Jeremiah Chapter 44 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 44:15–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15Then all the men who knew that their wives were burning incense to other gods, and all the women standing by—a great assembly—along with all the people living in the land of Egypt and in Pathros, said to Jeremiah, 16“As for the word you have spoken to us in the name of the LORD, we will not listen to you! 17Instead, we will do everything we vowed to do: We will burn incense to the Queen of Heaven and offer drink offerings to her, just as we, our fathers, our kings, and our officials did in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem. At that time we had plenty of food and good things, and we saw no disaster. 18But from the time we stopped burning incense to the Queen of Heaven and pouring out drink offerings to her, we have lacked everything and have been perishing by sword and famine.” 19“Moreover,” said the women, “when we burned incense to the Queen of Heaven and poured out drink offerings to her, was it without our husbands’ knowledge that we made sacrificial cakes in her image and poured out drink offerings to her?”
What the first hearers heard
For the exiles who heard and read the book of Jeremiah, in Babylon and in Egypt, this verse sets up the last public confrontation in the prophet's career. The narrator makes three points.
- The refusal was communal. The triple "all" and the word "assembly" show that this was not a few dissenters. It was the whole remnant in Egypt acting as a body, and that explains the sweeping judgement of 44:26–28: only a few survivors would return.
- Responsibility is shared. Women carried out the offerings, but the men "knew," and in Israelite law knowing and keeping silent meant consenting. The story does not let the blame fall on women alone. Husbands, wives and the whole people answer together.
- The covenant is reversed. "Other gods" echoes the first commandment, and "assembly" echoes Sinai. Back in Egypt, the land of the exodus, the covenant people gather and refuse the covenant word. For readers in exile, it explained why the community in Egypt had no future as a restored Judah. It also posed a pointed question about how they themselves would read the disaster of 586: as punishment for idolatry (Jeremiah's reading) or as punishment for neglecting the Queen of Heaven (the people's reading).
From the study of Jeremiah 44:15.
Verse by verse
-
15Then all the men who knew that their wives were burning incense to other gods, and all the women standing by—a great assembly—along with all the people living in the land of Egypt and in Pathros, said to Jeremiah,
Full study →Then they gave Jeremiah their answer. Every man who knew perfectly well, and let it go on, that his wife was regularly sending up offerings in smoke to other gods; all the women standing there, gathered as a great assembly, the kind of gathering that once stood before God at Sinai; indeed the whole people of Judah now settled in the land of Egypt, down into Pathros, the far southern country. Together they answered him, and this is what they said:
The verse is the solemn introduction to a refusal. Three times it says "all" (all the men, all the women, all the people), so that what follows in verses 16–19 is heard as the united voice of the whole refugee community. The husbands are named first and charged with knowing: in Israel a husband who knew of his wife's religious vows and stayed silent shared responsibility for them. The wives' worship is described as an ongoing practice, with "other gods," the classic covenant-breaking phrase from Deuteronomy, as its object. Gathered as a covenant "assembly," they are about to tell the prophet, "we will not listen."
-
16“As for the word you have spoken to us in the name of the LORD, we will not listen to you!
Full study →"That word, the one you have spoken to us claiming Yahweh's own name and authority: we are not people who heed you, and we are not going to."
The sentence begins by setting Jeremiah's message out in front, almost as if the people point at it, and then turns it down. They do not say they misheard or that Jeremiah is a fraud. They grant everything: he spoke, he spoke to them, and he spoke in Yahweh's name. Then they refuse. The Hebrew verb for "listen" means hearing that turns into obeying, so their refusal is not "we won't pay attention". It is "we will not do what you say". The grammar presents this as a fixed stance, not a passing mood.
The sentence opens with Yahweh's word and closes with "to you", meaning Jeremiah. Rejecting the messenger and rejecting the One who sent him are one act. In the next verse they swear to carry out "every word that has gone out of our mouth": burning incense to the Queen of Heaven. So the scene sets the word of Yahweh against the word of the people, and the chapter ends by asking whose word will stand (44:28).
-
17Instead, we will do everything we vowed to do: We will burn incense to the Queen of Heaven and offer drink offerings to her, just as we, our fathers, our kings, and our officials did in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem. At that time we had plenty of food and good things, and we saw no disaster.
Full study →"No. We will most certainly carry out every word of the vow that has left our own mouths, not the word you claim came from YHWH. We will send up the smoke of offerings to the Queen of Heaven and pour out wine to her, exactly as we always did: we ourselves, our ancestors, our kings and the officials who governed us, all through the towns of Judah and openly in the streets of Jerusalem. Back then we ate until we were full, we were thriving, and disaster never touched us."
