Jeremiah Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 5:17–19

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17They will devour your harvest and food; they will consume your sons and daughters; they will eat up your flocks and herds; they will feed on your vines and fig trees. With the sword they will destroy the fortified cities in which you trust.” 18“Yet even in those days,” declares the LORD, “I will not make a full end of you. 19And when the people ask, ‘For what offense has the LORD our God done all these things to us?’ You are to tell them, ‘Just as you have forsaken Me and served foreign gods in your land, so will you serve foreigners in a land that is not your own.’”

What the first hearers heard

For farmers and townspeople in Judah the verse lists, item by item, everything that made life possible. It covers the grain harvest, daily bread, children, sheep and goats, cattle, vineyards and fig orchards, and the walled cities that were supposed to protect them all. There is no category left untouched. The singular "you" makes the whole nation one person being stripped bare.

Anyone who knew the covenant traditions would recognise the language of Deuteronomy 28: a foreign nation that "eats" your produce and besieges you "until the walls in which you trust come down." So the verse works as more than a war report. It is the covenant's curse arriving, and it points to the cause: Judah has been relying on its fortifications (and, elsewhere in Jeremiah, on the temple, on political alliances and on other gods) instead of on YHWH. The verse aimed to break that false confidence. Even so, the next line (5:18) tells them that the judgment, though total in its reach, will not be the final end of the people.

From the study of Jeremiah 5:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17They will devour your harvest and food; they will consume your sons and daughters; they will eat up your flocks and herds; they will feed on your vines and fig trees. With the sword they will destroy the fortified cities in which you trust.”

    The invading nation God is bringing (v.15) becomes one enormous mouth, and Hebrew says "it will eat" four times over. It will eat your harvest and your bread: the grain standing in your fields and the loaves on your table. They will eat your sons and your daughters: its soldiers will cut down or carry off your children, the future of every household. (The KJV reads this line differently: "the bread your sons and daughters should have eaten".) It will eat your flocks and your herds: every sheep, goat and ox you own. It will eat your vine and your fig tree: the trees that take years to bear, the very picture of a peaceful life where "each sits under his own vine and fig tree". Last of all, it will smash your walled fortress-cities, the ones you are leaning on for safety, with the sword. That final word shows what has been "eating" all along: the sword, which in Hebrew has a mouth.

    The "you" is singular throughout, so Judah is addressed as one person stripped of everything it lives by, from field to table to children to livestock to orchards to walls. Anyone who knew the covenant warnings would recognise the curse of Deuteronomy 28: a far-off nation "will eat the fruit of your ground… until your high fortified walls in which you trust come down." The sting is in "which you trust": the walls are named as the false security that replaced trust in God. The next verse limits the threat: "yet even in those days… I will not make a full end of you."

    Full study →
  2. 18“Yet even in those days,” declares the LORD, “I will not make a full end of you.

    "And yet, even in those days (this is the LORD's own declaration), I will not carry out a total finishing-off against you."

    The verse comes straight after a picture of an invading nation that eats everything: harvest, bread, sons and daughters, flocks and herds, vines and fig trees, and finally the fortified cities Judah trusted (v.17). Hebrew uses "eat/devour" four times in that one verse. Then comes a small "and yet" (vegam). The time is the same, "in those days", the days of the invasion and not some distant future, and the speaker is the same God who is bringing the invader. He sets one limit. The word kalah means a "full end": something used up, finished, consumed until nothing is left. The invader will eat almost everything, but God will not let Judah be eaten to the last bite.

    Several details matter:

    • "I will not do" is in the first person. God, not Babylon, decides how far the destruction goes.
    • "With you" is plural. Verse 17 spoke to the nation as one person ("your harvest… your sons"). Verse 18 turns to the people as a group of real individuals who will live through it.
    • "Declaration of the LORD" stands in the middle of the sentence like a seal. This limit is not the prophet's wishful thinking.

