Joshua Chapter 22 Read as one passage

Joshua 22:17–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17Was not the sin of Peor enough for us, from which we have not cleansed ourselves to this day? It even brought a plague upon the congregation of the LORD. 18And now, would you turn away from the LORD? If you rebel today against the LORD, tomorrow He will be angry with the whole congregation of Israel. 19If indeed the land of your inheritance is unclean, then cross over to the land of the LORD’s possession, where the LORD’s tabernacle stands, and take possession of it among us. But do not rebel against the LORD or against us by building for yourselves an altar other than the altar of the LORD our God. 20Was not Achan son of Zerah unfaithful regarding what was set apart for destruction, bringing wrath upon the whole congregation of Israel? Yet it was not only Achan who perished because of his sin!’”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites hearing the book of Joshua, this verse did several things.

  • It made "Peor" a warning to remember. The nation's own history taught it: the last time Israel flirted with another worship east of the Jordan, thousands died. Hosea and Psalm 106 later return to the same memory, so it clearly stayed in Israel's mind as the classic case of falling away.
  • It showed guilt as shared and lasting. The speakers say "us" and "to this day." In their view the nation was still carrying the weight of Peor. One more breach could bring the full consequences down on everyone, which is the "tomorrow" of verse 18.
  • It defended one people around one place of worship. Readers who lived on either side of the Jordan heard that the river did not divide Yahweh's people. Worship that drifted from the shared sanctuary put everyone at risk.
  • It put the right man in the right place. Phinehas, the zealous priest who stopped Peor's plague, is the one who quotes it. In the end he also accepts the eastern tribes' explanation peacefully. So the story shows zeal for God's honour together with a willingness to listen before going to war.

From the study of Joshua 22:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17Was not the sin of Peor enough for us, from which we have not cleansed ourselves to this day? It even brought a plague upon the congregation of the LORD.

    "Wasn't the guilt of Peor bad enough for us? It is a guilt we have still not purified ourselves of, even now, today. And it brought God's deadly blow down on the whole community of the LORD!"

    The speaker is Phinehas, with ten tribal chiefs beside him. He opens with an idiom that means "Is that such a small thing?", and the answer has to be no. Notice that he says "for us." The western tribes do not stand above the eastern tribes as judges. They put themselves inside the same shared guilt. The word for that guilt, 'āwōn, means more than a wrong act. It is the weight a wrong leaves behind, a debt that stays on the nation's account and can still bring consequences. That is why he can say the people have not purified themselves of it "to this day." The verb is the priests' word for being in a clean, fit state to live near a holy God, and it is reflexive: the people should have done this to themselves, and they have not.

    "Peor" calls up one story everyone knew (Numbers 25). On the plains of Moab, just across the Jordan where the eastern tribes now live, Israelites joined the feasts of Baal of Peor. God's blow (negep, a striking or plague) fell on the camp. Twenty-four thousand died before Phinehas himself drove his spear through an offender and the plague stopped. Here the very man who stopped that plague is reminding the people of it, on that same side of the river. The last clause, "and there came the plague on the congregation of the LORD," says the real point. Unfaithfulness is never private. It brings the blow down on the whole people, and that is the argument verse 18 makes explicit: "if you rebel today, tomorrow He will be angry with the whole congregation of Israel."

    Full study →
  2. 18And now, would you turn away from the LORD? If you rebel today against the LORD, tomorrow He will be angry with the whole congregation of Israel.

    "And you, you of all people, are turning back this very day from following behind Yahweh! Here is how it will go: you revolt against Yahweh today, and tomorrow it is the whole assembled people of Israel his wrath will break out against."

    The picture is a people marching in column behind Yahweh as their commander and king. Building a second altar looks to the speakers like a section of the column peeling off, and "rebel" is the word for a sworn subject throwing off his overlord. Two "todays" stress that this is happening now, and "tomorrow" says the consequence will follow almost at once. The order of words puts the alarm in the right place. Before naming the anger, the speaker names who will bear it: "against all the congregation of Israel." God is not named as the one who will be angry, but the hearers knew who was meant. They had just been reminded of Peor (v. 17), where his wrath came as a plague that killed thousands. So the sentence is part accusation and part plea: your private revolt will not stay private. In Israel one tribe's treachery becomes everyone's funeral.

