Ezekiel Chapter 23 Read as one passage
Ezekiel 23:44–48
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
44And they slept with her as with a prostitute; they slept with Oholah and Oholibah, those lewd women. 45But righteous men will sentence them to the punishment of those who commit adultery and bloodshed, because they are adulteresses with blood on their hands. 46This is what the Lord GOD says: ‘Bring a mob against them and consign them to terror and plunder. 47The mob will stone them and cut them down with their swords. They will kill their sons and daughters and burn down their houses. 48So I will put an end to indecency in the land, and all the women will be admonished not to imitate your behavior.
What the first hearers heard
To the exiles in Babylon, many of whom still expected Jerusalem to survive, the verse said three things.
- The fall of Jerusalem is a lawful verdict. The language of trial, sentence and execution presents the coming destruction as justice carried out under the covenant, not as a defeat of Israel's God. It answers the complaint, voiced elsewhere in Ezekiel, that "the way of the Lord is not just" (18:25).
- The guilty party is convicted by her own law. The death penalties for adultery and murder were familiar from Torah. A priestly audience would recognize that Jerusalem was being judged by the very standards she claimed to keep.
- The charges are specific. "Adultery" names the alliances with Egypt and Babylon and the worship of foreign gods. "Blood" names child sacrifice and violence in the city. The verse sums up and closes the case laid out across the chapter.
The verses that follow draw the lesson for hearers: "so that all women may take warning" (v. 48), meaning other nations and the community itself, and "you will know that I am the Lord GOD" (v. 49). The judgment is meant to show who God is.
From the study of Ezekiel 23:45.
Verse by verse
-
44And they slept with her as with a prostitute; they slept with Oholah and Oholibah, those lewd women.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
45But righteous men will sentence them to the punishment of those who commit adultery and bloodshed, because they are adulteresses with blood on their hands.
Full study →"But men who are in the right — they are the ones who will try these two and pass on them the legal sentence the law fixes for women who commit adultery, and the sentence it fixes for women who pour out human blood. For that is exactly what they are: adulteresses, and their hands are wet with the blood they have shed."
This is courtroom language from start to finish. "Righteous" here means men whose verdict is just because the facts and the law support it. It does not mean holy men. Their "judgment" is the full process: verdict and execution. The two charges, adultery and murder, are both capital crimes under Israel's own law (Lev 20:10; Gen 9:6). The next verses name the punishment as stoning and the sword. The second half of the verse gives the reason in the same words already used as the charge in v. 37. The sisters are convicted by their own conduct.
The "women" are Oholah and Oholibah: Samaria, the northern capital, and Jerusalem. Their "adultery" is their unfaithfulness to Israel's God through alliances with Assyria, Egypt and Babylon and the worship of those nations' gods. Their "blood" is literal: children sacrificed to idols and innocent people killed in Jerusalem's streets. The verse insists that the coming destruction is a just sentence carried out against a guilty city, not mere misfortune.
-
46This is what the Lord GOD says: ‘Bring a mob against them and consign them to terror and plunder.
Full study →"Yes, this is what the Lord, Yahweh, says: Muster an assembly and march it up against them, and hand them over to become a horror and a heap of plunder."
The line reads like a sentence pronounced in court. In verse 45, "righteous men" have just found the two sisters, Oholah (Samaria) and Oholibah (Jerusalem), guilty of adultery and bloodshed. Now Yahweh orders the sentence carried out. The verbs are in a bare, clipped form that names no one who acts, so the line works both as a command ("Bring up!") and as a declaration ("I will bring up"). Either way, it is Yahweh who sets the attackers in motion.
"Bring up against" is the ordinary phrase for an army marching on a city. The "assembly" (qahal) points two ways at once. It is the community that gathered to stone an adulteress under Israel's law, and it is also the gathered armies of the nations that Jerusalem had courted as lovers (v. 24). The following verse makes the double picture explicit: the assembly stones them and cuts them down with swords.
To be handed over "to horror" means more than being frightened. It means becoming a shuddering spectacle that other nations look at in dread, as Deuteronomy's covenant curses had warned (Deut 28:25). To be handed over "to plunder" means being stripped as war booty by the very powers the cities had paid for protection. Even the grammar mixes the picture and the reality: "against them" is masculine (the real people), while "hand them over" is feminine (the two women of the story).
