Isaiah Chapter 42 Read as one passage

Isaiah 42:2–3

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

2He will not cry out or raise His voice, nor make His voice heard in the streets. 3A bruised reed He will not break and a smoldering wick He will not extinguish; He will faithfully bring forth justice.

What the first hearers heard

For exiles in Babylon, this verse overturned what they expected from anyone who would set things right. They had seen what world-changing power looked like: Babylon's processions and heralds, and now Cyrus's armies advancing across the map (41:2–3). They had also done their own crying out. In 40:27 the exiles complain that 'my mišpāṭ (my right, my case) is passed over by my God.'

God's answer in 42:1–4 is a servant who will bring that mišpāṭ, to Israel and even to the far-off 'coastlands' (42:4). He will not do it the way empires did. He would not:

  • gather people by public shouting;
  • push his claims on the street;
  • add to the noise of conquest.

The next verse makes the gentleness concrete. Damaged people, pictured as a cracked reed and a dying wick, will not be finished off. For a battered, discouraged community that might well feel like a cracked reed itself, the quietness was good news. Justice was coming, and it would not trample them on its way.

Who the servant was remained an open question for these first hearers. Israel is called God's servant just before (41:8–9) and later (49:3). Yet the servant also has a mission to Israel (49:5–6). The verse still conveyed a clear picture of how God's chosen agent would act.

From the study of Isaiah 42:2.

Verse by verse

  1. 2He will not cry out or raise His voice, nor make His voice heard in the streets.

    He will not shout. That means no urgent outcry of the kind a herald uses to gather a crowd, a warrior uses before battle, or a wronged man uses when he demands his rights in public. He will not lift up, with the object left hanging until the end of the line: his voice. Nor will he make it carry out into the open squares and lanes, the public places where proclamations were read, crowds were stirred and complaints were aired. His voice.

    The verse is three short denials ('not… and not… and not…'). It belongs to a passage that defines God's chosen servant mainly by what he refrains from: seven 'not's across verses 2–4. The point is not that he is mute. Elsewhere the servant has a mouth 'like a sharp sword' (49:2) and a tongue trained 'to sustain the weary with a word' (50:4). The point is how he works. The servant has just been given the royal task of bringing justice to the nations (42:1). Yet he does it without the noise, display and public pressure that kings, conquerors and heralds used. The next verse shows what that quietness means in practice: he does not snap the bent reed or snuff out the flickering wick.

    Full study →
  2. 3A bruised reed He will not break and a smoldering wick He will not extinguish; He will faithfully bring forth justice.

    "A reed already cracked through, he will not snap; a linen wick burning so low it is about to die, he will not pinch out. Steadily and reliably, he will bring out justice: the verdict that sets things right."

    The verse belongs to God's introduction of his "servant" (42:1–4). In Isaiah's world a cracked reed was proverbially worthless: Judah's enemies had mocked Egypt as exactly that, "a crushed reed" (36:6), a staff that splinters when you lean on it. The normal thing is to snap it and throw it away. A wick flickering in a clay oil lamp is one breath from going out, and in Hebrew, putting out someone's lamp or coal meant ending a life or a family line. The verb for "crushed" is also the everyday word for oppressing the poor, so the hearers would see people in these objects: the ground-down, the nearly extinguished, Israel itself "robbed and plundered" in exile (42:22).

    The servant does not finish them off. Yet the verse is not mainly about softness. Its main clause is the last one: he will bring out justice, and he will do it faithfully, in a way that holds. Gentleness to the weak is how he does the work, not a replacement for it. Verse 4 then turns the same words back on the servant: "he will not grow dim, nor be crushed, until he has set justice in the earth." The one who will not crush the crushed or quench the dim will not himself be crushed or go dim. He shares their fragility and outlasts it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    cry (KJV, YLT: "He shall not cry")

    yiṣʿaq

    What we hear
    He will not weep or shed tears, as if about emotional restraint or not showing sorrow.
    What they heard
    He will not shout or call out loudly: a public outcry, summons or appeal. Tears are not in view.
  • in v3

