Exodus Chapter 17 Read as one passage

Exodus 17:2–7

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

2So the people contended with Moses, “Give us water to drink.” “Why do you contend with me?” Moses replied. “Why do you test the LORD?” 3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?” 4Then Moses cried out to the LORD, “What should I do with these people? A little more and they will stone me!” 5And the LORD said to Moses, “Walk on ahead of the people and take some of the elders of Israel with you. Take along in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile, and go. 6Behold, I will stand there before you by the rock at Horeb. And when you strike the rock, water will come out of it for the people to drink.” So Moses did this in the sight of the elders of Israel. 7He named the place Massah and Meribah because the Israelites quarreled, and because they tested the LORD, saying, “Is the LORD among us or not?”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing this story, the verse explained two familiar names, Massah and Meribah, and made them a lasting warning. Their own scriptures returned to it again and again: 'Do not test YHWH your God as you tested him at Massah' (Deut 6:16), and 'Do not harden your hearts as at Meribah, as on the day of Massah in the wilderness' (Ps 95:8; compare Deut 9:22; 33:8; Ps 78; 106:32).

The verse taught them to tell three things apart:

  • Need: being thirsty is not the sin, and God answers it immediately (vv. 5–6).
  • Grumbling (lûn, v. 3): complaining against a leader.
  • Putting God on trial (nissâ): treating God's presence as unproven and demanding he justify himself. This is the charge that sticks.

It also shaped how they understood the relationship between God, his spokesman and the people. Attacking God's appointed messenger is in the end an attack on the God who sent him (compare 16:8: 'Your grumbling is not against us but against YHWH'). Later Jewish and early Christian readers kept using the episode this way (Matt 4:7; 1 Cor 10:4, 9; Heb 3:7–11).

From the study of Exodus 17:2.

Verse by verse

  1. 2So the people contended with Moses, “Give us water to drink.” “Why do you contend with me?” Moses replied. “Why do you test the LORD?”

    So the people brought their complaint against Moses: not a murmur of discontent but an angry confrontation, almost a charge in court, accusing him of failing the people he led out of Egypt. Together they demanded, without a word of courtesy: "You leaders, give us water, so we can drink!" Moses threw their own word back at them: "Why ever are you bringing a case against me? Why are you putting YHWH on trial?"

    The two questions climb. On the surface the dispute is with Moses, but the camp is where it is because YHWH led them there (v. 1). So demanding that the leaders produce water is really a demand that God prove, once again, that he is present and able. Testing here does not mean being lured into sin. It means putting someone to the proof. Only a chapter earlier God was the one testing Israel (15:25; 16:4). Now Israel turns the test on him. The narrator will fix both accusations in the landscape: Massah ('Testing') and Meribah ('Quarrel'), 'because they tested YHWH, saying, "Is YHWH among us or not?"' (v. 7).

    Full study →
  2. 3But the people thirsted for water there, and they grumbled against Moses: “Why have you brought us out of Egypt—to make us and our children and livestock die of thirst?”

    There at Rephidim the people were desperately thirsty. A dry camp, families, flocks: this was the kind of thirst people die of. The whole community, acting as one body, rose up in open, angry protest against Moses. This was not quiet muttering under their breath; the next verse shows Moses afraid of being stoned. With one voice, as if each person were speaking for himself, they demanded: “Why on earth did you bring us up out of Egypt?” They used the words Israel normally used for God's great act of rescue, but they pinned it on Moses. “Was it so you could kill me, my children and my animals, everything I have, with thirst?” The verse begins with thirst and ends with thirst. Between the two, the people turn their rescue from slavery into a story of a leader who brought them out to die.

    Full study →
  3. 4Then Moses cried out to the LORD, “What should I do with these people? A little more and they will stone me!”

    Moses shouted for help to the LORD. This was not weeping. It was the urgent outcry of a man in danger appealing to his protector, the same cry Israel had once raised against Pharaoh. He said: “What am I supposed to do with this people? (Or: what can I do for them?) Any moment now, they will stone me!”

    The scene is built as a chain of appeals. The people have brought their complaint against Moses (v.3). Moses, trapped, turns to God. His question is half a plea for instructions and half a protest. He calls them “this people,” keeping the angry crowd at arm's length and implicitly reminding God whose people they are. “Yet a little, and they will stone me” is an idiom for imminent danger: one more step and the crowd will act as judge and executioner. Stoning was how an Israelite community put to death someone it judged guilty of a grave wrong. The people had just accused Moses of leading them out to kill them and their children. Now Moses fears that they will kill him.

    Full study →
  4. 5And the LORD said to Moses, “Walk on ahead of the people and take some of the elders of Israel with you. Take along in your hand the staff with which you struck the Nile, and go.

    The LORD answered Moses, who had just cried that the people were about to stone him: "Go on out in front of the people, in plain sight of them. Don't hide from them. Take some of Israel's elders with you, the clan heads who speak for the nation, to see what happens with their own eyes. And your staff, the very one you struck the Nile with, take it in your hand. Then go."

