Luke Chapter 1 Read as one passage
Luke 1:51–53
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
51He has performed mighty deeds with His arm; He has scattered those who are proud in the thoughts of their hearts. 52He has brought down rulers from their thrones, but has exalted the humble. 53He has filled the hungry with good things, but has sent the rich away empty.
What the first hearers heard
To Jewish hearers in the first century, and to Luke's readers who knew the Greek Scriptures, this line said three things:
- The God of the Exodus is acting again. "His arm" and "scattered" are battle-hymn words. The story starting with Mary's pregnancy is presented as the next great act of the God who broke Pharaoh, not as a private spiritual event.
- The arrogant are on the wrong side of that act. Those who put themselves above others and plot from that position, including the rulers and the rich of the next verses, are not safe. Their plans will be broken apart.
- The reversal is as good as done. The past-tense verbs, in the style of Hannah's song and the Psalms, let a powerless woman speak of the fall of the powerful as already accomplished. This made the hymn something people could sing as both praise and hope. It tied Israel's confidence to God's track record and to his faithfulness to Abraham (vv. 54–55), not to any human army.
It also served as a warning to the hearers themselves. Proverbs 3:34 says God opposes the arrogant and gives grace to the lowly, and the hymn places Mary, and anyone who "fears him" (v. 50), on the side of the lowly.
From the study of Luke 1:51.
Verse by verse
-
51He has performed mighty deeds with His arm; He has scattered those who are proud in the thoughts of their hearts.
Full study →God has acted with his own ruling might, the same "arm" that broke Pharaoh at the Exodus. He has routed the arrogant like a defeated army and sent scattering those who set themselves above others and above God, right down to the plans and purposes they had settled in their hearts.
The first line is a Hebrew-flavored idiom, literally "he made might with his arm": God did not just have power, he used it, and it won. "His arm" is not a neutral image. For a Jewish hearer it recalled the Exodus ("a mighty hand and an outstretched arm") and Isaiah's promise that the LORD would one day "bare his holy arm" again to redeem his people.
The second line uses battle language. "Scattered" is what happens to a beaten army or a broken flock. The ones scattered are the hyperēphanoi, literally those who "show themselves above": the arrogant, the haughty, those who lord it over others. The next verse shows who they mostly are: rulers on thrones and the rich. Their arrogance is located in "the thinking of their heart". In Hebrew thought the heart is where a person plans and decides, so this means their deep intentions and schemes, not passing feelings or fantasies.
Both verbs are in the simple past. Mary speaks of God's overthrow of the arrogant as already done. That could mean God's past record in Israel's history, the decisive act now begun in her own pregnancy, or a future reversal so certain it can be sung as finished. The line probably carries all three at once.
-
52He has brought down rulers from their thrones, but has exalted the humble.
Full study →"He has pulled the powerful down off their thrones, and he has lifted high the people who were kept low."
Mary is singing about God. In the Greek the line is a see-saw: first a downward verb, then an upward one. Pulled down is a physical word, the same one Luke later uses for taking a body down from a cross, so the picture is of rulers being lifted bodily off their raised seats. The word for "rulers" (dynastai, "men of power") shares its root with "the Mighty One" of verse 49. The God who is truly mighty unseats those who only hold power for a time. None of the nouns has "the" in front of it, so this is not aimed at one named king. It describes thrones and rulers as a class, and how God deals with them.
The people lifted up are the tapeinoi, literally the "low-lying" ones: people with no rank, no wealth and no protection. In verse 48 Mary used the same family of words for herself, a young slave-girl (doulē) of no account whom God has noticed. So "the humble" here means first the socially low, people like her, and not mainly people with a modest attitude. Within the Jewish tradition Mary is drawing on, these are also the poor who have nothing to rely on but God.
The verbs are in the Greek past tense ("he pulled down", "he lifted up"). Mary speaks of this overturning as already done. It is what God has always done in Israel's story, from Hannah's song (1 Samuel 2:7-8) onward, and Mary sees it as already set in motion by the child she is carrying, who has been promised "the throne of his father David" (1:32). Verse 52 sits beside verse 53 (the hungry filled, the rich sent away empty). The pattern runs down-up, up-down: rulers down, lowly up, hungry filled, rich emptied.
-
53He has filled the hungry with good things, but has sent the rich away empty.
Full study →People who are hungry: God has fed them until they are full of good things. People who are rich: he has sent them away from his door with nothing in their hands.
