Zechariah Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Zechariah 11:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4This is what the LORD my God says: “Pasture the flock marked for slaughter, 5whose buyers slaughter them without remorse. Those who sell them say, ‘Blessed be the LORD, for I am rich!’ Even their own shepherds have no compassion on them.

What the first hearers heard

To a Judean audience who knew Ezekiel 34 and Jeremiah 23, a command to "shepherd the flock" would first have sounded hopeful. Here at last was the true shepherding God had promised. The phrase "of the killing" overturns that at once. The flock is already doomed, and verse 5 says why: its own leaders and those who trade in it treat the people as livestock to be sold and killed for profit, and even thank God for the income.

The prophet's role is to embody, publicly, God's offer of good leadership to such a people. The story that follows dramatises how that leadership is despised. The good shepherd is valued at thirty shekels, roughly the compensation price of a slave gored by an ox (Exod 21:32). Then God withdraws his protection (v. 6) and gives the flock over to a worthless shepherd (vv. 15–17).

For the first hearers the passage worked in two ways:

  • An indictment of their leaders, continuing Zech 10:2–3, for exploiting the community.
  • A warning to the community: rejecting the shepherd God provides has consequences, and the covenant protections ("Favor", "Union") can be broken.

It explained the people's troubles under foreign and domestic exploitation as the result of failed and rejected leadership. It did not present those troubles as random misfortune.

From the study of Zechariah 11:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4This is what the LORD my God says: “Pasture the flock marked for slaughter,

    "This is what YHWH, my own God, has said: 'Go and be the shepherd of the flock that is marked for killing.'"

    The verse opens with a herald's formula. What follows is a message passed on word for word from the King. The prophet adds "my God": the commission is personal, given to him alone.

    The command is a single word, reʿeh, "shepherd!" In Israel and across its world, a shepherd did more than feed animals. He led the flock to grazing, protected it from predators and thieves, gathered strays, and ruled it with his staff. Kings were called "shepherds" of their people. So the prophet is told to step into the role of the people's ruler and act out the care that God intended them to have.

    The flock is not an ordinary flock. Hebrew calls it "the flock of the killing". It is defined by what is going to happen to it. The word for "killing" (haregah) is rare and violent. Elsewhere it appears only in Jeremiah's name for the Valley of Ben-Hinnom, "the Valley of Slaughter", a place of judgment. The next verse explains how the flock came to be doomed: buyers kill the sheep and feel no guilt, sellers thank God for making them rich, and the flock's own shepherds have no pity.

    The prophet is therefore sent to shepherd a people already being destroyed, largely by those who should have protected them. The rest of the chapter shows that this last attempt at true shepherding is rejected, and the prophet's wages are a contemptuous thirty pieces of silver.

    Full study →
  2. 5whose buyers slaughter them without remorse. Those who sell them say, ‘Blessed be the LORD, for I am rich!’ Even their own shepherds have no compassion on them.

    "…the flock whose buyers kill them, and no guilt falls on them. Their sellers — each one of them — say, 'Blessed be the LORD, I've struck it rich!' And their own shepherds — not one of them — spares them or lifts a hand to protect them."

    The verse describes "the flock marked for slaughter" that God has just told the prophet to tend (v. 4). Its picture is a livestock trade in which the animals are human beings:

    • Buyers acquire the flock and kill it. The verb is the one used for violent killing of people, not the ordinary word for butchering. Afterwards they are not ʾasham: no guilt is charged to them and no penalty follows. They may even tell themselves they are innocent.
    • Sellers hand the flock over for money. One by one they recite a line from worship, "Blessed be YHWH!", and give the reason: "for I have become rich." They treat their profit as God's blessing, though the flock they are selling belongs to God.
    • Shepherds, a common ancient title for rulers, are the ones whose job is to protect the flock. They do not chamal: they feel none of the pity that would make them spare it.

    All three groups use the flock up, and nobody pays. Verse 6 answers with the same verb: since the shepherds would not spare the flock, God "will no longer spare" the people of the land.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    Feed (the flock)

    reʿeh

    What we hear
    Give the sheep food; provide nourishment.
    What they heard
    Act as shepherd: lead to pasture, guard, gather and rule the flock. Applied to people, it means to govern them as their leader.
  • in v5

    without remorse / hold themselves not guilty

    lo yeʾshamu

    What we hear
    The buyers feel no guilt. It is about their conscience.
    What they heard
    They incur or bear no guilt: no liability is charged and no penalty follows. The point is the objective state, whatever they feel, though they may also be claiming innocence (compare Jer 50:7).
  • in v5

    shepherds

    roʿim

    What we hear
    Literal herdsmen, or church pastors.
    What they heard
    Rulers and leaders of the community. 'Shepherd' was the standard royal and governing title in Israel and the wider ancient Near East.
  • in v5

    pity them not (KJV, WEB)

    lo yachmol

    What we hear
    They don't feel sorry for them, a passing emotion.
    What they heard
    They do not spare them. Chamal is the compassion that holds back harm and acts to protect.
Every word
  1. כֹּ֥ה

    koh · H3541

    thus, so · v4

    Opens the standard messenger formula ('Thus says...'). It marks what follows as the exact wording of a message passed on from a higher authority, the way a royal herald spoke.

