Matthew Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Matthew 9:11–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11When the Pharisees saw this, they asked His disciples, “Why does your Teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?” 12On hearing this, Jesus said, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. 13But go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”

What the first hearers heard

For Matthew's first readers, probably Jewish followers of Jesus in the later first century who were arguing with synagogue leaders heirs to the Pharisees, this scene was close to home. Their own communities mixed the respectable and the disreputable, Jews and eventually Gentiles. They faced the same question the Pharisees ask here: how can a community that claims to be faithful to Israel's God share its table with people like that?

The story answers through the shape of the scene:

  • The objection is serious. It comes from respected Law experts and rests on real Scripture about avoiding the company of the wicked. Matthew does not present it as foolish.
  • It is aimed at the disciples. The readers are the disciples now. They too must answer for their Teacher's table.
  • Jesus' answer (9:12-13) redefines the issue. Eating with sinners is a doctor visiting the sick, not approving of sickness. Quoting Hosea 6:6, Jesus says that God's own priority is mercy. The faithful reading of the Law is the one that goes out to the lost.

For Matthew's community, this justified their open table and their mission to the outcast (compare 11:19, 21:31-32). It also kept the call to repentance in view: Jesus calls sinners (9:13). He does not simply leave them where they are.

From the study of Matthew 9:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11When the Pharisees saw this, they asked His disciples, “Why does your Teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?”

    The Pharisees, respected experts in living by the Law of Moses, saw the banquet at Matthew's house. Being seen at someone's table was a public act, so this was more than gossip. They did not go to Jesus. They went to his pupils, and they kept pressing them: "On what grounds, of all people, does your teacher eat with the toll-men and the sinners?"

    The Greek puts "with the tax collectors and sinners" first, before the verb, so the weight falls on the company: these people? The single "the" covering both groups treats them as one disreputable crowd. On one side were the local toll-collectors, Matthew's former colleagues, known as extortioners, tied to the ruling powers and thought to make a house unclean by entering it. On the other were people publicly known to live outside God's law. "Sinners" here is a social label for the notoriously ungodly. It does not mean "everyone who has ever sinned."

    To eat with someone, reclining at a festive meal, was to accept them as your circle. Scripture's wisdom said the righteous should not sit with the wicked (Psalm 1:1). So the question is an accusation: a real teacher of Israel should model the Law's boundaries at his table. And calling him "your teacher" turns the challenge back on the disciples. If he does this, what is he teaching you, and why are you following him? Jesus overhears and answers in the next verses: the sick, not the healthy, need a doctor, and God wants mercy, not sacrifice (Hosea 6:6).

    Full study →
  2. 12On hearing this, Jesus said, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick.

    The Pharisees had asked Jesus' disciples why their teacher ate with tax collectors and sinners. Jesus answers for himself, with a saying everyone already knew: "It isn't the strong, the people whose health is intact, who need a physician. It's the people who are in a bad way."

    The first group is literally "the strong". The second is "those having it badly", the everyday Greek phrase for being ill. Matthew uses the same phrase throughout these chapters for the sick crowds Jesus has been healing. The logic is simple: a doctor goes where the illness is. Nobody faults a doctor for walking into a sickroom, and nobody thinks he has caught the fever because he sits by the bed.

    Hearers who knew their Scriptures would have caught more. Israel's God had called himself "the LORD who heals you". The prophets pictured the people's unfaithfulness as wounds and sickness waiting for God to heal, and they condemned the shepherds who "did not tend the sick". Jesus takes that healer's role. His meal in Matthew's house is a physician's house call on people who are morally and socially "unwell", not approval of their dishonesty.

    The saying does not grade the critics. It neither certifies them as healthy nor calls them sick. It simply explains why the doctor is at this table. The next verse makes the point explicit, through Hosea: God wants mercy, and Jesus came to call sinners.

