2 Samuel Chapter 3 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 3:21–27

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

21Then Abner said to David, “Let me go at once, and I will gather all Israel to my lord the king, that they may make a covenant with you, and that you may rule over all that your heart desires.” So David dismissed Abner, and he went in peace. 22Just then David’s soldiers and Joab returned from a raid, bringing with them a great plunder. But Abner was not with David in Hebron, because David had sent him on his way in peace. 23When Joab and all his troops arrived, he was informed, “Abner son of Ner came to see the king, who sent him on his way in peace.” 24So Joab went to the king and said, “What have you done? Look, Abner came to you. Why did you dismiss him? Now he is getting away! 25Surely you realize that Abner son of Ner came to deceive you and to track your movements and all that you are doing.” 26As soon as Joab had left David, he sent messengers after Abner, who brought him back from the well of Sirah. But David was unaware of it. 27When Abner returned to Hebron, Joab pulled him aside into the gateway, as if to speak to him privately, and there Joab stabbed him in the stomach. So Abner died on account of the blood of Joab’s brother Asahel.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelite hearers, this verse marked the turning point of the struggle between the house of Saul and the house of David. The most powerful man in Saul's camp names David "my lord the king" and offers to bring the whole people to him by covenant. That covenant was not a seizure of power but a sworn agreement in which the tribes freely bind themselves to the king. It presented David's kingship over all Israel as legitimate, negotiated, and in line with what YHWH had promised (3:9–10, 18).

The verse also has a defensive purpose. Scholars widely recognise that this part of Samuel argues for David's innocence in the violent deaths that cleared his path to the throne: Saul, Abner, Ish-bosheth. Saying three times that David sent Abner away "in peace" sets the record straight in advance. When Abner dies at Joab's hand, hearers are to conclude that David neither ordered nor wanted it. Under the customs of hospitality, David had in fact guaranteed his safety. Abner's candid line about David's "desire" also reminded hearers that ambition and political bargaining ran through the founding of the dynasty.

From the study of 2 Samuel 3:21.

Verse by verse

  1. 21Then Abner said to David, “Let me go at once, and I will gather all Israel to my lord the king, that they may make a covenant with you, and that you may rule over all that your heart desires.” So David dismissed Abner, and he went in peace.

    After the feast at Hebron, Saul's old general Abner, now openly changing sides, says to David: "Let me be off right away. Let me go and call together the whole of Israel to my lord the king, so that they can bind themselves to you in a solemn, sworn compact, and you will be king over everything you have set your heart on."

    Every phrase is loaded. Abner, who for years had propped up Saul's son against David, now calls David "my lord the king", the language of a servant. He offers to do what only he can: convene the northern tribes. The aim is a covenant (literally "to cut a covenant"), a binding political agreement made under oath and before God (fulfilled in 5:3). It ties the tribes to David and David to them. His closing promise appeals frankly to David's ambition. "All that your nefesh desires" means "all you crave": nefesh is the hungry, wanting self, not an immortal "soul." The same royal formula is later spoken to Jeroboam (1 Kgs 11:37).

    David sent Abner off, a formal, courteous leave-taking that put him under David's protection, and he went in peace: unharmed, on good terms, under safe conduct. The narrator will say "in peace" twice more in the next two verses. The reader is meant to remember it when Joab cuts Abner down a few lines later: whatever happened to Abner, he left David's presence safe and with David's goodwill.

    Full study →
  2. 22Just then David’s soldiers and Joab returned from a raid, bringing with them a great plunder. But Abner was not with David in Hebron, because David had sent him on his way in peace.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 23When Joab and all his troops arrived, he was informed, “Abner son of Ner came to see the king, who sent him on his way in peace.”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 24So Joab went to the king and said, “What have you done? Look, Abner came to you. Why did you dismiss him? Now he is getting away!

    Joab, fresh from a raid, marches straight in to the king and, with no courtesy or royal title, puts him on trial: "What have you done?" These are the words Israel's stories use when someone is called to answer for a wrong, the words God spoke to Eve and to Cain and Samuel spoke to Saul. "Look, Abner came to you, right into your hands! Why on earth did you send him off? And now he's gone, clean gone!"