    bruised (reed)

    rāṣûṣ

    What we hear
    Lightly hurt or marked on the surface, like a bruise that fades in a week.
    What they heard
    Crushed or cracked through: a reed whose structure has failed and that is useless as a staff. The verb is also the standard word for oppressing the poor.
  • in v3

    smoking flax

    pištâ kēhâ

    What we hear
    Unclear. Readers may picture a burning field or plant, or a fire giving off smoke.
    What they heard
    A lamp wick of linen fibre burning dimly and about to go out.
  • in v3

    judgment (KJV)

    mišpāṭ

    What we hear
    Condemnation or punishment, a sentence handed down against someone.
    What they heard
    A ruling that sets things right and the just order that follows. Here it is the vindication of people whose case had been ignored (40:27).
  • in v3

    unto truth (KJV)

    leʾĕmet

    What we hear
    Toward correct belief or factual accuracy.
    What they heard
    Reliably, faithfully, in a way that holds firm. ʾĕmet is first of all trustworthiness.
Every word
  1. לֹ֥א

    lō' · H3808

    not · v2, v3

    A flat negative placed first for emphasis. It opens a run of seven 'not's across verses 2–4. The servant is described mostly by what he will not do.

  2. יִצְעַ֖ק

    yiṣʿaq · H6817

    to cry out, shout · v2

    A loud, urgent outcry: the shout of someone in distress, someone appealing for justice, or someone calling people together. The servant does not work by raising that kind of public shout.

  3. יִשָּׂ֑א

    yiśśā' · H5375

    to lift, raise, carry · v2

    'He will not lift'. The object is left unstated and has to be supplied from 'his voice' at the end of the verse. 'Lift the voice' is the ordinary Hebrew idiom for speaking loudly, wailing or proclaiming.

  4. יַשְׁמִ֥יעַ

    yašmîaʿ · H8085

    to cause to hear, proclaim · v2

    This is the causative form of 'hear': 'make heard'. In Isaiah 40–55 it is the standard verb for public announcing and proclaiming. The servant does not broadcast himself.

  5. בַּח֖וּץ

    baḥûṣ · H2351

    outside; street · v2

    'In the outside': the open public spaces of a town, such as streets, squares and markets. Heralds proclaimed there, mourners wailed there, and in Proverbs Wisdom calls out there.

  6. קוֹלֽוֹ׃

    qôlô · H6963

    voice, sound · v2

    'His voice'. It finishes both 'lift' and 'make heard', so the verse ends on the thing the servant does not push into the public square.

  7. קָנֶ֤ה

    qāneh · H7070

    reed, stalk, cane · v3

    The tall marsh reed of the Nile, Euphrates and Jordan, used for walking-sticks, measuring rods and pens. It is a picture of something thin and easily snapped. Hebrew puts it first in the sentence, so the attention falls on the fragile thing before we hear what the servant does to it.

  8. רָצוּץ֙

    rāṣûṣ · H7533

    crushed, cracked, oppressed · v3

    A passive form: 'already crushed', a reed that is cracked or split and has lost its strength. The same verb is Hebrew's ordinary word for oppressing the poor (Deut 28:33; Amos 4:1; Isa 58:6, 'set the crushed free'), so the image would also call oppressed people to mind.

  9. יִשְׁבּ֔וֹר

    yišbôr · H7665

    to break, shatter · v3

    'He will break', or 'he does break': it can be a future promise or a fixed habit. Breaking a cracked reed would be the obvious thing to do, finishing off what is already useless. The servant does not do it.

  10. וּפִשְׁתָּ֥ה

    ûp̄ištâ · H6594

    and flax; (flax) wick · v3

    Flax fibre twisted into the wick of a clay oil lamp. 'Flax' here means the household wick, not a field crop. The same word appears in Isa 43:17, where Pharaoh's army is 'quenched like a wick'.

