Ecclesiastes Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Ecclesiastes 5:17–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17Moreover, all his days he eats in darkness, with much sorrow, sickness, and anger. 18Here is what I have seen to be good and fitting: to eat and drink, and to find satisfaction in all the labor one does under the sun during the few days of life that God has given him—for this is his lot. 19Furthermore, God has given riches and wealth to every man, and He has enabled him to enjoy them, to accept his lot, and to rejoice in his labor. This is a gift from God.

What the first hearers heard

To Qoheleth's first readers, Jews of the Persian or early Hellenistic period living in an economy of commerce, risky ventures and new wealth, this was a familiar figure: the man who works and saves obsessively, loses it, and grows sour, sick and angry. Qoheleth is not cursing him. He is diagnosing him. The verse rounds off the "sick evil" with its human cost and gets the reader ready for the turn in 5:18: since nothing can be carried out of the world (5:15), the only sane response is to receive daily food, drink and work as God's gift and enjoy them while the days last. The verse warned hearers against a way of holding possessions that turns life's ordinary goods into darkness, frustration and disease. It sits alongside Qoheleth's later counsel to "remove vexation (ka'as) from your heart" (11:10).

From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17Moreover, all his days he eats in darkness, with much sorrow, sickness, and anger.

    On top of everything else, this man's whole life is spent eating in the dark. He still eats every day, as people must, but the very act that the next verse will call God's good gift is joyless for him, done in a gloom that already looks like the grave. And his life piles up like a list nobody can bear to finish: a great deal of chafing frustration, that bitter mix of grief and resentment; his sickness; and anger that keeps flaring.

    The man is the one Qoheleth has just described. He hoarded wealth to his own harm, lost it in a bad venture, and has nothing left to pass on to his son. He will leave the world as naked as he came into it (5:13–16). Qoheleth called that a "sick evil," and now the sickness is the man's own. The darkness, vexation, illness and anger are not punishments dropped on him from outside. They are what a life of clutching and losing does to a person from the inside. The verse is written as a deliberate foil for what follows: the person who receives food, drink and work as a gift from God "eats" too, but in the light (5:18–20).

    Full study →
  2. 18Here is what I have seen to be good and fitting: to eat and drink, and to find satisfaction in all the labor one does under the sun during the few days of life that God has given him—for this is his lot.

    Look, here is what I myself have seen to be good, and fitting, even beautiful: to eat, to drink, and to really taste good things in all the hard, wearying work a person labors at here under the sun, through the counted and limited days of life that God has given him. For that is his share, the part of it all that is truly his.

    The verse is a deliberate turn. It comes straight after the portrait of a man who hoarded wealth, lost it in a bad venture, and "eats in darkness" with sorrow, sickness and anger (5:13–17). Against that picture Qohelet (the book's "Teacher" or "Preacher") sets ordinary meals, wine, and enjoyment within one's work. He uses the same verb twice on purpose: he saw that the best thing is to see good, which means to experience it. The work remains toil, and the days remain numbered. But the enjoyment is not something grabbed in defiance of God. God gives it. And it is not a consolation prize. It is the person's portion, the real share he can actually have, in a world where no one keeps any lasting "gain" (1:3; 5:15).

    Full study →
  3. 19Furthermore, God has given riches and wealth to every man, and He has enabled him to enjoy them, to accept his lot, and to rejoice in his labor. This is a gift from God.

    "And more than that: take any person to whom God has given wealth and property, and whom he has also made master over it, granted the right and the power actually to eat from it, to pick up and carry off his own allotted share, and to be glad right in the middle of his wearying toil. That, the whole of it, is God's gift."

    The Hebrew sentence opens with the person and leaves him hanging: "every human to whom God gave riches and possessions, and empowered him…". It then sums everything up with a single word: "this is a gift of God." The emphasis falls on that summary.

