1 Samuel Chapter 25 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 25:2–3

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

2Now there was a man in Maon whose business was in Carmel. He was a very wealthy man with a thousand goats and three thousand sheep, which he was shearing in Carmel. 3His name was Nabal, and his wife’s name was Abigail. She was an intelligent and beautiful woman, but her husband, a Calebite, was harsh and evil in his dealings.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers this verse sets up a familiar scene and a test.

  • They knew the country. Maon, Carmel and the Calebite clans around Hebron were real places and real people. The story roots David's rise in Judah's south, the region that would make him king at Hebron.
  • They read wealth as standing. A "very great" man with thousands of animals was a local power. Such a man was expected to act as patron to those around him, feeding dependants, rewarding protectors and hosting guests.
  • They heard "shearing" as "feast". The time marker raises expectations of plenty and generosity. When the rich man then refuses (vv. 10–11), the hearers recognise a scandal: hospitality denied at the season set aside for it, by the man most able to give it.
  • They were primed for irony. The man is introduced by his possessions before his name, and the name turns out to be Nabal, "fool" (v. 25). His greatness lies in what he owns, not in who he is. In chapters 24–26 the story sits between two scenes where David spares Saul, and many readers have seen Nabal as a stand-in for Saul: a powerful man who repays good with evil and whom God himself strikes down (v. 38), so that David does not have to take revenge.

From the study of 1 Samuel 25:2.

Verse by verse

  1. 2Now there was a man in Maon whose business was in Carmel. He was a very wealthy man with a thousand goats and three thousand sheep, which he was shearing in Carmel.

    There was a man, and the story deliberately holds back his name. He lived in Maon, a town in the southern hill country of Judah, but his estate was based at Carmel. This is not the famous northern mountain. It is a nearby Judean town whose name means "garden-land". He was "great, exceedingly", meaning he was a man of wealth and standing: what people would call a leading man of the district, not a good man. His holdings are counted for us: three thousand sheep and a thousand goats, a very large estate. Then the clock is set: it was the time of shearing his flock at Carmel. Shearing was the wool harvest, the season of feasting and plenty, when a rich man was expected to be generous.

    The order of the verse matters. We learn where he lived, where his wealth was, how great he was and how many animals he had before we learn his name (Nabal, "fool", in v. 3). The verse begins and ends in Carmel, so all of it is about his wealth and where it was. The first hearers would expect a feast, gifts and hospitality. The tension of the chapter comes from a "very great" man who will not share at the very moment he has most to give.

    Full study →
  2. 3His name was Nabal, and his wife’s name was Abigail. She was an intelligent and beautiful woman, but her husband, a Calebite, was harsh and evil in his dealings.

    The man's name was "Fool" (Nabal). The word did not mean a dimwit. It meant the kind of person Israel's wisdom tradition warned about: someone who ignores God, scorns his obligations to others and refuses bread to the hungry. His wife's name was Abigail ("my father rejoices"). The narrator then sets them side by side like two halves of a proverb:

    • She was good in good sense. She had practical, perceptive judgment that sees what a moment demands and acts on it. She was also beautiful in form, and the narrator mentions this second.
    • He was hard: harsh, unbending, heavy-handed with people. He was also bad in his dealings: his habitual conduct toward others was harmful and wicked. Her "good" and his "bad" are the exact opposites (tov and ra'). That contrast drives the whole chapter, which turns on Nabal "returning evil for good."

    Finally: "and he was a Calebite." On the surface this is a fact about his clan. He belonged to the leading clan of the Hebron hill country, descendants of the heroic Caleb. But the Hebrew consonants also suggest keleb, "dog", and can be read "just like his heart." So the hearer gets a last jab: the heir of faithful Caleb is a fool and a dog of a man, exactly what his heart is. Before a word of dialogue, the hearer knows who will act wisely in this story and who will come to a bad end.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    Carmel

    Karmel

    What we hear
    Mount Carmel, the northern mountain range by the Mediterranean where Elijah faced the prophets of Baal.
    What they heard
    A small town in the Judean hill country south of Hebron, next to Maon (Joshua 15:55), more than 150 km from the northern mountain. The name means 'garden-land'.
  • in v2

    the man was very great (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    gadol me'od

    What we hear
    A great man: admirable, distinguished, perhaps morally impressive.
    What they heard
    Very wealthy and socially powerful, a man of high standing. It says nothing about character, and the next verse calls him harsh and evil.
  • in v3

