Jeremiah Chapter 3 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 3:7–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7I thought that after she had done all these things, she would return to Me. But she did not return, and her unfaithful sister Judah saw it. 8She saw that because faithless Israel had committed adultery, I gave her a certificate of divorce and sent her away. Yet that unfaithful sister Judah had no fear and prostituted herself as well. 9Indifferent to her own infidelity, Israel had defiled the land and committed adultery with stones and trees. 10Yet in spite of all this, her unfaithful sister Judah did not return to Me with all her heart, but only in pretense,” declares the LORD.

What the first hearers heard

To Judah in Josiah's time, this was a family story with an uncomfortable punchline. They knew the north's fate: Samaria fallen, its people scattered, an event they could treat as God's judgment on those people up north. Jeremiah retells it as a story about them.

  • It showed YHWH's patience. Even after everything Israel did, YHWH expected her back. The door had been held open, so the "divorce" was not hasty.
  • It made Judah a witness. Judah "saw." She had a clear lesson to learn from and did not learn it. Under the moral logic of the time, someone who sees a warning and ignores it is more guilty, which is why v. 11 calls Israel "more righteous" than Judah.
  • It used a name as a verdict. Calling Judah "Treacherous" put her in the role of the covenant-breaking wife, a deep shame in a culture where a household's honour depended on loyalty.
  • It set up the call to return. The disappointed "she will return" prepares for the appeals in 3:12–4:4: "Return, turning-away Israel... return, turned-away children." The verse is part judgment and part groundwork for an invitation that is still open.

From the study of Jeremiah 3:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7I thought that after she had done all these things, she would return to Me. But she did not return, and her unfaithful sister Judah saw it.

    YHWH is speaking to Jeremiah about two sisters who are both married to him: the northern kingdom, Israel, and the southern kingdom, Judah.

    "And I said to myself (or: I called to her): 'After she has done all of this, it is to me that she will come back.' But she did not come back. And her sister, 'Treacherous' Judah, watched it all."

    Several things in the Hebrew are worth keeping:

    • The hope came after the offence. "After she had done all these things" points back to v. 6: Israel worshipping at shrines on every high hill and under every green tree, pictured as a wife prostituting herself. God's expectation of her return was not naïve ignorance of her conduct. It was held with full knowledge of it.
    • "To me" is emphatic. The words come first in the Hebrew clause. The hope was not simply that she would stop, but that she would come home to her husband rather than to her lovers.
    • The same verb is used twice. "She will return" and "she did not return" both use shuv, the Old Testament's word for turning around and coming back, the word behind "repentance". Expectation and refusal stand side by side.
    • Two sisters, two nicknames. Israel is called Meshuvah, "Turning-away" (v. 6). Judah here is called Bagodah, "Treacherous" or "Faithless", a word for betraying a sworn bond, used of marriage and treaty. The forms sound like names, as if the sisters were characters in a parable.
    • Judah was a witness. She saw: Israel's refusal, and (v. 8) the "divorce" that followed. A sister who sees this should be afraid and change course. As v. 8 says, Judah "did not fear", and she did the same thing.
    Full study →
  2. 8She saw that because faithless Israel had committed adultery, I gave her a certificate of divorce and sent her away. Yet that unfaithful sister Judah had no fear and prostituted herself as well.

    "And I saw it: on account of every one of the occasions when Turning-Away Israel committed adultery, I sent her away and put the legal deed of divorce into her hand. Yet her sister, Betrayer Judah, was not frightened by this. She went off and played the whore, she too."

    The verse is a single long sentence. Most of it recounts the north's divorce, and only then does the main point land on Judah. The northern kingdom has a nickname, "Turning-Away" (meshuvah), built from the same Hebrew verb for "turn" and "return" that runs through the whole chapter: God waits for her to return (v. 7), she does not return, and later he calls, "Return, Turning-Away Israel" (v. 12). Her "adultery" is the worship of other gods on the hilltops (v. 6, 9).