    The promise is not comfort in the sense of rescue. The next verse says what "no full end" will look like: those who served foreign gods in their own land will serve foreigners in a land not their own (v.19). Survival will mean exile. Still, survival is the point. However severe the judgment, it stops short of wiping out the people God had bound himself to.

    Full study →
  3. 19And when the people ask, ‘For what offense has the LORD our God done all these things to us?’ You are to tell them, ‘Just as you have forsaken Me and served foreign gods in your land, so will you serve foreigners in a land that is not your own.’”

    A day is coming, after the invader has eaten up your harvests, your flocks, your sons and daughters and your walled towns (5:15–17), when you will turn and ask: "What is all this payment for? What did we do that Yahweh, our own God, has done all this to us?" When that day comes, prophet, here is your answer, already written:

    "You walked out on me, the God you were bound to, and you worshipped and served the gods of other nations, right here in the land I gave you. So now you will serve outsiders, foreign masters and their gods, in a land that is not yours."

    The answer mirrors the crime point for point. The same word 'serve' is used for both the worship they chose and the bondage they will suffer: the gods they bowed to as servants become the masters who rule them. 'In your land' becomes 'in a land not yours.' They brought outsider gods into their home, so they will be taken out to live under outsiders in someone else's home. Their question used the language of repayment ('in exchange for what?'), and the reply answers in kind: this is the exchange you made. The verse comes right after God's promise that he will 'not make a full end' of them (5:18). The people will survive, but as servants in exile.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    they shall impoverish thy fenced cities (KJV); it maketh poor (YLT)

    yeroshesh

    What we hear
    The invaders will make the cities poor, perhaps through tribute or economic hardship; 'fenced' suggests a simple fence.
    What they heard
    They will beat down and shatter the walled fortress-cities: physical demolition by war.
  • in v17

    they shall eat up your sons and your daughters

    yokhelu (from 'akhal)

    What we hear
    Read literally, the invaders will practise cannibalism.
    What they heard
    'Eat' is the ordinary Hebrew idiom for consuming or destroying, as fire, the sword or an enemy 'eats'. The children will be killed or taken captive. (The separate siege-famine curse, where people eat their own children, is Deut 28:53 / Jer 19:9, not this verse.)
  • in v18

    the LORD

    YHWH

    What we hear
    A general title, 'the Lord', which could apply to any deity or ruler.
    What they heard
    The personal, covenant name of Israel's God. Hearers would have heard a name: the God who had bound himself to Israel by covenant. That is why it carries weight that he, specifically, refuses to make a full end of them.
  • in v19

    strange gods (KJV)

    ʾelohei nekhar

    What we hear
    Odd, bizarre or weird deities.
    What they heard
    Gods belonging to other nations and lands, foreign gods brought into Israel.
  • in v19

    serve

    ʿavad

    What we hear
    To help, assist or wait on someone. 'Serving gods' and 'serving foreigners' sound like two unrelated activities.
    What they heard
    One verb covering both worship of a god and labor or subjection under a master or overlord. The verse depends on the same word naming both the idolatry and the bondage that results.
  • in v19

    strangers (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    zarim

    What we hear
    People you have not met, unfamiliar faces.
    What they heard
    Outsiders who do not belong to your people, here foreign conquerors acting as masters. In Jeremiah the word can also mean foreign gods.
Every word
  1. וְאָכַ֨ל

    we'akhal · H0398

    and it will eat · v17

    The first of four 'eats'. The subject is the invading 'nation' of v.15. The verb form continues the future of 'Behold, I am bringing' (v.15), so it means 'and it will eat'. YLT's past tense 'hath consumed' misreads the form.

  2. קְצִֽירְךָ֜

    qetsirekha · H7105A

    harvest · v17

    The reaped grain crop (barley and wheat), the year's labor in the fields. 'Your' is singular: Judah is spoken to as one person.