    (The opening clause can also be read as a question, "would you turn back today…?" or as finishing the question of verse 17, "Is Peor too small a thing for us, that you must turn back today…?" Either way, the force is a shocked accusation.)

    Full study →
  3. 19If indeed the land of your inheritance is unclean, then cross over to the land of the LORD’s possession, where the LORD’s tabernacle stands, and take possession of it among us. But do not rebel against the LORD or against us by building for yourselves an altar other than the altar of the LORD our God.

    "And yet, if what troubles you is that the land you hold over there is unclean, outside the holy ground where YHWH can rightly be worshipped, then come across the river. Cross the Jordan again, as our fathers did, into the land that is YHWH's own estate, where his Dwelling, the tent-sanctuary, has settled down to stay. Come and be given holdings right here among us; we will share our own allotments with you. Only do not revolt against YHWH. And do not revolt against us, or drag us into your revolt, by building yourselves a private altar, a rival to the one altar of YHWH our God."

    The verse comes from a delegation that marched out ready for war. It is a moment of real generosity in the middle of a hard accusation. The speakers guess at the motive behind the new altar and then offer to pay for the remedy out of their own land. Several word-plays carry the argument. "Holding" comes three times: your holding, YHWH's holding, take a holding among us. "Dwelling dwells": holiness is found where YHWH has actually taken up residence. "Rebel" is repeated, binding loyalty to God and loyalty to the people together. And the closing "our God" gathers both sides of the river under one God and one altar.

    Full study →
  4. 20Was not Achan son of Zerah unfaithful regarding what was set apart for destruction, bringing wrath upon the whole congregation of Israel? Yet it was not only Achan who perished because of his sin!’”

    "Don't you remember Achan, Zerah's descendant? He broke faith with God by laying his hands on what had been handed over irrevocably to the LORD, the Jericho plunder that belonged to God alone. Wrath came down on the whole assembly of Israel. He was one man, and yet he did not go to his death alone in his guilt."

    The speakers are Phinehas the priest and ten tribal chiefs, sent to confront the tribes east of the Jordan over a large altar they have built. They are not asking for information. The opening 'Is it not…?' expects 'Yes, of course.' Achan's story (Joshua 7) was the community's own warning tale: one man secretly took gold, silver and a fine cloak from devoted spoil, and Israel was routed at Ai with thirty-six dead before the guilt was traced to him and he and his household were destroyed.

    The word for his crime, ma‘al, means more than 'sin'. It is sacrilege and betrayal of trust: taking what is God's, breaking faith the way a spouse breaks faith. It is the very charge the delegation is bringing against the eastern tribes (vv. 16, 22, 31). The 'devoted thing' (ḥerem) was not cursed because it was evil. It was dangerous because it was so wholly God's that touching it pulled the taker into its holiness and its doom.

    The final line moves from the whole people back to the single man: one individual's guilt (‘avon, the wrong together with the consequences it carries) swept others into death. The unspoken conclusion is: if one man's breach brought wrath on all of us, what will the breach of two and a half tribes bring? Your altar endangers us as well as you.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    iniquity

    'āwōn

    What we hear
    An old-fashioned word for a wicked act, something done and then over.
    What they heard
    The wrong together with the guilt it leaves behind, a burden that stays and brings consequences until it is dealt with. That is how Peor can still be 'not cleansed' years later.
  • in v17

    congregation

    'ēdâ

    What we hear
    A church audience, the people who attend a service.
    What they heard
    The whole people of Israel as one organized community with its elders and chiefs. In this chapter it has gathered for war, and it suffers or is spared as one body.
  • in v18

    rebel

    marad

    What we hear
    To defy authority, break rules, or refuse to conform; often personal or attitudinal.
    What they heard
    The political revolt of a sworn subject or vassal against his overlord: renouncing allegiance and breaking a treaty. Applied to Yahweh, it treats him as Israel's king and the altar as a declaration of independence.
  • in v18

