Exodus Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Exodus 5:7–18
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
7“You shall no longer supply the people with straw for making bricks. They must go and gather their own straw. 8But require of them the same quota of bricks as before; do not reduce it. For they are lazy; that is why they are crying out, ‘Let us go and sacrifice to our God.’ 9Make the work harder on the men so they will be occupied and pay no attention to these lies.” 10So the taskmasters and foremen of the people went out and said to them, “This is what Pharaoh says: ‘I am no longer giving you straw. 11Go and get your own straw wherever you can find it; but your workload will in no way be reduced.’” 12So the people scattered all over the land of Egypt to gather stubble for straw. 13The taskmasters kept pressing them, saying, “Fulfill your quota each day, just as you did when straw was provided.” 14Then the Israelite foremen, whom Pharaoh’s taskmasters had set over the people, were beaten and asked, “Why have you not fulfilled your quota of bricks yesterday or today, as you did before?” 15So the Israelite foremen went and appealed to Pharaoh: “Why are you treating your servants this way? 16No straw has been given to your servants, yet we are told, ‘Make bricks!’ Look, your servants are being beaten, but the fault is with your own people.” 17“You are slackers!” Pharaoh replied. “Slackers! That is why you keep saying, ‘Let us go and sacrifice to the LORD.’ 18Now get to work. You will be given no straw, yet you must deliver the full quota of bricks.”
What the first hearers heard
Israelites hearing this story knew mud brick, quotas and forced labour (Solomon's corvée, a system of compulsory state labour, was later remembered with bitterness, 1 Kgs 12). They would have heard the verse as the first turn of the screw in a contest between Pharaoh and Yahweh. Moses has just demanded, in Yahweh's name, "Let my people go" (5:1). Pharaoh replies, "Who is Yahweh?" (5:2), and answers with a work order. The verse shows how oppression works through administration. Nothing is said about cruelty as such. A supply line is cut, the quota stays the same (5:8), and the system grinds the people down while the blame falls on the Israelite foremen (5:14-16), who then turn on Moses (5:21).
Several details would have registered with hearers of the Hebrew:
- The play on "go." Moses asks that the people go to worship; Pharaoh lets them go, but only to scavenge. The king who will later be forced to say "Go!" (12:31) here grants a mocking version of it.
- "The people." Pharaoh speaks of "the people" as a labour pool; Yahweh calls them "my people." Whose people they are, and whom they serve, is the question the whole book of Exodus answers. The Hebrew word for "work" or "serve" (avad) covers both slave labour for Pharaoh and worship of Yahweh.
- Stubble. The people sent out to gather stubble (qash, 5:12) are later avenged when Yahweh's fury consumes Pharaoh's army "like stubble" (qash, 15:7).
The scene sets up the deliverance by first making things worse. Moses' intervention brings Israel more misery, not relief (5:22-23). That raises the question chapter 6 answers: whether Yahweh will keep his promise.
From the study of Exodus 5:7.
Verse by verse
-
7“You shall no longer supply the people with straw for making bricks. They must go and gather their own straw.
Full study →"You are not to go on issuing straw to the people for brick-making, the way it has been done up to now. They themselves can go out and scrape together their own straw."
The order is Pharaoh's, given the same day Moses asked that Israel be allowed to go into the wilderness to worship. It is addressed to the Egyptian slave-drivers and the Israelite foremen under them. In the Hebrew it sounds like a formal decree. "You shall not add to give" is the Hebrew way of saying "never again," and the verb carries a weighty, emphatic ending. Until now the workers had been supplied with chopped straw from the threshing floors to knead into their sun-dried mud bricks. That supply now stops for good. Pharaoh does not say the bricks can be made without straw. Straw is still needed: the verse begins and ends with the word. What changes is who provides it. An emphatic "they" shifts the burden from the state to the slaves. The verb for gathering is a scrounging word, used for picking up sticks and stubble. It pictures people scattering over harvested fields for scraps (v. 12 says they gathered "stubble for straw"). There is a bitter twist on the word "go." Moses asked that the people go to sacrifice; Pharaoh lets them go, but only to forage. Then the next verse delivers the blow: the daily brick count stays exactly what it was "yesterday and the day before."
