Job Chapter 24 Read as one passage
Job 24:5–8
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
5Indeed, like wild donkeys in the desert, the poor go to work foraging for food; the wasteland is food for their children. 6They gather fodder in the fields and glean the vineyards of the wicked. 7Without clothing, they spend the night naked; they have no covering against the cold. 8Drenched by mountain rains, they huddle against the rocks for want of shelter.
What the first hearers heard
To an ancient listener, the line pictured people who had lost their place in society. Owning land, keeping animals and eating bread were what marked settled human life. These people go out like onagers, the animals that belong to the empty plain, and spend the day hunting the way beasts do. Hearers who knew the language of hymns like Psalm 104 would notice that "going out to work" has been turned into "going out for prey".
In the book's argument, the verse is evidence. Job's friends have claimed that the world is morally ordered and that suffering follows sin. Job answers: look at these people. They are hungry not because of their own wrongdoing but because others moved the boundary stones (24:2). He stresses the children so that no one can explain the suffering away as deserved. The verse also prepares, with some irony, for God's speeches (chs. 38–39), where God's care for wild animals and their young is celebrated. Here humans who have been forced into the animals' life are scraping the same desert for their own young.
From the study of Job 24:5.
Verse by verse
-
5Indeed, like wild donkeys in the desert, the poor go to work foraging for food; the wasteland is food for their children.
Full study →Look at them: wild donkeys out on the steppe. Every day they go out to their "work". Their only work is hunting, searching hard from first light for food the way an animal hunts for its kill. The bare plain is all that man has to live on. Whatever bread his children get, the wasteland has to give it.
Job does not say the poor are like wild donkeys. He puts the two side by side, so the people are shown as having become the animal. The onager is the steppe creature no one owns or feeds. God later says he made the barren plain its home (Job 39:6).
The words echo the ordinary order of life: "man goes out to his work". In this verse that order has broken down. People who have been driven off their land (vv. 2–4) now live as beasts do, hunting for prey (the word for a lion's kill, also used for plain food). They are not robbers. They are scavengers.
The line ends on the children, and that is where the weight falls. What a man scrapes from the desert goes to feed hungry young ones. This is the scene Job wants his friends, and God, to look at.
-
6They gather fodder in the fields and glean the vineyards of the wicked.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
7Without clothing, they spend the night naked; they have no covering against the cold.
Full study →Stripped of the cloak that should have been their blanket, they pass the night naked, because they have nothing left to wear. There is nothing at all to cover them in the night's cold.
The verse is one sharp picture in two lines. The first line puts "naked" first: these people have lost their outer garment, the wool cloak a poor person wore by day and slept in by night. They "spend the night" in the open, which in a culture built on hospitality was the plainest sign that nobody would take you in. The second line pushes further: not only no clothes, but no covering. That is the very word the Law used for the poor man's pledged cloak, which a creditor had to give back before sunset, "for it is his only covering; in what else will he sleep?" (Exodus 22:26–27). Then comes the closing word: the cold, the winter chill of the hills that verse 8 fills with mountain rain.
In context the people meant are the poor of verses 4–8. They have been shoved off the road, sent out to scavenge like wild donkeys and to glean in a wicked man's vineyard, and their garments have been taken as security for debts (vv. 9–10). Job is not just describing poverty. He is making a case against heaven: this happens, the Torah's protections are ignored, and "God charges no one with wrong" (v. 12). The same words come back in Job's oath of innocence (31:19, 32). There he swears that he never let anyone perish "for lack of clothing" or "without covering", and never let a stranger "spend the night" outside.
-
8Drenched by mountain rains, they huddle against the rocks for want of shelter.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v5
prey (KJV, YLT)
teref
- What we hear
- Victims hunted by a predator. Readers may think the people in the verse are raiders preying on others.
- What they heard
- Food that has to be hunted or scavenged, like an animal's meal. Teref can also simply mean provisions (Prov 31:15). The people here are not attacking anyone; they are looking for something to eat.
-
in v5
wild asses / wild donkeys
pera'im
- What we hear
- A stubborn or dim farm animal, or an insult.
- What they heard
- The onager: a fast, untameable steppe animal that no one owns or feeds. It is the opposite of the domestic donkey.
-
in v7
naked
ʿārôm
- What we hear
- Completely unclothed.
- What they heard
- Without proper clothing, often specifically without the outer cloak: exposed, shamed and unprotected. Full nudity is possible but is not the main point here. The point is the lost blanket-cloak and exposure to cold.
-
in v7
They cause the naked to lodge (KJV)
yālînû (lûn)
- What we hear
- 'Lodge' suggests being housed or put up somewhere, so the KJV line can sound as if someone is giving the naked a place to stay.
