical philosophical 'free will'.
-
τρέχοντος
trechontos · G5143
to run · v16
'The one who runs.' A vivid picture of a runner in a race, straining and exerting himself. Paul uses running elsewhere for strenuous effort in the life of faith and in his ministry. Here it stands for human exertion, the outward counterpart to wanting.
The world behind it
Why the question had to be asked. Paul wrote Romans around AD 56–57 to house churches in Rome made up of both Jewish and non-Jewish believers. Emperor Claudius had expelled Jews (or at least some Jewish agitators) from Rome around AD 49, and when they returned, the balance in the congregations had probably shifted toward Gentiles. A visible and theological problem followed. The message about Israel's Messiah was being welcomed by Gentiles in large numbers while most Jews rejected it. To a Jew, and to Gentiles who had learned Israel's scriptures, that looked like evidence that God had abandoned his promises to Israel, or that the gospel was not really from Israel's God.
What "the word" meant. For a first-century Jew, God's "word" was not primarily a written text. It was something God said and then did: his oath to Abraham, his covenant with the patriarchs. The scriptures (the Law, the Prophets and the other writings then in use) recorded and announced that word. But the issue here is whether God keeps what he said.
A familiar category. The idea that the true or faithful Israel might be smaller than the whole nation was not new. The prophets spoke of a "remnant" (Isaiah 10:20–22, quoted in Romans 9:27). Elijah was told of 7,000 who had not bowed to Baal (cited in Romans 11:4). The Dead Sea Scrolls community regarded itself as the faithful Israel inside an unfaithful nation. Against this background, Paul's hearers would not take "not all from Israel are Israel" as an outsider's attack on the Jewish people. It sounded like an argument made from inside Israel's own scriptures and history, by a man who called himself "an Israelite" (11:1).
Why the patriarchs come next. Paul's proof (9:7–13) comes from Genesis: Abraham had more than one son, but the promise ran through Isaac, not Ishmael. Isaac had twins, but the promise ran through Jacob, not Esau. Inside the patriarchal family itself, physical descent and the line of promise were never simply the same.
From the study of Romans 9:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
Who is the second "Israel" ("these are Israel")?
-
A faithful remnant within ethnic Israel: those Jews whom God has called, including Jewish believers in Jesus such as Paul.
The proofs that follow (9:7–13) all draw distinctions inside Abraham's physical family: Isaac/Ishmael, Jacob/Esau. Paul later speaks of "a remnant chosen by grace" (11:5) and quotes Isaiah's "remnant" (9:27). Most modern commentators (e.g., Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Schreiner, Fitzmyer) read 9:6b this way.
-
The whole people of God, Jews and Gentiles, called through the Messiah: an Israel redefined around Christ.
In 9:24–26 Paul applies Hosea's "not my people… my people" to Gentiles among the called. Elsewhere he defines true Jewishness inwardly (2:28–29), makes Abraham father of uncircumcised believers (4:11–12) and speaks of "the Israel of God" (Gal 6:16). N. T. Wright and others argue for a redefined Israel that includes Gentiles.
-
The distinction in 9:6 is real but not Paul's last word; ethnic Israel as a whole still has a future.
Romans 11:26 ("and so all Israel will be saved") and 11:28–29 ("the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable") suggest that the narrower Israel of 9:6 does not exhaust God's purposes for the nation. Interpreters disagree over whether "all Israel" in 11:26 means ethnic Israel, the elect remnant, or Jews and Gentiles together.
in v6
What does the first "Israel" ("those out of Israel") refer to?
-
The patriarch Jacob: "those descended from Israel (the man)".
ἐξ is the language of physical descent, as in 9:5 ("from them… the Messiah according to the flesh"), and the argument moves straight into the patriarchs (9:7–13).
-
The nation of Israel: "those who belong to the people Israel".
"Israelites" in 9:4 refers to the people. Phrases like "of the race of Israel" (Phil 3:5) use Israel for the nation. In practice both readings mean physical membership by birth.
in v6
Is the "calling" that defines Israel in 9:6–13 about individuals' final salvation, or about God's choosing of a line to carry his purpose?
