1 Thessalonians Chapter 5 Read as one passage
1 Thessalonians 5:19–21
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
19Do not extinguish the Spirit. 20Do not treat prophecies with contempt, 21but test all things. Hold fast to what is good.
What the first hearers heard
To the Thessalonian believers this was a practical instruction about their meetings. God's Spirit was active among them. His presence showed up especially in prophetic speech, and they, as a community, were responsible not to smother it. They might be tempted to suppress it out of embarrassment, suspicion of anything ecstatic, reaction to excesses, or a wish for quiet order. Paul answers that the Spirit's fire is not something to put out.
Paul pairs this immediately with discernment (vv. 20–22), so the first hearers would not have taken it as a call to uncritical enthusiasm either. Prophecies were to be welcomed, then weighed. What was good was to be kept and what was evil rejected. The plural commands addressed them as one body, together responsible for both keeping the fire alive and testing what it produced. This fit Paul's larger hope for them, a community made holy by God's Spirit as it waited for the Lord's coming (4:8; 5:23).
From the study of 1 Thessalonians 5:19.
Verse by verse
-
19Do not extinguish the Spirit.
Full study →"The Spirit: don't put out his fire."
Paul has just given a rapid series of short commands for the community's shared life (rejoice always, pray constantly, give thanks in everything, vv. 16–18). Now he turns to how the church treats the activity of God's Spirit among them. He puts "the Spirit" first for emphasis and uses a verb for dousing a flame or letting a lamp go out. The picture is of God's Spirit as a fire burning in the gathered church. The command is plural and present tense: all of you, don't make a practice of smothering it.
The next lines show what he has in mind. "Do not treat prophecies with contempt, but test all things; hold fast to what is good; abstain from every form of evil" (vv. 20–22). Smothering the Spirit means shutting down or looking down on what the Spirit does when they meet, especially inspired speech. Paul does not ask them to swallow everything as genuine, though. The same breath that says "don't put out the fire" says "test everything." The verse is one half of a balanced instruction: neither smother what the Spirit does nor accept it without checking.
-
20Do not treat prophecies with contempt,
Full study →"As for prophetic utterances, don't treat them as nothing."
Paul has just said, "Do not put out the Spirit's fire" (v. 19). Now he names the main way that fire showed itself in the gathered church: prophecies. These were messages that ordinary members spoke aloud in the meeting because they believed God's Spirit had shown them something, words meant to build up, encourage and console (1 Cor 14:3). "Prophecies" comes first in the Greek for emphasis, and it is plural: actual utterances, one after another, not "prophecy" in the abstract and not the prophetic books of Scripture.
The verb means to count something as zero: to brush it aside, belittle it, write it off. It describes the dismissive look or eye-roll more than burning hatred. Because it is a present-tense command addressed to the whole community, it forbids an ongoing attitude: don't become a church that habitually waves these words away.
The sentence is only half of a balance. The next words, "but test all things, hold fast to what is good, keep away from every form of evil" (vv. 21–22), make clear that Paul is not asking for blind acceptance. The church is to neither swallow every utterance nor scorn them all, but listen, weigh, keep the good and drop the bad.
-
21but test all things. Hold fast to what is good.
Full study →"Do not treat prophetic words with contempt. Instead, put every one of them to the test, all of them, the way a moneychanger tests a coin or a smith assays metal, and keep doing so as a congregation. Whatever proves genuine and sound, grip it and keep holding on to it. And every kind of evil, keep well away from it."
Verse 21 is the middle of a balanced instruction about the Spirit's gifts in the gathered church (5:19–22). Paul has just said don't quench the Spirit and don't despise prophecies. Now he gives the alternative to both gullibility and contempt, which is discernment. Both commands are plural and in the ongoing present tense: the whole community, not one gatekeeper, is to keep testing and keep holding fast. "All things" is placed first for emphasis, so nothing spoken "in the Spirit" is exempt from scrutiny. The test leads to a sorting: the good (kalon, which means fine and genuine as well as morally right) is to be kept, and in verse 22 evil of every kind is to be refused. In the KJV, "Prove all things" means test all things, not demonstrate them true.
