Judges Chapter 8 Read as one passage
Judges 8:4–9
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4Then Gideon and his three hundred men came to the Jordan and crossed it, exhausted yet still in pursuit. 5So Gideon said to the men of Succoth, “Please give my troops some bread, for they are exhausted, and I am still pursuing Zebah and Zalmunna, the kings of Midian.” 6But the leaders of Succoth asked, “Are the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna already in your possession, that we should give bread to your army?” 7“Very well,” Gideon replied, “when the LORD has delivered Zebah and Zalmunna into my hand, I will tear your flesh with the thorns and briers of the wilderness!” 8From there he went up to Penuel and asked the same from them, but the men of Penuel gave the same response as the men of Succoth. 9So Gideon told the men of Penuel, “When I return in triumph, I will tear down this tower!”
What the first hearers heard
To Israelites hearing the Gideon story, this verse is a hinge. Chapter 7 is God's victory: the army is cut down to 300 so that no one could boast, and the enemy is routed by trumpets, jars and the cry "a sword for Yahweh and for Gideon!" Chapter 8:4–21 is a different kind of story. It takes place east of the Jordan and is driven by Gideon's own pursuit. The narrator no longer reports Yahweh acting, though Gideon himself invokes Yahweh (8:7, 19).
The verse does three things for its hearers:
- It raises the stakes. Three hundred exhausted men chasing two kings with 15,000 troops (8:10) is the same lopsided picture as chapter 7, so the hearers are primed to expect another rescue against the odds.
- It tests kinship. The men's hunger turns the story into a test of tribal solidarity, continuing the theme from Ephraim's quarrel in 8:1–3. Will fellow Israelites across the river feed the men fighting their common oppressor? Succoth and Penuel refuse, and Gideon's brutal punishment of them (8:16–17) shows Israel starting to turn on itself. That decline runs through the rest of Judges. Readers who knew Deuteronomy 25:18, where Amalek preys on Israel when they were 'faint and weary', may also have felt the irony: here the weary are let down by their own people, not by an outside enemy. This possible echo is suggestive, not certain.
- It turns from rescue to vengeance. The pursuit finally becomes personal. Gideon executes the kings because they killed his brothers at Tabor (8:18–21). Hearers in the age of the kings would see in this the first signs of a judge acting like a king, which leads into the offer of kingship (8:22) and the disaster of Abimelech (ch. 9).
From the study of Judges 8:4.
Verse by verse
-
4Then Gideon and his three hundred men came to the Jordan and crossed it, exhausted yet still in pursuit.
Full study →Gideon came down to the Jordan and went straight across it. He and the three hundred men who had stayed with him were worn out, running on empty, and still on the chase.
The Hebrew paints a moving picture rather than a summary. Came and crossing run together: Gideon reaches the river and goes over without a pause. The men are "the three hundred", the small force God had deliberately picked out at the water (7:6–8). They had attacked the Midianite camp in the dark and then chased the scattering army down the valley.
The word for their condition, ʿăyēpîm, describes bodies emptied out, the kind of exhaustion that comes from going without food and water. That is why Gideon's very next move is to ask a town for bread (8:5). The last two words sit side by side as two ongoing states: drained and pursuing. The Hebrew joins them with a plain "and". English versions add "yet" to bring out the contrast, which is a fair reading. But the narrator does not praise or comment. He simply sets the men's empty strength next to their unfinished chase and lets the next scene show who will feed them.
-
5So Gideon said to the men of Succoth, “Please give my troops some bread, for they are exhausted, and I am still pursuing Zebah and Zalmunna, the kings of Midian.”
Full study →Gideon has just waded back across the Jordan with his three hundred men. The narrator has already called them “exhausted yet pursuing” (8:4). He comes to the Israelite town of Succoth, whose name means “Shelters”, and addresses its citizens as a group. He frames his words as a request, not an order (“give, please”). He asks only for rounds of bread, the flat disc-loaves that were a soldier's basic ration, for “the people who are at my feet”: the men who follow at his heels, for whom he is responsible as their commander. They are Israel's own people, not mercenaries or strangers.