-
It concerns individual salvation: God's word has not failed because it was always aimed at those he chose for salvation.
The context is Paul's grief over Israelites who are lost (9:1–3; 10:1). The language of calling, mercy and wrath (9:11–23) is used elsewhere for salvation. Associated with Augustinian and Reformed interpretation (e.g., Piper, Schreiner).
-
It concerns God's sovereign shaping of the line and people who carry the promise in history, with salvation in view corporately.
The Old Testament texts cited (Gen 21:12; 25:23; Mal 1:2–3) are about peoples and lines of descent: "two nations are in your womb". Esau personally is never described as damned. Held by many Arminian, Wesleyan and "New Perspective" interpreters (e.g., Dunn, Wright, Witherington).
in v7
Whose "children" are meant in 7a: Abraham's or God's?
-
Abraham's children. The clause sets Abraham's seed against Abraham's children (NIV, ESV, NASB supply "Abraham's").
The immediate parallel with "seed of Abraham," and the quotation, which is about who counts as Abraham's ("to you").
-
Paul already has "children of God / of the promise" in mind, and v. 8 makes this explicit.
Verse 8 begins "that is" and explains 7a as "not the children of the flesh are children of God." Paul elsewhere connects being children with being heirs (Rom 8:16–17; Gal 4:28).
-
Many commentators hold both together: in Paul's argument, being Abraham's true children and being God's children are the same status.
Rom 4:11–18 and Gal 3:29 equate Abraham's seed with heirs of the promise.
in v7
Is the "calling" in Isaac about individuals' eternal salvation, or about God choosing a line to carry his purpose in history?
-
It sets out a principle of God's individual election to salvation, which Romans 9 then develops.
The chapter's framing is Paul's anguish that his kin are "cut off from Christ" (9:3). It goes on to "not of works but of him who calls" (9:11–12), "vessels of mercy" and "vessels of wrath" (9:22–23), and the calling of individuals from Jews and Gentiles (9:24).
-
It concerns God choosing which line carries the promise and his purpose, a corporate and historical role, not the final destiny of each person.
In Genesis, Ishmael is excluded from the covenant line but still blessed and made a nation (Gen 17:20; 21:13, 18). The Jacob/Esau texts Paul cites next speak of nations (Gen 25:23; Mal 1:2–3). Romans 11 says God has not rejected Israel and that "all Israel will be saved" (11:1, 26).
-
A mediating reading: the patriarchal examples are about the promised line, but Paul uses them to explain why many in Israel do not presently share in the Messiah's salvation. Both themes are in play.
9:6 is about whether God's word has failed concerning Israel's salvation. The examples Paul uses come from history and family lines.
in v8
Is Paul talking about individuals chosen for eternal salvation, or about God's choice of a line or people to carry the promise in history?
-
Individual election to salvation: Paul explains why some Israelites believe and others don't, and "children of God" is a saving status.
"Children of God" in Romans 8:14–17 is clearly a saving status. The anguish of 9:1–3 is about Israelites being "accursed". The argument quickly narrows to individuals (Jacob and Esau, 9:11–13) and to God's mercy on "whom he wills" (9:18).
-
Corporate or vocational election: Paul explains how God has formed the people who carry the promise, and the choice of Isaac and Jacob concerns their role in God's purposes, not the final fate of Ishmael or Esau as individuals.
The Genesis texts are about lineages and nations ("two nations are in your womb", Genesis 25:23; Malachi 1:2–3 is about Edom and Israel). The whole of Romans 9–11 is about Israel and the nations as peoples, and it ends with "all Israel will be saved" (11:26).
-
Mediating view: the passage concerns the identity of the covenant people, but membership in that people does involve salvation.
Paul moves between people-level categories ("Israel", "seed") and the question of who among them actually shares in the promise ("a remnant", 9:27; 11:5).
in v8
Who are the "children of the promise" in this verse: a selection within ethnic Israel, or a family that already includes Gentile believers?
-
Within Israel: in 9:6–13 the "children of the promise" are the believing remnant inside Abraham's physical family. Gentiles come in only at 9:24.