- What they heard
- Simply 'they spend the night', here outdoors with no shelter at all. The point is that they have no lodging.
Every word
-
הֵ֤ן
hen · H2005
look!, behold · v5
A word that points the listener at a scene: 'Look at them!' Job is asking his friends to look at what is really happening to the poor, which their neat theology leaves out.
-
פְּרָאִ֨ים
pera'im · H6501
wild donkeys, onagers · v5
The onager, the untamed wild ass of the steppe. It has no owner, no stall and no food put out for it. The Hebrew has no 'like': it simply says 'wild donkeys'. The comparison is made by putting the two side by side, so the people are pictured as having become these animals.
-
בַּֽמִּדְבָּ֗ר
bammidbar · H4057B
in the wilderness · v5
The midbar is the dry land past the farmland: rough grazing, scrub and open country. It is not necessarily sand desert. It is the place where people live who have no field of their own.
-
יָצְא֣וּ
yatse'u · H3318G
they go out · v5
The ordinary verb for going out to the day's work. The Hebrew perfect form here describes what they habitually do: every day they go out.
-
בְּ֭פָעֳלָם
befo'olam · H6467
in/to their work · v5
'Their work' is a bitter phrase, because the only work they have is scavenging. It echoes the normal pattern of human life, 'man goes out to his work' (Ps 104:23). For these people that pattern has been turned into foraging, the way animals live.
-
מְשַׁחֲרֵ֣י
meshacharei · H7836
seeking diligently / early · v5
A form of the verb that stresses effort: searching hard, perhaps starting at first light. It sounds like the word for 'dawn' (shachar), which is where the KJV gets 'rising betimes'. Their whole day is spent looking.
-
לַטָּ֑רֶף
lattaref · H2964
prey, torn food, food · v5
The usual meaning is an animal's prey, something torn. It can also mean simply food. Here it keeps the picture of the beast: they hunt for whatever scraps can be got, as an animal hunts its meal. It does not mean they prey on other people.
-
עֲרָבָ֥ה
'aravah · H6160L
steppe, desert plain · v5
The dry, empty plain. In Job 39:6 God says he made the 'aravah the wild donkey's home. Here it is the poor man's only larder.
-
ל֥וֹ
lo · H9033
to him, for him · v5
A singular 'to him', where the rest of the line is plural. It probably singles out each man, or treats the group as one: the steppe is all *he* has to draw on.
-
לֶ֝֗חֶם
lechem · H3899G
bread, food · v5
The basic word for daily food, the grain-bread of settled life. It is ironic here: the 'bread' of these people is whatever the barren plain gives up.
-
לַנְּעָרִֽים
lanne'arim · H5288
young ones, lads, servants · v5
Here it means the dependent young: the children the man must feed. The line ends on them, and that is where the weight falls. What he scavenges is not for himself but for hungry children.
-
עָר֣וֹם
ʿārôm · H6174
naked · v7
Comes first for emphasis: 'naked' is the first thing the hearer pictures. In this setting it most likely means stripped of the outer cloak that served as a night blanket, left in a thin under-tunic or less, rather than fully nude. Job used the same word of himself in 1:21: 'naked I came from my mother's womb.'
-
יָ֭לִינוּ
yālînû · H3885A
to lodge, spend the night · v7
'They pass the night.' The verb is about where and how you spend the night, and the irony is that these people have no lodging at all. The subject is the poor of verses 5–8, who have been pushed out to scavenge in the wild. The same verb comes back in Job's defence in 31:32: 'no stranger had to spend the night in the street.'
-
מִבְּלִ֣י
mibbəlî · H1097
without; for lack of · v7
'From' plus 'without', meaning 'for lack of'. It gives the cause: they are naked because they have nothing to wear, not by choice or custom.
-
לְב֑וּשׁ
ləbûš · H3830
-
וְאֵ֥ין
wəʾên · H0369
there is not · v7
'And there is no': a flat statement that something is missing. The second line goes beyond the first, from 'no clothes' to 'nothing at all to cover them'.
-
כְּ֝ס֗וּת
kəsût · H3682
covering · v7
From the verb 'to cover'. This is the word the law in Exodus 22:27 (English 22:26–27) uses for a poor man's pledged cloak: 'it is his only covering… in what else will he sleep?' A hearer who knew that law would think of the cloak that doubled as a blanket.
-
בַּקָּרָֽה׃
baqqārâ · H7135
cold · v7
'In the cold', with 'the': the familiar cold of the night, and in the rainy season of verse 8, the hill-country winter. It is a rare word. Proverbs 25:20 uses it for the cruelty of 'taking off a garment on a cold day.'