    A few things English can blur:

    • "Every" is conditional. It means every person who has been given wealth. The verse does not say everyone is given wealth.
    • The decisive gift is the second one. The verb "empowered" is the language of being granted authority or legal control, the right to dispose of one's goods. Wealth is one gift. The freedom and capacity to enjoy it is another. The next lines (6:1–2) show a man who has the first without the second, and "a stranger eats it."
    • "Eat" is concrete: the table, food and drink of 5:18.
    • "Take up his portion" is active. He collects his share the way one receives a share of land or spoil, and makes it his own. It is not the lasting profit Qoheleth says no one gets. It is the real, limited share this life offers.
    • "Toil" is Qoheleth's word for exhausting, troubled labor, the same toil he called empty and without profit in 1:3. Gladness is found within it, not by escaping it.
    • "Gift" shares its root with "gave" at the start. God giving frames the whole verse. Toil earns the money, but the joy of it cannot be earned. It is handed over.
    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    much sorrow (KJV, BSB)

    ka'as harbēh

    What we hear
    Deep sadness, grief or mourning.
    What they heard
    Much vexation: irritation, frustration and resentment mixed with grief, a chafing, provoked state rather than quiet sadness.
  • in v17

    wrath (KJV)

    qeṣep

    What we hear
    Mostly 'the wrath of God', divine punishment coming on the man.
    What they heard
    Here, in a list of the man's own inner states, it most naturally means his own flaring anger.
  • in v18

    lot ("this is his lot")

    ḥēleq

    What we hear
    Fate one puts up with, usually unwanted: "that's my lot in life".
    What they heard
    An allotted share, like an inherited plot of land or a share of the spoils. It is what properly belongs to you, here a good gift from God.
  • in v18

    under the sun

    taḥat haššemeš

    What we hear
    Often explained as "life lived without God" or "from a purely secular viewpoint".
    What they heard
    Here on earth, among the living: the sphere of human experience. In this same sentence God is the giver.
  • in v19

    labor / labour (BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT)

    'amal

    What we hear
    Work or a job in a neutral sense, possibly meaningful or fulfilling.
    What they heard
    Wearying, troublesome toil, a word that also means 'trouble' and 'misery'. In Qoheleth it is the hard striving that brings no lasting profit (1:3). Gladness *in* it is therefore surprising and has to be given.
  • in v19

    accept his lot (BSB; similar in NIV, ESV)

    lase't 'et-chelqo

    What we hear
    Resigning oneself to one's fate, putting up with one's circumstances.
    What they heard
    To take up or carry off one's allotted share, actively receiving one's portion of good as one would collect a share of land or spoil.
  • in v19

    enabled / the ability / good health

    hishlito

    What we hear
    Having the personal capacity or physical health to enjoy things.
    What they heard
    God 'made him master over it', granting authority and the right of control over his wealth. It is a second, separate gift that God can withhold (6:2).
Every word
  1. גַּ֥ם

    gam · H1571

    also, moreover · v17, v19

    Adds this verse to the 'sick evil' of the verse before. Losing everything at death is bad enough, and on top of that the man's whole life was miserable.

  2. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, every · v17, v18, v19

    'All' his days: the gloom is not a bad season. It fills his whole lifetime.

  3. יָמָ֖יו

    yāmāw · H3117

    day; (plural) lifetime · v17, v18

    'His days' is the ordinary Hebrew way to say 'his life.' Qoheleth (the book's 'Teacher') often counts life in days because there are few of them (5:18; 6:12).

  4. בַּחֹ֣שֶׁךְ

    baḥōšek · H2822

    darkness · v17

    'In the darkness': gloom and joylessness. Elsewhere in this book darkness belongs to the fool (2:14), the stillborn child (6:4) and the long 'days of darkness' of death (11:8). The living man already has death's colour on him.