The examples are all from Abraham's own household (Isaac rather than Ishmael, Jacob rather than Esau). The thesis is "not all who are from Israel are Israel" (9:6), a distinction drawn inside Israel.
-
Already pointing to Gentiles: "promise" and "reckoned" deliberately recall Romans 4 and Galatians, where Gentile believers are Abraham's seed.
Romans 4:16 ("the promise ... to all the seed"). Galatians 3:29 and 4:28 ("you, brothers, like Isaac, are children of promise"). Romans 9:24–26 applies "sons of the living God" to Gentiles.
in v8
Is "flesh" here only about natural descent, or does it also suggest human effort as opposed to divine power?
-
Mainly natural descent.
σάρξ in Romans 9:3 and 9:5 clearly means kinship and lineage. The parallel with "seed" and "children" keeps the focus on birth.
-
Descent plus an overtone of merely human means.
Ishmael came from Abraham and Sarah's own plan (Genesis 16), while Isaac came from God's word to a barren womb. Galatians 4:23, 29 contrasts "born according to the flesh" with "according to the Spirit" and "through promise".
in v10
What kind of 'election' does the Rebekah example illustrate (developed in vv. 11–13)?
-
Individual election: God's choice of Jacob over Esau shows God choosing individuals, including for salvation, apart from anything they do.
Verse 10 stresses two individual children with identical parentage. Verse 11 says the choice was made before birth and before any deeds 'so that God's purpose according to election might stand'. Romans 9 goes on to speak of mercy and hardening (vv. 15–18). Moo and Schreiner argue this view.
-
Corporate or historical election: the twins stand for two peoples (Israel and Edom), and the issue is God's choice of the line through which his promise and purpose would run, not individuals' final destiny.
The oracle Paul quotes concerns 'two nations' (Gen 25:23). The 'Jacob I loved, Esau I hated' quotation (v. 13) comes from Malachi 1:2–3, which is about the nations of Israel and Edom. The chapter's question is Israel's role in history (9:6; chs. 9–11). Dunn, Cranfield (in part) and Wright lean this way.
-
Mediating: Paul's main point is that God's calling, not ancestry or deeds, defines the people of promise. Questions of individual salvation are not the focus of v. 10, though later readers have drawn them from the passage.
The verse itself only removes natural grounds for distinction (same father, same mother). Its function in the argument is to answer 'Has God's word failed?' (9:6).
in v11
Is the choice of Jacob over Esau about individual eternal salvation, or about roles and peoples in God's plan?
-
Individual election to salvation. Paul uses Jacob and Esau to show that God chooses individuals for salvation unconditionally (associated with Augustine and the Reformed tradition, and argued at length by some modern commentators).
Romans 9 begins with Paul's grief that his kinsmen are 'accursed' (9:3), so salvation is at stake. 'Not from works but from the one who calls' (v.12) echoes Paul's salvation language. Verses 9:15–23 speak of mercy, hardening, and 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. The singular pronouns in 9:18–19 suggest individuals.
-
Election to a role in salvation history, and of peoples. The choice concerns which line carries the promise and what Israel and Edom become, not the eternal destiny of each twin.
Genesis 25:23 speaks of 'two nations', and the oracle is about *serving* ('the older will serve the younger'), which Esau personally never did. Malachi 1:2–3 (v.13) concerns the nations Israel and Edom. The argument of Romans 9–11 is about Israel as a whole and ends with mercy on all (11:32).
-
Mediating views. Paul's point is God's freedom to choose without regard to merit, applied in his own day to Israel and the nations and to who belongs to the true 'Israel' (9:6). The question of individuals is real but not the focus of verse 11.
In the verse itself the subject is God's 'purpose' remaining, answering 9:6. Paul moves between corporate examples (nations) and individual ones (Pharaoh, 'whom he wills').
in v11
Does 'not having done anything good or bad' rule out choice based on foreseen future deeds or faith?
-
Yes. Paul's wording and the contrast with 'works' exclude any basis in the twins themselves, including foreseen conduct.
The emphasis on 'before birth' and 'not from works but from the one who calls'. Paul's next question, 'Is there injustice with God?' (9:14), would only arise if the choice had no basis in the person.