    congregation

    'edah

    What we hear
    The members of a local church gathered for worship.
    What they heard
    The whole people of Israel as one organised body, tribal, legal and religious at once, able to be held collectively responsible and to suffer collective judgment.
  • in v18

    be angry / be wroth

    qatsaf

    What we hear
    A feeling of displeasure or temper.
    What they heard
    In priestly texts, divine wrath that "goes out" against the camp as a concrete, often lethal outbreak such as plague (Num 16:22, 46). Here it recalls the Peor plague of the previous verse.
  • in v19

    unclean

    teme'ah

    What we hear
    Dirty, unhygienic, or morally sinful.
    What they heard
    Ritually impure: a land not hallowed by YHWH's presence and so unfit for his worship and sacrifices. It describes the land's standing in worship, not filth or the people's moral character.
  • in v19

    tabernacle

    mishkan

    What we hear
    A church building or meeting hall, or (in some traditions) the cabinet for the reserved sacrament. Or simply an obscure religious word.
    What they heard
    'Dwelling': the portable tent where YHWH lived among Israel, then standing at Shiloh. The word is about presence. Here the verb from the same root says this Dwelling has 'settled' there.
  • in v19

    an altar beside the altar (KJV)

    mibbal'adey

    What we hear
    A second altar standing next to the first.
    What they heard
    An altar besides, other than, or in rivalry with the one lawful altar, wherever it stands. This one stood far from Shiloh, at the Jordan.
  • in v20

    the accursed thing (KJV)

    ḥerem

    What we hear
    An object that is evil, cursed, or carries a bad-luck curse.
    What they heard
    Something irrevocably handed over to YHWH, so holy and wholly his that it was off-limits to people. It was either destroyed or placed in God's treasury (Joshua 6:19). It was dangerous because it belonged to God, not because it was evil.
  • in v20

    commit a trespass (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    ma‘al

    What we hear
    A minor offence such as walking onto someone's property, or a mild churchy word for 'sin'.
    What they heard
    Sacrilege and breach of faith: taking what belongs to God, or betraying a sworn loyalty. The same word is used for marital unfaithfulness. In this chapter it is the charge on which civil war turns.
Every word
  1. הַמְעַט־

    ham'aṭ · H4592

    little, a small thing · v17

    The question marker ha- joined to 'little' makes a fixed rhetorical question: 'Is it a small thing…?' It means 'Wasn't that bad enough?' The expected answer is 'No, it was not small at all.'

  2. לָנוּ

    lānû · H9035

    to us, for us · v17

    'For us.' The speakers, Phinehas and the western chiefs, count themselves inside the guilt. Peor is 'our' sin, the whole nation's, not just the eastern tribes'.

  3. אֶת־

    'et · H0853

    object marker (untranslated) · v17

    This word normally marks the object of a verb, but there is no verb here for it to attach to. It seems to point to 'the guilt of Peor' and give it weight: 'that thing, the guilt of Peor.'

  4. עֲוֹן

    'ăwōn · H5771

    iniquity, guilt, punishment · v17, v20

    Here this is the guilt from Peor that has not gone away. It is less the act than the burden the act left behind, which still weighs on the people.

  5. פְּעוֹר

    pə'ôr · H6465

    Peor · v17

    A mountain and shrine in Moab. The name is shorthand for the whole episode in Numbers 25, when Israel joined in the worship of 'Baal of Peor.'

  6. אֲשֶׁר

    'ăsher · H0834

    which, that · v17, v19

    Brings in the clause that describes the guilt: it is one 'which' has not been washed away.

  7. לֹא־

    lō' · H3808

    not · v17, v20

    Plain negation. It denies that the purification is finished.

  8. הִטַּהַרְנוּ

    hiṭṭahárnû · H2891

    be clean, be pure · v17

    'We have purified ourselves.' The verb form is reflexive, so the people act on themselves. It is the language of ritual status: the people have not got back the clean standing that lets them live near a holy God.

