1 Samuel Chapter 18 Read as one passage
1 Samuel 18:1–5
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1After David had finished speaking with Saul, the souls of Jonathan and David were knit together, and Jonathan loved him as himself. 2And from that day Saul kept David with him and did not let him return to his father’s house. 3Then Jonathan made a covenant with David because he loved him as himself. 4And Jonathan removed the robe he was wearing and gave it to David, along with his tunic, his sword, his bow, and his belt. 5So David marched out and prospered in everything Saul sent him to do, and Saul set him over the men of war. And this was pleasing in the sight of all the people, and of Saul’s officers as well.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse opens one of the great loyalty stories of their tradition. They would have heard it on two levels together.
- A friendship of unusual depth. The phrase 'his nephesh bound to his nephesh' was the language a father used for a beloved son (Gen 44:30), and 'as his own nephesh' was the language for the closest friend imaginable (Deut 13:6). Jonathan's attachment is total.
- A shift in loyalty from one royal house to the next. The heir of Saul's house attaches himself to the anointed outsider. Hearers who knew how things turned out would see here the start of the legitimate passing of the kingdom to David. It happens through the heir's own willing loyalty, not through David's scheming. The covenant that follows (18:3; 20:14–17, 42) also explains David's later kindness to Jonathan's son Mephibosheth (2 Sam 9).
- Hints of trouble. The bond appears just as Saul begins to see David as a rival (18:8–9). The word 'bound' would later sound like the 'conspiracy' Saul accuses his court of (22:8), so the story already points toward the clash of loyalties between father and son.
From the study of 1 Samuel 18:1.
Verse by verse
-
1After David had finished speaking with Saul, the souls of Jonathan and David were knit together, and Jonathan loved him as himself.
Full study →Just as David finished answering King Saul, telling him whose son he was, something happened to the king's own son. Jonathan's very life, his self and everything he wanted, became tied fast to David's life. It was like a cord pulled tight, the way a father's life can be 'bound up in' his son's (Gen 44:30). And Jonathan loved David as his own life: he valued David as he valued himself. This love was deep personal affection, and it was also the loyalty of someone taking David's side.
The verse is entirely about Jonathan. He is the one bound and he is the one who loves, and David's feelings are not mentioned. The word 'love' runs through the whole chapter. Saul, the people of Israel and Judah, Saul's daughter Michal and his courtiers all come to 'love' David (16:21; 18:16, 20, 22), and the verb carries both warmth and allegiance. So the first hearers would have heard two things together. One is a friendship of unusual depth. The other is the heir to Saul's throne quietly attaching himself to the man God has already chosen to replace Saul's house. The very next verses turn this bond into a formal covenant and have Jonathan hand David his own royal robe and weapons (18:3–4).
-
2And from that day Saul kept David with him and did not let him return to his father’s house.
Full study →On that same day, the day David killed the Philistine champion and stood before the king, Saul took him. This was the way a king lays claim to a promising warrior and attaches him to his own household, as Saul did with every strong man he noticed (14:52) and as Samuel had warned a king would do with Israel's sons (8:11). From then on Saul would not let him go back to his father's house. The shepherd boy who had moved back and forth between the royal camp and Jesse's flocks now belonged to the king's household and no longer to his father's. His comings and goings were Saul's to permit.
The verse is wedged between two statements about Jonathan's love for David (v.1 and v.3), and the placement matters. On one day David is bound to the royal family twice: the king claims him and the king's son binds himself to him. Both ties will be tested, because the king who has taken David into his house will soon fear him.
-
3Then Jonathan made a covenant with David because he loved him as himself.
Full study →Then Jonathan cut a covenant, he and David, because he loved David as his own life.
The crown prince of Israel takes the initiative. The Hebrew says he cut a covenant, and David is added as his partner. Jonathan enters a sworn bond with the young warrior who has just killed Goliath. "Cut a covenant" is a solemn phrase. It recalls covenant rites in which animals were cut in two and the parties in effect said, "may I be cut off like this if I break faith." So this is not just a promise of friendship. It is a binding oath that sets up lasting obligations of loyalty, and later chapters show those obligations reaching Jonathan's own children.
The reason given is love. In Hebrew this love includes both warm personal attachment and committed allegiance. It is the same word Israel's neighbours used when a subject swore loyalty to a king or crown prince. Jonathan loves David "as his own nephesh": as his own life, his very self. He holds David as dear as he holds his own existence. In the next verse Jonathan strips off his royal robe, his armour, sword, bow and belt, and gives them to David. That is the outward sign of what this verse describes: Saul's heir binding himself, with his whole life, to the man who will take the throne.