He gives two reasons. First, they are spent. The word means worn out and depleted, especially from going without food or water, and it is the same word the narrator used a verse earlier, so the reader knows the need is real. Second, “and I, I am in the middle of chasing” Zebah and Zalmunna. The emphatic “I” and the ongoing verb picture a leader who is still on the run, refusing to stop, while his men are close to collapse. By naming the two kings of Midian, Gideon makes clear that this is no longer just a matter of driving raiders back across the border. He is going after the heads of the enemy that has plundered Israel for seven years. To a Hebrew ear the names carry a grim irony: Zebah is the ordinary word for “sacrifice/slaughter-victim”, and Zalmunna can be heard as “protection withheld”.
The verse sets up a test of loyalty between kin. Will an Israelite town east of the Jordan feed Israel's exhausted soldiers before the war is won? Verse 6 gives the town's answer.
-
6But the leaders of Succoth asked, “Are the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna already in your possession, that we should give bread to your army?”
Full study →The town council of Succoth answered Gideon with one voice and with contempt: "Are you already holding the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna? Then why should we have to feed your 'army'?"
The question is not polite curiosity. In the ancient Near East, soldiers often cut off a dead enemy's hand and brought it back as proof of a kill. Egyptian temple walls show the severed hands being counted in piles. So the officials are saying: show us the trophy first. Until the Midianite kings are dead or captured, "in your hand" in both senses, Gideon is only a man with a promise, and in their eyes 300 worn-out men chasing an army of 15,000 is a poor bet.
Their words "now" and "your army" are cutting. They imply that Gideon is acting like a conqueror demanding supplies before he has conquered anything. Behind the sarcasm is calculation. If they feed Gideon and the Midianite kings get away, the raiders will come back and punish Succoth. So these Israelite leaders refuse bread, the simplest food, to fellow Israelites fighting a common enemy. Their question also echoes, and doubts, the promise God had repeated to Gideon: "I will give Midian into your hand." Gideon's reply in the next verse picks up the same words: when the LORD gives them into my hand…
-
7“Very well,” Gideon replied, “when the LORD has delivered Zebah and Zalmunna into my hand, I will tear your flesh with the thorns and briers of the wilderness!”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
8From there he went up to Penuel and asked the same from them, but the men of Penuel gave the same response as the men of Succoth.
Full study →From Succoth, down on the floor of the Jordan valley, Gideon led his worn-out band higher up the Jabbok valley to the next Israelite town, Penuel, and made the same plea word for word: give my men bread, they are exhausted, and we are chasing the kings of Midian. The men of Penuel, speaking as a town and secure behind their fortified tower, gave him the same answer Succoth had given. In effect: Have you already got the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna? Show us the kings' hands, cut off as proof, and then we will feed your army. So the town that carried the name "Face of God", where Jacob once met God face to face, turned its face away from the deliverer God had raised up. The verse is built as a mirror ("he spoke to them like this… they answered just as Succoth answered") so that the second refusal echoes the first. The listener knows by now what Gideon will say next, and that what comes back down this road will be judgment, not thanks.
-
9So Gideon told the men of Penuel, “When I return in triumph, I will tear down this tower!”
Not studied yet. Study this verse
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
faint (KJV, WEB)
ʿăyēpîm
- What we hear
- About to pass out; or weak and 'faint-hearted' in courage.
- What they heard
- Physically drained and depleted, especially from hunger and thirst. The men's resolve is not in doubt; it is their bodies that are spent.
-
in v4
yet pursuing (KJV, BSB, and others)
wĕrōdĕpîm
- What we hear
- A pointed 'nevertheless', the narrator praising heroic determination against the odds.
- What they heard
- 'And pursuing.' Two conditions stated side by side: worn out, and still on the chase. Hebrew 'and' can carry a contrast, so 'yet' is a defensible reading. But the narrator does not comment on it, and the following scenes cast Gideon's campaign in a more mixed light.
-
in v5
faint (KJV, WEB: “for they be faint”)
ʿăyēpîm
- What we hear
- About to pass out or lose consciousness.