    Every part carries weight. "Pass before the people" means both leading the way and stepping into view of the crowd that threatens him. The elders are not decoration. They are Israel's own representatives, there as witnesses in what the context frames almost as a legal dispute (the people "quarreled", a word also used for bringing a lawsuit). The staff is described by its history. It is the shepherd's staff that became "the staff of God", the one that struck the Nile and turned Egypt's water into blood nobody could drink. God insists on it twice ("your staff… take"). The verse ends with "and go", without saying where. Verse 6 reveals the destination: a rock at Horeb where God himself will be standing in front of Moses. There the same staff and the same "striking" that once ruined a river will bring drinking water out of stone.

    Full study →
  5. 6Behold, I will stand there before you by the rock at Horeb. And when you strike the rock, water will come out of it for the people to drink.” So Moses did this in the sight of the elders of Israel.

    "Look: I will already be standing there, in front of you, on the rock at Horeb. Strike the rock, and water will pour out of it, and the people will drink." Moses did exactly that, while the elders of Israel watched.

    What the English loses:

    • "Look, I am standing." God does not only promise to come. He describes himself as already in place, waiting at the rock before Moses gets there. People normally stand before God; here God stands before Moses. The people are about to ask, "Is the LORD among us or not?" (v. 7), and this line has already answered them: he is right there, on the spot.
    • The rock and the place. The "rock" is a crag or rock face, not a loose stone. Horeb is the mountain of God where Moses met him at the burning bush, and its name probably means "dry place." Water will come out of the hardest, driest thing there is.
    • The staff. "Strike" is the same verb used when this staff struck the Nile (v. 5; 7:20). In Egypt that blow turned the river to blood and made it undrinkable. Now the same blow brings drinking water out of stone, for the very people who had just been arguing with Moses and close to stoning him.
    • The whole people drinks. In Hebrew "the people" takes a singular verb: the whole camp drinks as one body. In this verse the complaint gets no lecture, only water.
    • The witnesses. "In the sight of" is literally "to the eyes of" the elders, the heads of Israel's clans. They are there as official witnesses. The story does not describe the water gushing. It records that Moses obeyed and that responsible men saw it. That settles the dispute the people had raised against Moses and, behind him, against God.
    Full study →
  6. 7He named the place Massah and Meribah because the Israelites quarreled, and because they tested the LORD, saying, “Is the LORD among us or not?”

    Moses gave the place a two-part name, "Testing and Contention." Every time someone said the name afterwards, it would recall two things the people did there.

    First, the whole family of Israel brought a case against Moses. This was no passing grumble. It was a hostile accusation against God's appointed leader, serious enough that Moses feared being stoned (v. 4). By attacking Moses, the people were really accusing the God who sent him.

    Second, they put YHWH himself on trial. In the episodes just before this one, God had been testing them, using thirst and hunger to find out whether they would trust him (15:25; 16:4). Here they turned that around and set God an exam to pass.

    Their demand was all or nothing: "Is YHWH really here in the middle of our camp, or is there nothing there?" The question is not whether a god exists. It is whether the God who brought them out of Egypt is actually with them. They had already seen the plagues, the sea, the manna and the guiding cloud, and they still made water the proof of his presence. That is why "Massah" and "Meribah" became Israel's byword for distrust that demands proof (Deut 6:16; Ps 95:8–9).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    tempt (KJV: "wherefore do ye tempt the LORD?")

    nāsâ / tənassûn

    What we hear
    Trying to lure God into doing wrong, or provoking a desire.
    What they heard
    Putting God to the proof: demanding that he show again, on the people's terms, that he is present and able, despite the evidence he has already given.
  • in v2

    chide (KJV: "the people did chide with Moses")

    rîv

    What we hear
    A mild scolding or rebuke.
    What they heard
    A hostile confrontation, close to bringing a legal accusation. By v. 4 Moses fears being stoned.
  • in v3

    murmured (KJV, WEB, YLT); grumbled (BSB and most modern versions)

    vayyalen (lun)

    What we hear
    Quiet, low-voiced muttering or petty grousing under one's breath: annoying but harmless.
    What they heard
    Open, collective protest against the leader God appointed, close to revolt. The next verse has Moses fearing he will be stoned, and the parallel in Num 14 includes plans to replace the leaders and go back to Egypt.
  • in v3

    cattle (KJV)

    miqneh

    What we hear
    Cows specifically.
    What they heard
    All livestock as property, including sheep, goats and cattle: a household's wealth.
  • in v4

    cried (KJV, WEB: “Moses cried unto the LORD”)

    tsāʿaq

    What we hear
    Moses wept or broke down in tears before God.
    What they heard
    Moses called out loudly and urgently for help. It is the outcry of someone in danger or wronged, appealing to a protector or judge. Strong emotion is involved, but the core is the loud appeal, not tears.
  • in v5

    rod (KJV)

    maṭṭeh

    What we hear
    A thin stick for punishment, or a fishing rod.
    What they heard
    A full-length walking or shepherd's staff, also carried as a sign of authority. The same word means 'tribe'.
  • in v5

    elders

    zəqēnîm

    What we hear
    Old people, or members of a church board.
    What they heard
    Heads of clans and households who acted as Israel's representatives, decision-makers and legal witnesses.
  • in v6

    the elders of Israel

    ziqnê Yisraʾel

    What we hear
    A church-style leadership board, or simply elderly men.
    What they heard
    The heads of Israel's families and clans, who represented their kin and served as official witnesses and spokesmen for the people.
  • in v6

    by the rock (BSB, NIV)