    Nabal (a name only); 'fool' when explained

    naval / nabal

    What we hear
    Either just a foreign-sounding name, or, when explained as 'fool', someone silly or unintelligent.
    What they heard
    To Hebrew hearers the name was the word 'fool' in its biblical sense: a morally senseless, godless, ungrateful boor who withholds food from the hungry (Ps 14:1; Isa 32:6). It is not a judgment on intelligence. Nabal is a shrewd, rich man.
  • in v3

    churlish (KJV)

    qasheh

    What we hear
    Rude, sulky, ill-mannered.
    What they heard
    Hard, harsh, unbending and oppressive: the word used for the crushing labour in Egypt and for harsh speech. In 1611 'churl' also meant a coarse, stingy man, which fit better than the modern sense does.
  • in v3

    intelligent (BSB, WEB, NIV, NASB)

    sekhel

    What we hear
    Bright, academically capable, high IQ.
    What they heard
    Practical good sense and prudence: reading a situation correctly and acting successfully, as Abigail does in vv. 18–31.
Every word
  1. וְאִ֨ישׁ

    ve'ish · H0376

    and a man · v2, v3

    The story opens abruptly with no verb: 'And a man…'. He is left unnamed for now. The narrator identifies him first by where he lives and what he owns, and gives his name only in verse 3.

  2. בְּמָע֜וֹן

    be-Ma'on · H4584

    in Maon · v2

    Maon was a town in the hill country of Judah (Joshua 15:55), south of Hebron. Its 'wilderness' had just been David's hiding-ground from Saul (1 Samuel 23:24–25). This was where the man lived.

  3. וּמַעֲשֵׂ֣הוּ

    u-ma'asehu · H4639

    and his work · v2

    'His work': his operations, meaning the herds, land and labour that made up his livelihood. The word covers both the activity (occupation) and what it produces (property, especially livestock).

  4. בַכַּרְמֶ֗ל

    va-Karmel · H3760

    in (the) Carmel · v2

    This is the Judean town of Carmel, a short distance from Maon. It is not Mount Carmel in the north. The definite article ('the Carmel') keeps the sense of the common noun karmel, 'garden-land, fertile ground'.

  5. גָּד֣וֹל

    gadol · H1419

    great · v2

    'Great' in the social sense: wealthy, powerful, a man of standing. It says nothing about his character, and the next verse calls that character harsh and evil.

  6. מְאֹ֔ד

    me'od · H3966

    very · v2

    An intensifier: 'exceedingly'. He is not just comfortable. He is one of the leading magnates of the region.

  7. וְל֛וֹ

    ve-lo

    and to him · v2

    The preposition 'to' with 'him' is the ordinary Hebrew way to say 'he had'. It introduces the list of his holdings.

  8. צֹ֥אן

    tson · H6629

    flock, sheep · v2

    Usually a collective word for small livestock, sheep and goats together. Here it stands next to 'goats', so it means sheep in particular.

  9. שְׁלֹֽשֶׁת־

    shloshet · H7969

    three · v2

    'Three' of (thousands). Hebrew lists the sheep first, the larger and more valuable part of the herd.

  10. אֲלָפִ֖ים

    alafim · H0505

    thousands · v2

    'Thousands'. Three thousand sheep was a very large flock for a private owner in the Judean hills.

  11. עִזִּ֑ים

    'izzim · H5795

    goats · v2

    Goats were kept for milk, meat and hair (used for tent cloth). They were hardier than sheep on the dry edges of the wilderness.

  12. וַיְהִ֛י

    vayhi · H1961

    and it was · v2

    'And it came to pass'. This standard narrative marker sets the time frame for the events that follow.

  13. בִּגְזֹ֥ז

    bigzoz · H1494

    in shearing · v2

    'In (the time of) shearing'. The verb form has no stated subject, so it marks the season (shearing time) rather than a man personally holding the shears. That season was a festival of plenty, and the story depends on it.

  14. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    (object marker) · v2

    Marks 'his flock' as the direct object of the shearing. It has no English equivalent.

  15. וְשֵׁ֤ם

    veshem · H8034

    and the name of · v3

    Opens a formal introduction of a character. In Hebrew storytelling a name is often a clue to the person, and here the narrator puts the name first so the hearer reacts to it before anything else is said.

  16. נָבָ֔ל

    Naval · H5037

    Nabal · v3

    A personal name, but to any Hebrew ear identical to the common word nabal, 'fool': not a dimwit, but a person who is morally senseless, boorish, ungrateful and contemptuous of God and neighbour. Abigail spells it out in verse 25: 'as his name is, so is he.'