  5. יֹאכֵ֑ל

    yō'kēl · H398

    to eat, consume · v17, v18, v19

    'He eats': the verb shows something he keeps doing, every day. Eating stands for living and for enjoying what you have. That is the same activity the very next verse praises as God's gift. He does it, but in the dark, with no joy.

  6. וְכָעַ֥ס

    wekā'as · H3707

    to be vexed, provoked, grieved · v17

    'And he is vexed': a constant, grinding irritation, a mix of frustration, grief and resentment. The ancient translations read it as the noun 'vexation.'

  7. הַרְבֵּ֖ה

    harbēh · H7235

    to multiply; (adverb) much, greatly · v17

    A verb form used here as the adverb 'much, a great deal.' It is a favourite word of Qoheleth, and the one he uses in 1:18: 'much wisdom, much vexation.'

  8. וְחָלְי֥וֹ

    weḥolyô · H2483

    sickness, illness, affliction · v17

    'And his sickness': physical or general affliction. It echoes the 'sick evil' (rā'āh ḥôlāh) of the previous verse. The disease Qoheleth sees in the man's situation has got into his body and his days.

  9. וָקָֽצֶף׃

    wāqāṣep · H7110

    wrath, anger, outburst · v17

    'And anger': hot, bursting anger. This is the last item in a list that piles up without a full sentence around it, as if the speaker were just listing what the man has left.

  10. הִנֵּה

    hinnēh · H2009

    look!, behold · v18

    Grabs attention and marks a conclusion. After the grim case just described (5:13–17), Qohelet says: now look at this instead.

  11. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾăšer · H0834A

    which, that · v18, v19

    "That which": it introduces what he has seen.

  12. רָאִיתִי

    rāʾîtî · H7200G

    I have seen · v18

    Qohelet's word for observing. He presents the conclusion as something he found by looking at life, not as a rule handed down.

  13. אָנִי

    ʾānî · H0589

    I · v18

    An extra "I" that adds emphasis: "I myself have seen." It is typical of Qohelet's first-person voice (compare 2:13).

  14. טוֹב

    ṭôb · H2896A

    good · v18

    Good in the broad Hebrew sense: pleasant, beneficial, right. This is the verdict on what follows.

  15. יָפֶה

    yāpeh · H3303

    beautiful, fitting · v18

    Usually "beautiful" (of people, as in Song of Songs), but in Qohelet it also means "fitting, appropriate" (3:11, "everything beautiful in its time"). Here it means fitting and lovely at once.

  16. וְלִשְׁתּוֹת

    wəlištôt · H8354

    and to drink · v18

    Drinking, often wine at a meal. "Eat and drink" together stands for enjoying the table and normal life (compare 2:24; 9:7).

  17. עֲמָלוֹ

    ʿămālô · H5999

    his toil, trouble · v18, v19

    Hard, wearying labor, and also what that labor earns. Throughout Ecclesiastes it carries a tone of strain and trouble.

  18. שֶׁיַּעֲמֹל

    šeyyaʿămōl · H5998

    that he toils · v18

    "That he toils": the noun and verb from the same root are repeated for emphasis. It uses the short relative "she-", a feature of late Hebrew.

  19. תַּחַת־

    taḥat · H8478G

    under · v18

    Part of the phrase "under the sun".

  20. הַשֶּׁמֶשׁ

    haššemeš · H8121

    the sun · v18

    "Under the sun" means here in this world, among living people. It names the sphere Qohelet is observing; it does not mean "without God".

  21. מִסְפַּר

    mispar · H4557

    number · v18

    "The number of": the days are counted and limited. The idea is that they are few and they end.

  22. חַיָּיו

    ḥayyāw · H2416E

    his life · v18

    His lifetime. The phrase as a whole means his short, counted lifespan.

  23. נָתַן־

    nātan · H5414G

    he has given · v18, v19

    "Has given": a gift already granted. Qohelet often uses this verb for God handing out both burdens and joys (1:13; 2:26; 3:10; 5:19).