    ʿal haṣṣûr

    What we hear
    God waits somewhere near the rock, as a bystander would.
    What they heard
    The preposition most naturally means "on" or "over": God's presence is positioned on the very rock Moses will strike. The rock that is struck and the place of God's presence are the same.
  • in v7

    tempted the LORD (KJV)

    nassotam (nasah)

    What we hear
    Trying to lure God into doing wrong, or putting a sinful desire in front of him.
    What they heard
    Putting God to the test: demanding that he prove his presence and power on the people's terms, as a condition of their trust.
  • in v7

    the chiding (KJV) / quarreled (BSB, WEB)

    riv

    What we hear
    A mild scolding (chiding) or a petty argument (quarrel).
    What they heard
    A contention or case brought against someone: a hostile accusation against Moses (and through him, against God), with a real threat of violence (v. 4).
Every word
  1. וַיָּ֤רֶב

    wayyārev · H7378

    to contend, quarrel, bring a case · v2

    'And (so) the people contended.' This is the verb behind the place name Meribah ('Quarrel') in v. 7. It means a hostile, accusing confrontation, the kind of complaint you would bring against someone in court, not a passing grumble. The verb is singular because 'the people' acts as one body.

  2. הָעָם֙

    hāʿām · H5971A

    people · v2, v3, v4, v5, v6

    'The people': the whole congregation of v. 1, Israel as a kin-group and community. The word stresses them as one body confronting its leader.

  3. עִם־

    ʿim · H5973A

    with · v2

    'With.' Together with rîv it means 'to quarrel with, to have a dispute with': it names who the opposing party is.

  4. מֹשֶׁ֔ה

    mōsheh · H4872

    Moses · v2, v3, v4, v5, v6

    Moses, God's appointed spokesman. The people aim their accusation at the human leader they can see.

  5. וַיֹּ֣אמְר֔וּ

    wayyōʾmrû · H0559

    to say · v2, v3, v4, v5, v7

    'And they said.' Now the verb is plural: the single body of the people breaks into many voices.

  6. תְּנוּ־

    tənû · H5414G

    give · v2

    'Give!' A blunt command, and plural ('you people, give'). It treats the leaders as the ones who owe the people water. Who the plural addresses is debated: perhaps Moses and Aaron together.

  7. לָ֥נוּ

    lānû · H9035

    to us · v2

    'To us': the people who are owed.

  8. מַ֖יִם

    mayim · H4325G

    water · v2, v3, v6

    'Water.' In the desert this is a matter of life or death for people and herds (v. 3), not a comfort.

  9. וְנִשְׁתֶּ֑ה

    wənishteh · H8354

    to drink · v2, v6

    'And let us drink' or 'so that we may drink.' After a command, this form gives the purpose or result: give water, and then we can drink. It picks up v. 1's 'no water for the people to drink.'

  10. לָהֶם֙

    lāhem · H9038

    to them · v2

    'To them.' Moses answers the crowd directly.

  11. מַה־

    mah · H4100

    what? why? · v2, v3, v4

    Literally 'What?', used here as 'Why?' It is a rebuking question that challenges what they are doing, not a request for information.

  12. עִמָּדִ֔י

    ʿimmādî · H5978

    with me · v2

    'With me.' Moses names himself as the one they are attacking, and the next clause shows he is not the real party.

  13. תְּנַסּ֖וּן

    tənassûn · H5254G

    you test, put to the proof · v2, v7

    'Are you putting to the test?' It means putting someone on trial to see whether they will prove themselves, here by demanding that God show he is present and able (v. 7: 'Is YHWH among us or not?'). It also has the weighty final -n.

  14. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v2, v3, v5, v7

    An untranslatable marker that points to the object of the verb. Here it points at YHWH as the one being tested.

  15. יְהוָֽה׃

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh, the LORD · v2, v4, v5, v7

    The personal name of Israel's God, who has just led them out of Egypt and is leading their camp 'by his mouth' (v. 1). The verse ends on this word: the real defendant in their complaint is not Moses but YHWH.

  16. וַיִּצְמָ֨א

    vayyitsma · H6770

    to thirst · v3

    “And (the people) thirsted.” Real bodily thirst in the desert, not a picture for spiritual longing. The verb is singular because the whole people is treated as one body.