    Full study →
  3. 13But go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”

    Jesus is answering the Pharisees, who have just asked his disciples why their teacher eats with toll collectors and "sinners" (v.11). He has already said that healthy people don't need a doctor, sick people do (v.12). Now he turns their own expertise back on them, roughly: "Off you go and study, you teachers, and work out what this verse actually means: 'What I want, says God, is loyal, active compassion, not offerings at the altar,' or more exactly, compassion before and above offerings. Because I did not come to invite the people in good standing with God to my table. I came to invite the people everyone writes off as sinners."

    The quotation is Hosea 6:6. There, God complains that his people bring sacrifices while their loyalty to him evaporates "like the morning dew." The word for "mercy" carries the Hebrew sense of ḥesed: faithful, relationship-keeping kindness that acts, not just a decision not to punish. The "not" does not abolish sacrifice. In Hebrew style it ranks priorities, and Hosea's next line says "knowledge of God more than burnt offerings." Jesus applies this to the Pharisees' worry about ritual purity at meals: purity rules are real, but when they stand between God's people and the outsiders who need them, compassion wins. "Call" here is the everyday word for inviting guests to dinner, so the meal itself is the picture. Jesus's table shows who God is inviting.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    sinners

    hamartōloi

    What we hear
    Everyone, since all people sin. The Pharisees seem to object to Jesus eating with ordinary, imperfect people.
    What they heard
    A recognisable class of people known publicly as living outside God's law: the 'wicked' of the Psalms, notorious wrongdoers, people in dishonourable trades. It was a label others put on them.
  • in v11

    publicans (KJV)

    telōnai

    What we hear
    Pub or inn keepers.
    What they heard
    Local toll and tax collectors, despised as extortioners and collaborators.
  • in v11

    Master (KJV)

    didaskalos

    What we hear
    Lord, owner, one in command.
    What they heard
    Teacher, the Greek equivalent of 'rabbi', a man with pupils who imitate him.
  • in v11

    Pharisees

    Pharisaioi

    What we hear
    Hypocrites; self-righteous legalists.
    What they heard
    Members of a respected, popular movement of experts in the Law, known for exact observance of tithing, purity and Sabbath.
  • in v12

    whole (KJV, YLT: "They that be whole")

    ischyontes

    What we hear
    Complete, integrated, emotionally or spiritually 'whole'
    What they heard
    Strong, in possession of one's physical strength, simply 'healthy'
  • in v13

    I will have mercy (KJV)

    eleos thelō

    What we hear
    God promising that he will be merciful ("I will have mercy on you").
    What they heard
    "Mercy is what I want." God says what he desires *from his people*. In 1611 English, "will" here meant "want, wish."
  • in v13

    mercy

    eleos (for Hebrew ḥesed)

    What we hear
    Leniency: holding back a punishment that is deserved.
    What they heard
    Loyal, active compassion and kindness within a relationship, shown in deeds, here in welcoming outsiders to the table.
  • in v13

    not sacrifice

    kai ou thysian (Hebrew wəlōʾ zāvaḥ)

    What we hear
    God rejects sacrifice or ritual altogether.
    What they heard
    Mercy *rather than / more than* sacrifice, a Hebrew way of ranking priorities. Hosea's parallel line says "more than burnt offerings."
  • in v13

    to call

    kalesai

    What we hear
    A summons to a vocation or to conversion ("God's calling," an "altar call").
    What they heard
    To invite, in particular to invite guests to a meal, as fits this dinner scene.
  • in v13

    sinners

    hamartōlous

    What we hear
    Everyone in general ("we're all sinners").
    What they heard
    A recognised social group: people seen as openly living outside the Law, such as toll collectors.
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v11, v13

    Links this reaction directly to the meal just described in v.10. Matthew's narrative moves quickly from scene to challenge.

  2. ἰδόντες

    idontes · G1492

    having seen · v11

    The Pharisees saw the meal with their own eyes. Meals in a house with a courtyard could be watched by onlookers, and being seen at table with someone was a public statement. That is why seeing it mattered.

