1 Samuel Chapter 18 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 18:20–27

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20Now Saul’s daughter Michal loved David, and when this was reported to Saul, it pleased him. 21“I will give her to David,” Saul thought, “so that she may be a snare to him, and the hand of the Philistines may be against him.” So Saul said to David, “For a second time now you can be my son-in-law.” 22Then Saul ordered his servants, “Speak to David privately and tell him, ‘Behold, the king is pleased with you, and all his servants love you. Now therefore, become his son-in-law.’” 23But when Saul’s servants relayed these words to David, he replied, “Does it seem trivial in your sight to be the son-in-law of the king? I am a poor man and lightly esteemed.” 24And the servants told Saul what David had said. 25Saul replied, “Say to David, ‘The king desires no other dowry but a hundred Philistine foreskins as revenge on his enemies.’” But Saul intended to cause David’s death at the hands of the Philistines. 26When the servants reported these terms to David, he was pleased to become the king’s son-in-law. Before the wedding day arrived, 27David and his men went out and killed two hundred Philistines. He brought their foreskins and presented them as payment in full to become the king’s son-in-law. Then Saul gave his daughter Michal to David in marriage.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers, the verse did several things at once.

  • It added a witness to David's rise. The king's son, the people, the king's servants and now the king's daughter all "love" David. The throne is moving toward David by what looks like general consent, even from inside Saul's house, and not because David seized it.
  • It exposed Saul. The king does not see his daughter. He sees a tool. The hearers have just heard the same scheme with Merab (18:17), so they recognise Saul's pleasure as plotting. The "straight in his eyes" phrase measures how warped his view has become, the reverse of the "evil in his eyes" jealousy of 18:8.
  • It set up irony. The trap Saul builds becomes David's rescue. Michal's love, which Saul means as a snare, is the very thing that later helps David escape (19:11–17). Ancient hearers enjoyed this kind of reversal, where a schemer's plan comes back on him.
  • It opened a sad thread. Michal is the one woman in Israel's stories said to love a man, and her love is never said to be returned. She is given, taken away (25:44), taken back (2 Sam 3:13–16), and finally left childless and estranged (2 Sam 6:16–23). Listeners who knew the whole story would hear the pain begin in this first line.

From the study of 1 Samuel 18:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20Now Saul’s daughter Michal loved David, and when this was reported to Saul, it pleased him.

    Then Michal, Saul's own daughter, the king's girl, fell in love with David. And word of it reached Saul, and the news suited him exactly. It "lay straight in his eyes."

    The verse is short and quiet, and it is loaded. In the Hebrew Bible men are often said to love women: Jacob loved Rachel, Elkanah loved Hannah, Amnon "loved" Tamar. This is the only story where a woman is said to love a man. Michal is not just someone to be given away. She has her own heart, and she has set it on David.

    She is also one more name on a growing list. In these chapters King Saul loved David (16:21), Saul's son Jonathan loved him (18:1, 3), and all Israel and Judah loved him (18:16). Now Saul's daughter does. In Israel's world, "love" could also mean loyalty, the attachment people owe a leader. So the people nearest the throne are, one by one, giving themselves to the man who will replace Saul. The text never says David loved Michal back.

    Then the news is "told," meaning someone at court reports it. A daughter's feelings are now political information. Saul's reaction is not a father's joy. "The thing was straight in his eyes" means it fit his plans. Verse 21 spells out the plan: he will use Michal as bait, a "snare," to send David to his death against the Philistines. A few verses earlier, David's praise in the women's song was "evil in his eyes" (18:8). Now he finds something "straight in his eyes", and it is a way to be rid of him. The reader already suspects what the story will show: the daughter he means as a trap will be the one who lets David out the window and saves his life (19:11–17).

    Full study →
  2. 21“I will give her to David,” Saul thought, “so that she may be a snare to him, and the hand of the Philistines may be against him.” So Saul said to David, “For a second time now you can be my son-in-law.”