- What they heard
- Worn out and depleted, especially from lack of food and water. Spent, not unconscious.
-
in v5
loaves (KJV, WEB)
kikkerôt
- What we hear
- Tall, rectangular loaves baked in a tin.
- What they heard
- Flat round discs of bread, a basic unit of ration. The same word means a ‘round thing’, as in the talent weight and the round plain of the Jordan.
-
in v5
the people (KJV, WEB, YLT)
ʿam
- What we hear
- Civilians or people in general.
- What they heard
- In this context, Gideon's fighting men (the 300), with overtones of being kin and belonging to Israel.
-
in v6
princes (KJV, WEB)
sarei (שָׂרֵי)
- What we hear
- Sons of a king, members of a royal family.
- What they heard
- Town officials or leaders, a governing council (v. 14 lists them with the elders, 77 men). Succoth had no king.
-
in v8
the men of Penuel
ʾanshê Pənûʾēl
- What we hear
- Some local residents, a few individuals who happened to say no.
- What they heard
- The town's adult male citizens acting as its governing body. The refusal was an official civic decision binding the whole town.
Every word
-
וַיָּבֹ֥א
wayyābōʾ · H0935
come, go in, arrive · v4
'And he came.' This is the ordinary Hebrew way of moving a story forward. It picks the pursuit back up after the quarrel with Ephraim in 8:1–3.
-
גִדְע֖וֹן
gidʿôn · H1439
Gideon · v4
The judge from the clan of Abiezer in Manasseh, also called Jerubbaal (6:32). The name probably comes from a root meaning 'to hew down' and is usually taken as 'hewer' or 'cutter'. It fits the man who cut down his father's Baal altar.
-
הַיַּרְדֵּ֑נָה
hayyardēnâ · H3383
Jordan (river) · v4
'To the Jordan.' The ending -â marks direction, so the sense is 'Jordan-ward'. The Jordan was the boundary between the tribes west of the river and the Israelite settlements to the east.
-
עֹבֵ֣ר
ʿōbēr · H5674
pass over, cross · v4
A participle, 'crossing'. It pictures the crossing as going on, not as a finished event. Gideon arrives at the river and moves straight across, eastward, after the Midianites.
-
ה֗וּא
hûʾ · H1931
he · v4
'He.' It is added for emphasis and so that the three hundred can be listed alongside him: 'he, and the three hundred'.
-
וּשְׁלֹשׁ־
ûšĕlōš- · H7969
three · v4
'And three', the first half of 'three hundred'.
-
מֵא֤וֹת
mēʾôt · H3967
hundred · v4
'Hundreds.' Together with the previous word it makes 'three hundred', the same small force that was picked out at the water in 7:6–8.
-
הָאִישׁ֙
hāʾîš · H0376
man · v4
Literally 'the man', a singular used for a group. This is normal Hebrew after numbers ('three hundred man'), and English rightly says 'men'. The definite article points back to the well-known three hundred.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăšer · H0834
who, which, that · v4, v5, v8
'Who.' It begins the clause describing the men.
-
אִתּ֔וֹ
ʾittô · H0854
with · v4
'With him.' These are his own men, the ones who stayed with him through the night attack.
-
עֲיֵפִ֖ים
ʿăyēpîm · H5889
weary, faint, exhausted · v4, v5
'Worn out.' Elsewhere this word is closely tied to hunger and thirst, as with Esau 'famished' from the field (Gen 25:29–30) and the 'parched' land of Ps 63:1. It describes bodies that are running empty, which is why Gideon asks for bread in the next verse.
-
וְרֹדְפִֽים׃
wĕrōdĕpîm · H7291
pursue, chase · v4, v5
'And pursuing.' Like 'worn out', it is a participle describing an ongoing state: drained and still on the chase. The 'and' simply joins the two. English 'yet' is a reasonable reading of the contrast, but the Hebrew does not spell it out.
-
וַיֹּאמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v5, v6
Moves the story along: Gideon, who has just crossed the Jordan (8:4), now speaks to the town. Nothing in the verb itself marks politeness or command.