Behind the plain words lie several pointed echoes:
- The vow. 'Everything that went out of our mouth' is the formula of the Torah's vow law (Num 30:2): a spoken vow must be kept. They answer the prophet's 'word in the name of YHWH' with 'the word from our mouth'.
- Sinai turned around. Their 'we will surely do' sounds like Israel's pledge at Sinai, 'all that YHWH has spoken we will do', now made to a goddess.
- Ancestral and royal precedent. The list 'we, our fathers, our kings, our officials' claims that this was the established religion of Judah, done publicly and approved by the state.
- Blessing language given to her. 'We were filled with bread' and 'we were well off' are Deuteronomy's words for YHWH's covenant blessing. 'We saw no disaster' uses the very word (raʿah) that YHWH uses in this chapter for the catastrophe he brought.
The verse is a reasoned counter-theology: honouring the Queen brought prosperity, and abandoning her (v.18) brought sword and famine.
-
18But from the time we stopped burning incense to the Queen of Heaven and pouring out drink offerings to her, we have lacked everything and have been perishing by sword and famine.”
Full study →"Ever since we quit sending up our smoke-offerings to the Queen of the Heavens and pouring out our wine-offerings to her, we have gone short of everything, and sword and famine have been finishing us off."
Judean refugees in Egypt say this to Jeremiah's face, and in the next verse the women speak in their own name. It is a counter-sermon. In the verse before, they remembered the days when they "were filled with bread, were well off and saw no evil". Now they turn it around. Since that time (most likely King Josiah's reform, which shut down these household rites about forty years earlier) the bread has run out. The words they choose are the words of Israel's own covenant. "Lacking everything" and "famine" are the curse of Deuteronomy 28:48. "Lack nothing" and "bread" were the promise of Deuteronomy 8:9. "Finished by sword and famine" is the sentence Jeremiah has just pronounced on them (44:12). They accept every disaster the prophet named: the war, the starvation, the fall of the city. They deny his explanation. As they read history, the trouble did not come from forsaking Yahweh. It came from forsaking the Queen.
The "smoke" was more than incense. It was a family offering of baked cakes, fire and poured wine (v.19; 7:18). Their argument is simple. The old way worked, and the new way killed us.
-
19“Moreover,” said the women, “when we burned incense to the Queen of Heaven and poured out drink offerings to her, was it without our husbands’ knowledge that we made sacrificial cakes in her image and poured out drink offerings to her?”
Full study →"And as for us, when we kept sending up offering-smoke to the Queen of the Heavens and pouring out wine-offerings to her, was any of that done behind our husbands' backs? Did we bake her special cakes, shaped in her own likeness, and pour out her libations without our men knowing, agreeing and taking part?"
The question expects a firm no. The women of the Judean refugee community in Egypt are not apologising. They are defending themselves with an argument from Israel's own family law. In Israel a married woman's vow to a deity stood only if her husband heard it and let it stand (Numbers 30). By insisting that their husbands were fully involved, the women make their worship of the goddess a household matter that the men approved and that legally binds. It was not some private female deviation.
The ritual they describe is concrete and repeated, and the "we were doing" wording makes it a long-standing habit. It had three parts:
- smoke sent up to the goddess, probably more than incense alone;
- cakes called by a Babylonian-derived name (kawwanim), baked in her image;
- wine libations, a phrase repeated twice to give it the ring of a familiar liturgy.
The verse ends their reply to Jeremiah (vv.15–19). Their reading of history: while we honoured the Queen we had plenty, and since we stopped we have had sword and famine.
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
burned incense
qatar (Piel), meqatterot
- What we hear
- Lighting fragrant incense, a fairly mild devotional act.
- What they heard
- Making offerings go up in smoke to a deity: incense, but also fat, grain or cakes. It is the regular verb in Jeremiah for full sacrificial worship given to other gods.
-
in v15
a great multitude
qahal gadol
- What we hear
- Simply a large crowd.
- What they heard
- A great assembly, a community formally gathered. The word is used for Israel gathered before God, so here it suggests an official communal stand.
-
in v16
we will not listen to you
ʾênennû shōməʿîm (shāmaʿ)
- What we hear
- We won't pay attention to you or hear you out.
- What they heard
- We will not heed or obey you. Shāmaʿ covers hearing and compliance together, and these people have clearly already heard every word.
-
in v16
the LORD
YHWH
- What we hear
- A general title for God.
- What they heard
- The personal name of Israel's God. The people do not reject 'God' in general (they are very religious, v.17). They reject the claim of this particular God, named Yahweh, to their exclusive loyalty.
-
in v17
saw no evil (KJV, WEB)
raʿah lo raʾinu
- What we hear
- We did not see or commit anything morally wicked.