  2. אָמַ֖ר

    ʾamar · H0559

    to say · v4, v5

    Perfect tense, literally 'has said / said'. In the messenger formula it stands for a word already given by the sender and now being passed on. English 'says' is a fair rendering.

  3. יְהוָ֣ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (the divine name) · v4, v5

    Israel's God named personally. He is the sender of the command, and so the real owner of the flock the prophet is told to shepherd.

  4. אֱלֹהָ֑י

    ʾelohay · H0430

    my God · v4

    'God' with the suffix 'my'. The prophet speaks of his own bond with YHWH as he takes up a hard commission. In Zechariah the phrase comes again only at 14:5.

  5. רְעֵ֖ה

    reʿeh · H7462

    to pasture, tend, shepherd · v4, v5

    A command addressed to one man: 'Be shepherd to...'. It covers the whole job: leading to grazing, guarding, gathering and ruling the flock. Because shepherd was a standard word for a ruler, the prophet is being told to play the part of the people's leader.

  6. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    (marks the direct object) · v4

    This word is not translated. It shows that the flock is the object of the shepherding.

  7. צֹ֥אן

    tsoʾn · H6629

    flock (sheep and goats) · v4

    A collective noun for small livestock. Hebrew links it straight to the next word, 'flock of...', so the flock is defined by where it is headed. It stands for the people of Judah/Israel.

  8. הַהֲרֵגָֽה׃

    ha-haregah · H2028

    slaughter, killing · v4

    'The killing'. This is a rare noun from the verb harag, 'to kill' (violent killing, not the usual butchering words). The flock is already marked out for death. Verse 5 picks up the same root: the buyers 'kill them' (yahargun) and feel no guilt.

  9. אֲשֶׁר

    ʾasher · H0834A

    which, who, whose · v5

    Ties the verse back to 'the flock marked for slaughter' in verse 4. The whole verse describes what is being done to that flock: 'the flock whose buyers…'.

  10. קֹנֵיהֶן

    qoneihen · H7069

    to acquire, buy · v5

    Participle with a feminine-plural 'them' that points to the flock: 'those who buy them'. The sheep are goods bought for a price. The KJV's 'possessors' reflects the older sense 'acquire', but the trade setting (buyers and sellers) makes 'buyers' the better reading.

  11. יַהַרְגֻן

    yahargun · H2026

    to kill, slay · v5

    'They kill them.' This is the ordinary verb for violent killing, used mostly of people, not the usual words for butchering animals or offering sacrifice. It echoes 'the flock of slaughter' (tson ha-haregah) in verse 4 and hints that these sheep are people.

  12. וְלֹא

    ve-lo · H3808

    and not · v5

    Negates the next verb: the killing is followed by no guilt.

  13. יֶאְשָׁמוּ

    yeʾshamu · H0816

    to be guilty, incur guilt, bear the penalty · v5

    'They are not guilty' / 'they bear no guilt'. The buyers face no consequence and carry no liability for the killing. Whether this means they feel no remorse, or no one holds them to account, is debated. The verb points first to the objective state of liability, not to a feeling.

  14. וּמֹכְרֵיהֶן

    u-mokhreihen · H4376

    to sell · v5

    'And those who sell them.' The other half of the trade. Someone with rights over the flock is handing it over for money.

  15. בָּרוּךְ

    barukh · H1288

    blessed · v5

    The opening of a standard formula of praise: 'Blessed be YHWH'. In worship it thanks God for a good gift. Here it thanks God for the profit made from selling the flock to its death, which is bitter irony.

  16. וַאעְשִׁר

    va-ʾaʿshir · H6238

    to become rich · v5

    'And I have become rich' / 'for I am rich'. The form is unusual. It is intransitive: 'I have grown rich', not 'I have enriched someone'. The 'and' gives the reason for the praise: 'Blessed be YHWH, because I've made money.'

  17. יַחְמוֹל

    yachmol · H2550

    to spare, have pity, have compassion · v5

    'Does not spare / has no pity'. Again a singular verb with a plural subject: not one shepherd spares them. Chamal is pity that holds back harm. The shepherds feel nothing that would make them protect the flock. God uses the same verb in verse 6: 'I will no longer have pity'.

  18. עֲלֵיהֶן

    ʿaleihen · H5921A

    upon, over, on · v5

    'On them' (feminine plural, the flock). With chamal it marks who the pity would be for.

The world behind it

A prophetic sign-act. Verses 4–17 are a commission for the prophet to act out a message, as earlier prophets did: Isaiah walking stripped (Isa 20), Jeremiah's yoke (Jer 27), Ezekiel's sticks (Ezek 37). The prophet takes two staffs named "Favor" and "Union" (v. 7), gets rid of three shepherds (v. 8), breaks the staffs (vv. 10, 14), and is paid thirty shekels of silver, which he throws "to the potter" in the house of YHWH (vv. 12–13). Scholars debate whether this was actually performed or is a literary or visionary account (see debates).