    The last words carry the sting. Three times the narrator has said that David "sent Abner away, and he went in peace" (vv. 21–23): an honourable farewell after a feast and a pact. Joab uses the same verbs but drops "in peace" and puts an angry doubling of the verb in its place: "he went, gone." What David meant as a peace-making send-off, Joab describes as an enemy let loose. Behind his outrage is blood. Abner had killed Joab's brother Asahel (2:23), and Joab will shortly call Abner back and kill him (vv. 26–27, 30).

    Full study →
  5. 25Surely you realize that Abner son of Ner came to deceive you and to track your movements and all that you are doing.”

    Joab has just stormed in on the king ("What have you done?", v. 24), and now he presses the point:

    "You know Abner son of Ner, don't you? You know exactly what kind of man he is. He came here to sweet-talk you, to take you in, so that he could find out all your movements, every campaign you march out on and every return, and find out everything you are planning and doing."

    The verb Joab uses for "deceive" (pittah) is the word for enticing or seducing someone: winning them over with talk so that they lower their guard. It is what the Philistines asked Delilah to do to Samson to learn his secret. "Your going out and your coming in" is a stock Hebrew pair meaning all your activity, especially a commander's military operations. So the charge is spying. Abner was Saul's general, and Joab claims his peace overtures were cover for scouting David's position.

    The verse hammers on the word know three times: "you know… to know… to know." The next verse answers with "But David did not know" (v. 26). Joab claims to see through Abner and scolds the king for being naive. Yet it is Joab who is about to lure Abner back with a pretext and kill him in the city gate. The narrator stresses that David knew nothing about it.

    Full study →
  6. 26As soon as Joab had left David, he sent messengers after Abner, who brought him back from the well of Sirah. But David was unaware of it.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  7. 27When Abner returned to Hebron, Joab pulled him aside into the gateway, as if to speak to him privately, and there Joab stabbed him in the stomach. So Abner died on account of the blood of Joab’s brother Asahel.

    Abner came back to Hebron, recalled by messengers he believed were David's. There Joab steered him off the road, away from his men, into the inner part of the city gate, as though he wanted a quiet, private word with him. In that spot, the town's own place of public justice, Joab struck him in the belly. It was the very place where Abner had once driven his spear-butt into Joab's young brother Asahel. Abner died on the spot. The narrator gives the reason in Joab's own terms: it was payment for the blood of Asahel his brother. Asahel's shed life was treated as a debt still owed, and Joab, as next of kin, collected it with Abner's life.

    The surrounding story makes the irony plain. Abner had just been sent away 'in peace' after agreeing to bring all Israel over to David. Joab used that same mood of safety and friendly privacy as cover. Asahel had fallen in battle after being warned twice, so the 'blood' Joab claimed to avenge was a debatable claim. The next verse moves the guilt to its new owner: David declares that he and his kingdom are innocent of Abner's blood.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v21

    soul (WEB, YLT: "all that your soul desires")

    nefesh

    What we hear
    The immaterial, spiritual, immortal part of a person.
    What they heard
    The living self as the seat of appetite and desire: "everything you crave / set your heart on."
  • in v21

    covenant

    berit

    What we hear
    A religious bond with God, or a marriage vow. In legal English, a clause in a property deed.
    What they heard
    A solemn, sworn political compact between the tribes and their king, with obligations on both sides, sealed before YHWH (5:3).
  • in v21

    went in peace

    halakh beshalom

    What we hear
    Left feeling calm or serene.
    What they heard
    Left safely, unharmed, under the host's protection and on good terms: a safe-conduct formula.
  • in v24

    quite gone (KJV)

    vayyelekh halokh

    What we hear
    'Quite' is often heard as 'fairly' or 'somewhat', so the line can sound mild: he's rather gone.
    What they heard
    An emphatic doubling of the verb: he has gone, completely and for good. 'Clean gone, got clean away.'
  • in v24

    sent him away / dismiss

    shillach

    What we hear
    Turned him away, brushed him off, or carelessly let him go.
    What they heard
    In vv. 21–23 the same verb describes a formal, honourable send-off of a guest under safe conduct ('and he went in peace'). Joab twists it into 'you released him', but the word itself carries the courtesy of hospitality.
  • in v25

    thy going out and thy coming in (KJV/WEB)

    motsaʾakha ve-movaʾekha

    What we hear
    Your daily comings and goings around the house or town; perhaps your personal schedule.
    What they heard
    A fixed pair meaning all your activity, used especially of a leader leading troops out to battle and back. Joab means 'your military operations and plans'.
  • in v27

    under the fifth [rib] (KJV); in the fifth [rib] (YLT)