Where the English drifted
-
in v19
quench
sbennymi
- What we hear
- Mainly 'to satisfy (thirst)', so 'quench the Spirit' can sound vague or puzzling.
- What they heard
- To put out a fire or let a lamp go out. Figuratively, to suppress something pictured as a living flame.
-
in v20
despise
exoutheneō
- What we hear
- To hate or loathe something intensely.
- What they heard
- To treat as nothing, look down on, dismiss with contempt: belittling more than hatred.
-
in v20
prophecies / prophesyings
prophēteia
- What we hear
- Predictions of the future, or the prophetic passages of the Bible (often read through end-times charts).
- What they heard
- Messages members of the congregation spoke in the meeting under the Spirit's prompting, mainly to strengthen, encourage and comfort. These might include insight, warning, direction or occasionally prediction, and all were subject to the church's testing.
-
in v20
prophesyings (KJV)
prophēteia
- What we hear
- Readers influenced by Reformation tradition may take it to mean preaching or explaining Scripture.
- What they heard
- Paul lists prophecy separately from teaching (1 Cor 12:28–29; 14:6) and ties it to a "revelation" given on the spot (1 Cor 14:30). It was not a prepared exposition of a text.
-
in v21
Prove (KJV, YLT: "Prove all things")
dokimazete
- What we hear
- Demonstrate that things are true; establish or verify them.
- What they heard
- Put things to the test to see whether they are genuine, as metal is assayed or a coin checked, and then accept or reject them on the result.
-
in v21
all things / everything
panta
- What we hear
- A general maxim: examine every idea, philosophy or experience you meet, or try everything and keep what works.
- What they heard
- Following "do not despise prophecies", it means first of all every prophetic utterance and Spirit-claim in the assembly, each of which is to be weighed. The principle can extend further, but its home is the church's discernment of prophecy.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v19
'Quench the Spirit' is about the gathered church, not just private feelings
- What's often taught
- Quenching the Spirit is often taught as something an individual believer does inwardly, by sinning or ignoring the Spirit's personal promptings, so that the Spirit's presence in their own heart grows dim.
- What the text supports
The command is plural ("all of you, don't extinguish") and sits in a tight unit about the community's life together. The very next line is "do not treat prophecies with contempt", followed by "test all things, hold fast to what is good" (vv. 20–21). In context, quenching the Spirit means a congregation suppressing or looking down on what the Spirit does among them, especially inspired speech. Paul pairs it at once with careful testing, so the verse also gives no licence to accept every claimed word from the Spirit unexamined.
The popular reading is not wholly wrong. The church is made of individuals, and Paul elsewhere warns believers not to "grieve" the Spirit by how they live (Eph 4:30). But that is a different verse with a different verb. This one is about how the church treats the Spirit's activity in its midst.
- Where the English feeds it
- English 'you' does not show plural, so 'Do not quench the Spirit' reads easily as a private instruction. Printing the verse alone, cut off from verses 20–22, also hides its link to prophecy and testing.
in v20
This verse isn't about end-times Bible prophecy
- What's often taught
- Some read the verse as a command not to neglect or mock the Bible's prophecies about the future, and use it to urge believers to study prophetic Scripture and end-times events.
- What the text supports
The surrounding verses set the scene in the church's own meetings. "Do not quench the Spirit" (v. 19) comes just before, and "test all things; hold fast what is good" (v. 21) comes just after. "Prophecies" is plural with no article: particular messages that members spoke aloud in the meeting (compare 1 Cor 14:3, 29–31; 1 Tim 1:18). Paul's remedy is to test these utterances and keep only "the good". That makes sense for words spoken by fallible members. It is not how Paul treats Scripture, which he never tells churches to sift. Taking prophetic Scripture seriously may be right on other grounds, but this verse is about how a congregation receives Spirit-prompted speech: neither scorning it nor swallowing it whole.
- Where the English feeds it
- Modern English "prophecy" leans heavily toward "prediction" and "Bible prophecy". "Despise" also sounds like hostility rather than neglect, so the verse can be heard as a warning against attacking prophetic Scripture.
in v21
"Test everything" was about weighing prophecy, not sampling everything
- What's often taught
- The verse is often quoted on its own as a general motto for open-minded exploration: try all ideas, experiences or spiritual practices and keep whatever seems good. It is also sometimes quoted as grounds for treating claimed words from the Spirit with standing suspicion.