  9. מִמֶּנּוּ

    mimmennû · H4480

    from it · v17

    'From it,' meaning from the guilt of Peor. The guilt is pictured as something that clings to the people and has to be removed.

  10. עַד

    'ad · H5704

    until, up to · v17

    Carries the uncleanness forward in time, all the way up to the present moment.

  11. הַיּוֹם

    hayyôm · H3117

    day · v17, v18

    'The day.' Together with 'this' it makes the common Hebrew phrase 'to this day.' It picks up the repeated 'today' of verses 16 and 18.

  12. הַזֶּה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v17

    'This,' as in 'this very day.' It ties the old sin to the present crisis over the altar.

  13. וַיְהִי

    wayhî · H1961

    and it was, and there came · v17, v18, v20

    'And there was / and there came.' The verb form normally tells what happened next in a past story, so it points back to the plague that hit at Peor.

  14. הַנֶּגֶף

    hannegep · H5063

    plague, blow, striking · v17

    'The plague,' literally 'the blow' or 'the striking.' It means God's deadly strike on the people. The word comes from the same root as the term for the plague in Numbers 25.

  15. בַּעֲדַת

    ba'ădat · H5712

    congregation, assembly, community · v17, v18, v20

    'On / among the congregation of.' This means the whole people of Israel as one organized body. It echoes the title the speakers use for themselves in verse 16: 'the whole congregation of the LORD.'

  16. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v17, v18, v19

    God's personal name. The congregation belongs to Yahweh, which is why its unfaithfulness draws his blow.

  17. וְאַתֶּם֙

    ve'attem · H0859D

    and you (plural) · v18

    Hebrew verbs already show who the subject is, so the separate pronoun adds emphasis: "and *you*." It sets the eastern tribes against the "us" of verse 17, who are still living with the damage from Peor. The "and" can be read as "and yet" or "and now."

  18. תָּשֻׁ֣בוּ

    tashuvu · H7725G

    turn, turn back, return · v18

    "You are turning back." Together with "from after" it means walking away from the leader you were following. The verb form can mean an action in progress ("you are turning") or a possibility ("would you turn?"), which is why translations divide between a statement and a question.

  19. מֵאַחֲרֵ֖י

    me'acharei · H0310A

    from after, from behind · v18

    Literally "from behind." Israel is pictured walking behind Yahweh like a column behind its commander, or a vassal behind his overlord. Turning "from behind" him means leaving the line of march. Moses used the same words to warn these same tribes in Numbers 32:15.

  20. תִּמְרְד֤וּ

    timredu · H4775

    rebel, revolt · v18, v19

    The word for a subject or vassal state throwing off its overlord. Building a rival altar is framed as political revolt against Yahweh as Israel's king, not as a private religious difference.

  21. וּמָחָ֕ר

    umachar · H4279

    and tomorrow · v18

    "And tomorrow." It can mean the literal next day or, as an idiom, "very soon." Either way, judgment will not wait long.

  22. אֶֽל־

    'el · H0413

    to, toward, against · v18, v19

    Marks who the anger is aimed at. Here it is placed before the verb, so "against all the congregation of Israel" comes before "he will be angry" for emphasis.

  23. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, the whole · v18, v20

    "The whole" community, including the tribes west of the Jordan who did nothing. This one word carries the main point of the argument.

  24. יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v18, v20

    The twelve-tribe people as a whole. Speakers on both sides of the Jordan count as Israel, which is exactly why one group's revolt endangers everyone.

  25. יִקְצֹֽף׃

    yiqtsof · H7107

    be angry, be wrathful · v18

    "He will be wrathful." Yahweh is the subject but is not named. In the priestly writings this word is used for divine wrath breaking out on the camp, often as a deadly plague, which is what had just been recalled from Peor (v. 17).

  26. וְאַ֨ךְ

    ve'akh · H0389

    and yet, only, surely · v19

    A small word that turns the argument: 'and yet' or 'but still'. Right after the charge of rebellion in v.18, the speakers soften their tone and offer the eastern tribes a way out.

  27. אִם־

    'im · H0518A

    if · v19

    Opens a real condition: 'if (as you may think) …'. The speakers are guessing at the eastern tribes' motive. They do not say the land actually is unclean.