- What they heard
- Nothing bad happened to us: no disaster, harm or misfortune.
-
in v17
our princes (KJV, WEB)
sarenu
- What we hear
- The king's sons, members of the royal family.
- What they heard
- Royal officials: administrators, commanders, the ruling class of Judah's government.
-
in v17
whatsoever thing goeth forth out of our own mouth (KJV)
kol-haddavar asher yatsa mippinu
- What we hear
- Whatever we feel like saying or doing; doing as we please.
- What they heard
- Every word of the vow we have spoken. It is the Torah's formula for a binding vow (Num 30:2), as v.25 confirms ('we will surely perform our vows').
-
in v17
burn incense
leqatter
- What we hear
- Lighting fragrant incense only.
- What they heard
- Making an offering go up in smoke to a deity. It can be incense, but the verb covers burnt offerings in general.
-
in v17
Queen of Heaven
melekhet hashshamayim
- What we hear
- Some readers connect the title with the later Christian title for Mary, 'Queen of Heaven' (Regina Caeli).
- What they heard
- A sixth-century-BCE Near Eastern astral goddess, honoured with cakes, smoke offerings and libations. She has no historical link to any later Christian title.
-
in v18
burning incense
qaṭṭēr
- What we hear
- Lighting incense sticks or spices, a small symbolic gesture of devotion.
- What they heard
- Making offerings go up as smoke: possibly incense, but also burnt cakes, fat or grain, as part of a full family rite with libations.
-
in v18
we have wanted all things (KJV)
ḥāsarnû ḵōl
- What we hear
- We have desired everything.
- What they heard
- We have lacked everything: real material want, matching the covenant curse 'lack of everything' (Deut 28:48).
-
in v18
Queen of Heaven
mᵉleḵet haš-šāmayim
- What we hear
- Readers may connect it with the later Christian title for Mary (Regina caeli), or picture 'Heaven' as the afterlife.
- What they heard
- A title of the ancient Near Eastern sky-goddess (Ishtar/Astarte and related goddesses), queen of the visible heavens and the stars.
-
in v19
burned incense
məqaṭṭərîm (qāṭar)
- What we hear
- Lighting incense, perfumed sticks or a censer, a fairly minor devotional act.
- What they heard
- Making offerings go up in smoke to a deity. This could include grain, fat and the cakes themselves as well as aromatics. It was a real sacrifice offered as a rival to the temple's.
-
in v19
to worship her (KJV, WEB)
lə-haʿăṣībāh
- What we hear
- The cakes were simply a way of showing devotion.
- What they heard
- “To fashion her image”: the cakes were shaped or stamped with the goddess's likeness. They were edible images, and the root is the same as the word for “idol”.
-
in v19
Queen of Heaven
məleket ha-šāmayim
- What we hear
- Readers may connect the phrase with the later Christian title for Mary.
- What they heard
- A title of a Near Eastern sky goddess, most likely an Ishtar/Astarte figure, worshipped in Judah in the 7th–6th centuries BC.
Every word
-
וַיַּעֲנ֣וּ
vayya'anu · H6030B
-
אֶֽת־
'et- · H0853
[object marker] · v15, v17
Untranslatable marker showing that Jeremiah is the one answered.
-
יִרְמְיָ֗הוּ
yirmeyahu · H3414L
Jeremiah · v15
The prophet, taken to Egypt against his will (43:6–7). His name contains the divine name Yahu, which makes the conflict sharper: he speaks for Israel's God, and the people are about to defend their offerings to other gods.
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all · v15, v17, v18
'All.' This is the first of three 'all's in the verse (men, women, people). Together they make the refusal total and communal, not the opinion of a few.
-
הָאֲנָשִׁ֤ים
ha'anashim · H0582
men · v15, v19
'The men,' meaning the adult males and heads of households. This is the usual plural of ʾish ('man'), filed in this database under ʾenosh.
-
הַיֹּֽדְעִים֙
hayyode'im · H3045
to know · v15
'Who knew,' a participle describing a lasting state. The husbands were fully aware of what their wives were doing and let it go on. In Israelite law that awareness made them responsible for it (compare 44:19).
-
כִּֽי־
ki- · H3588A
that · v15, v17, v19
Introduces what the men knew.
-
מְקַטְּר֤וֹת
meqatterot · H6999H
to make offerings smoke · v15, v17, v18, v19
'Were making [offerings] go up in smoke.' It is a feminine plural participle, describing a regular, ongoing practice rather than a single act. In Jeremiah this form of the verb is the usual word for burning offerings to gods other than the LORD.