    The divorce is described in the exact language of Deuteronomy 24: grounds ("all the matters"), the written deed of "cutting-off", the handing over, the "sending away". To Jeremiah's hearers this was a picture of what had actually happened about a century earlier, when Assyria destroyed Samaria and deported the northern tribes. That disaster was not an accident of politics. It was a husband's lawful divorce of a wife who had broken the marriage.

    The sting is in the second half. Judah, called "Betrayer" (bogedah, the word for betraying a spouse), watched her sister's divorce and felt no alarm. She drew no warning from it, and she did the very same thing. The final "she too" points straight at the people of Jerusalem listening to Jeremiah.

    Full study →
  3. 9Indifferent to her own infidelity, Israel had defiled the land and committed adultery with stones and trees.

    And so it went: because her whoring weighed nothing with her, she polluted the land, and she broke her marriage with a rock and a piece of wood.

    The verse traces a chain of cause and effect. It starts with an attitude. The unfaithful wife found her own promiscuity light: trivial, not worth a second thought, beneath taking seriously. In Hebrew, seriousness and honour are pictured as weight, so "lightness" means she treated the whole matter as worthless.

    From that casualness came the result. The land was polluted. This was the LORD's own land, which he had given as his bride's home, and it was now unfit for his presence and in danger of throwing out its inhabitants, as the north had already been thrown out.

    The charge then climbs from "whoring" to "adultery". She is not an unattached woman behaving loosely. She is a wife, bound by covenant to a living husband, betraying him in the act.

    Last comes the insult. Her lovers are named only by what they are made of: the stone and the tree. These are the standing stones, wooden goddess poles and sacred trees of the hilltop shrines, which Jeremiah has already pictured as "every high hill and under every green tree" (3:6). The prophet refuses them the dignity of being called gods. The Hebrew even makes them the blunt direct objects of the verb: she "adulteried" a stone. The point is that her infidelity is grave, and that what she was unfaithful for is ridiculous.

    Full study →
  4. 10Yet in spite of all this, her unfaithful sister Judah did not return to Me with all her heart, but only in pretense,” declares the LORD.

    "And even after all of this — after watching her sister Israel thrown out of the house, divorced and sent into exile for her unfaithfulness — Judah, the sister who betrays, did not come back to me with her whole heart, with all her mind, will and loyalty. The only coming-back she did was a lie: a homecoming in appearance, with nothing real behind it. This is Yahweh's own declaration."

    The verse plays on the word shuv, "turn/return", which runs all through this chapter. Israel, the northern kingdom, is called "Turning-away". Judah is called "Betrayer", a word used for breaking faith in a marriage. Judah did not simply refuse to come back. She staged a return, and it was false (sheqer, Jeremiah's word for anything that looks solid and fails you). "With all her heart" is the language of Deuteronomy for undivided commitment. In Hebrew the heart is mainly the seat of thought and decision, not feeling. So the charge is about divided loyalty, not weak emotion. The next verse draws the shocking conclusion: the sister who openly walked away comes out more in the right than the sister who faked her return.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    unfaithful (sister Judah)

    bagodah

    What we hear
    Sexually unfaithful, cheating on a spouse.
    What they heard
    Treacherous: someone who breaks a sworn bond of loyalty. The word is used of marriage, but equally of treaties, alliances and covenant. Within the marriage picture it means covenant betrayal, here the worship of other gods. It is not only sexual misconduct.
  • in v8

    backsliding Israel

    meshuvah yisra'el

    What we hear
    An individual believer who has drifted, cooled off or slipped back in personal devotion: the "backslider" of revival preaching.
    What they heard
    "Turning-Away Israel": a name for the whole northern kingdom, which openly turned from its God to worship other gods. It means national defection from a covenant, not a gradual personal slide. It is also the reverse of the chapter's key word shuv, "return".
  • in v9

    stocks (KJV)