-
4And Jonathan removed the robe he was wearing and gave it to David, along with his tunic, his sword, his bow, and his belt.
Full study →Jonathan, whose name means "the LORD has given," now gives. Right after binding himself to David by covenant (v. 3), the king's son and expected heir takes off the robe he is wearing, the formal outer robe that in this book marks rank and office, and puts it on David. Then the list keeps building, with a repeated "and even" that will not stop: his garments (the fitted military tunic a warrior wore under his weapons), and even his sword, one of only two swords in all Israel's army, and even his bow, the weapon Jonathan was known for, and even his belt, the warrior's belt that held it all together.
He takes these things off himself, freely, from his own body. Nothing is mentioned coming back. Just a few lines earlier, Saul's war gear would not sit on David. Now the prince willingly dresses David in his own. To an Israelite listener who knew how the story ends, it looked like a man stepping out of his place and clothing another man in it.
-
5So David marched out and prospered in everything Saul sent him to do, and Saul set him over the men of war. And this was pleasing in the sight of all the people, and of Saul’s officers as well.
Full study →David kept marching out on the missions Saul sent him on, over and over, and on every one of them he handled things with skill and good judgment, and so he succeeded. The Hebrew word covers both ideas at once: insight, and the success that comes from it. So Saul put him in command of fighting men, a real military post in the king's standing force, though not the top command. The appointment won approval all round: the troops ("the people," which here largely means the people under arms) were glad of it, and, more surprisingly, so were Saul's own courtiers and officials, the men of rank at court who would normally resent an upstart.
The verse reads like a summary of a rising career, but it is also a setup. It uses the idiom "good in the eyes of" everyone. Three verses later the women's song is "evil in the eyes" of Saul (18:8), and from then on Saul keeps a suspicious eye on David (18:9). The word for David's success comes back as a refrain (18:14, 15, 30), and the narrator gives its real source: "YHWH was with him" (18:12, 14). The first hearers would also have noticed that David is already doing what Israel had asked a king to do, "go out before us and fight our battles" (8:20), while Saul is still the one sending him.
Where the English drifted
-
in v1
soul ("the soul of Jonathan was knit with the soul of David")
nefesh
- What we hear
- An immaterial, spiritual inner part of a person, so the verse is heard as two spirits mystically fusing.
- What they heard
- The whole living self: life, breath, desire and person. Jonathan's very life and longing became tied to David's, and he valued David's life as his own.
-
in v1
loved
ʾāhēv
- What we hear
- A private feeling of affection, often heard as romantic.
- What they heard
- Real affection together with committed loyalty and taking someone's side. At court and in treaties 'love' named a sworn ally's allegiance, and in this chapter all Israel 'loves' David in that public sense.
-
in v2
took him
lāqaḥ
- What we hear
- Saul casually brought David along or invited him to stay.
-
in v2
his father's house / home
bêt ʾābîw
- What we hear
- His parents' home, the building where he grew up, which a young adult naturally leaves.
- What they heard
- His father's extended household, the kinship and economic unit he belonged to and worked for. Being kept from it meant his belonging and loyalty passed to the king's household.
-
in v3
as his own soul
kĕnapšô (nephesh)
- What we hear
- A bond between two immaterial, spiritual souls, sometimes taken to mean a mystical joining of spirits.
- What they heard
- As his own life, as himself. Nephesh is the whole living person. The phrase measures how much Jonathan valued David: as much as his own life.
-
in v3
loved
ʼahăbâ
- What we hear
- A purely emotional or romantic feeling.
- What they heard
- Real affection together with committed, practical loyalty. In public and royal settings it was also the vocabulary of political allegiance, which is why it can be the grounds for a covenant.
-
in v3
covenant
bĕrît
- What we hear
- Either a religious term or a legal contract.
- What they heard
- A sworn bond of loyalty, sealed by oath and a self-curse, creating family-like obligations that could pass to descendants.
-
in v4
stripped himself (KJV, ESV, NASB)
hitpashshēṭ
- What we hear
- Undressed completely, got naked.
- What they heard
- Took off a specific garment, here the outer robe named in the sentence, along with his gear. It is a deliberate removal of the marks of his rank, not nudity.
-
in v4
girdle (KJV, YLT)
ḥăgôr
- What we hear
- A woman's shaping undergarment.
- What they heard
- A warrior's belt that held the sword and fastened the tunic for battle. It could also be a mark of military honour.
-
in v4
armor (ESV, NASB)
maddāw
- What we hear
- Metal body protection: mail or plate.