-
נְשֵׁיהֶם֙
nesheihem · H0802H
their wives · v15
'Their wives.' The same word means 'women' in general. The possessive 'their' ties each woman's worship to her husband's household.
-
לֵאלֹהִ֣ים
le'lohim · H0430J
to gods · v15
'To gods.' Here the word is a true plural meaning deities, not Israel's God. Verses 17–19 name the main one as 'the Queen of Heaven.'
-
אֲחֵרִ֔ים
'acherim · H0312
other · v15
'Other.' Together with the previous word this makes the stock phrase 'other gods' from Deuteronomy and the Ten Commandments, the standard way of naming a breach of the covenant.
-
הָעֹמְד֖וֹת
ha'omedot · H5975G
to stand · v15
'Who were standing [there],' meaning present at the gathering. YLT's 'remaining' takes the verb in its other sense ('to stay, remain'), but most readers take it as being present.
-
קָהָ֣ל
qahal · H6951
assembly · v15
'An assembly.' This is the word for Israel gathered as a community, the same word used for the people assembled at Sinai. Here the 'assembly' gathers to refuse the LORD's word, which is a bitter irony.
-
גָּד֑וֹל
gadol · H1419A
great, large · v15
'Great.' The gathering was large; the refusal had the weight of numbers behind it.
-
הָעָ֛ם
ha'am · H5971A
the people · v15
'The people.' This is the word for Judah as a kin-and-covenant people, now living away from their land.
-
הַיֹּשְׁבִ֥ים
hayyoshvim · H3427
to dwell · v15
'Who were living.' The verb implies settling down to stay. Verse 14 used a different verb, 'sojourn as resident aliens' (gur), so the narrator's word suggests they had made Egypt home.
-
בְּאֶֽרֶץ־
be'erets- · H0776G
in the land of · v15
'In the land of.'
-
מִצְרַ֖יִם
mitsrayim · H4714G
Egypt · v15
'Egypt.' The 'house of slavery' Israel's story began by leaving. Going back there reverses the exodus.
-
בְּפַתְר֥וֹס
befatros · H6624
Pathros · v15
'In Pathros,' from the Egyptian for 'the Southern Land,' meaning Upper (southern) Egypt. Either it pins down where the assembly met or it names the farthest region of the Judean settlement (see debates).
-
לֵאמֹֽר׃
lemor · H0559
saying · v15
'Saying,' which works like a colon and introduces their direct speech in verses 16–19.
-
הַדָּבָ֛ר
haddāvār · H1697
the word, message, matter · v16, v17
The prophetic message Jeremiah has just delivered (44:2–14). It comes first in the sentence and then hangs there: 'The word you spoke…' is set out as a topic, and the sentence then turns on it with a flat refusal.
-
אֲשֶׁר־
ʾăsher · H834
which, that · v16, v17
Relative particle linking 'the word' to the clause that describes it: the one you spoke.
-
דִּבַּ֥רְתָּ
dibbartā · H1696
speak · v16
'You have spoken', a completed act addressed to Jeremiah (singular 'you'). It shares a root with 'word' (dāvār … dibbartā), so the line repeats itself: 'the word you worded'. That is a normal Hebrew idiom, but it puts weight on the speech they are turning down.
-
אֵלֵ֖ינוּ
ʾēlênû · H413
to, toward · v16
'To us.' The people accept that the message was aimed at them directly. They do not deny they heard it.
-
בְּשֵׁ֣ם
bəshēm · H8034
name · v16
'In the name of', which means speaking as Yahweh's authorized spokesman, under his authority. The people repeat Jeremiah's claim to that authority and reject the message anyway.
-
יְהוָ֑ה
YHWH (Yahweh) · H3068
Yahweh, the LORD · v16
The personal name of Israel's God. The refugees still say the name and do not deny Yahweh exists. What they refuse is his claim to be their only god (v.17 shows them going back to the Queen of Heaven alongside him).
-
אֵינֶ֥נּוּ
ʾênennû · H369
there is not; not · v16
The negative 'there is no…' with 'we' attached: 'we are not'. Paired with a participle, it denies an ongoing state, so it sounds more like a settled position ('we are not ones who listen') than a single future act.
-
שֹׁמְעִ֖ים
shōməʿîm · H8085
hear, listen, obey · v16
An ongoing 'listening/heeding'. In this kind of setting shāmaʿ means hearing that leads to doing what is said. They have plainly heard the words with their ears. What they refuse is to obey.
-
עָשֹׂ֨ה
ʿasoh · H6213A
do (infinitive absolute) · v17, v19
The bare verb 'doing' set in front of the same verb for emphasis: 'we will most certainly do'. It is a declaration of fixed resolve.