-
Paul rules out *works* and birth rights specifically, so a choice in view of foreseen faith is not addressed (a view found in some early Greek commentators and in Arminian readings).
Romans 9:30–32 contrasts righteousness 'from faith' with 'from works'. Romans 8:29 says 'those whom he foreknew'.
in v12
Is Paul talking about individuals chosen for salvation, or about peoples chosen for a role in God's purposes?
-
Corporate and historical: the oracle concerns the nations Israel and Edom and their roles in salvation history. Paul uses it to show that God's choosing has always been free of lineage and merit, not to decide the eternal fate of Jacob and Esau as individuals.
Genesis 25:23 explicitly says 'two nations… two peoples'. Esau personally never served Jacob, and the fulfillment is national (2 Sam 8:14). Malachi 1:2-5, quoted in v.13, is about Edom as a nation. Romans 9-11 is about Israel and the Gentiles as groups and ends in mercy on 'all' (11:32). Commentators taking broadly this line include J.D.G. Dunn and N.T. Wright, and in part C.E.B. Cranfield.
-
Individual: Paul applies the oracle to God's free choice of particular persons for salvation, and Jacob and Esau are examples of that.
The problem Paul raises is the salvation of his kinsmen, for whom he would wish himself 'accursed' (9:3). He stresses the individual twins, 'not yet born', 'one conceived' (9:10-11). Verses 14-23 talk about mercy and hardening of individuals ('on whom he wills', 9:18). Commentators taking this line include D. Moo, T. Schreiner and J. Piper.
-
Mixed: the two cannot be cleanly separated. Paul's argument moves from historical election (peoples, roles) to the present question of who belongs to the true 'Israel'.
9:6-8 defines 'children of the promise' within physical Israel, and 9:24 speaks of 'us whom he called'. Both corporate and individual language appear in the chapter.
in v12
What are the 'works' that God's choice was 'not from'?
-
Human deeds in general, good or bad.
Verse 11 defines the context: 'before they had done anything good or bad'. The phrase has no 'of the law'.
-
Paul also has in mind 'works of the law', the Torah practices (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath) that marked Jews off from others, as in 3:20, 28.
This is Paul's normal use of 'works' in Romans, and 9:32 says Israel pursued righteousness 'as if from works'. Proponents point to 'New Perspective on Paul' readers (e.g. Dunn). Critics answer that Jacob and Esau lived before the Law was given, which favors the general sense here.
in v13
Is Paul speaking of individuals chosen for salvation, or of peoples chosen for a role in history?
-
Individual election to salvation: Esau and Jacob stand for individuals chosen or passed over with regard to their final destiny.
The chapter opens with Paul wishing himself 'accursed' (anathema) for his kinsmen (9:3), which concerns salvation. 9:11 stresses that the twins were individuals not yet born. The argument moves to 'vessels of mercy' and 'vessels of wrath' (9:22–23). Held in the tradition of Augustine and Calvin, and argued in detail by J. Piper (*The Justification of God*) and T. Schreiner.
-
Corporate or historical election: the line concerns peoples (Israel and Edom) and the role each plays in God's purpose, not the eternal destiny of individuals.
Genesis 25:23 speaks of 'two nations,' and the promise 'the older will serve the younger' was never fulfilled in the brothers' own lives but in their nations. Malachi 1:2–5 is plainly about Israel and Edom. Paul's argument ends with God's mercy to all (11:32). Held in various forms by many Arminian and 'New Perspective' interpreters (e.g. J. D. G. Dunn, N. T. Wright, B. Witherington).
-
Mediating: Paul draws on national texts but applies the principle (God's free, unearned choice) to the question of who belongs to the true 'Israel' in his own day.
9:6 ('not all who are of Israel are Israel') is about membership within the people. C. E. B. Cranfield and D. Moo both note the national setting of the Old Testament texts while treating Paul's application as concerning more than historical role. Moo leans toward individual salvation, Cranfield less so.
in v13
How strong is 'hate' here: 'love less,' 'reject,' or active hostility?
-
Comparative: 'loved less' or 'did not choose.'