- What the text supports
In context the verse sits between "do not despise prophecies" (v. 20) and "abstain from every kind of evil" (v. 22). Its first concern is prophetic words spoken in the gathered church. Paul tells the congregation (plural verbs) neither to dismiss them nor to accept them uncritically, but to test each one. Dokimazō is the language of assaying metal and checking coins.
- It is not an invitation to try things out. Testing means judging something's genuineness, not sampling it by experience, and verse 22 tells them to keep away from every kind of evil, not to taste it.
- It is not a charter for suspicion of the Spirit either. Verses 19–20 forbid quenching the Spirit and despising prophecy, and the testing is meant to lead to keeping what is good.
What the popular use gets right is that discernment is a real Christian duty, and Paul uses the same verb for moral discernment in general (Rom 12:2; Phil 1:10). The verse's own setting is narrower and more specific than a general slogan.
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV and Textus Receptus omit "but", so "Prove all things" reads like a free-standing maxim cut off from verse 20. The KJV's "prove" can also be heard as "try out" or "verify by experience" rather than "test for genuineness".
Every word
-
τὸ
to · G3588
-
πνεῦμα
pneuma · G4151G
spirit, breath, wind · v19
Here this is God's Spirit at work among the believers, especially in what the Spirit does when they gather, such as prophecy (v. 20). Paul puts the word first in the sentence for emphasis: 'The Spirit: don't put it out.'
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v19, v20
The ordinary negative used with commands. With a present-tense command it forbids an ongoing pattern of behaviour, 'don't be doing this', and does not by itself prove the readers were already doing it.
-
σβέννυτε
sbennute · G4570
to extinguish, put out (fire, lamp); suppress · v19
A fire word: to douse a flame or let a lamp go out. Addressed to 'you' plural, the whole congregation, it pictures the Spirit's activity among them as a fire the community itself could smother.
-
προφητείας
prophēteias · G4394
prophecy, prophetic utterance · v20
Plural and without "the": individual prophetic words spoken by members of the congregation when they met. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis, matching "the Spirit" at the head of v. 19. The meaning is "Spirit-prompted messages", not "predictions" or "Bible prophecy".
-
ἐξουθενεῖτε
exoutheneite · G1848
to treat as nothing, disdain, reject with contempt · v20
Built from ex- plus outhen, "nothing": to count something as worthless, brush it off, write it off. It is a plural command to the whole church. It describes dismissive scorn, not hot hatred.
-
πάντα
panta · G3956
all, every; (neuter plural) all things · v21
"All things", placed first for emphasis. Coming right after "do not despise prophecies", it means first of all every prophetic word spoken in the assembly, and by extension anything claimed to come from the Spirit. Nothing is exempt from testing, including the message you like.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and, now · v21
Only in some editions. Where it is read, it sets up a mild contrast with verse 20: do not treat prophecies with contempt, *but* test them, all of them. It shows that the testing is the alternative to contempt, not another way of expressing it.
-
δοκιμάζετε
dokimazete · G1381
to test, examine, assay; to approve after testing · v21
Present imperative, plural: "keep testing", as a standing practice of the whole congregation. The word comes from assaying metal and checking coins. You put something to the test in order to find out whether it is genuine and can be accepted.
-
καλὸν
kalon · G2570
good, fine, beautiful, genuine, sound · v21
Whatever proves sound and genuine under testing, as opposed to the "evil" (ponēros) of verse 22. Kalos covers good in the sense of fine and worthy as well as morally right, and it was used for genuine coin as opposed to counterfeit.
-
κατέχετε
katechete · G2722
to hold fast, retain, keep possession of; also to hold back, restrain · v21
Present imperative, plural: "keep holding on to". Once a word has passed the test, the community is to keep it and not let it slip. It is the opposite of verse 22's "keep away from" (apechesthe) every kind of evil.
