Job Chapter 42 Read as one passage
Job 42:5–6
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
5My ears had heard of You, but now my eyes have seen You. 6Therefore I despise myself, and I repent in dust and ashes.”
What the first hearers heard
The book of Job was probably written down for Israelite readers in the period after the exile (most scholars date it roughly to the 6th–4th centuries BCE), though its story is set in a patriarchal-era land of Uz. The friends speak for a common teaching of the time: God rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked, so suffering proves guilt. The book disputes that teaching.
For these readers, verse 5 did several things:
- It ranked two kinds of knowing. Tradition received by ear, the very thing the friends had appealed to, is real but secondhand. Meeting God directly goes beyond it. Readers who valued the wisdom of the elders would feel the contrast sharply.
- It resolved Job's complaint without answering his question. Job had demanded to see God and argue his case. He now has the encounter, yet God never explained the suffering. The book suggests the meeting itself, not an explanation, is what changes Job.
- It set up verse 6. "And now… therefore" (v. 6) shows that Job's response, however one translates its hard wording, comes from this seeing. It does not come from the friends' arguments, which God goes on to reject (42:7).
- It placed Job among those who "saw God." Hearers would recall Isaiah, Jacob and Moses. This was a rare privilege, normally met with fear and humility.
From the study of Job 42:5.
Verse by verse
-
5My ears had heard of You, but now my eyes have seen You.
Full study →"Before, I knew you the way people know someone they have only been told about. Your reputation reached me by ear, through report and tradition. But now, after you spoke to me out of the storm, my own eye has seen you, and I still see you."
The first line doubles its key word: "by the hearing of the ear I heard you." That makes hearing sound like all Job ever had. It recalls the tradition passed from father to son, the "wisdom of the ancients" that Job's friends quoted at him for thirty chapters. It does not call that knowledge false. Job was devout before (1:1), and God later says Job spoke rightly of him (42:7). It calls it secondhand. The second line answers with a single eye and a verb of completed action whose effect lasts: the seeing has happened, and it has changed what Job knows.
The words pick up Job's own earlier cry, "my eyes shall behold him, and not a stranger" (19:27), and his complaints that God passes by unseen (9:11; 23:8–9). God never answered Job's question "why?" What Job got was the encounter he had demanded, and that is what he reports here. The text describes no shape or figure. God spoke from a whirlwind. "Seen" uses the old language of meeting God face to face, as when Isaiah cried "my eyes have seen the King" (Isaiah 6:5). The point is the directness of the meeting, not a picture.
-
6Therefore I despise myself, and I repent in dust and ashes.”
Full study →"So, because I have now seen you and not only heard about you, I take it back. I withdraw my case and the words I hurled at you. I change my mind and let go, and I find comfort, about dust and ashes: about being the frail mortal I am, and about the ash heap of grief I have been sitting on."
The Hebrew is very compressed: five words after "therefore." The first verb, ʾemʾas ("I reject / I refuse"), has no object. English "myself" is a translator's addition. In context, what Job rejects is most naturally what he has just admitted to: speaking of things too wonderful for him (v. 3) and pressing his legal challenge against God. The second verb, niḥamtî, is not the usual word for confessing sin. It means to change one's mind, regret, or take comfort, and the Bible uses it when God "relents." "Dust and ashes" is the phrase Abraham used for himself as he bargained with God (Gen 18:27), and it is also the ash heap where Job sat mourning (2:8).
The verse is a real surrender. Job stops arguing and accepts his place as a creature before the Creator. It is not a confession that his suffering was punishment for hidden sin. In the very next breath God says Job, unlike his friends, spoke rightly (42:7).
Where the English drifted
-
in v5
now my eye sees you / my eyes have seen you
'eini ra'atekha
- What we hear
- Either "now I finally get it" (modern "I see" = "I understand"), or the picture of Job looking at a visible figure of God.