    Saul reasoned to himself: "I'll give her to him, so that she becomes the bait in a trap for him, and so that the Philistines' deadly hand comes down on him." Then the same Saul turned to David and said aloud, warmly: "Second time lucky. You'll be joined to my house as my son-in-law today."

    The verse is built as a contrast. Two sentences start with exactly the same words, "and Saul said." The first is the king's private calculation and the second is his public courtesy. Saul's daughter Michal, who the previous verse says genuinely loved David, becomes in her father's mind only a lure: the bait set in a hunter's trap. The real jaws of the trap are the bride-price Saul is about to name, a hundred Philistine foreskins (v. 25). He expects that price to send David to his death in battle, so that Philistine hands, not Saul's own, will kill him. The offer itself means more than a wedding. To become the king's in-law was to be bound into the royal house by an alliance with rights attached. Saul dangles that honour, perhaps saying "a second time" because the earlier promise of his older daughter Merab had been quietly broken (vv. 17–19). The first hearers would catch the irony that runs through the scene. The "snare" will later save David's life (19:11–17), and the alliance meant to destroy him will in the end strengthen his claim to Saul's throne.

    Full study →
  3. 22Then Saul ordered his servants, “Speak to David privately and tell him, ‘Behold, the king is pleased with you, and all his servants love you. Now therefore, become his son-in-law.’”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  4. 23But when Saul’s servants relayed these words to David, he replied, “Does it seem trivial in your sight to be the son-in-law of the king? I am a poor man and lightly esteemed.”

    Saul's courtiers did what the king told them. Quietly, in private conversation, they passed on his message: the king delights in you, the whole court loves you, now become the king's son-in-law. David answered with a question that turns on a play between "light" and "heavy," which in Hebrew is how honour was pictured:

    "Do you really think it's a light thing, a small and easy matter, to marry into the king's own family? Me? I'm a man without means, a lightweight with no standing to bring."

    "Light" (naqallah) at the start of his reply and "lightweight / held cheap" (niqleh) at the end come from two related, similar-sounding roots. The matter is heavy; David is light. "Poor" here does not mean destitute. It means poor next to a king. David has no fortune to pay the bride-price a royal daughter would be worth, and no family weight to match Saul's house. He was already famous (the women's song in 18:7), so the point is not that nobody knows him. The point is that his celebrity does not count as rank. His words are both proper courtly modesty and a real practical objection. That objection, carried back to Saul (v. 24), gives the king the opening he wanted. Saul will name a "price" that costs no silver but could easily cost David his life (v. 25).

    Full study →
  5. 24And the servants told Saul what David had said.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 25Saul replied, “Say to David, ‘The king desires no other dowry but a hundred Philistine foreskins as revenge on his enemies.’” But Saul intended to cause David’s death at the hands of the Philistines.

    Saul gives his courtiers a script for David, in the formal manner of a royal message: "Tell David this: the king has no wish for a bride-price in silver. What will satisfy him is a hundred Philistine foreskins, the king's retribution on his enemies."

    On the surface it is a gracious and patriotic offer. David has just protested that he is too poor and too lowly to pay the marriage gift a king's daughter deserves (v. 23). So Saul waives the money and asks for something an Israelite warrior could "pay" in another way: a feat of arms, the way Jacob paid for Rachel with years of labour and Othniel won Achsah by taking a city. The foreskins are proof. Only uncircumcised Philistines could supply them, and they made every kill countable, much as Egyptian scribes tallied severed hands and phalli after a battle. They also mocked the enemy at the very mark Israel despised them for ("this uncircumcised Philistine," 17:26).

    Then the narrator breaks in and shows what Saul is really counting: Saul had worked it out to bring David down, to get him killed, by the hand of the Philistines. A hundred kills in close combat meant a hundred chances for David to die, and his death would look like honourable service, with no blood on the king's hands. The verse begins and ends with the Philistines. They are the price Saul names and the weapon he hopes to turn on David.

    Full study →
  7. 26When the servants reported these terms to David, he was pleased to become the king’s son-in-law. Before the wedding day arrived,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  8. 27David and his men went out and killed two hundred Philistines. He brought their foreskins and presented them as payment in full to become the king’s son-in-law. Then Saul gave his daughter Michal to David in marriage.