  3. וְלַחְמֶ֗ךָ

    welachmekha · H3899G

    bread, food · v17

    Bread, and by extension food in general: the harvest turned into the household's daily meals. The invader eats both the crop in the field and the bread on the table.

  4. בָּנֶ֣יךָ

    banekha · H1121A

    sons · v17

    Your sons. On the majority reading they are what gets 'eaten', meaning killed or carried off by the army. This is not cannibalism.

  5. וּבְנוֹתֶ֔יךָ

    uvenotekha · H1323G

    daughters · v17

    And your daughters. Sons and daughters together stand for the whole next generation, the household's future.

  6. צֹאנְךָ֙

    tsonekha · H6629G

    flock · v17

    The collective word for sheep and goats, the small livestock that gave milk, wool and meat.

  7. וּבְקָרֶ֔ךָ

    uvqarekha · H1241

    herd, cattle · v17

    Cattle, the large livestock used for plowing and as a store of wealth. 'Flock and herd' together means all of your animals.

  8. גַּפְנְךָ֖

    gafnekha · H1612

    vine · v17

    Your vine (singular, but meaning all of them). Vines take years to become productive, so losing them is a long-term ruin and not just one bad season.

  9. וּתְאֵנָתֶ֑ךָ

    ut'enatekha · H8384

    fig tree · v17

    Your fig tree. 'Vine and fig tree' was Israel's stock picture of settled peace and prosperity (1 Kgs 4:25; Mic 4:4), and here that picture is being eaten up.

  10. יְרֹשֵׁ֞שׁ

    yeroshesh · H7567

    beat down, shatter · v17

    An intensive form of a rare verb meaning to beat down or shatter. Its only other clear use is Malachi 1:4, of Edom 'beaten down'. The KJV's 'impoverish' follows a similar-sounding root meaning 'be poor'.

  11. עָרֵ֣י

    'arey · H5892B

    cities of · v17

    Cities, here joined to the next word to mean 'your fortress-cities'.

  12. מִבְצָרֶ֗יךָ

    mivtsarekha · H4013

    fortification · v17

    Strongholds, fortified places. 'Cities of your fortifications' means your walled cities, such as Lachish and Azekah, Judah's military backbone.

  13. אֲשֶׁ֥ר

    'asher · H0834A

    which · v17, v19

    Introduces the stinging relative clause: the cities 'which you are trusting in'.

  14. אַתָּ֛ה

    'attah · H0859A

    you · v17

    An explicit 'you', which Hebrew does not need grammatically. It points the finger: *you* are the one relying on them.

  15. בּוֹטֵ֥חַ

    boteach · H0982

    trusting, relying · v17

    A participle, describing an ongoing state: 'are relying on', 'feel secure in'. In Jeremiah this is a loaded word for misplaced security (7:4; 17:5).

  16. בָּהֵ֖נָּה

    bahennah · H9039

    in them · v17

    'In them' (feminine plural, referring back to the cities). It resumes the object of 'trusting': the cities in which you trust.

  17. בֶּחָֽרֶב׃

    becharev · H2719

    with the sword · v17

    'With the sword' comes last for emphasis and names the instrument of the whole devastation. In Hebrew idiom the sword itself 'eats' (2 Sam 2:26; Jer 2:30), so this word ties back to all the 'eating'.

  18. וְגַ֛ם

    vegam · H1571

    and also, even, yet · v18

    'And even' or 'and yet'. It looks back at the total devastation just described in v.17 and adds something unexpected: even then there is a limit. Its force is concessive, close to 'yet even so'.

  19. בַּיָּמִ֥ים

    bayyamim · H3117

    day; (plural) days, time, period · v18

    'In the days'. The plural means a stretch of time, the whole period of invasion and its aftermath. It is not a single calendar day.

  20. הָהֵ֖מָּה

    hahemmah · H1992

    they, those · v18

    'Those', pointing back to the days of the invading 'nation from afar' (vv.15–17). It refers to the coming catastrophe, not to a far-off end of the world.