The world behind it
The steppe and the landless. In ancient Israel, food security depended on owning land. A family field, its boundary stones, and the right to glean at harvest were what stood between a household and hunger. Job 24:2–4 describes how that protection is removed: boundary markers moved, the orphan's donkey and the widow's ox taken as security for debt, the needy pushed off the road into hiding. Verses 5–8 show what happens next. The dispossessed move into the steppe (midbar, 'aravah), the uncultivated land beyond the fields, and live on roots, scrub and whatever can be found. Verse 6 adds gleaning in someone else's field and the vineyard of the wicked.
The wild donkey. The onager was a familiar animal of the Near Eastern steppe. Kings hunted it, and it was proverbial for living beyond human control (Gen 16:12). Its freedom was admired, but it also meant having no keeper and no feed. Using it for human beings expressed social death: being cut off from the settled community.
Job's complaint. The chapter opens with the question of why the Almighty does not set fixed "times" or court days for judgment (24:1), and it laments that "God charges no one with wrong" (24:12). In the Ancient Near East, kings and gods were expected to protect the widow, the orphan and the poor. The prologue and epilogue of Hammurabi's laws state this ideal, and so does Israel's own law (Deut 24:17–22). Job sets that ideal beside what he sees happening. The wild-donkey image also anticipates God's speeches in chapters 38–39, where God hunts prey for lions, feeds the raven's young, and gives the onager the steppe for its home. Read together, the two passages raise the sharp question of who provides for the human young who have been pushed into that same steppe.
From the study of Job 24:5.
Where scholars differ
in v5
Who are the 'wild donkeys': the dispossessed poor, or the oppressors and raiders?
-
The poor driven from their land (the majority view, followed by BSB, NIV, NLT and ESV).
It follows straight on from v. 4 (the needy forced into hiding). Verses 6–8 continue with gleaning, nakedness and sheltering among rocks, which describes victims. The searching is for lechem 'for the young ones', which points to providers for a family, not predators.
-
Marauders or desert raiders who 'go out for prey'.
Teref normally means a predator's prey, and the onager could stand for lawless people (Gen 16:12). Some older interpreters read vv. 5–6 as describing the wicked. Most modern scholars find this hard to fit with the flow of vv. 4–8.
in v5
How should the second half be construed?
-
Keep the traditional text as a verbless clause: 'the steppe is to him bread for the young ones' (the steppe is his only source of food).
It makes acceptable sense as compressed Hebrew poetry. It is supported by the Vulgate and by most translations, which supply 'yields' or 'provides'.
-
Repoint or rearrange (for example 'until evening', or moving 'aravah into the first half).
The singular 'to him' and the lack of a verb are awkward. Some commentators prefer a smoother parallel to the first half. These are conjectures without manuscript support.
in v7
Are the poor the ones who spend the night naked, or do the wicked make them do so?
-
The poor are the subject: 'Naked, they spend the night…' (most modern translations and commentators).
Verses 5–8 consistently describe what the poor do and suffer. Verse 8 continues with the poor as subject ('they are drenched… they cling to the rock'). The same wording in 31:19 describes the needy themselves. The supplied parsing reads the verb as the simple stem.
-
The oppressors are the subject: 'They cause the naked to lodge without clothing' (KJV, YLT, and in substance the LXX and Vulgate).
The form can be read as causative. The oppressors are the actors in vv. 2–4 and 9. The ancient Greek and Latin versions both make the stripping something done by the wicked.
in v7
Is all of Job 24 Job's speech?
-
Verses 1–17 (including v. 7) are Job's. Some scholars move vv. 18–24 to a friend (often Zophar or Bildad) because the third cycle of speeches seems disrupted.
Verses 18–24 sound like the friends' doctrine of retribution, and Zophar has no third speech in the present text.
-
The whole chapter is Job's, with vv. 18–24 as quotation, irony, or a curse on the wicked.
No manuscript support exists for rearranging. Job quotes or mimics his friends elsewhere (e.g. 21:19).
Sources
- BDB s.v. פֶּרֶא, טֶרֶף, שָׁחַר, עֲרָבָה
- HALOT s.v. פֶּרֶא, טֶרֶף, שׁחר, פֹּעַל
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- Septuagint, Job 24:5 (Rahlfs; Brenton translation)
- Vulgate, Job 24:5
- BDB s.v. עָרוֹם, לוּן, כְּסוּת, קָרָה
- HALOT s.v. עָרוֹם; לין I; כְּסוּת; קָרָה
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15)
- Exodus 22:25–27; Deuteronomy 24:10–13; Amos 2:8 (pledged-garment laws)
- Meṣad Ḥashavyahu (Yavneh-Yam) ostracon, KAI 200
- Septuagint Job (Ziegler, Göttingen edition) for the Greek reading
- Vulgate, Iob 24:7
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.