    David set out at once, he himself at the head of his own troop. They struck down two hundred Philistine fighting men, double the hundred Saul had asked for. David personally carried back their foreskins. These were the grim, countable proof that every man killed was one of the 'uncircumcised' enemy. The trophies were counted out to the king in full, every one accounted for, before the deadline had even run out. ("The days were not yet full," v26; now the count was "full.") The point of all this was to become the king's son-in-law, which meant marrying into the royal house and gaining standing at court. Saul had demanded this bride-price hoping the Philistines would kill David (v25). Instead he was left with no way out, and this time, unlike with his elder daughter Merab, he had to keep his word. Saul gave David his daughter Michal, the daughter who loved him, as his wife.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    it pleased him / the thing pleased him

    wayyishar haddavar beʿenav

    What we hear
    Saul was happy for his daughter and glad to have David as a son-in-law.
    What they heard
    'The matter was straight in his eyes': it suited his purposes. The next verse shows the purpose was to get David killed by using Michal as a 'snare'.
  • in v20

    loved

    ʾahav

    What we hear
    A purely private romantic feeling, a love story inside a war story.
    What they heard
    Real attachment, and probably romantic here. The same verb is used again and again in this chapter for loyalty to David (Jonathan, all Israel and Judah, Saul's servants), so Michal's love is also part of a public pattern: Saul's own household turning toward his rival.
  • in v21

    a snare to him

    moqesh

    What we hear
    Michal will be a seductress or a temptation who leads David into sin or folly, the 'dangerous woman' of Proverbs.
    What they heard
    A hunter's lure or trap that brings death. Michal is the unwitting bait in her father's murder plot. She does not scheme against David, and in the story she later saves him.
  • in v21

    son-in-law

    hitchatten

    What we hear
    Simply joining a family by marriage, a private and personal matter.
    What they heard
    Entering a marriage alliance with a household, here the royal house. It brought status and a potential claim on the dynasty.
  • in v23

    little known / have no reputation

    niqleh

    What we hear
    Obscure, not famous, unknown to the public.
    What they heard
    Held light, of low social rank, without the 'weight' (honour) that family, wealth and position give. David was in fact very famous at this point (18:7, 16).
  • in v23

    poor

    rash

    What we hear
    Destitute, in poverty.
    What they heard
    Without means compared with the king, and so unable to pay a royal bride-price. Jesse's family owned flocks and could send provisions and gifts (16:11; 17:17–18).
  • in v23

    servants

    ʿavdei

    What we hear
    Domestic staff or menial attendants.
    What they heard
    The king's courtiers and officials, men of his inner court acting as go-betweens.
  • in v25

    dowry (KJV, BSB, WEB; NASB similarly)

    mohar

    What we hear
    Money or property the bride's family gives to the groom or the new couple.
    What they heard
    A payment from the groom to the bride's father that sealed the betrothal. It flows the other way, which is why poor David cannot afford it.
  • in v25

    revenge / to be avenged

    lehinnaqem (naqam)

    What we hear
    Personal, emotional getting-even over a private grudge.
    What they heard
    The king's retribution on the nation's enemies, presented as rightful punishment by the crown. It is a respectable public pretext, not an admission of spite.
  • in v25

    make David fall

    lehappil

    What we hear
    Make him stumble, fail, or fall morally.
    What they heard
    Get him killed. In battle language 'to fall' means to die.
  • in v27

    in full tale (KJV)

    vaymal'um (from male', 'fill, complete')

    What we hear
    Sounds like 'a full story' or 'a complete account told to the king'.
    What they heard
    They counted out the full number. 'Tale' is old English for a count or tally, and the Hebrew means 'they made them complete'.
Every word
  1. וַתֶּאֱהַב

    watteʾehav · H0157G

    to love · v20

    'And she loved.' The verb form moves the story along ('and then…'). Michal is the subject, and that is rare: this is the only place in the Hebrew Bible's stories where a woman is said to love a man.

