2 Kings Chapter 17 Read as one passage
2 Kings 17:18–23
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18So the LORD was very angry with Israel, and He removed them from His presence. Only the tribe of Judah remained, 19and even Judah did not keep the commandments of the LORD their God, but lived according to the customs Israel had introduced. 20So the LORD rejected all the descendants of Israel. He afflicted them and delivered them into the hands of plunderers, until He had banished them from His presence. 21When the LORD had torn Israel away from the house of David, they made Jeroboam son of Nebat king, and Jeroboam led Israel away from following the LORD and caused them to commit a great sin. 22The Israelites persisted in all the sins that Jeroboam had committed and did not turn away from them. 23Finally, the LORD removed Israel from His presence, as He had declared through all His servants the prophets. So Israel was exiled from their homeland into Assyria, where they are to this day.
What the first hearers heard
The book of Kings in its finished form was most likely shaped for Judahites living through or after their own exile to Babylon (586 BCE). For them this verse worked in two directions:
- An explanation of the past. The northern kingdom fell not because Yahweh was weaker than Assyria's gods but because Yahweh himself acted. He had been provoked through generations of idolatry and refused warnings, exactly as Deuteronomy said he would be. The rare verb 'showed himself angry' pointed back to the golden calf at Horeb: the threat was old and well known.
- A mirror for the present. 'Only Judah was left' sounded reassuring for a moment. But the narrator immediately adds that Judah also walked in Israel's customs (v.19), and later uses the same phrase, 'remove from my presence,' for Judah (2 Kgs 23:27; 24:3). Exiled readers would recognise their own story. Judah had been 'left' only to go the same way.
The verse also kept alive a sense of a single people. 'Israel' in the north and 'Judah' in the south had both belonged to Yahweh's twelve-tribe people, and now only one fragment remained in the land. The verse called on the survivors to treat the north's fate as a warning and to return to covenant faithfulness.
From the study of 2 Kings 17:18.
Verse by verse
-
18So the LORD was very angry with Israel, and He removed them from His presence. Only the tribe of Judah remained,
Full study →So Yahweh, Israel's own covenant God, flared up in fury against Israel. This was not a sudden temper. It was the deliberate, long-provoked anger of a covenant partner, the same anger that blazed at Horeb over the golden calf and against Solomon's idolatry. He made them turn aside, off the land where they had lived before his face. Nothing was left over except the tribe of Judah, standing alone.
The verse is the turning point of the narrator's sermon on the fall of Samaria (722 BCE). Every phrase answers what came before. Israel 'provoked him to anger' (v.17), so he became angry. Israel would not 'turn aside' from Jeroboam's sins (v.22), so God 'turned them aside.' 'From upon his face' does not mean God stopped seeing them. It means they were taken off the land that lay under his gaze and favor, which in history meant deportation by Assyria.
The last words, 'only the tribe of Judah by itself,' repeat word for word the description of the kingdom's split two centuries earlier (1 Kgs 12:20). The story of the two kingdoms ends where it began. 'Was left' is the language of disaster survivors, the 'remnant.' The next verse immediately adds that Judah also failed, so the reader is warned that this remainder is not safe.
-
19and even Judah did not keep the commandments of the LORD their God, but lived according to the customs Israel had introduced.
Full study →And even Judah, the one tribe left standing, did not guard and carry out the commands that Yahweh its own God had given. Instead its people made their way of life out of the religious "statutes" of Israel, the northern kingdom. Those were practices that human beings had invented and set up, not anything God had decreed.
The verse breaks into the account of the north's destruction. Verse 18 has just said that only Judah survived when Yahweh removed Israel "from his presence." Verse 19 adds at once, "yet even Judah…" The survivor is not innocent. It has taken up the same habits that brought ruin on its sister kingdom. "Their God" makes the failure personal: Judah broke faith with its own covenant God. The Hebrew word for "statutes" is the one normally used for God's own fixed decrees, so applying it to Israel's homemade religion is bitter irony. Northern Israel had built a rival "law" of calf shrines, high places and imported cults (17:8, 16), and Judah walked that road too. The next verse, which speaks of "all the descendants of Israel" being rejected, shows where this is heading: the exile that took the north will take Judah as well.
-
20So the LORD rejected all the descendants of Israel. He afflicted them and delivered them into the hands of plunderers, until He had banished them from His presence.