  17. שָׁ֤ם

    sham · H8033

    there · v3, v6

    At Rephidim, the camp where “there was no water for the people to drink” (v. 1). It ties the thirst to that dry place and suggests the need was getting worse.

  18. וַיָּ֥לֶן

    vayyalen · H3885B

    to grumble, complain · v3

    “And (the people) grumbled.” This is the special word for the wilderness complaints: open, hostile protest against the leaders, not quiet muttering. In the next verse Moses fears he will be stoned.

  19. עַל־

    'al · H5921A

    upon, against · v3, v6, v7

    “Against.” With this verb the word marks who the complaint is aimed at. It is directed at Moses, though v. 7 shows that in the end it is aimed at God.

  20. זֶּה֙

    zeh · H2088

    this · v3, v4

    Added to “why” to make it stronger: “Why on earth…?” / “Why ever…?” KJV and YLT try to show it (“Wherefore is this”).

  21. הֶעֱלִיתָ֣נוּ

    he'elitanu · H5927

    to go up; (causative) bring up · v3

    “You brought us up.” This is the standard phrase for the exodus, a phrase normally used of God. Here the people say it to Moses, as though the rescue were his idea, and so his fault.

  22. מִמִּצְרַ֔יִם

    mimmitsrayim · H4714

    Egypt · v3

    “From Egypt.” The land of slavery, which in the complaint is now remembered as a place where at least there was water.

  23. לְהָמִ֥ית

    lehamit · H4191

    to die; (causative) to kill · v3

    “To put to death.” The form means “to cause to die,” and the prefix expresses purpose. They charge Moses with planning their deaths, not just making a mistake.

  24. בָּנַ֥י

    banay · H1121A

    son, child · v3, v7

    “My sons/children.” The family line, a household's future. Dying children is the most emotional point of the complaint.

  25. מִקְנַ֖י

    miqnay · H4735

    livestock, property in animals · v3

    “My livestock.” The word comes from a root meaning “acquire.” Flocks and herds were a household's wealth and means of living (Exod 12:38), and they need huge amounts of water.

  26. בַּצָּמָֽא׃

    batstsama' · H6772

    thirst · v3

    “By thirst.” The noun comes from the same root as the verse's first word, so the verse begins and ends with thirst.

  27. וַיִּצְעַ֤ק

    wayyitsʿaq · H6817

    to cry out · v4

    A loud outcry for help from someone in danger, not weeping. It is the same verb used for Israel's cry under Egyptian oppression and at the Red Sea (14:10); now Moses himself is the one in distress, and he takes his case to God.

  28. אֶל־

    ʾel · H0413

    to, toward · v4, v5

    Direction: Moses turns away from the crowd and directs his cry to God. The people complained *against* (ʿal) Moses in v.3; Moses cries *to* (ʾel) the LORD.

  29. אֶעֱשֶׂ֖ה

    ʾeʿĕseh · H6213A

    to do, make · v4, v6

    An unfinished-action verb used here as a question of deliberation: 'what am I to do?' It asks for direction and also says, 'I have run out of options.'

  30. ע֥וֹד

    ʿōd · H5750

    still, yet · v4

    With the next word it forms the idiom 'yet a little,' meaning 'any moment now' or 'just a bit more and…'

  31. מְעַ֖ט

    mĕʿaṭ · H4592

    a little · v4

    Completes the idiom 'yet a little' (compare Hos 1:4; Ps 37:10; Jer 51:33): the danger is imminent, only a short step away.

  32. וּסְקָלֻֽנִי׃

    ūsĕqālūnî · H5619

    to stone · v4

    'And they will stone me.' Stoning was the community's way of putting someone to death for a grave offense, with everyone taking part. Moses fears the crowd is about to treat him as a criminal and execute him. The verb form looks like a past tense but, after 'yet a little,' points to what is about to happen.

  33. עֲבֹר

    ʿăbōr · H5674

    pass, cross over, go on · v5

    A command: 'pass on, go across'. Together with the next word it means 'go on ahead of'. Moses is to walk out in front of the angry crowd in full view, not shelter from it.

  34. לִפְנֵי

    lipnê · H6440

    before (lit. 'to the face of') · v5, v6

    Literally 'to the face of'. It can mean 'ahead of' (leading the way) or 'in the presence of' (in plain sight). Both fit here. In v. 6 God uses the same word of himself: 'I will stand before you there.'

  35. וְקַח

    wəqaḥ · H3947

    and take · v5

    A command: 'and take (along)'. Here it means bringing people with him.

  36. אִתְּךָ

    ʾittəkā · H0854

    with you · v5

    The elders are to go along with Moses, as his company and as witnesses.

  37. מִזִּקְנֵי

    mizziqnê · H2205

    from (some of) the elders of · v5, v6

    The prefix 'from' means 'some of', a chosen group and not every elder. Elders were heads of clans and households who represented the people. In v. 6 they act as eyewitnesses.