  21. נְאֻם־

    ne'um · H5002

    utterance, oracle, declaration · v18

    'Utterance of', a formal prophetic stamp: what follows is YHWH's own spoken word, passed on by the prophet. Placed in the middle of the sentence, it gives the promise extra weight.

  22. יְהֹוָ֑ה

    YHWH · H3068

    YHWH (the divine name), 'the LORD' · v18, v19

    Israel's God, named by his own covenant name: the God who had bound himself to this people, and who is both the one punishing them and the one setting the limit.

  23. לֹֽא־

    lo' · H3808

    not · v18, v19

    A flat negation of the verb that follows: 'I will not'. It is a firm statement of intent, not a 'maybe'.

  24. אֶעֱשֶׂ֥ה

    e'eseh · H6213

    do, make, carry out · v18, v19

    'I will do/make', first person singular. God himself is the one acting in the judgment. Together with kalah it forms a set phrase, 'to make a full end', meaning to finish someone off completely.

  25. אִתְּכֶ֖ם

    ittekhem · H0854

    with · v18

    'With you', where 'you' is plural. The phrase means 'deal with you', 'do to you'. The switch from the singular 'you' of v.17 (the nation pictured as one person) to the plural here addresses the people as a body of individuals.

  26. כָּלָֽה׃

    kalah · H3617

    complete end, annihilation, full destruction · v18

    A finishing-off, a destruction so complete that nothing is left. It comes from the verb 'to be finished, used up, spent', and is the image of something consumed to the last scrap. That fits the fourfold 'eat/devour' of v.17.

  27. וְהָיָה֙

    vehayah · H1961

    and it will be · v19

    A standard opening for a future scene: 'and it shall come about.' It sets up a moment that has not happened yet, when the disaster has already fallen.

  28. כִּ֣י

    ki · H3588A

    that, when · v19

    After 'it will be' this means 'when.' It marks the moment the people will ask their question.

  29. תֹאמְר֔וּ

    tomeru · H0559

    you (plural) will say · v19

    The people as a group speak. God puts their future complaint into words before they say it.

  30. תַּ֣חַת

    tachat · H8478J

    under; instead of; in return for · v19

    With 'what' it means 'in return for what?' or 'on what account?' It is a word of exchange and payment. The people ask what they did to deserve this.

  31. מֶ֗ה

    meh · H4100

    what? · v19

    The question word. Together with tachat it asks, 'What is this the payment for?'

  32. אֱלֹהֵ֛ינוּ

    ʾeloheinu · H0430G

    our God · v19

    The people still call him 'our God' even as they complain. That is the irony: they call him theirs, but they have been serving others.

  33. לָ֖נוּ

    lanu · H9035

    to us · v19

    'To us,' meaning done against us. The complaint is personal.

  34. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    (object marker) · v19

    An untranslated word that points to the direct object, 'all these things.'

  35. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all · v19

    'All' of it: the whole run of invasion and loss just described in 5:15–17.

  36. אֵ֑לֶּה

    ʾelleh · H0428

    these · v19

    'These things': the harvests, flocks, children and fortified cities eaten up by the nation from far away (5:17).

  37. אֲלֵיהֶ֗ם

    ʾaleihem · H0413

    to them · v19

    To the people who asked the question.

  38. עֲזַבְתֶּ֤ם

    ʿazavtem · H5800A

    you forsook, abandoned · v19

    To walk away from someone you are bound to. Here it means breaking the covenant loyalty Israel owed Yahweh.

  39. וַתַּעַבְד֞וּ

    vattaʿavdu · H5647H

    and you served · v19

    To serve, work for, worship. Here it is religious service: offerings and devotion to other gods. The same verb comes back in the second half with a different object.