  24. לוֹ

    lô · H9033

    to him · v18, v19

    "To him": the individual person receives the gift.

  25. הָאֱלֹהִים

    hāʾĕlōhîm · H0430G

    God · v18, v19

    "The God", Qohelet's usual name for God. He never uses the covenant name YHWH. It presents God as the Creator who sets the conditions of every human life.

  26. כִּי־

    kî · H3588A

    for, because · v18

    "For": it gives the reason why this enjoyment is good.

  27. הוּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    it, that · v18, v19

    "It" or "that": the eating, drinking and enjoying just described.

  28. חֶלְקוֹ

    ḥelqô · H2506A

    his portion, share · v18, v19

    His allotted share, the part that is really his. It is the opposite of a lasting "gain", which Qohelet says no one gets, and it is something to receive, not to resent.

  29. הָאָדָ֡ם

    ha'adam · H0120G

    human being, person · v19

    The generic human being, Qoheleth's usual word for humanity as a whole. Not 'man' as male but any person.

  30. עֹ֨שֶׁר

    'osher · H6239

    riches, wealth · v19

    Wealth in general, the condition of being rich. Paired with the next word to mean 'a fortune'.

  31. וּנְכָסִ֜ים

    unekhasim · H5233

    possessions, property · v19

    Property and assets. A late word, Aramaic-influenced and used in legal and economic writing. The same pair, 'riches and possessions', is used of Solomon's wealth in 2 Chronicles 1:11–12, which fits the royal persona Qoheleth takes on.

  32. וְהִשְׁלִיט֨וֹ

    vehishlito · H7980

    to have mastery; (causative) to grant control · v19

    'And has empowered him', literally 'made him master over it'. God gives not only the wealth but the right and the control to use it. This is the turning point of the verse. In 6:2 God gives a man wealth but does *not* do this, and a stranger eats it.

  33. מִמֶּ֙נּוּ֙

    mimmennu · H4480A

    from it · v19

    'From it', meaning from the wealth. He eats from what he has, not merely looks at it or stores it up (compare the hoarded riches of 5:13).

  34. וְלָשֵׂ֣את

    velase't · H5375H

    to lift, carry, take up · v19

    'And to take up / carry off'. This is active: he picks up his share and walks away with it, like a person collecting his portion of a distribution. It is more than passively 'accepting'.

  35. אֶת־

    'et · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v19

    Untranslatable marker showing that 'his portion' is the object of 'take up'.

  36. וְלִשְׂמֹ֖חַ

    velismoach · H8055

    to rejoice, be glad, enjoy oneself · v19

    'And to be glad'. Ordinary gladness and enjoyment, the joy of feasting and good days. It is not a specifically religious exultation.

  37. זֹ֕ה

    zoh · H2090

    this (feminine) · v19

    'This': a late form of the usual zo't. It gathers up the whole long description that came before. The entire situation of having, being empowered to enjoy, and being glad is what is called God's gift.

  38. מַתַּ֥ת

    mattat · H4991

    gift · v19

    'A gift of', from the same root as natan, 'give'. A present freely handed over, not a wage earned by toil.

The world behind it

Where the verse sits. Ecclesiastes 5:13–17 (English numbering) is a short case study. Qoheleth has seen "a sickening evil under the sun": wealth kept by its owner to his harm, then lost in "a bad venture." The man has a son but nothing to give him, and he goes out of the world as naked as he came, with nothing for all his toil "for the wind." Verse 17 describes the inner side of that life. Verses 18–20 then give Qoheleth's alternative: eat, drink and find enjoyment in your work as your God-given "portion."

Eating as a picture of life. In Israel's world, eating and drinking were the basic signs of a blessed life. Festival law tells worshippers to "eat before the LORD your God and rejoice" (Deut 12:7). Qoheleth comes back to "eat and drink" as God's gift seven times. Saying that someone "eats in darkness" means even the most ordinary pleasure has gone sour for him.