  3. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v11, v12

    Marks the Pharisees as a known group that the readers already recognise.

  4. Φαρισαῖοι

    Pharisaioi · G5330

    Pharisees · v11

    Members of a respected lay movement known for exact interpretation of the Law of Moses and for careful practice of tithing, purity and Sabbath. Their question comes from people the public saw as authorities on how a godly Israelite should live.

  5. ἔλεγον

    elegon · G3004

    were saying · v11

    The imperfect tense can picture speech that went on or was repeated ('they kept saying', 'they began saying'), though with verbs of speaking it often means simply 'they said'. Either way, it reads as pointed talk rather than a one-off polite question.

  6. μαθηταῖς

    mathētais · G3101

    disciples, pupils · v11

    Jesus' students and followers. The challenge goes to the pupils rather than the teacher himself, which puts them on the spot and questions the teacher's reputation through his school.

  7. αὐτοῦ·

    autou · G846

    his · v11, v12

    Jesus' disciples. The group is identified by whose they are.

  8. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    because of, on account of · v11

    With τί, forms the idiom 'on account of what?' = 'why?'

  9. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? · v11, v13

    'Why?' In this setting it is less a request for information than a challenge: 'What justification can there be for this?'

  10. μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    with · v11

    Company or fellowship: 'in company with'. The phrase it begins is placed before the verb in Greek, so the stress falls on whom he eats with.

  11. τελωνῶν

    telōnōn · G5057

    toll/tax collector · v11

    Local agents who collected tolls and duties, here in Herod Antipas' territory, such as Matthew at his booth in Capernaum (9:9). They were widely seen as extortioners and as collaborators with ruling powers, and were classed with robbers.

  12. ἁμαρτωλῶν

    hamartōlōn · G268

    sinners · v11, v13

    Not 'people who sometimes sin' (everyone). It is a label for people publicly known to live outside the Law of Moses: notorious wrongdoers and people in dishonourable trades. It is how outsiders described them, not how they described themselves.

  13. ἐσθίει

    esthiei · G2068

    eats · v11

    Present tense. It can mean 'is eating' (this meal) or 'eats' (his habit). The objection is to sharing a table, which in that world meant accepting and identifying with one's table-companions.

  14. διδάσκαλος

    didaskalos · G1320

    teacher · v11

    The Greek equivalent of 'rabbi'. A teacher's conduct was the model his pupils copied, so the question is aimed at both: if your teacher does this, what is he teaching you?

  15. ὑμῶν;

    hymōn · G4771

    your (plural) · v11

    'Your teacher', not 'our teacher' or 'the teacher'. It keeps a distance and makes the disciples answer for the one they follow.

  16. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and · v12, v13

    A light connective that moves the scene to Jesus' reply. 'But' or 'and' both work; no strong contrast is meant.

  17. Ἰησοῦς

    Iēsous · G2424

    Jesus · v12

    Found only in later manuscripts (the Byzantine tradition and the Textus Receptus). It names who 'he' is, which the context already makes plain.

  18. ἀκούσας

    akousas · G0191

    to hear · v12

    'Having heard'. The Pharisees put their question to the disciples, not to Jesus (v. 11). He overhears, or the question reaches him, and he answers it himself.

  19. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v12

    A simple past 'he said'. It introduces a short, saying-like answer.

  20. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v12, v13

    Placed first for emphasis: 'Not', meaning it is not the strong who need a physician. The sentence is built as a 'not this, but that' contrast.

  21. χρείαν

    chreian · G5532

    need · v12

    'Need', as in a real lack that something must fill. With ἔχω and a genitive it is the ordinary idiom 'to have need of'.

  22. ἔχουσιν

    echousin · G2192

    have · v12

    Present tense, stating a general truth: this is how it always is with doctors and patients.