  28. טְמֵאָ֜ה

    teme'ah · H2931

    unclean, impure · v19

    Ritually impure, unfit for contact with the holy. Applied to land, it means ground not hallowed by YHWH's presence and so unfit for his worship. It is placed first for emphasis: 'if UNCLEAN is your land…'.

  29. אֶ֣רֶץ

    'erets · H0776G

    land, country · v19

    The territory east of the Jordan (Gilead and Bashan) given to Reuben, Gad and half of Manasseh.

  30. אֲחֻזַּתְכֶ֗ם

    'ahuzzatkhem · H0272

    holding, property · v19

    'Your holding': land the family holds and passes down. It is pointedly set against 'YHWH's holding' a few words later.

  31. עִבְר֨וּ

    'ivru · H5674A

    cross over, pass · v19

    A command: 'cross over'. It is the same verb used for Israel crossing the Jordan into the land (Josh 1–4), so the offer amounts to asking them to repeat the crossing and come fully in.

  32. לָכֶ֜ם

    lakhem · H9036

    for yourselves · v19

    An idiom that adds a personal note to the command ('you go across, for your own sake'). It does not mean 'cross over to yourselves'.

  33. שָֽׁכַן־

    shakhan · H7931

    settle, dwell · v19

    'Has settled / dwells.' The tent-shrine has come to rest and stays put. The verb comes from the same root as the noun 'tabernacle', so the phrase reads 'where YHWH's Dwelling dwells'.

  34. שָׁם֙

    sham · H8033G

    there · v19

    Completes 'where … there', pointing to a definite place. In context that is Shiloh (Josh 18:1; 22:12).

  35. מִשְׁכַּ֣ן

    mishkan · H4908

    dwelling, tabernacle · v19

    'The Dwelling of YHWH': the portable tent-sanctuary from the wilderness. It was the visible sign that YHWH lived among his people, and the one place where sacrifice to him was lawful.

  36. וְהֵאָחֲז֖וּ

    vehe'ahazu · H0270

    seize; (passive) be settled, acquire holdings · v19

    'And take a holding / be settled with property.' It uses the same root as 'holding' (words 5 and 10), so the play runs: give up your holding, come to YHWH's holding, and be given a holding among us.

  37. בְּתוֹכֵ֑נוּ

    betokhenu · H8432

    in the midst of · v19

    'In our midst / among us.' The western tribes offer to make room inside their own allotted land, which would cost them real territory.

  38. אַל־

    'al · H0408

    do not · v19

    The form of 'not' used to ask or urge someone in the moment ('please don't…'). It is not the flat ban of a law.

  39. וְאֹתָ֙נוּ֙

    ve'otanu · H0854

    with / (object marker) + us · v19

    'And us.' The grammar here is unusual. It most likely means 'do not rebel against us', but it may mean 'do not drag us along in your rebellion', which fits the fear of shared punishment in vv.18 and 20.

  40. בִּבְנֹֽתְכֶ֤ם

    bivnotkhem · H1129

    in your building · v19

    'By your building': this names how the rebellion would happen. The act of building the altar is itself the offence.

  41. מִזְבֵּ֔חַ

    mizbeah · H4196

    altar · v19

    'An altar' (the Hebrew has no 'the'). It means a place of slaughter and sacrifice. The western tribes assume it is meant for offerings.

  42. מִֽבַּלְעֲדֵ֔י

    mibbal'adey · H1107

    apart from, besides · v19

    'Apart from / other than': a rival in addition to the one lawful altar, not one standing next to it.

  43. אֱלֹהֵֽינוּ׃

    'eloheynu · H0430G

    our God · v19

    'Our God.' The closing 'our' presses unity: one God, one altar, one people that includes both speakers and hearers.

  44. עָכָן

    ‘akhan · H5912

    Achan · v20

    The man of Judah who took plunder from Jericho that had been devoted to YHWH (Joshua 7). His name had become a byword for the one person whose secret act brought disaster on everyone.

