1 Corinthians Chapter 10 Read as one passage
1 Corinthians 10:25–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
25Eat anything sold in the meat market without raising questions of conscience, 26for, “The earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof.” 27If an unbeliever invites you to a meal and you want to go, eat anything set before you without raising questions of conscience. 28But if someone tells you, “This food was offered to idols,” then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who told you and for the sake of conscience— 29the other one’s conscience, I mean, not your own. For why should my freedom be determined by someone else’s conscience?
What the first hearers heard
To Corinthian believers, most of them former pagans, along with some Jews and God-fearers, this verse gave a plain, workable rule for daily life:
- You may shop like everyone else. Christians did not need a separate food supply or to quiz every butcher. For poorer members, who rarely ate meat and may have met it mostly at religious festivals or in cheap cuts from the market, this was a real practical relief.
- Your freedom has a basis, and it is not your cleverness. The "strong" in Corinth claimed that "an idol is nothing" (8:4). Paul does not base the freedom on their knowledge but on God's ownership of creation (v. 26, Psalm 24:1). The meat belongs to the Lord, not to the idol it passed by.
- Freedom has limits. The same paragraph opens with "No one should seek his own good, but the good of others" (v. 24). Two verses later Paul says that if someone points out "this is sacrificial meat", you should not eat it, for that person's sake (vv. 28–29). Temple feasting is ruled out entirely (10:21).
For Jewish believers, and for anyone who knew synagogue practice, the instruction sharply relaxed normal Jewish food boundaries. It reflects Paul's conviction that Jews and Gentiles in Christ share one table, while he still refuses any part in idol worship itself.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 10:25.
Verse by verse
-
25Eat anything sold in the meat market without raising questions of conscience,
Full study →"Whatever is on sale in the city food market, eat it, all of it, and keep doing so. Don't cross-examine the seller about where it came from as though your conscience depended on the answer. It doesn't, because (as the next verse says) the earth and everything that fills it belongs to the Lord."
Several features of the Greek carry the meaning:
- "Everything" comes first and "nothing" mirrors it. Eat everything, ask nothing. The balance is deliberate and sweeping.
- "Market" is the Roman macellum. This was the public provisions hall of Roman Corinth, where butchers and fishmongers had their stalls. Some of the meat had passed through a pagan altar and some had not, and nobody at the counter could usually tell.
- "Being sold" puts the meat in the category of ordinary goods. Whatever had happened to it earlier, here it is simply merchandise.
- "Asking no questions" uses a word for interrogation. It is the verb for examining witnesses or holding a hearing. Paul tells the Corinthians not to put their dinner on trial.
- "Because of conscience" names the motive a scrupulous buyer would have for asking. Paul removes that motive: conscience has nothing to rule on until someone gives it a reason (vv. 28–29).
This is permission, not indifference to idolatry. Paul has just forbidden sharing "the table of demons" at temple meals (10:14–22). In the market, though, food is just food.
-
26for, “The earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof.”
Full study →“Because it is the Lord who owns the earth, and everything that fills it.”
Paul quotes the opening line of Psalm 24 word for word from the Greek Old Testament. He adds only the small word “for,” which makes the psalm the reason behind his instruction in the verse before: buy whatever is sold in the meat market and eat it without investigating where it came from. The Greek puts “the Lord’s” first for emphasis. Ownership is the point. The earth belongs to the Lord, and so does everything on it: animals, grain, wine, and the meat hanging in a Corinthian butcher’s stall, even if part of that animal was burned on a pagan altar the day before. The idols never owned it, because they are “nothing” (8:4). A sacrifice to them cannot transfer ownership of what the true Lord made and still owns.
For a Jewish hearer, the line probably also echoed the table: Jewish tradition used this same verse as the reason for blessing God before eating. Food is received from its owner with thanks. It is not taken as if it were one’s own (compare 10:30, “if I partake with thankfulness…”).
-
27If an unbeliever invites you to a meal and you want to go, eat anything set before you without raising questions of conscience.
Full study →Suppose someone outside the faith, a pagan neighbour, patron, business partner or relative, invites you to dinner at his home, and you decide you would like to go. Then go ahead and eat whatever is put in front of you, dish after dish. Don't turn the meal into an investigation. Don't quiz your host or his slaves about where the meat came from or whether it went through a temple sacrifice first. Conscience gives you no reason to make inquiries, because, as Paul has just quoted from Psalm 24, "the earth is the Lord's, and everything in it" (v. 26). The food on the table belongs to God before it belongs to any idol.