Full study →Israel had spurned its God (verse 15 uses the same word). So the LORD, Israel's own covenant God, spurned and refused the whole line descended from Israel, the very "seed" he had promised to multiply and plant in the land. The rejection was not one sudden blow. It played out over generations as a chain of events.
First he humbled them and brought them low. This is the word once used of Egypt crushing Israel under forced labour, and now God himself does it. Then he handed them over to the power of raiders and plunderers, just as in the days of the Judges. This time no deliverer came. Instead it went on until at last he flung them away from his face: he threw them out of the land where his presence was, the way a king expels someone from his court or a person throws away something worthless.
Coming right after the note that "even Judah" followed Israel's ways (verse 19), "all the seed of Israel" probably reaches past the northern kingdom to the whole people. What happened to Samaria becomes a warning, and in the end a description, of what would happen to Jerusalem.
-
21When the LORD had torn Israel away from the house of David, they made Jeroboam son of Nebat king, and Jeroboam led Israel away from following the LORD and caused them to commit a great sin.
Full study →Because Israel was ripped away from David's royal line, the way a robe is torn off its wearer. God did this in judgment on Solomon, as Ahijah had acted out when he tore his cloak into twelve pieces, though Israel also tore itself away. The northern tribes then crowned Jeroboam son of Nebat as their own king. Jeroboam in turn pushed and lured Israel out of its place following behind Yahweh, its rightful Lord, and so brought on them "a great sin," the same words Moses used for the golden calf at Sinai.
The verse traces a chain of causes. The kingdom was torn, a king of the people's choosing was crowned, the people were pulled away from following Yahweh, and a calf-worship system was built into the nation. The irony sits in one verb. Jeroboam drove Israel away from Yahweh, and the account ends with Yahweh driving Israel away from his presence into exile (vv. 20, 23). The whole fall of the northern kingdom in 722 BCE goes back to this first act.
-
22The Israelites persisted in all the sins that Jeroboam had committed and did not turn away from them.
Full study →The whole family of Israel, the northern tribes who broke away from David's line, kept walking down the road Jeroboam had built. They followed every part of the worship system he set up: the golden calves at Bethel and Dan, the shrines on the hilltops, priests he appointed himself, and a festival calendar of his own. Generation after generation they never once stepped off that road. The Hebrew counts the sins as many ("all the sins") and then calls them a single "it". The many practices together made up one great offence, the "great sin" of the verse before.
The words "turn aside" set up what comes next. Because Israel would not turn aside from Jeroboam's sin, the LORD turned Israel aside, removing them from his presence and sending them into exile in Assyria (v. 23). The verse also takes the refrain that Kings had used against one northern king after another ("he did not turn aside from the sins of Jeroboam") and now applies it to the whole people. In the end it was not only their kings who walked this way. They all did.
-
23Finally, the LORD removed Israel from His presence, as He had declared through all His servants the prophets. So Israel was exiled from their homeland into Assyria, where they are to this day.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v18
removed them out of his sight
hēsîr mēʿal pānāyw
- What we hear
- God stopped looking at them or caring about them; they disappeared from his notice.
- What they heard
- He removed them 'from upon his face': off the land where they lived in his presence and under his covenant favor. In concrete terms, exile from the land.
-
in v18
the tribe of Judah only
šēbeṭ yĕhûdâ lĕbaddô
- What we hear
- Only people descended from Judah, one bloodline, survived; every member of the other tribes was gone.
- What they heard
- The kingdom of Judah, the Davidic state named for its leading tribe, which also included Benjamin, Levites and others. The phrase repeats 1 Kgs 12:20 to close the story of the divided kingdom.
-
in v19
statutes (of Israel)
chuqqot
- What we hear
- Written laws or legislation, as in a statute book.
- What they heard
- Fixed, established practices treated as binding: here the state religion of the northern kingdom (calf shrines, high places, foreign cults), described ironically with the word normally reserved for God's decrees.
-
in v19
Israel
yisra'el
- What we hear
- The whole Jewish people or the nation as a single entity (or the modern state).
- What they heard
- Here specifically the northern kingdom (capital Samaria), as distinct from Judah. The verse sets the two kingdoms side by side.
-
in v20
cast them out of his sight (KJV, WEB, ESV, NASB)
hishlikham mippanav
- What we hear
- God turned away and stopped watching over or noticing them.