    ḥōmesh

    What we hear
    A precise anatomical spot, a thrust between particular ribs, sometimes taken as a detail of expert killing.
    What they heard
    'The belly, abdomen'. It is the same word used for where Abner struck Asahel (2:23), so the point is the matching wound, not anatomical precision.
  • in v27

    for the blood of Asahel

    bedam

    What we hear
    Literal blood, or a vague emotional 'because of'.
    What they heard
    In payment for a life that was taken. Shed blood was a standing claim of guilt that the next of kin was entitled to settle.
  • in v27

    quietly

    bashshelî

    What we hear
    Speaking softly, in a low voice.
    What they heard
    Privately and discreetly, in an unguarded, peaceful setting: a confidential talk away from others.
Every word
  1. וַיֹּ֣אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v21, v24

    The ordinary narrative verb that moves the story forward; it introduces Abner's speech at the close of the Hebron feast (v. 20).

  2. אַבְנֵ֣ר

    avner · H0074

    Abner · v21, v24, v25, v27

    Saul's cousin and former army commander, the real power behind Saul's son Ish-bosheth, now switching sides. The name likely means "(my) father is a lamp/light"; the fuller spelling Abiner appears in 1 Samuel 14:50.

  3. אֶל־

    el- · H0413

    to · v21, v24, v27

    Marks David as the one addressed.

  4. דָּוִ֡ד

    david · H1732

    David · v21

    At this point king only over Judah, ruling from Hebron (2 Sam 2:4, 11).

  5. אָק֣וּמָה׀

    aqumah · H6965B

    let me arise · v21

    A first-person form expressing resolve or polite request ("let me…"). "Rise" here means "get going, set about it" rather than literally standing up; BSB catches this with "Let me go at once."

  6. וְֽאֵלֵ֡כָה

    ve'elekhah · H1980G

    and let me go · v21, v24

    Same resolve form; paired with "rise" it makes a common Hebrew expression of immediate action: "let me be off."

  7. וְאֶקְבְּצָה֩

    ve'eqbetsah · H6908

    and let me gather · v21

    To assemble people, especially for a formal national gathering. Abner offers to convene the northern tribes, something only a man with his standing could do.

  8. אֲדֹנִ֨י

    adoni · H0113

    my lord · v21

    A respectful address from an inferior to a superior. Coming from Saul's general it signals a change of loyalty: Abner now speaks as David's servant.

  9. הַמֶּ֜לֶךְ

    hammelekh · H4428G

    the king · v21, v24

    "My lord the king" is the formal language of the court. Abner already treats David as king, before Israel has formally agreed.

  10. אֶת־

    et- · H0853

    [object marker] · v21, v25

    Marks "all Israel" as what is gathered; it has no English equivalent.

  11. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v21, v25

    Stresses completeness: the tribes as a whole, not one faction.

  12. יִשְׂרָאֵ֗ל

    yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v21

    Here mainly the northern and central tribes, including Benjamin, that had followed Saul's house, as distinct from Judah, which already had David (cf. 2:9–10; 3:17–19).

  13. וְיִכְרְת֤וּ

    veyikhretu · H3772H

    and they will cut / make (a covenant) · v21

    Literally "cut." "Cut a covenant" is the standard Hebrew phrase for concluding a binding agreement. Following the "let me" verbs it expresses purpose: "so that they may conclude…"

  14. אִתְּךָ֙

    ittekha · H0854

    with you · v21, v27

    The agreement is between the tribes and David personally, two parties bound to each other.

  15. בְּרִ֔ית

    berit · H1285

    covenant · v21

    A solemn, sworn political compact by which the tribes accept David as king and he takes on obligations toward them. It is fulfilled in 5:3.

  16. וּמָ֣לַכְתָּ֔

    umalakhta · H4427A

    and you will reign · v21

    The verb form looks forward to the result: once the covenant is made, David will be king over the whole people.