The verse makes three points:
- Going is your choice. Paul neither requires nor forbids accepting the invitation.
- The eating is meant to be normal. "Eat" is an ongoing command, so the guest eats freely through the whole meal.
- No checking. "Asking nothing" rules out a careful habit of checking that some believers thought was the responsible thing to do.
The phrase "because of conscience" points ahead. The next verse explains that conscience becomes a factor only when someone openly declares, "This was offered in sacrifice." Even then, the conscience at stake is the other person's, not the guest's (vv. 28–29).
-
28But if someone tells you, “This food was offered to idols,” then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who told you and for the sake of conscience—
Full study →"But suppose that, while you are at the meal, someone says to you, 'This is a sacred offering — it was sacrificed at the temple.' Then stop and don't eat it. Don't refrain because the meat has become dangerous to you or because your own conscience should trouble you. Refrain for the sake of the person who pointed it out, and because of what that person's conscience will make of it."
The scene is a dinner in an unbeliever's home (v. 27), where Paul has just told the Christian to eat whatever is served and not ask questions. Now, in the middle of the meal, someone mentions where the meat came from, and he uses the polite pagan phrase ("sacred offering"), not the Jewish-Christian label "idol-meat." Once that has been said aloud, eating is no longer just eating. Everyone at the table now knows what the meat is, and a Christian who goes on eating seems to be saying that honouring the temple's god is compatible with following Jesus. Paul's "do not eat" is not about the food, which belongs to the Lord (v. 26). It is about the other person and how he understands what the Christian's loyalty to God means. Paul makes this explicit in the next words: "the other one's conscience, I mean, not your own."
-
29the other one’s conscience, I mean, not your own. For why should my freedom be determined by someone else’s conscience?
Full study →Paul has just said: if someone at a dinner tells you, "This is sacrificial meat," don't eat it, "for his sake and for conscience' sake" (v. 28). Now he heads off a misunderstanding. "By conscience I mean not your own, but the other person's." The believer's own moral sense is clear: the meat is God's good gift, since "the earth is the Lord's" (v. 26). What is at stake is the moral perception of the person who spoke up. That might be a pagan host or fellow guest who now expects to see whether this Christian will eat openly declared sacrificial food. Or it might be a fellow believer with more scruples.
Then comes a sharp question: "For to what end should my freedom be condemned by someone else's conscience?" Paul is not giving up his freedom. Another person's scruple does not make the act wrong, and his "freedom" is the real freedom of one who belongs to the Lord whose world it is. The question is about exposure. Why let a good thing, received with thanksgiving (v. 30), be judged, denounced and spoken of as evil? It is better to set the meal aside quietly. Interpreters differ on how this question connects to the argument (see debates). Some hear it as defending the freedom to eat in vv. 25–27, or as a protest Paul is answering. But the next lines settle where the passage is heading: "do all to the glory of God… not seeking my own advantage, but that of the many" (vv. 31–33). The verse holds two things together. In principle, my freedom is not governed by another person's conscience. In practice, I may choose not to use it, out of concern for that person and so that the good I enjoy is not called evil.
Where the English drifted
-
in v25
shambles (KJV)
makellon
- What we hear
- A mess or scene of chaos ("the room was a shambles").
- What they heard
- The city's food market, a hall of meat and fish stalls. In 1611 "shambles" meant exactly that: benches or stalls where meat was sold.
-
in v25, v29
conscience
syneidēsis
- What we hear
- A built-in moral compass, often taken as God's voice inside, that reliably tells you in advance what is right and wrong.
- What they heard
- Moral self-awareness: the inner sense that judges your own conduct by what you know and believe. In this chapter it can be "weak" (shaped by old habits with idols) and is set off by information, which is why Paul says not to go looking for any.
-
in v26
the fullness thereof / its fullness
to plērōma autēs
- What we hear
- An abstract sense of completeness or abundance, sometimes even a spiritual “fullness” or the earth’s “fulfilment.”
- What they heard
- The concrete contents of the earth: everything that fills it, the creatures and produce that people eat and use.
-
in v27
unbeliever / them that believe not
apistos
- What we hear
- Someone with no religion: a skeptic, atheist or secular person.
- What they heard
- Someone outside the Christian community. In Corinth that was usually an actively religious pagan whose household honoured the gods, which is why his meat might have been sacrificed.