-
יָצָ֣א
yatsaʾ · H3318O
go out, come forth · v17
'Has gone out'. With 'from the mouth' this is the standard idiom for a vow or oath once spoken, which binds the speaker (Num 30:2; Judg 11:36). Verse 25 confirms it: 'we will surely perform our vows'.
-
מִפִּ֗ינוּ
mippinu · H6310G
from our mouth · v17
'From our mouth', not from YHWH's mouth. The contrast with the prophet's 'word in the name of YHWH' is deliberate.
-
לִמְלֶ֣כֶת
limlekhet · H4446
to the queen of · v17, v18, v19
A royal title for a goddess, 'the Queen'. Its unusual vowels may be a scribal way of avoiding the plain word 'queen' (see textual notes).
-
הַשָּׁמַיִם֮
hashshamayim · H8064
the heavens, the sky · v17, v18, v19
The sky where the astral powers live. The title places her among the heavenly bodies, probably tied to the planet Venus.
-
וְהַסֵּֽיךְ־
vehassekh · H5258A
and to pour out · v17, v18, v19
'And to pour out' a liquid offering. The word pairs naturally with the burnt offering before it, so together they describe a full worship ritual.
-
לָ֣הּ
lah · H9034
to her · v17, v18, v19
'To her': the feminine pronoun makes plain that a female deity receives the offerings.
-
נְסָכִים֒
nesakhim · H5262
drink offerings, libations · v17, v18, v19
Libations, usually wine, poured out for a deity. The same kind of offering belonged to YHWH's own sacrifices (Num 15:5–10).
-
אֲנַ֤חְנוּ
ʾanachnu · H0587
we · v17, v19
An emphatic 'we ourselves' that heads a list of everyone who took part.
-
וַאֲבֹתֵ֙ינוּ֙
vaʾavoteinu · H0001G
and our fathers · v17
'Our ancestors'. Ancestral practice carried great authority in a kinship society: this is the religion of the family line.
-
מְלָכֵ֣ינוּ
melakheinu · H4428G
our kings · v17
'Our kings'. They claim royal sanction, meaning the cult had been official, not fringe.
-
וְשָׂרֵ֔ינוּ
vesareinu · H8269
and our officials · v17
The royal administrators and commanders, the governing class of Judah. It does not mean the king's sons.
-
בְּעָרֵ֣י
beʿarei · H5892B
in the cities of · v17
Across the towns of the land. The practice was widespread.
-
יְהוּדָ֔ה
Yehudah · H3063G
Judah · v17
The southern kingdom, now destroyed. The speakers are its refugees.
-
וּבְחֻצ֖וֹת
uvechutsot · H2351
and in the streets of · v17
'The outside places', meaning open streets and public spaces. The worship was done openly, not in secret.
-
יְרוּשָׁלִָ֑ם
Yerushalayim · H3389
Jerusalem · v17
The capital and YHWH's chosen city. The goddess was honoured in its very streets (compare Jer 7:17–18).
-
וַנִּֽשְׂבַּֽע־
vannisbaʿ · H7646
-
לֶ֙חֶם֙
lechem · H3899G
bread, food · v17
Bread as the staple, and so food in general. 'Filled with bread' means there was no hunger. It is the reverse of the famine in v.18.
-
וַנִּֽהְיֶ֣ה
vannihyeh · H1961
and we were · v17
Another narrative past: 'and we were'.
-
טוֹבִ֔ים
tovim · H2896A
good, well-off · v17
'Well', in the sense of prosperous and thriving, not morally good. It means 'we were doing well'.
-
וְרָעָ֖ה
veraʿah · H7451C
-
לֹ֥א
loʾ · H3808
not · v17
A plain negative.
-
רָאִֽינוּ׃
raʾinu · H7200G
we saw · v17
'Saw', in the Hebrew sense of experiencing. 'We never saw disaster' means 'nothing bad happened to us'.
-
וּמִן־
ū-min · H4480A
and from · v18
'And from…' Paired with the next word it means 'ever since'. It marks the start of a period that runs up to the moment of speaking. The 'and' carries on from v.17 and sets the bad present against the good past.
-
אָ֡ז
ʾāz · H0227B
then · v18
'Then'. With 'from' it means 'since that time'. The speakers point to a turning point everyone in the crowd knows, most likely King Josiah's reform about forty years earlier.
-
חָדַ֜לְנוּ
ḥādalnû · H2308
we ceased, left off · v18
'We stopped'. The verb means quitting a habit or practice. They present the ending of the goddess's rites as the moment everything went wrong.