-
לְאַנְשֵׁי
leʾanšê · H0582
to the men of · v5, v8
“Men of [a town]” means its citizens, the full male members who speak for the community. In the next verse the reply comes from the town's “officials” (sārê), so the request goes to the town and its leaders answer.
-
סֻכּוֹת
sukkôt · H5523
Succoth (“booths, shelters”) · v5, v6, v8
An Israelite town east of the Jordan, given to Gad (Josh 13:27). By tradition Jacob named it for the shelters he built there (Gen 33:17). A place called “Shelters” is now asked to feed and shelter Israel's own soldiers.
-
תְּנוּ
tenû · H5414
give! · v5, v6
A plural command addressed to the whole town. On its own it is blunt, but the particle that follows softens it into a request.
-
נָא
nāʾ · H4994
-
כִּכְּרוֹת
kikkerôt · H3603
round things: round loaves (also a ‘talent’ weight, or a round plain) · v5
Flat, round discs of bread baked on hot stones or on the wall of a clay oven, the ordinary food of the field. The same word names the round ‘talent’ weight of metal and the round plain of the Jordan valley. The basic idea is ‘something round’.
-
לֶחֶם
leḥem · H3899
bread, food · v5, v6
Bread, and by extension food in general. ‘Rounds of bread’ is a modest request: rations, not a feast.
-
לָעָם
lāʿām · H5971
to the people / troops · v5
ʿam is ‘people’ or ‘kin’, and in a military setting the men under arms. Here it means Gideon's 300 (8:4). The word also carries a sense of belonging: these are Israel's own people.
-
בְּרַגְלָי
beraglāy · H7272
at my feet · v5
An idiom for ‘following me, under my command’, the men who walk at their leader's heels. The same expression is used of followers in Exod 11:8 and 1 Sam 25:27.
-
כִּי
kî · H3588
for, because · v5, v6
Gives two reasons for the request: the men's exhaustion and the ongoing chase.
-
הֵם
hēm · H1992
they · v5
‘They’ are exhausted. This is set against ‘and I’ in the next clause: the men are spent, but the leader presses on.
-
וְאָנֹכִי
weʾānōkî · H0595
and I · v5
An emphatic, stand-alone ‘I’. Gideon puts himself at the centre of the pursuit, a hint of the personal stake that comes out in 8:18–19.
-
אַחֲרֵי
ʾaḥărê · H0310
after · v5
Marks who is being chased: ‘pursuing after’.
-
זֶבַח
zebaḥ · H2078
Zebah · v5, v6
A Midianite king. Spelled this way the name is identical to the ordinary Hebrew word for ‘sacrifice’ or ‘slaughtered victim’, a grim fit for a man who will be executed (8:21).
-
וְצַלְמֻנָּע
weṣalmunnāʿ · H6759
and Zalmunna · v5, v6
The second Midianite king. Hebrew ears could hear it as ‘shade/protection withheld’. It may originally be a non-Israelite name, possibly containing the name of the Arabian god Ṣalm.
-
מַלְכֵי
malkê · H4428
kings of · v5
Gideon names his targets by title. He is no longer just driving raiders off; he is going after the enemy's leadership.
-
מִדְיָן
midyān · H4080
Midian · v5
Camel-riding tribes from the desert regions south and east of Israel. For seven years they had raided Israel's harvests (6:1–6).
-
שָׂרֵי
sarei · H8269
officials, leaders, commanders · v6
The town's ruling men. Verse 14 calls them 'officials and elders,' seventy-seven in all. These are local leaders who can speak for the town and decide what it will do, not royalty.
-
הֲכַף
hakhaf · H3709G
is the palm/hand of…? · v6
The opening ha- marks a question, and here it is a sneering one. Kaf is the palm or flat of the hand, a different word from the yad ('hand') later in the verse. The officials are asking for proof: show us the enemy kings' hands.
-
עַתָּה
ʿattah · H6258
now · v6
'Now, already, at this moment.' It carries the taunt: you haven't won yet, so why are you acting like a conqueror who can demand supplies?