-
47The mob will stone them and cut them down with their swords. They will kill their sons and daughters and burn down their houses.
Full study →The assembled host God summons (v. 46) will act as the community's executioners. They will stone the two sisters with stones, the formal stoning the law prescribes for adultery, idolatry and child sacrifice. Then they will hack them down with their own swords, the way woodsmen clear a forest. The verb here is not the "create" of Genesis 1 but a different word that sounds the same and means "cut down".
The sentence goes on: their sons and their daughters they will slaughter, and their houses they will burn up with fire. The children the sisters had given to idols by fire (v. 37) now die by the sword. The houses of the two cities, Samaria and Jerusalem, go up in flames.
Each part of the punishment answers a charge in v. 45. Stoning is the sentence for "adulteresses", meaning the cities' unfaithfulness to their divine Husband through foreign alliances and foreign gods. The sword is the sentence for "women who shed blood". Fire is the fate the law gives a city that turns to other gods (Deut 13:16) and the fate of Achan's household (Josh 7:24–25).
What the first hearers saw was not a lawless riot. It was a court sentence carried out by a foreign army: the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem, described in the words of Israel's own law.
-
48So I will put an end to indecency in the land, and all the women will be admonished not to imitate your behavior.
Full study →"So I will make this deliberate depravity stop, bring it to rest, throughout the land. All the women will take the lesson, corrected by what they have seen, and none of them will act out the kind of calculated outrage that you two committed."
The speaker is the LORD. He addresses the two sisters of the allegory, Oholah (Samaria) and Oholibah (Jerusalem), and turns from 'them' in verse 47 to 'you'. The word translated 'lewdness' or 'indecency' (zimmah) is much heavier than those English words. It means wrongdoing that is planned and shameful. Israel's law used it for the worst sexual crimes against family boundaries, and it named the atrocity at Gibeah. In this chapter it stands for Samaria's and Jerusalem's repeated betrayal of their covenant God: political alliances with Egypt, Assyria and Babylon, and the foreign gods that came with them, pictured as an unfaithful wife chasing lovers. The verse opens and closes on this word. God will end zimmah, and no one will again do 'your' zimmah.
The verb for 'warned' describes a lesson learned by watching a punishment. The stoning, killing and burning of verse 47 serve as a public example. It works like Deuteronomy's 'all Israel shall hear and fear, and never again do such evil.' The goal is a land cleared of this conduct, and verse 49 then states the outcome: 'you will know that I am the Lord GOD.'
Where the English drifted
-
in v45
righteous men
anashim tsaddiqim
- What we hear
- Holy, godly or saintly people, the faithful believers.
- What they heard
- Men who are in the right in a legal case: their verdict and sentence are just. The term describes what they are doing here, not their personal piety. In context they are probably the foreign armies sent against the city.
-
in v45
adulteresses
no'afot
- What we hear
- Individual married women caught in sexual affairs, as if this were a law about punishing such women.
- What they heard
- The verdict on two personified capital cities, Samaria and Jerusalem. Their 'adultery' is their political and religious unfaithfulness to their covenant God: alliances with empires and worship of other gods.
-
in v46
a mob (BSB, NIV, WEB)
qahal
- What we hear
- A disorderly, lawless crowd, like a lynch mob.
- What they heard
- A convened assembly: here both the community that lawfully carries out a sentence of stoning and a mustered military host. It is organized and called together, not a riot.
-
in v46
to be removed (KJV)
zaʿavah
- What we hear
- Taken away or relocated, perhaps deported.
- What they heard
- Trembling, terror, and above all an "object of horror" whose fate makes onlookers shudder. It is the language of the covenant curses (Deut 28:25).
-
in v46
a company (KJV)
qahal
- What we hear
- A business, or a group of friends.
- What they heard
- An assembled body, here an armed host and an executing assembly.
-
in v47
dispatch (them with their swords)
barēʾ
- What we hear
- To send off, or to deal with a task quickly and efficiently.
- What they heard
- To hack or cut down, like clearing trees from a forest. It is violent and physical.