The world behind it
A young church, a few months old. Paul writes around AD 50 to a mostly non-Jewish congregation in Thessalonica, gathered in houses only shortly before (Acts 17:1–10). Their experience of the gospel had come with visible signs of the Spirit's power (1:5). Early Christian gatherings included inspired speech: prophecy, revelation, tongues (compare 1 Cor 12–14).
Why someone might want to put the fire out. Former pagans knew ecstatic religion: oracles, Dionysian frenzy, prophets for hire. That could make some believers wary of anything that looked like inspired utterance. Inside the church there may also have been specific trouble. Wild claims about the Day of the Lord circulated, some apparently attributed to a "spirit" or a prophetic word (2 Thess 2:2). Paul also has to deal with "disorderly" members (5:14). A cautious group, or the leaders Paul has just told them to respect (5:12–13), might naturally react by discouraging prophecy altogether. Many commentators think this is the background to verses 19–22, though the letter does not say so explicitly.
The fire picture. In a world lit by oil lamps and centred on hearth and altar fires, "putting out" a fire was a vivid everyday image. Israel's altar fire was never to go out (Lev 6:12–13). John the Baptist promised a baptism "with the Holy Spirit and fire" (Matt 3:11), and at Pentecost the Spirit appeared as tongues of fire (Acts 2:3). Jewish hearers also knew the scene where Joshua wanted to stop two men prophesying in the camp, and Moses replied, "Would that all the LORD's people were prophets" (Num 11:26–29).
From the study of 1 Thessalonians 5:19.
Where scholars differ
in v19
Does 'the Spirit' mean God's Holy Spirit or the believers' own spiritual fervour?
-
God's Spirit, especially as he shows himself in the gathered community (the majority view).
The article and Paul's earlier references to the Holy Spirit given to them (1:5–6; 4:8). The next command, about prophecies, links the Spirit with inspired speech, as in Jewish expectation (Num 11; Joel 2).
-
The human spirit or inner spiritual zeal, as in 'fervent in spirit' (Rom 12:11).
πνεῦμα can mean the human spirit, and fire language is used of zeal. Most modern commentators find this less likely given verse 20 and 4:8. The two are also not far apart, since Paul sees the Spirit's fire working through people.
in v19
Were the Thessalonians already suppressing the Spirit?
-
Yes. Paul is correcting an existing tendency, probably a reaction against prophetic excesses or eschatological claims (compare 2 Thess 2:2).
The tight pairing with 'do not despise prophecies' suggests a real problem. Some read the present imperative as 'stop doing this'.
-
Not necessarily. These are general rules for community life, like the surrounding commands.
Verses 16–22 are a string of short, general instructions. Grammarians note that μή with a present imperative does not by itself mean 'stop what you are already doing'.
in v19
Who was doing the quenching?
-
Cautious members or leaders who distrusted prophecy.
The mention of leaders (5:12–13) and 'disorderly' people (5:14) just before, plus likely embarrassment at ecstatic phenomena familiar from pagan cults.
-
The congregation as a whole. Paul names no group.
The command is addressed to everyone in the plural, and the letter never identifies a faction opposed to prophecy.
in v20
Were the Thessalonians already dismissing prophecy, and if so why?
-
Yes. Prophecy had been discredited by over-excited or false claims, probably about the Day of the Lord.
2 Thess 2:2 warns against being alarmed "by a spirit" saying the Day has come. Verses 19–22 combine two negative commands with a call to testing, which suggests a real problem in both directions (e.g. Fee; Wanamaker).
-
Yes, but the tension was social: between spontaneous speakers and the recognised leaders.
The section opens with commands to respect those who "labour among you and are over you" (5:12–13), and vv. 14–15 deal with the "idle"/disorderly.
-
Not necessarily. These are general instructions for church life, not a response to a specific crisis.
Verses 16–22 are a list of short present-tense commands, several clearly general ("rejoice always", "pray without ceasing"). A present prohibition does not by itself prove the behaviour was already happening.
in v20
What kind of authority did congregational prophecy have?
-
Congregational prophecy was a real but lesser, testable kind of speech, distinct from the authoritative words of Old Testament prophets or apostles.
It is to be "tested" and only "the good" kept (v. 21). Others "weigh" what prophets say (1 Cor 14:29). Prophecy is "partial" (1 Cor 13:9). (Grudem and others.)