Shepherds = rulers. In the ancient Near East "shepherd" was a royal title (Hammurabi, Assyrian kings). Israel's prophets used it to put the nation's leaders on trial: Jer 23:1–4, and above all Ezekiel 34, where the shepherds fatten themselves on the flock and YHWH promises to shepherd it himself. Zechariah 11 deliberately turns this hope upside down. In Ezekiel 37 two sticks are joined to show a reunited Judah and Israel. Here the staff "Union" is broken, cancelling the brotherhood between Judah and Israel (v. 14).

Livestock trade. Verse 5 assumes how a flock market worked. Owners and dealers sold sheep, buyers slaughtered them, and hired shepherds were paid wages (compare v. 12). The image is of a people handled as a commodity. Those who profit even credit God for it ("Blessed be YHWH, for I am rich!").

Date and audience. Chapters 9–14 of Zechariah are widely thought to come from a later stage than chapters 1–8. Proposals range from the Persian period (5th century BC) to the early Hellenistic era, and a minority argue for earlier material. Either way, the first hearers were a small Judean community under foreign rule, with local elites (priests, governors, wealthy landholders) who could be partners in exploitation.

Later echo. Matthew 27:9–10 draws on vv. 12–13 (the thirty pieces of silver and the potter), attributing the passage to Jeremiah. Mark 14:27 quotes Zech 13:7 ("strike the shepherd"). Early Christians therefore read this shepherd material in the light of Jesus' rejection. This verse itself is not quoted in the New Testament.

From the study of Zechariah 11:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

Was this a sign-act the prophet actually performed, or a literary allegory?

  • Actually performed (or at least presented as a real public act).

    The first-person report ('So I shepherded...', v. 7), concrete details (two named staffs, a wage weighed out, silver thrown into the temple), and the precedent of acted-out prophecies in Isaiah, Jeremiah and Ezekiel.

  • Literary or visionary allegory.

    Elements that are hard to picture literally, such as removing three shepherds 'in one month' (v. 8) and breaking a covenant 'with all the peoples' (v. 10). The passage also reworks Ezekiel 34 and 37 very closely, which suggests a written composition.

in v4

Whom does the prophet represent, and who are the flock's oppressors?

  • The prophet represents YHWH himself, shepherding his people one last time.

    The staffs stand for YHWH's covenant ('my covenant', v. 10), and the wage is mockingly called 'the magnificent price at which I was valued by them' (v. 13), with the 'I' sliding between prophet and God.

  • The prophet plays a human, ideal (even messianic) ruler.

    Shepherd was a royal title. The worthless shepherd of vv. 15–17 is a human ruler, so the good shepherd may be too. Later Jewish and Christian readers linked the passage with a coming ruler, and Matthew applies vv. 12–13 to Jesus.

  • The oppressors are specific historical figures.

    Proposals tie the buyers, sellers and shepherds to Persian or Hellenistic overlords, Judean governors, high priests or wealthy elites. No identification has won consensus. The 'three shepherds' of v. 8 have drawn dozens of proposals.

in v5

Who are the buyers, the sellers and the shepherds?

  • Buyers are foreign powers; sellers and shepherds are Judah's own leaders.

    'Their own shepherds' sets the shepherds apart as insiders. Buying and killing fits foreign overlords who exploit or enslave the people (compare Joel 3:3–6). Verse 6 mentions 'neighbor' and 'king' as agents of ruin.

  • All three are internal elites in Judah: officials, wealthy landholders and priests.

    Nehemiah 5 shows Judeans selling fellow Judeans into debt-slavery. Hosea 12:8 and Ezekiel 34 aim similar language at Israel's own leaders. Verse 7's possible 'sheep merchants' (see Septuagint) points to insiders profiting.

  • The roles are typical, not tied to specific historical figures; the allegory sums up Israel's history of bad leadership.

    The text names no one. Zechariah 9–14 reuses earlier prophetic images heavily. Attempts to pin it to particular Persian governors, high priests or Hellenistic rulers have not reached any consensus.

in v5

Does 'lo yeʾshamu' mean they feel no guilt, or that they bear no penalty?

  • Subjective: they think themselves innocent or feel no remorse.

    Septuagint 'did not regret it'; KJV 'hold themselves not guilty'; Jeremiah 50:7, where enemies say 'we are not guilty' as self-justification.

  • Objective: they are not held liable and go unpunished.

    The core sense of ʾasham is liability and its consequences (Lev 4–5; Hos 10:2; 14:1). God's intervention in verse 6 answers a world in which no one pays.

  • Both are in view: no guilt is charged and none is felt.

    In Hebrew thought, being guilty and owning one's guilt go closely together, and the bare statement leaves both open.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).