-
חָסַ֣רְנוּ
ḥāsarnû · H2637
we have lacked, been in want · v18
'We have gone short'. It is the opposite of 'we were filled with bread' in v.17. It also echoes Deuteronomy's promise of a land where 'you will lack nothing' (Deut 8:9), now said to have failed.
-
וּבַחֶ֥רֶב
ū-ḇa-ḥereḇ · H2719
and by the sword · v18
'And by the sword': war, invasion and slaughter. It is the first half of Jeremiah's own stock phrase of judgment.
-
וּבָרָעָ֖ב
ū-ḇā-rāʿāḇ · H7458
and by the famine · v18
'And by famine', the hunger of siege and ruined harvests. The 'the' points to the specific famine they had all lived through, above all the siege of Jerusalem.
-
תָּֽמְנוּ׃
tāmᵉnû · H8552
we have come to an end, been finished · v18
'We have been finished off', used of a people being used up and wiped out. It is the same verb Jeremiah used in his threat of 44:12 ('by sword and famine they will be finished'), and the people throw it back at him.
-
הֲמִֽבַּלְעֲדֵ֣י
ha-mib-bilʿădê · H1107
(is it) apart from / without · v19
The ha- turns the sentence into a question expecting “No!”: “Was it apart from our men…?” The preposition means “without the involvement/consent of”, which is more than “without their knowing about it”.
-
כַּוָּנִים֙
kawwānîm · H3561
cult cakes · v19
A loanword from Akkadian (the language of Babylon and Assyria), kamānu, a kind of sweet cake offered to Ishtar. Outside this verse it appears only in Jeremiah 7:18. It is a technical cult term, not the everyday word for bread.
-
לְהַ֣עֲצִבָ֔ה
lə-haʿăṣībāh · H6087B
to fashion (an image of) her · v19
“To make an image of her” or “to represent her”, from the verb that gives ʿāṣāb, “idol, shaped image”. The cakes were most likely shaped or stamped with the goddess's likeness. The KJV's “to worship her” follows the Latin Vulgate and is not the Hebrew.
The world behind it
After the fall of Jerusalem. Babylon destroyed Jerusalem and the temple in 587/586 BC. The governor Babylon appointed, Gedaliah, was murdered soon afterwards (Jer 41). Fearing Babylonian reprisal, the remaining Judean leaders asked Jeremiah for a word from the LORD, received a command to stay in Judah, and went to Egypt anyway, taking Jeremiah and Baruch with them (Jer 42–43).
Judeans across Egypt. Chapter 44 is addressed to Judeans living at Migdol and Tahpanhes (border forts in the eastern Delta), at Noph (Memphis), and in Pathros (Upper Egypt) (44:1). Judeans had been settling in Egypt for some time, some as mercenaries in Pharaoh's garrisons. A century later, the Aramaic papyri from Elephantine show a Judean garrison community in the far south with its own temple to YHW. Its records also list other divine names linked with Yahu (Anat-Yahu, Anat-Bethel), which shows how ancestral Judean worship could take in other deities.
The women's cult. Verses 17–19 say the women burned offerings, poured drink offerings and baked cakes "to the Queen of Heaven," a goddess they had worshipped in the towns and streets of Judah before the exile (compare Jer 7:18, where whole families take part). This was household and family religion. It was not a foreign novelty but long-standing popular practice that Josiah's reform (2 Kgs 23) had suppressed. The people's argument in verses 17–18 is that their disasters began when they stopped these offerings.
Husbands and vows. Under Numbers 30, a husband who heard of his wife's vow and did not cancel it let it stand, and shared responsibility for it. That is why the verse stresses that the men "knew," and why the women say in v. 19, "Was it without our husbands that we made her cakes?"
From the study of Jeremiah 44:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
Where and how did this 'great assembly' take place, given that it includes people 'in Pathros' (Upper Egypt) while Jeremiah was in the Delta?
-
An actual gathering, possibly at a festival or in Pathros itself, where Jeremiah addressed the community.
The verse uses the language of a concrete event ('standing by,' 'assembly'), and 44:1 shows Jeremiah's word was addressed to Pathros among other places. Jeremiah could have travelled, or representatives from Pathros could have been present.
-
A literary summary that presents the whole Egyptian diaspora answering as one body.
The triple 'all,' the abrupt 'in Pathros' with no 'and,' and Jeremiah's last known location at Tahpanhes (43:8) suggest the scene is a stylised portrait of the community's collective response.
-
'In Pathros' is a later scribal addition.
The awkward grammar, and the view of commentators such as Bright and Holladay that the phrase was inserted from 44:1.
in v15
Who were the 'other gods,' chiefly the 'Queen of Heaven' named in vv. 17–19, that the women offered to?