Darkness and death. For Israelites, Sheol, the place of the dead, was a land of darkness (Job 10:21–22; Ps 88). Qoheleth uses "darkness" for the stillborn child and for the long "days of darkness" ahead (6:4; 11:8). Calling a living man's days "darkness" says he is living a kind of death before he dies.

From the study of Ecclesiastes 5:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Is the original text 'he eats in darkness' or 'all his days are in darkness and mourning'?

  • Keep the Hebrew text 'he eats' (yō'kēl).

    Supported by the Vulgate, Targum and Peshitta. It is the harder reading. It sets up a deliberate contrast with 'to eat and drink' in 5:18, and eating is a theme that runs through the book (2:24; 3:13; 8:15; 9:7).

  • Follow the Septuagint: 'and mourning' ('ēbel).

    The Septuagint's πένθει implies אבל, which looks very like יאכל. It gives a smooth list of nouns (darkness, mourning, vexation, sickness, anger) and avoids the odd idea of 'eating darkness/in darkness.'

  • Guess 'he walks' (yēlēk).

    Matches 'so he goes' (5:15) and 'the fool walks in darkness' (2:14). No manuscript supports it.

in v17

Is 'eats in darkness' literal or figurative?

  • Figurative: a joyless, death-shadowed life.

    Qoheleth's other uses of darkness (2:14; 6:4; 11:8) and the wider link between darkness and Sheol. 'All his days' points to a whole way of life rather than mealtimes.

  • Partly literal: the miser eats alone, in the dark.

    A strand of medieval Jewish interpretation pictured the stingy man eating without a lamp, to save oil or to avoid having to share with guests. It fits the hoarding in context, but the text does not require it.

in v17

Whose anger is qeṣep?

  • The man's own anger.

    It sits in a list of his inner and bodily states (vexation, his sickness). Qoheleth never speaks of God's qeṣep.

  • A hint of divine displeasure.

    Elsewhere qeṣep is overwhelmingly God's wrath. A few interpreters hear an echo of that, but the context does not develop it.

in v18

How should ṭôb ʾăšer-yāpeh ("good which is beautiful") be construed?

  • It is a fixed expression meaning "good and fitting / good and proper".

    Most modern translations (BSB, ESV, WEB) take it this way. Some commentators compare it to idioms in Aramaic or other ancient languages that pair "good" and "beautiful" for what is right and pleasing, and a few compare the Greek ideal *kalos kagathos* ("beautiful and good"). How much that comparison proves is disputed.

  • The relative word introduces the subject: "what is good, what is fitting, is to eat and drink…"

    This takes *ʾăšer* in its normal sense of "that which", with two parallel predicates. It is close to the Septuagint's "good, which is beautiful".

  • It is causal: "good, because beautiful/fitting".

    YLT reads it this way. *ʾăšer* can sometimes mean "because" in late Hebrew, but this reading has few followers.

in v18

Is Qohelet's call to enjoyment a genuine affirmation or a resigned consolation?

  • Genuine affirmation: Qohelet is a "preacher of joy".

    R. N. Whybray (1982) pointed to the seven joy passages, which grow stronger as the book goes on and end in the command "rejoice" (11:9). This verse calls enjoyment "good", "fitting", God's gift and one's portion.

  • A sober, limited consolation within a bleak outlook.

    Commentators such as M. V. Fox stress that enjoyment is the best available option, not an answer to absurdity (*hebel*). The joy is bounded by "the number of the days" and depends on God's unpredictable giving (6:1–2).

  • It is the view of a character, which the book's frame narrator qualifies.

    T. Longman and others read Qohelet's words (1:12–12:7) as a character's speech that the epilogue (12:9–14) assesses, so the joy advice is real but not the book's final word.

in v19

What exactly is 'the gift of God': the wealth, or the power to enjoy it?