    'ets

    What we hear
    Stock-market shares, or the wooden frame used to pin offenders for public punishment.
    What they heard
    A tree, block or piece of wood. Here it means the sacred trees, wooden Asherah poles and carved wooden idols of the hilltop shrines.
  • in v9

    fornication (YLT)

    zenut

    What we hear
    Sex between two unmarried people.
    What they heard
    Promiscuity or prostitution, pictured here as the behaviour of a *married* woman. It is a metaphor for the covenant people pursuing other gods.
  • in v9

    lightness of her whoredom (KJV)

    qol

    What we hear
    Either something pleasant and airy, or a hint that her unfaithfulness was only slight or minor.
    What they heard
    Frivolity, levity: she treated her infidelity as weightless and of no account. The 'lightness' is in her attitude, not in the size of the sin.
  • in v9

    defiled / polluted the land

    chanef

    What we hear
    Environmental damage, or a loose figure of speech for moral decline.
    What they heard
    A sacral condition of the LORD's own land, rendering it unfit for his presence and liable to expel its inhabitants (Numbers 35:33; Deuteronomy 24:4; Leviticus 18:24–28).
  • in v10

    with all her heart / with her whole heart

    bekhol libbah

    What we hear
    With full emotional sincerity and fervor: really meaning it, feeling it deeply.
    What they heard
    With an undivided mind, will and loyalty. In Hebrew the heart is mainly where a person thinks and decides. In Deuteronomy the phrase means exclusive covenant allegiance to Yahweh, with no other gods.
  • in v10

    return / turned

    shuv

    What we hear
    Read as 'repent' in the sense of feeling sorry for sin, a private inner change.
    What they heard
    To turn around and go back to the one you left. Here it pictures an estranged wife coming home and living faithfully again. That is a change in loyalty and behavior toward a person.
  • in v10

    treacherous (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    bagod

    What we hear
    Dangerous or hazardous, as in 'treacherous roads'.
    What they heard
    Faithless toward someone you are bound to, especially a marriage partner. Betrayal of trust.
Every word
  1. וָאֹמַ֗ר

    va'omar · H0559

    and I said · v7

    Literally 'and I said'. In Hebrew, 'to say' often means 'to say to oneself', so 'I thought' (BSB) is a fair reading. It could also introduce something God actually said to Israel (KJV: 'Turn thou unto me'). The speaker is YHWH, still talking to Jeremiah (v. 6).

  2. אַחֲרֵ֨י

    'acharei · H0310A

    after · v7

    'After'. It places God's expectation at the point when Israel's run of shrine-worship was already complete, so the hope came after the offence, not before it.

  3. עֲשׂוֹתָ֧הּ

    'asotah · H6213A

    to do · v7

    'Her doing': a verb used as a noun, with 'her' attached. It picks up 'what faithless Israel has done' from v. 6. The 'doing' is the 'prostitution' on every high hill and under every green tree.

  4. אֶת־

    'et- · H0853

    [object marker] · v7, v8, v9

    An untranslatable particle that marks 'all these' as the definite object of 'doing'.

  5. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v7, v8, v10

    'All'. It stresses the full extent of what she did. Even after every bit of it, return was still expected.

  6. אֵ֛לֶּה

    'elleh · H0428

    these · v7

    'These [things]'. It points back to the acts listed in v. 6.

  7. אֵלַ֥י

    'elay · H0413

    to me · v7, v8, v10

    'To me'. It comes before the verb in the Hebrew, which gives it emphasis: 'to ME she will come back'. The issue is not only that she stop, but that she come back to her husband, YHWH, rather than to her other 'lovers'.

  8. תָּשׁ֖וּב

    tashuv · H7725G

    return, turn back · v7, v10

    An unfinished-action form: 'she will / would return'. The same form can also be 'you will return', which is how the ancient versions read it as a summons. This is the Hebrew verb for turning around and coming back, and it is the Old Testament's main word for repentance.

  9. וְלֹא־

    velo- · H3808

    and not · v7, v8, v10

    'And not'. It turns the expectation down flat.