-
in v27
for conscience' sake / questions of conscience
dia tēn syneidēsin
- What we hear
- Conscience as an inner moral voice, maybe God's voice, which either troubles you or doesn't. So the verse sounds like "don't let your conscience bother you".
- What they heard
- Conscience as moral self-awareness, which can be weak and easily wounded (8:7–12). Paul says there is no need to investigate the food on conscience grounds, and then specifies that the conscience to protect is someone else's (v. 29).
-
in v28
offered to idols / sacrificed to idols
hierothyton
- What we hear
- The same thing as Paul's other phrase "idol-meat," said in a Christian voice that disapproves of the food.
- What they heard
- A respectful pagan word, "sacred offering, temple-sacrificed." It is the speaker's own religious vocabulary, which shows that the voice is most likely an unbeliever's at an unbeliever's table.
-
in v28
for the sake of conscience / for conscience sake
dia tēn syneidēsin
- What we hear
- Abstain so that your own conscience stays clean, as if eating would make you guilty.
- What they heard
- Abstain because of the other person's moral understanding: what the informant will conclude if you eat. Paul states this outright in v. 29: "the other one's conscience, I mean, not your own."
-
in v29
freedom / liberty
eleutheria
- What we hear
- Personal autonomy: my right to do as I choose without others restricting me.
- What they heard
- The free status of one who belongs to Christ, here specifically freedom to eat any food as God's gift. Paul uses this freedom on behalf of others (9:19) rather than as a protected personal right.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v29
"Why should my freedom be judged?" is not a license verse
- What's often taught
- The second half of this verse is often quoted on its own to say that Christian liberty should never be restricted by other people's scruples: if my conscience is clear, no one else's conscience has a say.
- What the text supports
Part of this is right. Paul does deny that another person's conscience can turn a lawful act into sin. The freedom is real (v. 26).
But the question comes immediately after an instruction to give way: "do not eat it, for the sake of the one who told you" (v. 28). Paul then clarifies that the conscience in view is "not your own, but the other's." Krinetai ("is judged") is paired in v. 30 with "denounced" (blasphēmoumai), echoing Rom 14:16, "do not let your good be slandered." On the most natural reading, the question explains why to abstain: what is gained by letting a good freedom be condemned? Even interpreters who read 29b as defending freedom agree that Paul's conclusion follows straight away: "not seeking my own advantage, but that of the many" (10:33), and "be imitators of me" (11:1), the same Paul who, "though free from all," made himself a slave to all (9:19). The verse protects the believer's freedom in principle while calling for that freedom to be held back in practice for the other person's sake.
- Where the English feeds it
- Renderings like "be determined by" (ESV, BSB) and especially "limited by what someone else thinks" (NLT) turn a verb of condemnation into a verb of restriction. That makes the line sound like a protest against being restricted. "Judged" (KJV, NASB, WEB) keeps the link to "denounced" in v. 30.
ἐλευθερία eleutheria ἕτερος heteros κρίνω krinō συνείδησις syneidēsis
Every word
-
Πᾶν
Pan · G3956
all, every, everything · v25, v27
Placed first for emphasis: "everything", with no exceptions by category. Paul does not sort the market's goods into safe and unsafe; the whole stock is in view.
-
τὸ
to · G3588
the · v25, v26, v27, v28, v29
The article turns the following phrase into a noun: "the [stuff] being sold in the market". It binds "everything" to the participle "being sold".
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v25
Locates the goods: what is on sale in the market. The rule covers the public market, not a temple dining room (that case was dealt with in 10:14–22).
-
μακέλλῳ
makellō · G3111
provisions market, meat market · v25
A Latin loanword (macellum): the city's covered food market, where butchers and fishmongers sold meat, fish and other provisions. In Roman Corinth this was an actual building near the forum.
-
πωλούμενον
pōloumenon · G4453
to sell · v25
Present passive participle, "being sold": whatever is routinely offered for sale there. The focus is on its status as an ordinary commercial item, whatever its earlier history.
-
ἐσθίετε
esthiete · G2068
to eat · v25, v27, v28
Present imperative, plural: "eat [it]", addressed to the whole congregation as a standing practice. It works as a permission put in the form of a command: go ahead and eat, as a regular habit.
-
μηδὲν
mēden · G3367
nothing, not at all · v25, v27
"Nothing" or "not at all" as the object of the questioning: make no inquiry whatever. It mirrors the "everything" at the start of the verse: eat everything, ask nothing.