-
8But require of them the same quota of bricks as before; do not reduce it. For they are lazy; that is why they are crying out, ‘Let us go and sacrifice to our God.’
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
9Make the work harder on the men so they will be occupied and pay no attention to these lies.”
Full study →Pharaoh is speaking to his slave-drivers and foremen: "Let the labor lie heavy on these men. Keep them bent over it, doing it and nothing else, so they have no eyes left to turn toward these empty, deceiving words."
Several things in the Hebrew sit underneath that:
- "Heavy" (kaved) is the word the story will soon use for Pharaoh's own stubborn "heavy" heart, for the "heavy" plagues that hit Egypt, and for the "glory" (literally "weightiness") God wins over Pharaoh. The weight Pharaoh puts on Israel will come back on him.
- "The labor" ('avodah) also means "service" and even "worship". Moses has just asked that Israel be allowed to go and serve their God with sacrifice and a feast. Pharaoh's answer is more service to Pharaoh. The two masters are competing for the same word.
- "Pay attention" is literally "gaze at" or "look to": the look of someone turning hopefully toward help. Pharaoh's plan is to wear people out so badly that they cannot even look up toward hope.
- "Lies" is Pharaoh's name for a message that began "Thus says the LORD." Ancient hearers would catch the irony: the king calls God's word a lie. One verse later his officials go out saying "Thus says Pharaoh."
The logic is chillingly practical. People who are crushed with work don't organize, don't hope, and don't listen to talk of freedom.
-
10So the taskmasters and foremen of the people went out and said to them, “This is what Pharaoh says: ‘I am no longer giving you straw.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
11Go and get your own straw wherever you can find it; but your workload will in no way be reduced.’”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
12So the people scattered all over the land of Egypt to gather stubble for straw.
Full study →So the people broke apart and spread out across the whole of Egypt's farmland, scraping up stubble to use as straw.
The verse records what Pharaoh's order in 5:7–11 did to people. The workers had been given chopped straw, the short threshing-floor waste mixed into brick clay to bind it. Now they had to find their own, with no cut in their daily brick quota. So the work gang dispersed. Hebrew uses the same verb for flocks with no shepherd, for the builders of Babel, and later for Israel in exile. A people meant to stay together is being pulled apart under a foreign king.
What they could find was not proper straw. It was stubble: dry stalks left in the harvested fields, which the Bible elsewhere uses as a picture of worthless stuff that burns or blows away. Hebrew makes the drudgery audible with a sound-play, ləqōšēš qaš, roughly "to stubble-gather stubble." The verb is used elsewhere for a poor widow picking up sticks. Skilled brickmakers are reduced to gleaners in other people's fields, and they still have to cut the stubble down to something usable "for the straw." Readers of Exodus will hear the word again at the sea, where Pharaoh's army is burned up "like stubble" (15:7).
-
13The taskmasters kept pressing them, saying, “Fulfill your quota each day, just as you did when straw was provided.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
14Then the Israelite foremen, whom Pharaoh’s taskmasters had set over the people, were beaten and asked, “Why have you not fulfilled your quota of bricks yesterday or today, as you did before?”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
15So the Israelite foremen went and appealed to Pharaoh: “Why are you treating your servants this way?
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
16No straw has been given to your servants, yet we are told, ‘Make bricks!’ Look, your servants are being beaten, but the fault is with your own people.”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
17“You are slackers!” Pharaoh replied. “Slackers! That is why you keep saying, ‘Let us go and sacrifice to the LORD.’
Full study →Pharaoh answered the Israelite foremen with a sneer: "Slack! You've gone slack, that's what you are, slack! That's the only reason you keep coming back with this line: 'Let us go off and slaughter offerings to Yahweh.'"
The word Pharaoh throws at them pictures something drooping and gone limp: hands that have let go of the work. He says it twice, wrapped around an emphatic "you," the way someone repeats an insult to rub it in. It is also exactly what he said about them behind their backs in 5:8, so his verdict was settled before they ever came to complain. The foremen had just protested that they were being beaten for a quota no one could meet, and that the fault lay with Pharaoh's own people (v.16). Pharaoh flips the blame. They are not mistreated, he says. They are lazy, and their talk of worship proves it.