  2. מִיכַל

    mikhal · H4324G

    Michal · v20, v27

    Saul's younger daughter (14:49). The name is probably a short form of Michael, 'Who is like God?', though that is not certain. She is named here for the first time since the family list.

  3. בַּת־

    bat- · H1323G

    daughter (of) · v20, v27

    'Daughter of.' This ties Michal to the royal house, and that is the reason her love matters politically. The narrator keeps calling her 'daughter of Saul', even after she becomes David's wife (2 Sam 6:16, 23).

  4. שָׁאוּל

    shaʾul · H7586G

    Saul · v20, v21, v23, v25, v27

    The reigning king. By now he openly fears David and wants him dead (18:8–12).

  5. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v20, v23, v25, v27

    This small word has no English equivalent. It marks David as the one who is loved.

  6. דָּוִד

    dawid · H1732

    David · v20, v21, v23, v25, v27

    The young commander from Bethlehem. In these chapters he is loved by nearly everyone: Saul (16:21), Jonathan (18:1, 3), all Israel and Judah (18:16), Saul's servants (18:22), and now Michal.

  7. וַיַּגִּדוּ

    wayyaggidu · H5046

    to tell, report · v20

    'And they told.' The plural 'they' has no named subject, so it means 'someone reported it' or 'word reached Saul'. Her feelings did not stay private. At court they became political information.

  8. וַיִּשַׁר

    wayyishar · H3474

    to be straight, right, agreeable · v20

    'And it was straight / right.' Something 'straight in someone's eyes' suits them or fits what they want. The next verse says why: Saul sees a way to have David killed.

  9. הַדָּבָר

    haddavar · H1697I

    word, thing, matter · v20, v23

    'The thing / the matter,' meaning the news of Michal's love. It is the same phrase as 18:8, where 'this thing' (the women's song praising David) was 'evil in his eyes'.

  10. בְּעֵינָיו

    beʿenav · H5869I

    eye(s) · v20, v23

    'In his eyes,' that is, as Saul judged it. The phrase points to how Saul saw things, which was different from the reality and from his daughter's view.

  11. וַיֹּ֨אמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v21, v23, v25

    Here it introduces Saul's private thinking, not words spoken aloud. Hebrew often uses 'said' for what a person says to himself (compare 1 Sam 27:1), which is why the BSB has 'thought.'

  12. אֶתְּנֶ֤נָּה

    ettenennah · H5414

    I will give her · v21, v27

    'I will give her', with an emphatic form of the 'her' ending. It is the ordinary language of a father giving his daughter in marriage (compare 17:25, 18:17, 19), and here it is turned into the first move in a plot.

  13. לּוֹ֙

    lo · H9033

    to him · v21

    To David. In Saul's private thought David is just 'him.'

  14. וּתְהִי־

    utehi · H1961

    and let her be · v21

    A verb form that expresses a wish or purpose: 'so that she may become.' It states the aim of the gift.

  15. לְמוֹקֵ֔שׁ

    lemoqesh · H4170

    for a snare · v21

    A hunter's trap or its bait. Michal is the lure that will draw David into a deadly bride-price challenge (v. 25). She herself knows nothing of the plot.

  16. יַד־

    yad · H3027

    hand of · v21, v25

    'Hand' as power, especially the power to kill. It repeats Saul's earlier thought in 18:17: 'not my hand, but the hand of the Philistines.'

  17. פְּלִשְׁתִּ֑ים

    pelishtim · H6430

    Philistines · v21, v25, v27

    Israel's main military enemy. Saul wants them to do the killing for him.

  18. אֶל־

    el · H0413

    to · v21

    Marks who is being addressed: David himself.

  19. בִּשְׁתַּ֛יִם

    bishtayim · H8147

    by two / a second time · v21

    Literally 'with/by two.' Most likely it means 'a second time,' looking back to the offer of Merab that came to nothing (18:17–19). The phrase is unusual, and older interpreters read it as 'through one of the two [daughters].'