- What they heard
- A fitted cloth tunic or military dress worn under weapons and armour. In 17:38 it is listed separately from the bronze helmet and coat of mail.
-
in v4
robe
mə'îl
- What we hear
- A loose, casual or household garment, like a bathrobe.
- What they heard
- A formal outer garment of rank worn by priests, prophets, kings and royal children. In 1 Samuel it is a recurring symbol of office and kingdom.
-
in v5
prospered (BSB)
yaskīl
- What we hear
- Became prosperous or wealthy; was blessed with material gain.
- What they heard
- Acted with insight and so succeeded: competent handling of military missions that turned out well.
-
in v5
behaved himself wisely (KJV)
yaskīl
- What we hear
- Conducted himself well, was well-mannered, modest or discreet.
- What they heard
- Showed skilled, effective judgment in carrying out tasks, with success as the result. It is about competence, not etiquette.
-
in v5
servants
ʿavdê shāʾūl
- What we hear
- Household staff or domestic help.
- What they heard
- The king's officials and courtiers, men of rank at the royal court.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v1
'Knit souls' doesn't describe a spiritual soul tie
- What's often taught
- This verse is often cited as biblical proof of 'soul ties': the idea that close emotional or sexual relationships create a spiritual bond between two souls that keeps a hold on a person until it is broken through prayer.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew word is nefesh, a person's whole living self, not an immaterial part that can be linked to someone else's. The exact same construction, 'his nefesh is bound (qashar) in his nefesh', is used in Gen 44:30 for Jacob, whose life depends on his son Benjamin. It is a vivid idiom for devotion and dependence, not a description of a spiritual mechanism. In 1 Samuel the bond is a good one. It becomes a sworn covenant (18:3) and is honoured to the end (20:42; 2 Sam 9). Nothing in the verse involves sex, harm or a need to break the tie. The common reading gets one thing right: the verse does describe an unusually strong attachment that shapes a person's life and choices.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Soul' in KJV, ESV and NASB suggests a spiritual part of a person, and 'knit' suggests two things woven into one fabric. Together they invite a mystical reading that Hebrew 'his life was tied to his life' does not.
in v4
Jonathan and David didn't swap robes, belts and swords
- What's often taught
- Many sermons and popular books on covenant teach that Jonathan and David performed a covenant ceremony of exchange: they traded robes (identities), belts (strength), and weapons (enemies), often within a larger set of "blood covenant" steps that includes cutting and mingling blood.
- What the text supports
In the Hebrew, every verb has Jonathan as its subject. He stripped himself (yitpashshēṭ) and gave (yittənēhû) the robe, tunic, sword, bow and belt to David. David gives nothing back in this verse or in the surrounding narrative, and no blood, cutting or ceremony is described. The gift goes in one direction, from the higher‑ranking prince to the lower‑ranking newcomer. That one‑way direction is the point: the heir is giving away his own standing.
What the popular teaching gets right is that the gift is closely tied to the covenant of verse 3 and that clothing carried identity. But the specific "exchange" ritual comes from 19th‑century comparative studies of blood‑brotherhood customs in other cultures, not from this text. The phrase "cut a covenant" (v. 3) is the normal Hebrew idiom for making a covenant and does not by itself point to a cutting ritual here.
- Where the English feeds it
- Very little. Every major English translation correctly shows only Jonathan giving. The misreading comes from teaching built on top of the text rather than from translation, though paraphrases that call the act "sealing the pact" can encourage people to read a formal ritual into it.
Every word
-
וַיְהִ֗י
wayhî · H1961
and it was / and it came about · v1
The standard Hebrew storytelling opener, like 'Now it happened'. It marks a new scene that follows straight on from David's conversation with Saul in 17:55–58.
-
כְּכַלֹּתוֹ֙
kekhallōtô · H3615G
when he finished · v1
'As his finishing', so 'just as he finished'. The 'he' is David, who had just answered Saul's question 'Whose son are you?' Jonathan's attachment begins at that very moment, apparently as he listened to David at court.
-
לְדַבֵּ֣ר
ledabbēr · H1696G
to speak · v1
David's speaking. The conversation, with its talk of who David's father is, is what sets the bond off. The narrator says nothing at all about David's looks at this point.
-
אֶל־
ʾel- · H0413
to, toward · v1
Marks Saul as the one David was speaking to. Jonathan is a listener, not the person being spoken to.
-
שָׁא֔וּל
shāʾûl · H7586G
Saul · v1, v2, v5
The reigning king and Jonathan's father. Naming him here sets up the tension of the chapter: the king's son binds himself to the man the king will come to fear.