- What they heard
- A real, firsthand encounter with God himself, told in the traditional language of "seeing God" (Isaiah 6:5; Genesis 32:30). In the story God is heard from a storm and no form is described. The point is that God met Job in person, as opposed to Job knowing him by report.
-
in v6
I abhor myself / I despise myself
ʾemʾas (no object)
- What we hear
- Job feels self-hatred and disgust at his own person, as though he had found out how sinful he was.
- What they heard
- "I reject / I retract" with the object left unstated. In context that most likely means his words or his lawsuit against God. Some readers take it from a second root meaning "I melt away."
-
in v6
repent
niḥamtî
- What we hear
- Confessing personal sin and turning from wrongdoing in order to be forgiven.
- What they heard
- To change one's mind, regret, back down from a course, or be comforted. The same verb is used of God "relenting," with no sin implied.
-
in v6
in dust and ashes
ʿal ʿāpār wāʾēper
- What we hear
- A picture of a penitent sinner sitting in ashes as an act of contrition.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v6
Job never says "I hate myself"
- What's often taught
- At the end of the book Job finally sees his own sinfulness, hates himself for it, and repents. This is taken to show that meeting God means recognising one's own wretchedness, and sometimes that Job's suffering had exposed real sin.
- What the text supports
The common reading gets one thing right: Job is truly humbled. He stops arguing and admits he spoke of things beyond him (42:3). But the Hebrew verb ʾemʾas ("I reject / retract") has no object, so "myself" is supplied by translators. The second verb, niḥamtî, means to change one's mind, relent or be comforted. It is used of God, and it is not the usual word for repenting of sin (šûb). "Dust and ashes" echoes Abraham's description of human frailty (Gen 18:27) and Job's mourning on the ash heap (2:8).
The frame of the book rules out a confession of hidden sin. The narrator and God call Job blameless (1:1; 2:3), and immediately after this verse God says Job spoke "what is right," unlike the friends who insisted he must have sinned (42:7–8). Job withdraws his challenge and accepts his creaturely place. He does not take back his innocence or declare self-hatred.
- Where the English feeds it
- "Abhor myself" / "despise myself" (KJV, BSB, WEB, NIV, ESV) prints a supplied object as if it were the text. The KJV's italics, which mark it as supplied, are invisible to most readers. "Repent" carries the modern sense of confessing sin, and "in dust and ashes" adds a penitential posture.
Every word
-
לְשֵֽׁמַע־
le-shema' · H8088
report, hearing, rumour · v5
The preposition le- ("by, according to") plus the noun for what is heard: a report or reputation passed by word of mouth. It frames Job's earlier knowledge of God as received, secondhand knowledge.
-
אֹ֥זֶן
ozen · H241
ear · v5
"The hearing of the ear" is a set phrase (also Psalm 18:44) for knowing something because you were told it. The single "ear" stands for the organ in general and sets up the contrast with the single "eye" in the second line.
-
שְׁמַעְתִּ֑יךָ
shema'tikha · H8085
hear, listen, heed · v5
"I heard you" (verb with "you" as object). With a person as object it can mean "I heard about you." The noun and verb come from the same root, so the line reads "by hearing-of-ear I heard you". The repetition presses the point that this was all he had: hearing.
-
וְ֝עַתָּ֗ה
ve-'attah · H6258
and now · v5
The hinge of the verse. It marks a break between Job's past and the present moment after God has spoken out of the storm (chapters 38–41).
-
עֵינִ֥י
'eini · H5869
eye · v5
"My eye" is the grammatical subject of "has seen." Job's own eye, not someone else's account. It echoes his earlier hope in 19:27 that "my eyes" would see God.
-
רָאָֽתְךָ׃
ra'atekha · H7200
see, perceive, experience · v5
"It has seen you" (feminine verb agreeing with "eye"). The form is a completed action whose result still holds: "my eye has seen you" and so, in effect, "now sees you." The verb is the ordinary one for sight, and it is also the one used for meeting God directly (Isaiah 6:5).