-
בְּיָדֶךָ
beyadekha · H3027H
in your hand · v6
'In your hand' means in your possession and power. It plays against kaf: is their hand in your hand? Gideon throws the phrase back in v. 7: 'when the LORD gives Zebah and Zalmunna into my hand.'
-
לִצְבָאֲךָ
litsvaʾakha · H6635A
-
וַיַּ֤עַל
wayyaʿal · H5927G
go up, ascend · v8
'And he went up.' Literal: Gideon climbs from Succoth on the Jordan valley floor eastward and higher up the Jabbok valley to Penuel. The 'and' form moves the story on to the next step.
-
מִשָּׁם֙
mishshām · H8033G
there; from there · v8
'From there,' meaning from Succoth, where he had just been turned down (vv. 5–7). It ties the two refusals together in one line of travel.
-
פְּנוּאֵ֔ל
Pənûʾēl · H6439G
Penuel / Peniel ('face of God') · v8
The destination, given with no preposition, the normal Hebrew way of marking where someone goes. This is the place where Jacob said he had 'seen God face to face' (Genesis 32:30–31), and a Hebrew hearer would know the story behind the name.
-
וַיְדַבֵּ֥ר
wayədabbēr · H1696G
speak · v8
'And he spoke.' A general verb for speaking. Here it stands for the request repeated from v. 5: bread for his worn-out men.
-
אֲלֵיהֶ֖ם
ʾălêhem · H0413
to, toward · v8
'To them.' 'Them' points ahead to the men of Penuel, who are named only in the next clause, as often happens in Hebrew storytelling.
-
כָּזֹ֑את
kāzōʾt · H2063
like this, in the same way · v8
'Like this,' meaning the same words as at Succoth. The narrator doesn't repeat the speech. The short word tells the reader it was the same plea word for word.
-
וַיַּעֲנ֤וּ
wayyaʿănû · H6030B
answer, respond · v8
'And they answered.' A plural verb: the town answers as one body. Their answer, a refusal, mirrors v. 6.
-
אוֹתוֹ֙
ʾôtô · H0853
direct-object marker + 'him' · v8
'Him,' meaning Gideon. The particle marks him as the person the answer is directed at. English has no separate word for it.
The world behind it
- The enemy. Midianites, Amalekites and other "people of the east" had raided Israel's harvests for seven years on camels (6:1–6). After Gideon's night attack, the survivors fled east toward the Jordan fords and on into the desert fringe, heading for Karkor (8:10) under their kings Zebah and Zalmunna.
- East of the Jordan. Succoth and Penuel (8:5–9) were Israelite towns in the Jabbok valley, in land assigned to Gad. They were kin to Gideon's men, but they lived nearest the desert routes and so were most open to Midianite revenge. Their reply in 8:6, "Are the hands of Zebah and Zalmunna already in your hand?", refers to the practice of cutting off a defeated enemy's hands as a trophy or count. They will not commit until the kings are actually captured.
- What kin owed. In a tribal society with no standing army, towns along an army's route were expected to feed fighters of their own people. 2 Samuel 17:27–29 shows the ideal: allies east of the Jordan bring food to David's people because they are "hungry, weary and thirsty in the wilderness". Gideon's exhausted men, asking for bread, are making exactly that claim.
- Distances. The battle began near the hill of Moreh in the Jezreel valley (7:1). The flight ran southeast toward Beth-shittah and Abel-meholah (7:22), a long downhill chase to the Jordan, all after a night without sleep.
From the study of Judges 8:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
How does 8:4 fit with 7:25, where Gideon seems to be already 'beyond the Jordan'?
-
8:4 picks up again after the Ephraim interlude (8:1–3), returning to the moment of the crossing. 7:25 simply jumps ahead.
Hebrew stories often finish one thread before going back to another. 8:1–3 is clearly a side scene, and 8:4 begins with the ordinary 'and he came', which resumes the main action.