Mary speaks as if it has already happened. Greek uses a simple past tense for both acts ("filled", "sent away"). She sings about God's great reversal as a settled fact, already begun in the child she is carrying and as certain as God's past deeds for Israel.
The words are concrete. "Hungry" means people without enough to eat. "Good things" are real goods and provisions, the same phrase Luke later uses for the rich fool's barns and the rich man's comforts. "Rich" is the opposite of hungry. The picture is a great patron's household. Some callers are seated and fed until they are satisfied. Others are dismissed at the door "empty", a phrase Israel's Scriptures used for a wrong done to the vulnerable: you do not send a freed slave or a widow away empty. Here God does to the rich what the powerful usually did to the poor.
The two lines are built as mirrors: hungry and filled with good, rich and sent away empty. The line echoes Psalm 107:9 ("he fills the hungry soul with good things") and Hannah's song (1 Samuel 2:5–8). In the same way, Luke's later "Blessed are you who are hungry now… Woe to you who are full now" echoes this verse.
Where the English drifted
-
in v51
the imagination of their hearts (KJV, WEB)
dianoia kardias
- What we hear
- Their fantasies, daydreams or creative mental pictures, as if God scattered people for what they fancied.
- What they heard
- The thinking, intentions and plans of their inmost self: the settled purposes and schemes that express their arrogance.
-
in v51
the proud
hyperēphanoi
- What we hear
- People with high self-esteem or an inner feeling of pride, or even people who are rightly "proud" of something; a private character flaw.
- What they heard
- The arrogant who set themselves above others and God, a stance lived out in how they use power. The next verse identifies them with rulers on thrones and the rich.
-
in v52
the humble
tapeinous
- What we hear
- People with a modest, unassuming character; the opposite of arrogant.
- What they heard
- People of low position: the poor, powerless and overlooked, set directly against rulers on thrones. In the Jewish tradition this includes their dependence on God, but social lowliness comes first, as Mary's own 'low estate' (1:48) shows.
-
in v52
put down
katheilen
- What we hear
- To insult or belittle someone; or to euthanise an animal.
- What they heard
- To pull or lift someone down from a raised seat, i.e. to depose them.
-
in v53
the hungry
peinōntas
- What we hear
- People who are spiritually hungry or longing for God, often read through Matthew 5:6 ('hunger and thirst for righteousness').
- What they heard
- People who actually lack food, the poor of Israel. In the psalms these were also the people who depend on God, but the physical hunger is not erased.
-
in v53
good things
agatha
- What we hear
- Abstract or spiritual 'blessings'.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v53
Mary's 'hungry' are not only the spiritually hungry
- What's often taught
- The verse is often read as being about spiritual appetite: God fills those who hunger for him with spiritual blessings and sends away the spiritually self-satisfied, whatever their bank balance.
- What the text supports
The reading gets one thing right. In Israel's psalms the hungry poor are also the people who depend on God, and the surrounding verses speak of the proud and the humble (1:51–52).
But the wording does not let 'hungry' and 'rich' become purely inner states:
- No qualifier. Luke writes simply 'hungry' (peinōntas), with no 'for righteousness' as in Matthew 5:6. He does the same in 6:21 ('you who hunger now').
- 'Rich' is the counterpart. The opposite of 'hungry' is 'rich' (ploutountas), an economic word, not 'proud'.
- 'Good things' are goods. Luke uses the same plural for the rich fool's stored goods (12:18–19) and the rich man's comforts (16:25).
- Luke repeats the reversal. 'Woe to you who are filled now, for you will hunger' (6:25) uses the very verb of 1:53.
The song announces a real reversal of conditions, with physical hunger and wealth included, as an act of God's mercy to Israel. The spiritual dimension is part of it, not a replacement for it.
- Where the English feeds it
- Generally the English does not cause this. 'Good things' is vague enough to be heard as 'blessings', and readers who know Matthew's 'hunger and thirst for righteousness' carry it into Luke.
ἐμπίμπλημι empimplēmi ἀγαθός agathos πεινάω peinaō πλουτέω plouteō
Every word
-
ἐποίησεν
epoiēsen · G4160
to do, make · v51
Literally "he made/did." Joined to "might", it copies a Hebrew way of speaking: "to do strength" means to act with power (compare Psalm 118:15–16, "the right hand of the LORD does valiantly"). The verb is in the simple past form (aorist), presenting God's action as a single, completed whole.