  17. אֲשֶׁר־

    asher- · H0834A

    which / that · v21, v25

    Introduces the clause that defines the extent of David's rule.

  18. תְּאַוֶּ֖ה

    te'avveh · H0183

    it craves / desires · v21

    A strong verb of longing or craving, often used of appetite. Abner names David's ambition openly and promises to satisfy it.

  19. נַפְשֶׁ֑ךָ

    nafshekha · H5315G

    your soul / self / appetite · v21

    Not an immaterial soul. Nefesh is the living self as the seat of appetite and desire: "all that you crave."

  20. וַיְּשַׁלַּ֥ח

    vayshallach · H7971G

    and he sent away · v21, v24

    In this stem the verb means to dismiss or send someone off. Here it is a courteous, sanctioned departure: David formally lets his guest go.

  21. בְּשָׁלֽוֹם׃

    beshalom · H7965G

    in peace · v21

    Safe, unharmed, and on good terms with David. The narrator repeats the phrase in vv. 22 and 23 to establish that Abner left David's presence with no hostility from David.

  22. וַיָּבֹ֤א

    vayyavo · H0935

    and he came · v24, v25

    Joab has just come back from a raid (v. 22). This verb begins the next step of the story: he goes straight to the king. The same verb 'come' runs through the whole scene (Abner 'came', v. 23; 'came', v. 24; 'came to deceive', v. 25).

  23. יוֹאָב֙

    yoav · H3097

    Joab · v24, v27

    David's nephew (son of his sister Zeruiah) and the commander of his army. Abner had killed Joab's brother Asahel in battle (2:18–23), and that killing lies behind everything Joab says here.

  24. מֶ֣ה

    meh · H4100

    what? · v24

    Opens the classic Hebrew question of accusation, 'What have you done?' It is not a request for information but a charge that a wrong has been done.

  25. עָשִׂ֑יתָה

    asitah · H6213

    you have done · v24, v25

    A completed action ('you have done'), written in a longer, fuller spelling. With 'what?' it repeats the formula used by God to Eve (Gen 3:13) and Cain (Gen 4:10), by Pharaoh and Abimelech to Abraham (Gen 12:18; 20:9), and by Samuel to Saul (1 Sam 13:11). Joab speaks to the king the way a prophet or an injured party would.

  26. הִנֵּה־

    hinneh- · H2009

    look! behold! · v24

    A word that grabs attention, as if Joab were pointing: 'Look, think about this.' It makes the next fact sound obvious and damning.

  27. זֶּ֥ה

    zeh · H2088

    this · v24

    Added to 'why' for emphasis: 'why ever?', 'why on earth?'. YLT keeps it as 'why [is] this'. It adds exasperation.

  28. יָדַ֙עְתָּ֙

    yadaʿta · H3045

    to know · v25

    'You know', a completed-action form meaning 'you know full well'. Said to the king, it is pointed and sarcastic, or a question ('Don't you know?'), as the Greek and Latin translations took it. It is the first of three uses of 'know' in the verse.

  29. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121A

    son · v25

    'Son of'. Here it is the formal family name.

  30. נֵ֔ר

    Ner · H5369G

    Ner · v25

    Abner's father, of Saul's clan. Using the full name 'Abner son of Ner' stresses whose family he belongs to: he is Saul's man, the old enemy.

  31. כִּ֥י

    ki · H3588A

    that, for · v25

    'That'. It introduces what the king should know about Abner.

  32. לְפַתֹּתְךָ֖

    lefattotekha · H6601B

    to entice, deceive · v25

    'To entice/deceive you'. The verb means winning someone over by smooth talk and taking advantage of their openness. Joab says Abner's friendly visit was a trick to win David's trust. The word comes first in its clause for emphasis: 'to DECEIVE you he came!'

  33. מוֹצָֽאֲךָ֙

    motsaʾakha · H4161

    going out, exit · v25

    'Your going out'. The first half of a stock pair. 'Going out' often means marching out on campaign (1 Sam 18:13, 16).

  34. מ֣וֹבָאֶ֔ךָ

    movaʾekha · H4126

    coming in, entrance · v25

    'Your coming in'. The second half of the pair. This rare form seems chosen to rhyme with motsaʾakha. Together the two words mean 'all your movements and operations', military ones especially.