Genesis 29:30–31 (Leah 'hated' = loved less than Rachel), Deuteronomy 21:15–17, and Luke 14:26 compared with Matthew 10:37.
-
Rejection with real disfavor: more than 'love less,' including judgment.
Malachi 1:3–4 describes Edom's land laid waste and the LORD's lasting anger. The word sits in a prophecy of judgment, not a comparison of affections. The aorist, matched with 'loved,' presents two opposite decisions.
in v14
What exactly is the objection: is God being unfair to individuals, or untrue to his promises to Israel?
-
Mainly about arbitrariness or fairness. If God chooses before anyone has done good or bad, he seems to treat people unequally, and that looks unjust.
The objection comes straight after 9:11 ('before they were born or had done anything good or bad'). Paul's answer speaks of mercy and hardening of particular figures (Moses, Pharaoh, 9:15–18). The follow-up objection in 9:19 ('Why does he still find fault? Who resists his will?') is about individual blame. Commentators such as Cranfield, Moo and Schreiner tend to stress this.
-
Mainly about God's faithfulness to his word. If most of Israel is now outside, has God broken his covenant promise?
The section opens with 'it is not as though the word of God has failed' (9:6). Chapters 9–11 are about Israel as a people. Malachi 1:2–3 refers to the nations Israel and Edom. In Rom 3:3–5 adikia stands against God's faithfulness (pistis) and truthfulness. Commentators such as Dunn and Wright stress this.
-
Both are in view. The fairness question arises inside the question of God's faithfulness.
Adikia covers both wronging someone and breaking faith. Paul's answer (God's freedom to show mercy, 9:15–16) speaks to both at once. Many commentators combine the readings.
in v14
Is the 'choosing' that prompts this objection about individuals or about peoples?
-
Individual election: God chooses particular persons.
Jacob and Esau are named individuals. Pharaoh is a person. 9:16 speaks of 'the one who wills or runs' and 9:19 of 'who' in the singular. The objection of injustice is sharpest if individuals are in view.
-
Corporate or historical election: God chooses peoples and their roles in his purpose.
Gen 25:23, quoted in 9:12, says 'two nations are in your womb'. Mal 1:2–3, quoted in 9:13, concerns Israel and Edom. The whole of chapters 9–11 concerns Israel and the gentiles as groups, and ends with mercy on 'all' (11:32).
in v15
What kind of mercy is in view: individuals' eternal salvation, or God's purpose with peoples (Israel and the Gentiles) in history?
-
Mercy toward individuals, deciding who is saved. Paul defends God's freedom to choose particular people for salvation (an Augustinian and Reformed reading, e.g. Piper, Schreiner, and in modified form Moo).
9:16 denies that the outcome depends on human willing or running. 9:18 pairs mercy with hardening. 9:22–23 speaks of 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. And Paul's grief in 9:1–3 is about his kinsmen being cut off from Christ, which seems to concern salvation itself.
-
Mercy in God's dealings with peoples and his historical purpose. The issue is how God forms his covenant people (Gentiles included, Israel's unbelief only partial and temporary), not the fixed fate of each individual (e.g. Dunn, Wright, Abasciano, and in part Cranfield).
The Old Testament examples concern nations and roles: Jacob and Esau stand for Israel and Edom (Genesis 25:23; Malachi 1:2–3), and Pharaoh's hardening served God's purpose in history. Exodus 33:19 is about mercy to a whole people. And the argument ends in 11:32 with mercy 'on all', where the groups in view are Jews and Gentiles.
in v15
What does the repeated formula 'I will be gracious to whom I am gracious' stress?
-
God's sovereign freedom. God declines to name any condition outside himself, which closes off debate (Lundbom).
The same pattern elsewhere ends discussion (compare Exodus 3:14). Paul uses the verse to answer the charge of injustice, and 9:16 spells out that the outcome lies in God, not in human effort.
-
The certainty and fullness of God's grace. In Exodus it reassures Moses that God really will be gracious to sinful Israel, not merely that he is free to choose.