-
'Beyond the Jordan' in 7:25 means 'from the Jordan region' or is seen from a different standpoint, so there is no real conflict.
The phrase can depend on the speaker's position, and the Hebrew preposition can mean 'from the region of'.
-
Two separate accounts of the campaign have been joined: a western story (ch. 7) and an eastern one (8:4–21).
There are different enemy leaders (Oreb and Zeeb vs. Zebah and Zalmunna), a change in tone, and the narrator no longer mentions Yahweh acting in 8:4–21. Many critical commentators, such as Boling and Soggin, hold this view.
in v4
Is the original reading 'and pursuing' or 'and hungry'?
-
Keep the standard Hebrew 'and pursuing'.
It is the harder-to-improve, well-attested Hebrew reading. It matches Gideon's 'I am pursuing' in v.5 and the verb's repetition through 7:23–8:12. The Vaticanus-type Greek also has 'pursuing'.
-
Read 'and hungry', following part of the Greek tradition.
The Alexandrinus-type Greek has 'hungry'. It suits the request for bread in v.5, and the two Hebrew words are similar enough to be confused when copied. The NRSV follows this.
in v4
Does the narrator present Gideon's pursuit as admirable endurance or as the start of overreach?
-
Heroic endurance: the verse highlights the faithful few pressing on to finish God's victory.
The 300 are the force Yahweh chose. Gideon invokes Yahweh in 8:7, the kings are captured (8:12), and the oppression ends (8:28).
-
A darker turn: the pursuit becomes Gideon's private campaign and ends in vengeance and violence against fellow Israelites.
The narrator does not credit Yahweh in 8:4–21. Gideon tortures and kills men of Succoth and Penuel (8:16–17), and he kills the kings because of his own brothers (8:18–19). Literary readings such as those of Webb and Block point to this pattern.
in v5
Was Succoth's refusal (anticipated by this request) reasonable caution or betrayal of kin?
-
It was reasonable caution: a small Transjordanian town could not risk reprisal from Midian while 15,000 enemy troops remained.
8:10 (15,000 still with the kings); the officials' wording in 8:6, ‘are the hands … already in your hand?’, points to fear of a premature commitment; seven years of Midianite dominance (6:1–6).
-
It was a breach of kinship duty, and the narrator presents it as such.
The polite request (nāʾ) and the narrator's repeated ‘exhausted’ (8:4–5) frame the need as genuine; parallels with Nabal (1 Sam 25) and the contrast with the loyal Transjordanians in 2 Sam 17:27–29; the theme of the tribes failing one another runs through Judges.
-
The narrator blames both sides: Succoth fails, but Gideon's response is disproportionate.
Gideon's threats and punishments (8:7, 16–17) contrast with his diplomatic handling of Ephraim (8:1–3), and the story moves into his personal vendetta (8:18–19) and his ephod (8:27).
in v5
Is the pursuit of Zebah and Zalmunna a war of deliverance or a personal blood feud?
-
It completes the LORD's deliverance by removing the enemy's leaders.
Ps 83:11 remembers it as divine judgement on enemies; Isa 9:4 and 10:26 recall ‘the day of Midian’.
-
It is largely Gideon's private revenge for his brothers.
8:18–19 reveals that the kings killed Gideon's brothers at Tabor; the emphatic ‘and I’ in 8:5; in chapter 8, unlike chapters 6–7, there is no mention of the LORD directing the pursuit.
in v5
Where was Succoth?
-
Tell Deir ʿAlla in the central Jordan valley.
Traditional identification. It fits Gen 33:17, Josh 13:27 and 1 Kgs 7:46 (the Jordan plain between Succoth and Zarethan).
-
Tell el-Ekhsas or another nearby site.
Some archaeologists argue that Deir ʿAlla's remains fit a sanctuary site better and that its ancient name was different.
in v6
Does 'the palm of Zebah and Zalmunna in your hand' refer to severed hands taken as war trophies, or is it only an idiom for capture?
-
It alludes to the practice of cutting off enemies' hands as proof of a kill.