-
in v47
company
qahal
- What we hear
- A business, or a group of guests or friends.
- What they heard
- A gathered host, here an invading army that also acts as the assembly carrying out a legal sentence.
-
in v47
mob
qahal
- What we hear
- A disorderly, lawless crowd acting on its own impulse.
- What they heard
- A convened assembly or host. In this verse it carries out a sentence pronounced by 'righteous men' (v. 45), in the words of the law's community stoning.
-
in v48
lewdness / indecency
zimmah
- What we hear
- Crude, vulgar or sexually suggestive behaviour: bad taste, improper conduct.
- What they heard
- Planned, shameful wrongdoing. The law used it for the gravest sexual crimes (incest in Lev 18:17; 20:14), and Judges 20:6 used it for the outrage at Gibeah. Here it stands for Samaria's and Jerusalem's deliberate covenant betrayal through foreign alliances and idolatry.
-
in v48
taught (KJV, WEB)
nivvasseru (yasar)
- What we hear
- Given instruction, educated.
- What they heard
- Corrected or disciplined, taking a lesson to heart from someone else's punishment, like Deuteronomy's 'hear and fear'.
Every word
-
וַאֲנָשִׁים
va'anashim · H0582
and men, people · v45
In practice this is the plural of 'ish ('man'). It means grown men acting as a body, here a group who will carry out a sentence. The opening 'and' sets them against the lovers who used the sisters in v. 44.
-
צַדִּיקִם
tsaddiqim · H6662
righteous, in the right, just · v45
Used here in its courtroom sense: men who are in the right and whose verdict is just. It is spelled without its usual middle yod. It does not describe these men as saintly; see the study below.
-
הֵמָּה
hemmah · H1992
they (masc.) · v45
A pronoun added for emphasis: 'righteous men, they are the ones who will judge.' It stresses who does the judging.
-
יִשְׁפְּטוּ
yishpetu · H8199
to judge, decide a case, execute justice · v45
This covers the whole legal process: hearing the case, giving the verdict and carrying out the penalty. Verses 46–47 show that the penalty is meant.
-
אוֹתְהֶם
'otham · H0853
object marker + 'them' · v45, v46, v47
This points to the two sisters, but the ending is grammatically masculine. Ezekiel often switches between masculine and feminine endings for the women in chapters 16 and 23. Later in the verse the forms become feminine ('they', 'their hands').
-
מִשְׁפַּט
mishpat · H4941
judgment, legal ruling, sentence, due penalty · v45
This means the sentence the law lays down for this kind of offender: the punishment due to adulteresses.
-
נֹאֲפוֹת
no'afot · H5003
to commit adultery · v45
A feminine plural participle: 'women committing adultery'. The form describes who they are by what they keep doing. In Israelite law, adultery was a capital crime.
-
שֹׁפְכוֹת
shofekhot · H8210
to pour out, spill · v45
Literally 'women pouring out'. With 'blood' it is the standard idiom for murder. The supplied gloss 'kill' gives the sense, but the picture is blood poured on the ground.
-
דָּם
dam · H1818
blood · v45
Blood that has been shed, which brings guilt with it. Here it points to the child sacrifice and violence charged in vv. 37–39 and chapter 22.
-
כִּי
ki · H3588
for, because · v45, v46
Introduces the reason. The sentence fits because the women's own conduct matches the two charges.
-
הֵנָּה
hennah · H2007
they (fem.) · v45
The feminine pronoun returns. It points back to Oholah and Oholibah, who stand for Samaria and Jerusalem.
-
בִּידֵיהֶן
bideihen · H3027
in their hands · v45
'Hand' stands for what a person does, so 'blood in their hands' means they are directly guilty of killing. The ending is feminine.
-
כֹּ֥ה
koh · H3541
thus, so · v46
Opens the standard formula a messenger used, "Thus says…", which tells the hearers that the words that follow are the sender's, not the prophet's.
-
אָמַ֖ר
ʾamar · H0559
to say · v46
The Hebrew is in the past form ("has said"). In this formula it is the word the messenger received and now repeats, so English renders it "says".