In context Moses is asking whether God will still go with the people (33:12–17). God agrees, and then proclaims his name as compassionate and gracious (34:6–7). On this view freedom and generosity belong together, since mercy that is free cannot be cancelled by Israel's sin either.
in v16
What is the unstated 'it' that does not depend on willing or running?
-
Individual salvation: whether a particular person receives saving mercy depends only on God's choice, not on that person's will or effort.
The individual examples (Jacob, Esau, Pharaoh), the language of 9:18 ('he has mercy on whom he wants, and he hardens whom he wants'), and the potter imagery of 9:20–23 with 'vessels of mercy' prepared for glory. This view is held in the Augustinian and Reformed tradition (e.g. Augustine, To Simplician 1.2; modern exegetes such as J. Piper and T. Schreiner).
-
God's choice of people for a role in his saving purposes in history (Isaac's line, Jacob's people, Moses, even Pharaoh), rather than the final destiny of individuals.
Genesis 25:23, behind 9:12, concerns two nations and which serves which. Pharaoh is 'raised up' to display God's power (9:17). The whole argument answers a question about Israel as a people (9:6). Associated with readings by C. E. B. Cranfield (in part), J. D. G. Dunn and N. T. Wright.
-
God's mercy toward a people, as a group: God is free to define who his covenant people are and to include gentiles on the basis of faith, not descent or law-works.
Exodus 33, the source of the quotation, is about God's mercy to the whole nation after the golden calf. 9:24–26 applies the argument to 'us, whom he called, not only from the Jews but also from the gentiles'. 9:30–32 explains the outcome in terms of faith versus works. 11:32 has mercy on 'all'. Argued in detail by B. J. Abasciano and others.
in v16
Does the verse deny that human willing and running play any part?
-
It denies that they are the source or basis of mercy, not that they exist or matter. People want and run, but God's mercy is what decides.
Paul elsewhere commands running (1 Cor 9:24) and in this same section speaks of faith and calling on the Lord as the way righteousness is received (9:30–10:13). Early on, Origen (On First Principles 3.1.18) compared it to a ship arriving safely: the sailors' work is real, but the safe arrival is rightly credited to God.
-
It denies that human willing and running have any decisive role in who receives mercy. God's mercy comes first and decides who will in fact want and run.
The strict 'not … nor … but' contrast. The parallel 'not from works but from the one who calls' (9:11–12), said before the twins were born. 9:18's 'whom he wants'. This was developed by the later Augustine and the Reformers.
in v16
Do 'willing' and 'running' allude to a specific story?
-
They are general pictures of human desire and effort, with running drawn from athletics as elsewhere in Paul.
Paul regularly uses trechō in this way (1 Cor 9:24–26; Gal 2:2; 5:7; Phil 2:16), and the race picture continues in 9:30–32. This is the majority view.
-
They echo Genesis 27: Isaac's wish to bless Esau and Esau's hurrying out to hunt, both of which failed to stop Jacob receiving the blessing.
It fits the Jacob–Esau context of 9:10–13. But the LXX of Genesis 27 does not use trechō, so the verbal link is weak, and most commentators doubt it.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἐκπίπτω
- BDAG s.v. οἷος
- BDAG s.v. λόγος
- Thayer s.v. ἐκπίπτω
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §304
- LXX Isaiah 40:7–8; Joshua 21:45; 23:14; 1 Kings 8:56; Sirach 34:7
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
- D. J. Moo, The Letter to the Romans (NICNT)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
- R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
- N. T. Wright, Paul and the Faithfulness of God
- Philo, on the name Israel as "one who sees God" (e.g., De Abrahamo 57)
- Vulgate, Romans 9:6
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
- Septuaginta (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Genesis 21:12–13