  10. וַתֵּ֛רֶא

    vattere' · H7200G

    and she saw · v7, v8

    'And she saw'. The subject is Judah. What she saw is left unstated, but it is Israel's refusal and, as v. 8 goes on to say, what came of it. Seeing should have taught her something, and v. 8 says it did not.

  11. בָּגוֹדָ֥ה

    bagodah · H0901

    treacherous, faithless · v7, v10

    An adjective, 'Treacherous', used almost like a nickname. It appears only here and in v. 10. It pairs with Israel's nickname meshuvah, 'Turning-away' (v. 6). It accuses Judah of betraying a sworn bond, here a marriage.

  12. אֲחוֹתָ֖הּ

    'achotah · H0269

    her sister · v7, v8, v10

    'Her sister'. Israel and Judah are two sisters married to the same husband. A sister should have learned from what happened in her own household.

  13. יְהוּדָֽה׃

    yehudah · H3063G

    Judah · v7, v8, v10

    The southern kingdom, with Jerusalem as its capital. These are Jeremiah's own hearers, who are watching the story of the north as if it were a mirror.

  14. כִּ֤י

    ki · H3588A

    that, because · v8, v10

    Introduces what was seen ("that..."). The sentence then runs a long way, through the whole divorce, before it gets to the main point about Judah.

  15. עַל־

    'al · H5921A

    upon, on account of · v8

    With the next two words it forms a phrase meaning "on account of". It gives the legal grounds for the divorce.

  16. אֹדוֹת֙

    'odot · H0182

    causes, circumstances · v8

    A rare word for "matters, occasions, reasons". KJV's "all the causes whereby" catches it: the divorce had grounds, and they were many.

  17. אֲשֶׁ֤ר

    'asher · H0834A

    which, in which · v8

    Links the "matters" to what Israel did in them.

  18. נִֽאֲפָה֙

    ni'afah · H5003

    she committed adultery · v8, v9

    The legal word for adultery, meaning breaking an existing marriage. Here it stands for Israel's worship of other gods (v. 9: "adultery with stone and tree").

  19. מְשֻׁבָ֣ה

    meshuvah · H4878

    turning away, apostasy · v8

    Literally "Turning-Away", used almost as a name for the northern kingdom. It comes from the verb shuv ("turn, return") that runs all through Jeremiah 3.

  20. יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל

    yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v8

    In this chapter it means the northern kingdom, whose capital was Samaria. Assyria destroyed it in 722 BC. It does not mean the whole nation.

  21. שִׁלַּחְתִּ֕יהָ

    shillachtiha · H7971I

    I sent her away · v8

    In this intensive form the verb was the standard term for divorcing a wife (Deut 24:1, 3). In history the "sending away" was the Assyrian conquest and the northern tribes being carried into exile.

  22. וָאֶתֵּ֛ן

    va'etten · H5414G

    and I gave · v8

    The formal step of handing over the document, as in Deut 24:1: "he writes her a certificate of divorce and puts it in her hand."

  23. סֵ֥פֶר

    sefer · H5612A

    document, written record · v8

    Any written document. Here it is a legal deed, not a "book".

  24. כְּרִיתֻתֶ֖יהָ

    keritutey-ha · H3748

    divorce (lit. cutting-off) · v8

    "Her cutting-off": the divorce. It comes from karat, "to cut", the same verb used for "cutting" (making) a covenant. The deed formally cut the bond.

  25. יָֽרְאָ֜ה

    yare'ah · H3372G

    she feared · v8

    Here "fear" means being alarmed or warned off. Judah saw what happened to her sister and was not frightened into changing.

  26. בֹּֽגֵדָ֤ה

    bogedah · H0898

    treacherous (one) · v8

    "Treacherous", the second name in the verse's pair of nicknames: "Turning-Away Israel" and "Treacherous Judah". The verb is used for betraying a spouse or a trust.

  27. וַתֵּ֖לֶךְ

    vattelekh · H1980G

    and she went · v8

    "She went": a deliberate act of setting off after other lovers, echoing v. 6, where Israel "went" up every high hill.