-
וְנֶ֙פֶשׁ֙
wenefesh · H5315G
life, self, soul · v1, v3
Jonathan's whole living self: his life, his desire, his inner drive. It does not mean an immaterial soul as a separate part of him.
-
יְה֣וֹנָתָ֔ן
yehônātān · H3083H
Jonathan ('YHWH has given') · v1, v3, v4
Saul's eldest son and the expected heir, already a war hero in his own right (ch. 14).
-
נִקְשְׁרָ֖ה
niqsherāh · H7194
was bound, tied · v1
A passive form, 'was tied / became bound'. The verb is about tying things together. In other forms it means 'to conspire', which is to bind yourself into a pact with someone. Here Jonathan's life became fastened to David's.
-
דָּוִ֑ד
dāwid · H1732
David · v1, v3, v4, v5
The young shepherd who had just killed Goliath and whom Samuel had already secretly anointed (ch. 16). The reader knows something Jonathan does not yet say aloud.
-
וַיֶּאֱהָבֵ֥הוּ
wayyeʾehāvēhû · H0157G
-
וַיִּקָּחֵ֥הוּ
wayyiqqāḥēhû · H3947
-
בַּיּ֣וֹם
bayyôm · H3117
on the day · v2
Points to a specific day: the day of the victory over Goliath and David's audience with Saul (17:57–18:1).
-
הַה֑וּא
hahûʾ · H1931
that · v2
'That day' ties the taking to the same day as Jonathan's attachment in v.1. Everything in vv.1–4 happens at once. The Hebrew says 'on that day'; 'from that day' (BSB) is an inference about what followed.
-
וְלֹ֣א
wəlōʾ · H3808
and not · v2
A plain negative that sets up the second half: Saul took David, and he did not release him.
-
נְתָנ֔וֹ
nətānô · H5414
-
לָשׁ֖וּב
lāšûb · H7725
to return · v2
'To go back.' It recalls 17:15, where David 'went back and forth' between Saul and his father's flock. That back-and-forth now ends.
-
בֵּ֥ית
bêt · H1004
house of · v2
Not just a building. In 'house of the father' it means the extended family household David belonged to, worked for and answered to.
-
אָבִֽיו׃
ʾābîw · H1
his father · v2
Jesse, the head of David's household. Leaving 'his father's house' means moving from Jesse's authority into the king's.
-
וַיִּכְרֹ֧ת
wayyikrōt · H3772
cut; (with covenant) make · v3
Literally "and he cut." "Cut a covenant" is the standard Hebrew phrase for making a sworn agreement. The verb is singular ("he cut") even though two names follow. That puts Jonathan forward as the one who took the initiative.
-
בְּרִ֑ית
bĕrît · H1285
covenant, binding agreement · v3
A formal bond sealed by oath that sets up lasting obligations of loyalty. In this story it later extends to the two men's descendants (1 Sam 20:14–17, 42; 2 Sam 9).
-
בְּאַהֲבָת֥וֹ
bĕʼahăbātô · H160
love; (here) his loving · v3
"In his loving," meaning "because he loved." The form works like a verb, which is why it takes the object marker that follows. It gives the reason for the covenant. The word includes both warm attachment and committed loyalty.
-
אֹת֖וֹ
ʼōtô · H853
[object marker] + him · v3, v4
"Him," meaning David, as the object of Jonathan's loving. Hebrew has no English equivalent for this marker. It shows that "his loving" is acting as a verb with an object.
-
וַיִּתְפַּשֵּׁ֣ט
wayyitpashshēṭ · H6584
to strip (oneself) · v4
"And he stripped himself (of)." The verb form points the action back at the one doing it: Jonathan took the robe off his own body, by choice. Nobody took it from him. The same root is used for stripping the dead after battle and for taking the high priest's vestments off Aaron so they could be put on his successor.
-
הַמְּעִיל֙
hammə'îl · H4598
the robe (outer garment of rank) · v4
"The robe": a formal outer garment worn by people of standing, such as priests, prophets, kings and royal children. In 1 Samuel the robe keeps showing up as the sign of who holds office.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăsher · H834A
which, that · v4, v5
This word introduces the clause that tells us which robe is meant: the one he had on.
-
עָלָ֔יו
'ālāw · H5921A
upon him · v4, v5
"[That was] on him." It was not a spare robe from a chest. It was the robe on his own body at that moment, so he was giving off himself.
-
וּמַדָּ֕יו
ûmaddāw · H4055
and his garment(s) · v4
"And his garments." This means a fitted tunic or military dress, the kind of garment a sword was strapped over (Judg 3:16; 2 Sam 20:8). It is the same word used when Saul tried to dress David in his own gear in 17:38–39, which David then took off.