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Genesis 21:12
- BDAG s.v. καλέω, σπέρμα, τέκνον
- HALOT s.v. קרא (niphal), זֶרַע
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:6–13
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:6–13
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC), on 9:6–13
- Jubilees 15:30; 16:17–18
- Psalms of Solomon 9:9; 18:3
- Hebrews 11:18; Galatians 3:16, 29; 4:28; Matthew 3:9; John 8:33–39
- BDAG s.v. σάρξ, τέκνον, ἐπαγγελία, λογίζομαι, σπέρμα
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. λογίζομαι
- LXX Genesis 15:6; 18:10, 14; 21:12
- Jubilees 16:16–18
- Mishnah Nedarim 3:11
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Romans 9
- NA28 Greek New Testament; Vulgate (Stuttgart edition)
- BDAG s.v. κοίτη
- BDAG s.v. εἷς
- LSJ s.v. κοίτη
- LXX Lev 15:16–18; 18:20, 23; Num 5:20; Wis 3:13
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:10
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:10–13
- T. R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- Jubilees 19; 35
- Genesis Rabbah 63:6
- Vulgate, Romans 9:10
- BDAG s.v. ἐκλογή, πρόθεσις, μένω, φαῦλος
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἐκλογή, φαῦλος
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Romans 9:11
- Psalms of Solomon 9:4
- Philo, Legum Allegoriae 3.88–89
- Jubilees 19; Genesis Rabbah 63
- Genesis 25:21–26; Malachi 1:2–3 (LXX)
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., Rom 9:11-12
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Genesis 25:23
- BDAG s.v. δουλεύω, μέγας, ἐλάσσων, καλέω, ἔργον
- HALOT s.v. רַב, צָעִיר, עבד
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.257-258 (Idumean conquest)
- Jubilees 19; 35 (Jacob and Esau traditions)
- J.D.G. Dunn, Romans 9-16 (WBC)
- D. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- C.E.B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- T. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Rom 9
- BDAG s.v. μισέω
- BDAG s.v. ἀγαπάω
- HALOT s.v. שׂנא
- BDB s.v. אָהֵב
- Septuagint, Malachi 1:2–4; Genesis 25:23
- Genesis 29:30–31; Deuteronomy 21:15–17; Luke 14:26 with Matthew 10:37
- W. L. Moran, 'The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy,' CBQ 25 (1963)
- Elephantine Aramaic marriage contracts (e.g. TAD B2.6 / Cowley 15), 'hate' as divorce formula
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.257–258 (Idumeans)
- J. Piper, The Justification of God
- Vulgate, Romans 9:13
- BDAG s.v. ἀδικία
- BDAG s.v. γίνομαι (μὴ γένοιτο)
- BDAG s.v. παρά (with dative)
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §§384, 427 (optative of wish; μή in questions)
- Septuagint: Deut 32:4; 2 Chr 19:7; Ps 91:16 (Eng. 92:15); Gen 44:7, 17; Josh 22:29
- Epictetus, Discourses 1.1.13; 1.2.35
- A. J. Malherbe, 'ΜΗ ΓΕΝΟΙΤΟ in the Diatribe and Paul', Harvard Theological Review 73 (1980)
- S. K. Stowers, The Diatribe and Paul's Letter to the Romans (1981)
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC 38B)
- Vulgate, Romans 9:14
- Septuagint, Exodus 33:19; Masoretic Text, Exodus 33:19; 34:6–7
- BDAG s.v. ἐλεέω, ἔλεος
- BDAG s.v. οἰκτίρω, οἰκτιρμός
- HALOT s.v. חנן, רחם
- J. R. Lundbom, 'God's Use of the Idem per Idem to Terminate Debate', Harvard Theological Review 71 (1978)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:14–18
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:15
- J. Piper, The Justification of God: An Exegetical and Theological Study of Romans 9:1–23
- B. J. Abasciano, Paul's Use of the Old Testament in Romans 9.10–18
- N. T. Wright, 'The Letter to the Romans' (New Interpreter's Bible)
- BDAG s.v. ἐλεέω
- BDAG s.v. τρέχω
- BDAG s.v. θέλω
- LSJ s.v. τρέχω
- LXX Exodus 33:19; 34:6
- NA28 critical apparatus at Rom 9:16
- Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
- Thomas R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
- N. T. Wright, 'Romans', New Interpreter's Bible vol. 10
- Brian J. Abasciano, Paul's Use of the Old Testament in Romans 9.10–18
- John Piper, The Justification of God
- Augustine, Ad Simplicianum 1.2
- Origen, De Principiis 3.1.18
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.