  20. תִּתְחַתֵּ֥ן

    titchatten · H2859

    you will become son-in-law · v21, v23, v27

    'You will make yourself related by marriage.' The word means joining a family, and for a king's family it means a political bond: being tied to the royal house.

  21. בִּ֖י

    bi · H9030

    with me · v21

    'With me': the marriage tie is with Saul himself, the king.

  22. הַיּֽוֹם׃

    hayyom · H3117

    today · v21

    'Today', which makes the offer sound immediate and warm. It is the friendly-sounding end of a sentence that hides a death trap.

  23. וַֽיְדַבְּר֞וּ

    vayedabberu · H1696

    and they spoke · v23

    The ordinary verb for speaking, in the narrative 'and then' form. It carries out Saul's order of v. 22 ('speak to David privately'): the courtiers do exactly as told.

  24. עַבְדֵ֤י

    ʿavdei · H5650

    servants of · v23

    Saul's courtiers and officials, men attached to the king's service. In a royal court the word covers high officers as well as attendants; these are the king's go-betweens, not household slaves.

  25. בְּאָזְנֵ֣י

    beʾoznei · H241

    in the ears of · v23

    A Hebrew idiom for speaking directly and personally to someone. It fits the 'privately' of v. 22: this is quiet, off-the-record court talk, not a public proclamation.

  26. הָאֵ֑לֶּה

    haʾelleh · H428

    these · v23

    'These words', pointing back to the exact message of v. 22. The same phrase returns in v. 24 when David's answer is reported back to Saul, framing the exchange.

  27. הַֽנְקַלָּ֤ה

    hanaqallah · H7043

    is it a light thing? · v23

    A question word joined to a form of qalal, 'to be light, slight, of little weight'. 'Is this a light thing?' means 'Do you think this is easy, minor, something just anyone can do?' It begins a play on 'light' that the verse closes with niqleh.

  28. בַּמֶּ֔לֶךְ

    bammelekh · H4428

    with the king · v23, v25, v27

    'With the king': the tie is with Saul himself, not only with Michal. David keeps the courtiers' word 'king' from v. 22, stressing how far apart the ranks are.

  29. וְאָנֹכִ֖י

    veʾanokhi · H595

    and I · v23

    An emphatic 'I', set against 'the king'. The 'and' here works as 'when I am…' or 'seeing that I am…', and it explains why David thinks it is no light thing.

  30. אִֽישׁ־

    ʾish · H376

    a man · v23, v27

    'A man', setting up the descriptions that follow.

  31. רָ֥שׁ

    rash · H7326

    poor · v23

    'Poor', meaning without wealth or means. Here it means poor compared with a king: David cannot pay a bride-price fit for a royal daughter. This is exactly the point Saul picks up in v. 25.

  32. וְנִקְלֶֽה׃

    veniqleh · H7034

    and lightly regarded / of low standing · v23

    From qalah, 'to be held cheap, treated with contempt'. As a description of a person it means someone of no social weight, the opposite of the 'heavy', honoured man. It echoes naqallah at the start of David's reply: the matter is not light, but I am.

  33. כֹּֽה־

    koh · H3541

    thus · v25

    Starts the formula used for official messages, 'Thus you shall say'. Saul is handing his courtiers a script to carry to David.

  34. אֵֽין־

    'ein · H0369

    there is not · v25

    Denies that something exists: 'there is no…'. It starts a 'not X but Y' construction that the כִּי later finishes.

  35. חֵ֤פֶץ

    chefets · H2656

    delight, desire, pleasure · v25

    What someone wants or takes pleasure in. Saul pretends to be generous: the king has no wish for the usual payment.

  36. בְּמֹ֔הַר

    bemohar · H4119

    bride-price · v25

    The payment a groom gave the bride's father to settle a marriage. It answers David's worry in verse 23 that he cannot afford a price worthy of a king's daughter.

  37. כִּ֗י

    ki · H3588

    but, rather · v25

    After the negative it means 'but rather' or 'except'. It brings in what the king does want.