  17. אִשְׁתּ֖וֹ

    ishto · H802

    his wife · v3

    Defines her, at first, by her relation to Nabal. The rest of the chapter undoes that dependence: she acts independently of him and ends up as David's wife.

  18. אֲבִגָ֑יִל

    Avigayil · H26

    Abigail · v3

    Most likely 'my father rejoices' or 'my father is joy' (avi + gil). Unlike her husband's name, hers carries no warning. The name is a positive one, and the narrator does not dwell on it.

  19. טֽוֹבַת־

    tovat · H2896

    good of · v3

    'Good in respect of', the first half of the expression 'good of insight'. Tov ('good') here sets up the chapter's central contrast of good against bad (ra'), which comes back in verse 21: 'he has returned me evil for good.'

  20. שֶׂ֙כֶל֙

    sekhel · H7922

    insight, prudence, good sense · v3

    Practical, perceptive good sense: the ability to read a situation and act successfully in it. Abigail shows exactly this when she moves fast to head off disaster (vv. 18–31). It is the same root used of David 'acting wisely and succeeding' in 18:14–15.

  21. וִ֣יפַת

    vifat · H3303

    and beautiful of · v3

    'Beautiful in respect of'. Her beauty is noted, but only after her good sense: the narrator ranks her mind first.

  22. תֹּ֔אַר

    to'ar · H8389

    form, figure, appearance · v3

    Outward shape or bearing, the whole figure and not just the face. 'Beautiful of form' is the stock phrase used for Rachel, Joseph and Esther, people whose looks matter to the plot.

  23. קָשֶׁ֛ה

    qasheh · H7186

    hard, harsh, severe, stubborn · v3

    Hard to deal with: harsh, unyielding, oppressive in how he treats people. The same word describes the 'hard' slave labour in Egypt (Exod 1:14) and 'harsh' words (Gen 42:7; 1 Sam 20:10). His rough reply to David's men in verses 10–11 shows it.

  24. וְרַ֥ע

    vera' · H7451

    and bad / evil of · v3

    The exact opposite of Abigail's tov, 'good'. Ra' covers both harmful and morally wicked, and here it describes how he behaves toward others.

  25. מַעֲלָלִ֖ים

    ma'alalim · H4611

    deeds, practices, dealings · v3

    Habitual conduct, a person's track record. The prophets use it almost formulaically in 'the evil of your deeds' (Deut 28:20; Jer 4:4). The charge is that his ways of acting are bad, not just one act.

  26. וְה֥וּא

    vehu · H1931

    and he · v3

    Adds a final, separate piece of information about Nabal: his clan identity, which also works as a pun.

  27. כָלִבִּֽי׃

    kalibbi (written consonants kalbo / kelibbo) · H3614

    Calebite · v3

    A member of the clan of Caleb, which held the Hebron hill country where Maon and Carmel lay. The written consonants can also be read as 'like his heart' and sound like keleb, 'dog'. So the clan label doubles as a jibe that the man is a dog, or 'just as his heart is'.

The world behind it

Place. Maon and Carmel were neighbouring towns in the dry hill country south of Hebron (Joshua 15:55), on the edge of the Judean wilderness. The area belonged to the clan of Caleb (Hebron had been given to Caleb, Joshua 14:13–14), and verse 3 calls Nabal a Calebite. David had recently been hiding in "the wilderness of Maon" (1 Samuel 23:24–25). Saul had set up a victory monument at Carmel (1 Samuel 15:12).

Herding economy. A flock of 4,000 animals needed hired shepherds and seasonal pasture deep in the wilderness, where flocks were exposed to raiders. Verses 7 and 15–16 report that David's armed band had been "a wall" around Nabal's shepherds. In return David expected a share of the bounty, a customary arrangement on that frontier.

Shearing time. Sheepshearing, usually in spring, was the wool harvest and the main payday of a herding estate. It came with feasting, drink and gifts, and also with risk: Absalom used his shearing feast to kill Amnon (2 Samuel 13:23–29). For the first hearers, "it was at the shearing" meant that food was plentiful and generosity was expected. That is why David sends his request "on a good day" (v. 8) and why Nabal's refusal is so shocking.

Political background. Scholars such as Jon Levenson and Baruch Halpern have argued that Nabal was a leading figure, possibly a chief, among the Calebites. If so, David's later marriage to his widow Abigail gave David a foothold in the region whose centre, Hebron, would soon anoint him king (2 Samuel 2:1–4). The verse's stress on Nabal's "greatness" fits this reading, though it remains an inference.

From the study of 1 Samuel 25:2.