  28. וַתִּ֥זֶן

    vattizen · H2181

    and she played the harlot · v8

    To be sexually promiscuous or to act as a prostitute. Here it is the prophets' picture of giving worship to other gods.

  29. גַּם־

    gam · H1571

    also, too · v8, v10

    "Too": Judah did exactly what her sister had been divorced for.

  30. הִֽיא׃

    hi' · H1931

    she · v8

    An extra, emphatic "she" at the very end: "she too". The sentence lands on Judah, the audience.

  31. וְהָיָה֙

    vehayah · H1961

    and it was / came to be · v9

    An opening formula, 'and so it went'. The form often describes something repeated or habitual, which fits a pattern of behaviour rather than a single act.

  32. מִקֹּ֣ל

    miqqol · H6963B

    lightness, frivolity · v9

    'From the lightness of'. The word comes from a root meaning 'to be light, slight, of little weight'. Her infidelity carried no weight with her. She treated it as trivial, and that casualness is given as the cause of what follows.

  33. זְנוּתָ֔הּ

    zenutah · H2184

    prostitution, whoring · v9

    'Her whoring'. Promiscuous sexual behaviour, pictured as a woman's. Jeremiah uses it for the nation chasing other gods (compare 3:2).

  34. וַתֶּחֱנַ֖ף

    vattecheneph · H2610

    to be polluted, profaned · v9

    'And she polluted / it was polluted'. Sacred pollution: the land was the LORD's, and it became unfit for him and for life before him, as Jeremiah has just warned in 3:1–2.

  35. הָאָ֑רֶץ

    ha'arets · H0776G

    land, country, earth · v9

    'The land', meaning the specific land the LORD gave Israel and owned himself (compare 2:7, 'you made my inheritance detestable'). It is not 'the planet'.

  36. הָאֶ֖בֶן

    ha'even · H0068G

    stone · v9

    'The stone'. In this setting it means the standing stones and stone images of the hilltop shrines. The prophet names them by their raw material, as if to say 'a rock'.

  37. הָעֵֽץ׃

    ha'ets · H6086H

    tree, wood · v9

    Hebrew uses one word for both 'tree' and 'wood'. Here it covers the sacred trees 'under every green tree' (3:6), the carved wooden poles of the goddess Asherah, and wooden idols. The prophet deliberately reduces them all to lumber.

  38. זֹ֗את

    zot · H2063

    this · v10

    Points back to vv. 6–9: Israel's idolatry, her 'divorce' and exile, and Judah watching it happen without fear.

  39. לִבָּ֑הּ

    libbah · H3820

    her heart · v10

    The inner center of thought, will and commitment, not mainly feeling. 'Not with all her heart' means her loyalty stayed divided.

  40. אִם־

    im · H518

    if; (with ki) except · v10

    'Ki im' after a negative means 'but rather, only'. The only kind of return Judah made was a false one.

  41. בְּשֶׁ֖קֶר

    besheqer · H8267

    with falsehood, in a lie · v10

    Her return was a sheqer: something that looks real but has nothing behind it. This is one of Jeremiah's favorite words of accusation.

  42. נְאֻם־

    ne'um · H5002

    utterance, declaration · v10

    The standard formula prophets use to mark an oracle. It stamps the verdict as Yahweh's own statement, not Jeremiah's opinion.

  43. יְהוָֽה׃

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh (the LORD) · v10

    The personal, covenant name of Israel's God, the one Judah claimed to have come back to.

The world behind it

When: Verse 6 dates the oracle to "the days of King Josiah" (reigned c. 640–609 BC). Jeremiah's call came in Josiah's 13th year, c. 627 BC.

The two kingdoms: After Solomon, the tribes split into Israel in the north (capital Samaria) and Judah in the south (capital Jerusalem). The north was conquered by Assyria in 722/720 BC and much of its population was deported. Jeremiah speaks of this as YHWH giving Israel a "certificate of divorce" and sending her away (v. 8). By Jeremiah's day it was about a century in the past, close enough to remember and plainly visible to Judah.