-
ἀνακρίνοντες
anakrinontes · G350
to examine, question, investigate · v25, v27
Present participle describing how they eat: "without conducting an inquiry". The word is used for questioning witnesses or examining a case; here it means not cross-examining the butcher about where the meat came from or whether it had been sacrificed.
-
διὰ
dia · G1223
because of, for the sake of · v25, v27, v28
With the accusative it gives the reason or motive: "on account of". It attaches to the questioning: the inquiry a scrupulous person would make on conscience grounds is the one Paul tells them to skip.
-
συνείδησιν
syneidēsin · G4893
conscience, moral awareness · v25, v27, v28, v29
A person's awareness of their own conduct, the inner judge that registers guilt or innocence. Paul's point: in the market, conscience is not the issue, so there is no need to dig up information that would give it something to judge.
-
κυρίου
kyriou · G2962
lord, master, owner · v26
This is a possessive form (“belonging to the Lord”), and Paul puts it first for emphasis, as the Hebrew psalm does: it is the Lord’s, and no one else’s. In the Greek Psalm, kyrios stands for God’s personal name, YHWH. In 1 Corinthians, Paul usually uses kyrios for Jesus.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for, because · v26, v29
Paul added this word to the quotation. It turns the psalm line into the reason for verse 25: eat what the market sells without asking questions, because all of it belongs to the Lord.
-
γῆ
gē · G1093
earth, land, ground · v26
The inhabited world and the ground that produces food. It translates Hebrew ʾereṣ, which in Psalm 24 means the whole world God founded “upon the seas.”
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v26, v27, v28
Adds a second thing the Lord owns: not just the earth itself but everything on it.
-
πλήρωμα
plērōma · G4138
that which fills, contents, fullness · v26
What fills the earth: its creatures, crops, animals and people. In this setting that includes the meat on a Corinthian market stall. The supplied gloss “fulfillment” does not fit here. The word means contents, not the completion of a promise.
-
αὐτῆς
autēs · G0846
of it (her) · v26
The pronoun is feminine because it points back to “the earth” (gē is feminine in Greek): the earth’s contents.
-
Εἴ
Ei · G1487
if · v27
Opens a condition that Paul treats as a real possibility, with the verb in the present tense. Such invitations obviously happened in Corinth, and Paul is giving the rule for when they do.
-
τις
tis · G5100
someone, anyone · v27, v28
Any host at all. It is defined only by the phrase that follows, "of the unbelievers".
-
καλεῖ
kalei · G2564
to call, invite · v27
Used here in its ordinary social sense of inviting someone to a meal, the standard verb on Greek dinner invitations. There is no religious meaning of "calling" here.
-
ὑμᾶς
humas · G4771
you (plural) · v27, v28
The Corinthian believers as a group. The guidance is for any member of the congregation who gets an invitation.
-
ἀπίστων
apistōn · G571
unbelieving · v27
Someone outside the Christian community. In Corinth that almost always meant a pagan who worshipped the city's gods, not a secular skeptic.
-
θέλετε
thelete · G2309
to want, wish · v27
"And you want to go." Paul leaves the decision to the believer. He neither orders acceptance nor forbids it.
-
πορεύεσθαι
poreuesthai · G4198
-
παρατιθέμενον
paratithemenon · G3908
to set before, serve · v27
The ordinary word for food being put on the table for guests. The present tense suggests each dish as it comes.
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if · v28
Introduces a condition that may or may not happen ("if it should happen that…"). Paul is not predicting it. He is giving a ruling for the case where it does happen.
-
δέ
de · G1161
but, and · v28, v29
Marks a contrast with verse 27. There Paul said to eat whatever is served without asking questions. Here comes the exception.
-
εἴπῃ·
eipē · G2036
say · v28
"Should say," a single remark made in passing at the meal. The hypothetical form fits the condition: if the remark is made.
-
τοῦτο
touto · G3778
this · v28
"This," pointing to the dish on the table. The speaker refers to the actual food in front of them.
-
ἱερόθυτόν
hierothyton · G9995
offered in sacrifice, sacred offering · v28
A respectful, ordinary Greek religious word: "sacrificed at a sanctuary," "a holy offering." It is not the scornful Jewish-Christian word "idol-sacrificed" that Paul uses elsewhere in chapters 8–10. The change of word suggests that the speaker is speaking as a pagan would.
-
ἐστιν,
estin · G1510
is · v28
"Is." A plain statement of fact about where the meat came from.