-
אֲדֹנָ֣י
ʾadonai · H0136
Lord, Master · v46
A title of supreme lordship. Ezekiel pairs it with the divine name more than any other prophet, about 200 times, to stress Yahweh's sovereign authority as judge.
-
יְהוִ֑ה
YHWH (Yahweh) · H3069
Yahweh, the personal name of Israel's God · v46
Israel's covenant God, the one whose "wife" the two cities were in the allegory. Since Adonai already comes first, the scribes added vowels here so it would be read "Elohim". That is why English prints "Lord GOD" in small capitals.
-
הַעֲלֵ֤ה
haʿaleh · H5927J
to bring up, lead up (in attack) · v46
Causative "make go up", the stock phrase for leading an army up against a city. The form does not say who does the action: it can work as a command ("Bring up!") or stand for "I will bring up".
-
עֲלֵיהֶם֙
ʿaleihem · H5921A
upon, against · v46, v47
"Against them". The ending is masculine plural even though the two sisters are female. Ezekiel's grammar keeps sliding between the women of the picture and the real people of Samaria and Jerusalem.
-
קָהָ֔ל
qahal · H6951
assembly, convened company, host · v46, v47
A body of people called together. Here it means two things at once: the community that carried out a stoning under Israel's law, and the mustered armies of the nations (v. 24, "a company of peoples").
-
וְנָתֹ֥ן
venaton · H5414I
to give, hand over, make · v46
"And hand over". It is the same unconjugated verb form as "bring up". Paired with "to" it means turning someone over to a fate, or making them into something.
-
לְזַעֲוָ֥ה
lezaʿavah · H2189
trembling, terror, object of horror · v46
"Into a horror". The word comes from "to tremble, quake" and covers both the panic of the victims and the shudder of everyone who sees what happened to them. It is a phrase from the covenant curses.
-
וְלָבַֽז׃
velavaz · H0957
plunder, booty · v46
"And into plunder". The goods, people and property that conquerors carry off. The cities become loot for the very lovers they courted.
-
וְרָגְמ֨וּ
wəragəmu · H7275
and they will stone · v47
The technical verb for judicial stoning, the community's way of carrying out a death sentence. The form continues the command of v. 46 and states what will now happen: 'and they shall stone.'
-
אֶ֙בֶן֙
ʾeven · H0068G
-
וּבָרֵ֥א
uvareʾ · H1254A
and cut down · v47
This is not the 'create' verb of Genesis 1. It is a separate word that sounds the same and means 'cut down, clear', as with a forest (Josh 17:15, 18). Here it means hacking people down with swords.
-
בְּחַרְבוֹתָ֑ם
bəḥarvotam · H2719
with their swords · v47
'Their' is masculine and means the attackers' own swords. In Ezekiel the sword is the standard tool of judgment (ch. 21). In this verse it also carries out the death penalty for 'women who shed blood' (v. 45).
-
בְּנֵיהֶ֤ם
bənêhem · H1121A
their sons · v47
The women's sons. Ezekiel often uses masculine endings for feminine subjects. These are the children of the cities, the sisters' 'offspring' (cf. v. 10, 25).
-
וּבְנֽוֹתֵיהֶם֙
uvənotêhem · H1323G
and their daughters · v47
'Sons and daughters' together means the whole next generation. The phrase echoes v. 37, where the sisters had given their children to idols by fire.
-
יַהֲרֹ֔גוּ
yaharogu · H2026
they will kill · v47
The ordinary verb for violent killing or slaughter, often used of war. It is blunt and not ritual.
-
וּבָתֵּיהֶ֖ן
uvattêhen · H1004B
and their houses · v47
The ending is feminine again, so these are the sisters' houses: the actual buildings of Samaria and Jerusalem. The word can also suggest the households living in them.
-
בָּאֵ֥שׁ
baʾesh · H0784
with the fire · v47
'With the fire', a stock phrase in sentences that destroy something completely. It completes the legal triad of stoning, sword and fire.
-
יִשְׂרֹֽפוּ׃
yisrofu · H8313
they will burn · v47
To burn up completely. It is used of burning a condemned city (Deut 13:16) and of the Babylonian burning of Jerusalem's houses (2 Kgs 25:9).