-
Ishtar/Astarte, the Mesopotamian–Phoenician goddess of love, fertility and the morning/evening star.
The kawwanim cakes of v. 19 correspond to Akkadian kamānu cakes offered to Ishtar. 'Queen of Heaven' matches Ishtar's titles, and Phoenician Astarte was widely worshipped.
-
Asherah, Canaanite and Israelite consort of the high god.
Inscriptions from Kuntillet 'Ajrud and Khirbet el-Qom mention 'Yahweh and his asherah,' and many female pillar figurines have been found in Judahite homes. Opponents point out that Asherah is not called 'Queen of Heaven' in surviving texts.
-
Anat, or a combined goddess drawing on several of these figures.
Egyptian texts give Anat and Astarte titles like 'Lady of Heaven,' and Elephantine names such as 'Anat-Yahu' suggest Judeans in Egypt honoured Anat. Many scholars (e.g. Ackerman) see a blended West Semitic goddess.
in v16
What exactly did the refugees reject, and on what grounds?
-
An open rejection of Yahweh's exclusive claim, rooted in polytheism the people had practised all along.
V.17 says 'we, our fathers, our kings and our officials' did these rites in Judah's cities. Jer 7:18 already condemns Queen of Heaven worship in Jerusalem. The book's editors present the scene as the climax of Israel's long refusal to listen.
-
A considered theological argument blaming the disaster on Josiah's reform, not necessarily denying Yahweh but reviving older forms of worship.
V.18: 'since we stopped… we have lacked everything'. This lines up with the end of the cult after Josiah (c. 622 BC) and the decline that followed (Josiah's death in 609, the exile). Scholars such as Susan Ackerman argue the Queen of Heaven cult was popular, family-based religion that many Judeans did not see as disloyal to Yahweh.
in v17, v18
Who was the 'Queen of Heaven'?
-
Ishtar, or a blend of Ishtar and Astarte (the most widely held view).
Ishtar bears the title *šarrat šamê*, 'queen of heaven', and is the Venus star. The *kawwanim* cakes of v.19 match the Akkadian *kamānu* cakes for Ishtar. Assyrian influence in Judah was strong under Manasseh. West Semitic Astarte was the local counterpart of Ishtar (argued by S. Olyan and S. Ackerman).
-
Asherah.
Asherah was the most prominent goddess in Judah: the Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qom inscriptions mention 'YHWH and his asherah', and Josiah removed Asherah's objects (2 Kgs 23). But the title 'queen of heaven' is not attested for her, and she is not especially an astral goddess.
-
Anat.
An Egyptian-period stela from Beth-Shan calls Anat 'queen of heaven'. Jews at Elephantine in Egypt later venerated Anat-Yahu. Against this, Anat is not clearly attested in seventh-century Judah.
-
A composite figure, not one deity.
Ancient worshippers easily merged goddesses. A Hermopolis papyrus shows a 'Queen of Heaven' temple in Egypt c. 500 BCE without naming her. Jeremiah himself never gives a personal name.
in v17
Was this a foreign cult or part of traditional Judahite religion practised alongside YHWH?
-
Popular Judahite religion, practised alongside YHWH worship.
The speakers claim ancestral, royal and official sanction across Judah and Jerusalem. Female figurines are found throughout Judahite homes. Jews at Elephantine later worshipped goddesses alongside YHW. Jeremiah 44:26 implies these people still swore 'as the Lord YHWH lives'.
-
Apostasy to 'other gods', as the book presents it.
Jeremiah consistently classes the cult under 'other gods' (7:18; 44:3, 5, 8, 15). Deuteronomy's demand for exclusive worship, which these texts assume, leaves no room for a consort or a second divine provider.
in v18
What moment does 'since we stopped' refer to?
-
Josiah's reform (c. 622 BCE)
2 Kings 23 records the removal of 'host of heaven' worship. After that came Josiah's death, vassalage, deportation and destruction, which matches the speakers' story of decline. Most commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) take this view.
-
A later, more local break, such as during the final siege or in response to Jeremiah's preaching
The vague 'from then' could refer to a shorter interruption remembered by those present. But 7:18 shows the cult was alive again under Jehoiakim, so any stopping was not permanent.
in v19
Who is the “Queen of Heaven”?
-
A Mesopotamian Ishtar figure, perhaps blended with West Semitic Astarte
The exact title šarrat šamê, the Akkadian loanword kawwānîm (kamānu cakes offered to Ishtar), Ishtar's link with the Venus star, and the strong Assyrian influence on Judah in the 7th century. This is the view of Susan Ackerman and many others.