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921A
upon, over, concerning · v6
First half of the fixed phrase ʿal-kēn, "therefore." On its own it means "on" or "because of"; here it ties Job's response to what he has just said in verses 3–5.
-
כֵּ֭ן
kēn · H3651C
so, thus · v6
Completes ʿal-kēn, "on account of this / therefore." What follows is Job's answer to having "seen" God (v. 5), not a separate confession that comes out of nowhere.
-
אֶמְאַ֣ס
ʾemʾas · H3988A
to reject, refuse, despise · v6
"I reject" or "I retract." The verb normally takes an object, but none is written here. The reader has to supply one: myself, my words, my lawsuit, my mourning. This gap is the main puzzle of the verse.
-
וְנִחַ֑מְתִּי
wənīḥamtî · H5162H
to be sorry, relent, change one's mind; to be comforted · v6
In this form (the Niphal) the verb means to change one's mind, regret, back down from a course, or take comfort. It is the word used when God "relents" (Exod 32:14; Jonah 3:10). It is not the usual Hebrew word for turning away from sin (šûb).
-
עָפָ֥ר
ʿāpār · H6083
-
וָאֵֽפֶר׃
wāʾēper · H0665
The world behind it
Where this falls in the book. Job 42:1–6 is Job's last reply to God's two speeches "out of the storm" (38:1–40:2; 40:6–41:34). In verses 3 and 4 Job quotes God's own words back (38:2, 38:3/40:7): "Who is this that hides counsel…?" and "Hear now, and I will speak." Verse 5 is his answer to that challenge to hear.
Knowing God by hearing. In Israel, knowledge of God came mainly by ear: the commands spoken at Sinai, "Hear, O Israel," and parents retelling God's deeds ("we have heard with our ears, our fathers have told us", Psalm 44:1). Job's friends rely on exactly this kind of inherited knowledge: "inquire of the former generation" (Bildad, 8:8–10), "what wise men have told from their fathers" (Eliphaz, 15:17–18). Deuteronomy 4:12 stresses that at Sinai Israel "heard the sound of words but saw no form." So for Job to say "my eye has seen you" is a strong claim. It puts his experience alongside the rare figures who "saw God" (Jacob, Moses, Isaiah).
Eyewitness versus report. Ancient people commonly ranked what you see for yourself above what you are told. The closest biblical parallel is the Queen of Sheba: she heard the report of Solomon but "did not believe it until I came and my eyes saw" (1 Kings 10:6–7). Job's line uses the same pattern.
Job's demand to see God. Throughout the debate Job asked for a face-to-face hearing with God (13:3; 23:3–7; 31:35) and despaired that God could not be seen (9:11; 23:8–9). He also hoped that "my eyes shall behold" God (19:26–27). Verse 5 tells us that hope has been met, though in a way Job did not script: God came in a storm and asked questions instead of answering them.
From the study of Job 42:5.
Where scholars differ
in v5
What did Job "see"?
-
A real theophany, meaning a perceptible appearance of God in the storm, which Job describes as seeing.
God speaks "out of the storm" (38:1; 40:6), and storm-theophanies elsewhere involve visible phenomena (Ezekiel 1:4; Habakkuk 3). "My eye" is emphatic and answers Job's literal-sounding hope in 19:26–27 and his complaint in 23:8–9.
-
"Seeing" stands for direct, personal encounter rather than visual sight.
No form is described. Only speech is reported. The Hebrew verb ra'ah regularly means "experience" or "perceive." The contrast is with secondhand report (compare 1 Kings 10:6–7), so the emphasis falls on directness. Deuteronomy 4:12 links hearing God's voice with seeing no form.
in v5
Does "by the hearing of the ear" disparage Job's earlier faith?
-
Yes. Job's former knowledge was inherited and inadequate, and the encounter replaces it.