  38. יִשְׂרָאֵל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v5, v6, v7

    The tribal people as a whole. The elders stand for all of Israel.

  39. וּמַטְּךָ

    ûmaṭṭəkā · H4294

    and your staff · v5

    Moses' own walking or shepherd's staff (4:2), which had become 'the staff of God' (4:20; 17:9). It is placed first in its clause for emphasis: 'And your staff, the one you struck the Nile with, take it.'

  40. אֲשֶׁר

    ʾăšer · H0834

    which, that · v5

    Introduces the description that marks out which staff is meant: the one with a history.

  41. הִכִּיתָ

    hikkîtā · H5221

    you struck · v5, v6

    'You struck' (a completed past act). This is the same verb used for the plagues on Egypt. In v. 6 Moses is told to 'strike' again, this time the rock.

  42. בּוֹ

    bô · H9033

    with it · v5

    'With it', meaning the staff was the instrument of the striking.

  43. הַיְאֹר

    hayʾōr · H2975

    the Nile, the River · v5

    A word borrowed from Egyptian meaning 'river'. With 'the' it means the Nile. It recalls the first plague, when the struck Nile turned to blood and Egypt 'could not drink' its water (7:17–24).

  44. בְּיָדְךָ

    bəyādəkā · H3027

    in your hand · v5

    In the Hebrew Bible, 'hand' often stands for power and control. The staff is carried openly as a visible sign.

  45. וְהָלָכְתָּ

    wəhālāktā · H1980

    and you shall go · v5

    A verb form that carries the command forward: 'and go'. The verse ends in motion, and the destination is held back until v. 6: the rock at Horeb, where God will be standing.

  46. הִנְנִ֣י

    hinnî · H2005

    look! here I am · v6

    "Look, I…" A pointing word with "I" attached. Put in front of a participle (a verb form for ongoing action), it announces something about to happen: "I am about to be standing." It answers in advance the people's question in v. 7, "Is the LORD among us or not?"

  47. עֹמֵד֩

    ʿōmēd · H5975

    stand, take a position · v6

    Participle, "standing." It describes God already in place, taking up a position at the rock before Moses gets there. The verb is the ordinary one for standing at a post or standing in someone's presence.

  48. הַצּוּר֮

    haṣṣûr · H6697

    rock, crag, rock face · v6

    "The rock." Hebrew says "the," a particular rock face or outcrop at Horeb. Tsur means a big mass of rock, a cliff or crag, not a loose stone. Elsewhere it is also a title for God ("the Rock," Deut 32).

  49. בְּחֹרֵב֒

    bᵊḥōrēb · H2722

    Horeb · v6

    "At Horeb," the name used for the mountain of God (Exod 3:1), which Deuteronomy uses for Sinai. The name probably comes from the root for "dry, desolate," so water from the rock "in Dryland" is fitting, though the text does not point out the wordplay.

  50. וְיָצְא֥וּ

    wᵊyāṣᵊʾû · H3318

    go out, come out · v6

    "And they will come out," plural to match the plural word for water. It is the common verb for going out, the same one used all through Exodus for Israel going out of Egypt.

  51. מִמֶּ֛נּוּ

    mimmennû · H4480

    from · v6

    "From it," from inside the rock itself. The water comes out of the stone. It is not found next to it.

  52. כֵּן֙

    kēn · H3651

    so, thus · v6

    "So," exactly as told. "He did so" is a fixed phrase in the Pentateuch for obedience carried out to the letter. The story does not describe the water gushing out. Moses' obedience and the witnesses are enough.

  53. לְעֵינֵ֖י

    lᵊʿênê · H5869

    eye(s); 'in the sight of' · v6

    "To the eyes of," an idiom for "in full view of." It stresses witnesses: the act was seen by responsible men and was not done in private.

  54. וַיִּקְרָא֙

    vayyiqra · H7121

    and he called · v7

    With 'name', the standard Hebrew idiom for naming. The subject is Moses, the last person named (vv. 4–6). This is the usual way a story ties a place name to the event that produced it.

  55. שֵׁ֣ם

    shem · H8034

    name · v7

    'The name of.' In Israel a place name worked as a memorial. Anyone who said it afterwards would remember what happened there.

  56. הַמָּק֔וֹם

    hammaqom · H4725

    the place · v7

    The spot at Rephidim (v. 1), near 'the rock at Horeb' (v. 6), where the water came out. It is a particular site, not the whole region.

  57. מַסָּ֖ה

    massah · H4532

    Massah ('Testing') · v7

    Built from the verb nasah, 'to test'. To a Hebrew ear the name simply meant 'Testing' or 'Proving'. It looks ahead to 'their testing' later in the verse.

  58. וּמְרִיבָ֑ה

    umerivah · H4809

    and Meribah ('Contention') · v7

    Built from riv, 'to bring a case, contend'. The name meant 'Contention' or 'Dispute', and it echoes 'the riv of the sons of Israel' that comes next.