-
κράτος
kratos · G2904
might, power, dominion · v51
Power that actually prevails and rules, not just potential strength. In the New Testament it is used almost only of God, often in praise formulas ("to him be the dominion"). Here it is the object of "made": God put his ruling power into action.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, with, by · v51
Here it marks the means: "with" or "by" his arm, matching the Greek Old Testament's "by your mighty arm" (Psalm 89:10).
-
βραχίονι
brachioni · G1023
arm · v51
The arm, the limb a warrior uses to strike. In Israel's Scriptures "the arm of the LORD" is shorthand for God's power at work in history, above all in the Exodus ("with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm").
-
αὐτοῦ·
autou · G846
-
διεσκόρπισεν
dieskorpisen · G1287
to scatter, disperse · v51
To scatter in every direction, like an army routed on the battlefield or a flock broken up. It recalls the old battle cry "Arise, LORD, let your enemies be scattered" (Numbers 10:35; Psalm 68:1). Again a simple past form.
-
ὑπερηφάνους
hyperēphanous · G5244
arrogant, proud, haughty · v51
Literally "showing oneself above" others: people who rank themselves over others and over God. It is the opposite of the "lowly" whom God lifts up in v. 52. In Israel's Scriptures it often describes powerful oppressors and enemies, not just people with a private vanity.
-
διανοίᾳ
dianoia · G1271
mind, thinking, intention · v51
The faculty of thinking things through, and also its product: plans, purposes, schemes. Grammatically it specifies where the arrogance lies ("proud in their thinking"). It may also hint that God scatters them right in the middle of their plans.
-
καρδίας
kardias · G2588
heart · v51
In Hebrew thought the heart is the center of the person: where people reason, decide and plan, not chiefly where they feel. "The thinking of their heart" means their deepest plans and intentions.
-
καθεῖλεν
katheilen · G2507
-
δυνάστας
dynastas · G1413
ruler, potentate, man of power · v52
People who hold real political power: kings, princes, high officials. There is no article, so it means rulers as a class, not one named king. It comes from the same root as 'the Mighty One' (ho dynatos) in 1:49: the truly Mighty One unseats the mighty.
-
ἀπὸ
apo · G0575
from, away from · v52
Marks separation. The rulers are removed from the seat that gave them their status.
-
θρόνων
thronōn · G2362
throne, seat of authority · v52
The raised chair of a king or judge, the visible symbol of rule and honour. It is plural and has no article: thrones in general. Being removed from your throne means losing your office and your public honour together.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v52, v53
A simple 'and' joins the two halves. The contrast between them comes from the meaning of the words (down/up, rulers/lowly), so translations that say 'but' (BSB) are spelling out what is implied.
-
ὕψωσεν
hypsōsen · G5312
-
ταπεινούς
tapeinous · G5011
low, lowly, of low status, humble · v52
Literally 'low-lying'. Here it means people of low standing: the poor, the powerless, the overlooked. It is set directly against rulers on thrones, and it picks up Mary's own 'low estate' (tapeinōsis) in 1:48. It describes their position more than a modest attitude.
-
πεινῶντας
peinōntas · G3983
to be hungry · v53
"People who are hungry": a present participle with no article, so it describes people by their ongoing condition. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: *the hungry*, of all people, are the ones God fills.
-
ἐνέπλησεν
eneplēsen · G1705
to fill up, satisfy · v53
"He filled full": eating until you are satisfied. The aorist (a simple past tense) states it as something God has done. Luke uses the same verb in 6:25 for the 'full now' who will go hungry.
-
ἀγαθῶν
agathōn · G18
-
πλουτοῦντας
ploutountas · G4147
to be rich · v53
"People who are rich": a present participle with no article, like 'hungry' in the first line. It means people who have wealth, and it is the direct opposite of the hungry.
-
ἐξαπέστειλεν
exapesteilen · G1821
to send off, send away, dismiss · v53
"He sent away": dismissing someone from your presence. The picture is a patron's door, where some callers are fed and others are sent off without receiving anything.
-
κενούς
kenous · G2756
empty, empty-handed · v53
"Empty": it describes the rich as they leave, with nothing in their hands. It ends the verse as the opposite of 'good things' at the end of the first line.