-
וְעַד־
wə'ad- · H5704
and even to, up to · v4
"And even including." Repeated three times, it builds the list toward its end: robe, tunic, and *even* the sword, *even* the bow, *even* the belt. He held nothing back.
-
חַרְבּ֥וֹ
ḥarbô · H2719
his sword · v4
"His sword." According to 1 Sam 13:22, only Saul and Jonathan in all Israel's army had swords, so this was nearly irreplaceable. David himself had come to the fight with no sword in his hand (17:50).
-
קַשְׁתּ֖וֹ
qashtô · H7198
his bow · v4
"His bow." It was the weapon most tied to Jonathan in the story. He signals David with arrows in chapter 20, and David's lament praises it: "the bow of Jonathan did not turn back" (2 Sam 1:22).
-
חֲגֹרֽוֹ׃
ḥăgōrô · H2290A
his belt · v4
"His belt": the warrior's belt that held the sword and closed the tunic for action. A belt could also be a mark of military honour (2 Sam 18:11). Coming last, it finishes the picture. Jonathan has handed over his whole equipment as prince and soldier.
-
וַיֵּצֵ֨א
wayyētsē · H3318
-
בְּכֹל֩
bekhōl · H3605
all, every · v5
'In all / in every.' It stresses that there were no exceptions. Every mission went the same way.
-
יִשְׁלָחֶ֤נּוּ
yishlāḥennū · H7971
-
יַשְׂכִּ֔יל
yaskīl · H7919
act with insight; succeed · v5
'He acted with insight / he succeeded.' The verb stands on its own with no 'and', which makes it read like a short verdict. In Hebrew this word joins skilful judgment with the success it brings. David did not just get lucky. He handled each mission well, and it worked.
-
וַיְשִׂמֵ֣הוּ
wayesīmēhū · H7760
put, set, appoint · v5
'And he put him.' It is a plain verb of placing, used here for appointing someone to an office. Saul promotes David because of his record.
-
אַנְשֵׁ֣י
ʾanshê · H582
men · v5
'Men of.' The phrase 'men of the war' that it begins is a fixed expression for fighting men or soldiers.
-
הַמִּלְחָמָ֑ה
hammilḥāmāh · H4421
-
וַיִּיטַב֙
wayyīṭav · H3190
be good, be pleasing · v5
'And it was good.' This begins the Hebrew idiom 'to be good in someone's eyes', meaning to win their approval. The subject may be the appointment or David himself; KJV takes it as 'he was accepted'.
-
בְּעֵינֵ֣י
beʿênê · H5869
eye(s) · v5
'In the eyes of.' It means in their judgment or view. The promotion was approved by public opinion.
-
הָעָ֔ם
hāʿām · H5971
people · v5
'The people.' In military settings ʿam often means the troops, the people under arms. That fits here: the soldiers welcomed their new officer. A wider popularity follows in 18:16 ('all Israel and Judah loved David').
-
וְגַ֕ם
wegam · H1571
and also, even · v5
'And also / and even.' It adds a second group the reader might not have expected, and stresses it.
-
עַבְדֵ֥י
ʿavdê · H5650
servant, slave, official · v5
'Servants of.' Here this means the king's officials and courtiers, the men of rank around Saul. A royal court is the place where a fast-rising outsider would normally meet resentment.
The world behind it
The royal court after Goliath. Jonathan is Saul's eldest son and the expected heir. He is a proven warrior who had already routed a Philistine garrison with only his armour-bearer (ch. 14). David is a shepherd boy from Bethlehem who has just killed Goliath. Saul's question in 17:55–58, 'Whose son are you?', was a practical one at court, because Saul had promised the giant-slayer's family rewards and tax freedom (17:25). Jonathan's bond forms while he is listening to that conversation.
'Love' as the language of loyalty. In the ancient Near East, kings and allies spoke of 'loving' one another to mean loyal, sworn support. This appears in the Amarna letters (diplomatic correspondence of the 1300s BC) and in Hiram of Tyre, who 'had always loved David' (1 Kgs 5:1). In 1 Samuel 16–18 almost everyone comes to 'love' David, and the narrator uses this to show public support moving away from Saul. When the crown prince himself does so, it carries great political weight.
The larger story. Chapters 16–2 Samuel 5 are often read as a defence of David's rise to the throne. They show that David did not grab the kingship. Even Saul's heir willingly bound himself to David and handed over the symbols of his position (18:4; 23:17, 'you will be king over Israel, and I will be second to you').
From the study of 1 Samuel 18:1.