- What they heard
- He threw them away from his face, meaning he expelled them from his presence: deportation from the land that was the sphere of his presence and worship, pictured as being banished from a king's court.
-
in v20
spoilers (KJV)
shosim
- What we hear
- Something that ruins things, or indulges someone too much.
- What they heard
- Plunderers and raiders who strip a land of its goods.
-
in v21
sin a great sin / commit a great sin
heḥĕṭîʾām ḥăṭāʾâ gədôlâ
- What we hear
- Jeroboam got the people to do something very wrong, in a general moral sense, a bad sin among many.
- What they heard
- A fixed phrase that recalls the golden calf at Sinai (Exod 32:21, 30–31) and the language of covenant betrayal. It names a specific, state-built act of worship-apostasy, the calves of Bethel and Dan, as the founding offense that led the nation to exile.
-
in v22
the sins of Jeroboam
chattot Yarov'am
- What we hear
- Jeroboam's personal immoral behaviour, or private wrongs in general that the people copied.
- What they heard
- A set phrase for the rival national worship system Jeroboam founded: calf images at Bethel and Dan, high-place shrines, priests who were not Levites, and a festival in the wrong month. It is public and religious, not private moral lapses.
-
in v22
children of Israel (KJV, WEB)
benei Yisra'el
- What we hear
- Young people, or literally the children of the population.
- What they heard
- The whole nation as Israel/Jacob's descendants, adults included. It is a family name for the people.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v18
'None left but Judah' doesn't mean the northern tribes disappeared
- What's often taught
- This verse shows that the ten northern tribes were entirely deported and lost after 722 BCE, so that from then on only Judahites remained of Israel, and the 'ten lost tribes' must be looked for elsewhere.
- What the text supports
The verse speaks of kingdoms, not a census. 'The tribe of Judah alone' repeats 1 Kgs 12:20, where the same phrase describes the Davidic kingdom, and 12:21 immediately counts Benjamin with it. 'Removed from his presence' describes the end of the northern kingdom and the deportation of its leading population.
The Bible itself shows northern Israelites still present afterwards:
- Hezekiah invites people of Ephraim, Manasseh, Asher and Zebulun to Passover, and some come (2 Chr 30:1–11, 18).
- Josiah's temple repairs are funded by 'Manasseh, Ephraim and all the remnant of Israel' (2 Chr 34:9).
- Men from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria come to worship after 586 (Jer 41:5).
- Anna is 'of the tribe of Asher' (Luke 2:36).
Sargon II's own figure (about 27,000 deported from Samaria) is a large but partial number. What the verse does say is serious enough: Israel as a nation was finished, and its people had lost their place before Yahweh in the land.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'None left but the tribe of Judah only' (KJV, ESV) sounds like an absolute headcount, and 'tribe' suggests a single bloodline. In Kings the phrase names a political unit.
Every word
-
וַיִּתְאַנַּף
wayyitʾannap · H0599
be angry · v18
The verb form here means 'showed himself angry' or 'became angry' (the reflexive form of the verb), and the 'and' that opens it marks it as the next event in the story. It answers v.17, where Israel 'provoked him to anger.' The root is connected with ʾap, 'nose', the flared nostril of an angry face.
-
יְהוָה
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh, the LORD · v18, v19, v20, v21
God's personal, covenant name. It stresses that Israel's own God, the one bound to them by covenant, is the one acting. No foreign god and no blind fate is behind this.
-
מְאֹד
meʾōd · H3966
very, greatly · v18
Strengthens the verb: the anger is extreme, enough to end the kingdom.
-
בְּיִשְׂרָאֵל
bĕyiśrāʾēl · H3478
Israel · v18, v19, v20, v21, v22
The preposition bĕ, used with an anger verb, means 'against' or 'with'. Here 'Israel' means the northern kingdom whose capital was Samaria, as opposed to Judah.
-
וַיְסִרֵם
wayĕsirēm · H5493
turn aside; (causative) remove · v18, v22
Literally 'he made them turn aside,' that is, he removed them. Israel had refused to 'turn aside' from Jeroboam's sins (v.22, same verb), so God 'turns them aside' out of his presence. In history this was the Assyrian deportation.