  38. בְּמֵאָה֙

    bem'ah · H3967

    in/for a hundred · v25, v27

    The preposition repeats from 'in bride-price', so the hundred stands in for the price. A large number like this guarantees many dangerous fights.

  39. עָרְל֣וֹת

    'orlot · H6190

    foreskins · v25, v27

    Trophies cut from enemy dead. Since Israelites were circumcised and Philistines were not, a foreskin proved the dead man was a Philistine and made the kills countable.

  40. לְהִנָּקֵ֖ם

    lehinnaqem · H5358

    to take vengeance, avenge oneself · v25

    The stated purpose: the king's retribution on his enemies. It dresses Saul's trap up as patriotic punishment of the nation's foes.

  41. בְּאֹיְבֵ֣י

    be'oyvei · H0341

    on the enemies of · v25

    'Enemy' as a hostile party in war. The preposition marks who receives the vengeance.

  42. חָשַׁ֔ב

    chashav · H2803

    reckoned, devised, planned · v25

    To work something out in the mind, to calculate or scheme. Saul has a hidden plan under the public offer.

  43. לְהַפִּ֥יל

    lehappil · H5307

    to make fall · v25

    The causative form of 'fall'. In battle language, to 'fall' is to be killed, so 'make David fall' means 'get David killed'.

  44. וַיָּ֨קָם

    vayyaqom · H6965

    rise, get up · v27

    Not literal standing up but the Hebrew way of saying someone set out or went into action; it marks David's prompt response to Saul's terms.

  45. וַיֵּ֣לֶךְ

    vayyelekh · H1980

    go, walk · v27

    'And went': paired with 'arose' it forms a stock phrase for setting out on an expedition, here a raid into Philistine territory.

  46. ה֣וּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v27

    An emphatic 'he himself', added so that 'his men' can be joined to him; David leads the raid personally.

  47. וַאֲנָשָׁ֗יו

    va'anashav · H582

    men · v27

    'And his men': David's own troop, the unit of a thousand Saul had given him (18:13). The feat is a military operation, not single combat.

  48. וַיַּ֣ךְ

    vayyakh · H5221

    strike, smite · v27

    'He struck down': the normal verb for military blows that kill. The trophies taken afterward show these were deaths, not wounds.

  49. וַיָּבֵ֤א

    vayyave · H935

    bring · v27

    'And he brought': David personally carries the proof back to court.

  50. וַיְמַלְא֣וּם

    vaymal'um · H4390

    fill; complete · v27

    'And they made them full', meaning they counted out the full number. The price was paid completely and witnessed. The plural 'they' probably stands for 'it was done' (David's men or officials counting).

  51. ל֥וֹ

    lo

    to him · v27

    'To him', to David.

  52. לְאִשָּֽׁה

    le'ishah · H802

    woman, wife · v27

    'As a wife': the standard marriage formula, 'to give X to Y as a wife'.

The world behind it

Marriage, daughters and the throne. In Iron Age Israel a daughter's marriage was arranged by her father. The groom paid a bride-price (mohar) to her family. What a daughter wanted was rarely recorded, let alone decisive. That is why the narrator's note that Michal loved David stands out.

Saul's broken promise. Before Goliath, Saul's men had said the king would give his daughter to the man who killed the giant (17:25). Saul then offered his elder daughter Merab to David on condition that he fight Saul's battles, hoping "the hand of the Philistines" would kill him (18:17). He then gave her to someone else (18:19). Michal's love gives Saul a second chance at the same trick. In 18:25 the bride-price he names is a hundred Philistine foreskins, a demand that could get David killed on the way.

Why a royal son-in-law mattered. Marrying into the king's house gave a man standing and a possible claim to succeed him. That is why David later insists on getting Michal back before he negotiates over Saul's kingdom (2 Sam 3:13–14). Saul is taking a risk: he binds David more tightly to his house, expecting David to die before it matters.