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v28
The negative used with commands. Together with the next word it forms a prohibition.
-
ἐκεῖνον
ekeinon · G1565
that one · v28
"That person," the one who spoke. The focus moves from the food to the person, and that move is the point of the verse.
-
μηνύσαντα
mēnysanta · G3377
disclose, inform, point out · v28
"The one who pointed it out" or "tipped you off." The word means passing on information that was not obvious. The speaker has made public something that would otherwise have gone unnoticed.
-
λέγω
legō · G3004
I say, I mean · v29
Present tense, first person. "I am saying" works here like "I mean": Paul is spelling out his own wording before anyone misreads it.
-
οὐχὶ
ouchi · G3780
not (emphatic) · v29
A stronger form of "not". It firmly rules out the reading that the eater's own conscience is troubled.
-
ἑαυτοῦ
heautou · G1438
of oneself, your own · v29
Reflexive "of yourself". The form is technically third person, but Koine Greek often uses it for "your own". It points to the believer who has been invited to the meal.
-
ἀλλὰ
alla · G235
but rather · v29
Strong contrast: not this person's conscience, *but rather* the other's.
-
ἑτέρου
heterou · G2087
-
ἱνατί
hinati · G2443
why? for what purpose? · v29
Short for "in order that what [may happen]?" It asks "why?" but often leans toward "to what end? what good is served?" It is the hinge of a disputed sentence.
-
ἐλευθερία
eleutheria · G1657
-
μου
mou · G1473
my · v29
Paul now speaks in the first person as a typical believer, or possibly voices the strong believer's protest. It is not purely autobiographical.
-
κρίνεται
krinetai · G2919
is judged, is condemned · v29
Present passive: "is being judged." In context this is adverse judgment, being condemned or called wrong. The next verse pairs it with "denounced, slandered" (*blasphēmoumai*).
-
ὑπὸ
hypo · G5259
by · v29
Marks who does the judging: another person's conscience.
-
ἄλλης
allēs · G243
another · v29
"Another" conscience. Mostly a stylistic variation on *heterou* above. It refers to the same outside person's moral judgment.
The world behind it
A Roman city with a Roman market. Julius Caesar refounded Corinth as a Roman colony in 44 BC. Its public inscriptions were in Latin, and Paul's Greek word for the market is a Latin loanword. A Latin inscription from Corinth mentions the city's macellum. Markets of this type (well preserved at Pompeii) were courtyard buildings lined with stalls, under the control of civic market officials.
Where market meat came from. In Greek and Roman religion, killing an animal for food was often a religious act. A portion was burned for the god, some went to the priests, worshippers ate some at the shrine, and surplus could be sold. Not all meat in a macellum came from a sacrifice, and scholars disagree about how much did. But some certainly did: Pliny the Younger (Letters 10.96) notes that sacrificial meat had been struggling to find buyers in Bithynia when Christianity spread. A shopper normally could not tell which was which.
The Jewish norm. Faithful Jews avoided Gentile food altogether (Dan 1:8; Tob 1:10–11), and food that had touched idolatry most of all. The Mishnah, later than Paul but reflecting older practice, forbids meat "entering into idolatry" (m. Avodah Zarah 2:3). Diaspora communities arranged their own supply. Josephus records a decree at Sardis directing the market officials to make "suitable food" available for the Jews (Antiquities 14.259–261). Against that background, Paul, a former Pharisee, telling a mixed congregation to buy from the general market without asking would have stood out.
The verse quoted next. Verse 26 quotes Psalm 24:1, "The earth is the Lord's, and the fullness thereof." Later rabbinic tradition used this same verse as the reason for saying a blessing before eating (b. Berakhot 35a). Paul may be drawing on a familiar Jewish table idea: food is God's gift and is received with thanks (compare 10:30).
Where the verse sits in the argument. In chapters 8–10 Paul answers the Corinthians' question about "food sacrificed to idols" (8:1). He sets knowledge against love (ch. 8), offers his own example of giving up his rights (ch. 9), and gives a stern warning from Israel's wilderness history, banning participation in idol feasts (10:1–22). Then 10:23–11:1 sets out practical cases. Verse 25 is the first: the public market.
From the study of 1 Corinthians 10:25.
Where scholars differ
in v25
What does "asking no questions because of conscience" mean, and whose conscience is meant?
-
Don't investigate, because conscience is not at stake in the market: the food is the Lord's (v. 26). Your own conscience has nothing to rule on.