Where scholars differ
in v1
What kind of love is Jonathan's 'love' for David?
-
Mainly political loyalty: a covenant ally's allegiance to the future king.
'Love' is standard treaty and court vocabulary in the ancient Near East (Moran 1963). In 1 Sam 16–18 Saul, all Israel and Judah, and the courtiers all 'love' David (Thompson 1974). The love quickly becomes a formal covenant (18:3) and the handing over of royal clothing and weapons (18:4).
-
Deep personal friendship that also has political consequences.
Ackroyd (1975) and many commentators note that the language of nephesh ('his life bound up in', Gen 44:30; 'friend as your own self', Deut 13:6) is personal and emotional. The later scenes show weeping and kissing (20:41) and David's lament 'your love to me was wonderful' (2 Sam 1:26). The narrative keeps the personal and political senses together.
-
A love with erotic or romantic overtones.
Some scholars (e.g. Schroer & Staubli; Ackerman, When Heroes Love, 2005) point to 2 Sam 1:26's comparison with 'the love of women', Saul's coarse insult in 20:30, and the intense language. Others (e.g. Zehnder 1998) answer that ʾāhēv here carries no sexual sense, that kissing and weeping between men were ordinary in that culture, that nothing in the vocabulary is sexual, and that Saul's insult is aimed at Jonathan's disloyalty and his mother's shame. Most see no explicit sexual sense in this verse's wording.
in v1
Is the longer Hebrew story of chapters 17–18 (including this verse) the original, or did the shorter Greek come first?
-
The shorter Greek reflects an earlier Hebrew edition, and the extra material (including 17:55–18:5) is a second, interwoven version of how David came to Saul.
The longer text has doublets and tensions: in 16:21 Saul already knows and loves David, yet in 17:55–58 he does not know him. Tov and Lust argue for two combined versions.
-
The Greek translator, or the Hebrew text he used, shortened a longer original to remove those tensions.
Barthélemy and Gooding argue that the omissions are selective and smooth over difficulties. This is part of a joint study, The Story of David and Goliath (1986), in which the four scholars set out both views.
in v2
Is the longer Hebrew text (including 18:2) original, or was it added to a shorter story?
-
The shorter Greek text reflects an earlier Hebrew edition. The extra material (including 17:55–18:5) comes from a second, parallel account of David's arrival and was added later.
The Vaticanus Septuagint lacks these verses. The pluses form a coherent story of their own. There is tension with 16:14–23, where David already serves Saul (argued by Tov, Lust and McCarter).
-
The longer Hebrew text is original, and the Greek translator or its Hebrew source shortened it to remove apparent contradictions.
The omitted verses are exactly the ones that seem to clash with ch.16, which suggests deliberate harmonising. 17:15 already reconciles David's earlier service with his presence at home (argued by Barthélemy and Gooding).
in v2
Why is v.2 placed between Jonathan's love (v.1) and his covenant (v.3)?
-
The placement is deliberate. It sets the king's 'taking' of David beside his son's self-binding, so David is attached to Saul's house both politically and personally on one day.
'On that day' ties vv.1–4 together. The language of love and covenant in these chapters also carries political loyalty overtones, as in ancient Near Eastern treaty language where 'love' means loyalty (Thompson, VT 1974).
-
V.2 is a short narrative note giving background (David's permanent residence at court), which explains how the friendship and covenant could develop. Its position is mainly practical.
The verse uses no love or covenant vocabulary and simply records an administrative fact that the next verses assume.
in v3
What kind of relationship do "love" and "covenant" describe between Jonathan and David?
-
Mainly political and covenantal: Jonathan's "love" is the loyalty of an ally or subject, and the story uses it to show the house of Saul handing the kingship to David.
"Love" is standard treaty language in ancient Near Eastern texts (Moran 1963). Esarhaddon's Succession Treaty requires loving the crown prince "as your own lives," very close to kĕnapšô. In 1 Sam 16–18 all Israel, Judah and Saul's servants also "love" David (Thompson 1974). Jonathan hands over his royal robe and weapons (18:4) and later states that David will be king (23:17).
-
Deep personal friendship that the covenant then formalised: real affection and political loyalty together.
The narrative stresses emotion: Jonathan's nephesh is "bound" to David's (18:1); they weep and kiss at parting (20:41), a normal gesture between men in that culture; David mourns him intensely (2 Sam 1:26). Ancient covenants often grew out of existing relationships and formalised them, so personal and political readings can both be true.
-
A romantic or erotic relationship.