  23. ἰσχύοντες

    ischyontes · G2480

    be strong; be well · v12

    Literally 'those who are strong', meaning people with their bodily strength intact and so healthy. Mark has the same word. Luke uses the more clinical 'those who are sound'.

  24. ἰατροῦ

    iatrou · G2395

    physician · v12

    'Of a physician', a healer who tends the sick. Jesus casts himself in this role: his eating with sinners is a doctor making a house call.

  25. ἀλλ᾽

    all' · G0235

    but (rather) · v12, v13

    The strong 'but rather' that completes the 'not… but…' frame and shifts the weight to the second group.

  26. κακῶς

    kakōs · G2560

    badly · v12

    'Badly'. Paired with ἔχω it forms a fixed phrase for being ill. The phrase carries no moral sense of 'evil' by itself.

  27. πορευθέντες

    poreuthentes · G4198

    go, travel · v13

    "Having gone." The participle goes with the command that follows, so it means "go and…". There is an edge to it: go away and study, then come back with an answer.

  28. μάθετε

    mathete · G3129

    learn · v13

    A command, "learn!" It comes from the same root as mathētēs, "disciple, learner." The Pharisees, who were respected teachers of the Law, are sent back to be learners of a text they already knew.

  29. ἐστιν·

    estin · G1510

    is · v13

    Literally "what it is," meaning "what it means." Jesus is asking for the sense of the text, not for its words, which they knew by heart.

  30. Ἔλεος

    eleos · G1656

    mercy, compassion · v13

    Placed first for emphasis. It is the Septuagint's (the Greek Old Testament's) usual word for Hebrew ḥesed, loyal and active kindness. Here it means compassion acted out toward people in need, which in this scene means eating with outsiders.

  31. θέλω

    thelō · G2309

    want, desire · v13

    "I want, I take pleasure in." The speaker is God, through Hosea. The word renders Hebrew ḥāphēṣ, "delight in." It says what God wants from people. It is not a statement that God will show mercy.

  32. θυσίαν·

    thysian · G2378

    sacrifice, offering · v13

    An animal or other offering at the altar. It stands for the whole system of worship and ritual purity. Jesus applies it to the Pharisees' concern about ritual purity at the table.

  33. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v13

    "For." It gives the reason. Jesus's own mission puts Hosea's priority into practice.

  34. ἦλθον

    ēlthon · G2064

    come · v13

    "I came." This is one of Jesus's "I came to…" sayings, which sum up the purpose of his whole mission (compare 5:17; 10:34).

  35. καλέσαι

    kalesai · G2564

    call, invite · v13

    "To call" or "to invite." It is the ordinary word for inviting guests to a meal or banquet (22:3–9). Here the setting is a dinner, so "invite" is very much in view.

  36. δικαίους

    dikaious · G1342

    righteous, just · v13

    "Righteous ones": people in good standing under the covenant who keep the Law. There is no article. It describes a type of person and is not a name for a group.

The world behind it

The place and the people. The scene follows directly from Matthew's call at his toll booth in Capernaum (9:9). Capernaum sat on a trade route near the border between Herod Antipas' Galilee and his brother Philip's territory, a natural spot for collecting tolls on goods. The guests in v.10 are Matthew's own circle.

Tax collectors. In Galilee these were not Roman senators' agents but local men who contracted to collect tolls and duties for the Herodian administration and lived off what they could collect above the contract. Jewish sources treat them as robbers. The Mishnah allows a person to lie to them (m. Nedarim 3:4) and says a house they enter becomes unclean (m. Tohorot 7:6). Greek writers class them with the lowest trades.

Meals as statements. A meal where guests reclined on couches (v.10) was a banquet, not a snack. Across the ancient Mediterranean, whom you ate with showed whom you accepted, and it affected your own honour. Jewish wisdom tradition told the righteous to choose their table-companions carefully (Psalm 1:1; Proverbs 1:10-15; Sirach 9:16; 11:29-34). Pharisaic piety also cared about whether food had been tithed and handled in purity, and so about whom one ate with (compare m. Demai 2:2-3, a later text that reflects older concerns).