"That is why" makes their religion a symptom: only men with too much free time dream up festivals. The form of "you keep saying" shows a request made again and again. He then mimics their own words, a clipped "let us go, let us sacrifice." What they asked for was a pilgrimage feast with animals slaughtered and eaten before their God in the wilderness, not a day off. Pharaoh uses the divine name only to quote it back with contempt, the name of a god he had said a few verses earlier he did not know (5:2). In the next breath he hurls their "go" back at them: "Go now, work!" (v.18). The reader is left with the irony the whole book is built on: whom will Israel serve, and who is this Yahweh?
-
18Now get to work. You will be given no straw, yet you must deliver the full quota of bricks.”
Full study →"So then — go, serve! Straw will not be given to you. But the fixed count of bricks — that you will hand over."
This is Pharaoh's verdict on the Israelite foremen, delivered right after he called them "slackers" (v.17). Every phrase cuts:
- "Go, serve" throws Israel's own request back at them. They had asked, "Let us go and sacrifice to the LORD." Pharaoh says "Go," and means back to the brick pits. He says "serve," using the Hebrew word that also means worship, and means serve me. English "get to work" is correct but hides the taunt. Later in Exodus Pharaoh will speak these same two words again, defeated, adding "the LORD": "Go, serve the LORD" (10:8; 12:31).
- "Straw will not be given to you" comes first in its clause for emphasis ("As for straw..."). Chopped straw was the binder mixed into Nile mud. The state used to supply it, and now that supply ends for good.
- "The measure of bricks you will give" uses an official's word for a measured, checked quantity: the daily quota, counted and enforced with beatings (v.14, 19).
- The same verb, give, opens and closes the verse: nothing will be given to you, yet you will give. All the giving now flows from the slaves to the state.
The task was not impossible. It was doubled: find your own straw by gathering stubble from the fields (v.12), and still hit yesterday's number.
Where the English drifted
-
in v7
bricks
levenim
- What we hear
- Hard red blocks fired in a kiln, like modern building bricks.
- What they heard
- Mud bricks made from Nile silt, usually tempered with chopped straw, shaped in a mould and dried in the sun. Firing was the exception (Gen 11:3 notes it specially for Babel).
-
in v7
straw
teven
- What we hear
- Long dry stalks or bales of hay, often assumed to be a minor filler.
- What they heard
- Chopped straw and chaff from the threshing floor, a processed by-product kneaded into brick mud as a standard ingredient.
-
in v9
vain words (KJV)
divrei sheqer
- What we hear
- Boastful, self-admiring words.
- What they heard
- Deceptive, empty, groundless words: talk with nothing true behind it.
-
in v12
straw
teben
- What we hear
- Long dry stalks or bales of hay, the kind used for animal bedding.
- What they heard
- Chopped, broken straw from the threshing floor, a by-product of threshing grain. It was used as fodder and as a binding material mixed into brick mud.
-
in v17
sacrifice
zavach
- What we hear
- To give something up at personal cost, as in 'make sacrifices.'
- What they heard
- To slaughter an animal as an offering, normally followed by a festive meal eaten before God. Here it is part of a requested pilgrimage feast.
-
in v17
the LORD
YHWH (Yahweh)
- What we hear
- A general title for God.
- What they heard
- The personal name of Israel's God, the very name Pharaoh dismissed in 5:2 ('Who is Yahweh? I do not know Yahweh'). He is quoting it as the name of a foreign slave people's god.
-
in v18
the tale of bricks (KJV)
tokhen levenim
- What we hear
- A "tale" sounds like a story or account, as if Pharaoh wanted a report about the bricks.
- What they heard
- The measured, counted quantity of bricks: the daily quota.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v7
Pharaoh didn't demand bricks without straw
- What's often taught
- Exodus 5 is often summed up, in sermons and in the proverb "making bricks without straw," as Pharaoh forcing Israel to make bricks with no straw at all, an impossible task with no materials.
- What the text supports
The verse and its context say something more specific, and in a way harsher. Straw is still required: the verse ends with the word teven. What Pharaoh withdraws is the supply: "you shall no longer give straw… they must go and gather straw for themselves" (5:7; again in 5:10-11, "get your straw yourselves wherever you can find it"). The people do exactly that, scattering across Egypt "to gather stubble for straw" (5:12), while the quota stays the same as "yesterday and the day before" (5:8, 13-14).