-
מֵעַל
mēʿal · H5921
from upon, from off · v18, v21
A compound preposition (min + ʿal), 'from upon / away from.' It pictures them being taken off the place where they stood before him.
-
פָּנָיו
pānāyw · H6440
face; presence · v18, v20
'His face.' Together with the preceding word the idiom means 'from before him, from his presence.' It refers to the land and worshiping community where Israel lived under Yahweh's turned-toward face.
-
לֹא
lōʾ · H3808
not · v18, v19, v22
Negates the verb that follows: 'there was not left.'
-
נִשְׁאַר
nišʾar · H7604
be left, remain · v18
Passive form, 'was left over / remained.' This is the root behind the prophets' 'remnant' (šĕʾār, šĕʾērît). The survival that remains is Judah's, not Israel's.
-
רַק
raq · H7535
only, except · v18
After the negative it means 'none … except.' It narrows what survives to one entity.
-
שֵׁבֶט
šēbeṭ · H7626
rod, staff; tribe · v18
'Tribe of.' The word also means a rod or staff (a symbol of leadership). Here it names Judah as a political-tribal unit: in practice, the kingdom of Judah.
-
יְהוּדָה
yĕhûdâ · H3063
Judah · v18, v19
The southern kingdom ruled by David's dynasty from Jerusalem, named after its leading tribe.
-
לְבַדּוֹ
lĕbaddô · H0905
alone, by itself · v18
'By itself, alone.' It repeats 'only' for emphasis and echoes 1 Kings 12:20, where at the kingdom's split 'only the tribe of Judah alone' stayed loyal to David's house. The story of the divided kingdom ends where it began.
-
גַּם־
gam · H1571
also, even · v19
Adds Judah to the guilty party just described. Coming right after 'only the tribe of Judah remained' (v.18), it works like 'yet even Judah…': the survivor is no cleaner than the one destroyed.
-
שָׁמַ֔ר
shamar · H8104
keep, guard, observe · v19
Singular, completed action: Judah did not keep. Shamar is the verb for guarding something valuable. Not 'keeping' Yahweh's commands means failing to watch over them and carry them out.
-
אֶת־
et · H0853
[direct object marker] · v19, v21
Untranslatable grammatical marker that points to the definite direct object, 'the commandments'.
-
מִצְוֹ֖ת
mitzvot · H4687
commandments · v19
'Commandments of', linked directly to Yahweh. These are the instructions Israel's God gave, set against the 'statutes' Israel made for itself later in the verse.
-
אֱלֹהֵיהֶ֑ם
eloheihem · H0430
God (their God) · v19
'Their God' stresses the relationship. Judah ignored the commands of its own covenant God, not those of some distant deity. The plural 'their' already anticipates the plural verb that follows.
-
וַיֵּ֣לְכ֔וּ
vayyelkhu · H1980
and they walked · v19, v22
A narrative past tense with 'and': 'and they walked'. In Hebrew idiom 'walking in' something means living by it as a settled way of life. It describes conduct, not a single act.
-
בְּחֻקּ֥וֹת
bechuqqot · H2708
in the statutes / customs of · v19
'In the statutes of'. The word normally means God's fixed decrees, so it is used with bitter irony here: Israel's 'statutes' are man-made religious practices that stand in for God's.
-
אֲשֶׁ֥ר
asher · H0834
which, that · v19, v20, v22
Relative word that attaches the closing clause to 'statutes'. It leaves open who the 'they' is who made them.
-
עָשֽׂוּ׃
asu · H6213
they made, did · v19, v22
'They made' or 'they practised'. The point is that these statutes were made by people, not given by God. The plural subject is most naturally Israel, matching v.8, though it could also be Judah.
-
וַיִּמְאַס
wayyimʾas · H3988A
to reject, refuse, spurn · v20
'And he rejected.' The verb answers verse 15, where Israel 'rejected his statutes and his covenant' with the same word. Israel refused God, and God now refuses Israel. The verb form moves the story along to its result: 'and so he rejected.'
-
בְּכָל־
bekhol- · H3605
all, the whole · v20, v22
'All.' Hebrew marks the object of this verb with the preposition be-, a normal idiom with no special force. The weight is on 'all': the rejection covers the whole line, not just a guilty faction.
-
זֶרַע
zeraʿ · H2233H
seed, offspring, descendants · v20
'Seed of.' This is the word of the promise to Abraham and Jacob ('your seed'). The people the promise was meant to multiply are now the people rejected.