The emphatic doubling of the hearing-word, the strong "but now," and the self-abasement that follows in verse 6 all point that way.
-
No. It contrasts degrees of directness, not true and false knowledge.
The narrator calls Job "blameless and upright" (1:1), and God says Job, unlike the friends, spoke "what is right" of him (42:7). The Sheba parallel (1 Kings 10:6–7) shows the same pattern, where the report was true but fell short of seeing.
-
Job's whole reply (vv. 2–6) is deliberately ambiguous or even ironic, so verse 5 should not be read as a simple conversion.
Several commentators (e.g. Good, Curtis, Morrow) point to the famously uncertain wording of verse 6, "I reject/retract… and am consoled/repent concerning dust and ashes." They argue the response can be read as submission, as retraction of the lawsuit, or as something more guarded.
in v6
What does Job "reject" (ʾemʾas), given that there is no object?
-
"I despise / abhor myself": the traditional reading of self-abasement.
Septuagint and Vulgate. Job's own words in 9:21 ("I despise my life"). The overwhelming sight of God in 42:5.
-
"I retract / reject [my words, my case]": withdrawing the lawsuit.
The context: 40:4–5 ("I will add no more") and 42:3 ("I spoke of things I did not understand"). The legal framing of the book. Adopted by NASB, NJPS and many modern commentators (e.g. Habel, Clines, Newsom in various forms).
-
"I melt away / dissolve": from māʾas II.
Septuagint etakēn, 11QtgJob "I am dissolved," and the Niphal of māʾas in Ps 58:7 and Job 7:5. A minority view.
-
Defiant or ironic: Job rejects God, or something in God's answer, rather than submitting.
The missing object allows it, and some scholars (e.g. J. B. Curtis, JBL 1979) have argued for it. Most think it fits poorly with God's approval in 42:7 and the narrative that follows.
in v6
What does niḥamtî ʿal ʿāpār wāʾēper mean?
-
"I repent [while sitting] in dust and ashes": penitence on the ash heap.
Job sits in ashes in 2:8. The traditional translations.
-
"I relent / change my mind concerning dust and ashes": about the human condition.
The regular use of niḥam ʿal to mean "relent of / concerning." The phrase "dust and ashes" for human lowliness in Gen 18:27 and Job 30:19. The NJPS rendering.
-
"I give up (am done with) dust and ashes": ending the mourning ritual.
Proposed by Dale Patrick (VT 1976). It fits the restoration that follows in 42:10–17 and the use of niḥam for ending mourning.
-
"I am comforted concerning [my] dust and ashes."
The comfort sense of the Niphal (Gen 24:67; 2 Sam 13:39). The book's running theme of "comforters" (2:11; 16:2; 21:34; 42:11). The rabbinic Targum.
Sources
- BDB s.v. שֵׁמַע, שָׁמַע, רָאָה
- HALOT s.v. שֵׁמַע, רָאָה, עַתָּה
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 38–42 (Word Biblical Commentary 18B, 2011)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library, 1985)
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15, 1965)
- C. A. Newsom, The Book of Job: A Contest of Moral Imaginations (2003)
- R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies (1978)
- W. Morrow, "Consolation, Rejection, and Repentance in Job 42:6," JBL 105 (1986)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 42:5
- Vulgate Job 42:5
- BDB s.v. מָאַס, נָחַם, עָפָר, אֵפֶר
- HALOT s.v. מאס I and II; נחם Niphal
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 38–42 (Word Biblical Commentary 18B)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- C. A. Newsom, The Book of Job: A Contest of Moral Imaginations
- D. Patrick, "Job's Address of God," VT 26 (1976)
- J. B. Curtis, "On Job's Response to Yahweh," JBL 98 (1979)
- Septuagint Job 42:6 (NETS)
- 11QtgJob (Qumran Targum of Job)
- Vulgate Iob 42:6
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).