The popular reading is partly right. From the workers' point of view, "no straw is given" (5:16, 18), and the task really is impossible to complete in the time allowed. But the oppression is not an absurd demand for strawless bricks. It is the realistic tactic of cutting off materials and pushing the cost of finding them onto the workers, while keeping their output fixed.
in v18
'Bricks without straw' wasn't actually the order
- What's often taught
- Pharaoh ordered the Israelites to make bricks with no straw at all, an impossible task. This is where the English idiom "to make bricks without straw" comes from: being made to produce something with none of the materials it needs.
- What the text supports
The decree was not "make bricks with no straw." It was "no straw will be given to you." Verse 7 spells it out: "let them go and gather straw for themselves." Verse 12 shows them scattering "throughout all the land of Egypt to gather stubble for straw." The bricks still had straw in them. What changed was who had to get it.
The oppression was a doubled workload: forage your own materials and still meet the same counted quota (tokhen, v.18; "do not reduce," v.19). That is grinding administrative cruelty rather than a literally impossible command, and it fits what Egyptian records show about brick quotas and shortfalls. The popular reading is right that the demand was unjust and crushing. It just misses what the demand actually was.
- Where the English feeds it
- The idiom "bricks without straw" became proverbial in English (possibly shaped by the KJV's "there shall no straw be given you" in v.18). It is often taken as a summary of the story, even though the passive "be given" in the text is about supply, not about the bricks' ingredients.
Every word
-
לֹ֣א
lo' · H3808
not · v7, v18
The plain negative of a firm prohibition. With the following verb it forms a flat command to the officials: this is not to happen any more.
-
תֹאסִפ֞וּן
tosifun · H3254
add, do again, continue · v7
Literally "you shall not add (to do)": Hebrew says "no longer" by saying "do not keep on adding." The extra -n ending is an older, fuller verb form that gives the decree a solemn, emphatic ring.
-
לָתֵ֨ת
latet · H5414
give · v7, v18
"To give." Straw had until now been issued to the workers, presumably from state stores. That supply is what Pharaoh stops.
-
תֶּ֧בֶן
teven · H8401
straw (chopped) · v7, v12, v18
Chopped straw and chaff left over from threshing grain, used as animal fodder and mixed into brick mud as a binder. It was processed material, not raw stalks in the field.
-
לָעָ֛ם
la'am · H5971
people · v7, v12
"To the people," meaning the Israelite labour force. In this chapter Pharaoh keeps calling them "the people," while Yahweh's demand in 5:1 calls them "my people." The difference between the two names is the conflict in small.
-
לִלְבֹּ֥ן
lilbon · H3835
make bricks · v7
A verb made from the noun "brick": "to brick." It is rare in the Bible (also Gen 11:3) and paired here with its own noun.
-
הַלְּבֵנִ֖ים
hallevenim · H3843
brick · v7, v18
"The bricks": the definite article points to the familiar, assigned bricks of the daily quota (5:8). These were moulded mud bricks dried in the sun, not kiln-fired.
-
כִּתְמ֣וֹל
kitmol · H8543
yesterday · v7
"As yesterday." It is the first half of a fixed idiom meaning "as before, as up to now."
-
שִׁלְשֹׁ֑ם
shilshom · H8032
day before yesterday, formerly · v7
Literally "the third day (back)." Together with "yesterday" it means "previously, as has been the practice." It marks a break with the established routine.
-
הֵ֚ם
hem · H1992
they · v7
An emphatic "they," which Hebrew does not need for grammar. It sets the workers against the officials ("you"): you will not supply it; they themselves must.
-
יֵֽלְכ֔וּ
yelkhu · H1980
-
וְקֹשְׁשׁ֥וּ
veqoshshu · H7197
gather stubble, scrape together · v7, v12
A verb built from qash, "stubble," meaning to pick up scraps of plant matter bit by bit. It is used elsewhere of gathering sticks (Num 15:32; 1 Kgs 17:10). It pictures slow, scattered, demeaning foraging. Joined by "and" to "let them go," it continues the command: "and let them gather."
-
לָהֶ֖ם
lahem · H9038
for them(selves) · v7
"For themselves": they supply their own material, on their own time, at their own cost.