-
וַיְעַנֵּם
wayʿannem · H6031B
to afflict, humble, oppress · v20
'And he humbled/afflicted them.' This intensive form of the verb means to bring someone low by force. It is the verb used of Egypt oppressing Israel (Exod 1:11–12), so the hearer hears a bitter reversal.
-
וַיִּתְּנֵם
wayyittenem · H5414G
to give, hand over · v20
'And he gave them.' It opens the stock war phrase 'give into the hand of', meaning to hand someone over to an enemy's power.
-
בְּיַד־
beyad- · H3027H
hand; power, control · v20
'Into the hand of,' meaning under the power of. In Hebrew, 'hand' is the usual picture of control.
-
שֹׁסִים
shosim · H8154
to plunder, despoil · v20
'Plunderers,' a participle: people who make a practice of plundering. It is the exact word of Judges 2:14, so it calls up the old cycle of raiders. For the northern kingdom that meant Aramean raids and Assyrian campaigns.
-
עַד
ʿad · H5704
until, up to · v20
'Until.' It marks the end point. The afflictions were a process that went on for generations and ended in exile.
-
הִשְׁלִיכָם
hishlikham · H7993
to throw, cast, fling away · v20
'He threw them.' This causative form is used for throwing something down or throwing it away, like a corpse, an idol or rubbish. It describes the deportation as a violent expulsion.
-
כִּֽי־
kî · H3588A
for, because, when · v21
Begins the explanation. It connects v. 20 ('the LORD rejected all the descendants of Israel') to where the trouble started, the split of the kingdom. 'For' (KJV) and 'When' (BSB) both work here. The supplied contextual gloss 'if' does not fit.
-
קָרַ֣ע
qāraʿ · H7167
to tear, rip · v21
A violent, physical verb, used for ripping cloth. It recalls the prophet Ahijah tearing his new cloak into twelve pieces as a sign that God would tear the kingdom from Solomon's line (1 Kgs 11:29–31). Who does the tearing is not stated: most likely Yahweh, though possibly Israel tearing itself away.
-
בֵּ֣ית
bêt · H1004M
house (of) · v21
'House' here means the royal family line, David's dynasty, not a building. It recalls God's promise to build David a lasting 'house' (2 Sam 7:11–16).
-
דָּוִ֔ד
dāwid · H1732
David · v21
The founder of the Jerusalem dynasty. By this point David's line ruled only Judah.
-
וַיַּמְלִ֖יכוּ
wayyamlîkû · H4427A
and they made king · v21
A causative form, 'they caused to reign'. The plural subject is the northern tribes in assembly. It repeats the wording of 1 Kgs 12:20, where 'all Israel' made Jeroboam king at Shechem. The people did the choosing, even though God had already promised Jeroboam the throne (1 Kgs 11:31–38).
-
יָרָבְעָ֣ם
yārobʿām · H3379G
Jeroboam · v21, v22
Jeroboam I, the first king of the northern kingdom (c. 930 BCE). He was an Ephraimite official who had run Solomon's forced labor in the north (1 Kgs 11:26–28).
-
בֶּן־
ben · H1121A
son (of) · v21, v22
This is the standard way of naming a man by his father. 'Jeroboam son of Nebat' had become a fixed label in Kings, almost always used along with his sin.
-
נְבָ֑ט
nəbāṭ · H5028
Nebat · v21
Jeroboam's father, an Ephraimite from Zeredah (1 Kgs 11:26). The full name tells readers which Jeroboam is meant, as distinct from the later Jeroboam II.
-
וַיַּדַּ֨ח
wayyaddaḥ · H5080
and he drove away / lured away · v21
The verb means to push or drive someone off course. It is the same verb Deuteronomy 13 uses for someone who lures Israel 'away from Yahweh' into other worship. It is also the verb for God driving Israel into exile, so it carries the irony that Jeroboam drove Israel away from God and God in the end drove Israel out of the land.
-
מֵאַחֲרֵ֣י
mēʾaḥărê · H0310A
from after, from behind · v21
'From behind Yahweh': going 'after' someone is Hebrew for following them as your lord and giving them your loyalty. Israel was pulled out of its place behind Yahweh, and elsewhere Kings describes it 'going after' other gods instead.