How the story is told. 1 Samuel 16 to 2 Samuel 5 is often read as an account of David's rise that explains why the throne passed rightly from Saul's house to David. One of its recurring threads is that everyone, including Saul's own children, was drawn to David without David grasping for it.

From the study of 1 Samuel 18:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

Is Michal's 'love' for David personal romance, political loyalty, or both?

  • Mainly personal and romantic.

    Michal is a young unmarried woman and the context is marriage. In Hebrew narrative the verb is often used of attraction between the sexes. Her later risky rescue of David (19:11–17) fits real attachment. Many literary readers (e.g. Alter) stress that she is the only woman in Hebrew narrative said to love a man, and that her love is never said to be returned.

  • Mainly part of a political pattern of loyalty to David.

    The same verb is used one after another for Jonathan (18:1, 3), 'all Israel and Judah' (18:16), Michal (18:20, 28) and Saul's servants (18:22). Ancient Near Eastern treaty and diplomatic language uses 'love' for loyalty to a king (Moran 1963). Thompson (1974) argued the David–Jonathan 'love' language carries this sense. On this reading Michal's love shows Saul's own house shifting toward David.

  • Both at once (the most common view).

    The narrator can describe a real personal feeling and also use it as one link in a chain of support for David. The private emotion is what gives the political point its force.

in v20

Is the Merab episode (18:17–19), and so the 'second' son-in-law offer, original to the story?

  • A later addition. The shorter Greek text is older.

    The Old Greek (Vaticanus) lacks 18:17–19 and 18:21b, along with other passages in chs. 17–18 that look like a second, parallel account. Some critics (e.g. McCarter) take the Greek as witness to an earlier Hebrew text.

  • Original. The Greek translator or its source shortened the story.

    The longer Hebrew text is coherent. It links back to the promise in 17:25 and explains 'for a second time' in 18:21. Some scholars argue the Greek removed what looked like doublets or tensions.

in v21

What does בִּשְׁתַּיִם ('by two') mean in Saul's offer?

  • 'A second time': a second marriage offer, after the broken promise of Merab.

    It fits the immediate context (18:17–19). Most modern translations and commentaries take this view. The yiqtol verb plus 'today' reads naturally as a renewed offer.

  • 'Through one of the two (daughters)'

    Medieval Jewish commentary, reflected in the KJV's italics. It treats 'two' as Saul's two daughters (14:49). It requires words to be supplied that are not in the text.

  • 'In two ways / on two counts', or a damaged phrase

    The Vulgate's 'in two things.' Some critics treat the phrase as obscure or corrupted, noting that it has no parallel and that 21b is absent from the oldest Greek.

in v21

Is v. 21b original to the story?

  • It is part of a secondary, expanded edition that brought in the Merab episode.

    It is absent, with 18:17–19, from Codex Vaticanus. It sits awkwardly with v. 22, where Saul makes his proposal through servants rather than directly.

  • It belongs to the Hebrew narrative as we have it and is coherent there.

    In the Hebrew text as it stands, Saul's public word sets up the private persuasion through servants in v. 22. The 'second time' links the two marriage offers deliberately.

in v23

Is David's protest sincere humility, conventional court modesty, or a shrewd negotiating move?

  • Sincere: David really cannot afford a royal bride-price and is reluctant to rise above his station.

    The economic objection is real. Saul treats it as real and answers it with a non-monetary 'price' (v. 25). The narrative consistently presents David as not reaching for power.

  • Conventional courtesy: formulaic self-lowering expected before royalty.

    Parallel formulas: 'Who am I…?' (18:18; 2 Sam 7:18); Saul's own 'Am I not a Benjaminite, from the least tribe…?' (9:21). Refusing first was a standard opening in ancient negotiation.

  • Shrewd: David's 'objection' invites Saul to name terms, and David then gladly meets them (v. 26, 'it pleased David well').

    Verse 26 shows David eager once the terms are set, and he even doubles the price (v. 27). Some interpreters read the narrator's portrait of David as deliberately ambiguous, showing his inner life rarely and leaving his motives open.

in v25

Why foreskins rather than heads or hands?