-
תִּכְבַּ֧ד
tikhbad · H3513
be heavy, weighty · v9
A command in the form 'let it be heavy': Pharaoh orders the labor to weigh more on the workers. The same root later describes Pharaoh's own 'heavy' (stubborn) heart and the 'glory' (weightiness) God wins over him, so the word starts a thread that runs through the whole story.
-
הָעֲבֹדָ֛ה
ha'avodah · H5656
work, labor, service · v9
'The labor': the forced brick-making service owed to Pharaoh. In Exodus the same word also names the service and worship Israel owes to God (Exod 12:25–26), so the real question of the story is whose service Israel will do.
-
עַל־
'al · H5921
upon, on · v9, v17
'Upon': the work is pictured as a load set on top of the men, which fits the 'heavy' picture of the verb.
-
הָאֲנָשִׁ֖ים
ha'anashim · H582
men, people · v9
'The men': the Israelite laborers, spoken of in the third person, as a workforce to be managed rather than as people to be answered.
-
וְיַעֲשׂוּ־
veya'asu · H6213
-
בָ֑הּ
vah
in it, at it · v9
'At it': the feminine 'it' points back to 'the labor'. They are to be absorbed in it, with no time or energy left over.
-
וְאַל־
ve'al · H408
and not (in a wish or ban) · v9
'And let them not': the negative used with wishes and prohibitions, so the second half is a goal Pharaoh means to reach: shutting down their attention.
-
יִשְׁע֖וּ
yish'u · H8159
look at, gaze, regard, look to · v9
'Let them not look at / pay heed to': more than hearing. The word means turning your gaze toward something with interest, hope or trust (God 'looked with favor' on Abel, Gen 4:4; people 'look to' their Maker, Isa 17:7). Pharaoh wants them unable to look toward hope.
-
בְּדִבְרֵי־
bedivrei · H1697
word, matter, message · v9
'At words of': the message Moses and Aaron brought, which began 'Thus says the LORD' (5:1). Pharaoh describes God's word as just more 'words'.
-
שָֽׁקֶר׃
shaqer · H8267
lie, falsehood, deception, empty thing · v9
'Falsehood': in Pharaoh's mouth, a claim that the message is baseless and misleading, a story with nothing behind it. The narrator expects the reader to see the irony: these 'lies' are the LORD's own words.
-
וַיָּ֥פֶץ
wayyāpeṣ · H6327
and (it) scattered, dispersed · v12
The usual Hebrew way of moving a story forward: 'so then they scattered.' The people spread out by their own movement, but Pharaoh's order drove them to it. The word pictures a group that had been together in one place breaking apart and spreading out.
-
בְּכָל־
bəkol · H3605
in all, throughout · v12
'In all of' or 'throughout.' It stresses how wide the search had to go. Somewhat exaggerated, as storytellers do, but the point is real: the stubble close at hand soon ran out.
-
אֶ֣רֶץ
ʾereṣ · H776
land, country · v12
Here it means the territory of Egypt, the farmed land along the Nile, not the whole planet.
-
מִצְרָ֑יִם
miṣrāyim · H4714
Egypt · v12
Egypt as a country. The people who had been settled in Goshen (Gen 47:27) are now strung out across their oppressor's farmland.
-
קַ֖שׁ
qaš · H7179
-
וַיֹּ֛אמֶר
vayyomer · H0559
and he said · v17
The usual verb for moving the story along. The subject, Pharaoh, is left unstated because he was the one addressed in v.16. BSB and WEB supply 'Pharaoh' to make this clear.
-
נִרְפִּ֥ים
nirpim · H7503
slack, lazy, idle · v17
A plural verbal form that describes a state: 'gone slack, let loose.' The root pictures something that sinks, droops or loosens, like hands hanging down. Pharaoh uses it as an insult: men who have gone soft about their work.
-
אַתֶּ֖ם
attem · H0859D
you (plural) · v17
An emphatic 'you'. Hebrew does not need the pronoun, so including it points the finger: 'you, you are the slackers.' The foremen had just said the fault lay with Pharaoh's own people (v.16), and he turns the blame back on them.
-
כֵּן֙
ken · H3651C
so, thus · v17
Completes 'al-ken', 'that is why.' Pharaoh presents their religious request as a symptom of laziness, and their laziness as the cause.