Some interpreters (e.g., T. Horner 1978; S. Schroer and T. Staubli) point to the intensity of the language, Saul's angry outburst in 20:30, and "surpassing the love of women" (2 Sam 1:26). Critics answer that ʼāhab is used constantly for non-sexual loyalty in this very chapter, that the text uses none of the Hebrew Bible's usual sexual vocabulary (e.g., yādaʿ, šākab) for the two men, that Saul's insult in 20:30 concerns dynastic shame rather than sexuality, and that 2 Sam 1:26 compares kinds of loyalty and devotion. Most scholars find the evidence for this reading weak, but it is argued in the academic literature.
in v3
Is the shorter Greek text (without 17:55–18:5) closer to the original story?
-
Yes: the Septuagint reflects an earlier, shorter Hebrew edition, and passages like this were added later.
The Greek translation of Samuel is otherwise fairly literal, so a large omission is less likely to be the translator's own choice. The longer Hebrew text has doublets and tensions, for example Saul not knowing who David is in 17:55 after 16:21–23 (Tov, Lust).
-
No: the shorter Greek text is a deliberate abridgment meant to remove narrative tensions.
The omissions line up with the very places where the story seems inconsistent, which suggests intentional harmonising. The longer narrative can be read as a coherent literary whole (Gooding, Barthélemy).
in v4
Was Jonathan's gift a symbolic handover of his right to the throne, or a gift of honour sealing friendship?
-
It is a symbolic transfer of status or succession. The heir clothes David in his own role.
Garments of office pass to successors elsewhere (Num 20:26–28, with the same verb pashat; Isa 22:21 robe and sash; 2 Kgs 2:13). In 1 Samuel the me'il is consistently a symbol of kingdom (15:27–28; 24:4–5, 20). Jonathan later says it outright (23:17), and Saul accuses him of siding with David against his own claim (20:30–31). Commentators such as McCarter (Anchor Bible) and Alter read the act this way, as does Jobling's structural study.
-
It is a lavish gift of honour and loyalty confirming the covenant, without a formal abdication.
The verse itself says nothing about kingship, and David stays in Saul's service (v. 5). Gifts of clothing and weapons were common marks of favour between a patron and a client (compare 2 Sam 18:11). On this view the meaning of succession comes from the wider narrative looking back, not from the act itself. Many commentators, such as Klein (WBC), treat it primarily as a covenant gift while granting the overtones.
in v4
What kind of "love" lies behind the gift (v. 3)?
-
Political or covenant loyalty.
"Love" is standard ancient Near Eastern treaty language for allegiance (Moran, CBQ 1963). In this chapter the same verb is used of all Israel and Judah loving David (18:16), and elsewhere of Hiram loving David (1 Kgs 5:1). J. A. Thompson (VT 1974) argued that the David–Jonathan vocabulary is largely political.
-
Deep personal friendship expressed in covenant form.
"Loved him as his own soul" (18:1, 3) and David's lament, "your love to me was wonderful" (2 Sam 1:26), go beyond ordinary treaty phrasing. Political and personal loyalty were not separate categories in this world. This is the majority reading in Jewish and Christian tradition.
-
A romantic or erotic bond.
Some modern interpreters cite 2 Sam 1:26 ("surpassing the love of women"), Saul's insult in 20:30, and the language of stripping in this verse. Critics reply that this verse describes removing an outer robe, tunic and weapons, not nudity. They also point out that the vocabulary closely matches political love‑language elsewhere. The verse on its own does not settle the question.
in v4
Is 1 Samuel 17:55–18:5 (including this verse) original to the book?
-
The shorter Greek version reflects an older Hebrew text, and the Masoretic Text has combined two accounts.
Tov and Lust point to how consistent the Greek gaps are and to tensions in the Hebrew (Saul not knowing David in 17:55 after 16:21–23).
-
The Greek abridged a longer original to remove tensions.
Barthélemy and Gooding argue that the omitted sections fit the narrative's literary patterns and that the translators had harmonising motives.
in v5
Why is this verse (with 17:55–18:5) missing from the main Septuagint text?
-
The shorter Greek text reflects an earlier Hebrew version of the David and Goliath story. The Masoretic Text combined it with a second, parallel account, which included 17:55–18:5.
The longer Hebrew text has tensions: Saul asks who David is in 17:55–58 even though David already served him in 16:21–23, and David's introduction in 17:12 repeats earlier information. The LXX translator of Samuel is otherwise fairly literal, which makes large deliberate cuts less likely (argued by E. Tov and J. Lust in Barthélemy et al., The Story of David and Goliath, 1986; McCarter, Anchor Bible).
-
The Greek translator, or its Hebrew source, shortened a single longer story to remove apparent contradictions.