The "for" opening v. 26 gives the reason directly. The parallel in v. 27 has the same wording. Commentators such as Fee and Thiselton read the phrase as removing the need for scruples.
-
Don't investigate, so that you don't create a conscience problem. Once you know the meat was sacrificed, the situation changes (as v. 28 shows), so it is better not to know.
Verses 28–29 show that knowing does change what you should do. Not asking keeps things in the category of the unknown, where eating is allowed.
-
The conscience in view looks ahead to other people's: don't make an issue of it that could unsettle weaker believers.
Verse 29 explicitly says "not your own conscience, but the other person's", and the whole section is governed by v. 24 (seek the other's good). Most scholars, however, take v. 25 as being about the buyer's own conscience, with the other person's coming in only at v. 28.
in v25
Did Paul treat idol food as morally neutral, or did he forbid knowingly eating it?
-
Idol food is neutral in itself. Paul forbids only taking part in temple meals (10:14–22) and causing a weaker believer to stumble. Market meat is free.
8:4–8 ("an idol is nothing"; "food will not bring us closer to God"); 10:25–27 permit eating without asking; 10:30 ("I partake with thankfulness"). This is the majority view (e.g., Fee, Garland).
-
Paul, in line with Jewish practice, forbids knowingly eating idol food anywhere, but presumes food of unknown origin to be acceptable. "Don't ask" is a rule for doubtful cases, not a declaration that idol food is neutral.
10:28 forbids eating once the food is identified as sacrificed. Rabbinic law likewise distinguishes known idol offerings from food of doubtful status. This view fits Acts 15:29 and Rev 2:14, 20. Argued by P. J. Tomson (*Paul and the Jewish Law*) and A. T. Cheung (*Idol Food in Corinth*).
in v25
How much of the meat in Corinth's market had actually been sacrificed?
-
Much or most of it: in Greco-Roman practice slaughter was routinely accompanied by ritual, so market meat would commonly have had a sacrificial history.
Pliny, *Letters* 10.96 (sacrificial meat sold on the market); the close ties between butchers, cooks and sacrificers in Greek usage; P. D. Gooch, *Dangerous Food*.
-
A smaller and uncertain share. Plenty of meat was slaughtered without temple involvement, and the poor met meat mainly in cheap eateries or at festival handouts.
J. J. Meggitt, *JTS* 45 (1994), and others note how mixed the archaeological and literary evidence is. Paul's own "don't ask" assumes that a shopper could not tell, which fits either view.
in v26
Who is “the Lord” (kyrios) here: God the Creator, or Jesus?
-
God (YHWH) as Creator, in the psalm's original sense.
In Psalm 24 kyrios stands for YHWH, who “founded it upon the seas.” Paul elsewhere attributes creation to God the Father, “from whom are all things” (8:6), and v. 31 says “do all to the glory of God.”
-
The risen Jesus, whom Paul calls “Lord” throughout the letter.
In the immediate context, “the cup of the Lord” and “the table of the Lord” (10:21) and “provoke the Lord to jealousy” (10:22) refer to Christ. Paul calls Jesus the one Lord “through whom are all things” (8:6), and elsewhere he applies YHWH texts to Jesus (e.g. Rom 10:13). Several commentators (e.g. Fee, Capes) see Christ intended here.
-
Deliberately both.
1 Cor 8:6 places Father and Lord Jesus together in the work of creation. Paul may be reading a YHWH psalm with Jesus included in the divine identity, without separating the two.
in v27
What does "because of conscience" attach to, and whose conscience is meant?
-
Don't ask, because the believer's own conscience has nothing at stake. Since the food is the Lord's (v. 26), asking would be needless scrupulosity.
The identical phrase in v. 25 follows directly on the market ruling and leads straight into v. 26's "for the earth is the Lord's". The most natural reading is that there is no conscience reason to investigate.
-
Don't ask, so that you don't create a conscience problem. Asking could stir up anxiety in yourself or in a weaker believer, or make the food's origin a public issue.
Vv. 28–29 show that once the sacrificial origin is stated, conscience does come into play. Not asking keeps the meal free of that complication. Several commentators (e.g. Thiselton, Garland) note the phrase deliberately looks ahead.
-
In vv. 25 and 27 the phrase refers generally to conscience. Paul then narrows it in v. 29 to "not your own, but the other person's".