  59. רִ֣יב׀

    riv · H7379

    dispute, case, contention · v7

    The people's formal complaint against Moses, and through him against God (v. 2: 'the people contended with Moses'). The word carries a legal tone: an accusation, a case brought against someone. It means more than a squabble.

  60. הֲיֵ֧שׁ

    hayesh · H3426

    is there? · v7

    A question marker attached to 'there is'. The question asks whether YHWH is actually present: 'Is YHWH really here?'

  61. בְּקִרְבֵּ֖נוּ

    beqirbenu · H7130

    in our midst · v7

    Literally 'in our inner part / within us', meaning in the middle of the camp. This is the key word in Exodus for God dwelling with his people (25:8; 33:3–5; 34:9).

  62. אִם־

    ʾim- · H518

    or · v7

    Introduces the second half of a two-option question: is it this, or that?

  63. אָֽיִן׃

    ʾayin · H369

    there is not; nothing · v7

    The opposite of yesh. 'Or is there nothing?' The question is put as an all-or-nothing choice, a demand that God prove he is present.

The world behind it
  • The third crisis in a series. Since crossing the sea, Israel has hit bitter water at Marah (15:22–26), hunger in the Desert of Sin (ch. 16), and now no water at Rephidim. Each time God has provided. So this demand comes after repeated proof, not before any.
  • Led there by God. Verse 1 stresses that they moved 'according to the mouth of YHWH', which probably means following the cloud (13:21–22). A dry campsite on God's own route is the background to Moses' reply: blaming the location blames the guide.
  • Water in the desert. For a large group with flocks and herds (v. 3 mentions 'livestock'), a camp without water means death within days. Their fear is real. Water rights and wells were among the most common causes of disputes in that world (Gen 21:25; 26:20–22), and rîv is the very word used for those well-quarrels.
  • The leader as the one responsible. In the ancient Near East a leader or king was expected to secure food and water for his people. The demand 'give us' treats Moses (and probably Aaron) as having taken on that duty by leading them out of Egypt, and v. 3 accuses him of bringing them out to kill them.
  • Where Rephidim was is uncertain. Tradition places it in southern Sinai, often linked with the Wadi Refayid or Wadi Feiran region, but this cannot be confirmed.

From the study of Exodus 17:2.

Where scholars differ

in v2

Who is addressed by the plural 'Give us water'?

  • Moses and Aaron (and possibly the elders) together.

    In 16:2 the people grumble 'against Moses and Aaron', and Aaron is active in this narrative (17:10–12). The Masoretic plural is the harder reading and is likely original.

  • Moses alone. The plural is a loose or generalizing form, or a scribe's change.

    The verse names only Moses, and Moses answers alone ('with me'). The Septuagint and Samaritan Pentateuch have a singular.

in v2

How does this account relate to the Meribah story in Numbers 20:1–13?

  • Two separate events: one at Rephidim early in the journey, one at Kadesh near its end.

    Different locations (Rephidim vs Kadesh), different instructions (strike the rock vs speak to it), and different outcomes (Moses and Aaron are condemned only in Numbers 20). Deut 33:8 and Ps 95 can be read as recalling more than one occasion.

  • Two versions of one remembered tradition, explaining the same place name.

    Both stories involve no water, the people contending (rîv), a rock and a staff, and the name Meribah. Many critical scholars see parallel accounts from different strands of tradition. Deut 33:8 pairs Massah and Meribah as a single memory.

in v2

Was the people's demand itself wrong, or only the way they made it?

  • Their need was legitimate. The fault lay in the hostile accusation and in doubting God's presence.

    God answers at once with no punishment (vv. 5–6). Verse 7 locates the 'testing' in the question 'Is YHWH among us or not?' rather than in asking for water.

  • The demand itself, after so much proof, was faithless.

    This comes right after the provisions at Marah and with the manna. Later texts (Deut 6:16; Ps 78:18–20; Ps 95:8–9) treat Massah as a typical example of unbelief.

in v3

Why does v. 3 repeat the complaint of v. 2 (the people quarrel and ask for water, then thirst and grumble)?

  • Two sources combined. Older source-critical scholarship assigned v. 2 and v. 3 to different strands (often J and E), which would explain the doubled complaint and the extra “there.”

    Duplication with different verbs (*riv* “quarrel” in v. 2, *lun* “grumble” in v. 3), and the place named twice (Massah and Meribah, v. 7). See Childs, *Exodus* (OTL).

  • Deliberate escalation in a single story. The quarrel of v. 2 becomes worse in v. 3 as the thirst deepens (“there”), moving from a demand to an accusation of murder, then a threat of stoning in v. 4.

    The steady rise in intensity across vv. 2–4, and the way the verse is framed by thirst at both ends. Sarna (JPS Torah Commentary) and many literary readers take this view.

in v3

Is the people's complaint itself presented as sin, or only their distrust?

  • The grumbling is rebellion. The *lun* motif describes revolt against God's appointed leaders and so against God.