  45. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121A

    son of · v20

    Here 'descendant of' rather than literal son: Joshua 7:1 traces him as son of Carmi, son of Zabdi, son of Zerah. Naming the clan ancestor places him inside the tribal family of Judah.

  46. זֶרַח

    zeraḥ · H2226I

    Zerah · v20

    Son of Judah and Tamar (Genesis 38:30), founder of the Zerahite clan. In Joshua 7:17 the lot fell on this clan before narrowing to Achan.

  47. מָעַל

    ma‘al · H4603

    act unfaithfully, commit sacrilege · v20

    The verb for breaking faith with God, especially by laying hands on what belongs to him. It is the key word of the whole chapter (vv. 16, 22, 31), so citing Achan defines the eastern tribes' altar as the same kind of crime.

  48. מַעַל

    ma‘al · H4604

    breach of faith, sacrilege · v20

    The noun from the same root, repeated after its verb ('broke faith a breach of faith'). The repetition stresses the act and copies word for word the charge against Israel in Joshua 7:1.

  49. בַּחֵרֶם

    baḥerem · H2764A

    in the devoted thing · v20

    'In the matter of the ḥerem': the Jericho spoil set apart wholly for YHWH, to be destroyed or put in his treasury (Joshua 6:17–19). Achan's crime was taking God's property for himself.

  50. וְעַל־

    ve‘al- · H5921A

    and upon · v20

    'And upon': wrath came down on the whole community. The preposition gives the picture of anger falling on people from above.

  51. קָצֶף

    qatsef · H7110A

    wrath · v20

    Divine wrath that breaks out against the community, usually because something holy has been violated. It is not a bad mood. It is a danger, like a plague, that spreads beyond the guilty person.

  52. וְהוּא

    vehu’ · H1931

    and he · v20

    'And he': the focus moves back to Achan for the final, pointed contrast.

  53. אִישׁ

    ’ish · H0376G

    man · v20

    'A man', one individual, set against 'the whole congregation' earlier in the verse.

  54. אֶחָד

    ’eḥad · H0259

    one, single · v20

    'One' or 'a single': the force of the argument rests here. If one man brought this, what will two and a half tribes bring? The wording echoes Moses' plea in Numbers 16:22.

  55. גָוַע

    gava‘ · H1478

    expire, perish · v20

    'Breathe one's last, expire'. It is a fairly formal word for death, used in Genesis of the patriarchs and in the flood story of all flesh perishing. Here it covers Achan's execution and the deaths that came with his crime.

The world behind it

The crisis. Canaan west of the Jordan has been conquered. Joshua sends Reuben, Gad and half of Manasseh home to their land east of the river (22:1–9). At the Jordan they build "a great altar, imposing to see" (22:10). The western tribes hear of it and gather at Shiloh, where the tabernacle stands, ready for war (22:12). First they send a delegation: Phinehas the priest, son of Eleazar, and one chief from each of the ten western tribes (22:13–14).

Why an altar was alarming. Israel's law allowed sacrifice only at the one place God chose (Lev 17:8–9; Deut 12:5–14). A second altar looked like a rival sanctuary. That could mean the eastern tribes were splitting off from Israel's worship, or sliding toward local gods. Verse 16 calls it ma'al, a breach of faith: taking what belongs to God and misusing it.

Why Peor. The Peor apostasy (Num 25) happened at Shittim in the plains of Moab. That is Transjordan, the region the eastern tribes had just settled. Phinehas was the hero of that story, and he was given a "covenant of lasting priesthood" for stopping the plague (Num 25:10–13). In verse 20 the speakers add a second warning from recent history, Achan. His theft at Jericho brought defeat on all Israel (Josh 7). Both examples make the same point: in Israel's covenant thinking, one group's unfaithfulness puts the whole people under God's wrath.

How it ends. The eastern tribes answer that the altar is only a copy, built as a witness that they too belong to Yahweh. It is not for sacrifice (22:21–29). Phinehas accepts their answer and war is avoided (22:30–34).

From the study of Joshua 22:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

In what sense was Israel 'not cleansed' from Peor 'to this day'?