-
וְהִשְׁבַּתִּ֥י
vehishbatti · H7673A
and I will cause to cease · v48
God speaks in the first person: 'I will bring to a stop', 'I will put to rest'. It comes from the same root as 'Sabbath'. The form means making something stop for good, not slowing it down. It repeats God's stated aim in 23:27, where he says he will end this same zimmah.
-
זִמָּ֖ה
zimmah · H2154
planned wickedness, depravity · v48
Shameful wrongdoing done on purpose, often sexual. In this chapter it is the picture Ezekiel uses for Samaria's and Jerusalem's betrayal of the LORD through foreign alliances and idol worship. There is no article, so it means depravity of this kind in general.
-
מִן־
min- · H4480A
from · v48
'From' or 'out of'. The depravity is pictured as removed out of the land.
-
הָאָ֑רֶץ
ha'arets · H0776G
the land · v48
Almost certainly the land of Israel, which Ezekiel treats as polluted by its people's conduct. It is not the whole earth.
-
וְנִֽוַּסְּרוּ֙
venivvasseru · H3256
and they will be disciplined / take warning · v48
A rare verb form that means something like 'they will let themselves be corrected' or 'they will take the lesson'. The root yasar is about correction, sometimes by punishment. Here the lesson comes from watching someone else being punished.
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all · v48
'All' or 'every'. The warning reaches everyone who sees it.
-
הַנָּשִׁ֔ים
hannashim · H0802G
the women · v48
'The women'. The noun is feminine even though its plural ending looks masculine. Scholars disagree about who these women are: real women, or other cities and nations pictured as women, as in 16:41 (see debates).
-
וְלֹ֥א
velo · H3808
and not · v48
Negates the next verb. It states the expected result: they will not do it.
-
תַעֲשֶׂ֖ינָה
ta'asenah · H6213H
they (fem.) will do · v48
'They will do' or 'they will act'. The verb is feminine plural, matching 'the women'.
The world behind it
The allegory. Ezekiel 23 tells the story of two sisters married to the LORD. Oholah ("her tent") is Samaria and Oholibah (probably "my tent is in her") is Jerusalem (23:4). Both "play the harlot" with Egypt, Assyria and Babylon. In the prophets' language this stands for political alliances and for taking up the gods and cults of those powers. In the ancient Near East a capital city was often pictured as a woman, sometimes as the wife of her city's god, so the image would have been natural to the first hearers.
The date. Ezekiel was a priest deported to Babylon in 597 BC. He prophesied among the exiles while Jerusalem was still standing, about 593–586 BC. Samaria had fallen to Assyria in 722 BC. Verses 36–49 are a final courtroom scene: the charges are read out (vv. 37–44), the sentence is pronounced (v. 45), and the punishment is carried out (vv. 46–49).
The law behind the sentence. Under Israelite law, adultery was punished by death for both parties (Lev 20:10; Deut 22:22), and in some cases by stoning by the whole community (Deut 22:21, 24). Murder required the life of the killer (Gen 9:6; Num 35:16–21). Verse 46 calls up a qahal ("assembly") to stone the women and cut them down with swords. That echoes a lawful community execution, but it is also the picture of an army breaking into a city. Ezekiel judges Jerusalem by her own law.
The blood. Verse 37 explains it: the sisters "caused their sons… to pass through [the fire] to them as food", which refers to child sacrifice to idols (cf. 2 Kgs 21:6; 23:10; Jer 7:31). Ezekiel 22 adds political murder and the corruption of justice in Jerusalem.
From the study of Ezekiel 23:45.
Where scholars differ
in v45
Who are the 'righteous men', and why are they called righteous?
-
The foreign armies (Babylon and its allies) sent against the city. They are 'righteous' only in the legal sense that the sentence they carry out is just.
Verses 46–47 describe an 'assembly' that stones and puts to the sword, plunders, and burns houses. Earlier in the chapter (23:22–24) God sets the Babylonians and others against Oholibah and says, 'I will commit judgment to them, and they will judge you according to their judgments.' Tsaddiq often means 'in the right' in court (Deut 25:1).
-
'Righteous' compared with the sisters: even pagan nations are in the right next to such guilt.