-
נִזְבְּחָ֥ה
nizbechah · H2076
let us sacrifice (by slaughter) · v17
A second 'let us' set right beside the first with no 'and', which gives it a clipped, mocking rhythm. The verb means to slaughter an animal as an offering, usually followed by a sacred meal or feast (5:1 calls it a 'festival').
-
לַֽיהוָֽה׃
la-YHWH · H3068G
to Yahweh · v17
The personal name of Israel's God, joined to 'to.' In 5:2 Pharaoh said, 'Who is Yahweh? I do not know Yahweh.' Here he says the name only to quote it back as a slave's excuse.
-
וְעַתָּה֙
ve'attah · H6258
and now · v18
Not just a time word. It marks the turn from Pharaoh's accusation ("You are slackers!", v.17) to his ruling: "So then..." It works like a judge's "therefore" before the sentence is read out.
-
עִבְד֔וּ
ʿivdu · H5647
serve, work, labor (plural command) · v18
The verb means work done for a master, and it is also the ordinary word for serving (worshiping) a god. Israel asked to serve the LORD. Pharaoh orders them to serve, meaning to keep laboring for him. The question of whom Israel serves runs through the whole book of Exodus.
-
לָכֶ֑ם
lakhem · H9036
to you (plural) · v18
Addressed to the Israelite foremen (v.15) as representatives of the whole workforce. The plural takes in all the brickmakers.
-
וְתֹ֥כֶן
vetokhen · H8506
and the measure / fixed amount of · v18
A measured, set quantity, from a root meaning "to weigh, measure, regulate." Here it is the counted daily quota. In v.8 Pharaoh used a related word (matkonet) for the same quota. The "and" here reads as "yet."
The world behind it
Mud-brick economy. Egypt built most of its houses, storehouses, fortresses and enclosure walls from mud brick: Nile silt mixed with water and usually chopped straw or chaff, pressed into a wooden mould and left to dry in the sun. The straw helped the brick hold together and reduced cracking as it dried. Brickmaking was organised as gang labour with daily quotas. A painting in the tomb of the vizier Rekhmire at Thebes (15th century BC) shows foreign workers fetching water, mixing, moulding and stacking bricks while overseers stand by with rods. A leather roll from Ramesses II's reign (now in the Louvre) records brick targets for work teams and notes shortfalls. Official letters from the same era complain about shortages of both workers and straw.
Where straw came from. Straw was a by-product of threshing grain, so it piled up at estate and temple threshing floors and granaries. The state could issue it to work gangs as part of their materials. Without that issue, workers had to go to fields already harvested and collect stubble (qash, 5:12), then cut and prepare it themselves. That took time away from moulding bricks.
Who is being addressed. The nogesim (5:6) were Egyptian slave-drivers. The shoterim were Israelite foremen responsible for their own people's output, and they are the ones beaten when the quota fails (5:14). Pharaoh's stated reasoning is that the Israelites are "lazy" (5:8) and that heavier work will stop them listening to "lying words" (5:9), meaning Moses' message from Yahweh. Withdrawing the straw is meant to break a movement as well as to punish.
From the study of Exodus 5:7.
Where scholars differ
in v9
What exactly is Pharaoh trying to prevent with 'let them not look at' (sha'ah)?
-
Simple attention: keep them too busy to listen to Moses' talk.
Context of overwork (5:8–9), and translations such as 'pay attention' and 'regard'. The LXX's 'be concerned with' also points to mental attention.
-
Hopeful reliance: keep them from looking to the promise for deliverance.
Elsewhere sha'ah often means looking to someone with favor or trust (Gen 4:4–5; Isa 17:7; 31:1). The Vulgate's 'give assent' points the same way, and 6:9 shows broken hope as the result.
in v12
What does 'for the straw' (lattēben) mean: 'to use as straw' or 'instead of straw'?
-
Purpose: they gathered stubble to serve as or to make straw. It would have to be chopped and used as temper in the brick mix.
The lamed most naturally marks purpose ('for'). BSB, WEB, ESV and NIV read it this way. It also fits the earlier order to 'gather straw for themselves' (5:7).