Teacher and pupils. A Jewish teacher's life was itself the lesson; disciples learned by imitating him. Challenging the disciples about their teacher's conduct was an honour challenge, a public test of his standing that needed an answer. Jesus supplies it in 9:12-13.

From the study of Matthew 9:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Who were the 'sinners' (hamartōloi)?

  • The common people who did not keep Pharisaic purity and tithing rules (the 'am ha-arets, 'people of the land'), together with people in despised trades.

    Joachim Jeremias, drawing on rabbinic lists of suspect occupations and on John 7:49 ('this crowd that does not know the law is accursed'). Widely popularised in 20th-century preaching.

  • The 'wicked': deliberate, ongoing law-breakers who lived outside the covenant and did not repent through the normal means of restitution and sacrifice. Not ordinary pious-but-lax people.

    E. P. Sanders (Jesus and Judaism), arguing from the Septuagint use of hamartōlos for Hebrew rasha' and from the pairing with tax collectors and prostitutes (Matt 21:31-32). He argues the scandal was that Jesus accepted them without first requiring the usual repentance and restitution.

  • A label used between factions: each group called those who failed its own standard 'sinners', so to Pharisees it could include Jews who were otherwise observant but did not follow their interpretations.

    J. D. G. Dunn, citing the Psalms of Solomon, 1 Enoch and Qumran texts, where rival Jewish groups label each other 'sinners' or 'the wicked'.

in v11

What exactly was the Pharisees' objection?

  • Ritual purity and tithing: sharing food with such people risked impurity and eating untithed produce, which the Pharisees, eating ordinary meals in near-priestly purity, avoided.

    Jacob Neusner's reconstruction of Pharisees as a table-fellowship group, supported by m. Demai 2:2-3 and m. Tohorot 7:6 (a tax collector entering a house makes it unclean).

  • Moral association: by welcoming notorious wrongdoers to his table, a teacher appeared to approve of their way of life and to undercut repentance.

    Psalm 1:1, Proverbs 1:10-15 and Sirach 11:29-34 warn against such company. Sanders argues purity was not the main issue, since impurity was common, temporary and not sinful. Jesus' reply about 'the sick' answers a moral concern rather than a ritual one.

in v12

Does Jesus grant that the Pharisees really are 'healthy', or is he being ironic?

  • Ironic: the critics only think they are healthy. In fact they need the physician too.

    Matthew's later harsh words for the Pharisees (ch. 23). The command 'go and learn' (v. 13) suggests they do not yet understand Scripture. Elsewhere Jesus treats self-assessed righteousness as blindness (e.g. Luke 18:9–14).

  • Not ironic, and not meant to be pushed that far: it is a proverb about what a healer is for, and it says nothing about the Pharisees' actual condition.

    Proverbs make one point. The Greek parallels (Antisthenes and Diogenes in Diogenes Laertius 6.6; Plutarch, Moralia 230F) use the image only to justify spending time with low company. Commentators such as France and Davies & Allison caution against allegorizing 'the healthy'.

  • Relative and real: the Pharisees really are more observant of the law ('righteous' in that sense), but that is not where Jesus' mission is aimed.

    In v. 13 'righteous' and 'sinners' are ordinary social and religious categories of the time. Jesus says elsewhere that the scribes and Pharisees have a real, if not sufficient, righteousness (5:20).

in v13

Is "the righteous" ironic ("those who *think* they are righteous") or meant straightforwardly?

  • Ironic or self-defined: Jesus means people who consider themselves healthy and so refuse the doctor.

    Matthew elsewhere criticises outward righteousness (5:20; 23:28). In the parallel, Luke 18:9 speaks of those who "trusted in themselves that they were righteous."