The marriage picture: The prophet Hosea, a northerner, had already pictured Israel as YHWH's unfaithful wife. Ezekiel later developed the "two sisters" story at length (Ezekiel 23, Oholah and Oholibah). The picture rests on the covenant as an exclusive bond. Worshipping other gods, such as Baal and the Asherah at hilltop shrines and sacred trees, counted as adultery, and the people's political alliances could be described the same way.

The divorce law behind the chapter: Jeremiah 3:1 quotes almost word for word the law of Deuteronomy 24:1–4. A man who divorces his wife may not take her back once she has married another. Against that legal background, "to me she will return" in v. 7 is striking: YHWH expected and wanted a return that the law itself would rule out.

Josiah's reform: In 622 BC Josiah cleansed the temple and destroyed rural shrines (2 Kings 22–23). Verse 10, "Judah did not return to me with her whole heart, but in pretence", is often read as Jeremiah's verdict that the reform stayed on the surface. If so, the verse's warning was aimed at a Judah that thought it had returned.

From the study of Jeremiah 3:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

Is the middle clause God's inner expectation ('I thought she would return') or a spoken appeal ('Return to me!')?

  • Inner expectation: 'I said [to myself], she will return to me.'

    'Amar commonly means 'think'. The following clause, 'and she did not return', is 3rd feminine, which makes a 3rd feminine 'she will return' the natural reading. Most modern translations and commentaries take this view (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom).

  • Spoken appeal: 'I said, Return to me!'

    The Septuagint and Vulgate both translate it as a command, and the KJV follows them. It fits the long prophetic record of calls to the north before 722 BC (Hosea 14:1, 'Return, O Israel'). The Hebrew form can be 2nd person, and Hebrew imperfects can carry command force.

in v7

Does 'I thought she would return, but she did not' mean God did not know how things would turn out?

  • It is relational language. It expresses God's real longing and the genuine openness of the invitation, not a gap in his knowledge.

    The prophets regularly describe God in human terms of grief, regret and hope (Hosea 11:8; Jeremiah 3:19–20). The rhetorical aim here is to show Israel's guilt and God's patience, not to teach about divine foreknowledge. Jeremiah elsewhere stresses God's knowledge of the heart (Jeremiah 17:10).

  • It shows that God's expectations about human response can genuinely go unmet, so the future is in some sense open.

    The plain wording records an expectation that did not come true. The same pattern appears in Jeremiah 3:19–20 ('I thought you would call me Father… but…') and in God's 'regret' passages (Genesis 6:6; 1 Samuel 15:11). Some modern theologians cite this verse for that view.

  • The question may not arise if the clause is a summons ('Return to me!') rather than a forecast.

    This is the Septuagint and Vulgate reading (see the previous debate). On this view the verse reports a call that went unanswered, not a prediction that failed.

in v8

Who "saw": God or Judah?

  • Keep the standard Hebrew "And I saw" (God). The long middle section is a parenthesis, and what God saw is that Judah "did not fear".

    Masoretic text and Vulgate. It is the harder reading, and scribes tend to smooth hard readings rather than create them. The sentence makes sense with the divorce as a parenthesis. Followed by KJV, NASB and NIV (NIV reorders the sentence).

  • Read "And she saw" (Judah saw that God divorced Israel), continuing v. 7.

    One Hebrew manuscript and the Syriac. Verse 7 ends with "and her treacherous sister Judah saw", using this very form. It removes the awkward syntax. Followed by BSB, ESV and NRSV.

in v8

Who wrote the prose of 3:6–11, and when?

  • Substantially from Jeremiah in Josiah's reign, as the heading says. It was an appeal to the former northern territory at a time when Josiah was extending control northward.

    The date in 3:6. It fits 2 Kings 23:15–20, where Josiah's reforms reach Bethel and Samaria. The "turn and return" vocabulary is typical of Jeremiah. Defended by commentators such as Holladay and Lundbom.