-
וְהֶחֱטֵיאָ֖ם
wəheḥĕṭîʾām · H2398
and he caused them to sin · v21
A causative form: Jeroboam made the people sin. Kings repeats this about twenty times: 'Jeroboam son of Nebat, who made Israel sin.' The blame falls on the leader who built the system, but the people who went along with it are not excused (v. 22).
-
חֲטָאָ֥ה
ḥăṭāʾâ · H2401
sin, offense · v21
A noun from the same root as the verb, so the phrase reads literally 'made them sin a sin'. The rare form ḥăṭāʾâ shows up mostly in the fixed expression 'a great sin'.
-
גְדוֹלָֽה׃
gədôlâ · H1419A
great, large · v21
'A great sin' is the phrase Moses uses three times for the golden calf (Exod 32:21, 30, 31). Since Jeroboam set up golden calves, the phrase names his sin as Israel's first apostasy repeated.
-
חַטֹּ֥אות
chattot · H2403
sins, offences · v22
These are specific offences against Israel's covenant with YHWH, and in Kings they always point to Jeroboam's rival worship system (1 Kings 12:26–33). The plural covers its parts: the calf images, the shrines, the priests and the festival.
-
מִמֶּֽנָּה׃
mimmennah · H4480
from it · v22
"From it" is feminine singular. It treats Jeroboam's "sins" as one thing, probably the single "great sin" of v. 21. English versions write "from them".
The world behind it
The event. Hoshea, the last king of the northern kingdom, stopped paying tribute to Assyria and looked to Egypt for help (2 Kgs 17:4). Shalmaneser V besieged Samaria for three years. The city fell in 722/721 BCE. Sargon II, who claims the conquest in his inscriptions, deported part of the population, giving the figure 27,290 (27,280 in another copy). He resettled them in Assyria and Media (17:6) and brought foreign peoples into the land (17:24). Mass two-way deportation was standard Assyrian policy for breaking rebellious states.
The sermon. Verses 7–23 are not a battle report. They are the narrator's theological explanation of why it happened, written in the vocabulary of Deuteronomy: other gods, high places, ignoring prophets' warnings, child sacrifice, divination. Verse 18 states the verdict.
How 'divine anger' landed. In the ancient Near East it was common to explain a national catastrophe by saying the land's god was angry and had abandoned it. The Mesha Stele of Moab uses the same Semitic root: 'Chemosh was angry with his land,' so Israel's king Omri oppressed Moab. An Israelite hearer would recognise the formula. The shock was that Israel's God was not defeated by Assyria's gods. He had used Assyria against his own people.
The 'face' and the land. To live 'before Yahweh' meant living in his land, near his sanctuary, within his covenant blessing (Deut 28). Exile was the covenant curse Deuteronomy had threatened (Deut 28:63–64; 29:28): being uprooted from the land meant being put away from his presence.
'Only Judah.' In Kings, 'the tribe of Judah' is shorthand for the Davidic kingdom based in Jerusalem, which included Benjamin and others (1 Kgs 12:21). Archaeological surveys suggest Jerusalem grew sharply in the late 8th century, possibly partly through northern refugees, though the scale is debated.
From the study of 2 Kings 17:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
Are vv.19–20 (Judah's guilt) part of the original sermon, or a later insertion from the time of Judah's exile?
-
Later insertion
They interrupt the logical flow from v.18 ('only Judah remained') to v.21 ('when he tore Israel from the house of David'). They also assume Judah's rejection (v.20, 'all the descendants of Israel'), which fits a time after 586 BCE. This view is held by many critical commentators (e.g., Cogan & Tadmor; Nelson).
-
Integral to the composition
Others argue that a single exilic author wrote the whole sermon to address Judahite readers, and that the sudden turn to Judah is a deliberate rhetorical move, matched by 2 Kgs 23:27.
in v18
Does 'the tribe of Judah alone' mean literally one tribe, or the kingdom of Judah?
-
Political shorthand for the Davidic kingdom
1 Kgs 12:20 uses the same phrase, and the next verse (12:21) includes Benjamin. 1 Kgs 11:13, 32, 36 speak of 'one tribe' for David while the kingdom plainly included Jerusalem (in Benjaminite territory). Chronicles places Levites and northerners in Judah (2 Chr 11:13–16).