    Moses: “Why do you test the LORD?” (v. 2). The rebuking place names (v. 7). Deut 6:16; Ps 95:8–11. Coats, *Rebellion in the Wilderness*.

  • The need is presented sympathetically before Sinai. What is condemned is testing God (“Is the LORD among us or not?”), not crying out for water as such.

    v. 1 confirms there really was no water. God provides without punishing anyone in Exod 15–17, unlike the complaints after Sinai in Numbers. Commentators such as Fretheim point to this difference between before and after Sinai.

in v4

Is Moses asking for help, or complaining against God?

  • Mainly a legitimate appeal for help and direction.

    *Tsāʿaq* is the normal word for a rightful appeal to a protector. God answers at once with instructions (v.5) and no rebuke. Elsewhere Moses' crying out is followed by God's help (15:25).

  • An appeal colored by complaint and frustration with the people (and perhaps with God).

    The distancing phrase 'this people' and the parallel with Num 11:11–15, where Moses openly complains about the burden God has put on him, suggest exasperation. The question 'what shall I do' also hints that the problem is really God's to solve.

in v4

Is the episode framed as a kind of trial?

  • Yes: the scene uses legal language and procedure.

    The people 'contend' (*rîb*, a legal-dispute word) and accuse Moses of trying to kill them. Moses fears communal execution. God has Moses take elders as witnesses and the staff, and God 'stands before' him (v.6). Commentators such as Propp (Anchor Bible) and Childs discuss these legal overtones.

  • The legal tone is incidental; it is a straightforward provision story.

    *Rîb* can simply mean 'quarrel.' Elders often accompany Moses on official occasions. The narrative's main focus is the miracle of water and the naming of the place (v.7), not trial procedure.

in v5

Why is Moses told to 'pass before the people'?

  • Practical leadership: he simply walks ahead to lead them to the rock.

    ʿābar lipnê commonly means 'go on ahead' (Gen 32:16[17]). Verse 6 gives a destination, the rock at Horeb.

  • Public exposure that answers Moses' fear and corrects his complaint about the people.

    The command comes right after 'they will stone me' (v. 4). The Mekhilta and Rashi read it as 'pass before them and see whether they stone you', with God objecting to Moses speaking ill of Israel.

  • A public vindication of Moses' authority.

    The elders as witnesses (v. 6), the staff of the plagues, and the legal language of 'quarrel' (rîb) in v. 2 and v. 7 all point to a public settling of the dispute.

in v5

Is vv. 5–6 shaped like a trial scene, and if so, who is 'struck'?

  • Yes: the staff of judgment, elders as witnesses, and a 'lawsuit' (rîb) suggest a legal scene. Because God stands on the rock Moses strikes, some interpreters see God taking the blow himself.

    rîb in vv. 2 and 7. The elders as witnesses. The staff is the plague instrument. 'I will stand before you there upon the rock' (v. 6). This is suggestive literary reading rather than explicit statement.

  • No: the scene is a miracle of provision, and the legal overtones are secondary.

    The text never says God is struck. 'Standing before' someone can simply mean being present or attending (compare 1 Kgs 17:1). The emphasis falls on water for the people and on God's presence in answer to v. 7.

in v6

What does it mean that God will stand "before you … on the rock"?

  • A statement of presence: God, perhaps visibly in the cloud, takes his place at the rock so the water is clearly his act.

    The cloud pillar has been with Israel since 13:21–22. Verse 7's question "Is the LORD among us?" is answered by God being there. Most commentators (e.g. Childs, Sarna) take it this way.

  • A reversal of rank: God, the superior, "stands before" his servant, which shows unusual closeness and support for Moses.

    "Stand before" normally describes a person standing before a superior (Deut 10:8; 1 Kgs 17:1). Rabbinic commentators were also struck by this phrasing.

  • A courtroom reading: in a dispute (*rîb*) staged with witnesses and the staff of judgment, God stands where the blow falls, so the strike lands where God is.

    The legal vocabulary (quarrel, test, elders as witnesses) and "on the rock" fit together. But the text never says God is struck. This reading is an inference by some modern interpreters and should be held loosely.

in v6

Why is Horeb named when the camp is at Rephidim (17:1)?

  • Horeb is the name of the wider region or mountain range, and Rephidim lay within or near it.

    "Horeb" can refer to more than one peak. Exodus 18:5 has Moses camped "at the mountain of God" before ch. 19.

  • The chapter weaves together traditions, and the name Horeb links this story to the mountain of God, so the geography is not tidy.

    Arrival at Sinai is narrated only in 19:1–2. Source-critical commentators (e.g. Propp, Childs) see different traditions behind the place names.

in v6

Are Exodus 17:1–7 and Numbers 20:2–13 the same event?

  • Two separate events: early in the journey and near its end, with different instructions (strike / speak) and different outcomes.