  • Proof of identity and count: only the uncircumcised Philistines could supply them, so the trophies could not be faked with other bodies and made the total countable.

    Israel's neighbours mostly practised circumcision (Jer 9:25–26), while Philistines are called 'the uncircumcised' (Judg 14:3; 1 Sam 17:26). Egyptian records chose phalli for uncircumcised Libyans and hands for circumcised foes, which suggests the trophy was picked to identify the people.

  • Humiliation tied to Israel's identity: the demand mocks the enemy at the very mark that set them outside Israel's covenant.

    The insult 'uncircumcised' is central to the David and Goliath story (17:26, 36). The trophy turns that insult into the price of a royal marriage.

  • A way to guarantee danger: the gruesome task forced David into many close-quarters kills and increased his risk.

    The narrator says outright that Saul's aim was David's death (v. 25b, compare v. 17).

in v25

Is the mohar a purchase price for the bride?

  • Essentially a purchase: the bride was in effect bought from her father.

    The word 'price' in translations; Exodus 22:16–17 treats an unbetrothed daughter's sexual status as a loss to her father that must be paid for.

  • A marriage gift or compensation that created ties between families, not a sale.

    A wife was never resold like property. The mohar sits beside other gifts (mattan, Gen 34:12). Bride-price could be paid in service or a feat, and comparable Mesopotamian payments (terhatu) were often partly returned with the bride (R. de Vaux, Ancient Israel).

in v27

Did David kill 200 Philistines or 100?

  • The original reading was 100; the Hebrew '200' is a later change.

    The Greek Septuagint reads 100. It matches Saul's demand (18:25) and David's own statement in 2 Samuel 3:14.

  • The Hebrew '200' is original: David doubled the price.

    It fits the narrator's theme of David outdoing every expectation and Saul being cornered. In 2 Samuel 3:14 David may simply be quoting the agreed price rather than the number he actually delivered.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. אָהֵב; s.v. יָשַׁר
  • HALOT s.v. אהב; s.v. ישׁר
  • W. L. Moran, "The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy," CBQ 25 (1963)
  • J. A. Thompson, "The Significance of the Verb Love in the David-Jonathan Narratives in 1 Samuel," VT 24 (1974)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • J. Cheryl Exum, Fragmented Women (on Michal)
  • Septuagint, 1 Reigns 18:20 (Codex Vaticanus)
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)
  • BDB s.v. מוֹקֵשׁ
  • HALOT s.v. חתן (hithpael)
  • HALOT s.v. מוֹקֵשׁ
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Reigns 18
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 18:21
  • BDB s.v. קָלָה, קָלַל, רוּשׁ, חָתַן
  • HALOT s.v. נִקְלֶה; חתן hitp.
  • Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex) with supplied morphology
  • Septuagint 1 Kingdoms 18:23 (Codex Vaticanus tradition)
  • Vulgate 1 Samuel 18:23
  • P. Kyle McCarter, I Samuel (Anchor Bible) on 1 Sam 17–18 and the shorter Greek text
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 18 (bride-price)
  • Roland de Vaux, Ancient Israel: Its Life and Institutions (marriage and mohar)
  • BDB s.v. מֹהַר, חֵפֶץ, נָקַם, חָשַׁב
  • HALOT s.v. מֹהַר; עָרְלָה
  • R. de Vaux, Ancient Israel: Its Life and Institutions (marriage, mohar)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 1 Sam 17–18 and the LXX shorter text
  • R. W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • ANET: Merneptah's Libyan war inscription (Karnak); Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III
  • G. E. Mendenhall, 'The Vengeance of Yahweh', in The Tenth Generation
  • Code of Hammurabi §§159–161 (terhatu)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 18:25
  • Westminster Leningrad Codex / supplied morphology (lemma, Strong's)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. עׇרְלָה, מָלֵא, חָתַן, נָכָה
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Reigns 18:27
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 6.197-203
  • Merneptah Karnak inscription; Medinet Habu reliefs of Ramesses III (counting of enemy hands and phalluses)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 18:25-27

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

3 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.