-
Deliberate numerical symbolism
Some read it against Ahijah's twelve cloak pieces (1 Kgs 11:30–32), where the counting is symbolic ('one tribe' with Benjamin either absorbed into Judah or treated as Jerusalem's own territory). This view and the first are compatible, and both agree it is not a population census.
in v19
Is verse 19 (with v.20) part of the original sermon or a later addition written after Judah's fall?
-
It is a later, exilic insertion. An editor writing after 586 BCE added it to extend the north's judgment to Judah.
It breaks the logical link between v.18 and v.21, which goes back to Jeroboam and the division. Verse 20's 'all the seed of Israel' reads naturally as including Judah's exile. It fits the 'double edition' theory of Kings (F. M. Cross and others): a first edition under Josiah, updated in exile. Commentators such as Gray and Cogan & Tadmor treat these verses as secondary.
-
It belongs to a single exilic composition of the whole sermon, or is an integral aside by the same author.
Martin Noth's model has one exilic historian writing the whole work. Kings already says that Judean kings 'walked in the way of the kings of Israel' (8:18; 16:3), so the comment is consistent with the book's outlook and need not come from a different hand.
in v19
Who are the 'they' who 'made' the statutes?
-
Israel, meaning the northern kingdom or its kings, made the statutes and Judah adopted them.
This is the closest parallel: 17:8 has 'the kings of Israel, which they made' (אֲשֶׁר עָשׂוּ). Most modern versions (BSB, ESV, NIV, NASB: 'Israel had introduced') read it this way.
-
Judah is the subject: the statutes of Israel 'which they [Judah] practised'.
The nearest plural subject is the 'they' of 'they walked', which refers to Judah. עָשָׂה can mean 'practise, do' as well as 'make'. The Hebrew allows it, but the parallel in v.8 makes it the less likely reading.
in v20
Does 'all the seed of Israel' mean the northern kingdom only, or the whole people including Judah?
-
Whole people, north and south
The verse comes right after v. 19 ('even Judah…'). 'All' is emphatic. Elsewhere 'seed of Israel' means the whole nation (Jer 31:36–37). 'Until he cast them out from his presence' is repeated of Judah in 2 Kgs 24:20.
-
Northern kingdom only
The chapter as a whole is about Samaria. v. 18 says 'none was left but the tribe of Judah', and v. 21 goes straight back to Jeroboam and the north. On this view v. 19 is a parenthesis and v. 20 continues the northern story.
in v20
Are verses 19–20 part of the original account or a later addition?
-
Later addition from the exile
vv. 18 and 21 join smoothly without them. Their interest in Judah fits a time after 586 BCE (proposed by Cogan & Tadmor, Nelson and others).
-
Part of a single theological sermon
Some scholars read ch. 17 as one composed piece that deliberately turns to Judah to address its readers. Moving from north to south is part of its rhetoric, not proof of a later hand.
in v21
Who is the subject of 'tore' in the first clause?
-
Yahweh tore Israel from the house of David (most English versions; many commentators).
The 'tear … from upon' formula always has God as subject (1 Sam 15:28; 1 Kgs 11:11, 31; 14:8). In v. 20 Yahweh is the acting subject. Kings presents the split as God's judgment on Solomon.
-
Israel tore itself away from the house of David.
There is no object marker before 'Israel', unlike 'ʾet-yiśrāʾēl' later in the same verse. The next verb, 'they made king', has the people as subject. 1 Kgs 12:19 describes the split as Israel's rebellion against David's house.
-
The original text was passive: 'Israel was torn away'.
The Vulgate (and reportedly the Greek) render it as passive, which may reflect a Hebrew niphal form. Some critical commentators suggest emending the text this way.
in v21
What were Jeroboam's calves meant to be?
-
Pedestals or mounts for the invisible Yahweh, comparable to the cherubim in Jerusalem, and not intended as rival gods.
In ancient Near Eastern art, gods are often shown standing on bulls. Jeroboam's proclamation names the God of the exodus (1 Kgs 12:28). Northern prophets such as Elijah attacked Baal worship but not the calves directly.
-
As Kings presents them, idolatry equal to the golden calf.
The deliberate echoes of Exodus 32 ('your gods … who brought you up', 'a great sin'). Hosea 8:5–6 and 13:2 condemn the calf of Samaria. Deuteronomy's law requires worship at one chosen place.
in v22
Were Jeroboam's golden calves meant as idols of other gods, or as pedestals for the invisible YHWH?
