Mark Chapter 12 Read as one passage
Mark 12:4–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4Then he sent them another servant, and they struck him over the head and treated him shamefully. 5He sent still another, and this one they killed. He sent many others; some they beat and others they killed.
What the first hearers heard
To the temple leadership listening in Jerusalem, and to Mark's readers after them, this verse compressed a familiar national story into one line. Israel's own scriptures confessed that God had sent prophet after prophet and that the people, often led by their rulers, had abused and killed them (Neh 9:26; 2 Chr 36:15–16). By telling it as tenants mistreating an owner's agents, Jesus made the hearers judge the tenants' conduct first, as outrageous theft and violence against a rightful owner, before seeing that the story described their own role as Israel's leaders. Grief at the killing of the prophets was well established, and building monuments to murdered prophets was a known practice (compare Matt 23:29–31). So the claim that the current leaders stood in the line of the prophet-killers was a heavy accusation.
The verse also stresses the owner's patience. A real landlord would have sent armed men long before the 'many others'. The excess points to God's persistence in seeking the fruit owed to him. It also builds tension: if 'many' messengers have been killed, what will happen to the son (v. 6)? Mark's readers knew the answer from Jesus' passion predictions, which use the same verb, 'kill'.
From the study of Mark 12:5.
Verse by verse
-
4Then he sent them another servant, and they struck him over the head and treated him shamefully.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
5He sent still another, and this one they killed. He sent many others; some they beat and others they killed.
Full study →The vineyard owner, already refused twice (one slave beaten and sent away empty-handed, a second struck on the head and humiliated), commissions yet another of his own slaves as his agent to collect his share of the harvest. That one too is met by the tenants, and this time they kill him. The story then stops counting. The owner goes on sending many others, a long line of agents each carrying his rightful claim, and the tenants keep up their pattern: some they keep beating, others they keep killing. The Greek here leaves its sentence unfinished, and the verbs switch from single events to ongoing action, so the effect is a weary summary of a whole history of rejection and not one more incident. Anyone who knew Israel's scriptures would hear the old refrain behind it: "I sent you all my servants the prophets, sending them again and again, but you did not listen… you killed your prophets." The verse holds two things together: the tenants' violence, getting worse and settling into habit, and the owner's astonishing, almost unreasonable patience, which keeps on sending. Both prepare for the final step in the next verse, when he sends his one beloved son.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v5
Continues the storytelling chain: 'and… and… and'. Mark strings the sendings together so they feel like one long, wearying pattern.
-
ἄλλον
allon · G0243
another · v5
'Another' slave of the owner, the third one sent. Placed first in the Greek for emphasis: *another* he sent, even after the first two were abused.
-
ἀπέστειλεν
apesteilen · G0649
-
ἀπέκτειναν
apekteinan · G0615
-
πολλοὺς
pollous · G4183
many · v5
'Many': the story stops counting. After three single sendings, a long series is packed into one word. That points past a single harvest season to a long history.
-
οὓς
hous · G3739
whom / some · v5
A relative pronoun used in a 'some… others' pair (hous men… hous de), a common Greek way of splitting a group.
-
μὲν
men · G3303
on the one hand · v5
Sets up the contrast that δέ completes: 'some, on the one hand… others, on the other'. It does not mean 'indeed' in a strong sense here.
-
δέροντες
derontes · G1194
beating, thrashing · v5
'Beating' them, the same verb used of the first slave in v. 3. The present-tense participle pictures it as a repeated, ongoing practice rather than one incident.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v5
Completes the μέν contrast: 'and others…'.
The world behind it
Tenant farming and absentee owners. In first-century Galilee and Judea much land belonged to wealthy owners who lived elsewhere and leased estates to tenant farmers. Rent was paid in kind, as a share of the crop. A new vineyard could not be harvested for its first several years (compare Lev 19:23–25), so the owner's first collection came after a long wait. Greek papyri from Egypt, including the 3rd-century BC Zenon archive, which concerns an estate with vineyards in Galilee, record real disputes in which tenants refused rent and owners' agents were driven off or assaulted. The scenario was believable to the audience, even if the owner's endless patience is not.
Agents carry the owner's authority. A slave sent to collect rent was not a mere errand-runner. He stood in for his master, and an insult to him was an insult to the master (later rabbinic law: "a man's agent is like himself," Mishnah Berakot 5:5).
The vineyard is Israel. Mark 12:1 echoes Isaiah 5:1–7, where God's vineyard is "the house of Israel" and its failure to yield fruit brings judgment. Jesus tells the parable in the temple courts to the chief priests, scribes and elders who had just challenged his authority (11:27–33). Mark 12:12 says they understood it was aimed at them. In that setting the owner's slaves would be heard as the prophets. Scripture repeatedly calls them God's "servants" or "slaves" (douloi) whom he "sent", and it remembers them being rejected and killed: Zechariah son of Jehoiada stoned in the temple court (2 Chr 24:20–22), Uriah killed by Jehoiakim (Jer 26:20–23), and the summaries in 1 Kgs 19:10, Neh 9:26 and 2 Chr 36:15–16. Jewish writings of the period developed this into stories of individual prophets' martyrdoms (for example the Lives of the Prophets and the Martyrdom of Isaiah). In the episode just before, Jesus had pointed to John the Baptist, recently executed, as a messenger these same leaders refused to accept (11:30–32).
From the study of Mark 12:5.
Where scholars differ
in v5
Is the escalation to killing and 'many others' part of Jesus' original parable, or a later expansion that makes it point more clearly to Israel's history?
-
Later expansion. The simpler original had a few slaves who were beaten, not killed, and Mark's version adds allegorical detail pointing to the prophets.
Gospel of Thomas 65 (two slaves, beaten only) and Luke 20:10–12 (three slaves, none killed) are simpler. 'Many others' strains the realism of a story about one vineyard. Scholars such as C. H. Dodd and J. Jeremias argued along these lines, and J. D. Crossan argued that Thomas preserves an earlier form.
-
Original or early. The prophetic echoes were part of the parable from the start, because it was built on Isaiah 5 and told to temple leaders.
The opening line quotes Isaiah 5, so a reference to Israel's history is built in from the beginning. 'Sending servants' and 'killing prophets' was standard Jewish language (Jer 7:25; Neh 9:26). Thomas regularly trims allegorical features and may depend on the Synoptic tradition. Scholars such as K. Snodgrass and C. A. Evans take this view.
in v5
Should each slave be matched to a specific prophet?
-
Yes, in broad strokes. The slaves represent the prophets, and some early interpreters matched individual treatments to particular prophets.
Matthew's version adds 'stoned' (Matt 21:35), which recalls Zechariah (2 Chr 24:21). Jewish martyr traditions assigned specific deaths to specific prophets.
-
No. The slaves stand for the prophets as a group, and the details mainly create dramatic escalation.
Mark's 'many others' deliberately stops counting, which works against one-to-one matching. Mark gives no names, and the three gospel accounts differ in their details.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἀποστέλλω, ἀποκτείνω, δέρω, μέν
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 12:5
- Septuagint: Jer 7:25; 25:4; 2 Chr 24:19–22; 36:15–16; Neh 9:26; 1 Kgs 19:10
- Mishnah Berakot 5:5 (agency principle)
- J. S. Kloppenborg, The Tenants in the Vineyard (2006): papyri on tenancy disputes, including the Zenon archive
- K. R. Snodgrass, Stories with Intent (2008), on the Wicked Tenants
- C. A. Evans, Mark 8:27–16:20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Gospel of Thomas, saying 65
- Vulgate, Mark 12:5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.