Paul's clarification in v. 29 ("I mean not your conscience but the other's") suggests readers could have misunderstood the earlier, unspecified uses (Fee).
in v27
Who is the "someone" who says "This was offered in sacrifice" in v. 28, and how does that affect the freedom granted in v. 27?
-
A pagan, either the host or another guest.
The word *hierothyton* ("sacred offering") is respectful pagan vocabulary, not the Jewish-Christian *eidōlothyton*. Eating after such a remark would look to a pagan like approving the god.
-
A fellow Christian with a "weak" conscience.
Paul's concern for the conscience of a fellow believer in 8:7–13 and here (vv. 28–29) suggests a believer whose faith might be harmed. A Christian might use the polite term while speaking in a pagan home.
in v27
Does Paul's permission conflict with the Jerusalem decree of Acts 15:29, which tells gentile believers to abstain from food sacrificed to idols?
-
There is real tension. Paul works from his own principle and does not cite the decree.
Paul never mentions the decree in his letters and allows market and home meat without inquiry (vv. 25–27).
-
There is no essential conflict. The decree targets eating in a cult setting, which Paul also forbids (10:14–22).
Paul fully forbids temple dining and forbids knowingly eating openly identified sacrificial food (v. 28). Only unidentified food is permitted.
in v28
Who is the "someone" who points out the sacrificial food?
-
A pagan: the host or another unbelieving guest.
The setting is an unbeliever's dinner (v. 27). The speaker uses the respectful pagan term *hierothyton*, not the Jewish-Christian *eidōlothyton*. Paul's closing concern is giving no offence to "Jews or Greeks" as well as the church (v. 32). This is the majority view among recent commentators (e.g. Fee, Thiselton, Garland, Witherington).
-
A fellow Christian with a "weak" (over-scrupulous) conscience who is also at the meal.
It parallels 8:7–13, where the concern is a weaker believer being drawn into eating against his conscience. A pagan might not seem to have a "conscience" at stake in a Christian eating his god's meat. Some suggest a believer might use the polite term out of courtesy in a pagan home. Held by some older interpreters (e.g. Godet) and others.
-
Deliberately left open: anyone, pagan or Christian.
Paul uses the vague *tis* ("anyone"). The principle in v. 32 covers all three groups (Jews, Greeks, the church). The ruling works whoever the speaker is, because what matters is that the food's religious meaning has been announced.
in v28
How does a pagan's "conscience" come into it?
-
The pagan would conclude that Christian faith is compatible with honouring the gods, or that the Christian is inconsistent.
If the informant is pagan, *syneidēsis* means his moral judgment about what is fitting for a Christian. Eating after being told would confirm that Jesus' followers can also honour other gods, which undermines the exclusive loyalty Paul demands in 10:14–22.
-
The word points to a weaker believer's conscience, which could be led into sin.
This fits the language of 8:7, 10, 12, where "weak conscience" and being "emboldened" to eat idol-food lead to the weak believer's ruin. It requires the informant to be a Christian.
in v29
How does the question in 29b–30 ("why should my freedom be judged…?") connect to the instruction to abstain in v. 28?
-
It explains *why to abstain*. There is no point exposing my freedom to condemnation. If I eat after being warned, my good, received with thanks, gets denounced, so I refrain.
The *gar* ("for") most naturally explains the sentence just before it. *Krinetai* is paired with *blasphēmoumai* ("denounced", v. 30), which closely matches Rom 14:16, "do not let your good be slandered" (*blasphēmeisthō*). *Hinati* can mean "to what end?". The conclusion in vv. 31–33 points to seeking others' good.
-
Verses 28–29a are an aside, and 29b–30 go back to defending the permission of vv. 25–27. The believer's freedom is not finally subject to another person's scruples, even though he may give way voluntarily. (Argued, for example, by Gordon Fee.)
Verses 29b–30 are in the first person and use the language of freedom and thanksgiving, which echo vv. 25–27 and 9:1, 19. Read straight after v. 28, the question sounds like a defence of eating, so the aside reading smooths the logic.
-
Paul is voicing a Corinthian objection ("Why should my freedom be judged by someone else's conscience?") in the style of a debater who answers imagined opponents. His answer follows in vv. 31–33.
Paul quotes or echoes Corinthian slogans elsewhere in the letter (6:12; 8:1; 10:23). The sudden "my" and the indignant tone suit an imagined objector. However, Paul gives no clear marker such as "someone will say" (compare 15:35).
in v29
Whose is the "other" conscience: a pagan's or a weaker Christian's?