Ezekiel 16:51–52 says Jerusalem has made Samaria and Sodom look righteous by comparison. Jeremiah 3:11 says faithless Israel is more righteous than treacherous Judah. Genesis 38:26 uses the same comparative sense.
-
The verse belongs to a later editorial layer (vv. 36–49), which pictures a lawful community of the righteous carrying out Torah's penalties, not foreign invaders.
The section uses wording from Ezekiel 16 and from Torah's laws on execution. It uses the word qahal ('assembly') for the executioners, which elsewhere names the community that carries out lawful stonings. It mixes the 'sisters' imagery with direct legal procedure. Some critical commentators (e.g. Zimmerli) treat it as secondary.
in v45
How should the violent sexual imagery of Ezekiel 16 and 23 be read?
-
It is legal and covenant metaphor. A shocking courtroom image based on Israel's own adultery and murder laws, used to make the exiles feel the seriousness of the city's betrayal.
The penalties match Torah law (Lev 20:10; Deut 22:22–24; Gen 9:6). The 'women' are explicitly cities (23:4). The marriage metaphor for the covenant goes back to Hosea and Jeremiah.
-
The metaphor also reflects and reinforces ancient attitudes toward women's bodies and violence against wives, and readers should note this openly.
Scholars such as Renita Weems (Battered Love) and J. Cheryl Exum point to the graphic exposure and punishment of female figures and the warning addressed to 'all women' (23:48). They argue that the image depends on accepting a husband's violence as legitimate.
in v46
Is "Bring up… hand over" a command, and if so to whom, or does it mean "I will bring up"?
-
Command (imperative sense)
The infinitive absolute often works as a command (Exod 20:8; Deut 5:12). The LXX and Vulgate both translate with imperatives. On this reading Yahweh is giving orders, rhetorically to the executing agents or to the "righteous men" of v. 45, as a court gives orders to its officers.
-
Declaration ("I will bring up")
The infinitive absolute can also stand in for an ordinary verb whose subject comes from context. Right after "thus says the Lord GOD", Yahweh is the natural subject. The parallels Ezek 16:40 ("they will bring up") and 26:3 ("I will bring up") describe the action as a statement, not an order. KJV and WEB take this route.
in v46
How should modern readers handle the passage's imagery of sexual shame and violence against women?
-
Read it as a conventional metaphor for cities and nations
Ancient Near Eastern texts commonly picture capital cities as women and wives of gods. The "women" here stand for Samaria and Jerusalem, and the masculine pronouns show the real referent breaking through. The "punishment" describes the historical siege of 586 BC, and the intended audience was the male exile community.
-
Recognise that the rhetoric shapes and uses gendered violence
Feminist and literary scholars (e.g., Renita Weems, J. Cheryl Exum, Julie Galambush) argue that the shock value depends on public humiliation and violence against a woman being presented as just punishment. They hold that this deserves critical reflection even if the referent is a city. V. 48 ("all women may take warning") moves from metaphor toward actual women.
in v47
Is the 'assembly' a foreign army or Israel's judicial community?
-
It is the invading Babylonian-led coalition.
In Ezekiel qahal regularly means a military horde (16:40; 26:7; 32:3; 38:4, 7, 15). In 23:24 the attackers come with 'an assembly of peoples'. The burning of houses matches 2 Kgs 25:9.
-
It deliberately evokes the legal assembly that carries out stoning.
'Righteous men' pass a formal sentence for adultery and bloodshed (v. 45). The fixed phrase 'stone with stone' comes from execution laws (Lev 20:2; 24:16; Deut 21:21). The full sequence of stoning, sword or killing of children, and burning matches Achan (Josh 7:24–25) and the apostate city (Deut 13:15–16).
-
Both at once (the majority view among commentators such as Greenberg and Block).
Ezekiel describes historical conquest in the words of a court case: the foreign army acts as executioner of a covenant verdict.
in v47
Do vv. 36–49 come from Ezekiel or from a later editor?
-
A later expansion that reuses ch. 16.
Zimmerli points to the abrupt shifts between second and third person and between masculine and feminine, the near-quotation of 16:40–41, and v. 48's address to 'all women'.
-
Ezekiel's own deliberate closing section.