The world behind it
A hymn built from Israel's Scriptures. The Magnificat (Luke 1:46–55) is almost entirely woven from Old Testament phrases. Its main model is Hannah's song in 1 Samuel 2:1–10, sung by another unlikely mother: "Talk no more so very proudly… The LORD brings low and he exalts… he raises up the poor from the dust… to make them sit with princes." Verse 51 draws especially on Psalm 89:10 (Greek version 88:11), which already combines "the arrogant", "your mighty arm" and "you scattered your enemies", and on the Exodus language of God's "arm".
Who is speaking, and under whom. A young woman from an obscure Galilean village, with no status, sings this under the rule of Herod's family and behind them Rome (Luke 1:5; 2:1). Jewish hymns of the time spoke the same way. The Psalms of Solomon (1st century BC) call the Roman general Pompey and Jerusalem's own corrupt elite "arrogant" and pray for God to bring them down and raise up a son of David. So "the arrogant" and "rulers on thrones" (v. 52) would not have sounded abstract. The hearers' world was full of men who put themselves above others.
The "lowly" and the "arrogant". In Israel's Psalms and Prophets the poor and lowly (Hebrew ʿanāwîm) were those who, having no power of their own, relied on God, while the arrogant relied on their power. Mary has just called herself God's lowly servant (v. 48). Verse 51 is the other side of that: what God does to the ones on top.
From the study of Luke 1:51.
Where scholars differ
in v51
What do the past-tense verbs ("has shown", "has scattered") refer to?
-
God's past acts in Israel's history: the Exodus, the defeat of oppressors. Mary praises God's character as shown in his record.
The imagery comes from Exodus and the Psalms (Psalm 89:10). Verses 54–55 look back to Abraham and the fathers.
-
The decisive act God has just done in Mary's conception of the Messiah, which in principle already settles the reversal.
The hymn begins with what God "has done for me" (v. 49). For Luke, the coming of Jesus is the turning point of history.
-
A future end-time reversal described as already done because it is certain, like the Hebrew "prophetic perfect" (a past-tense verb used for a future event).
Rulers had not yet visibly fallen when this was sung. Similar reversal language appears in Luke 6:20–26 as future promise. Hebrew poetry often used past tenses this way.
-
A "timeless" past tense: this is what God characteristically does.
Hymns and proverbs use the aorist for general truths. Compare Proverbs 3:34 ("the Lord opposes the arrogant").
in v51
Who are "the arrogant"?
-
Mainly foreign oppressors and powerful elites: Gentile rulers, Herodian and priestly aristocracy.
Verse 52 pairs them with "rulers on thrones" and verse 53 with "the rich". Psalms of Solomon uses the same word for Pompey and corrupt rulers.
-
Anyone, inside or outside Israel, who sets himself above God and others. A moral and spiritual category that applies to social power but is not limited to it.
The arrogance is located in "the thinking of their heart". Proverbs 3:34, James 4:6 and 1 Peter 5:5 use the same contrast without a political target. In Luke, Pharisees and the rich within Israel are warned (Luke 16:14–15; 18:9–14).
in v52
What do the past-tense verbs ('has brought down', 'has exalted') refer to?
-
God's past deeds in Israel's history
The song ends by grounding everything in God's mercy 'to Abraham and his offspring' and his promises 'to our fathers' (1:54-55), and the language comes from Hannah's song and the Psalms, which recount God's past acts.
-
A timeless description of what God habitually does
Greek can use the aorist for general truths. Parallel lines in Job, Psalms and Sirach describe God's characteristic ways, not single events.
-
A future reversal spoken of as already accomplished
This is the 'prophetic perfect' of Hebrew poetry, which Greek renders with the aorist. Mary sings in response to the conception of the coming king (1:31-33), and Luke's later narrative (6:20-26; 16:19-31) shows the reversal unfolding. Fitzmyer, Brown and others see the decisive act as begun in the coming of Jesus.
in v52
Is the reversal social and political, or spiritual?
-
Concrete social and political overturning
The terms are concrete: rulers, thrones, hungry, rich (v. 53). Tapeinos is set against rulers, not against arrogant attitudes, and Luke elsewhere pairs blessing on the poor with woe on the rich (6:20-26). The setting under Herod and Augustus gives the language a political edge.
-
Primarily religious and moral: God opposes pride and favours the humble-hearted
Verse 51 speaks of the proud 'in the thoughts of their hearts', an inner attitude. In Jewish usage 'the poor/lowly' became a name for the pious. Luke 14:11 and 18:14 use the same verbs for attitudes of self-exaltation and self-humbling.