  • The gift is the whole package: wealth, the authority to use it, and gladness.

    'This' (zoh) summarizes everything in the sentence, and the verse opens with God 'giving' the wealth itself.

  • The emphasis falls on the empowerment and the enjoyment, which is the gift that cannot be assumed.

    6:2 shows wealth given *without* empowerment. The parallel in 3:13 calls eating, drinking and seeing good in toil the gift, with no mention of wealth. Most commentators (e.g. Fox, Seow, Longman) stress this point.

in v19

Is Qoheleth's call to enjoyment a resigned consolation or a positive affirmation?

  • Resigned or pessimistic: enjoyment is the best available relief in an absurd world, a way of not thinking about death (compare v. 20).

    The surrounding refrains that all is 'vapor' (hevel), the denial of lasting profit (1:3), and the stress on how few one's days are. Associated with readings such as Crenshaw's and, more moderately, Fox's.

  • Positive affirmation: joy is God's real gift and the book's constructive counsel.

    The joy passages (2:24; 3:12–13, 22; 5:18–20; 8:15; 9:7–9; 11:9) grow in strength through the book and are tied explicitly to God's giving. R. N. Whybray called Qoheleth a 'preacher of joy'. N. Lohfink read 5:19–20 as God 'answering' or revealing himself through the joy of the heart.

in v19

Does 'rejoice in his toil' mean gladness in the work itself, or in what the work earns?

  • In the activity: finding joy while working.

    'Amal is often the effort itself (1:3), and the preposition be- naturally means 'in, during'.

  • In the proceeds: enjoying the fruit of one's labor.

    'Amal can mean earnings (2:18–19, where 'all my toil' is left to an heir). The context is about enjoying wealth. Fox often takes 'amal in this sense.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חֹשֶׁךְ, כַּעַס, חֳלִי, קֶצֶף
  • HALOT s.v. כעס, קֶצֶף, חֳלִי
  • C.-L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C)
  • Michael V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes
  • Tremper Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT)
  • Roland E. Murphy, Ecclesiastes (Word Biblical Commentary 23A)
  • Robert Gordis, Koheleth: The Man and His World
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Ecclesiastes 5:16
  • Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:16
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, critical apparatus at Ecclesiastes 5:16
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. חֵלֶק, עָמָל, יָפֶה, מִסְפָּר
  • C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Yale Bible 18C)
  • M. V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes
  • R. N. Whybray, "Qoheleth, Preacher of Joy," JSOT 23 (1982)
  • T. Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT)
  • Phoenician inscriptions of Tabnit and Eshmunazar (KAI 13–14) for "under the sun"
  • Epic of Gilgamesh, Old Babylonian version (Sippar tablet), Siduri's speech
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Ecclesiastes 5:17
  • Vulgate Ecclesiastes 5:17
  • BDB s.v. שָׁלַט, חֵלֶק, עָמָל, מַתַּת
  • HALOT s.v. שׁלט (hif.), חֵלֶק I, עָמָל, נְכָסִים
  • C. L. Seow, Ecclesiastes (Anchor Bible 18C, 1997)
  • C. L. Seow, 'Linguistic Evidence and the Dating of Qohelet,' JBL 115 (1996)
  • M. V. Fox, A Time to Tear Down and a Time to Build Up: A Rereading of Ecclesiastes (1999)
  • R. N. Whybray, 'Qoheleth, Preacher of Joy,' JSOT 23 (1982)
  • N. Lohfink, 'Ecclesiastes 5:17–19 — Revelation by Joy,' CBQ 52 (1990)
  • T. Longman III, The Book of Ecclesiastes (NICOT, 1998)
  • J. L. Crenshaw, Ecclesiastes (OTL, 1987)
  • Epic of Gilgamesh, Old Babylonian version (Sippar tablet), Siduri's advice
  • Septuagint, Ecclesiastes 5:18 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Ecclesiastes 5:18

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).