  • Lingering corporate guilt: the nation still carries the burden of Peor, so any new breach risks bringing the full consequence down again.

    'āwōn has a range that includes guilt left 'on the account' and punishment still to come (Gen 4:13; Lev 5:1). Verse 18 threatens wrath on 'the whole congregation' tomorrow. Verse 20 uses Achan for the same idea of shared guilt.

  • Rhetorical exaggeration: the speaker heightens the danger to shock the eastern tribes, without claiming any literal ongoing impurity.

    The whole speech is a heated rhetorical question. Numbers 25:13 says Phinehas made atonement and the plague stopped, which suggests the matter was formally resolved.

  • Lingering idolatry or its effects: some Israelites never fully gave up the Peor cult, or its effects (such as the later war with Midian, Num 31) carried on.

    Later Jewish interpreters suggested continuing effects or hidden adherents. Num 31:16 shows Peor still shaping events afterward. The verse itself, though, gives no details.

in v18

How should v. 18a relate to v. 17: a continuation of its question, a new question, or a statement?

  • It completes v. 17's rhetorical question: "Is the iniquity of Peor too little for us… that you must turn away today?"

    Verse 17 opens with the question marker and v. 18 has none, so continuing the question gives a smooth sentence. The KJV tradition (KJV, WEB, ESV, NASB) follows this.

  • It is a fresh question or an exclamation: "And you are turning away today!" or "Would you turn away?"

    The emphatic "and you" can mark a new beginning set against the "us" of v. 17. The imperfect verb allows either a statement in progress or a possibility. BSB and NIV take this route.

in v18

When was this episode written, and does it reflect the law of one central sanctuary?

  • The account was shaped late (exilic or after the exile) in priestly circles, using the episode to address who belongs to Israel and loyalty to one legitimate sanctuary.

    Heavy priestly vocabulary (*'edah*, *ma'al*, *qetsef*, Phinehas, the "tabernacle of Yahweh"), the assumption of a single legitimate altar, and the concern about "unclean" land outside the core territory. This is common in critical commentaries (e.g. Nelson, OTL).

  • The account preserves older tradition about tension between the tribes east and west of the Jordan, later framed in priestly and Deuteronomic language.

    The real geographical divide of the Jordan, the memory of a named altar ("Witness," v. 34), and continuity with Num 32's concerns about these same tribes. Argued by more conservative commentators (e.g. Hess, TOTC; Woudstra, NICOT).

in v19

Does the verse assume the land east of the Jordan really was 'unclean' or outside the promised land?

  • Yes, the text reflects a real tradition that the land of promise proper ended at the Jordan.

    Num 34:1–12 and Ezek 47:18 put Canaan's eastern border at the Jordan. Josh 22:25 has the eastern tribes fearing that 'YHWH made the Jordan a boundary'. The phrase 'YHWH's holding' is used only of the west. Moses first resisted the eastern settlement (Num 32:6–15).

  • No, the speakers raise it only as a guess at motive, and the book treats the eastern land as fully legitimate Israelite territory.

    The 'if' makes it conditional. Moses granted the land with divine approval (Num 32:20–33; Deut 3:12–20; Josh 13:8–32), and Josh 22:4 and 22:9 call it their 'ahuzzah given by Moses at YHWH's command'. The story ends with the eastern tribes vindicated (vv.30–34).

in v19

What does 've'otanu 'al-timrodu' mean: 'do not rebel against us' or 'do not drag us into rebellion'?

  • 'Do not rebel against us': rejecting the shared altar breaks with the tribal league.

    It parallels the preceding 'against YHWH'. Most English versions (KJV, BSB, WEB, YLT) read it this way. Loyalty to God and to the people are bound together throughout the chapter.

  • 'Do not involve us in rebellion / do not make us rebels': the fear is shared guilt.

    The unusual object marker *'et* in place of the normal *be-*. Verse 18 ('tomorrow he will be angry with the whole congregation') and the Achan example in v.20 make shared punishment the explicit concern.

in v19

When and why was Joshua 22:9–34 written?

  • A late, priestly-style composition (or heavy reworking) addressing later debates over worship away from Jerusalem.