-
Pedestals or mounts for YHWH, like the cherubim in Jerusalem, so the offence was illegitimate worship of YHWH, not worship of a different god.
Ancient Near Eastern art often shows a storm god standing on a bull. Jeroboam ties the calves to the God of the exodus (1 Kings 12:28). Jehu, a zealous worshipper of YHWH who destroyed Baal worship, still kept the calves (2 Kings 10:28–29), which suggests they were seen as Yahwistic.
-
Effectively idols, worship of 'other gods', as the biblical writers present them.
1 Kings 12:28 and 14:9 speak of 'gods' and 'molten images'. The echo of Exod 32:4 frames the calves as the Sinai apostasy repeated. Hosea mocks the calf of Samaria as a man-made god (Hos 8:5–6; 13:2). 2 Kings 17:16 lists the calves alongside Asherah and Baal.
in v22
Do vv. 21–23 come from the same writer as the rest of 2 Kings 17:7–23?
-
A separate layer. vv. 21–23 are an earlier, Jeroboam-focused explanation, and vv. 7–20 a later and broader list of sins (partly written in exile, with Judah included).
vv. 21–23 blame only Jeroboam's sin and pick up the refrain from Kings. vv. 7–17 list many other practices, and v. 19 abruptly brings in Judah. Many scholars of the books from Deuteronomy to Kings see several editions.
-
One deliberately built sermon that moves from general to particular.
The vocabulary is consistent across the passage (sur in vv. 18 and 23; "removed from his presence"). Ending on Jeroboam brings the reflection back to the root cause Kings has stressed all along.
Sources
- BDB s.v. אָנַף; סוּר; פָּנִים; שֵׁבֶט; שָׁאַר
- HALOT s.v. אנף (hitp.); שֵׁבֶט
- Mesha Stele (KAI 181), lines 4–5
- Sargon II, Display Inscription (Khorsabad) and Nimrud Prism on the deportation from Samaria
- M. Cogan & H. Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible)
- R. D. Nelson, First and Second Kings (Interpretation)
- M. A. Sweeney, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 4 Kingdoms 17:18
- Vulgate, 4 Regum 17:18
- BDB s.v. שָׁמַר, מִצְוָה, חֻקָּה, הָלַךְ, עָשָׂה
- HALOT s.v. חֻקָּה
- Mordechai Cogan & Hayim Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible)
- John Gray, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- James A. Montgomery, The Books of Kings (ICC)
- F. M. Cross, Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic (double redaction of Kings)
- Martin Noth, The Deuteronomistic History
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), 4 Reigns 17:19
- Vulgate, 4 Regum 17:19
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, 2 Kings 17
- BDB s.v. מָאַס, עָנָה, שָׁסָה/שָׁסַס, שָׁלַךְ, פָּנִים
- HALOT s.v. מאס I, ענה II, שׁסה, שׁלך
- Cogan, M. & Tadmor, H., II Kings (Anchor Bible 11)
- Nelson, R. D., First and Second Kings (Interpretation)
- Sweeney, M. A., I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- Walton, Matthews & Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Kings 17
- Sargon II, Khorsabad Annals and Nimrud Prism (deportation from Samaria)
- Brenton, The Septuagint with Apocrypha: English (4 Kingdoms 17:20)
- BDB s.v. קָרַע, נָדַח, אַחַר, חָטָא
- HALOT s.v. נדח, חֲטָאָה, קרע
- Mordechai Cogan and Hayim Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible)
- Marvin A. Sweeney, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- James A. Montgomery and Henry S. Gehman, The Books of Kings (ICC)
- Richard D. Nelson, First and Second Kings (Interpretation)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus and Masoretic notes at 2 Kgs 17:21
- Vulgate, 4 Regum 17:21
- Tel Dan inscription (bytdwd)
- BDB s.v. הָלַךְ, חַטָּאת, סוּר
- HALOT s.v. חַטָּאת; סוּר
- Cogan & Tadmor, II Kings (Anchor Bible), on 17:7–23
- Sweeney, I & II Kings (Old Testament Library)
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (agreement by sense)
- Septuagint, 4 Kingdoms 17:22
- 1 Kings 12:26–33; Exodus 32; Hosea 8:5–6
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.