Egyptian evidence (the Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III; the tomb of Ahmose son of Ebana) shows severed hands being counted and rewarded. Hebrew uses the concrete word kaf ('palm') rather than the usual yad, and Judg 1:6–7 shows that mutilating defeated kings was known in this period. Many commentators (e.g., Boling, Block) take this view.
-
It is an idiom of control: 'Have you got the kings in your grasp yet?'
Kaf can mean grip or power just as yad does (e.g., 2 Sam 19:9; Judg 6:14 uses kaf for 'the hand of Midian'). The kings were in fact captured alive (8:12, 21), so literal hands may not be the point. The phrase works as a demand for proof of victory either way.
in v8
Where were Penuel and Succoth?
-
Penuel = Tell edh-Dhahab esh-Sherqiyeh (the eastern of the twin hills on the Jabbok); Succoth = Tell Deir ʿAlla.
Fits Genesis 32–33 and the order of Gideon's route here, with Penuel higher up the river. The twin hills dominate the Jabbok gorge. Deir ʿAlla matches the Jordan-valley setting of Succoth and the mention of bronze casting in 1 Kings 7:46. This is the majority view in recent atlases and commentaries.
-
Penuel = the western hill (Tell edh-Dhahab el-Gharbiyeh), or Succoth = another valley site such as Tell el-Ekhsas.
There are no inscriptions naming either town. Some scholars argue that the pottery sequence at Deir ʿAlla does not fit an Israelite town well, and that the western Dhahab hill better suits an Iron Age fortified town. The exact sites are uncertain, though the general area is not.
in v8
Does the narrator approve of Gideon's response to Penuel's refusal?
-
The refusal was treachery, and Gideon's punishment is presented as deserved.
Judges condemns tribes that fail to join Israel's wars (5:23 curses Meroz for not coming 'to the help of the LORD'). Gideon carries out exactly what he threatened, as a judgment promised in advance.
-
The episode marks Gideon's moral decline: rightful anger turning into excessive revenge on fellow Israelites.
In v. 17 Gideon kills the men of Penuel, which goes beyond his threat in v. 9 (only the tower). The chapter goes on to his personal vengeance for his brothers (vv. 18–21), the gold ephod that 'became a snare' (v. 27), and Abimelech's bloodshed (ch. 9). Commentators such as Webb and Block read the transjordan episode as a turning point.
Sources
- BDB s.v. עָיֵף, רָדַף, עָבַר
- HALOT s.v. עָיֵף, רדף
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Judges 8:4 (A and B texts)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Judg 8:4
- Vulgate, Liber Iudicum 8:4
- Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (New American Commentary)
- Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT)
- Robert G. Boling, Judges (Anchor Bible)
- J. Alberto Soggin, Judges (Old Testament Library)
- BDB s.v. כִּכָּר, עָיֵף, רֶגֶל
- HALOT s.v. כִּכָּר; עַם; עָיֵף
- Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology) for Judg 8:5
- Josh 13:27; Gen 33:17; Deut 25:18; 1 Sam 25; 2 Sam 17:27–29; Ps 83:11
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 8:4–9
- Daniel I. Block, Judges, Ruth (NAC) on Judg 8:4–17
- Barry G. Webb, The Book of Judges (NICOT) on Judg 8
- BDB and HALOT s.v. כַּף, יָד, שַׂר, צָבָא, לֶחֶם
- Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III; Autobiography of Ahmose son of Ebana (ANET / Lichtheim, Ancient Egyptian Literature II)
- Joshua 13:27; Genesis 33:17; Judges 7:7–15; 8:4–16
- BDB (Brown–Driver–Briggs) s.v. עָלָה, עָנָה, אִישׁ, פְּנוּאֵל, סֻכּוֹת
- HALOT s.v. פְּנוּאֵל, סֻכּוֹת, עָלָה
- Trent C. Butler, Judges (Word Biblical Commentary)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Judges 8:4–17
- Egyptian evidence for severed hands as battle tallies: autobiography of Ahmose son of Ebana; Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III
- Topographical list of Shoshenq I (Karnak) for Penuel/Succoth/Mahanaim
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.