The omissions are exactly the passages that create the narrative difficulties, which suggests harmonising by design. The longer text can be read as one deliberately layered story (argued by D. W. Gooding and D. Barthélemy in the same volume).
in v5
Does yaskīl mean 'acted wisely' or 'was successful'?
-
Prudence or insight is the main sense: David conducted himself wisely.
The basic meaning of śākal is to understand or have insight; the Vulgate (prudenter) and KJV follow this, and wisdom literature uses the verb this way.
-
Success is the main sense: David succeeded.
The chapter context (18:14–15, 30) links yaskīl with 'YHWH was with him' and with Saul's fear of David's achievements. 2 Kings 18:7 uses the same pairing of 'going out' and śākal for military success.
-
Both together: skilled judgment that produces success.
Hebrew lexicons (HALOT, BDB) list both meanings for the Hiphil and often cannot separate them in a given passage. Most commentators read 18:5 as competence plus results.
in v5
How does Saul's appointment here relate to his making David 'commander of a thousand' in 18:13?
-
Verse 5 is a summary that looks ahead, and 18:13 describes the same appointment from Saul's darker point of view: removing David from court.
Verse 6 goes back in time to the return from killing Goliath, which shows that v. 5 is a summary placed out of strict order.
-
They are two stages: an early honorary command (v. 5) and a later posting that sent David away from court (v. 13).
Verse 13 says explicitly that Saul 'removed him from his presence', a motive that v. 5 does not have.
Sources
- BDB s.v. נֶפֶשׁ, קָשַׁר, אָהֵב
- HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ; קשׁר
- H.W. Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (1974), ch. on nepeš
- W.L. Moran, 'The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy', CBQ 25 (1963)
- J.A. Thompson, 'The Significance of the Verb Love in the David-Jonathan Narratives in 1 Samuel', VT 24 (1974)
- P.R. Ackroyd, 'The Verb Love — ʾāhēḇ in the David-Jonathan Narratives: A Footnote', VT 25 (1975)
- P.K. McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible, 1980)
- D. Barthélemy, D.W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath (1986)
- S. Ackerman, When Heroes Love (2005)
- M. Zehnder, 'Exegetical Observations on the David-Jonathan Relationship', Trinity Journal 19 (1998)
- BDB s.v. לָקַח
- HALOT s.v. לקח
- HALOT s.v. נתן (with lamed + infinitive, 'permit')
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), on 17:55–18:5
- D. Barthélemy, D.W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on the Septuagint of 1 Samuel 17–18
- L.E. Stager, 'The Archaeology of the Family in Ancient Israel,' BASOR 260 (1985)
- J.A. Thompson, 'The Significance of the Verb Love in the David–Jonathan Narratives in 1 Samuel,' Vetus Testamentum 24 (1974)
- Robert Alter, The David Story (1999)
- Vulgate, 1 Regum 18:2
- BDB s.v. כָּרַת, בְּרִית, אָהַב/אַהֲבָה, נֶפֶשׁ
- HALOT s.v. כרת, בְּרִית, אַהֲבָה, נֶפֶשׁ
- Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) §45d, §115 (infinitive forms with object)
- W. L. Moran, "The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy," CBQ 25 (1963)
- J. A. Thompson, "The Significance of the Verb Love in the David–Jonathan Narratives in 1 Samuel," VT 24 (1974)
- Esarhaddon's Succession Treaty (Vassal Treaties of Esarhaddon), §24 (SAA 2, no. 6)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- E. Tov, D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
- T. Horner, Jonathan Loved David (1978)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 18:1–4
- BDB s.v. פָּשַׁט, מְעִיל, מַד, חֲגוֹר
- HALOT s.v. פשׁט (hitp.), מְעִיל, מַד, חֲגוֹר
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- J. A. Thompson, "The Significance of the Verb Love in the David-Jonathan Narratives in 1 Samuel," VT 24 (1974)
- D. Barthélemy, D. W. Gooding, J. Lust, E. Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (1986)
- David Jobling, "Jonathan: A Structure in the David Narrative," in The Sense of Biblical Narrative (1978)
- H. Clay Trumbull, The Blood Covenant (1885), as background to the popular 'covenant exchange' teaching
- HALOT s.v. שׂכל (Hiphil: have insight; have success)
- BDB s.v. שָׂכַל
- BDB/HALOT s.v. עֶבֶד (royal official)
- Barthélemy, Gooding, Lust, Tov, The Story of David and Goliath: Textual and Literary Criticism (OBO 73, 1986)
- P. K. McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
- R. W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible
- Vulgate, 1 Regum 18:5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).