Where scholars differ

in v2

Was David's expectation of payment at shearing time a fair custom or a protection racket?

  • A legitimate customary claim: David's band actually protected Nabal's shepherds, and a share of the shearing bounty was the expected return.

    Nabal's own shepherd testifies that David's men were 'a wall to us both by night and by day' and that nothing went missing (vv. 15–16). Shearing was a recognised time for gifts. Abigail treats the request as just (vv. 18, 28).

  • A veiled demand for protection money from an armed outlaw band.

    David's message stresses that 'we did not harm them' (v. 7), which can read as an implied threat. His immediate move to kill every male of Nabal's household when refused (vv. 13, 21–22, 34) shows armed pressure behind the request. Nabal's dismissal of David as a runaway servant (v. 10) reflects how the landowner may have seen it.

in v2

Was Nabal a private rich man or a Calebite clan leader whose holdings had political weight?

  • A clan magnate. His estate and status made his household politically significant, and David's marriage to Abigail helped secure Judahite (Calebite) support before David was anointed at Hebron.

    The 'very great' status (v. 2), the Calebite identification (v. 3), the 'feast like a king's' (v. 36), and the location in Caleb's territory near Hebron, with David's anointing there soon after (2 Samuel 2:1–4). Argued by J. D. Levenson (1978) and Levenson and Halpern (1980).

  • A wealthy landowner whose story is told chiefly for moral and literary purposes.

    The text never calls Nabal a chief or ruler. The narrative's focus is on folly versus wisdom and on David being kept from shedding blood (vv. 26, 33). The political reading is an inference from later events.

in v3

Was 'Nabal' (Fool) really the man's name?

  • It is a nickname or narrator's label, chosen or adapted to fit his character.

    No parent would plausibly name a child 'Fool' in its moral sense. The story is full of meaningful wordplay (vv. 25, 36–37), and Abigail's 'as his name is, so is he' reads like the narrator underlining a symbolic name.

  • It was a real name with an innocent original meaning, which the storyteller turns into a pun.

    Semitic languages have other roots spelled n-b-l. Arabic nabil, for instance, means 'noble' or 'skilled', and some scholars (e.g., James Barr) propose a respectable meaning for the name. On this view the Hebrew narrator exploits an accidental likeness to nabal, 'fool'.

in v3

What is the point of 'he was a Calebite'?

  • Mainly historical and political: Nabal belonged to the dominant clan of the Hebron region, and marrying his widow strengthened David's position there.

    Calebites held Hebron (Josh 14–15). David is anointed at Hebron soon afterward (2 Sam 2:1–4), and Abigail goes there with him. Jon Levenson and Baruch Halpern have argued for the political weight of David's marriages.

  • Mainly a pun: 'dog-like' or 'just as his heart is'.

    The written consonants כלבו allow 'like his heart'. The Septuagint renders 'dog-like' (kynikos). 'Dog' is a common insult in Samuel (1 Sam 17:43; 24:14; 2 Sam 3:8). Heart imagery returns at Nabal's death (v. 37).

  • Both at once.

    Hebrew narrative often lets a factual detail carry a second, ironic meaning. Neither reading excludes the other.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מַעֲשֶׂה, גָּדוֹל, כַּרְמֶל, גָּזַז
  • HALOT s.v. מַעֲשֶׂה, כַּרְמֶל, צֹאן
  • Joshua 15:55; 1 Samuel 15:12; 23:24–25
  • Genesis 38:12–13; 2 Samuel 13:23–29 (sheepshearing feasts)
  • 2 Samuel 19:32 (Barzillai, 'a very great man')
  • Jon D. Levenson, '1 Samuel 25 as Literature and as History', Catholic Biblical Quarterly 40 (1978)
  • Jon D. Levenson and Baruch Halpern, 'The Political Import of David's Marriages', Journal of Biblical Literature 99 (1980)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • Robert P. Gordon, 'David's Rise and Saul's Demise: Narrative Analogy in 1 Samuel 24–26', Tyndale Bulletin 31 (1980)
  • BDB s.v. נָבָל, שֵׂכֶל, קָשֶׁה, מַעֲלָל
  • HALOT s.v. נָבָל I and II, כָּלִבִּי
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 25:3
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities book 6 (Nabal episode)
  • Jon D. Levenson, '1 Samuel 25 as Literature and as History', CBQ 40 (1978)
  • Jon D. Levenson and Baruch Halpern, 'The Political Import of David's Marriages', JBL 99 (1980)
  • James Barr, 'The Symbolism of Names in the Old Testament', BJRL 52 (1969)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).