  11. כֵהָ֖ה

    kēhâ · H3544

    dim, faint, faded · v3

    Burning low and about to go out. Elsewhere the word describes failing eyes (1 Sam 3:2), a faded skin mark (Lev 13), and a 'faint spirit' (Isa 61:3). It is not a 'smoking' wick (that comes from the Greek). It is a dying flame.

  12. יְכַבֶּ֑נָּה

    yĕkabbennâ · H3518

    to quench, put out · v3

    'He will put it out.' The verb is intensive and carries an object suffix ('it', meaning the wick). Putting out someone's lamp or coal was a Hebrew picture for ending a life or a family line (2 Sam 14:7; 21:17). The servant will not snuff out what is barely alive.

  13. לֶאֱמֶ֖ת

    leʾĕmet · H571

    firmness, faithfulness, truth · v3

    Literally 'to/for faithfulness'. Most likely it works as an adverb, 'faithfully, reliably': the justice he brings is dependable and in line with reality. It could also mean 'so that it stands firm'. It is not mainly about correct doctrine.

  14. יוֹצִ֥יא

    yôṣîʾ · H3318

    to bring out, cause to go forth · v3

    'He will bring out', the language of a verdict or decree going out from a judge or king. It repeats v. 1 ('he will bring forth justice to the nations'), so the same goal frames the description of his gentleness.

  15. מִשְׁפָּֽט׃

    mišpāṭ · H4941

    justice, verdict, right order · v3

    A ruling that puts things right, and the just order that results. It is the key word of 42:1–4, appearing in vv. 1, 3 and 4. It answers the exiles' complaint in 40:27 that 'my mishpat (my case) is ignored by my God'.

The world behind it

Where this sits. Isaiah 42:1–4 is the first of the passages scholars call the 'Servant Songs' (42:1–9; 49:1–6; 50:4–9; 52:13–53:12). Most scholars date chapters 40–55 to the last years of the Babylonian exile, around 550–539 BC. The traditional view holds that Isaiah of Jerusalem (8th century BC) wrote them as prophecy of that future. Either way, the words address Judeans exiled in Babylon.

What power sounded like. In that world, justice and authority were loud:

  • Royal decrees were cried aloud by heralds in streets and at city gates.
  • Conquerors announced themselves with war cries, processions and inscriptions boasting of their deeds. The chapter just before describes Cyrus the Persian sweeping through nations and trampling rulers 'like mud' (41:2–3, 25).
  • People who had been wronged also 'cried out' (ṣāʿaq) publicly to the king for redress (2 Kgs 8:3–5).

Royal language, unexpected manner. Verse 1 introduces the servant in terms used for installing a king: 'my chosen one', on whom God puts his Spirit, who will bring mišpāṭ, justice and right order, to the nations. Establishing justice was the king's job. A hearer would expect the trumpet, the herald and the proclamation in the square. Verse 2 denies all of it.

Contrast inside the chapter. In 42:13–14 YHWH himself 'goes out like a warrior… he shouts, he raises the war cry', and says 'I will cry out like a woman in labour'. The loud cry belongs to God. The servant he upholds is the quiet one.

From the study of Isaiah 42:2.

Where scholars differ

in v2

What exactly is the servant refraining from when he does not 'cry out' or make his voice heard publicly?

  • Gentleness and restraint of manner: he does not bully, coerce or use loud force.

    Verse 3 immediately describes not breaking the bruised reed or quenching the dim wick. The surrounding negatives describe a non-violent way of bringing justice.

  • He is not a herald or conqueror who announces himself with public proclamation and display.

    Isaiah 40–55 uses the 'make heard' verb for heralds and announcements (40:9; 48:20; 52:7). The servant is set against Cyrus's noisy conquest (41:2–3, 25) and against YHWH's own war cry (42:13).

  • He does not raise a public outcry or complaint about his own wrongs.

    *ṣāʿaq* is the verb for appealing to the king for redress (2 Kgs 8:3–5) and for the cry of the oppressed. It fits the later picture of the servant who 'did not open his mouth' when afflicted (53:7) and who 'will not grow faint' (42:4).