  35. אַתָּ֖ה

    ʾattah · H0859A

    you (m. sg.) · v25

    'You'. The pronoun is spelled out, which keeps the focus on the king as the target of the spying.

  36. וַיָּ֤שָׁב

    vayyāshov · H7725

    return, come back · v27

    Abner 'came back': he had already left Hebron in peace (v. 21–23) and was recalled by Joab's messengers (v. 26). The form continues the story in sequence ('and then…').

  37. חֶבְר֔וֹן

    Ḥevrôn · H2275

    Hebron · v27

    David's royal capital at this stage, where he reigned over Judah. Hebrew needs no 'to' here: the place name alone marks where he went.

  38. וַיַּטֵּ֤הוּ

    vayyaṭṭēhû · H5186

    stretch out; (causative) turn aside · v27

    'He turned him aside': Joab steered Abner away from the open road and from his escort. The verb pictures deliberately leading someone off the expected path.

  39. תּ֣וֹךְ

    tôkh · H8432

    midst, middle · v27

    'The midst of' the gate: the inside of the gate complex, probably one of the recesses or chambers in the gate passage, away from the street.

  40. הַשַּׁ֔עַר

    hashshaʿar · H8179

    gate · v27

    The city gate, a large built structure with side chambers that served as the town's courtroom, market and meeting place. The setting is ironic: the place where justice was done publicly becomes the place of a private killing.

  41. לְדַבֵּ֥ר

    ledabbēr · H1696

    to speak · v27

    The stated purpose, the pretext Joab offered: 'to speak with him'. The Hebrew does not itself say 'as if'; the story shows it was a pretext.

  42. בַּשֶּׁ֑לִי

    bashshelî · H7987

    quietness, privacy · v27

    'In quiet': privately, discreetly, with no fuss. The word appears only here in the Bible. It suggests an unguarded, peaceful setting, which is exactly what made Abner an easy target.

  43. וַיַּכֵּ֤הוּ

    vayyakkēhû · H5221

    strike, smite · v27

    'He struck him': in stories of violence this verb usually means a deadly blow. Here a stab with a blade (compare 20:10, where Joab uses a sword the same way).

  44. שָׁם֙

    shām · H8033

    there · v27

    'There', in the gate itself. The word stresses where the killing happened.

  45. הַחֹ֔מֶשׁ

    haḥōmesh · H2570

    belly, abdomen · v27

    'The belly': the same spot where Abner had struck Asahel (2:23). The blow mirrors the original killing, a life for a life in the same place. The KJV's 'fifth rib' comes from linking the word to the Hebrew for 'five'.

  46. וַיָּ֕מָת

    vayyāmot · H4191

    die · v27

    'And he died': a blunt, immediate result. Israel's most powerful general dies in a single line.

  47. בְּדַ֖ם

    bedam · H1818

    blood · v27

    'For the blood of': in return for the life Abner had taken. In Israel, 'blood' that had been shed was a claim waiting to be settled. The small word 'for' (be-) gives the reason, or the price.

  48. עֲשָׂה־

    ʿĂsāh- · H6214

    Asahel (first part) · v27

    First half of the name Asahel, 'God has made'. It is written as two joined parts.

  49. אָחִֽיו׃

    ʾāḥîv · H251

    brother · v27

    'His brother', meaning Joab's. The kinship tie is the whole basis of the claim: as next of kin, Joab took on the role of avenger.

The world behind it

Civil war between two royal houses. After Saul's death (1 Sam 31), Judah crowned David at Hebron (2 Sam 2:4). Abner, Saul's cousin and commander, made Saul's surviving son Ish-bosheth king over the other tribes, ruling from Mahanaim across the Jordan (2:8–10). A "long war" followed (3:1), and in it Abner killed Asahel, the brother of David's commander Joab (2:18–23). That created a blood feud.

Abner's break. When Ish-bosheth accused Abner of sleeping with Saul's concubine Rizpah (in that culture, a move that could signal a claim to the throne), Abner swore to transfer the kingdom to David, "as YHWH swore to David" (3:6–11). David demanded the return of his wife Michal, Saul's daughter, which strengthened his link to Saul's house (3:13–16). Abner then lobbied the elders of Israel and of Benjamin, Saul's own tribe (3:17–19).