    The vocabulary resembles the priestly writings of the Pentateuch ('edah 'congregation', ma'al 'treachery', 'ahuzzah, mishkan, Phinehas). The strong one-altar view matches Deut 12 and Lev 17. Scholars such as Kloppenborg suggest a priestly editing of an older tradition. Some link it to later questions about communities living away from the central sanctuary.

  • It preserves an older tradition about a real Jordan-side altar and early tension between the tribes, later shaped by editors.

    It mentions a specific place (Geliloth by the Jordan). The rivalry between east and west matches other early material (Judg 12:1–6). The story does not fit neatly into any single later controversy.

in v20

Who are the others who 'perished' with Achan?

  • The thirty-six Israelites killed at Ai

    Joshua 7:5 links the defeat directly to the breach of faith (7:1, 11–12). The verse's own setup, wrath 'upon all the congregation', points to people outside Achan's household suffering.

  • Achan's household

    Joshua 7:24–25 says Achan, 'his sons and his daughters', his animals and his tent were taken to the Valley of Achor, and 'they stoned him… and burned them with fire'.

  • Both

    The phrase is general ('did not perish alone'), and the speakers' point needs only that the consequences spread, not a list of names. Most commentators take it this way.

in v20

Was Achan's family actually executed?

  • Yes, the family died with him

    Joshua 7:24–25 lists sons and daughters among those brought out, and the plural 'them' is used for the stoning and burning. Ḥerem made everything that touched it ḥerem (Joshua 6:18; Deuteronomy 7:26). This verse's 'not alone' is commonly read as confirming it.

  • Only Achan and his goods were destroyed; the family were witnesses

    Joshua 7:25 switches between singular ('stoned him') and plural ('them'), which may refer to his possessions. Deuteronomy 24:16 forbids putting children to death for a father's sin. On this reading, those who 'perished' with him in Joshua 22:20 are the men of Ai.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. עָוֺן, טָהֵר, נֶגֶף, עֵדָה, מְעַט
  • HALOT s.v. עָוֺן; טהר; נֶגֶף
  • Joüon–Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew §125j (את with non-object nouns)
  • Numbers 25:1–18; 31:16; Deuteronomy 4:3; Psalm 106:28–31; Hosea 9:10 (Peor tradition)
  • Septuagint, Joshua 22:17 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Joshua 22:17
  • T. C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
  • R. S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
  • J. Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary), on Num 25
  • BDB s.v. מָרַד, קָצַף, עֵדָה, שׁוּב
  • HALOT s.v. מרד, קצף, עֵדָה
  • J. Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary), on qetsef and the Levitical cordon (Num 1:53; 16:22, 46)
  • M. H. Woudstra, The Book of Joshua (NICOT)
  • Cross-references: Num 14:9, 43; 16:22, 46; 25:1-9; 32:15; Deut 12; Josh 7; 22:20, 22, 29; 2 Kgs 18:7; 24:1, 20
  • BDB s.v. טָמֵא, אֲחֻזָּה, אָחַז, מָרַד, בִּלְעֲדֵי, מִשְׁכָּן
  • HALOT s.v. טָמֵא, אֲחֻזָּה, מָרַד, שָׁכַן
  • Trent C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary 7)
  • Richard D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library, 1997)
  • L. Daniel Hawk, Joshua (Berit Olam)
  • J. S. Kloppenborg, 'Joshua 22: The Priestly Editing of an Ancient Tradition', Biblica 62 (1981)
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on ritual impurity versus sin
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 22
  • Supplied morphological source text (word-by-word lemma/Strong's data)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. מַעַל / מָעַל
  • HALOT s.v. חֵרֶם
  • HALOT s.v. קֶצֶף
  • BDB s.v. עָוֺן
  • J. Milgrom, Cult and Conscience (on ma‘al as sacrilege); Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible)
  • Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), line 17 (ḥrm)
  • Septuagint, Joshua 22:20 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Josue 22:20
  • R. Nelson, Joshua (OTL); R. Boling, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Joshua 7 and 22

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).