-
Astarte (Phoenician/Canaanite)
Astarte is called “queen of heaven” in later Phoenician and Egyptian sources and was the goddess of the coastal neighbours Judah dealt with most.
-
Anat
Egyptian texts call Anat “mistress of heaven”, and Judeans at Elephantine in Egypt honoured Anat-Yahu, which fits the Egyptian setting of chapter 44.
-
Asherah
Asherah was the most prominent goddess in Judah's own religious history (inscriptions reading “YHWH and his Asherah”, many female figurines). But she is never called “queen of heaven” in the Bible or in inscriptions.
in v19
Who speaks v.19: the women alone, or the whole community?
-
The women
The content (baking cakes, “our husbands”) only makes sense from wives. Verse 15 points ahead to the women, and Jeremiah later says “you and your wives” (v.25). Many translations add “said the women”.
-
The whole people, or an editorial reworking
The participle məqaṭṭərîm is masculine plural, and v.20 says Jeremiah answered “men and women”. Some scholars think the verse as it now stands was shaped by later editing or combines speakers. Others note that Hebrew often uses masculine forms loosely.
in v19
What exactly does lə-haʿăṣībāh mean?
-
“To make an image of her”: cakes shaped or stamped with her likeness
The root is the one behind ʿăṣabbîm, “idols”, and clay moulds from Mari include female-figure shapes. This view lies behind BSB, ESV, NIV and NASB.
-
“To represent/portray her” more loosely, or “to worship her”
The Vulgate (“ad colendum eam”) and the KJV. Some note the written form's missing dot and suggest the reading has been altered. The case for an image remains stronger.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. קטר (Piel 'make sacrifices smoke')
- HALOT s.v. קָהָל
- BDB s.v. פַּתְרוֹס (Egyptian p3-t3-rsy)
- J. Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
- B. Porten, Archives from Elephantine
- S. Ackerman, Under Every Green Tree: Popular Religion in Sixth-Century Judah
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jeremiah 44
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 51:15 (Rahlfs)
- BDB s.v. שָׁמַע
- HALOT s.v. שׁמע
- HALOT s.v. אַיִן
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, §37.6 (participles with negation)
- Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 37–52 (Anchor Bible)
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia)
- Susan Ackerman, Under Every Green Tree: Popular Religion in Sixth-Century Judah
- Bezalel Porten, Archives from Elephantine
- BDB s.v. מְלֶכֶת, קָטַר, רָעָה, שָׂבֵעַ
- HALOT s.v. קטר (piel: 'to make a sacrifice go up in smoke'), s.v. מְלֶכֶת
- S. Ackerman, 'And the Women Knead Dough: The Worship of the Queen of Heaven in Sixth-Century Judah', in P. Day (ed.), Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel (1989)
- S. Ackerman, Under Every Green Tree: Popular Religion in Sixth-Century Judah (1992)
- S. M. Olyan, 'Some Observations Concerning the Identity of the Queen of Heaven', Ugarit-Forschungen 19 (1987)
- O. Keel and C. Uehlinger, Gods, Goddesses, and Images of God in Ancient Israel
- B. Porten, The Elephantine Papyri in English (Hermopolis papyri)
- Septuagint Jeremiah 51:17 and 7:18; Targum Jonathan to Jeremiah 44:17; Vulgate
- BDB s.v. קָטַר, חָסֵר, תָּמַם, מְלֶכֶת
- HALOT s.v. קטר, חסר, תמם, מְלֶכֶת
- S. Ackerman, 'And the Women Knead Dough: The Worship of the Queen of Heaven in Sixth-Century Judah' (1989)
- M. Haran, Temples and Temple-Service in Ancient Israel (on qṭr)
- B. Porten, The Elephantine Papyri in English (Hermopolis letters; Anat-Yahu)
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 51:17–19 (Greek order)
- BDB s.v. כַּוָּן, עָצַב II, קָטַר, בִּלְעֲדֵי
- HALOT s.v. כַּוָּן (Akkadian kamānu), מְלֶכֶת
- Susan Ackerman, “‘And the Women Knead Dough’: The Worship of the Queen of Heaven in Sixth-Century Judah,” in Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel (1989)
- Susan Ackerman, Under Every Green Tree: Popular Religion in Sixth-Century Judah (1992)
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 2 (Hermeneia), on 44:15–19
- Menahem Haran, Temples and Temple-Service in Ancient Israel, on the verb qiṭṭēr
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 51:19 (χαυῶνας; βασίλισσα τοῦ οὐρανοῦ)
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 44:19 (“ad colendum eam”)
- Hermopolis Aramaic papyri (mention of a temple of the Queen of Heaven at Syene)
- Numbers 30:6–15 (husband's confirmation or cancellation of a wife's vows)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).