The feast and the departure. Abner came to Hebron with twenty men, and David held a mishteh, a banquet or drinking feast (3:20). Sharing a meal in the ancient Near East often sealed an agreement and created obligations of hospitality and protection. When a host "sent off" a guest "in peace," he publicly guaranteed his safety.

What follows. Joab returns from a raid, learns Abner has gone, calls him a spy, secretly brings him back, and kills him in the gate of Hebron "for the blood of Asahel" (3:22–27). Hebron was one of Israel's cities of refuge (Josh 20:7), which made the act worse. David publicly curses Joab's house and mourns Abner (3:28–39). The repeated "in peace" in vv. 21–23 prepares for David's declaration: "I and my kingdom are innocent before YHWH" (3:28).

From the study of 2 Samuel 3:21.

Where scholars differ

in v21

Was Abner acting out of conviction or self-interest?

  • Conviction: he recognised YHWH's choice of David.

    In 3:9–10 and 3:18 Abner himself cites YHWH's oath to give David the kingdom. After his death David calls him "a prince and a great man" (3:38).

  • Self-interest: he was bargaining for position after falling out with Ish-bosheth.

    His switch follows directly on the Rizpah insult (3:7–11). He secures a private feast and agreement with David. Joab immediately suspects him of spying (3:25). His flattering appeal to David's "desire" reads like a negotiator's pitch. Many commentators (e.g. McCarter, Alter) see mixed motives.

in v21

Does the repeated "in peace" reflect historical fact or a pro-David defence?

  • It reflects real events: David genuinely protected Abner, and Joab acted alone out of blood vengeance.

    The blood feud over Asahel (2:23; 3:27, 30) is a sufficient motive. David's public cursing of Joab and mourning for Abner (3:28–39) fit innocence, as does his later instruction to Solomon about Joab (1 Kgs 2:5).

  • The repetition is deliberate court defence, written to clear David of a death that benefited him.

    Scholars such as McCarter and VanderKam (JBL 1980) note that the narrative repeatedly protests David's innocence in convenient deaths (Saul, Abner, Ish-bosheth). The triple "in peace" and the statement that "all the people knew it was not the king's will" (3:37) read as answers to rumours of complicity. Even on this view, the text's claim is clear: David did not intend Abner's death.

in v24

What drove Joab's protest and his later killing of Abner?

  • Blood vengeance for his brother Asahel.

    The narrator says it outright: Joab killed Abner 'for the blood of Asahel his brother' (3:27) and because Abner 'had killed their brother Asahel at Gibeon' (3:30). The duty of the 'avenger of blood' (Num 35:19) gives the cultural frame.

  • Rivalry: fear of losing his command to Abner.

    Abner was bringing all Israel to David and would likely be rewarded with high rank. Joab later kills Amasa after David makes Amasa commander in his place (19:13; 20:9–10), which suggests a pattern of removing rivals. Many commentators (e.g. Anderson, McCarter) see both motives at work.

  • Genuine suspicion that Abner was a spy (Joab's stated reason).

    Joab claims in v. 25 that Abner came 'to deceive you and to know your going out and coming in'. Abner's earlier loyalty to Saul's house made the suspicion plausible. But the narrator gives no support to the charge, and most interpreters read it as a pretext.

in v25

Was Joab's charge sincere suspicion or a pretext for revenge?

  • Mainly a pretext: Joab wanted vengeance for Asahel and feared Abner as a rival commander.

    The narrator gives the motive outright: 'for the blood of Asahel his brother' (3:27, 30). Joab later kills the rival commander Amasa by a similar trick (20:9–10). He kills Abner deceptively in a city of refuge after the king had guaranteed his safety ('in peace' three times).

  • A real if self-serving military suspicion: a seasoned enemy general visiting the capital was a genuine security risk.

    Abner had led Saul's war against David for years. Ancient envoys were often suspected of spying. Abner switched sides only after a personal quarrel (3:7–11), so his loyalty could reasonably be doubted. Joab's words pick up a real danger even if his motives were mixed.

in v25

Is the account of Abner's death written chiefly to clear David?

  • Yes. It is part of a 'defence of David' narrative written to answer charges that he gained the throne by eliminating Saul's house.