-
A pagan host or fellow guest.
The setting is an unbeliever's dinner (v. 27). The speaker uses *hierothyton*, the respectful pagan word, not the Christian *eidōlothyton*. Paul's concern for outsiders follows in v. 32 ("give no offence to Jews or to Greeks").
-
A weaker Christian present at the meal.
The language of "conscience" and of not causing a fellow believer to stumble echoes 8:7–13, where the conscience in question belongs to the "weak" brother. A believer might use the polite word in a pagan home.
in v29
Does *syneidēsis* in 1 Cor 8–10 mean moral "conscience" or simply "consciousness/awareness"?
-
Moral conscience, the faculty that judges right and wrong.
It is described as "weak", "defiled" and "wounded" (8:7, 12), which are moral categories. It is parallel to Paul's moral use in Rom 2:15 and 2 Cor 1:12.
-
Closer to "awareness" or "consciousness", possibly a Corinthian catchword for spiritual self-awareness. (Associated with R. A. Horsley.)
The basic Greek sense is "co-knowledge". The word clusters with "knowledge" (*gnōsis*) in ch. 8, and the Corinthians' own vocabulary of knowledge may lie behind it.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. μάκελλον, ἀνακρίνω, συνείδησις
- LSJ s.v. συνείδησις
- H. J. Cadbury, "The Macellum of Corinth," Journal of Biblical Literature 53 (1934)
- G. D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)
- A. C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)
- D. E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT)
- P. D. Gooch, Dangerous Food: 1 Corinthians 8–10 in Its Context (1993)
- J. J. Meggitt, "Meat Consumption and Social Conflict in Corinth," Journal of Theological Studies 45 (1994)
- A. T. Cheung, Idol Food in Corinth: Jewish Background and Pauline Legacy (1999)
- P. J. Tomson, Paul and the Jewish Law (1990)
- C. A. Pierce, Conscience in the New Testament (1955)
- Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96
- Josephus, Antiquities 14.259–261
- Mishnah Avodah Zarah 2:3
- Babylonian Talmud Berakhot 35a
- Didache 6:3
- Vulgate, 1 Corinthians 10:25
- Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, Psalm 23:1
- BDAG s.v. πλήρωμα
- BDAG s.v. κύριος
- HALOT s.v. מְלֹא
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)
- Anthony C. Thiselton, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)
- Tosefta Berakhot 4:1; Babylonian Talmud Berakhot 35a
- H. J. Cadbury, “The Macellum of Corinth,” JBL 53 (1934)
- Peter D. Gooch, Dangerous Food: 1 Corinthians 8–10 in Its Context (1993)
- David B. Capes, Old Testament Yahweh Texts in Paul’s Christology (1992)
- BDAG s.v. συνείδησις, ἀνακρίνω, ἄπιστος, παρατίθημι, καλέω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. συνείδησις
- Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT, rev. ed.)
- David E. Garland, 1 Corinthians (BECNT)
- Wendell L. Willis, Idol Meat in Corinth (1985)
- P.Oxy. 110 and 523 (dinner invitations, Roman Egypt)
- Mishnah Avodah Zarah 2:3; Tosefta Berakhot 4:1
- NA28 critical apparatus at 1 Cor 10:27
- NA28 / UBS5 Greek New Testament and apparatus
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on 1 Cor 10:28
- BDAG s.v. ἱερόθυτος, εἰδωλόθυτος, μηνύω, συνείδησις
- LSJ s.v. μηνύω, ἱερόθυτος
- Ben Witherington III, Conflict and Community in Corinth
- Peter D. Gooch, Dangerous Food: 1 Corinthians 8–10 in Its Context
- Wendell L. Willis, Idol Meat in Corinth
- C. A. Pierce, Conscience in the New Testament
- Plutarch, Quaestiones convivales (Table Talk) 729C
- Didache 6:3; 4 Maccabees 5:2; Acts 15:29; Revelation 2:14, 20
- BDAG s.v. συνείδησις
- BDAG s.v. κρίνω
- BDAG s.v. ἐλευθερία
- BDAG s.v. ἱνατί
- C. Maurer, TDNT s.v. σύνοιδα, συνείδησις
- R. A. Horsley, "Consciousness and Freedom among the Corinthians: 1 Corinthians 8–10," CBQ 40 (1978)
- W. L. Willis, Idol Meat in Corinth (1985)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on 1 Cor 10:23–33
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
- Vulgate, 1 Cor 10:29
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).