    Different settings (Rephidim vs. Kadesh), different words for the rock (*tsur* vs. *selaʿ*), and Moses is judged only in Numbers 20.

  • Two forms of one tradition about Meribah, each retold for its own purpose.

    Both are named Meribah, both involve quarreling over water and a staff striking a rock. Many critical scholars treat them as variants of one story.

in v7

Is this the same 'Meribah' as in Numbers 20, and were Massah and Meribah originally one story?

  • Two separate episodes that share a theme. The names came out of Israel's contending, and the same theme recurs later at Kadesh.

    Exodus 17 is set at Rephidim near Horeb, early in the journey. Numbers 20 is set at Kadesh decades later, where Moses himself fails (20:12) and the place is called 'Meribah of Kadesh' (Num 27:14; Deut 32:51), which seems to distinguish it from this site. A recurring name is natural when a recurring sin produces it.

  • Two traditions (or two place names) that have been combined. Critical scholars often attribute them to different sources.

    The double name is unusual. Deut 9:22 lists Massah on its own, and Deut 33:8 sets 'Massah' and 'Meribah' in parallel as if they were distinct but related. Some scholars (e.g. Noth, and discussed by Childs) take the Exodus and Numbers accounts as versions of one water-from-the-rock tradition.

  • Literary unity within Exodus 17.

    Verse 2 already pairs the two verbs ('Why do you contend [riv] with me? Why do you test [nasah] YHWH?'), and v. 7 takes them up one by one. This suggests the double name is a deliberate two-part memorial, whatever its earlier history (Sarna, Propp).

in v7

Who tested whom at Massah/Meribah?

  • Israel tested God. This is the plain claim of Exod 17:7.

    'Because they tested YHWH' (17:7). Echoed in Deut 6:16, Ps 95:9 and Ps 78:18, 41.

  • The tradition also remembered God testing Israel (or Levi) at the same place.

    Ps 81:7: 'I tested you at the waters of Meribah'. Deut 33:8: of Levi, 'whom you tested at Massah, with whom you contended at the waters of Meribah'. This fits the 'God tests Israel' pattern of Exod 15:25 and 16:4. Most interpreters see the two views as complementary: the episode was a test in both directions.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. רִיב
  • BDB s.v. רִיב
  • HALOT s.v. נסה
  • BDB s.v. נָסָה
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §47m (paragogic nun)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 17:2
  • Vulgate, Exodus 17:2
  • Brevard S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL), on Exod 17:1–7
  • William H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Exod 17
  • Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied data)
  • BDB s.v. לוּן II, צָמֵא, מִקְנֶה
  • HALOT s.v. לון, עלה (hiphil), מות (hiphil)
  • G. W. Coats, Rebellion in the Wilderness (1968)
  • B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL, 1974)
  • N. M. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary, 1991)
  • W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible, 1999)
  • T. E. Fretheim, Exodus (Interpretation, 1991)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 17:3
  • Vulgate, Exodus 17:3
  • BDB s.v. צָעַק, סָקַל, עוֹד, מְעַט
  • HALOT s.v. צעק, סקל
  • G. Hasel, 'zāʿaq/ṣāʿaq', Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, vol. 4
  • H. J. Boecker, Redeformen des Rechtslebens im Alten Testament (on the legal 'cry for help')
  • W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible)
  • B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (Old Testament Library)
  • Septuagint, Exodus 17:4 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Exodus 17:4
  • BDB s.v. עָבַר, מַטֶּה, זָקֵן, יְאֹר, נָכָה
  • HALOT s.v. מַטֶּה; יְאֹר (Egyptian loanword itrw)
  • Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Vayassa (on Exod 17:5)
  • Rashi on Exodus 17:5
  • J. I. Durham, Exodus (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 17:1–7
  • Septuaginta, ed. Rahlfs, Exod 17:5
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Exod 17:5
  • BDB s.v. צוּר, נָכָה, עָמַד, זָקֵן
  • HALOT s.v. צוּר; חֹרֵב
  • Brevard S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL), on 17:1–7
  • Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus, on 17:1–7
  • Septuagint, Exodus 17:6
  • Vulgate, Exodus 17:6
  • Pseudo-Philo, Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum 10:7; 11:15
  • Tosefta Sukkah 3:11–13 (the well that followed Israel)
  • 1 Corinthians 10:4; Psalm 78:15–20; 105:41; 114:8; Deuteronomy 8:15; Numbers 20:2–13
  • BDB s.v. ריב, נסה, מַסָּה, קֶרֶב, יֵשׁ, אַיִן
  • HALOT s.v. ריב, נסה, מְרִיבָה, מַסָּה, קֶרֶב
  • J. Limburg, 'The Root ריב and the Prophetic Lawsuit Speeches,' JBL 88 (1969)
  • B. S. Childs, The Book of Exodus (OTL)
  • N. M. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 17
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exod 17:7; Ps 94:8 LXX
  • Vulgate, Exod 17:7
  • Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Amalek 1; Rashi on Exod 17:8

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).