  40. נֵכָר֙

    nekhar · H5236

    foreignness, foreign land · v19

    'Gods of foreignness': gods that belong to other peoples and other lands, imported into Yahweh's land.

  41. בְּאַרְצְכֶ֔ם

    beʾartzekhem · H0776G

    in your land · v19

    'In your land,' the land Yahweh had given them. They brought outside gods into the land that was his gift.

  42. כֵּ֚ן

    ken · H3651C

    so, thus · v19

    The second half of 'just as… so…'. The consequence is shaped to fit the offense.

  43. זָרִ֔ים

    zarim · H2114A

    strangers, outsiders · v19

    People who do not belong to you, often foreign enemies. Jeremiah also uses the word for foreign gods (2:25; 3:13), so it may echo the 'gods of foreignness' just mentioned.

  44. לָכֶֽם׃

    lakhem · H9036

    to you, yours · v19

    'To you,' the ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'yours.' 'A land not to you' means exile. It closes the verse by echoing the people's opening 'to us.'

The world behind it

The "foe from the north." Jeremiah 4–6 is a series of oracles about an invader from the north. The invader is unnamed but vividly described: a distant, ancient nation whose language Judah won't understand (5:15), with quivers "like an open grave" (5:16). Jeremiah's ministry began around 627 BCE, and these oracles were most likely given or gathered under Josiah and Jehoiakim. Later they were read as fulfilled by Babylon, which besieged Jerusalem in 597 and destroyed it in 587/586 BCE.

How ancient armies "ate" a land. Armies in the Iron Age fed themselves from the country they invaded. They took standing crops and stored grain, and they slaughtered flocks and herds. Assyrian and Babylonian kings boasted in inscriptions and palace reliefs of cutting down the orchards and vineyards of rebel lands. That was a deliberate long-term ruin, since vines and fig trees take years to mature. Israel's own law forbade cutting down fruit trees during a siege (Deut 20:19–20). Captured children were killed or deported as slaves.

Judah's fortified cities. Judah's defense depended on a network of walled towns guarding the approaches to Jerusalem (2 Chr 11:5–12). In 701 BCE Sennacherib claimed to have taken 46 of them. During Babylon's final campaign only Lachish and Azekah held out for a while (Jer 34:7), and an ostracon (a letter written on a pottery shard) found at Lachish reports that Azekah's signal could no longer be seen. To a Judean listener, "your fortified cities" meant these places, not an abstract idea.

Covenant curse language. The verse draws heavily on Deuteronomy 28:49–52 and Leviticus 26:16. Those passages warn that if Israel breaks the covenant, a far-off nation with a foreign tongue will eat its produce and livestock and besiege it "until your high and fortified walls, in which you trust, come down." Jeremiah's hearers would have heard the old covenant warning coming true.

From the study of Jeremiah 5:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Are 'your sons and daughters' the victims eaten, or the ones who would have eaten the bread?

  • Victims: 'they will eat your sons and your daughters' (most modern translations and commentators).

    The Septuagint and Vulgate both read it this way. The parallel list in Jer 3:24 has 'sons and daughters' among the things consumed. The verse's pattern is 'eat' + 'your X and your Y' in pairs, and the Deut 28 curse background lists offspring among the losses.

  • Relative clause: 'your bread, which your sons and daughters should eat' (KJV, WEB, some older Jewish commentary).

    It explains the switch to a plural verb ('they eat') with a plural subject (sons and daughters), and it keeps the verse purely about food. However, it requires reading in an unexpressed 'which', and it breaks the verse's pairing pattern.

in v17

Who is the 'foe from the north' in Jeremiah 4–6?

  • Babylon (the majority view, at least in the final form of the book).

    Babylon is the enemy the book itself later names (Jer 20:4; 25:9). Its campaigns of 605–586 BCE matched the destruction described, including the fall of the fortified cities (Jer 34:7).