-
Both, inseparably
In the biblical idiom the 'lowly' are the oppressed who depend on God, and the 'mighty' are those whose power makes them self-reliant and proud. Many commentators (e.g. Green, Bovon) hold that Luke does not separate social status from relation to God.
in v52
Who composed the Magnificat?
-
Luke, writing in a deliberately Septuagint style
Luke 1-2 as a whole imitates the Greek Old Testament, and the song's themes match Luke's own emphases throughout the Gospel.
-
An earlier Jewish or Jewish-Christian hymn that Luke adapted
Its Semitic poetic structure, Maccabean-style 'victory hymn' tone and loose fit to Mary's situation in some lines suggest an existing hymn. R. E. Brown suggested a circle of Jewish-Christian 'poor ones' (anawim).
in v53
What do the past tenses refer to: things God has done, or things he will do?
-
God's past deeds for Israel, recited as the pattern he is now repeating.
Hymns in the psalms often praise God for his past acts (Ps 107; 1 Sam 2). Verses 54–55 point back to the promises to Abraham.
-
A 'prophetic' past: future events stated as already done because they are certain.
Hebrew prophecy often describes the future in completed form. The Gospel itself shows the reversal still to come (Luke 6:20–25; 16:25).
-
What God has decisively begun in the conception of Jesus, from which the rest is sure to follow.
The song responds to the announcement and the conception (1:48–49, 'he has looked on… has done great things for me'). Several commentators (e.g. Brown, Green) see the past tenses as rooted in this event.
in v53
Are 'the hungry' and 'the rich' economic groups or religious types?
-
Mainly literal and economic.
Luke's consistent pattern: 'hungry now' and 'rich' in 6:20–25; 12:16–21; 16:19–31. 'Good things' means material goods in 12:18–19 and 16:25.
-
Mainly the pious poor ('the lowly' of the psalms) as against the proud and self-sufficient.
1:51–52 speaks of 'the proud' and 'the humble'. Psalms such as 34 and 107 tie poverty to dependence on God. Some propose the hymn came from circles of devout poor Jews (Brown's 'Anawim' hypothesis).
-
Both, held together.
In Israel's Scriptures the economically poor and those who depend on God usually overlap, and Luke keeps both the social and religious sides. Most recent commentators take this view.
in v53
Where did the hymn come from?
-
Mary's own song, as Luke presents it.
The narrative assigns it to Mary, and the language is drawn from Scripture a devout Jew would know.
-
An earlier Jewish or Jewish-Christian psalm that Luke adapted.
It is close in style to Jewish hymns of the time, and its fit into the narrative is loose (1:48 may be an addition).
-
Composed by Luke in the Septuagint's style.
Luke imitates biblical Greek elsewhere in chapters 1–2, and the song's themes are typical of Luke.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. κράτος, βραχίων, διασκορπίζω, ὑπερήφανος, διάνοια
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ὑπερήφανος
- Septuagint: Psalm 88:11; 117:15–16; Proverbs 3:34; 1 Samuel 2:1–10; Numbers 10:35
- Psalms of Solomon 2; 17
- Sirach 10:7–18
- Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah (on the Magnificat's sources and aorists)
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I–IX (Anchor Bible)
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the New Testament (dative of respect)
- Tyndale New Testament (1526) and KJV (1611) for "imagination"; Vulgate Luke 1:51
- BDAG s.v. δυνάστης, καθαιρέω, ταπεινός, ὑψόω, θρόνος
- W. Grundmann, TDNT s.v. ταπεινός
- Septuagint: 1 Samuel 2:7-8; Job 5:11; 12:19; Sirach 10:14; Psalm 146(147):6; Ezekiel 21:26
- Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I-IX (Anchor Bible)
- François Bovon, Luke 1 (Hermeneia)
- Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
- Vulgate, Luke 1:52
- BDAG s.v. πεινάω, ἐμπίμπλημι, ἀγαθός, πλουτέω, ἐξαποστέλλω, κενός
- Septuagint: Psalm 106:9 (MT 107:9); Psalm 33:11 (MT 34:10); 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 2:5–8; Genesis 31:42; Deuteronomy 15:13; Job 22:9
- 1 Enoch 94–104 (woes against the rich)
- Vulgate, Luke 1:53
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).