  • Straightforward, a proverb-like contrast: Jesus's mission aims at the needy. It does not mean faithful people are rejected or that they are fakes.

    It parallels the doctor saying in v.12, where the "healthy" really are healthy. Matthew uses dikaios positively (1:19; 13:43; 25:37), and the "not X but Y" saying is about where his effort goes. Many commentators, e.g. Davies & Allison and France, prefer this or a mild version of the ironic reading.

in v13

Who were "the sinners"?

  • The ordinary, non-observant population ("people of the land," *ʿam ha-ʾarets*) and people in despised trades, looked down on by the pious.

    Joachim Jeremias and older scholarship, drawing on rabbinic lists of suspect trades and on Pharisaic separation from the common people.

  • The openly wicked, people who had in effect stepped outside the covenant (*reshaʿim*). They were not the common people as a whole.

    E. P. Sanders, *Jesus and Judaism* (1985). He points to how "sinners" is used in the Psalms of Solomon and the Septuagint, and to the pairing with toll collectors. On this view the scandal was that Jesus welcomed them, apparently without first requiring the usual signs of repentance such as restitution and sacrifice.

in v13

Does "not sacrifice" reject the worship system or rank priorities within it?

  • It ranks priorities: compassion comes before ritual, and ritual is not abolished.

    Hosea's parallel line says "more than burnt offerings." The Septuagint renders it "rather than." Jesus assumes offerings in Matthew 5:23–24 and 8:4, and says in 23:23 "these you ought to have done without neglecting the others." Most commentators hold this view.

  • It is a sharper break: in Jesus's ministry God's mercy replaces the purity and sacrifice system as the way to belong to God.

    Matthew 12:6–7 ("something greater than the temple is here") and the later Christian view that Jesus's death fulfils sacrifice. Critics answer that this is a later theological development and not what the Hosea quotation itself says.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἁμαρτωλός
  • BDAG s.v. τελώνης
  • BDAG s.v. Φαρισαῖος
  • BDAG s.v. διδάσκαλος
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.297-298; 17.41-42; 18.12-15; Jewish War 2.162-166
  • Mishnah Nedarim 3:4; Tohorot 7:6; Bava Qamma 10:1-2; Demai 2:2-3
  • Septuagint Psalm 1:1, 5; 1 Maccabees 1:34; 2:44; Sirach 9:16; 11:29-34; Psalms of Solomon
  • E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism (1985), ch. 6
  • J. Jeremias, New Testament Theology (1971)
  • J. D. G. Dunn, 'Pharisees, Sinners, and Jesus' in Jesus, Paul and the Law (1990)
  • J. R. Donahue, 'Tax Collectors and Sinners', CBQ 33 (1971)
  • J. Neusner, From Politics to Piety (1973)
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 9:9-13
  • NA28 apparatus on Matt 9:11
  • BDAG s.v. ἰσχύω, ἰατρός, κακῶς, χρεία
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Matt 9:12)
  • Septuagint, Ezekiel 34:4; Hosea 6:1–6
  • Sirach 38:1–15
  • Mishnah Qiddushin 4:14
  • Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers 6.6
  • Plutarch, Moralia (Apophthegmata Laconica) 230F
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 9:9–13
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 9:12
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia), on 9:9–13
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 9:10–13
  • BDAG s.v. ἔλεος, θυσία, καλέω, δίκαιος, ἁμαρτωλός, μανθάνω
  • HALOT s.v. חֶסֶד, חָפֵץ
  • Septuagint, Hosea 6:6 (Rahlfs)
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 9:13
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
  • E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism (1985), ch. 6 on 'sinners'
  • J. Jeremias, New Testament Theology, on 'sinners' and table fellowship
  • Avot de Rabbi Natan A 4 (Yohanan ben Zakkai on Hosea 6:6)
  • K. D. Sakenfeld, The Meaning of Hesed in the Hebrew Bible
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 9:9–13

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).