  • Originally an unnamed or different threat, such as the Scythians (an older theory) or a deliberately undefined enemy drawn in mythic terms.

    The oracles never name the foe, and some likely date to Josiah's reign, before Babylon's rise. Herodotus reports a Scythian incursion toward Egypt, but the historical evidence for Scythians in Judah is weak, and most scholars now doubt that view.

in v18

Is v.18 (with v.19) Jeremiah's original oracle or a later explanatory addition from the exile?

  • A later prose addition, written after 586 BC to explain the disaster and soften its finality.

    Vv.18–19 break into the poetry of vv.15–17 with prose. The address switches from singular to plural. V.19 follows a fixed question-and-answer pattern ('Why has the LORD done this?… Because you forsook…') found in Deut 29:24–28, 1 Kgs 9:8–9, Jer 16:10–13 and 22:8–9, which is associated with writers reflecting on the exile in the style of Deuteronomy. Commentators such as McKane and Carroll take this line.

  • Authentic to Jeremiah, or at least an integral part of the book's message from early on.

    'Not a full end' recurs throughout Jeremiah (4:27; 5:10; 30:11; 46:28), so it is a characteristic theme rather than a one-off insertion. Prophets mixed poetry and prose freely, and the covenant idea behind it is old (Lev 26:44). Commentators such as Lundbom and Thompson give it more weight as part of Jeremiah's own preaching.

in v18

Is 'I will not make a full end' a word of hope or a further threat?

  • Primarily hope: a guarantee that a remnant will survive and the covenant people will not be wiped out.

    The parallels at Jer 30:11 and 46:28 are clearly promises of comfort ('Do not fear, O Jacob… I will not make a full end of you'). The idea matches Lev 26:44 and Neh 9:31, where 'not making an end' is credited to God's mercy.

  • Sombre: the judgment is not over yet, because survivors will go on to exile and servitude.

    V.19 immediately explains what survival will mean: serving foreigners in a land not your own. In the context of chapters 4–6, which are relentlessly severe, 'not a full end' can mean 'not finished with you': the punishment continues beyond the invasion.

  • Both at once.

    The Hebrew says only that total annihilation is ruled out. That is grim (there is more suffering ahead) and hopeful (there will be a people left to suffer it, and later to return). Many commentators hold the two together.

in v19

Who are the 'zarim' (strangers/foreigners) Israel will serve in exile: foreign peoples, foreign gods, or both?

  • Foreign peoples, meaning the Babylonian conquerors and overlords.

    Zar commonly means foreign invaders (Isa 1:7; Hos 7:9; Ezek 7:21; Jer 30:8, where zarim 'make him their servant'). The context is a foreign nation invading (5:15–17), and the contrast is about land and political subjection. Most translations take this view.

  • Foreign gods, or a deliberate double meaning that includes them.

    In Jeremiah zarim already means foreign gods (2:25; 3:13; compare Deut 32:16). The parallels Deut 28:36, 64 and Jer 16:13 threaten that exiles will 'serve other gods' in the foreign land. The 'just as… so' pairing may mean they will serve the same kind of thing they chose, only now under compulsion.

in v19

Is 5:18–19 part of Jeremiah's original poem or a later prose addition?

  • A later addition in the style of Deuteronomy, written for exiles.

    Verses 18–19 are prose set among poetry. They use stock covenant phrasing found in Deuteronomy and Kings (the 'why has Yahweh done this?' form). Verse 18 softens the 'full end' threatened in 5:10 and seems to assume survivors in exile. Many critical commentators (e.g. McKane, Carroll) read them as a later layer.

  • Original or early Jeremianic material.

    Jeremiah regularly mixes poetry and prose. He shares vocabulary with Deuteronomy because he was steeped in the same covenant tradition. Exile was already threatened in the curses of Deuteronomy, so a prophet in the late 600s could have spoken of it. Commentators such as Lundbom and Holladay give more weight to continuity with Jeremiah himself.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).