-
It was continuous with Old Testament prophecy. Testing was aimed at telling true prophets from false, not at sifting a true prophet's words.
Deut 13 and 18 already require testing prophets. Early texts such as Didache 11 test the prophet's conduct and doctrine.
-
It was largely what later became preaching or teaching.
This was the Reformation-era reading (Calvin). Critics note that Paul distinguishes prophecy from teaching (1 Cor 12:28–29; 14:6) and links it to spontaneous revelation (14:30), which makes this identification hard to sustain from the Greek.
in v21
What does "all things" refer to?
-
Primarily the prophecies of verse 20, together with other Spirit-claims in the assembly.
The "but" (where read) contrasts testing with despising prophecy. Verses 19–22 form a unit about the Spirit. The close parallels are 1 Cor 14:29 ("let the others weigh") and 1 John 4:1 ("test the spirits"). This is the majority view in recent commentaries (e.g. Fee, Wanamaker, Weima).
-
A broader principle of moral discernment, with prophecy as the occasion.
The neuter "all things" is unrestricted. Verse 22's "every form of evil" is general. Paul uses dokimazō for general moral discernment elsewhere (Rom 12:2; Phil 1:10). Many interpreters past and present hold that the principle covers more than prophecy, while still rooted in it.
in v21
Why were some Thessalonians inclined to despise prophecy?
-
Reaction against unsettling end-times prophecies.
The letter is preoccupied with the Lord's coming (4:13–5:11), and 2 Thess 2:2 warns against being shaken "by a spirit" claiming the Day had come.
-
Reaction against disorderly or idle members who used ecstatic speech.
5:14 warns the "disorderly" (ataktoi). Some link them with charismatic excess, though the letter does not make that link explicit.
-
Wariness shaped by pagan ecstatic religion in the city.
Converts had "turned to God from idols" (1:9) and may have associated inspired speech with oracles and mystery cults. This is plausible background but cannot be confirmed from the text.
in v21
Does the verse carry a deliberate coin-testing image?
-
Yes. Dokimazō, kalon (genuine) and possibly eidos ("kind" or "stamp") in verse 22 call up the testing of coins.
This was common Greek usage, and early Christian writers linked the "approved moneychangers" saying with this passage.
-
Only loosely. Dokimazō had long since become a general word for discernment.
Paul's other uses (Rom 12:2; Phil 1:10) carry no coin imagery, and kalos/ponēros is a standard moral pair.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. σβέννυμι
- BDAG s.v. πνεῦμα
- LSJ s.v. σβέννυμι
- Homer, Iliad 9.678
- Septuagint: Lev 6:12–13; 2 Sam 21:17; Song 8:7; Isa 42:3
- Gordon D. Fee, God's Empowering Presence (1994), on 1 Thess 5:19–22
- Gordon D. Fee, The First and Second Letters to the Thessalonians (NICNT, 2009)
- Charles A. Wanamaker, The Epistles to the Thessalonians (NIGTC, 1990)
- Jeffrey A. D. Weima, 1–2 Thessalonians (BECNT, 2014)
- Abraham J. Malherbe, The Letters to the Thessalonians (Anchor Bible, 2000)
- Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (1996), on prohibitions
- Plutarch, On the Obsolescence of Oracles
- BDAG s.v. ἐξουθενέω
- BDAG s.v. προφητεία
- LSJ s.v. προφητεία, ἐξουθενέω
- David E. Aune, Prophecy in Early Christianity and the Ancient Mediterranean World (1983)
- Wayne Grudem, The Gift of Prophecy in the New Testament and Today
- John Calvin, Commentary on 1 Thessalonians 5:20
- Didache 11
- Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics, on prohibitions
- BDAG s.v. δοκιμάζω, καλός, κατέχω, πᾶς
- W. Grundmann, TDNT s.v. δόκιμος, δοκιμάζω
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at 1 Thess 5:21)
- SBL Greek New Testament
- Septuagint: Proverbs 17:3; Psalm 65:10 LXX
- Didache 11–12
- Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 1.28 (agraphon on 'approved moneychangers')
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).