    There is heavy stress on David's ignorance ('David did not know', 3:26) and innocence (3:28, 37), and a pattern of convenient deaths (Saul, Abner, Ish-bosheth) each followed by David mourning or punishing the killers. Argued by McCarter and others, comparing royal self-justification texts such as the Hittite Apology of Hattusili III.

  • It is a candid history that includes its hero's weakness. The story does not simply clean up David's image.

    The narrative openly shows David unable to control Joab (3:39) and leaves the killers unpunished in his lifetime. It goes on to record David's own crimes (2 Sam 11). Both readings agree that the text presents David as not guilty of Abner's death.

in v27

What was Joab's real motive?

  • Blood vengeance for Asahel, as the narrator states.

    v. 27 'for the blood of Asahel his brother'; v. 30 repeats that Joab and Abishai killed Abner 'because he had killed their brother Asahel at Gibeon in battle'. The duty of the next of kin to avenge a death was a real social obligation (Num 35).

  • Political rivalry and suspicion, with vengeance as the stated cover.

    Joab had just accused Abner of spying (v. 24–25). Abner, bringing all Israel over, would likely have rivalled Joab for command. Joab later kills Amasa, who had been appointed commander in his place, in an identical way (20:10). 1 Kgs 2:5 frames the killing as treachery in peacetime rather than legitimate vengeance.

in v27

Was David complicit?

  • The narrative should be taken at its word: David was unaware and innocent.

    v. 26 'David did not know'; v. 28–39: David's public curse on Joab's house, his mourning, his fasting, and the people's acceptance that 'it had not been the king's will' (v. 37).

  • The account is a pro-David defence written to clear him of a suspicion that was widespread.

    The narrator repeatedly insists on David's innocence, and David gained very conveniently from the deaths of Abner and then Ish-bosheth (ch. 4). Scholars such as J. VanderKam (JBL 1980) and B. Halpern (David's Secret Demons) read the text as apologetic. Others answer that the narrative also openly records David's failures.

in v27

Where in the gate did the killing happen?

  • 'Into the midst of the gate' (Masoretic Text): within the gate passage or one of its chambers.

    The standard Hebrew text. Chambered gates from this period offered semi-private side rooms.

  • 'At the side of the gate' (Septuagint): just off the gateway.

    The Greek 'from the sides of the gate' may reflect a different Hebrew text. Some commentators prefer it because a crowded central passage seems an unlikely place for a private talk.

Sources
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. בְּרִית, כָּרַת, נֶפֶשׁ, אוה, שָׁלוֹם, שָׁלַח
  • TDOT s.v. berît (M. Weinfeld) and s.v. nepeš
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 3:6–39
  • A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • J. C. VanderKam, "Davidic Complicity in the Deaths of Abner and Eshbaal," JBL 99 (1980)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 3
  • Supplied Hebrew text with morphology (OSIS 2Sam.3.21); BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT
  • BDB s.v. שָׁלַח (Piel)
  • HALOT s.v. שׁלח (Piel: let go, send away, accompany a departing guest)
  • BDB s.v. זֶה (enclitic use with interrogatives)
  • Gesenius-Kautzsch, Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive absolute)
  • Joüon-Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §123, §143g
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Oxford English Dictionary s.v. 'quite' (historical sense 'completely')
  • BDB s.v. פָּתָה
  • HALOT s.v. פתה I
  • HALOT s.v. מוֹצָא; s.v. מוֹבָא
  • BDB s.v. יָדַע
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
  • A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 11)
  • Robert P. Gordon, 1 & 2 Samuel: A Commentary
  • Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 3:25 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 3:25
  • BDB s.v. חֹמֶשׁ II ('belly')
  • HALOT s.v. חֹמֶשׁ and שְׁלִי
  • BDB s.v. שְׁלִי
  • Rashi on 2 Samuel 3:27 / 2:23 ('fifth rib')
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 2 Kingdoms 3:27
  • Vulgate, 2 Samuel 3:27
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text of the Books of Samuel
  • J. C. VanderKam, 'Davidic Complicity in the Deaths of Abner and Eshbaal', JBL 99 (1980)
  • B. Halpern, David's Secret Demons (2001)
  • Numbers 35; Joshua 20–21; 1 Kings 2:5, 31–34 (cross-references)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

3 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.