-
Substitution: they gathered stubble in place of straw, an inferior replacement.
KJV 'instead of straw'. The two materials really are different: field stubble is not threshing-floor teben. Either way the practical sense is much the same: a worse material that cost more work.
in v17
Was the request for a three-day journey to sacrifice (5:3), which Pharaoh mocks here, sincere or a tactic?
-
A genuine but deliberately modest request, meant to show how hard Pharaoh's heart is: he refuses even a small, reasonable petition.
God told Moses to ask this (3:18). Worship 'on this mountain' was the promised sign (3:12). Leave for religious duty was known in Egypt (Deir el-Medina absence records). Commentators such as Cassuto and Sarna stress the reasonableness of the request.
-
A strategic understatement of the real goal, which was full departure. Pharaoh's suspicion is therefore not entirely unfounded, even though his 'laziness' charge is a slander.
The goal of leaving for the land is already stated in 3:8, 17. Pharaoh's later haggling over who and what may go (10:8–11, 24–26) shows he understood more was at stake. Propp and others discuss this as a shrewd ploy of a familiar kind in ancient storytelling.
in v18
What did straw actually do in Egyptian mud bricks, and how much did losing it matter?
-
Mainly a binder that holds the brick together and reduces cracking and shrinkage as it dries.
Analyses of ancient Egyptian bricks often find chopped straw or chaff. Modern experiments with traditional adobe show that fibre reduces cracking. On this view the problem in Exodus 5 was time and labor, since the workers still needed straw and had to find it themselves (v.7, 12).
-
Straw also changed the clay chemically, making it easier to work and stronger.
Early 20th-century experiments (E. G. Acheson) claimed that substances from straw steeped in clay increased its plasticity, and some popular commentaries repeat this. The claim is less firmly established and is not needed to make sense of the text.
-
Straw was useful but not essential, since some Egyptian bricks contain little or none.
Surviving bricks vary, and some are made with sand or other tempers. Even so, the text assumes straw was part of the normal process (v.7 "as before"), and the issue is the extra labor of getting it, not whether bricks could be made at all.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. תֶּבֶן, קשׁשׁ, לבן II, לְבֵנָה, יסף, תְּמוֹל, שִׁלְשֹׁם
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (Kautzsch–Cowley) §47m on the paragogic nun
- W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 1–18 (Anchor Bible)
- K. A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (on brickmaking texts: Louvre Leather Roll, Papyrus Anastasi IV)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exodus 5
- A. J. Spencer, Brick Architecture in Ancient Egypt
- Tomb of Rekhmire (Theban Tomb 100), brickmaking scenes
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate, Exodus 5:7
- BDB s.v. כָּבֵד, עֲבֹדָה, שָׁעָה, שֶׁקֶר
- HALOT s.v. שׁעה I, שֶׁקֶר
- Septuagint, Exodus 5:9 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Exodus 5:9
- K. A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Egyptian brick quotas, Louvre Leather Roll, Deir el-Medina absence records)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Exodus 5
- N. Sarna, Exodus (JPS Torah Commentary)
- BDB s.v. פּוּץ, קָשַׁשׁ, קַשׁ, תֶּבֶן
- HALOT s.v. פוץ; קשׁשׁ; תֶּבֶן
- K. A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Egyptian brickmaking, Louvre Leather Roll, Papyrus Anastasi)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 5:6–19
- N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus, on 5:7–12
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exod 5:12
- BDB s.v. רָפָה
- HALOT s.v. רפה
- BDB s.v. זָבַח
- HALOT s.v. זבח
- Ostracon British Museum EA 5634 (Deir el-Medina absence register)
- N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
- U. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Exodus
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 5:17
- Vulgate, Exodus 5:17
- BDB s.v. תֹּכֶן, תכן
- HALOT s.v. עבד, תֶּבֶן, תֹּכֶן, לְבֵנָה
- K. A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Louvre Leather Roll; Papyrus Anastasi brick and straw complaints)
- J. K. Hoffmeier, Israel in Egypt (brick-making and corvée background)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 5
- N. M. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
- E. Fox, The Five Books of Moses ("go, serve")
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exod 5:18
- Vulgate, Exod 5:18
- Tomb of Rekhmire (Theban Tomb 100), brick-making scenes
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
7 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.