  • He will not show partiality (Vulgate).

    Reads the bare 'lift' as 'lift the face', a known idiom. The verse's own 'his voice' as object of 'lift' and 'make heard' makes this less likely.

in v2

Who is the servant?

  • Israel, the people as a whole or a faithful core of it.

    Israel/Jacob is called God's servant and 'chosen' in 41:8–9, 44:1 and 49:3. The Septuagint of 42:1 adds 'Jacob… Israel'.

  • An individual: the prophet, a future royal figure, or the Messiah.

    The servant has a mission to restore Israel (49:5–6) and suffers on others' behalf (52:13–53:12). The Targum reads 42:1 as the Messiah, and Matthew 12:18–21 applies the passage to Jesus.

  • Cyrus (a minority view for this passage).

    Cyrus is called YHWH's 'shepherd' and 'anointed' (44:28; 45:1). However, the quiet, gentle portrait of 42:2–3 contrasts sharply with how Cyrus is described.

in v3

Who or what are the 'crushed reed' and 'dim wick'?

  • Weak and oppressed people: exiled Israel and vulnerable people among the nations. This is the majority view.

    Rāṣaṣ is standard vocabulary for oppressing the poor (Amos 4:1; Isa 58:6). The exiles describe themselves as crushed and faint (40:27–31; 42:22). Isa 61:3 speaks of a 'dim/faint spirit' (rûaḥ kēhâ). The Targum reads the images as the humble and the poor.

  • The images describe how the servant uses legal power: he does not pronounce death sentences or 'put out' anyone's life. Klaus Baltzer has argued this, connecting the images to symbolic acts of condemnation.

    Quenching a lamp or coal stands for ending a life or line (2 Sam 14:7; 21:17), and the verse sits inside the language of justice (mišpāṭ three times). Clear evidence of a formal court ritual of breaking a reed or putting out a lamp in Israel is thin, so this specific part of the view is uncertain.

  • The images deliberately echo weakened powers and enemies as well, so even broken nations are not simply destroyed.

    Egypt is 'this crushed reed' in 36:6 (same phrase), and Egypt's army is 'quenched like a wick' in 43:17 (same nouns and verb). The servant's justice goes to the 'nations' and 'coastlands' (42:1, 4). Most scholars treat these as echoes that widen the picture, not as the main referent.

in v3

Who is the servant of 42:1–4?

  • Israel/Jacob as a people.

    Isaiah 40–55 repeatedly names Israel as 'my servant' (41:8–9; 44:1–2, 21; 45:4; 49:3), and the Septuagint adds 'Jacob… Israel' at 42:1.

  • An individual: the prophet, a royal figure, or a future anointed ruler (Messiah).

    The servant is given the spirit as a king is and has a mission that includes Israel (49:5–6). The Targum reads 'my servant the Messiah' at 42:1. Matthew 12:18–21 applies the passage to Jesus. Cyrus has been proposed, but 41:25 contrasts sharply with 42:2–3.

  • A figure that moves between the people and an individual who embodies faithful Israel.

    The servant is called 'Israel' in 49:3 but is sent to restore Israel in 49:5–6. Many modern commentators (e.g., Childs, Blenkinsopp, Goldingay) emphasise this fluidity and the way the songs develop.

in v3

What does leʾĕmet ('to/for faithfulness') mean?

  • It works as an adverb: 'faithfully, reliably'.

    Le- with an abstract noun often forms adverbs. Most modern versions (ESV, NASB, BSB, WEB, NIV) read it this way.

  • 'In accordance with truth/reality': justice that matches the facts.

    The Septuagint has eis alētheian, the Vulgate in veritate, the KJV 'unto truth'. In Isa 43:9 ʾĕmet means a claim proved true.

  • 'So that it endures / to a lasting outcome'.

    The root means firmness. Matthew's 'to victory' (eis nikos, the usual Greek for lāneṣaḥ 'forever, to completion') shows that early readers took the phrase as being about final, lasting success.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).