  • A later prose expansion by editors steeped in Deuteronomy, possibly from the exile, explaining Judah's fall by comparing it with Samaria's.

    The prose style and the phrases shared with Deuteronomy and Kings ("every high hill and under every green tree"). The two-sisters comparison is also found in Ezekiel 23. Argued by scholars such as McKane and Carroll.

in v9

Who is 'she' in this verse: the northern kingdom (Israel) or Judah?

  • Israel. The verse looks back on the northern kingdom's conduct that led to the divorce in v. 8 (BSB, NIV).

    Verse 10 opens 'and yet in spite of all this, her sister Judah…', which reads naturally if 'all this' is Israel's record and fate described in v. 9. The pluperfect 'had defiled' in BSB reflects this view.

  • Judah. The verse continues the last clause of v. 8, 'she too played the harlot' (a view taken by several major commentators, e.g. Lundbom).

    Judah is the nearest subject. Verse 10's 'not with all her heart, but in pretense' builds directly on Judah's 'lightness' about her own infidelity. 'In spite of all this' would then mean in spite of her own sin and her sister's fate.

  • Deliberately blurred: the two sisters' conduct is the same.

    Verses 6–11 build a parallel between the sisters, ending with 'faithless Israel has shown herself more righteous than treacherous Judah' (3:11). The Hebrew never names the subject, and translations that insert a name are making an interpretive choice.

in v9

What exactly do 'the stone and the tree' refer to?

  • Cult objects of the local shrines: standing stones (matsevot) and wooden Asherah poles or sacred trees.

    Jeremiah 2:27 (tree as 'father', stone as 'mother', with the genders deliberately reversed); 3:6 'under every green tree'; 2 Kings 23:14; Deuteronomy 16:21–22, which forbids planting an Asherah or setting up a pillar beside YHWH's altar.

  • Idol images in general, made of wood and stone.

    The stock phrase 'gods of wood and stone, the work of human hands' (Deuteronomy 4:28; 28:36, 64; Isaiah 37:19).

  • Both: the phrase is a contemptuous way of naming any non-YHWH worship by its materials.

    The two uses overlap in Jeremiah, and a polemic does not need to tell the objects apart. The force is the same either way.

in v10

Is the verse a criticism of Josiah's reform?

  • Yes. The 'false return' is the reform of 622 BC: outward and imposed from above, without real change in loyalty.

    The oracle is dated to Josiah's days (v. 6). It uses the same verb and phrase as 2 Kgs 23:25 ('turned … with all his heart'). Later chapters show idolatry back in force (Jer 7; 11:9–13; 44:17–18). Many commentators, including Thompson and Holladay in various forms, read it as a judgment on how shallow the national response was.

  • It criticizes the people's response, not the king or the reform itself.

    Jeremiah praises Josiah elsewhere for doing justice and knowing Yahweh (22:15–16). The subject here is 'Judah', not the king, so the target is a population that conformed outwardly while the king was sincere.

  • It is a later reflection, written after Jerusalem fell, explaining why reformed Judah still went into exile.

    The prose of 3:6–11 has the style and vocabulary of Deuteronomy and Kings, and it interrupts the poetry. Scholars such as Carroll and McKane assign it to editors in exile who looked back on the failure of the reform, rather than to Jeremiah in Josiah's reign.

in v10

Who wrote the prose unit 3:6–11?

  • It comes from Jeremiah, perhaps preserved and shaped by his scribe Baruch.

    Scholars such as Holladay and Lundbom note how tightly it reuses the shuv wordplay of the surrounding poetry (meshuvah, shuvah, shovavim), which suggests the same mind. The dating to Josiah fits Jeremiah's early ministry.

  • It was written by editors steeped in Deuteronomy.

    Its stock phrases ('with all her heart', 'on every high hill and under every green tree'), its prose form, and its reflection on the fall of the north match the editorial layer of the book. Mowinckel called this 'source C'. Carroll and McKane take this view.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).