Greenberg and Block read the shifts as typical of Ezekiel's style and the reuse of ch. 16 as intentional. They see the court scene as completing the allegory.
in v47
How should the violent female imagery be understood?
-
It is shock rhetoric aimed at a male audience about cities and their leaders, not about women as such.
The 'women' are explicitly Samaria and Jerusalem (23:4). The addressees are male elders. The prophet uses the most shameful image available to an honour-and-shame culture (e.g. Block, Galambush on the city-as-wife picture).
-
The metaphor itself depends on and reinforces violence against women's bodies, whatever its target.
Feminist scholars (e.g. Weems, Exum, and others) note that the rhetoric works only because public sexual humiliation and execution of women was imaginable and accepted. They argue that readers should name this rather than pass over it.
in v48
Who are 'all the women' who take warning?
-
Personified cities or nations, keeping the allegory going.
Ezekiel 16:41 has 'in the sight of many women', and in ch. 16 the women are neighbouring peoples (16:27, 57). Ezekiel 5:15 calls Jerusalem's punishment a warning lesson (musar) to the surrounding nations, and this verse uses a verb from the same root.
-
Real women: the verse leaves the allegory and warns actual wives.
The plain wording 'all the women'. Verses 45–47 echo the laws on adultery and the Deuteronomic 'hear and fear' clause, which speaks to real members of the community. Critical commentators such as Zimmerli read vv. 46–49 as turning the allegory into a general moral warning.
-
The text deliberately moves between both levels.
Greenberg and others note that Ezekiel's metaphors often slip between picture and reality. Feminist studies (e.g. Galambush; Weems) point out that the image reaches real women whatever its first target was.
in v48
Is vv. 46–49 original to the oracle or a later expansion?
-
A later addition that generalises the oracle.
Zimmerli (Hermeneia) and others cite the overlap with vv. 22–35, the shift between 'them' and 'you', and the moralising tone as signs of later editing within Ezekiel's circle.
-
An integral conclusion to the chapter.
Greenberg (Anchor Bible) and Block (NICOT) read ch. 23 as a deliberate whole. They point to v. 48 fulfilling v. 27 almost word for word, and to the recognition formula of v. 49 as Ezekiel's usual way to close an oracle.
Sources
- BDB s.v. צַדִּיק, שָׁפַט, מִשְׁפָּט, נָאַף, שָׁפַךְ
- HALOT s.v. צַדִּיק; מִשְׁפָּט
- Moshe Greenberg, Ezekiel 21–37 (Anchor Bible)
- Daniel I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel, Chapters 1–24 (NICOT)
- Walther Zimmerli, Ezekiel 1 (Hermeneia)
- Julie Galambush, Jerusalem in the Book of Ezekiel: The City as Yahweh's Wife
- Renita J. Weems, Battered Love: Marriage, Sex, and Violence in the Hebrew Prophets
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezekiel 23
- BDB s.v. קָהָל, זַעֲוָה / זְוָעָה, בַּז
- HALOT s.v. קָהָל; זַעֲוָה
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive absolute used for imperative and finite verb)
- Renita J. Weems, Battered Love
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Ezek 23:46; Vulgate Ezek 23:46
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezekiel 16 and 23
- HALOT s.v. ברא II (Piel 'to cut down')
- BDB s.v. בָּרָא II
- HALOT s.v. רגם
- BDB s.v. קָהָל
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §113 (infinitive continuing a finite verb)
- J. Cheryl Exum, Plotted, Shot, and Painted
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezek 16 and 23
- BDB s.v. זִמָּה, זָמַם
- HALOT s.v. זִמָּה; s.v. יסר
- BDB s.v. יָסַר; s.v. שָׁבַת
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §55k (Nithpael forms)
- W. Zimmerli, Ezekiel 1 (Hermeneia)
- M. Greenberg, Ezekiel 21–37 (Anchor Bible)
- D. I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel, Chapters 1–24 (NICOT)
- J. Galambush, Jerusalem in the Book of Ezekiel: The City as Yahweh's Wife
- R. Weems, Battered Love: Marriage, Sex, and Violence in the Hebrew Prophets
- Septuagint, Ezekiel 23:48
- Vulgate, Ezekiel 23:48
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.